Mayo GAA Discussion - Part 3

km79 · 23-07-2017 07:54PM

statto25 wrote: »

Rossies have ready named their team for next Sunday.

LOL they aren't even pretending
The whole thing is a joke now
Mayo will probably tweet 4 different teams at midnight next Saturday

Mayo Club 51 · 23-07-2017 08:09PM

franklyon · 23-07-2017 08:14PM

Just watched it back again, well bits and pieces here and there anyway, Lee Keegan unlucky to get a black card as he had been fouled himself seconds earlier, at least he should be well rested for next Sunday.

Oldtree · 23-07-2017 09:08PM

km79 wrote: »

LOL they aren't even pretending
The whole thing is a joke now
Mayo will probably tweet 4 different teams at midnight next Saturday

Maby roscommon are trying some sort of reverse reverse psychology?

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 09:34PM

Oldtree wrote: »

Maby roscommon are trying some sort of reverse reverse psychology?

TBF simple consistency really,they announced their team the Sunday previous to the Connacht final.

Can't see any element of reverse psychology involved,Kevin McStay could hardly change the team after their performance the last day out.

km79 · 23-07-2017 09:43PM

seligehgit wrote: »

TBF simple consistency really,they announced their team the Sunday previous to the Connacht final.

Can't see any element of reverse psychology involved,Kevin McStay could hardly change the team after their performance the last day out.

It's a week to the game
Does training this week not count ?
Lads close to the team pushing for a place ?

And then of course there could be an injury

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 10:13PM

km79 wrote: »

It's a week to the game
Does training this week not count ?
Lads close to the team pushing for a place ?

And then of course there could be an injury

Of course it does but unless the players in situ are doing something awfully wrong one rarely changes a winning team,if there's an injury quel est la probleme?Simply make the change,it's really a storm in a teacup.

How many team permutations has Stephen Rochford made leading up to games without anybody batting an eyelid?We've had many matchday changes.McStay is simply emphatically expressing a vote of confidence in the men who went into battle the last day and is consistent in the timing of that expression.

km79 · 23-07-2017 10:19PM

seligehgit wrote: »

Of course it does but unless the players in situ are doing something awfully wrong one rarely changes a winning team,if there's an injury quel est la probleme?Simply make the change,it's really a storm in a teacup.

How many team permutations has Stephen Rochford made leading up to games without anybody batting an eyelid?We've had many matchday changes.McStay is simply emphatically expressing a vote of confidence in the men who went into battle the last day and is consistent in the timing of that expression.

So just wait till after training Friday night to make sure there are no injuries and then name the unchanged team ?
It's mind games
Putting it out early as if he doesn't care about the opponents
It's the same as naming a dummy team due to all the possibilities between now and Sunday

Anyway it's makes no odds I just think it's absolutely daft

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 10:35PM

km79 wrote: »

So just wait till after training Friday night to make sure there are no injuries and then name the unchanged team ?
It's mind games
Putting it out early as if he doesn't care about the opponents
It's the same as naming a dummy team due to all the possibilities between now and Sunday

Anyway it's makes no odds I just think it's absolutely daft

Mind games are an essential part of sport,I still think it's much ado about nothing.Is there any harm in the psychology of concentrating on your own team and letting your opponents worry about you?It expresses a certain confidence in your team naming them this early.Such is McStay's prerogative.As you correctly state named teams mean nothing anyway.

Anyway we're up momentarily on the Sunday Game!

blinding · 23-07-2017 10:46PM

Well we are talking about it so from that point of view maybe its working......

If we beat them it won't have worked mind.....

23-07-2017 11:03PM

Good points made tonight regarding cafferkey, we must have someone else who can jump more than 2 inches available as a full back ??

naughto · 23-07-2017 11:15PM

He has to be dropped no question about it

Audioslaven · 23-07-2017 11:22PM

naughto wrote: »

He has to be dropped no question about it

The problem is who do you replace him with. It's so late in the season to go messing around with such a vital position. We just don't have many options here unless you drop Barrett into the position but I do agree with you that a change needs to happen

naughto · 23-07-2017 11:25PM

Coen and Barrett at 6 or 3 or 3 and 6 would be my answer

23-07-2017 11:27PM

Audioslaven wrote: »

The problem is who do you replace him with. It's so late in the season to go messing around with such a vital position. We just don't have many options here unless you drop Barrett into the position but I do agree with you that a change needs to happen

Anybody at this stage, he was no better against Sligo than against Cork. He could't field, couldn't out run his forward, and more often than not pushed the forward in the back giving away easy frees.

