Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Disband the Irish hockey teams.

  • 30-08-2005 6:02pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    God I am so angry. The Irish hockey team can’t play the national anthem or fly our national flag because people from the Northern Ireland think it doesn’t represent them.

    This is not a sporting matter so please don’t move it mods.

    People from the north can’t hijack our country for their own ends. It’s our country, our culture. If they want to play hockey then they can go to England and play their game there.

    The Irish government gives grants to Irish hockey. How then can the farcical arrangements where we held the European Championships here but can’t even fly our own flag in our country. It’s pathetic

    The fact that they don’t want to wear green anymore is another disgrace. This wouldn’t be tolerated in any other European country.


«1

Comments



  • you moan the same way about the rugby?
    Notice something would you please, the Irish rugby team, and the irish Hockey team represent the island of ireland, which doesn't have the same national anthem or flag as the Republic of Ireland. It's as easy as that!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    jubbly wrote:
    If they want to play hockey then they can go to England and play their game there.

    Who are they and why is it their game?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    edit.. maybe this is a sporting matter ><

    In fairness Irish rugby plays in green, and plays the national anthem. The least irish hockey could do is follow suit.

    They ?? The people from Northern Ireland UK who are from another country.




  • listen, you're confused. It would be as ludicrous to sugest what you have as to ask the British and Irish Lions to play with a Union Jack on their hearts.
    look at it like this

    ----Northern Ireland
    Ireland
    ----Republic of Ireland

    when the 2 countries combine under the name "Ireland" then they use an anthem which is acceptable to both.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 17,208 ✭✭✭✭aidan_walsh


    jubbly wrote:
    In fairness Irish rugby plays in green, and plays the national anthem. The least irish hockey could do is follow suit

    Wait... They haven't gone and voted Ireland's Call as the national anthem, have they? :eek:


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,357 ✭✭✭secret_squirrel


    The simple fact is that the IHA has loads of sponsors from both sides of the border - the Irish govt is just one of many.

    You should be glad there is a united irish hockey team - and quit your whining about the symbol they play under. Fortunately your mindless republicanism has nothing to do with Hockey.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    jubbly wrote:
    edit.. maybe this is a sporting matter ><

    In fairness Irish rugby plays in green, and plays the national anthem. The least irish hockey could do is follow suit.

    They ?? The people from Northern Ireland UK who are from another country.

    Have you ever even seen an Irish hockey international? They do play in green.

    The rugby team don't play the anthem away from Dublin and whenever an international was played in Belfast "God Save the Queen" would be played.

    Perhaps we shouldn't let the Northern teams play in the GAA championship....maybe Dublin might have a chance then.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 94 ✭✭Viscosity


    I've always believed that the reason why Hockey, Rugby, entrants to the Olympics have players from both sides of the border is that their governing bodies like the IRFU were founded prior to partition. It really throws up some strange cases where people who consider themselves British end up representing Ireland. As far as I know Wayne McCoullagh is from the Shankill Road. I remember when he won the medal in 1992, one of his neighbours hung out a Union Jack for the RTE cameras.

    I really don't have a problem with the fact that they don't sing the national anthem. Sport should be above politics. The fact that we have two soccer associations on this island hasn't really benefited anyone.

    But yes I'm all for banning the six counties from the GAA, and Dublin too!!! :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14,483 ✭✭✭✭daveirl


    This post has been deleted.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    Im glad that everyone else is happy with the status quo.

    The way I see it is, we dont have a hockey team. We have a team that says it plays for Ireland but we arent allowed to play our own anthem and were not allowed to have our flag flown. They are changing to a navy colour. The soccer team wouldnt be allowed to do that.

    I would have a heart attack if the soccer team wasnt allowed to fly an Irish Tri Colour and the anthem. Would you not be ?

    The national team should represent the country its playing for. They are representing US out there, not Northern Ireland. I really cant accept this.

    England is part of the United Kingdom along with Northern Ireland.

