Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

~ Building a House in 2020 ~

  • 06-04-2020 9:28am
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 14 rqc1i3ovl5uxt6


    Hi All,


    I've created a thread in order to determine the cost of building a house in Ireland in 2020.

    I'm looking for individual case studies, with the hope of boards.ie users posting their location (east, west, south, midlands of Ireland), type of construction (block, ICF, SIP, Timber Frame etc), type of house (bungalow, dormer, one and half storey, two storey, two storey + attic), and most importantly, tender cost from contractors.

    Personally, I have just received a mortgage offer of €195,000 and have savings of €70,000 (Total €265,000). I am hoping to buy a site in the west for €40,000, giving me a budget of €225,000 for a 175sqm house; is this realistic?

    Any information would be greatly appreciated!


    Thanks! :)


«134

Comments

  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 40,339 Mod ✭✭✭✭Gumbo


    You will be hopping to build a new dwelling to current regs for €1275 per square meter. My opinion is no, it can’t be done unless a very very significant % of the labour is done by you free of charge.

    What about planning costs, contributions, connections, professional fees etc?
    Are they separate to the €225k?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,595 ✭✭✭ECO_Mental


    Just tendered for my house outside Cork City, 250 sqrm inc PC sums for kitchen flooring etc Block built 200mm cavity A2 rated (high enough spec) €540,000.....add another €35,000 for Engineers Architects, planning fees service connection charges etc etc and you get a move into house with my bags, fully finished cost of around €575,000 :eek::eek: eek! that's even scaring me :P €2300/sqrm

    Building a house these days is not cheap, there are so many regs you have to comply with, even getting a mortgage these days is geared towards main builder with them signing off on stages etc. Could I buy a house for cheaper (possibly... probably)but I am lucky I didnt have to pay for the site and the site is 8 minutes to the Wilton Road Roundabout in an A2 zoned area so I wont be losing money in doing it. (famous last words..thank you COVID)

    If I was looking for a home way out west where house prices are significantly cheaper I would say you will buy a house now for a lot less than you will build it, but then you wont have the house of your dreams.

    6.1kWp south facing, South of Cork City



  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    Jaysis those are mad figures. Are these prices all down to new building regs?

    Not really

    Materials, Tax, charges, service connections, Insurance, H&S etc


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,470 ✭✭✭JoeA3


    I’m also building a house, in the west of the country. By contractor. We broke ground last August and we are now at 2nd fix stage, but progress has dramatically slowed down in recent weeks (thanks Covid!).

    It’s approx 210 sq/m and by the time we’ve moved in I reckon it’ll be up at around €440k. That includes a very decent level of finish (but not furniture/soft furnishings), a good amount of groundworks, basic landscaping, 40 sq/m garage, fees, contributions, etc. Does not include the cost of the site of course.

    Definitely not cheap, but no regrets so far. The Covid situation is a bit of a worry, but hopefully we will get back on track before too long.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,082 ✭✭✭enricoh


    Jaysis those are mad figures. Are these prices all down to new building regs?

    Was talking to a lad that does heat surveys, ber's etc recently and he said you'd nearly want air conditioning installed in houses now as they are uncomfortably warm in the summer with all the new regs.


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 40,339 Mod ✭✭✭✭Gumbo


    enricoh wrote: »
    Was talking to a lad that does heat surveys, ber's etc recently and he said you'd nearly want air conditioning installed in houses now as they are uncomfortably warm in the summer with all the new regs.

    I hear those comments from inexperienced or ill-informed people to be honest.
    I would take the comments in jest.


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    enricoh wrote: »
    Was talking to a lad that does heat surveys, ber's etc recently and he said you'd nearly want air conditioning installed in houses now as they are uncomfortably warm in the summer with all the new regs.

    Rubbish. Overheating is poor design and nothing to do with new regs.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 14 rqc1i3ovl5uxt6


    Hi all,

    Many thanks for your comments; I appreciate all the advice I can get!

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    Gumbo wrote: »
    You will be hopping to build a new dwelling to current regs for €1275 per square meter. My opinion is no, it can’t be done unless a very very significant % of the labour is done by you free of charge.

    What about planning costs, contributions, connections, professional fees etc?
    Are they separate to the €225k?

    Thanks Gumbo; I will be doing the planning drawings and application myself as I work in the construction industry and getting a friend to do the percolation test and structural drawings. I hope to opt out of BCAR certification.

