MCU Werewolf MAIN GAME THREAD

Spook_ie

duffman13 wrote: »

I'm Starlord if that's any help to your rabbit hole?

You really are loving that photo

You mean Peter Quinn?

Wendy WW

Like look at this since we joined up yesterday.

There was 2 peeked villagers on cosmic confirmed (apparently) by the death of shatter. Like lock clear.

Since then the wolfs have.

Munched Necro

Redirected a bullet to GNR

Tried to shoot pat

And then munched Pat.

4 attempts at kills we know of and haven't taken out the lockest of clearest villagers

Wendy WW

Wendy WW

I'm So Ronery

Abigail WW

I've been reading back and trying to get caught up. So are you saying that there was another wolf on cosmic thread?

Spook_ie

Who knows, I just can't get out of this missing character loop!

Wendy WW

Spook_ie

Spook_ie wrote: »

Who knows, I just can't get out of this missing character loop!

Drumpot

Wendy WW wrote: »

Like look at this since we joined up yesterday.

There was 2 peeked villagers on cosmic confirmed (apparently) by the death of shatter. Like lock clear.

Since then the wolfs have.

Munched Necro

Redirected a bullet to GNR

Tried to shoot pat

And then munched Pat.

4 attempts at kills we know of and haven't taken out the lockest of clearest villagers

Interesting that with Conor gone, there’s now another effort to go back and throw Shade on me and the others who survived cosmos.

How are all these connected? I read what your saying but I’m not seeing how it lines up to “more wolves on cosmos and earth”.

Pat was targeted because he was on fire yesterday. To ignore that to push a narrative is extremely dodgy. He was the most obvious candidate for the munch this morning. Why wouldn’t wolves of munched Necro yesterday? Can’t say what he was like in Cosmos but he is a really strong player and he we know he was good.

Yesterday there were 4 people from earth alive , three wolves and me. Why would they target me when I was their only cover yesterday? Why would they target me or any of cosmos lads today over Patrick?

This is as flimsy a narrative as I’ve read yet. Between you and Lucy and lesser so Gertrude, I find it all very questionable.

Gertrude WW

MacDanger wrote: »

Which (I think) leaves:
Abigail
Doris
Emily
Gertrude
Holly
Jake
Katie
Lucy
Orla
Steve
Wendy

Orla and Gertrude fired shots at villagers yesterday so I'd have them as likely green. Wendy also shot a wolf but he was as good as dead at that stage

That leaves it as 3 wolves from the remaining 9 on that list

You know that's not true right? I shot JGF and he redirected it to GnR and he died instead.



Also, anyone who doubts I am a villager please do an ISO on me. You will see who I had in my sites. Wolves!


As for Drumpot, I really should not have put you on my FFA. I was saying though you are not 100% cleared. I was rushing during my break and added you. You would really be one of the last I looked at. I should not have rushed my FFA.


The other two stand though!


Shame on Conor, that was a loss for us

MacDanger

Wendy WW wrote: »

Like look at this since we joined up yesterday.

There was 2 peeked villagers on cosmic confirmed (apparently) by the death of shatter. Like lock clear.

Since then the wolfs have.

Munched Necro

Redirected a bullet to GNR

Tried to shoot pat

And then munched Pat.

4 attempts at kills we know of and haven't taken out the lockest of clearest villagers

Probably because Necro & G&R were making the best reads, esp in the Cosmic thread, they chewed up the wolves (with the help of some peeks it must be said) after two nights. Presumably thought Pat was one of those two with his reads yesterday.

Duffman and spook haven't been posting much so are less of a threat. I'm a new player to the game and was more or less 100% certain that Isla was a wolf yesterday

While I wouldn't completely rule out that there's something weird going on, it wouldn't be the first place to look imo. Occam's razor and all that

Wendy WW

Drumpot wrote: »

Interesting that with Conor gone, there’s now another effort to go back and throw Shade on me and the others who survived cosmos.

How are all these connected? I read what your saying but I’m not seeing how it lines up to “more wolves on cosmos and earth”.

Pat was targeted because he was on fire yesterday. To ignore that to push a narrative is extremely dodgy. He was the most obvious candidate for the munch this morning. Why wouldn’t wolves of munched Necro yesterday? Can’t say what he was like in Cosmos but he is a really strong player and he we know he was good.

Yesterday there were 4 people from earth alive , three wolves and me. Why would they target me when I was their only cover yesterday? Why would they target me or any of cosmos lads today over Patrick?

This is as flimsy a narrative as I’ve read yet. Between you and Lucy and lesser so Gertrude, I find it all very questionable.

Wow thats the most you have contributed since Ive been on the main thread and its to shoot down a theory, any reads on others or is the game still too much.

Why are the lock clearest peeked villagers being kept alive?

How do you know thats why pat was munched?

Also why was Pat shot at, like that makes no sense.

This wasn't even shade on you.

There is an extra character in the cosmic picture, have you even looked at this and asked why instead of shooting down this?

