Al Porter Scandal

Galwayguy35 · 19-11-2017 10:11AM

tigger123 wrote: »

If Al Porter had the cultural penetration that George Hook had, it would be a different story.

George Hook, at least until recently, was transmitting his views straight into peoples homes every day. When he made the comments he did, it resonated much more through society.

The allegations against Al Porter aren't given the same attention because his media profile and impact is far, far lower.

Porter has about 122000 listeners to his radio show and with the Blind Date show he did with TV3 I'd suggest he is just as well known as George Hook.

In fact if you asked young people on the street who GH was many of them wouldn't have a clue.

The liberal left media didn't like Hook so when they got their chance they went for blood.

I'd be interested to see will Sarah McInerney and Elaine Crowley go on TV screaming hysterically for Porters head like they did about GH.

darkdubh · 19-11-2017 10:17AM

rustynutz wrote: »

This is no ordinary panto...... Its a gaaaaay panto...

Sorry, ill get my coat

Isn't all panto gay to an extent? All this men dressing as women and "he's behind you, ohh er" Kenneth Williams type innuendo.

strandroad · 19-11-2017 10:21AM

Galwayguy35 wrote: »

The liberal left media didn't like Hook so when they got their chance they went for blood.

I'd be interested to see will Sarah McInerney and Elaine Crowley go on TV screaming hysterically for Porters head like they did about GH.

Porter's head is on the plate already, he's suspended, his shows gone. It took Newstalk a long time to react to Hook hence the campaigning.

Porter's victims can or possibly have reported him for assaults which is a separate avenue. I wish them success and yes they have the right to feel assaulted whether they could have punched him or not.

glenfieldman · 19-11-2017 10:23AM

I see the singer and presenter Aled Jones has been fired for the same allegations, I dont see Porters fan boys screaming about innocent until .... about this guy. He has been named and shamed in UK press

Beechwoodspark · 19-11-2017 10:24AM

Just looking at it from the comedy career angle.

Even if he does "go to ground" and emerges a few months from now, how can he possibly go back to his "act" which was heavy on the brazen sexual innuendo?

Beechwoodspark · 19-11-2017 10:26AM

strandroad wrote: »

Porter's head is on the plate already, he's suspended, his shows gone. It took Newstalk a long time to react to Hook hence the campaigning.

Porter's victims can or possibly have reported him for assaults which is a separate avenue. I wish them success and yes they have the right to feel assaulted whether they could have punched him or not.

Some of the allegations involve porter contacting guests he met through his employment on the today fm show and sending them unwanted sexual messages. That is indefensible surely

PowerToWait · 19-11-2017 10:26AM

Because this thread has become such a clusterfcuk, for my own sake I would like to clarify my personal opinion on the questions raised.

If Porter did what is alleged then he should be subject to appropriate sanction.

I am not in any way condoning any such behaviour, by straight, gay, bi whatever people, from the left or the right or any other political orientation I've missed out.

Any poster conflating massively powerful, movie mogul billionaires who can make or break careers and possibly lives through a phone call, with an unestablished, 19 year old, 2 bit comedian is being deliberately obtuse.

All abuse is wrong. There are no excuses.

However, while I can understand why the alleged victims of a Hollywood superpower would remain silent for years, I do not quite understand why the alleged victims of a basic nobody would not immediately go to the authorities. Or social media. Or whatever.

The gender, sexuality, race, religion or toughness of either the alleged victim or alleged perpetrator are irrelevant.

Also, while i felt the Hook bandwagon was distasteful, he said what he said live to hundreds of thousands. No doubt about why he was being hounded.

I'm sure people will find ways to misinterpret what I've said here.

Colser · 19-11-2017 10:27AM

CalamariFritti wrote: »

But it doesn't matter is my point. Even if he is and all is true this public witch hunt is a terrible thing. If this becomes the norm its only matter of time until someone innocent is going to be destroyed by the mob.

I agree with you..it's frightening to think that any of us could be falsely accused of something and be judged /discussed publicly online...I think it would push a lot of people over the edge tbh.
I can't stand Al Porter..he should never have been allowed do Blind Date..lots of us love a bit of innuendo etc on a dating show but he often took it to another level,complete sleaze and cringe and not even slightly funny...I don't find him one bit funny and hate when someone has to mock someone else to try and get a laugh from a crowd.I do feel sorry for him being publicly judged but that's how everything is done now (unfortunately imo) but I'd be very surprised if there isn't truth in it.