    Im not a nationalist / republian btw.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    They are representing all the people of this island...and I for one am proud of that. Oh and i am a nationalist ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 915 ✭✭✭ArthurDent


    jubbly wrote:
    God I am so angry. The Irish hockey team can’t play the national anthem or fly our national flag because people from the Northern Ireland think it doesn’t represent them.


    The fact that they don’t want to wear green anymore is another disgrace. This wouldn’t be tolerated in any other European country.

    It is an all Ireland team, it represents both Ireland and Northern Ireland and currently Amhran na bhFiann does not represent all the island of Ireland. Also can't find anything on the Irish Hockey site that says they are changing their stirp, can you provide a link please? They certainly played in green at the european championship.

    As for Irelands Call - hmmm can take it or leave it, but it certainly doesn't freak me out that it's played.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,048 ✭✭✭✭murphaph


    I think they should change our anthem anyway. Nobody speaks Irish in any meaningful way so the anthem should be in english for a start. Ireland's call is more rousing for a sporting occasion than Amhrain na bhFiann IMO anyway. I certainly believe that an all-ireland team should play under a flag and anthem acceptable to all communities on the island. I like the shamrock as a symbol of the island. The harp is sort of taken as the O'Neill harp represents the political entity, Ireland (the only country in the world with a musical instrument as it's emblem btw!). As a firm irish soccer fan who never misses a home international and has been away to many I'd happily ditch the tricolour & anthem to get a unified team-ok Norn Iron are a can of p!ss now but they have had serious talent in the past and a bigger pool of players should make us a stronger side in the long run.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    I am poles apart Murphaph. I am personally proud of the Irish national anthem. I like the fact that we use Irish words instead of some wishy washy English version - Irelands call -which sounds all airy fairy, middle class and lacklustre. (I voted for the Irish language to be used as an EU language and would like to see the language grow not demise). I like the way there is a big uplifting end and it’s fantastic when we sing it away in World Cups etc.

    The French national anthem is like ours (militaristic) and they are never going to change it. Would they ever change to an English anthem? I never feel the same about Irelands call. It was forced upon us by a minority.

    Supporting your national team away from home is one of the few ways you can express your Irish ness collectively. I want to support the Ireland I (and the rest of the world) know, not what some person from Antrim thinks it should be.

    To be brutally honest, a small group of northern unionist take part in two sports: rugby and hockey. There are less of them in rugby and so they made do with the inclusion of Irelands call. There are a great proportion of them in hockey (compared to people from Republic of Ireland) and the way I see it is, they are not having one bit of our country yet they want to play under "Ireland". What kind of a hijack is that?

    Why don’t they go and play for Northern Ireland, England or where ever and fly whatever flag they fancy and sing whatever song they wish. I think it would be fairer than them taking over the Irish hockey team and stripping us with without any form of identity.

    I never want to have a faked down Ireland, something that I don’t recognise as being Irish, a team lining out that I don’t recognise as being Irish. The way I see it, Ireland is Ireland, England is England. If you don’t want to play for a country then fine – no one is forcing you. Trying to overtake another countries identity (which you don’t accept as your own) and making it your own is not on for me. I would never try to make England change its jersey, anthem, flay etc.

    Plus on top of all this, it will set a bad precedent for an all Ireland soccer team. That’s another thread but I would only be in favour of them joining us without any changes.

    2/c


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 24,144 Mod ✭✭✭✭robinph


    The way I see it is, we dont have a hockey team.
    Correct, its one team for both the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland.
    We have a team that says it plays for Ireland but we arent allowed to play our own anthem and were not allowed to have our flag flown. They are changing to a navy colour.
    The hockey team plays for Ireland, but they do not play for the Republic of Ireland if thats is what you mean, and as there is neither a flag nor an anthem agreed to represent both coutries at the same time so they have to find a compromise as the rugby team does.
    The soccer team wouldnt be allowed to do that. I would have a heart attack if the soccer team wasnt allowed to fly an Irish Tri Colour and the anthem. Would you not be ?
    The soccer team that you are talking about though plays for the single country of the Republic of Ireland, which is a different group of people than the hockey or rugby teams play for.
    The national team should represent the country its playing for. They are representing US out there, not Northern Ireland.
    But they are representing Northern Ireland, just as they are also representing the Republic of Ireland at the same time. Which bit don't you get?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    robinph wrote:
    Which bit don't you get?

