Louise Byrne Prime Time - Poor Interview Etiquette

Azatadine

Those new presenters on Prime Time are atrociously aggressive and cut across guests far too often (without letting them answer questions).

Louise Byrne is terrible. Really poor interview with a guest from Brussels this evening. Would not even let him answer questions or finish speaking without cutting across him.

Radio5

It seems to be RTE practice to interrupt/cut across speakers. Mary Wilson, Aine Lawlor for example have been doing it on radio for years.

.anon.

Any time I've seen her, she's been really good. Doesn't seem to have much tolerance for interviewees who ignore the question and spout whatever spiel they've rehearsed.

nc6000

They are both much better than Miriam anyway.

beachhead

Azatadine wrote: »

Those new presenters on Prime Time are atrociously aggressive and cut across guests far too often (without letting them answer questions).

Louise Byrne is terrible. Really poor interview with a guest from Brussels this evening. Would not even let him answer questions or finish speaking without cutting across him.

Not just these presenters.It is common among the presenters in the rte organisation on tv or radio.Agressive,ignorant,all to willing to push their own agenda and personal views-sometimes disguised as viewers comments.

Misguided1

Interviewers should ask open questions not the current practice of asking leading questions designed to trap people into saying something they will turn into a headline. RTE interviewers are shocking at it. So you're saying.......Does that mean.

Just once I would love an interviewee to directly answer the question they are asked and make the interviewers work a little harder.

Q Isn't it the case that you didn't consult with unions on the matter.
A Yes.

Q So you are saying that the hospital system is at full capacity.
A Yes.

This business of feeding people a statement and pretending it is a question drives me nuts!

Even better - if someone being interviewed didn't respond to a statement until a question was actually asked.......

Mr E

nc6000 wrote: »

They are both much better than Miriam anyway.

Genuinely?

EmptyTree

Didn't care much for Louise's style of questioning. But that new Mark chap, I like the cut of his jib. He's a refreshing addition to the panel.

silverharp

they should do it Joe Rogan style have it 2 hours long, and everyone has a spliff, entertaining and informative. the faux antagonistic style is so boring

Azatadine

You could see the guest from Brussels was shell shocked by her style of questioning last night. She didn't even introduce him properly and kept cutting across him before he could even answer her questions. It was actually embarrassing.

walshb

I watched her last night interviewing Nora Foley, the education minister.

It was just attack attack, interrupt interrupt all night..

Weird.

What is it with these shows, where everything is attack and trying to find fault and trip people up?

It’s the same with all them across radio and tv.

So unbalanced and one-sided, and for listeners it is not giving them the proper picture...

They must be under orders to be simply as combative as they can..

Jellybaby_1

I have found the female RTE news presenters often interrupt the person they are interviewing and I end up listening to two voices neither of which will stop. I find myself shouting stop, stop, at the TV and in the end I just switch off. I hate that style of 'interviewing'.

Azatadine

I presume she does it to appear "hard hitting" but it comes across as really really unprofessional.

mickdw

Ya someone made the point that the government were offered huge numbers of a vaccine early days. The guest clearly and in a cool manner explained that the offer was early days before they had any idea if they would even produce an effective vaccine and it was therefore wise to do pre orders with a number of possible suppliers. She then came back with a similar question, looking very foolish imo.

Jellybaby_1

Azatadine wrote: »

I presume she does it to appear "hard hitting" but it comes across as really really unprofessional.

I agree with you there. Are they still trained by Carr's?

bfa1509

And bizarrely they have ramped up the interruptiveness since they brought in the zoom calls. So now the simultaneous talking over one another is magnified. Infuriating stuff.

Azatadine

bfa1509 wrote: »

And bizarrely they have ramped up the interruptiveness since they brought in the zoom calls. So now the simultaneous talking over one another is magnified. Infuriating stuff.

Yes, that's absolutely true!

Azatadine

There was a new presenter on this evening and he was refreshingly professional I thought. He allowed guests to speak without cutting across them and seemed less interogatory. Didn't catch his name though.

Azatadine

Haven't seen her on PT as much since her debacle of an interview. Wonder is she getting sidelined?

amacca

walshb wrote: »

I watched her last night interviewing Nora Foley, the education minister.

It was just attack attack, interrupt interrupt all night..

Weird.

What is it with these shows, where everything is attack and trying to find fault and trip people up?

It’s the same with all them across radio and tv.

So unbalanced and one-sided, and for listeners it is not giving them the proper picture...

They must be under orders to be simply as combative as they can..

funny I watched that and I though the interview as very weak...she gave norma a very easy ride imo...didnt ask any difficult questions

the combative style as people put it may look combative but it didnt put the interviewee under and real pressure at all that time

I too though she was poor at interviewing but for other reasons it seems

Azatadine

Even if for different reasons, she is a poor interviewer.

ford fiesta

silverharp wrote: »

they should do it Joe Rogan style have it 2 hours long, and everyone has a spliff, entertaining and informative. the faux antagonistic style is so boring

Mark the car salesman has not been spotted in a few weeks, Fran McNulty presenting since New Year in his place.

homerun_homer

ford fiesta wrote: »

Mark the car salesman has not been spotted in a few weeks, Fran McNulty presenting since New Year in his place.

Mark was on last week! I saw on Twitter that he had a baby so that explains that.

bfa1509

homerun_homer wrote: »

Mark was on last week! I saw on Twitter that he had a baby so that explains that.