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    ECO_Mental wrote: »
    Just tendered for my house outside Cork City, 250 sqrm inc PC sums for kitchen flooring etc Block built 200mm cavity A2 rated (high enough spec) €540,000.....add another €35,000 for Engineers Architects, planning fees service connection charges etc etc and you get a move into house with my bags, fully finished cost of around €575,000 :eek::eek: eek! that's even scaring me :P €2300/sqrm

    Building a house these days is not cheap, there are so many regs you have to comply with, even getting a mortgage these days is geared towards main builder with them signing off on stages etc. Could I buy a house for cheaper (possibly... probably)but I am lucky I didnt have to pay for the site and the site is 8 minutes to the Wilton Road Roundabout in an A2 zoned area so I wont be losing money in doing it. (famous last words..thank you COVID)

    If I was looking for a home way out west where house prices are significantly cheaper I would say you will buy a house now for a lot less than you will build it, but then you wont have the house of your dreams.

    Thanks ECO_Mental; I must say my heart sank when I saw a quotation of €575,000 for a 250sqm new build outside Cork City. That really is mental, I understand that an A2 BER is required to meet NZEB regulations. Do you mind me asking what the most expensive items were in this quotation?

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    JoeA3 wrote: »
    I’m also building a house, in the west of the country. By contractor. We broke ground last August and we are now at 2nd fix stage, but progress has dramatically slowed down in recent weeks (thanks Covid!).

    It’s approx 210 sq/m and by the time we’ve moved in I reckon it’ll be up at around €440k. That includes a very decent level of finish (but not furniture/soft furnishings), a good amount of groundworks, basic landscaping, 40 sq/m garage, fees, contributions, etc. Does not include the cost of the site of course.

    Definitely not cheap, but no regrets so far. The Covid situation is a bit of a worry, but hopefully we will get back on track before too long.

    Thanks JoeA3; Do you mind me asking what the most expensive items were in this quotation? Is it a straight forward footprint (rectangle, l-shaped) or have you many projections and features?

    - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
    enricoh wrote: »
    Was talking to a lad that does heat surveys, ber's etc recently and he said you'd nearly want air conditioning installed in houses now as they are uncomfortably warm in the summer with all the new regs.
    Gumbo wrote: »
    I hear those comments from inexperienced or ill-informed people to be honest.
    I would take the comments in jest.
    BryanF wrote: »
    Rubbish. Overheating is poor design and nothing to do with new regs.

    Thanks enricoh, Gumbo and BryanF; what are your opinions on a DCV (Demand Control Ventilation) system as an alternative to a MVHR (Mechanical Heat Recovery & Ventilation) system, would this be considerably cheaper to buy, install and run?


  • Subscribers Posts: 42,170 ✭✭✭✭sydthebeat


    DCV, while cheaper, is not significantly cheaper... And you do not get any heat recovery element to it.

    Its a step up from natural ventilation, but in my opinion, the extra cost of the MHRV greatly outweighs the trade off in extra energy efficiency, when compared to DCV


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    Op if you’re in The industry, best advise I can give is to complete a passive house design course.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,470 ✭✭✭JoeA3


    Thanks JoeA3; Do you mind me asking what the most expensive items were in this quotation? Is it a straight forward footprint (rectangle, l-shaped) or have you many projections and features?

    I did think it was straightforward on paper, but no, its not a very straightforward footprint (so my builder keeps reminding me!).

    Its an L-shape, part bungalow (bedrooms space) and part double-height (living/kitchen), and there's a few non-standard details in it such as a couple of large corner windows, a small flat roof section over the stairs void and a double-height ceiling in the kitchen/dining.

    Most expensive items...
    - windows/doors. There was a PC sum for this but we've gone over that a bit as we went with aluclad. We dropped a few unnecessary velux's though, so that balances out.

    - electrical - again its a PC sum and I reckon we will have exceeded that too, as we have a lot of long cable runs, due to the nature of the L-shape footprint and the double-height kitchen.

    - groundworks are a very big one. We were obliged to build a block wall on the site perimeter, that was a sore cost, I'd have preferred a fence too even for aesthetics. The garage is also a chunky cost but its something I really wanted.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,595 ✭✭✭ECO_Mental


    "Thanks ECO_Mental; I must say my heart sank when I saw a quotation of €575,000 for a 250sqm new build outside Cork City. That really is mental, I understand that an A2 BER is required to meet NZEB regulations. Do you mind me asking what the most expensive items were in this quotation?"