Don Kiddick · 19-11-2017 10:27AM

strandroad wrote: »

Porter's head is on the plate already, he's suspended, his shows gone. It took Newstalk a long time to react to Hook hence the campaigning.

Porter's victims can or possibly have reported him for assaults which is a separate avenue. I wish them success and yes they have the right to feel assaulted whether they could have punched him or not.

I think there's a world of difference between what GH said..and what Porter has done ...not even in the same stratosphere

CalamariFritti · 19-11-2017 10:29AM

glenfieldman wrote: »

I see the singer and presenter Aled Jones has been fired for the same allegations, I dont see Porters fan boys screaming about innocent until .... about this guy. He has been named and shamed in UK press

I don't know where to start with this. You're saying because it happened to someone else its ok to happen to anyone thrown in with a few silly bits about 'fan boys' and 'screaming'. For effect I imagine.

Well I suppose isn't that what they say about mobs? Their combined intelligence is that of their most stupid members. Divided by ten.

suicide_circus · 19-11-2017 10:41AM

I wonder will anyone refuse to share the airwaves with Al Porter

Woodville56 · 19-11-2017 10:47AM

Galwayguy35 wrote: »

tigger123 wrote: »

If Al Porter had the cultural penetration that George Hook had, it would be a different story.

George Hook, at least until recently, was transmitting his views straight into peoples homes every day. When he made the comments he did, it resonated much more through society.

The allegations against Al Porter aren't given the same attention because his media profile and impact is far, far lower.

Porter has about 122000 listeners to his radio show and with the Blind Date show he did with TV3 I'd suggest he is just as well known as George Hook.

In fact if you asked young people on the street who GH was many of them wouldn't have a clue.

The liberal left media didn't like Hook so when they got their chance they went for blood.

I'd be interested to see will Sarah McInerney and Elaine Crowley go on TV screaming hysterically for Porters head like they did about GH.

Porter was also was a self styled political analyst in a newspaper in wide circulation here and also a regular current /social affairs commentator on tv/ radio - he used that column and his broadcasts to throw stones at just about anyone right of centre or of Christian beliefs. Not a supporter of Enda Kenny but I bet he’s got that smug grin all over his cornflakes this morning having been the butt of Porter’s vicious lefty political correctness over the years. What comes around goes around.

zoobizoo · 19-11-2017 10:48AM

PowerToWait wrote: »

I do not quite understand why the alleged victims of a basic nobody would not immediately go to the authorities. Or social media. Or whatever.

.

Couple of years back I was sharing a room with a gay lad in a hostel. Three of us were in the room. Me, him and his brother (who didn't speak English). He had been flirting with me for a few days. I batted it off - I'm a straight easy going guy.

Woke up in the middle of the night with him having pulled my duvet down, had his hand on the top of my boxers and his mouth moving towards my dick...

He was a basic nobody - I punched him before his mouth reached its intended destination. I guess it was sexual assault. Or would have been had I not woken.

I cornered him, shouted at him for a few minutes. Threatened him with a beating. Then went back to bed. Got up the next day and got him kicked out of the hostel.

Didnt' bother going to the cops... why would I? What good would it have done? Court... hassle.... qusestions like "why had I not prevented it seeing as he had been flirting with me?"

I don't see myself as a victim mind.

But, here you've got young or aspiring acts in a "it's your word against his" scenario. Sure that's just a flirty gay lad "messing".... that's part of his shtick, part of his act...

I think it comes to a head when they see him talking about mental health issues, or seeing him making sexualised remarks on Blind Date or basically see a sexual bully who has harrassed them not being taken to task for his behaviour.

And they say "enough is enough" .... in the same way that kids come out after years to say "my dad raped me"....

munster87 · 19-11-2017 10:49AM

suicide_circus wrote: »

I wonder will anyone refuse to share the airwaves with Al Porter

I will

pjohnson · 19-11-2017 10:49AM

Claiming George Hook is better known surely doesn't matter? I mean Hook never touched ANYONE. Porter has apparently grabbed others genitals. Regardless of how "well known" or how "young" Porter is. His alleged misdemeanours are far worse than anything Hook did.

strandroad · 19-11-2017 10:51AM

pjohnson wrote: »

Claiming George Hook is better known surely doesn't matter? I mean Hook never touched ANYONE. Porter has apparently grabbed others genitals. Regardless of how "well known" or how "young" Porter is. His alleged misdemeanours are far worse than anything Hook did.