    No need for scarcasim Robinph. Its the lowest form of wit.

    If its not the Republic of Ireland out there then I dont give a rats ass if they lose all their games. Its a complete sell out.

    As for the new navy blue gear they are getting. Well I heard that on Today FM today.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,564 ✭✭✭✭whiskeyman


    jubbly wrote:
    I want to support the Ireland I (and the rest of the world) know, not what some person from Antrim thinks it should be.

    I better not tell you where Uachtaráin na hEireann is from then!!! :p

    You want her out of office now I guess too?


    I dont think people from the North are "hijacking" anything here.
    If anything, we're "hijacking" more players, fans and sponsors.
    It's to our advantage to have a greater base for the above!

    I dont know why it infuriates you so...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 303 ✭✭solskjaer20


    I'm from the north, and I think its a disgrace that the Irish hockey team doesn't fly the tri-colour or sing Ambhrán na Fiann.

    FFS i fly a tricolour in my own room.

    Ireland is one country.
    By not flying the tricolour we're giving into partition thats the Brits forced on uis.

    Also to the people here saying people from the north should go to England.....
    we're far more Irish than many of you Free Staters will ever be.


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 24,144 Mod ✭✭✭✭robinph


    jubbly wrote:
    No need for scarcasim Robinph. Its the lowest form of wit.

    If its not the Republic of Ireland out there then I dont give a rats ass if they lose all their games. Its a complete sell out.

    As for the new navy blue gear they are getting. Well I heard that on Today FM today.

    That wasn't sarcasm, it was a genuine question.

    You were comparing the hockey team to the soccer team who represent two different groups of people. Compare it to the rugby team changing their strip to navy and you'd have something to complain about though.

    But I doubt they'd do that seeing as there is already Scotland, France and Italy playing in varying shades of blue during the 6 nations and it would get a bit confusing. :confused:

    But basicly what you want is two seperate teams competing against each other, with a smaller pool of players to pick from and a smaller source of funding/ sponsorship?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,564 ✭✭✭✭whiskeyman


    jubbly wrote:
    People from the north can’t hijack our country for their own ends. It’s our country, our culture. If they want to play hockey then they can go to England and play their game there.

    I forgot to mention.... did you support the Irish soccer team a few years ago?
    Remember? An Englishman in charge and only a handful of Irish on the squad.
    Did you have any issues that an Englishman decided on the Irish squad?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    I'm from the north, and I think its a disgrace that the Irish hockey team doesn't fly the tri-colour or sing Ambhrán na Fiann.

    FFS i fly a tricolour in my own room.

    Ireland is one country.
    By not flying the tricolour we're giving into partition thats the Brits forced on uis.

    Also to the people here saying people from the north should go to England.....
    we're far more Irish than many of you Free Staters will ever be.



    Free State? I'm from Ireland.

    BTW, which football team do you support solskjaer? ;) Hope it wasn't one the Brits forced upon you?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 303 ✭✭solskjaer20


    Football?
    Why I support Derry opf course.

    But I presume you meant soccer...
    In that case...Derry City.
    I also keep an eye on Man Utd's results as well.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    just surprised your nick isn't Coyle20 :D

    anyway, why not support the Irish hockey team and the different cultures it represents? Surely inclusivity and a team that does not recognise the "partition" and picks it's players from Ireland is a good thing


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,075 ✭✭✭ReefBreak


    I'm from the north, and I think its a disgrace that the Irish hockey team doesn't fly the tri-colour or sing Ambhrán na Fiann.

    FFS i fly a tricolour in my own room.

    Ireland is one country.
    By not flying the tricolour we're giving into partition thats the Brits forced on uis.