The Cork forward yesterday who is 36, ran past cafferkey got the ball and then went right around him and popped it over the bar, he may as well not of been there.

franklyon · 23-07-2017 11:28PM

I would disagree and say its not too late to change, whoever replaces him can't do any worse. You can be sure that high ball will be pumped in there all day long for Donaghy if we manage to get past Roscommon.

Padkir · 23-07-2017 11:29PM

naughto wrote: »

Coen and Barrett at 6 or 3 or 3 and 6 would be my answer

Would agree something needs to change, but I thought Coen, after a good showing against Clare, was poor when brought on against Cork. Gave the ball away an awful lot.

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 11:32PM

naughto wrote: »

Coen and Barrett at 6 or 3 or 3 and 6 would be my answer

Barrett has not got the requisite height to command the position in my opinion.Coen for me although what about Caolan Crowe?

I might be reading things all wrong but for me the body language between Rochford and Cafferkey was totally off when he was finally called ashore.The manager appeared none too pleased,anybody else notice this or am I always reading too much into same.:)

glack · 23-07-2017 11:33PM

seligehgit wrote: »

Barrett has not got the requisite height to command the position in my opinion.Coen for me although what about Caolan Crowe?

I might be reading things all wrong but for me the body language between Rochford and Cafferkey was totally off when he was finally called ashore.The manager appeared none too pleased,anybody else notice this or am I always reading too much into same.:)

If he was none too pleased why didn't he take him off much sooner?!

Kristopherus · 23-07-2017 11:33PM

Padkir wrote: »

Would agree something needs to change, but I thought Coen, after a good showing against Clare, was poor when brought on against Cork. Gave the ball away an awful lot.

Yep, he had a mare on Saturday. But he is a young big lad who should be able to jump higher than Caff.

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 11:36PM

glack wrote: »

If he was none too pleased why didn't he take him off much sooner?!

Not a notion that's why I'm asking the question.

As I stated I may have seen something in nothing.

yop · 23-07-2017 11:37PM

Audioslaven wrote: »

The problem is who do you replace him with. It's so late in the season to go messing around with such a vital position. We just don't have many options here unless you drop Barrett into the position but I do agree with you that a change needs to happen

At this stage Vaughan or Coen. Its harsh but he is a liablity. His man kicked 6 points off him in the 1st half and between the 2 lads he marked, they took 11 points off him. Now that has to set alarm bells ringing. His pace is gone and his confidence has to be on the ground. The Roscommon forwards will destroy him next Sunday. Hopefully he will prove me wrong and he has been a massive servant, but his day is done.

Yesterday was a repeat of many of our games in the last 7 months. Great spurts, some great positives, some shocking defending.
If we lost it was a nail in the coffin for a few stalwarts and management. The decisions off the bench have me baffled.
Respect Dillion and all he has done, but for the 2nd time in a row now he has offered us nothing in his appearances, almost cost us. Taking off A Moran, Barret, O'Shea so close together was not great.

Lee really needs to cop the fk on. He is long enough on the road to know better than kick out like that. All players get riled, they need to deal with it. Its another disciplinary issue.

Pro - The character, no one can ever question that. we were 7 up, looked like we blew it, went 3 down thought they heads would drop, but these guys have incredible resilience.
8 forwards scored from play, for a team with no forwards the return of 81% is a great return.
AOS - Again was a mountain. Again got ZERO protection from officials. Twice I saw him taking punches, with the linesman watching.
COC - Took some lovely scores.
Loftus - Really top notch scores.
Durcan - Was A1 when he came on, I'd teach lee a lesson and put his ass on the bench for this lad.
Doherty - Emptied it, gave 100%. Always does, never gets the limelight.

Rossies will hurt us, they have the tail up and rightly so. Experience and cool heads needed next Sunday. Could see a draw on this one. But I expect an open game. Need big big games at the back and from AOS and COC.
Would want a top strong ref on this one as its going to be hell for leather.

manofwisdom · 23-07-2017 11:38PM

Fr Tod Umptious wrote: »

They thought there were brilliant displays by Mayo all over the field.

Cillian was on song, AOS was once again giving a big F you to the rest of the country, Moran got 4 from play, 5 of the starting 6 forwards scored, and all did from play.

As the game was unfolding I was wondering what the media narrative would be like in the sense that Mayo would be compared to Kerry because they both played Cork.

Kerry were 4 up at HT, Mayo were 3 up.

Kerry won by 11, Mayo were 7 up at one point and cruising.

Of the 21 they scored in normal time, 18 we're from play, that's the sort of stuff that people gush on about Kerry doing.

Cork created as many if not more goal chances v Kerry as they did v Mayo.

Cork hit the side netting and had one cleared off the line I think v Kerry

The only problem is that two went in v Mayo and for all their good work up front they found themselves in a dog fight.