Doris WW

Spook_ie wrote: »

Who knows, I just can't get out of this missing character loop!

If there was a wolf still on cosmic, logically it could only be you.

Now if the 13 / 12 debate meant anything it could be Thanos , or an another, controlling 1 of MacD or Duff.

There could be 2 in the one body. Might explain the whole night time embargo. They are good during the day as told by the peeks and get wolfy at 10pm.

Doris WW

Sorry, that probably only fries your brain a bit more.

Wendy WW

MacDanger wrote: »

Probably because Necro & G&R were making the best reads, esp in the Cosmic thread, they chewed up the wolves (with the help of some peeks it must be said) after two nights. Presumably thought Pat was one of those two with his reads yesterday.

Duffman and spook haven't been posting much so are less of a threat. I'm a new player to the game and was more or less 100% certain that Isla was a wolf yesterday

While I wouldn't completely rule out that there's something weird going on, it wouldn't be the first place to look imo. Occam's razor and all that

Occam's razor

Why are there 13 people in that pic?

Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

MacDanger

Wendy WW wrote: »

Wow thats the most you have contributed since Ive been on the main thread and its to shoot down a theory, any reads on others or is the game still too much.

Worth remembering that Drumpot may have more than one account to keep going so low posting wouldn't reflect badly on him imo

The 4 wolfs/world theory is far fetched for me, 8 wolfs and 16 villagers? Literally no chance for the village without some seriously powerful villagers which there don't seem to be

Wendy WW

MacDanger wrote: »

Worth remembering that Drumpot may have more than one account to keep going so low posting wouldn't reflect badly on him imo

The 4 wolfs/world theory is far fetched for me, 8 wolfs and 16 villagers? Literally no chance for the village without some seriously powerful villagers which there don't seem to be

I didnt mean in number of posts in meant in content, not having a go at low posters he just hasn't given much in reads but produces a long post to shoot down the theory

Katie WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Occam's razor

Why are there 13 people in that pic?

Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

The thirteen people, I don't have an answer for. Perhaps there's an additional wolf in there.

The clearest villagers may be being left alive so that people start to question them though. If we have 3 lock clear villagers say and they all survive (by this I mean not targeted) a number of kills people are going to start wondering why those villagers are still alive. Then they survive another kill and it pushes people over the edge and now lock clear villagers aren't quite lock clear any more. It's a bold strategy frankly but it does ultimately widen the potential pool of suspects.

MacDanger

Wendy WW wrote: »

Occam's razor

Why are there 13 people in that pic?

Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

I dunno about the 13 people tbh.

I've already answered your second question

Spook_ie

Doris WW wrote: »

If there was a wolf still on cosmic, logically it could only be you.

Now if the 13 / 12 debate meant anything it could be Thanos , or an another, controlling 1 of MacD or Duff.

There could be 2 in the one body. Might explain the whole night time embargo. They are good during the day as told by the peeks and get wolfy at 10pm.

Doris WW wrote: »

Sorry, that probably only fries your brain a bit more.

Yeah that fried it alright

Barbara WW

Ok i reckon Emily is a wolf


Posts are well structured stating the obvious or basically agreeing with someone they know has village credit aka conor

I believe steve is good and that they had their peek stolen so i looked back over that time and this was a red hearing

Emily WW wrote: »

I'm in the list of unknowns, ive a power alright but not a peek unfortunately!

I'd agree with peeking and lynching in this list for now! Makes most sense really! Id start with the low posters and work up, outside of Islas comment about not wanting to be peeked ive no real definitive feeling on any of the above just yet

Emily made it a point to add her self to the unknown list and to also recommend to peek from the low posters of which she had 3 posts at the time...

Steve informed the thread that his peek was stolen 9 minutes after this...


Emily then went on to attack isla so it would look justified that she was on that wagon after isla flips good after the lynch,

Emily WW wrote: »

"Hey folks, I'm a good guy, peek me rather than lynch me. I've a power of protecting one our confirmed villagers. Keep me alive"

A play like that might work better than

Don't peek me

I'm protecting myself so the wolves can munch me!

Emily WW wrote: »

Thats shading right there, first person to suggest you was a known villager early on. Ive been reading back, you popped back online when Duffers again said you should peeked and you said that you shouldn't. You were good, it was waste as a known villager would get lynched.

You then suggested Babs as an alternative peek

Your own reaction to the peek is what got us here, nothing else

And after isla was lynched

Emily WW wrote: »

Well this was surprising to come back to!

I think Conors list yesterday of unknowns is still the place to shoot/peek from for now! Competition today hopefully will clear a bit of the field

It wasn't that surprising isla was 50/50 as the day came to a close and looked more like a villager that had a small meltdown as im sure most villagers would have thought even if they had voted isla, so acting surprised is what a wolf would do in this situation


So in conclusion Emily has asked no questions of any other player other than isla who was a runaway lynch. She has so few posts but they are precise but have no substance other than to try and look like a villager

Emily is a classic coasting wolf and i would bet my vote on it,

I would like to suggest we run katie and emily so no wagon can form

MacDanger

Wendy WW wrote: »

I didnt mean in number of posts in meant in content, not having a go at low posters he just hasn't given much in reads but produces a long post to shoot down the theory

He could well be posting in his anon account though was my point.