    Also to the people here saying people from the north should go to England.....
    we're far more Irish than many of you Free Staters will ever be.
    I feel embaressed that solskjaer20 and jubbly call themselves Irish. It's interesting how the idiotic shinner republicans only ever talk about inclusiveness and welcoming the protestant population into a united ireland. But when it comes to the crunch - even as something as trivial as a hockey match - they suddenly become bigotted, sectarian rabble-rousers.

    I'd be willing to bet that both jubbly and solskjaer20 are Glasgow Celtic supporters - a British team.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,075 ✭✭✭ReefBreak


    RuggieBear wrote:
    just surprised your nick isn't Coyle20 :D

    anyway, why not support the Irish hockey team and the different cultures it represents? Surely inclusivity and a team that does not recognise the "partition" and picks it's players from Ireland is a good thing
    That's very true. It's jaw-droppingly ironic that despite the fact that the twice (hockey & rugby) that we've a United Irish team, all the Shinner-kids can do is moan and whinge about the song that's played. If they were actually willing to tolerate a non-indiginous culture on the island of Ireland, they might find that United Ireland would come much quicker - but I doubt very much that they ever would. Granted, I don't see the loyalist population being of any help either.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 40,038 ✭✭✭✭Sparks


    Out of interest jubbly, are you fluent in Irish? And do you play rugby or hockey?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    whiskeyman wrote:
    I forgot to mention.... did you support the Irish soccer team a few years ago?
    Remember? An Englishman in charge and only a handful of Irish on the squad.
    Did you have any issues that an Englishman decided on the Irish squad?

    Yes of course I did. I support anyone who is representing my country regardless of race, nationality, sex, etc. Thats not the problem.

    The problem is with the few people who have hijacked hockey and hijacked the hockey team that used to represent Ireland. We used to have an Irish team. Now we dont. I cant accept this. It all boils down to a few key points :

    A number of Unionist people in Northern Ireland play hockey. They dont have enough people to compete for Northern Ireland on the world stage. So they decided to join together with Ireland exclusively on their terms . They took the players from here and gave us the sh1t end of the stick. Its their warped idea of a all island hockey team. One that plays for two countries with no form of idenity. it might as well be called Atlantis out there because all the results are meaningless.

    So what if they win the European Championship. Its not us out there.

    If people from the republic of ireland tried to over take the northern ireland soccer team 20 years ago there would be civil war. Imagine us trying to tell them, not to play god save the queen, no british flags and no Northern Irish jersey. Its their right to represent their country.

    ReefBreak, Im not a republican. Im sorry that you feel embarassed. Im just pointing out something that wouldnt be acceptable in any other country in Europe.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    Sparks wrote:
    Out of interest jubbly, are you fluent in Irish? And do you play rugby or hockey?


    Stay on topic Sparks. Re read the first post please.

    ReefBreak, I HATE Glasgow Celtic F.C and HATE Rangers F.C BTW. Just go into the soccer forum. I posted as much already. I think they are both excuses for racism.

    I have no problem with rugby btw. It plays the Irish national anthem, flys the flag and even takes a handshake from our president.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 78,574 ✭✭✭✭Victor


    we're far more Irish than many of you Free Staters will ever be.
    But realise that Amhrán na bhFiann is a Free State anthem (adopted 1926) and not a true 32-county real-Ireland anthem.
    jubbly wrote:
    The problem is with the few people who have hijacked hockey and hijacked the hockey team that used to represent Ireland.
    Isn't hockey a foreign sport?
    jubbly wrote:
    We used to have an Irish team. Now we dont.
    Then what do we have? Why are you complaining about this team if it isn't even the Irish team?
    jubbly wrote:
    ReefBreak, I HATE Glasgow Celtic F.C and HATE Rangers F.C BTW.
    Well thats the problem, isn't is - H.A.T.E.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 40,038 ✭✭✭✭Sparks


    jubbly wrote:
    Stay on topic Sparks. Re read the first post please.
    I did read the first post, and I am on topic.
    Are you fluent in Irish? Do you play hockey? Or rugby?


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 24,144 Mod ✭✭✭✭robinph


    jubbly wrote:
    I have no problem with rugby btw. It plays the Irish national anthem, flys the flag and even takes a handshake from our president.

