Are there too many stand up comics?

darkdubh · 24-04-2017 09:29PM

Deleted User wrote: »

Eoin Colgan can be funny alright. Not sure about him doing stand up though.

The worst are comedians from North of the border, like the Hole in the Wall Gang.

That crowd behind Give My Head Peace, they all bloody deserved internment without trial for that comedic atrocity. There was another one from The North about a family who all had red hair and that was pretty much the only joke, made Mrs Browns Boys look subtle in comparison.

mikeym · 24-04-2017 10:36PM

Amy Schumer & Tommy Tiernan are by far the worst comedians out there.

Murrisk · 25-04-2017 02:46AM

PARlance wrote: »

I'll whisper this one... I thought Maxwell was quite funny at the start.

Parchment wrote: »

I agree - i thought Andrew Maxwell was funny on the Panel.

Me too. Liked him back then. There is a pathological dislike of Andrew Maxwell on boards that personally I find a tad OTT.

fatknacker · 25-04-2017 03:25AM

Ash.J.Williams wrote: »

I enjoy Farmer michael on youtube, anyone like or dislike him? most seem to dislike.

I liked the first few I'd seen but I imagine it will get tired quite soon.

Arghus · 25-04-2017 03:52AM

Ash.J.Williams wrote: »

I enjoy Farmer michael on youtube, anyone like or dislike him? most seem to dislike.

Sometimes I do laugh at the accuracy with which he captures that particular brand of Irish shitetalk. But the shtick wears fairly thin after video number three or four. And also with all the tats and the McGregor haircut I wonder if he is just as big a caricature as the character he portrays.

Arghus · 25-04-2017 03:58AM

Murrisk wrote: »

Me too. Liked him back then. There is a pathological dislike of Andrew Maxwell on boards that personally I find a tad OTT.

There's an inverse relationship between how funny he actually is and how funny he thinks he is. Saw him a few times live and I've - sincerely - never seen someone phone it in with so little effort. Maybe I was unlucky, but it happened more than once. I don't hate the man or anything that extreme - I just think he's a dire comedian!

suicide_circus · 25-04-2017 04:42AM

Dylan Moran is miles ahead of the rest. McSavage has very occasional glimpses of genius, go on now country boy.

darkdubh · 25-04-2017 06:44AM

Ash.J.Williams wrote: »

ha i nearly forgot, i was in the international a few months back and something hilarious happened!

Having a great night, the comedians were funny and the atmosphere was great, Then one of the hosts sheepishly mentioned that there was going to be a change of plan and there was an extra act. In walks "the boss" aka Aidan Bishop and up he gets....and quickly dies on the spot and limps off the stage. I looked around at the crowd reactions and people were really confused about why this guy was onstage.

Next comedian gets up "well ....that was weird!"

That guy is a prime example of someone riding on the coat tails of their (slightly) more talented and famous sibling.

Erik Shin · 25-04-2017 06:53AM

Anybody who believes Dave McSavage is a good comedian needs to actually see the guy live.....Pure drivel...And I'm being kind.

Jim Jeffries is a modern day genius imo

Ranjo · 25-04-2017 07:03AM

"Too many comedians thread becomes praise/rant of comedians in an effort to determine the ranking for culling of aforementioned comedians." Internet Comedien, 2017

Subcomandante Marcos · 25-04-2017 07:10AM

Right now in stand up world wide there's a handful of top tier performers.

People like Louis CK, Dave Chappelle, Bill Burr, Jim Jefferies, and a few others are almost peerless in the field.

The closest that Ireland has to them currently is Dylan Moran. Beyond that there's a lot of people who are ok like O'Brien and a hape of absolute shiiiiite.

JupiterKid · 25-04-2017 07:25AM

I watched Amy Schumer for the first time at my sisters place buzzing on a few Js and thought she was amusing. Saw her again sober back at my place and thought she was meh.

Dylan Moran and Dara O'Brian are among our best talents. Moran in particular is very witty. But so many others are just average or diabolical. Katherine Lynch in particular is utter drivel. So many "comedians" seem to be one trick ponies who only have one actual joke in them that they repeat ad nauseam.

Ash.J.Williams · 25-04-2017 08:58AM

suicide_circus wrote: »

Dylan Moran is miles ahead of the rest. McSavage has very occasional glimpses of genius, go on now country boy.

I would have thought Dylan Moran was over

Ash.J.Williams · 25-04-2017 09:00AM

Erik Shin wrote: »

Anybody who believes Dave McSavage is a good comedian needs to actually see the guy live.....Pure drivel...And I'm being kind.