Makes you wonder where Mark Little went to. He could make Disneyland sound like Chernobyl in 86

elperello

bfa1509 wrote: »

Makes you wonder where Mark Little went to. He could make Disneyland sound like Chernobyl in 86

He's on VM 1 just now.

bfa1509

elperello wrote: »

He's on VM 1 just now.

No way! That is creepy. I honestly hadn't seen him since he left RTE.

amacca

bfa1509 wrote: »

Makes you wonder where Mark Little went to. He could make Disneyland sound like Chernobyl in 86

He set up a business...successful I think....news aggregator/storyful????.....somebody jump in here I'm only half remembering the details, thought I heard him talking about it at a conference a couple of years ago

greedygoblin

amacca wrote: »

He set up a business...successful I think....news aggregator/storyful????.....somebody jump in here I'm only half remembering the details, thought I heard him talking about it at a conference a couple of years ago

Yep, storyful is the one. Originally set up to verify breaking news stories. Subsequently bought by Rupert Murdoch, which is kind of ironic when you think about it.

elperello

amacca wrote: »

He set up a business...successful I think....news aggregator/storyful????.....somebody jump in here I'm only half remembering the details, thought I heard him talking about it at a conference a couple of years ago

He sold up Storyful and did well out of it.

This is his new day job https://www.kinzen.com/

Voice still as rich as ever.

Just by the way there is a discussion at the moment on the Claire Byrne Today thread and she is getting stick for not being aggressive enough.

Funny old world media

dvdman1

Louise Byrne is awful

.anon.

.anon. wrote: »

Any time I've seen her, she's been really good. Doesn't seem to have much tolerance for interviewees who ignore the question and spout whatever spiel they've rehearsed.

I was about to post exactly the same. She seems to have a good bull**** detector.

Azatadine

She's at it again this evening I see. Why can't she let people answer a question without cutting them off? Really unprofessional way to do an interview.

crossman47

Radio5 wrote: »

It seems to be RTE practice to interrupt/cut across speakers. Mary Wilson, Aine Lawlor for example have been doing it on radio for years.

OHeadhra on Drivetime is even worse

Stihl waters

Jesus titty fcukin christ she's the worst thing on television, she has a vacant stare when she looks at the camera, she's a terrible interviewer and wtf does she be wearing, she's like something dragged out of a 70s lesbian magazine. Painful to watch

Azatadine

No matter who she interviews, she just won't let them answer a question without barging in. Terrible. I think she tried to give off the impression that she's hard hitting but she's not. She's just very rude.

appagri

What the heck is Prime Time doing?
One 10 second reference to Groundhog Day would have been enough as a lead into some serious discussion but tonight was crap.

Prime Time has gone down hill.

What about having competent presenters/interviewers/journalists dealing with serious issues from Ireland and around the world.

More fluff than substance.

amacca

Azatadine wrote: »

No matter who she interviews, she just won't let them answer a question without barging in. Terrible. I think she tried to give off the impression that she's hard hitting but she's not. She's just very rude.

The quality of the questions and the research that went into them should do the vast bulk of the hard hitting

Atlantic Dawn

"Should off licences be open tomorrow?" Ffs, do they want a civil war to start out, a Covid militia taking over St James Gate with a gunship perhaps

StevenToast

Prime time is pure dogsh*t now....

Atlantic Dawn

You sign a disclaimer getting the vaccine so how would HSE be liable if it went bad?

Azatadine

Louise Byrne is an horrific presenter.

StevenToast

Azatadine wrote: »

Louise Byrne is an horrific presenter.

She has this smugness and arrogance....

Who is she?....zero credibility...

boombang

Don't watch much RTE TV channel affairs as I think the analysis is very shallow, but what always strikes me is how for each hour slot there's usually only about 12 minutes substantive footage. Between ads, intros, repetition there's very little actual material. This tells me they have some very lazy producers at Montrose.

drunkmonkey

Atlantic Dawn wrote: »

You sign a disclaimer getting the vaccine so how would HSE be liable if it went bad?

You what now?

rovers_runner

StevenToast wrote: »

She has this smugness and arrogance....

Who is she?....zero credibility...

She covers at least two of the three RTE recruitment criteria.
- LGBT
- Female
- Related to someone in a senior public service position /RTE

jrosen

Primetime is doom and gloom at the best of times but she is useless.

Mad_maxx

rovers_runner wrote: »

She covers at least two of the three RTE recruitment criteria.
- LGBT
- Female
- Related to someone in a senior public service position /RTE

she did an interview in the SINDO about six months ago

one of her quotes

" we need diversity in media because as everyone understand nowadays , diversity is extremely important "

card carrying progressive so id say she ticks at least three boxes ?

glenfieldman

99nsr125 wrote: »

Guaranteed got the job cause she's a lezzer

Absolutely brutal she is

I cant like this enough
But for context, my eldest daughter married her girlfriend last year, and even they both say the same about her

Emptur.

glenfieldman wrote: »

But for context, my eldest daughter married her girlfriend last year, and even they both say the same about her

The Ultimate Wokism

glenfieldman

Emptur. wrote: »

The Ultimate Wokism

Yes it is :eek:
Crawl back under your rock

Emptur.

glenfieldman wrote: »

Yes it is :eek: ✓

Crawl back under your rock ✓

You're ticking all the right boxes