    Everything....TBH, I went over the BOQ even with a few of my buddies to see where I could save money, but in reality if you are going to save money you need to be omitting things....You have to have walls, you have to have windows, foundation, heating etc etc.

    But do you need stove 5k?, do you need a big outside patio, but this is small change, also changing the spec on you flooring its only small change. The only way you are going to save big money in building is build a smaller house...seriously do you need 2500sqr ft house that is where your biggest cost saving will be reducing the size of your house.

    My house was also Architecturally designed (fancy angles:o) and split level so that is costing me more, if it was a simple box then I'm sure that it would cost me less. But hey, its the house of my dreams and if I was just going to build a box to live in then I should be buying a house.

    6.1kWp south facing, South of Cork City



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8 Abbey47


    Midlands build. Project manager but feels like direct labour the stress of it all! 2 year build n serious hardship.. only way it got moved on at all was when I got involved 24/7 calling lads n being around more. Lost 12 months by not being around n thinking it would all be grand and things work as they should.. U need to be there every day kicking stones n asking questions, lots of questions.. A lot of which u have an answer to u just need to keep lads honest unfortunately. If I did It again I'd build smaller and get a contractor. But we went for architect designed spilt level n with it came issues of extra expense via planning. 130sq ft builder finish. High spec, 190mm fullfill insulation, block build, spray foam roof insl everywhere, passive alu windows, mvhr, a2w underfloor everywhere. Loads of ups and downs. Best advice I'd give, meet your trades early whether u have builer pm or self build build relationship n keep them in money when they are there on site n let them know u will if they are there.. I cant get over how people hold back money and think the person will work harder for them! Doesn't happen. Anyone who is not a trade n has family in trades to help and thinks they will build high spec A rated for 100 sq ft is in for some shock! Both during it and most certainly when they come to finish it.. and by then it's too late. Your absolutely delusional if u think u will do it on your own or move in for under 120 sq ft to a A2 high spec finish.. u can cod yourself all u want but you will cut corners and your budget will take an unexpected hit somewhere during it all. Best of luck though I wudnt wise the whole process on my worst enemy!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 129 ✭✭TAPlank


    Internal solid (concrete Block) walls absorb heat when the house heats up and release it again when it cools. This is not in line with the trend of timber frame housing, but it overcomes much of their deficiencies and should be a standard method. It will also minimise condensation problems.


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    TAPlank wrote: »
    Internal solid (concrete Block) walls absorb heat when the house heats up and release it again when it cools. This is not in line with the trend of timber frame housing, but it overcomes much of their deficiencies and should be a standard method. It will also minimise condensation problems.



    Re walls absorbing heat (thermal mass) Research cellulose and decrement delay

    Re Condensation problems, research ventilation & vapour barrier

    I have a timber frame constructed extension, very happy with it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 372 ✭✭JD1763


    East of the country - approx. 200 sq metres architect designed A2 mono pitch roof bungalow but a few 'funny' angles. Standard block build but we also need a decent amount of steel given the design.

    Have not gone to tender yet but will be going with a main contractor as have no experience and could not manage the build ourselves.

    Pre-corona QS indicative estimate was coming in around EUR 3,500 per square metre for a turn key finish. This included a 10% contingency.

    Once we go through to tender will see what the real cost will be but given recent events it is anyone's guess where things will end up.

    The estimate does not include any professional fees (architect, QS, engineer, solicitor), development contribution or connection fees (ESB and Irish water). When we first looked at architects we received quotes ranging from 10% to 13% of the build cost.

    You can probably safely put EUR 100k against those costs. We already owned the site so have not included any costs for that in the figures.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3 CantFixIt


    Hi all! Long time reader/lurker, first time poster as I thought our experience here with this recently might be valuable to some.

    We have a site south of Cork City, got planning for a ~360sqm 5 bed (A2 rated, not bananas in terms of shape with nothing super special about it) and plan to self build as we have prior building experience. As we were getting through our stages of planning the build and costing everything up, we went to the market twice to see what contractors were pricing the work at relative to our own numbers. We got two prices back from their respective QS' between 780k and 840k, not including the large garage on the plans. That includes their % markups, which they were transparent with.