Absolutely. But then his employers acted quickly and decisively, unlike Hook's.

munster87 · 19-11-2017 10:52AM

Imagine the outcry if George Hook was going around grabbing genitalia like that!

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 10:56AM

KKkitty wrote: »

end of the road wrote: »

unfortunately people have made accusations of such a nature before, which have turned out to be false. reasons are unknown. i don't know whether the allegations against al porter are true or not, and we will find out in time, but people do make allegations that turn out to be false from time to time, for reasons unknown.

that could very well be true, we don't know, we will in time know whether it's true or false. however, a number of people who have made allegations which later turned out to be false, have been very convincing.

there's no smoke without fire is not really a valid statement in relation to allegations, as sometimes there very much is smoke without fire. whether this particular case is one of those cases, i don't know.

not reallly. it is standard procedure these days for people who have had allegations made against them to be taken off air while the allegations are investigated.

If Al Porter has nothing to hide why is his social media presence dead in the water? If you were accused of something like him would you be on everything possible to say the truth? He's been inappropriate in his behaviour. Call a spade a spade FFS.

Because maybe finally there's someone who doesn't worship at the altar of f***ing social media.

I cannot stand Porter. He's as funny as trapping your hand in a car door but I am thoroughly sick of "taking to Twitter" when anything happens from the cat farting to yoy allegedly being assaulted.

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 10:58AM

zoobizoo wrote: »

PowerToWait wrote: »

I do not quite understand why the alleged victims of a basic nobody would not immediately go to the authorities. Or social media. Or whatever.

.

Couple of years back I was sharing a room with a gay lad in a hostel. Three of us were in the room. Me, him and his brother (who didn't speak English). He had been flirting with me for a few days. I batted it off - I'm a straight easy going guy.

Woke up in the middle of the night with him having pulled my duvet down, had his hand on the top of my boxers and his mouth moving towards my dick...

He was a basic nobody - I punched him before his mouth reached its intended destination. I guess it was sexual assault. Or would have been had I not woken.

I cornered him, shouted at him for a few minutes. Threatened him with a beating. Then went back to bed. Got up the next day and got him kicked out of the hostel.

Didnt' bother going to the cops... why would I? What good would it have done? Court... hassle.... qusestions like "why had I not prevented it seeing as he had been flirting with me?"

I don't see myself as a victim mind.

But, here you've got young or aspiring acts in a "it's your word against his" scenario. Sure that's just a flirty gay lad "messing".... that's part of his shtick, part of his act...

I think it comes to a head when they see him talking about mental health issues, or seeing him making sexualised remarks on Blind Date or basically see a sexual bully who has harrassed them not being taken to task for his behaviour.

And they say "enough is enough" .... in the same way that kids come out after years to say "my dad raped me"....

Waiting decades also eliminates that pesky forensic evidence or lack thereof and muddies memories, meaning alibis2are difficult to establish.

Galwayguy35 · 19-11-2017 11:00AM

zoobizoo wrote: »

Couple of years back I was sharing a room with a gay lad in a hostel. Three of us were in the room. Me, him and his brother (who didn't speak English). He had been flirting with me for a few days. I batted it off - I'm a straight easy going guy.

Woke up in the middle of the night with him having pulled my duvet down, had his hand on the top of my boxers and his mouth moving towards my dick...

He was a basic nobody - I punched him before his mouth reached its intended destination. I guess it was sexual assault. Or would have been had I not woken.

I cornered him, shouted at him for a few minutes. Threatened him with a beating. Then went back to bed. Got up the next day and got him kicked out of the hostel.

Didnt' bother going to the cops... why would I? What good would it have done? Court... hassle.... qusestions like "why had I not prevented it seeing as he had been flirting with me?"

I don't see myself as a victim mind.

But, here you've got young or aspiring acts in a "it's your word against his" scenario. Sure that's just a flirty gay lad "messing".... that's part of his shtick, part of his act...

I think it comes to a head when they see him talking about mental health issues, or seeing him making sexualised remarks on Blind Date or basically see a sexual bully who has harrassed them not being taken to task for his behaviour.

And they say "enough is enough" .... in the same way that kids come out after years to say "my dad raped me"....

If this happened the way you say it did then of course you are a victim of sexual assault.

Don Kiddick · 19-11-2017 11:03AM

PeterParker957 wrote: »

Because maybe finally there's someone who doesn't worship at the altar of f***ing social media.

