Terminator Werewolf - Game thread

Derry WW

Vernon WW wrote: »

Out of the 4 on Nigel there's hardly 2 wolves is there? In order of wolfiest I would say Phil, Isla, Frank Vernon.

Dont forget Jake who was part of the Lynch Nidge gang, but switched to No Lynch at the last minute.

Tegan WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Nice cop out here too at the last minute from Jake

If one of Phil or Emily ends up being a wolf its a villagery cop out.

Steve WW

Grah, keep forgetting there's two tied wagons beneath Nidge. Yeah if either are wolves definitely two. Maybe even more if BOTH are wolves

Angus WW

Sorry for the delay folks, I got assigned the gun, so will be looking to co-ordinate the shots now, will need to read back a bit as I'm a couple of pages behind now since reopen

Tegan WW

Emily WW wrote: »

I started to look back over your posts and got distracted with some other things. Now that Nigel is dead and good they may not be so relevant. One is interesting though. Nigel was told he had 30 mins to make a selection of who to get bullets or it would be handed out randomly but yesterday Conor had an hour and a half to hand out lynch power to me. Not sure if it means anything, maybe BJ let Conor get back to thread before randing? Alternative is Conor was waiting to see how to play it. Would of been more suspect of Nigel to be honest had he not died in this one as he actually had a disagreement with Barbara on how to use a bullet that I was going to bring up but again it’s not relevant now.

I voted for you because I felt, like I said earlier you have engaged in some serious fence sitting at times. Today with Barbara you leap quickly to her defence. You can talk about mechanics but it read like somebody who had placed a kill. You defend her method, suggesting I over reacted and then later you yourself think she might need to be lynched (I can link post if you like, have to put kids to bed now) because of her erratic behavior. But then you go and vote for me. That’s inconsistent voting behavior.

But I’d voted for you because you again started playing both sides. Defending Nigel and then casting shade on him when he was looking dodgy for the chop.

Not sure how I feel now after that. If I can get time I will try and do a proper review of you.

Tegan , you said “Nigel is village” in a random post yesterday, what was that about?

As I am about to explain for the umpteenth time, I read him as a villager on tone. He was aggressively pushing cases in a villagery way and I just instantly felt like he was a villager. barbara is doing the same thing at times. I read them both as villager.

Tone is a hard thing to explain. its a feeling and I just got a villagery feeling from both of them

Isla WW

Clodagh WW wrote: »

Isla's reason for voting me was even flimsier than the logic people used for Nidge as wolf. It was a ridiculous non reason....she voted for me because I listed someone on an FFA. Bizarre.

I said that at the time though. So not bizzare at all

Eva WW

My leans for bullets

Phil - Simply has to get a bullet IMO

Jakes distancing post stinks

I'm not sure id advocate using the third one. Emily was 2nd in voting and didn't self pres and left her vote on me. She could comfortably have stood behind a nigel vote but didn't make it. Moves from my wolf lean to my village lean pile

If I was pushed id go Frank

Ffa bullets
Phil
Jake
Frank

Steve WW

Isla WW wrote: »

I said that at the time though. So not bizzare at all

She speaks! And what say you now re: Nigel, Isla

Eva WW

Steve WW wrote: »

Grah, keep forgetting there's two tied wagons beneath Nidge. Yeah if either are wolves definitely two. Maybe even more if BOTH are wolves

Emily no self pres......

Clodagh WW

If we are doing it my bullet list

Phil
Isla
Vernon

Steve WW

Bullet list for me

Phil - gotta go
Frank
Isla

Tegan WW

Eva WW wrote: »

My leans for bullets

Phil - Simply has to get a bullet IMO

Jakes distancing post stinks

I'm not sure id advocate using the third one. Emily was 2nd in voting and didn't self pres and left her vote on me. She could comfortably have stood behind a nigel vote but didn't make it. Moves from my wolf lean to my village lean pile

If I was pushed id go Frank

Ffa bullets
Phil
Jake
Frank

So if Phil is a wolf and Jake and Frank are villagers, then vernon and eva are more than likely wolves.

Emily WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

if Phil or Emily are wolves, they would definitely risk putting 2 wolves on there to protect one of their own.

If I was a wolf why wouldn’t I vote for Nigel? I think it was a fairly easy thing for me to do and to justify it and protect myself. I didn’t vote to self preservation, that’s not a wolf look whatever about anything else I’ve done

Jake WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Dont forget Jake who was part of the Lynch Nidge gang, but switched to No Lynch at the last minute.

Yeah

This morning I was 100% that Nigel was wolf for leading the Lucy train, then Katie dropped in a mention of him and promptly got munched. It just all added up so much.

