Lost Werewolf - GAME THREAD

Nigel WW

Did Angus say what prize he got?

Fiona WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

@Emily, with the result so close, if I was a wolf, I could have just voted late on Frank to save him. Instead, I posted a hard defence of him and didn't do the one thing I could have done to save him. After my earlier posts tying myself to Frank, if I knew he'd flip red, I would surely have voted Angus rather than Mary at 2058.

Well your theory above is a possibility, but Emilys theory is also possible.

The "I would have saved my buddy if I was a wolf" theory isn't ironclad. You could have easily let him die to try stay hidden.

Saying things like "surely I would have voted angus" in order to save Frank is not a sure conclusion.

Abigail WW

Ok folks so BG played a blinder last night in saving Angus. So glad I flipped onto Frank last night even though I wasn't 100% sure on him.

So with 14 players left I've a nice core of people I trust and people with non-contested role claims. The list of potential wolves is shrinking fast. I think my most suspicious then at the moment are Barbara, Gertie, Mary, Vernon and Wendy. I think Wendy would be top of my pile so that's where my vote will be tonight.

Emily WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

@Emily, with the result so close, if I was a wolf, I could have just voted late on Frank to save him. Instead, I posted a hard defence of him and didn't do the one thing I could have done to save him. After my earlier posts tying myself to Frank, if I knew he'd flip red, I would surely have voted Angus rather than Mary at 2058.

Which is fine but your vote isn't in isolation, when you voted Mary was at no risk really. Similar to when you threw your vote on Gertie the night before. You can make the claim you'd have saved your mate but again, no guarantee of this considering the dwindling wolf numbers. Youd be inextricably linked

Nigel WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

Well your theory above is a possibility, but Emilys theory is also possible.

The "I would have saved my buddy if I was a wolf" theory isn't ironclad. You could have easily let him die to try stay hidden.

Saying things like "surely I would have voted angus" in order to save Frank is not a sure conclusion.

I was hardly staying hidden with my posts leading up to lynch!!! I literally couldn't have been much more pro-Frank

Nigel WW

Emily WW wrote: »

Which is fine but your vote isn't in isolation, when you voted Mary was at no risk really. Similar to when you threw your vote on Gertie the night before. You can make the claim you'd have saved your mate but again, no guarantee of this considering the dwindling wolf numbers. Youd be inextricably linked

I presume you mean Frank was at no risk when I voted? Not true - I voted at 2058 when it was Frank 8, Angus 7.

My earlier posts had already inextricably linked me to Frank

Patrick WW

@Gertie - what can you tell us about Jacob or the others?

You seem to be the most in the know around here

Fiona WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

I was hardly staying hidden with my posts leading up to lynch!!! I literally couldn't have been much more pro-Frank

Hidden from the lynch auditor though.

Fiona WW

Like Nigel, if you were a wolf.... youd never switch to Frank. Why risk being caught by an auditor or risk sending him to death.

You would have stayed away. Which you did.

The same accusation could be leveled at me to be fair as I boted Mary.

Gertrude WW

Patrick WW wrote: »

@Gertie - what can you tell us about Jacob or the others?

You seem to be the most in the know around here

The others are here to welcome us with beads and feasts


Or maybe not


All I know about the others is from the show. They weren’t very nice. Given this is a Necro build I’m expecting we may have a new bad team appear at some point, maybe as early as this afternoon. In effect most of our current clears will no longer be clears from then on

Only upsides are I) we got one already due to phils courageous sacrifice and II) in that scenario we probably only have one wolf left. Kill pace has been two per day anyway so I’d guess the others will just keep doing Smokey’s work

All speculation at this point though

Nigel WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

Like Nigel, if you were a wolf.... youd never switch to Frank. Why risk being caught by an auditor or risk sending him to death.

You would have stayed away. Which you did.

The same accusation could be leveled at me to be fair as I boted Mary.

No, of course I wouldn't have, I would have hummed and hawed over who to vote for and eventually go with Angus to save Frank.

If I knew Frank was going to flip red, no way would I have been hard defending him on thread

Nigel WW

Gertrude WW wrote: »

Given this is a Necro build I’m expecting we may have a new bad team appear at some point, maybe as early as this afternoon. In effect most of our current clears will no longer be clears from then on

I expect something like this to happen also, around 4pm when the black smoke arrives

@Angus & Derry, can you share your prize details?

Fiona WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

No, of course I wouldn't have, I would have hummed and hawed over who to vote for and eventually go with Angus to save Frank.

If I knew Frank was going to flip red, no way would I have been hard defending him on thread

Its debatable. Nothing certain. Unlikely but not improbable.

Derry WW

Yeah I'm a dope.

Wendy is good and needs protection

Fiona WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Yeah I'm a dope.

Wendy is good and needs protection

Go on..... why

Abigail WW

Assume it has to do with the numbers reward this morning. Soz Wendy.

Angus WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Did Angus say what prize he got?

I got a “seer check”. I’ve made a choice and will let you know outcome.

Angus WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

Did Angus say what prize he got?

I got a “seer check”. I’ve made a choice and will let you know outcome.

Fiona WW

If Angus doesn't peek Orla Id be shocked

Fiona WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

If Angus doesn't peek Orla Id be shocked

To clarify Id say its a waste of a peek.

Angus WW

Fiona WW wrote: »

If Angus doesn't peek Orla Id be shocked

Get ready be shocked!!

I know Orlas evil so why waste a peek.

I went for you instead Fiona and can confirm you’re......



.....good.

Abigail WW

Did someone not have a theory that Fiona and Orla are on the same team?

Patrick WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Did someone not have a theory that Fiona and Orla are on the same team?

According to Isla they are

I’ve always said Fiona is, and would trust Orla based on this and Isla’s comment

Fiona WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Did someone not have a theory that Fiona and Orla are on the same team?

Isla aluded to it, as the detective its possible she knew this.

Whether she actually knew is debatable as her post suggesting it was on Day1.

Abigail WW

And Isla was the detective so we can trust her assertion.

Fiona WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Get ready be shocked!!

I know Orlas evil so why waste a peek.

I went for you instead Fiona and can confirm you’re......



.....good.

Thanks Angus. Nice to be confirmed.

Fiona WW

Derry WW wrote: »

Yeah I'm a dope.

Wendy is good and needs protection

You need to explain Derry, preferably before 4

Angus WW

Abigail WW wrote: »

Did someone not have a theory that Fiona and Orla are on the same team?

Ehhh.....I think you’re mistaken.....I don’t remember anything thing like that.....

Fiona WW

Angus WW wrote: »

Ehhh.....I think you’re mistaken.....I don’t remember anything thing like that.....

Its been well documented. If Im good, Orla is most likley good too.

Nigel WW

Nigel WW wrote: »

@Patrick, I think you had the right conclusion but maybe the wrong reason here for Frank's vote.

Look at the night 1 voting data, I think Frank's late vote wasn't down the assassin wolf at all - he voted late on the Angus wagon to ensure that the auditor got a result of "even". One of Fiona & Emily is a wolf.

I'm off to bed

Hmmm, that blows this theory of mine out of the water then if Fiona has been peeked village and there's no counter claim to Emily's Oracle.