    No they don't. They play only Irelands Call at all internationals apart from ones in Lansdowne Road.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 568 ✭✭✭por


    jubbly wrote:
    …. I am personally proud of the Irish national anthem. I like the fact that we use Irish words instead of some wishy washy English version - Irelands call -which sounds all airy fairy, middle class and lackluster….

    Have to agree with you on that ‘jubbly’.

    I have no support for both the Irish rugby team or the Irish hockey team because they do not represent my country, i.e. The Republic of Ireland.
    The only Irish team I support is the soccer team because they represent the ROI; they play the national anthem and fly the national flag.
    The best move the FAI ever made was their first back in the 1920s when they broke away from the northern dominated IFA.

    Hockey and rugby can play all the songs they like and fly the Jolly Roger for all I care; as long as they represent ‘Ireland’ they could be Mongolia in my eyes.

    On the other hand , and this may been seen as hypocritical, I have no problem with a team representing Ireland playing in Compromise Rules v Australia or shinty v Scotland.
    Firstly these games are just exhibitions and secondly the people from the north that play in them recognize both the anthem and the flag and have no issues with either.
    The only issue I have with northern GAA teams is the brutal level they have brought football down to.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    jubbly wrote:
    Yes of course I did. I support anyone who is representing my country regardless of race, nationality, sex, etc. Thats not the problem.

    The problem is with the few people who have hijacked hockey and hijacked the hockey team that used to represent Ireland. We used to have an Irish team. Now we dont. I cant accept this. It all boils down to a few key points :

    A number of Unionist people in Northern Ireland play hockey. They dont have enough people to compete for Northern Ireland on the world stage. So they decided to join together with Ireland exclusively on their terms . They took the players from here and gave us the sh1t end of the stick. Its their warped idea of a all island hockey team. One that plays for two countries with no form of idenity. it might as well be called Atlantis out there because all the results are meaningless.

    So what if they win the European Championship. Its not us out there.

    If people from the republic of ireland tried to over take the northern ireland soccer team 20 years ago there would be civil war. Imagine us trying to tell them, not to play god save the queen, no british flags and no Northern Irish jersey. Its their right to represent their country.

    ReefBreak, Im not a republican. Im sorry that you feel embarassed. Im just pointing out something that wouldnt be acceptable in any other country in Europe.

    Can you provide any evidence of this hijacking and when they decided to join with us.

    wow....i actually can't argue with you at all. There is no logic there at all. :eek:


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 24,144 Mod ✭✭✭✭robinph


    Just out of interest, how do you feel about the European Ryder Cup team? After all they are representing Ireland, but then they let all them foreigners join in as well, I hear that there is even some English people on the team. :eek: And what about the flag that they use, thats only got 12 stars on it I think but are there not 25 countries in the EU now. Which one of those stars is for Ireland? They should change it to be a green one just so that everybody knows. And as for using that Beethoven tune as the 'anthem'.

    You'll be pleased to know though that there will probably never be a whole Ireland soccer team though, as that would mean that the FA, SFA, FAW and IFA would have to give up their seats on FIFA and I doubt they would like that idea.



    "I'm all for change and integration, so long as its the other guys that do all of the changing and integrating to our way of doing things."


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,048 ✭✭✭✭murphaph


    Amhran na bhFiann doesn't rouse me at all I have to say. It's because I know the words and their translation, but because Irish isn't my native tongue, the meaning behind those words will forever be lost on me. An english anthem would convey all it's meaning to everyone on the island.

    I don't see what France has to do with this, they all speak french so of course their anthem should be french.

    Guys, just realise that we have a unique situation here on this island and sometimes inclusion means sacrificing things we like. 3000 dead people in NI might be alive today if people had been more inclusive for the past 80 years. I take my international soccer seriously, but it's just a game at the end of the day. It's not worth dividing ourselves over it's symbols.

    I have to agree that blue is a stupid colour for the hockey team. All irish teams play in green, even NI's soccer team. It's internationaly recognised as being of the island of Ireland.