I'm not good at analysing defensive structures so I don't know why it happened but it will have to stop.

Mayo's meeting Kerry in the next round always required Donegal to win anyway and that as it turns out never happened, but after the effort put in yesterday, on a warm evening, facing the weaker of the QF opponents may be the best thing.

In a game that Mayo were expected to win comfortably there was some good individual displays from the likes of C O Connor,A Moran and A O Shea but midfield and defensively Mayo were not brilliant on Saturday.

You are using the Munster final as example there but Kerry won that match by 11 after 70 mins and rarely got out of 2nd gear doing so, yes Kerry could have conceded a goal or two however don't think Kerry would have allowed themselves to get into a dog fight against a side that was on life support.

Both Mayo and Kerry scored points for fun from play against Cork but i think that says more about Corks defending, they get numbers back but rarely lay a glove on the shooters.

Its not just the goal chances Mayo gave up yesterday either, Cork kicked around 16 wides on top of the 20 point they conceded and Mayo playing brilliant do not give up that amount of scoring chances in a game especially against a side like cork who are in a poor place.

Yes of course Donegal lost and ruled out that pairing but i do believe Mayos best chance of beating Kerry this summer was in the Quarter final. I expect Galway to now give a rusty Kerry a good test next Sunday but they are unlikely to beat them because they lack experience and their record in Croke park in the championship since 2001 for a county of their size and pick is terrible.

km79 · 23-07-2017 11:38PM

Thank god I watched the game back and didn't rely on the Sunday game "coverage " and "analysis "

All the pissing and moaning about Sky
They do it right
RTÉ had it all their own way for years so you would assume they would have stepped up tbeir game when challenged
But no they just came out moaning

It's the first game I've watched back on sky as I go to them alll anyway and it's light years ahead
They ANALYZE instead of throwing out the same auld ****e

Although RTÉ changed tack tonight
After moaning about our lack of forwards and marquee forwards
They decided to completely ignore our proficiency and a performance for the ages from Cillian to tear Caff apart

seligehgit · 23-07-2017 11:41PM

Forgot about Donie Vaughan as an option as full back until Yop kindly reminded me. Played the position previously in the FBD league,not so sure about the league.

He has the physical presence,adequate mobility and would be a definite improvement under the high ball.

Audioslaven · 23-07-2017 11:44PM

yop wrote: »

Lee really needs to cop the fk on. He is long enough on the road to know better than kick out like that. All players get riled, they need to deal with it. Its another disciplinary issue.

yes, he needs to rail it in. If he gets another one, he is out for a game as he will have three AFAIK.
He is some player though. Before the start of the game, keegan and his man were at it. He will not give an inch and this is what makes him a great player.

km79 · 23-07-2017 11:46PM

Audioslaven wrote: »

yes, he needs to rail it in. If he gets another one, he is out for a game as he will have three AFAIK.
He is some player though. Before the start of the game, keegan and his man were at it. He will not give an inch and this is what makes him a great player.

Still haven't seen it
The Sunday game didn't show it .......

Audioslaven · 23-07-2017 11:50PM

seligehgit wrote: »

Forgot about Donie Vaughan as an option as full back until Yop kindly reminded me. Played the position previously in the FBD league,not so sure about the league.

He has the physical presence,adequate mobility and would be a definite improvement under the high ball.

I don't think Vaughan is the answer as his pace is gone and we need someone with a bit of pace. Coen may be the best option and I hear from a good source that he is very driven to make it into the team.

The main thing is whoever we slot in, we need a sweeper to protect him properly, so that he can build some confidence in the role.

km79 · 23-07-2017 11:53PM

Audioslaven wrote: »

I don't think Vaughan is the answer as his pace is gone and we need someone with a bit of pace. Coen may be the best option and I hear from a good source that he is very driven to make it into the team.

The main thing is whoever we slot in, we need a sweeper to protect him properly, so that he can build some confidence in the role.

We don't have time to build someone's confidence in the role
It's caff
Or
Vaughan
Or
Back to last years system

Talk of throwing in an inexperienced senior player into a specialist position he doesn't play at the quarter final stage is nonsense
It will not and should not happen

Again I'd be questioning the protection the sweeper Higgins gave the full back
Higgins doesn't se to want to mark or defend anymore and I think he is becoming a problem

Blackjack · 23-07-2017 11:53PM

km79 wrote: »

Still haven't seen it
The Sunday game didn't show it .......

To be fair it was a trip and he can have no complaints about receiving a black card for it. He was being pulled and dragged by his man all the while beforehand but that's no excuse for a player of Lee's quality.

Mayo GAA Discussion - Part 3

Comments