    By far and away the most expensive item (estimated 118K) was plastering & finishes, steel, windows (depending on the provider, we have a lot of glazing and that number will vary) and blocklaying/external were next up before getting into the rest of the list. Some (but not a lot) of their lists can be taken with a pinch of salt. We went and independently priced the entire BoQ a number of times and were able to find unrealistic quotes from those providers but a lot of what they priced (minus their % markup) was realistic.

    FWIW, we have confidence in our numbers at ~600k mark and had started building just before this COVID problem kicked off so who knows, when things start to flow again there might be additional savings to make in places.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 317 ✭✭tonytoc11


    JD1763 wrote: »
    East of the country - approx. 200 sq metres architect designed A2 mono pitch roof bungalow but a few 'funny' angles. Standard block build but we also need a decent amount of steel given the design.

    Have not gone to tender yet but will be going with a main contractor as have no experience and could not manage the build ourselves.

    Pre-corona QS indicative estimate was coming in around EUR 3,500 per square metre for a turn key finish. This included a 10% contingency.

    Once we go through to tender will see what the real cost will be but given recent events it is anyone's guess where things will end up.

    The estimate does not include any professional fees (architect, QS, engineer, solicitor), development contribution or connection fees (ESB and Irish water). When we first looked at architects we received quotes ranging from 10% to 13% of the build cost.

    You can probably safely put EUR 100k against those costs. We already owned the site so have not included any costs for that in the figures.

    The figures you're quoting here seem extremely high. What are you including in the €3500/m2? I'm in the middle of building a 240m2 high spec house in Cork and not seeing anywhere near those costs.

    Also, €100k for architect, QS, engineer, solicitor, development contribution and connection fees certainly wouldn't be the norm.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 372 ✭✭JD1763


    Given that 2,500 was the 'average' cost per m2 pre-corona I don't believe 3,500 is extremely high at all. That figure is based off the QS calculating actual costs of certain element from other projects they've worked on and then allowing PC sums for other discretionary elements such as flooring, kitchen, lighting, bathrooms etc.

    In reality you cannot compare one self-build with another as all have different characteristics and costs based on the design, desired level of finish and required site works. Prime example - you can have a 7,000 kitchen or a 70,000 kitchen. Flooring could be polished concrete/walnut or laminate. In our design we have a lot of glazing and steel so this raises our costs compared to a project that may not need the same budget for those elements. Also being a bungalow we have higher foundation and roofing costs than if we had been able to simply add a second storey.

    Having been there myself trying to get an idea of what a self build could cost and could we afford it, I know people want to hear what the average is. But only a QS can give you a reasonable estimate of building your house based on the choices you make on every single element of your build.

    For the ancillary costs - when I was researching self-building it was rare to see someone setting out a detailed costing for these elements. I think it is important for anyone considering self-building to at least have an awareness of where these can land when preparing their budget and looking at their financing so they don't get mis-led by 'averages'.

    Maybe ours is an outlier, I don't feel like it is to be honest, but then at least it might serve as a worst case scenario for anyone looking at self-building. So the breakdown is:

    Architect was 10% of our initial build budget landing around 58k for full service - stages 1-4. QS is around 12k for the whole project. Engineer was 11k for the design work, site inspections and preparing the site health and safety plan. Energy consultant 1,000. Development contribution approx. 20k. Depending on what services the solicitor is providing - a gifted land transfer will cost anywhere from 1-2k. You also have to pay stamp duty on the transfer and the fee for valuing the land. Connection fees depend on your site but Irish water is approx. 2k to connect to water main and 4k for waste water within 10 meters of the main and a lot more if you go beyond 15 metres. ESB is 2,000 if the connection is straightforward - I read an article on a project where it cost 10k for the ESB connection.

    The only element in that breakdown that I would agree may not be the norm is the architect but like I said we contacted a number of firms and all quoted between 10-13% of build cost. Maybe we could have found another for a lower or a fixed price but we went with the firm we wanted based on their past work and reputation. We are only doing this once and wanted a particular design so we were prepared to pay for the right architect. For the other professionals we obtained multiple quotes and all were coming in reasonably similar so I do not believe these are excessive.

    I would be interested in seeing the breakdown of these costs for your project.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 759 ✭✭✭Cushtie


    Following this one.

    We have just got planning permission for a fairly standard L Shaped bungalow. 158 sq meters.
    UFH, A2W, MHRV. A2 RATING.

    Midwest region.

    The back of the L is split level as the site has a fair slope back on it.

    That's about the only non standard aspect of it.