When he won the contest I didn't think it changed anything and talked myself into the idea he admitted it and picked Conor to gain credibility. It fit in my head, especially as it implicated Barbara who is just annoying (but I no longer think wolf). At the time I didn't feel there was much pushback from anyone except Nigel.

And I left a really detailed post on why I was picking him before logging off for a while and he just ignored it, I still don't understand why he did that.

When I came back I still believed he was a wolf, and his threats that I'd get shot rattled me but kind of confirmed my belief. In the end it was a few other players getting involved and fear of him actually being right that made me jump ship, but honestly I still believed he was wolf when I did.

I get how that looks but that's it. I can dig up my posts to back up all of that

Eva WW

Tegan WW wrote: »

So if Phil is a wolf and Jake and Frank are villagers, then vernon and eva are more than likely wolves.

You’ll need to explain that to me?

Isla WW

Steve WW wrote: »

She speaks! And what say you now re: Nigel, Isla

I was wrong.
I'm sorry to Nigel.
He read wolf to me.

I don't get this maddest thing in WW. Mad things happen every game.

Barbara WW

Jake WW wrote: »

Yeah

This morning I was 100% that Nigel was wolf for leading the Lucy train, then Katie dropped in a mention of him and promptly got munched. It just all added up so much.

And you didn't think that'd be a bit too obvious?

Jake WW

Barbara WW wrote: »

And you didn't think that'd be a bit too obvious?

It was in a post where she mentioned a few people, so no.
Obviously in hindsight I was blinkered but it just made sense, I thought

Barbara WW

Isla WW wrote: »

I was wrong.
I'm sorry to Nigel.
He read wolf to me.

I don't get this maddest thing in WW. Mad things happen every game.

Nah, that vote for Nigel is the bizzarest thing I've seen in my time playing Werewolf.

Derry WW

Jake WW wrote: »

It was in a post where she mentioned a few people, so no.
Obviously in hindsight I was blinkered but it just made sense, I thought

If you were so sure he was a wolf, why go no lynch? How does that help anything?

Angus WW

Steve and Eva

Ye went with Emily, do you think she is deserving to be on the list for a bullet also?

I'd agree with Phil, he's a cert.

Jake WW

Derry WW wrote: »

If you were so sure he was a wolf, why go no lynch? How does that help anything?

It was last minute and I couldn't justify voting for anyone else at that point

Steve WW

I just don't get how the guy that claims the guns and gives the guns to the people he says he's giving the guns to somehow winds up being lynched on the back of it

Angus WW

Eva WW wrote: »

My leans for bullets

Phil - Simply has to get a bullet IMO

Jakes distancing post stinks

I'm not sure id advocate using the third one. Emily was 2nd in voting and didn't self pres and left her vote on me. She could comfortably have stood behind a nigel vote but didn't make it. Moves from my wolf lean to my village lean pile

If I was pushed id go Frank

Ffa bullets
Phil
Jake
Frank

Sorry just seen this.

Steve WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Steve and Eva

Ye went with Emily, do you think she is deserving to be on the list for a bullet also?

I'd agree with Phil, he's a cert.

Eva has a point about Emily not self-pressing, she could have easily piled onto Nigel or even Phil but left her vote on Eva

Barbara WW

Well, to help us get a bit of direction...


I'll take one for the village and will shoot Phil seeing as the consensus seems to be Phil + 1.

Emily WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Steve and Eva

Ye went with Emily, do you think she is deserving to be on the list for a bullet also?

I'd agree with Phil, he's a cert.

I’m interested to hear Steve’s reason for voting me. Perhaps he posted earlier but I didn’t think I was somebody he was going to target. Also when looking back over Some of Eva’s posts I noticed she had Steve down as suspect yesterday. Now that on its own might not mean much but could Steve be cosying up to Eva? Not sure myself but interested to hear Steve’s response.

Mary WW

My votes for bullets are
Phil
Jake
Isla

Eva WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Steve and Eva

Ye went with Emily, do you think she is deserving to be on the list for a bullet also?

I'd agree with Phil, he's a cert.

I've said above already thst probably not tbh

Easy self pres to vote Nigel, she voted me instead and telegraphed it in advance

Eva WW

Emily WW wrote: »

I’m interested to hear Steve’s reason for voting me. Perhaps he posted earlier but I didn’t think I was somebody he was going to target. Also when looking back over Some of Eva’s posts I noticed she had Steve down as suspect yesterday. Now that on its own might not mean much but could Steve be cosying up to Eva? Not sure myself but interested to hear Steve’s response.

I'm interested too, Steve actually said he had reasons to provide for his vote