Jim Jeffries is a modern day genius imo

have to agree about Jim J, he's one of the best out there, and so bloody clever!

Ash.J.Williams · 25-04-2017 09:01AM

darkdubh wrote: »

That guy is a prime example of someone riding on the coat tails of their (slightly) more talented and famous sibling.

i was one of the older people in the room and was amused by the savage car crash of it all, but some of the younger folk were absolutely baffled ....very awkward

Anongeneric · 25-04-2017 04:51PM

Has Frankie Boyle been mentioned in this thread?

Best stand up of his and quite a few more generations,(obviously my opinion, it's subjective)

Cee-Jay-Cee · 25-04-2017 05:01PM

Noveight wrote: »

Ed Byrne is a dose.

And has never been funny, ever. I refuse to watch anything he appears on which thankfully these days is very little.

Agricola · 25-04-2017 05:24PM

That whole bunch off Republic of Telly who's material revolves around 1980's childhood nostalgia. Neil Delamere can be added to them.
They can't even go to England to try to make it big because no one over there heard of Dempsey's Den or the Glenroe music on a school night phenomenon.

25-04-2017 05:27PM

Anongeneric wrote: »

Has Frankie Boyle been mentioned in this thread?

Best stand up of his and quite a few more generations,(obviously my opinion, it's subjective)

I think he's fantastic but I can see why he irks a lot of people

25-04-2017 05:29PM

Agricola wrote: »

That whole bunch off Republic of Telly who's material revolves around 1980's childhood nostalgia. Neil Delamere can be added to them.
They can't even go to England to try to make it big because no one over there heard of Dempsey's Den or the Glenroe music on a school night phenomenon.

I despise the remember when/Irish mammys/fr Ted memes

Anongeneric · 25-04-2017 10:12PM

Becuase they don't have the intellect to get his humour??:D

Yousef Future Stepladder wrote: »

I think he's fantastic but I can see why he irks a lot of people

Zaph · 25-04-2017 10:14PM

Ash.J.Williams wrote: »

I would have thought Dylan Moran was over

Went to see him in Vicar Street a couple of years ago and he was absolutely superb. Not quite as angry as he used to be, but still sharper and wittier than 99% of other comedians out there. My wife had never seen him before and wasn't sure what to expect, but afterwards told me it was one of the best comedy gigs she'd ever been to.

buckwheat · 26-04-2017 12:07AM

Frankie Boyle is the best I've seen. Genius

No good female stand up comedians for some reason. Loads of very funny women on TV but doesn't seem to work on the stage

Anongeneric · 26-04-2017 12:12AM

The silver lining to that twat Theresa May calling a general election is that we should get another Frankie's Election night special.

buckwheat wrote: »

Frankie Boyle is the best I've seen. Genius

No good female stand up comedians for some reason. Loads of very funny women on TV but doesn't seem to work on the stage

Noveight · 26-04-2017 12:13AM

buckwheat wrote: »

No good female stand up comedians for some reason. Loads of very funny women on TV but doesn't seem to work on the stage

I remember seeing Shappi Khorshandi on Live At The Apollo, thought she was alright.

But yeah, very few wimmins seem to do well with stand up.

Ash.J.Williams · 26-04-2017 08:36AM

Anongeneric wrote: »

Has Frankie Boyle been mentioned in this thread?

Best stand up of his and quite a few more generations,(obviously my opinion, it's subjective)

I must start reading more Frankie Boyle, I'm dying to know what he was doing when he made that show Tremadol nights. It's seemed to me that we went all out to push things way over the line, like he went so far over the line he must have planned it to perfection. Anyone know what his motives were?? It looked to me like a big FU to TV.

who the fug · 26-04-2017 08:49AM

biko wrote: »

Humour is one of the most diverse things there is.
Funny for you might not be funny for me.

There is room for everyone

Even Adèle King

Ash.J.Williams · 26-04-2017 08:50AM

who the fug wrote: »

Even Adèle King

ha i met adele once and she was hilarious!

railer201 · 26-04-2017 09:00AM

Yes, half of them should sit down!

bnt · 26-04-2017 10:24AM

It's not just standup comedians, or theatre in general: there are too many people in the "Arts" in general? How do we know there are too many? Since many of them are struggling to make any money, and end up in jobs that are not in the Arts: waiting tables, call centres, and so on. I have some sympathy for them in general, but not when they start acting all entitled, and make sweeping statements such as "we need the arts". To which I'm tempted to reply "yes, we need the Arts, but does the Arts need you?"

Are there too many stand up comics?

Comments