    We are putting in hollow core slabs in ceiling as will be putting a couple of rooms in attic at a later stage.

    We built our last house about 13 years ago by Direct Labour and had planned on going main contractor route this time round, however seeing some of the prices quoted in this thread I'm thinking we will be looking to break it up a bit.

    The plan was to sell current house and build from proceeds and wipe out mortgage in process. Probably won't happen now what with COVID 19 throwing a bag of spanners in the works.

    We have it out with builders at the minute for quotes.

    Will report back.

    One question, some posters obove mention haveing a BOM.. Is this provided by the builders when they quote or are people getting this from. QS Separately?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 242 ✭✭actuar90


    tonytoc11 wrote: »
    The figures you're quoting here seem extremely high. What are you including in the €3500/m2? I'm in the middle of building a 240m2 high spec house in Cork and not seeing anywhere near those costs.

    Also, €100k for architect, QS, engineer, solicitor, development contribution and connection fees certainly wouldn't be the norm.

    What costs are you seeing Tony? We're just starting to plan for a similar sized house in cork so would be great to get some details on your experience


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 317 ✭✭tonytoc11


    We tendered our house to 5 local builders in Nov 2019 and the build cost was working out at €1,708/m2. This was a turnkey quote inducing the following:

    Septic tank, a 54m2 garage, finished driveway and landscaping, 20m2 of flat roofs, Siberian larch cladding, limestone cladding, vaulted ceilings, hollowcore slabs and precast staircase, fully spec'd electrical plan with Click Define sockets & switches throughout, A2W system with UFH on both floors and an MVHR system. Provisional sums were included for aluclad windows, kitchen, tiling and glass balustrade.

    The ancillary costs are not included in the €1,708/m2, but I'm expecting these to come under €50k. We were gifted the site, so site purchase isn't included in my costs.

    Architect - approx. €7k (I carried out this role)
    Engineer - €6k incl. PSDP and stage sign off
    QS - I didn't use one but I received quoted of approx. €1.5k for a BOQ
    BER consultant - €400
    Development contribution - €5k
    Solicitor - €5k excl. stamp duty
    Well - €5k
    ESB - €2,650
    Percolation test - €850 incl. excavator and driver rental

    I'm certainly not disputing the fact that the house mentioned above is coming at €3,500/m2 with €100k ancillary costs. It's quite possible if the budget allows, but I wouldn't agree that these are typical costs for building a house in Ireland. All of my costs are inclusive of VAT.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 25 kyler_87


    Hi all,

    I posted before in a different thread but have finalised figures now.

    30 mins from Cork city. 1950sqft bungalow,rectangular. 1 main bathroom, 1 ensuite. 450 sqft kitchen and dining area with vaulted ceiling. South facing rear, with fair bit of glazing. Costs below , broken out by fees and build costs. A2/A3 rating minimum.

    Fees
    Planning and Design 2500
    Percolation and Site Suitablity 950
    Cork CC Dues 3500
    Construction Supervision | Engineer 7500
    QS 800
    PSDP 1300
    BER Design & Assessment 1000
    Solicitor | Land Transfter & Mortgage 1800
    Stamp duty 6000
    ESB Connection 2600
    Total 28K

    Basic House
    Builder's payment 209000
    Heating 15200
    Windows 15750
    Fencing 3045
    Water (Incl Steeltech Shed) 10000
    Plumbing (not ware) 8600
    MHVR System 4700
    Extra Electrical 1000
    Extra Carpentry 1000

    Total 268K

    Finishes
    Bathroom Ware 5000
    Flooring & Tiles 10500
    Appliances 6000
    Kitchen & Utility 22000
    Painting 2000 (to date, doing ourselves)
    Furniture 7000
    Light fittings 750
    Flue/Stoves 5130
    Blinds/Curtains 1500
    Site Levelling 4800
    Walk in Wardrope 1300
    Driveway/Kerbs 5500

    Total 75K

    Overall:
    28K fees
    268K - shell of house with running water, heat and electricity
    ~343K relatively turn-key build cost + 28K fees = 371K

    Notes:
    Main contractor did groundwork, foundations, blockwork, roof, internal plastering, sewage (biocycle unit and raised bed perc) and electrics, internal carpentry.

    A2W heating system installed. Ashgrove in Kanturk.