    NI's anthem is much nicer than RoI's too and the air it uses is recognised by millions of people around the world as being from Ireland (even though it was written by an english bloke with no irish connections!).


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 82 ✭✭hill16


    Unionists would be the first to tell you that majority rules. For the majority of people on this Island the soldiers song is their anthem.This is just another example of middle class Ireland bending over backwards to apease Unionists who are a minority. :mad:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    Victor wrote:
    But realise that Amhrán na bhFiann is a Free State anthem (adopted 1926) and not a true 32-county real-Ireland anthem.

    I’m not calling for any 32 county "real" Ireland anthem. I want my own country and culture represented at an international level. Nothing else.
    Isn't hockey a foreign sport?
    what kind of a question is that ? Do you think I’m some kind of Provo republican ? Well I am a republican but in the same sense as is Mc Dowell. I’m happy with the Irish republic and republican values (constitutionally)
    Then what do we have? Why are you complaining about this team if it isn't even the Irish team?

    What am I complaining about ?? well, the national team was hijacked and now there is no national team. There is a team who plays in green (for the short term) has no anthem or flag associated with it but trades under the name "Ireland". That’s what I’m complaining about.

    If people can’t consider themselves Irish then fine. However they want to play for "Ireland" and want to remove all traces of Irishness. Its ludicrous . This is the point I’m making. Why play for an organisation when you cant associate yourself with the very organisation you are playing for ??

    I really can’t get my head around this idea. What do they intend to put in its place? Northern Irish culture?? Make up some new flag and song? It’s not like its to our benefit. Were in a lose lose situation. They just took everything away - players, flags, anthem etc. It should be the other way around. They can join us, not us join them. I’m proud of Irish teams playing internationally. I don’t want a new country. There is nothing wrong with this sovereign country.
    Well thats the problem, isn't is - H.A.T.E.

    go and read what i posted . I hate the clubs because of the whole bigitory that is involved. It’s nothing to do with football.
    Are you fluent in Irish? Do you play hockey? Or rugby?
    That’s irrelevant to the topic.
    No they don't. They play only Irelands Call at all internationals apart from ones in Lansdowne Road.

    That’s good enough for me, coupled with the fact that the Irish flag is allowed to be flown, the president shakes players hand etc. They didn’t come in and say ok we want to play under the name "Ireland" but by the way we want to bin all your culture and values associated with Ireland. I would have liked the Irish national anthem to be played away from home. Its defintely a big loss but Im willing to make allowances for a largely Protestant (British) people minority.

    murphaph, If anyone wants to play for Ireland, where ever they are from then fine. As long as they accept Irish values in sport, accept the country etc. Coming along with their own views and trying to impose them on us is not on IMO. It’s a small minority of middle class people who think they can do this. They can’t. This is Ireland. I’m happy with the country.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 25,848 ✭✭✭✭Zombrex


    I'm not quite sure what the big deal is ... it isn't the Republic of Ireland hockey team, why would it sing the Republic of Ireland national anthem? You would have a whole load of people singing a national anthem that doesn't belong to them or the team they play for. As someone has already pointed out, do you think they should be singing "God save the Queen" when they play matches in Belfast? Think the players from the Republic would find that as offensive as asking the players from N.I to sing the Republic anthem.

    Instead of demanding that the Ireland (as in the island of Ireland) hockey team be disbanded, maybe you should ask why we don't have a Republic of Ireland hockey team? As far as I know it is because the pool of good players is too small, and it gets a lot bigger when you include the North. So really is it worth having a sh*t team all of our own who sing the Republic anthem, or having a good team made up of players from the whole Island?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 983 ✭✭✭Hercule


    Cant we all just get along?...............no? oh ok then. i think that its a simple fact that the hockey and to a lesser extent rugby teams are "less irish" then say the soccer team
    I feel its not patriotic to support a team that is obviously moving away from its own identity, it is blatantly obvious that the team is made up of (unfortunately)two countries on the one island and that it should not represent one of them only. It should not be seen as the ROI team or a UK team but if it is going to call itself ireland it should wear the islands' colour (definitely not blue)

    I dont like the way in which people who express a strong interest in a unified Ireland are seen as having a politically incorrect opinion.
    Even if certain "elements" of society like to allign themselves to the opinion and bring it down, people cannot and should not distort the reasoning behind it as being simple racism,hatred or bigotry.