I cannot stand Porter. He's as funny as trapping your hand in a car door but I am thoroughly sick of "taking to Twitter" when anything happens from the cat farting to yoy allegedly being assaulted.

He has over 9k tweets....he's a twitterwhore if I ever saw one

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 11:04AM

Galwayguy35 wrote: »

zoobizoo wrote: »

Couple of years back I was sharing a room with a gay lad in a hostel. Three of us were in the room. Me, him and his brother (who didn't speak English). He had been flirting with me for a few days. I batted it off - I'm a straight easy going guy.

Woke up in the middle of the night with him having pulled my duvet down, had his hand on the top of my boxers and his mouth moving towards my dick...

He was a basic nobody - I punched him before his mouth reached its intended destination. I guess it was sexual assault. Or would have been had I not woken.

I cornered him, shouted at him for a few minutes. Threatened him with a beating. Then went back to bed. Got up the next day and got him kicked out of the hostel.

Didnt' bother going to the cops... why would I? What good would it have done? Court... hassle.... qusestions like "why had I not prevented it seeing as he had been flirting with me?"

I don't see myself as a victim mind.

But, here you've got young or aspiring acts in a "it's your word against his" scenario. Sure that's just a flirty gay lad "messing".... that's part of his shtick, part of his act...

I think it comes to a head when they see him talking about mental health issues, or seeing him making sexualised remarks on Blind Date or basically see a sexual bully who has harrassed them not being taken to task for his behaviour.

And they say "enough is enough" .... in the same way that kids come out after years to say "my dad raped me"....

If this happened the way you say it did then of course you are a victim of sexual assault.

This is the thing I don't get.

When did it become ok to tell someone they were assaulted? They don't feel they were, they don't consider themselves a victim - that's their decision/perspective not someone else's.

Don Kiddick · 19-11-2017 11:06AM

PeterParker957 wrote: »

This is the thing I don't get.

When did it become ok to tell someone they were assaulted? They don't feel they were, they don't consider themselves a victim - that's their decision/perspective not someone else's.

Completely untrue,

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 11:06AM

Don Kiddick wrote: »

PeterParker957 wrote: »

Because maybe finally there's someone who doesn't worship at the altar of f***ing social media.

I cannot stand Porter. He's as funny as trapping your hand in a car door but I am thoroughly sick of "taking to Twitter" when anything happens from the cat farting to yoy allegedly being assaulted.

He has over 9k tweets....he's a twitterwhore if I ever saw one

Maybe being falsely accused of something has put him off?

Phoebas · 19-11-2017 11:06AM

strandroad wrote: »

Absolutely. But then his employers acted quickly and decisively, unlike Hook's.

They're not comparable cases.
Hook was accused of having an unpopular opinion.
Porter is accused of criminal behaviour.

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 11:08AM

Don Kiddick wrote: »

PeterParker957 wrote: »

This is the thing I don't get.

When did it become ok to tell someone they were assaulted? They don't feel they were, they don't consider themselves a victim - that's their decision/perspective not someone else's.

Completely untrue,

Strongly disagree. I had my arse grabbed on the tube.

Told him to move the arm or lose it.

I was not sexually assaulted, I am not a victim. Do not weaken my response and ability to defend myself by calling me such.

It's no one's call but mine. Same as poster in hostel above.

PeterParker957 · 19-11-2017 11:09AM

Phoebas wrote: »

strandroad wrote: »

Absolutely. But then his employers acted quickly and decisively, unlike Hook's.

They're not comparable cases.
Hook was accused of having an unpopular opinion.
Porter is accused of criminal behaviour.

And yet both tried in the twin courts of Twitter and da feelz.

Don Kiddick · 19-11-2017 11:12AM

PeterParker957 wrote: »

Strongly disagree. I had my arse grabbed on the tube.

Told him to move the arm or lose it.

I was not sexually assaulted, I am not a victim. Do not weaken my response and ability to defend myself by calling me such.

It's no one's call but mine. Same as poster in hostel above.

Again...your initial statement is totally untrue

PowerToWait · 19-11-2017 11:13AM

zoobizoo wrote: »

And they say "enough is enough" .... in the same way that kids come out after years to say "my dad raped me"....

It's not at all comparable to paternal rape. Not in the slightest.

Kerrydude1981 · 19-11-2017 11:15AM

Nice change of subject there on TV3 going from the Al Porter story to asking people have they the Xmas tree up

Al Porter Scandal

Comments