Like I said, there could be something in what you're saying but it's way way way down the list for me when it comes to lynching.

Doris WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

I didnt mean in number of posts in meant in content, not having a go at low posters he just hasn't given much in reads but produces a long post to shoot down the theory

It doesn't matter how long the post was. Its the contents that matters. You didn't comment on that.

Drumpot

Wendy WW wrote: »

Wow thats the most you have contributed since Ive been on the main thread and its to shoot down a theory, any reads on others or is the game still too much.

Why are the lock clearest peeked villagers being kept alive?

How do you know thats why pat was munched?

Also why was Pat shot at, like that makes no sense.

This wasn't even shade on you.

There is an extra character in the cosmic picture, have you even looked at this and asked why instead of shooting down this?

I’m in the top 5 posters in this thread and at least convinced the village to kill 3 wolves ahead of me yesterday. So excuse me if I snigger at your “most you contribute” comments.

There’s only been two munches since the islands merged and I believe one wolf shot another and another dodged a bullet into cosmos. Why dodge it into cosmos? I actually don’t know the mechanics of the dodging bullet but if they get to choose where the bullet goes it makes sense to go after cosmos people.

I think yesterday morning there were 8 or 9 from earth and 3 wolves. They were well hidden. That’s why it looked like people pelting bullets into earthers actually looked more like villagers. It didn’t benefit the wolves at all by thinning out team earth. Look how it ended up for them, they started the day with a full team and ended it without anybody on earth.

I’d be more inclined to trust those who shot and came out on thread. Yes Nigel was bad but he was forced into a corner. Don’t think anybody was pushing Gertie to shoot JFG and Orla didn’t have to finish him off.

I thought it made perfect sense for pat to be shot. He was as lock clear an Anon account as you can get. I think the “maybe there’s more wolves on cosmos/earth” is a desperate effort to keep the focus off the remaining wolves in the anons.

Think about this. If we think there was a copy and paste of wolves then there is I think actually 5 remaining wolves in the anons and 2 in cosmos/earth.

An extra character means what? I get trying to understand things , I tried to ask questions earlier but it doesn’t seem to matter. Figuring out characters that are not in the picture (think there might be 12), i was going to try and work it out but couldn’t see how that will help anything.

So I don’t see these theories adding up, I just see somebody trying to come up the way you do.

Gertrude WW

MacDanger wrote: »

Worth remembering that Drumpot may have more than one account to keep going so low posting wouldn't reflect badly on him imo

The 4 wolfs/world theory is far fetched for me, 8 wolfs and 16 villagers? Literally no chance for the village without some seriously powerful villagers which there don't seem to be

MacDanger wrote: »

He could well be posting in his anon account though was my point.

Like I said, there could be something in what you're saying but it's way way way down the list for me when it comes to lynching.

Can I ask what you mean Drumpot has more than one account to keep going? sorry if I am being slow here

Ewan WW

Wendy WW wrote: »

Occam's razor

Why are there 13 people in that pic?

Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

occam's razor.

>Why are there 13 people in that pic?

A player had two characters. Most likely thanos was provided with a backup character in case of a mass reveal.

>Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

a) They believed there was higher priority kills on the board and went for them.
or
b1) There is a wolf among the group and killing them would narrow the pool.
b2) They create doubt that the pool is not actually lock clear and we begin lynching there to find out.

My best guesses at occams razoring.

Baggly

Mod

I would recommend staying away from speculating on whether people have more than one account.

Spook_ie

Ewan WW wrote: »

occam's razor.

>Why are there 13 people in that pic?

A player had two characters. Most likely thanos was provided with a backup character in case of a mass reveal.

>Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

a) They believed there was higher priority kills on the board and went for them.
or
b1) There is a wolf among the group and killing them would narrow the pool.
b2) They create doubt that the pool is not actually lock clear and we begin lynching there to find out.

My best guesses at occams razoring.

Has there ever been a mass character reveal in WW games? I can see the logic of Thanos having an alter ego in that case.

Wendy WW

Ewan WW wrote: »

occam's razor.

>Why are there 13 people in that pic?

A player had two characters. Most likely thanos was provided with a backup character in case of a mass reveal.

>Why are the clearest lock clear villagers being left alive?

a) They believed there was higher priority kills on the board and went for them.
or
b1) There is a wolf among the group and killing them would narrow the pool.
b2) They create doubt that the pool is not actually lock clear and we begin lynching there to find out.

My best guesses at occams razoring.

OOOOOOOOOOOOOO actually that makes sense

Ewan WW

Spook_ie wrote: »

Has there ever been a mass character reveal in WW games? I can see the logic of Thanos having an alter ego in that case.

its happened loads of times.


the simpsons
the wrestling game
many others.