Second Captains

foxtrot101 · 18-01-2017 04:14PM

Dots1982 wrote: »

Kilbane, Andrews, Cunningham and Dan McDonnell. Any of those 4 are able to offer a far greater insight than Richie Sadier IMO.

I think your giving the new lot way too much credit here. OTB is just a continuation of SC's work, SC's are the ones that developed the show to what it is now. The new crowd have hardly changed a thing, they're still following the same formula that was there before they took over. The difference is they have 13 hours of airtime a week as opposed to SC's 4, Which means they can spend more time on topics.

The new OTB is OK, but it is just pale imitation of the original line up.

Dots1982 · 18-01-2017 04:24PM

foxtrot101 wrote: »

I think your giving the new lot way too much credit here. OTB is just a continuation of SC's work, SC's are the ones that developed the show to what it is know. The new crowd have hardly changed a thing, they're still following the same formula that was there before they took over. The difference is they have 13 hours of airtime a week as opposed to SC's 4, Which means they can spend more time on topics.

The new OTB is OK, but it is just pale imitation of the original line up.

I wouldn't disagree really but I think OTB, especially the Football show, is better than what SC produces now. For me it is a better listen for insight with an inferior sense of humour.

SC has a small budget, can't react to live sport and can't interact with texters during the show so it is limited.

In a perfect world the original lineup would still be on OTB I'm sorry to say.

redbuck · 18-01-2017 04:37PM

Dots1982 wrote: »

Kilbane, Andrews, Cunningham and Dan McDonnell. Any of those 4 are able to offer a far greater insight than Richie Sadier IMO.

Personally I think Richie is on par with these guy but my persona favourite is Kenny.

Brock Turnpike · 19-01-2017 06:21PM

Dots1982 wrote: »

Kilbane, Andrews, Cunningham and Dan McDonnell. Any of those 4 are able to offer a far greater insight than Richie Sadier IMO.

Your inclusion of McDonnell in that list is a nonsense. I'm amazed anyone thinks this guy has anything insightful to offer.

Kenny is good. Andrews is okay. I'd take Richie over both of them though.

Dots1982 · 19-01-2017 06:28PM

Brock Turnpike wrote: »

Your inclusion of McDonnell in that list is a nonsense. I'm amazed anyone thinks this guy has anything insightful to offer.

Kenny is good. Andrews is okay. I'd take Richie over both of them though.

Well if you read this thread, plenty do.

pc7 · 19-01-2017 09:07PM

Is there only one podcast today?

MEGA BRO WOLF 5000 · 19-01-2017 09:21PM

Id murder a Cornish pasty.

foxtrot101 · 19-01-2017 10:36PM

pc7 wrote: »

Is there only one podcast today?

No, Richie is supposed to be presenting the second one. It was late when he did it last week too.

yosser hughes · 19-01-2017 11:18PM

foxtrot101 wrote: »

No, Richie is supposed to be presenting the second one. It was late when he did it last week too.

I really don't get their fascination with Ritchie. Boring, whiney voice, not really suited to broadcasting. I can't listen to him

lawred2 · 20-01-2017 09:58AM

yosser hughes wrote: »

I didn't.
I think Ritchie is painful to listen to and regularly disappears up his own arse. He fancies himself as a bit of a Sigmund Freud. He works in the pseudo psychology area.Which of course he was careful to mention.
The lads seem to idolise him a bit which is kind of sad.

yosser hughes wrote: »

I really don't get their fascination with Ritchie. Boring, whiney voice, not really suited to broadcasting. I can't listen to him

I think we get it

Raisins · 20-01-2017 10:38AM

Dots1982 wrote: »

Kilbane, Andrews, Cunningham and Dan McDonnell. Any of those 4 are able to offer a far greater insight than Richie Sadier IMO.

I've never heard anything insightful from Kilbane. I really like him he seems like a genuine guy but he's captain obvious in fairness.

Arghus · 20-01-2017 01:23PM

Those questions from that Dail sub commitee. Jesus wept.

lawred2 · 20-01-2017 02:24PM

Arghus wrote: »

Those questions from that Dail sub commitee. Jesus wept.

incredible eh!?

but would you have expected any different?

wnolan1992 · 20-01-2017 02:32PM

Just listening to the interview with Katie Cook (?) from Monday.

Excellent stuff! Such an interesting story and she comes across really well. The clip of her having a seizure and then being like "Come on! Let's go! No time to rest!" by the time the guy had actually got to her was hilarious.

Arghus · 20-01-2017 03:09PM

lawred2 wrote: »

incredible eh!?

but would you have expected any different?

In a way I wasn't wholly shocked. But, having said that, It was still amazing to hear such inarticulate gibberish from a public representative. Absolute baloney talk at about the level of some fella spoofing at the bar after several pints; like something out of Father Ted. The man couldn't string a coherent sentence together!

lawred2 · 20-01-2017 04:43PM

Arghus wrote: »

In a way I wasn't wholly shocked. But, having said that, It was still amazing to hear such inarticulate gibberish from a public representative. Absolute baloney talk at about the level of some fella spoofing at the bar after several pints; like something out of Father Ted. The man couldn't string a coherent sentence together!