    Just said I'd share some real world costs.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 372 ✭✭JD1763


    tonytoc11 wrote: »
    Development contribution - €5k

    I want to move to your local authority!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 671 ✭✭✭madmac187


    In the industry chaps, still got a builder didn’t have the time with work, 2650sqft for 229,000 in 2016 for an A2 rating with Mhrv, a2w ufh, triple glaze passive windows, precast floors with 50% oak stairs, including 100m access road and surround and cavity full fill with PVC facing. Christ costs really have jumped.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 671 ✭✭✭madmac187


    JD1763 wrote: »
    I want to move to your local authority!

    Development charge 2.5k!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17 BarryT2012


    Hi all,

    Can anybody recommend any good free apps/sites out there that allow you to do some site/floor plans based on sqft/site acreage etc.

    I see apps like autocad but they look to be subscription based.

    If its the case of good auld fashion maths then so be it will get out excel..

    Looking to buy a site but not sure what my minimum/max requirements are, total novice at this as you can see!!

    Thanks in advance.


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    Sketchup


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2 ilovefruit


    Hi all - I have found reading some of these posts quite frightening! We have just got quote from qs of 520,000 for 2660sqft house - some complicated angles and we are on quite an elevated site in the midlands. My husband is a plumber so will obviously doing that side of things. It seems that price above is reflective of current market - being in the trade or not? Any advice or insight greatly appreciated.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,595 ✭✭✭ECO_Mental


    ilovefruit wrote: »
    Hi all - I have found reading some of these posts quite frightening! We have just got quote from qs of 520,000 for 2660sqft house - some complicated angles and we are on quite an elevated site in the midlands. My husband is a plumber so will obviously doing that side of things. It seems that price above is reflective of current market - being in the trade or not? Any advice or insight greatly appreciated.

    What you need to do is see what can you get in your locality if you were to buy a new house or renovate an old house. Would you get the same value?

    For me I live in the south side of cork city and for my budget I certainly would not get the same value for what I am building mine for (537k for a 250m2 house) excluding professional fees and planning fees (total €575k)

    All the new build houses what we were looking for (4 bed detached) were mid 500s with no space and bad layouts. I could then buy an old house and totally renovate but you will need 200k+ to do any decent renovation job and extension, so on top of 400k for a secondhand house and then add 200 you re looking at 600.

    Now if I was out in the middle of the country where house prices are a lot lower it would be a different conversation I would be having and could I justify it. It would be deffo cheaper to buy a house then build it.


    I think you are doing the right thing getting a QS involved and doing a breakdown on the costs. But building regs now are high so you have to have an "A" rated house which mean underfloor heating, heat pumps, mechanical conventional etc etc you will though get a super house that will cost you nothing to heat and run.

    6.1kWp south facing, South of Cork City



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 34,216 ✭✭✭✭listermint


    BarryT2012 wrote: »
    Hi all,

    Can anybody recommend any good free apps/sites out there that allow you to do some site/floor plans based on sqft/site acreage etc.

    I see apps like autocad but they look to be subscription based.

    If its the case of good auld fashion maths then so be it will get out excel..

    Looking to buy a site but not sure what my minimum/max requirements are, total novice at this as you can see!!

    Thanks in advance.

    Floorplanner.com free version.

    I found it's way better than sketchup.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 53 ✭✭Dazed2020


    Hi all,
    Hopefully this is a suitable thread to post in as it's about the choice of extension vs build new.

    Wife & I want a nice ~186m2/2000sq ft house of reasonable spec with modern kitchen/diner with plenty of glazing in East Cork.
    I appreciate the most obvious response to the below will be to talk to an expert, however, I’d like to get a reasonable sense for things first.
    I see 3 options right now:
    1: Buy site + build. Likely to take some time with planning.
    2: Buy a 1970s-1990s type bungalow/dormer, of approx 150 m2; renovate (bring up BER from F or G to B1/A3) & extend by ~37m2. No planning permission needed but cost to renovate likely expensive on top of expensive house.
    3: Buy older/far smaller house of approx 50-70m2; renovate & extend by 120-130m2.

    This is all very speculative at this point and I’m basing costs off what I’ve read above, in other threads & the SCSI estimate tool so realise they're not going to be terribly accurate.
    Am i mad to think that it’s likely to be more economical to buy a smaller almost wreck of a house that needs everything done, than a more expensive house that’s liveable but not to the standard we’d want (so would need a decent outlay)?

    And do people know if planning for an extension (in the case below to take floorspace to 3x the original size) take as long as for a new house anyway?