    When people see national teams lose there identity they are bound to get annoyed - even if they dont give a flying **** about hockey as a sport


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    So really is it worth having a sh*t team all of our own who sing the Republic anthem, or having a good team made up of players from the whole Island?

    A bad team which will get better who is proud to represent your country ? Or a team that has nothing to do with your country, playing international hockey for the benefit of a minority. I would take the former please. At least I can see its Ireland playing out there.

    The least the hockey team could do is follow rubgys example


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,958 ✭✭✭✭RuggieBear


    Hercule wrote:
    i think that its a simple fact that the hockey and to a lesser extent rugby teams are "less irish" then say the soccer team

    huh?

    how are they less "irish"?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 516 ✭✭✭jubbly


    I think I will give up on this topic. Obviosuly everyone is happy with the new "ireland" team.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 40,038 ✭✭✭✭Sparks


    So when was the last time the Republic played the North in hockey anyway?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 983 ✭✭✭Hercule


    how are they less "irish"?

    ah, this brings up a scary "what it means to be irish" topic
    i suppose for some people the definition of being irish effects my original statement

    on a basic level i think a team that moves away from wearing green or singing the national anthem is making itself less irish by my own definition but maybe not by others - im not saying that we should purge the foreign games and make sure our international teams are full of provos but that a team that wants to represent me and get my support should actually represent me (if ya know wat i mean)

    This topic is scary an I want to go home now.


  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 24,144 Mod ✭✭✭✭robinph


    How about considering the rugby and hockey teams that play under the name of Ireland as being equivalent to the Unified Team, or whatever they called themselves, that represented the former Soviet countries in the 1992 Olympics, I think it was '92 anyway.

    Its just the process is curently potentially heading in the oposite direction from what was happening there at the time.

    And dont accuse someone else of having used a majority rules type system, that you clearly don't like, and then go and attempt to make exactly the same mistake as they made.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,048 ✭✭✭✭murphaph


    robinph wrote:
    How about considering the rugby and hockey teams that play under the name of Ireland as being equivalent to the Unified Team, or whatever they called themselves, that represented the former Soviet countries in the 1992 Olympics, I think it was '92 anyway.
    'Twas called the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS). Ah, memories.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,048 ✭✭✭✭murphaph


    Show of hands for Danny Boy to be the new all island of Ireland anthem. Has a nice tune that everyone knows.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 363 ✭✭SparkyLarks


    Amazing you's swear the Republic of Ireland has a green flag. It's Green white and orange.


    Why not orange jersey's? anyone?It's one of the colours on our flag. Are people not proud of all of the flag of the Irish republic??

    The Republic of Ireland don't have a hockey team.
    Just like we don't have a rugby team.
    The island of Ireland does
    ( the rugby team was at one time called the Eire and northern Ireland
    Why should these combined teams play one nationial anthem.
    If the team was mostly from the north then should we play God save the queen.( The Irish rugby team has had 12 players from ulster )
    It's either both or none.


    Jubbly. Has the Team realy nothing to do with you. A team made up of players from your Island. Does the european team for the ryder Cup have nothing to do with you.??

    Hercule. Less Irish thatn the Soccer team, who all live in England, A lot of them wer born there too, not as many as beofre but still a few.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 132 ✭✭Sherlock


    Whats this about Irelands call being played at all Ireland games except at Lansdowne Road, when was it not played at Lansdowne before an international?. Is this whole thread a troll?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 363 ✭✭SparkyLarks


    Sherlock
    Irelands call is played before all of the Irish Rugby Teams matches. home or away.

    In landsdown road they also play The Soldiers song, well some of it anyway.
    For Home Internationals in NIthey aparently play God Save the Queen( I can;t verify as I've never been at one)


  • Advertisement
Advertisement