He clearly hadn't given a second thought to this assembly... Obviously to him the sports committee is the cushy down time committee..

Such absolute waffle about being worried about kids having too many options to play sport... Unreal stuff, when I was growing up it was too few options outside the local GAA club to play sport.

But I fear that was ultimately the motivation...

yosser hughes · 20-01-2017 05:26PM

lawred2 wrote: »

I think we get it

Are you stalking me? I don't care if you 'get it' or not.

Cartman78 · 20-01-2017 05:36PM

wnolan1992 wrote: »

Just listening to the interview with Katie Cook (?) from Monday.

Excellent stuff! Such an interesting story and she comes across really well. The clip of her having a seizure and then being like "Come on! Let's go! No time to rest!" by the time the guy had actually got to her was hilarious.

Just caught up with that today as well - really inspiring stuff.

It was like a breath of fresh air after 30 mins of Shane Horgan and Gerry Thornley droning on about rugby. I actually fast forwarded most of it tbh....they are perilously close to Graham Hunter territory at this stage.

I'm not a massive rugby fan by any means but surely they (and OTB/RTE etc) can do more than forensically discuss Munster & Leinster week in week out. Is there an appetite out there for some coverage of the English or French leagues?

buyer95 · 20-01-2017 09:20PM

Cartman78 wrote: »

Just caught up with that today as well - really inspiring stuff.

It was like a breath of fresh air after 30 mins of Shane Horgan and Gerry Thornley droning on about rugby. I actually fast forwarded most of it tbh....they are perilously close to Graham Hunter territory at this stage.

I'm not a massive rugby fan by any means but surely they (and OTB/RTE etc) can do more than forensically discuss Munster & Leinster week in week out. Is there an appetite out there for some coverage of the English or French leagues?

Thornley has been straddling that line with a long time to be fair. Horgan has a ways to go to ever reach those depths.

lawred2 · 20-01-2017 10:33PM

yosser hughes wrote: »

Are you stalking me? I don't care if you 'get it' or not.

Yeah I'm stalking you. You're just so interesting.

trixiebust · 21-01-2017 05:10AM

Arghus wrote:

Those questions from that Dail sub commitee. Jesus wept.

Ridiculous stuff. How much are these gombeens getting paid a year for that !

John Delaney and his prior appointment too.

TheScoringGoal · 21-01-2017 10:13AM

Is it two soccer podcasts this Thursday? Can't find the sports one

pc7 · 21-01-2017 02:42PM

TheScoringGoal wrote: »

Is it two soccer podcasts this Thursday? Can't find the sports one

Richie's one isn't a bad listen (I don't usually listen to the soccer one) it's more about contracts and how it's changed for young players, quite interesting.

buyer95 · 21-01-2017 11:47PM

Really enjoyed the Stephen Elliot interview. Wasn't expecting much but we got some great insight on academy culture, Roy Keane in his early days in management and other interesting things from his career. Seems like a sound fella, hope it works out for him at Drogheda.

Say Your Number · 22-01-2017 07:16PM

Liked Sadlier's story of pissing off Keane at the start, he obviously gave Ken the same order to stay out of studio during the interview that Gilesy would give in the OTB days :pac:

Listened to that Jarlath Regan interview, was almost like Ken was on the psychologists chair at times, doesn't surprise me that he doesn't feel like he's living the dream doing that job, I think he's right in saying that Conor McGregor's life is probably quite boring.

23-01-2017 10:23PM

yosser hughes wrote: »

I really don't get their fascination with Ritchie. Boring, whiney voice, not really suited to broadcasting. I can't listen to him

Agree, his voice is like nails on a blackboard at this stage.

Yes, he is bright and very confident, but at times he comes across as a smug know-it-all.

Dots1982 · 23-01-2017 10:37PM

Decent football show today. Not sure what the lads were on about that people no longer see Rooney as a bit thick. The average football fan mostly would see Rooney as a little simple.

Utopia Parkway · 23-01-2017 10:58PM

Dots1982 wrote: »

Decent football show today. Not sure what the lads were on about that people no longer see Rooney as a bit thick. The average football fan mostly would see Rooney as a little simple.

The Game podcast today was titled Is Wayne Rooney a genius?

They were being serious too.

Dots1982 · 23-01-2017 11:05PM

Utopia Parkway wrote: »

The Game podcast today was titled Is Wayne Rooney a genius?

They were being serious too.

They didn't call their podcast that after he was smashing keys on that piano in the hotel for that wedding while on England duty. Seem to remember Ken Early taking the p*** out of him for that.

lawred2 · 23-01-2017 11:41PM

To be fair, they weren't holding him out as a genius.. Just not a simpleton. Which he's clearly not.

Second Captains

Comments