    Site:
    Required Build 186m2
    Initial Cost of site: 100,000
    Build@ 2,000/m2 372,000
    Total 472,000

    Small house
    Size 60m2
    Required Extension 126m2
    Initial Cost 150,000
    Rennovate @1,500/m2 90,000
    Extend/Build@ 2,000/m2 252,000
    Total 492,000

    Bigger house
    Size 150m2
    Required Build 36m2
    Initial Cost 250,000
    Rennovate @1,500/m2 225,000
    Extend/Build@ 2,000/m2 72,000
    Total 547,000


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 130 ✭✭tadgho


    Hi all, is there anywhere (website etc.) where one can see photos of finished houses (exterior and interior) and a figure for total spend on the house, just to get an idea of what a 250k/300k/400k house actually looks like?! It's interesting reading all the different figures on this thread and numbers on square feet, energy rating etc. etc but some pics for finished products would be nice as someone considering a self build in the future. I know "Self-build" magazine often have feature articles on builds with pictures, spec and overall total cost, but a lot of the time overall cost is not disclosed! I know there are variables and there is more to a build than meets the eye by looking at it, but just a rough idea! Thanks!:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,470 ✭✭✭JoeA3


    tadgho wrote: »
    Hi all, is there anywhere (website etc.) where one can see photos of finished houses (exterior and interior) and a figure for total spend on the house, just to get an idea of what a 250k/300k/400k house actually looks like?! It's interesting reading all the different figures on this thread and numbers on square feet, energy rating etc. etc but some pics for finished products would be nice as someone considering a self build in the future. I know "Self-build" magazine often have feature articles on builds with pictures, spec and overall total cost, but a lot of the time overall cost is not disclosed! I know there are variables and there is more to a build than meets the eye by looking at it, but just a rough idea! Thanks!:)

    If you're on Facebook, try the "Self build and Renovations Ireland" group. Loads of what you're looking for on there.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 123 ✭✭eire1987


    Hi All,

    We are due to start our build at home in Cork in next few weeks. Site was gifted to us. And the spec were getting is high (A1/NZEB)

    House is Timber frame (lego style house company -snip-) its a dormer bungalow (2031sq ft).To builders finish its 145 sq/ft... is that too much?? or is it ok?? we really arent sure, our engineer suggested we can save 10/20k but that is about it... we are getting a contractor to build it...

    Main contractor doing groundwork, foundations, windows, doors, roof, internal plastering, sewage (biocycle unit and raised bed perc) and electrics, internal carpentry. A2W heating system to be installed. Ashgrove in Kanturk.

    Overall to finish it, we have costs at 165 sq ft... is that mental or is it norm.. advice would be great


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 36 ToTheSea


    Hi All,

    We have an old 19th-century cottage that we are looking to renovate or demolish and rebuild. The house is stilled used as a holiday home, so would be connected to mains water and electric.

    If we were to demolish nd replace we would be looking to replace with a 80-90sq bungalow.

    The house is in the North West, so it would be great if anybody could give a ballpark figure for the cost of a rebuild?

    What other fees would we have to pay other than the cost of the construction cost?
    I'm aware we would probably have to pay the planning application fees, the architecture fees but not really sure if there anything else

    Measurements would be something like the attached picture and the plans attached are just a rough idea taken from [snip]


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,397 ✭✭✭CBear1993


    Pay a decent QS or anyone with half a notion to do this for you. Much better than taking the heed of anonymous people on here


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 10,146 Mod ✭✭✭✭BryanF


    copyright infringement links and images removed, please read the forum charter before posting again thanks


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 373 ✭✭Jimi H


    ToTheSea wrote: »
    Hi All,

    We have an old 19th-century cottage that we are looking to renovate or demolish and rebuild. The house is stilled used as a holiday home, so would be connected to mains water and electric.

    If we were to demolish nd replace we would be looking to replace with a 80-90sq bungalow.

    The house is in the North West, so it would be great if anybody could give a ballpark figure for the cost of a rebuild?

    What other fees would we have to pay other than the cost of the construction cost?
    I'm aware we would probably have to pay the planning application fees, the architecture fees but not really sure if there anything else

    Measurements would be something like the attached picture and the plans attached are just a rough idea taken from [snip]

    I’m in a similar position where I’m trying to decide on whether to renovate an old cottage or build. Did you decide? I can’t see the measurements from your post unfortunately.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1 mickeyh


    Hi,
    Hoping someone can help. I'm hoping to commence a new house build in the south west in the new year (subject planning which is due soon)

    Does anyone have a useful spreadsheet with main construction elements broken down so that I can start sourcing quotes etc. to build up a reasonable estimate.

