Still not cracked it

Caribs · 24-10-2017 08:11PM #1

I've been experimenting with extract recipes, primarily on the additions of different types of hops at different stages of the boil but have been disappointed with the results. Generally get a lovely clear brew, good head and right amount of carbonation, good FG etc. Just being let down by the minor detail of the taste!

I normally start by boiling up 3kg of Craft range LME and water in a 10L pot, attempt to get the hot break and then over an hour add hops at different stages. I don't have a cooler but once the boil is over I try to get the temp down as quickly as possible, add the yeast and leave it go.

Last couple of brews while smelling somewhat okay, in that you get a bit of hop aroma, just seem to be overwhelmed with almost a burnt malty type taste. I don't let the malt stick or burn off during the boil and would sometimes get a similar taste when starting off with the extract kits.

Basically, beers end up tasting like muck and are not improving - any hints?

Bogwoppit · 24-10-2017 08:14PM

Caribs wrote: »

I've been experimenting with extract recipes, primarily on the additions of different types of hops at different stages of the boil but have been disappointed with the results. Generally get a lovely clear brew, good head and right amount of carbonation, good FG etc. Just being let down by the minor detail of the taste!

I normally start by boiling up 3kg of Craft range LME and water in a 10L pot, attempt to get the hot break and then over an hour add hops at different stages. I don't have a cooler but once the boil is over I try to get the temp down as quickly as possible, add the yeast and leave it go.

Last couple of brews while smelling somewhat okay, in that you get a bit of hop aroma, just seem to be overwhelmed with almost a burnt malty type taste. I don't let the malt stick or burn off during the boil and would sometimes get a similar taste when starting off with the extract kits.

Basically, beers end up tasting like muck and are not improving - any hints?

Simple solution, go all grain or at least partial mash.

Caribs · 24-10-2017 08:15PM

I don't have the gear (or don't think I do) to start using grain

Bogwoppit · 24-10-2017 08:19PM

Caribs wrote: »

I don't have the gear (or don't think I do) to start using grain

What do you have?

Caribs · 24-10-2017 08:57PM

I have the 25L fermentation drum, airlock etc and then just a 10L pot for starting off the process.

Fairly basic set up I know

BeerNut · 25-10-2017 09:39AM

Your system seems fine in theory, but you'd need to post some of your recipes for us to be of assistance. Even then there's not a whole we can do without tasting your beer. Your best bet is to bring some to your local homebrew club for appraisal. They'll be happy to advise.

RasTa · 25-10-2017 11:41AM

You're cooking your chips in a microwave. Buy a potato and go all grain.

BeerNut · 25-10-2017 11:48AM

I've brewed extract for years and got perfectly good results. Moving to all-grain when you don't know why your extract beers aren't turning out the way you want would be a mistake. It seems unlikely it would fix the problem.

Caribs · 25-10-2017 12:19PM

BeerNut wrote: »

Your system seems fine in theory, but you'd need to post some of your recipes for us to be of assistance. Even then there's not a whole we can do without tasting your beer. Your best bet is to bring some to your local homebrew club for appraisal. They'll be happy to advise.

Thanks for the advice, good to know the process is in theory at least okay so far. I'd concerns that boiling the LME was causing the problems.

Here's two recipes I used both of which were made up to 23 litres

3kg Craft Range LME
500gms Spray Malt brew enhancer

40gms Cascade Hops @ 60 mins
30gms Columbus Hops @ 30mins
12gms Chinook Hops @ 10 mins

Starting Gravity 1.046 and Finished at 1.007

3kg Craft Range LME
500gms Spray Malt brew enhancer

50gms Cascade Hops @ 60 mins
40gms Columbus Hops @ 30mins
12gms Target Hops @ 10 mins

Starting Gravity 1.005 and Finished at 1.008

First recipe was very nice to drink (initially at least) but the second one despite being very similar didn't end up tasting great

RasTa · 25-10-2017 12:25PM

I thought you don't bother with 60min boils during extract?

mordeith · 25-10-2017 12:30PM

Is the brew enhancer boiled with the LME?

macnug · 25-10-2017 12:34PM

Personally I'd don't like the taste of LME, taste totally different to an all DME brew. I find LME taste closer to a kit while DME taste closer to a all grain.

RasTa · 25-10-2017 12:38PM

from reading around the forums it seems boiling for 60mins is causing this caramelised taste.

Caribs · 25-10-2017 01:02PM

mordeith wrote: »

Is the brew enhancer boiled with the LME?

No, I normally mix that in just before I start to bring the temp down but did some more searching after the post from Rasta and have read you can boil it but the jury seems to be out :-).

If it's the boiling that is causing that caramelised taste but I want to play with the hops, can you just boil the hops in water or a very diluted part of the LME/DME and then just bring it all together at the end?

BeerNut · 25-10-2017 01:06PM

You have no speciality malt, which could be why the beers aren't coming out very interesting. On the assumption that you're making something vaguely in a pale ale style, steep 500g of light crystal or amber or Caramunich malt in a muslin bag or cheese cloth in about 3L of water at 60C for about 20 minutes, then add that to the kettle.

If it were me I would abandon the LME altogether: it oxidises in the tin. Switch to 100% spraymalt.

The hop additions seem unbalanced towards the beginning: I would change to more late hops.

Assuming that you're doing partial boils, ie topping up with cold water afterwards, I have been told that it's best for hop utilisation to begin with only half the fermentables in the kettle and add the rest half way through. That might fix your caramelisation issue too.

Plenty to tweak there, but the speciality malt is the biggie.

Caribs · 25-10-2017 01:08PM

Thanks for the advice all, much appreciated

beans · 25-10-2017 03:02PM

I use a similar setup for extract brewing, and my most noticeable improvement came from the addition of a copper-pipe heat-transfer setup to get the temps down to room-temp after cooking. Takes about 20 minutes now.

Caribs · 18-12-2017 04:24PM

Thanks for all the advice lads,

Latest brew much more drinkable with the burnt flavours no where to be seen. Back to the hop experimentations again but DME seems to have definitely helped.

loyatemu · 20-12-2017 11:44AM

reading various forums, liquid malt is blamed by a lot of people for what is called "kit twang" - the cidery aftertaste a lot of kit beers have. Personally I've never made a kit beer that didn't have some slight off-taste, when I switched to doing Extract I used DME and never had the same problem. The one issue with DME is it's very expensive compared to all-grain (though that's not factoring the cost of extra equipment, but hey, no one ever counts the cost of the gear :pac:)

Still not cracked it

Comments