Phantom Compilation Cd

scotsman

In my opinion. If Phantom need dosh to spank up their studio and feed the Phantoms..

what better way to Phundraise, than to put together a compilation CD. Make it a double CD, filled back to back with every signed and un-signed (IRISH) band that ever made waves in Phantom airspace. It would take little or no bother to get permission from all the bands. Take for example the Phutloose CD. www.phutloose.com.

Am I right or am I right. There's no argument. It would sell as quick as a slippery snot!!! It would soon have PhantomFM looking like the Taj-Mahal. It would definitley be a NATIONAL success. More Profile could only put more pressure on the FAT licence CAT. They could even sell it over their Web-Site. It could be international!! The Rewards!!! THE REWARDS!!!!

To propose 12 home-grown tracks on each CD. Stressing Home-grown. That makes 24.

If this WAS to go ahead. Would the Phantom listeners not choose the songs? DAMN RIGHT THEY WOULD....


The petition.....

Reply if you feel this could/should be done:


Choose....

Choose the tracks/artists YOU feel are worthy:


As this post increases in size, we should all ( because I'm lazy) observe the top 24 requested artists. With me?

p.s There is no doubt in my mind the artists BELOW will recieve countless ammounts of votes. Give a LITTLE MORE THOUGHT to less fortunate but worthy artists

Turn, Bellx1, Gemma Hayes, Brando, Melaton, (cough) the revs (cough), Damien Rice, The Frames, Blotooth, Mundy, Redneck manifesto, jimmy cake, Babelfish e.t.c

AtlantaSuburb

i had the same idea a few weeks ago actually...

:-)

AtlantaSuburb:cool:

Thomas from Presence

Sounds like a plan. We'd help if it came together (mastering, supply of bands, duplication discount we've got goin with a company, phundraising for phundraising cd etc...)

Monkey

there have been quite a few local compilations released recently: The Phutloose one, Dead Languages, Rockets Are Heavy and don't Gigsmart have one out too? Is there much point in another so soon ?

Thomas from Presence

It'd be an excellent cost effective and tasteful money spinner at a phundraising gig where its demand would be at its peak and its market most concentrated, loads of bands will get a good bit of tangible exposure and ppl get introduced to cool tunes they can see live in their city frequently everyone wins.

Twould be dodgy and hard to sell it in a shop for the reasons you outline.

scotsman

Originally posted by Monkey
there have been quite a few local compilations released recently: The Phutloose one, Dead Languages, Rockets Are Heavy and don't Gigsmart have one out too? Is there much point in another so soon ?

Hi there Monkey, Glad to see you're still keepin an eagles eye over proceedings in these here boards. Yea, there's been a bunch of compilations. But let's face it, if Phantom needs the DO, they've got the designer label. There's no doubt their sales would rocket beyond any of the compilations you speak of, all of which are very good.

Thomas from Presence

Not so sure it would outsell the gigsmart one thats got a rather super cool brand name!




(only messin Pete, really!)

polarbelly

phantom were quoted the other day as having 30,000 listeners (the irish times)
7% of the dublin listenership

if just 1000 of those 30,000 people bought the cd in 1 week it'd chart in the top 20 in ireland!

its an amazing idea scotsman... however the capital required to do a proper release would be pretty big... it'd perhaps require a phundraiser night specially to get it off the ground

again i commend your idea

Lisaq

Man, thats not just a good idea, thats a feckin excellent idea! Good stuff outta u!

metalish

That's a really GOOD idea. U should ask about on the Two Petes Talk Rubbish show. There isn't really any cd out there in the shops that sell irish un-signed singed bands compilation, and it'll will help Phantom to get a lisence aswell if it goes ahead:)

freakofnature

as long as

damien rice
brando
turn
blotooth

are on it me and all my phantomloving friends will buy it. that's a lot of people.


how much would it cost?

Pigman

Stick on "no easy way to go" by SubRosa and I'd buy it! Also get some stuff by Crayons and Taribo and we'll be heading in the right direction

scotsman

let me see..mmmmmm....

scotsman

Ok then. Here's how we're shapin up..


Turn
Blotooth
Brando

in at first place with two votes each


Cmon folks, more bands... let get this thread movin

randy_courage

brilliant idea.

future kings of spain,should be on it.
maybe some wilt??? but then again maybe not....

crow

melaton
future kings of spain
Mic Christopher/Mary Janes
Brando
bellx1
Gemma Hayes
Wilt
Damien Rice
Josh Ritter
The Walls
Cyclefly
The Murder of Crows *cough*
Kittser
TURN!

AtlantaSuburb

deputy fuzz
el diablo
louise byrne

gee this city has some great music to offer...

:-)

AtlantaSuburb:cool:

funkster

Based on what I saw last night at TBMC I'd vouch for Polar and Ginseng(?) for deffo and some jimmy cake and Delerentoes

snot

turn - beretta
blowtooth - day job
gemma hayes - worked my way into a calm
bellx 1 - man on meer
wilt- betty, I was hoping every day but it's all over...
la rocca- 1902
the crayons - bringing the conversation down
the frames - this situation's killing me or god bless m
polar - lonely robot song

no booring melaton or damien ricers
keep it sweet -

atonal

hmmm I think it is a good idea - would be cooler if it had stuff that was not on other cd's especially from the better known acts(maybe unreleased songs or acoustic versions or something)

some I would like to see for starters:
The Frames
David Kitt
Polar
Turn
Dudley Corp
LaRocca
BellX1
Arch Stanton

not that i dont allready have most this stuff on cd/downloaded but I would by it anyway, actually I think the Phantom compilation would end up looking alot like the mixes I burn for my friends

DerekD Goldfish

What a great idea if phantomhas as many lisiners as quoted by polarbelly then it could make it to number one as most lisiners would love a copy. the exposure caused by this in newspaper tv whith phantom fm compolation number 1 (slightly optimistic but you never know) it would eaise a hapload for the station. Im sure they could find the money from somewhere

thedrowner

oooh some debuty fuzz and some npb would be nice
also mundy...is mundy irish? im dying to hear his stuff, and every he's playing i'm unable to make it

kirn

this is a brilliant idea!

how about this:

double cd:
side one has rare stuff by the best of the more well known irish acts:

eg
damien rice
frames
wilt
turn
mary janes
bell x1
david kitt
National Prayer Breakfast
the walls
gemma hayes
josh ritter
jimmy cake
the walls
the revs

side two has the best songs by the best of less well known acts:

eg
brando
melaton
blotooth
subrosa
crayons
deputy fuzz
future kings of spain
delorentos
el diablo
polar
ginseng
dudley corporation
laRocca

winners:
people who buy it will get a broad range view of the irish music scene and up and coming acts.

phantom will earn money, credibility, and prove their worth across the irish music industry, and also raise the profile hugely and help their push for the elusive lisense...

the well known bands will gain much exposure and press from this release

the less known bands will expand their fanbase and gain huge exposure, possibly getting into the record collection of 1000 people they wouldn't previously.

truely this is a genious idea and it must be pushed forward....

scotsman

we're doin good here folks. At this stage if I was'nt so lazy, I'd count up the totals. Somebody go to the EDIT- FIND ON THIS PAGE control , add up each band entry and do some kinda chart.

scotsman

And now.....the phanthom complilation chart is brought to you by........

polarbelly

at time of writing heres how it shapes up

with 6

turn

4

brando
blotooth
polar...(not a fix count em yourself... i didnt believe it either)
damien rice
the frames
wilt
bell x 1
gemma hayes

3

mundy
melaton
the crayonz
deputy fuzz
the future knigs of spain
la rocca
david kitt
the jimmy cake

2

subrosa
delerentos
el diablo
ginseng
the dudley corporation
mary janes
NPB
the walls
josh ritter
the revs

1

the redneck manifesto
arch stanton
babelfish
taribo
mic christopher...(although if you count mic and the mary janes together you get 3)
cyclefly
the murder of crows
and
louise byrne



phew...

nice one by the way to everyone putting polar down...

thedrowner

Originally posted by scotsman
ooops:eek: poor mundy:eek: not a single mention:eek:

check again, i do believe i brought him up:)

scotsman

Nice one POLARBELLY.
Will that be the final line-up?
I'm sure there's someone with a CD burner out there who could make a prototype or two. CMON PHANTHOM give us the thumbs up!
Until you do...More people voting please...

Minx

this is a great idea scotsman. if there was a double cd how about one cd of signed bands and one of unsigned.
i was in eamon dorans on sunday night and came across a band called the jive principle - supposidly they get played quite alot on phantom. they were wicked. here's my ideas

the frames
brando
david kitt
mundy
the redneck manifesto
the jive principle

Dr. Loon

Wahey, a bit of support for us!!
Who are you minx? Do we know ye? Thanx anyway....

<edit>BTW Minx... did you happen to see the girl stripping at the front of the stage!? I missed it as I was engrossed in the kit! </edit>

Kurdt

mundy
frames
damien rice (with lisa of course)
wilt
turn
melaton
snow patrol
the walls
therapy?
bell X1
cyclefly
superskin
skyjack
NPB
polar (like the new single, keep it up!!)
ginseng
murder of crows
berkeley
presence
paul o'rielly and friends

ferdi

just do more PHUNDRAISERS, they'll never get old, people will pay more than €12 or whatever it was, the last one was class.

ferdi

Kurdt

there's one in the pipelines, i heard...

autumn time...

Vert

Super idea guys!
You have my money and i'll spread the word!

Some Bands..
Turn, Bellx1,Brando, Melaton,the revs
Damien Rice, The Frames, Blotooth, Mundy,
Crayons, Future kings of spain, Wilt,The Walls
Polar, la rocca, David Kitt
Errmm I'd like some JJ72
Nero...?
Blink!!!
National prayer breakfast

Thomas from Presence

Somebody say Presence?! Awww cheers kurdt! Unfortunately it would be unfair for a defunct band to hold up a spot that could be given to an up and coming act (and for that reason I would like to voice my opinion that the balance of artists under the class new, upcoming, unknown and kickin is a bit lob sided, my nominees for the cd in this category are
Otranome
Skyjack
Murder of Crows
Ginseng
Polar
and Keith Mullins (of whom you'll all know about as soon as we sort him out with a few gigs in Dublin, amazing performer!)

Kurdt

forgot otranome...

obsolete are funny...

and of course Sack...

Vert

Now im not super at maths..
But with well over 500 views of this thread and 35 replies it means some people don't know how to type, are being lazy or they don't think this idea is worthy of a few seconds of their time!

COME ON PEOPLE GET THE FINGERS OUT!!!

LA_girl

I'm way over here in LA, and I'd do *anything* to get my hands on a Phantom CD, definitely! Fabulous idea!

matilda

the frames
turn
wilt
blotooth
bell x 2
mundy
crayonz
la rocca

crow

holy sheep! I forgot aboot Label & Ginseng! my 2 favourite Dublin bands at the moment...

cheers for all who said The Murder of Crows, much appreciated:)!anyone (else) cares to check us out we areThe Murder of Crows. mp3's and other websitey stuff!

bigbigLove,

Seán.

Dr. Loon

C'mon... someone give us a vote We're "up and coming"
Check us out ;
The Jive Principle

Ciaran

Great idea!

The Frames
Mundy
Turn
Subrosa
Brando
Blotooth
Bell X 1
Melaton
David Kitt
NPB

Bateman

This CD would be a great idea, perhaps even to sell a small pressing on a trial basis at Phantom and unsigned events to start with, and if it proevd successful enough then make it bigger.

Kurdt

Originally posted by Dr. Loon
C'mon... someone give us a vote We're "up and coming"
Check us out ;
The Jive Principle

hey man i checked out some songs on yer website...gotta say i was impressed...

so you have my vote...:)

Dr. Loon

Originally posted by Kurdt


hey man i checked out some songs on yer website...gotta say i was impressed...

so you have my vote...:)

Excellent, two votes, thanks a million. If some more people check out the site you might be surprised too! So go on...

hmmwhat?

I suppose my two cents would be (judging from what I have heard in the past couple of months):
The Walls
Quincey
Wallmark
Damien Rice
Murder of Crows (on complete hearsay!)
The Frames of course
The Corpo
Brando
Johny Pyro
Polar
Eh, think that is it?
Great idea though.

SimonMaher

Hello all,

This is something that we in Phantom towers have been thinking about for quite some time at this stage! Could really be a good runner too. We have a couple of musical irons in the fire at the moment in terms of potential plans, but I will chat to some people and get back to ye all on it as soon as I can.

In the meantime, please do keep suggesting. And someone keep track of the votes! Counting was never my strong point.

Regards,

Pete Reed
Phantom FM

LA_girl

What's the tally now?

My vote (does my vote count if I'm not Irish?):

David Kitt
The Walls
Polar
Skyjack
Fairuza
Turn
Bellx1
Bran'do
Future Kings of Spain
The Frames
Blotooth

Vert

Right guys, i tried my best but if someone has the time..maybe look over them..
The results so far..

11
turn, the frames

10

9
polar, bell x 1, Brando, blotooth

8
mundy

7
wilt, damien rice, david kitt
the walls

6
melaton

5
the crayonz, la rocca, ginseng, NPB,
the future kings of spain

4
the murder of crows
gemma hayes

3
Skyjack,
subrosa
deputy fuzz
the jimmy cake
the revs,
the dudley corporation

2
the redneck manifesto
the jive principle
delerentos
el diablo
mary janes
Otranome
cyclefly
josh ritter,


1
arch stanton , babelfish, taribo, Fairuza
mic christopher...(although if you count mic and the mary janes together you get 3)
louise byrne ,
snow patrol
therapy?, Super skin, berkeley, presence
paul o'rielly and friends, Wallmark, Johny Pyro
JJ72, Nero, Blink, Keith Mullins, obsolete, Sack, label, Quincey

Come on people keep voting!!
:cool:

Jim Beam

They've been away for a while but I hear there back now and are most defiantly up and coming and Irish so
"Sundogs"
get a vote from me. There's a lot of good bands being mentioned here which is cool seeing a lot of the time people are complaining about Irish bands. Keep it up people.

kranog

My suggestions,

Ginseng
Blotooth
Otranome
X-Constant
Corrupted
Pinion
Gym-Slip
Popstar (for all the happy Punks)
Polar
Murder of Crows
The Frames (if possible)
&
Wilt (cause they kick ass !!!)

Peace,
kranog

http://popstar.2ya.com