    I don't want to employ a QS at this stage as I have reasonable knowledge of the building process. I'd like to manage the build myself and subcontract each element - to save money.

    It would be great to hear from anyone that has built recently.

    House is in the country and approx 2,500ft2 house and garage.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,789 ✭✭✭PowerToWait


    I have practically no building knowledge and estimated my costs pretty well according to my QS. Surely if you’re too good for a QS you don’t need an elemental breakdown of the building stages?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 861 ✭✭✭tails_naf


    CBear1993 wrote: »
    Pay a decent QS or anyone with half a notion to do this for you. Much better than taking the heed of anonymous people on here

    I always think it's mad getting a QS for a domestic build. If you want to get a house done and your are on a budget, then do a bit of spade work and get the excel spreadsheet out yourself. Don't pay for professional fees that will basically end up at an 'industry standard' cost per sq ft. If you want to do better than that then you must go direct labour. I built a house to A3 spec in 2010 for 65/sq ft, and recently built a domestic garage, which is better insulated than the house (100mm pumped cavity, 100mm plasterboard), and the basic frame is not that expensive for blocks, windows, roof, insulation. The garage has a converted attic so is 1400 sq ft, and is say I've spent under 30k. It's a lot of work though, but so is paying off a 500k mortgage when it could be 250k!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 222 ✭✭VANG1


    I must say a QS was the best investment I ever made, more than paid for himself.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,595 ✭✭✭ECO_Mental


    VANG1 wrote: »
    I must say a QS was the best investment I ever made, more than paid for himself.


    I would double up-vote this if I could...

    6.1kWp south facing, South of Cork City



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 861 ✭✭✭tails_naf


    VANG1 wrote: »
    I must say a QS was the best investment I ever made, more than paid for himself.

    Care to give an example? What cost / sq ft did you achieve?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,595 ✭✭✭ECO_Mental


    tails_naf wrote: »
    Care to give an example? What cost / sq ft did you achieve?


    Currently at €214/sqft, including EVERYTHING eg move in with your bags.. south of Cork City

    6.1kWp south facing, South of Cork City



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,642 ✭✭✭dubrov


    tails_naf wrote: »
    Care to give an example? What cost / sq ft did you achieve?

    To be fair, it's not so much how much it cost per sq/ft but the reduction in cost per sq/ft that justifies a QS.

    Obviously a self builder who runs the project themselves and prices up everything multiple times is unlikely to get much benefit from a QS.

    Someone who uses a prime contractor for the whole build could benefit greatly from independent advice on pricing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 861 ✭✭✭tails_naf


    ECO_Mental wrote: »
    Currently at €214/sqft, including EVERYTHING eg move in with your bags.. south of Cork City

    For my house I was offered a turn key option for something similar per sq ft, would have cost 600k to go that way, built it for 240k all in, incuding flooring, kitchen all tiling and painting done. It was a busy year of my life though!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 861 ✭✭✭tails_naf


    dubrov wrote: »
    To be fair, it's not so much how much it cost per sq/ft but the reduction in cost per sq/ft that justifies a QS.

    Obviously a self builder who runs the project themselves and prices up everything multiple times is unlikely to get much benefit from a QS.

    Someone who uses a prime contractor for the whole build could benefit greatly from independent advice on pricing.

    Thats fair. If you are on a budget, and willing to do the leg work, you can do much better.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 513 ✭✭✭Frozen Veg


    mickeyh wrote: »
    Hi,
    Hoping someone can help. I'm hoping to commence a new house build in the south west in the new year (subject planning which is due soon)

    Does anyone have a useful spreadsheet with main construction elements broken down so that I can start sourcing quotes etc. to build up a reasonable estimate.

    I don't want to employ a QS at this stage as I have reasonable knowledge of the building process. I'd like to manage the build myself and subcontract each element - to save money.

    It would be great to hear from anyone that has built recently.

    House is in the country and approx 2,500ft2 house and garage.

    I'd be allowing 160sqft for the house from planning to turnkey finish. Plus your garage costs. That's for a moderate finish.

    You might do it slightly cheaper than that but that's what I'd use to get a ball park figure.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement