Dublin GAA Discussion Thread: Mod Note - No 'Dublin Dominance' chat allowed!

ArielAtom

Roscommon are poor, we are in 2nd gear. Little more than an easing back into it.

Fann Linn

1 wide at HT according to stats. Costelloe's last kick.

Comic Book Guy

Comic Book Guy wrote: »

Is there a new rule for the pull back/down. Foul for penalty looked well outside the square

Actually is a new rule. Black card offence within the 20 metre line or the arc results in a penalty.

dobman88

Comic Book Guy wrote: »

Is there a new rule for the pull back/down. Foul for penalty looked well outside the square

Yep. Anywhere inside the 20m line when a foul is committed and is considered a goal scoring opportunity, is a penalty now.

Edit. It actually includes inside the D also

GAA Congress voted to introduce the new rule on a trial basis. This sees any cynical foul which prevents a goal-scoring opportunity, within the 20m line or the 'D', get punished with a penalty and a 10-minute sin-bin for the perpetrator

Fann Linn

Not sure what to make of this rule. Black card might be enough as punishment. Plus we could be crucified if Jonny Cooper had 'one of those days'.

How Soon Is Now

Not a great peno there suited the keeper.

Games getting bit scrappy now has free flowing as first half.

dog_pig

dobman88 wrote: »

Yep. Anywhere inside the 20m line when a foul is committed and is considered a goal scoring opportunity, is a penalty now.

Not just any foul, specifically a cynical foul.

How Soon Is Now

Dublin have dropped off a bit unfortunately. That peno would of finished the game.

MFPM

ArielAtom wrote: »

Roscommon are poor, we are in 2nd gear. Little more than an easing back into it.

Only 4 point game and Roscommon a man down. Dublin a bit sloppy in possession but yeah they're no where near top gear.

dobman88

dog_pig wrote: »

Not just any foul, specifically a cynical foul.

Yeah, I know. It says that in the piece of my post you edited out :pac:

dog_pig

dobman88 wrote: »

Yeah, I know. It says that in the piece of my post you edited out :pac:

I quoted what you typed yourself, the rest you copy pasted no?

dobman88

dog_pig wrote: »

I quoted what you typed yourself, the rest you copy pasted no?

I did. I corrected myself. Thought that was obvious. But sure not a big deal.

dog_pig

dobman88 wrote: »

I did. I corrected myself. Thought that was obvious. But sure not a big deal.

Fair enough, just thought you might not have realised. No worries.

Strumms

Referee needs to get the cards out... Roscommon getting very ‘cynical’. Tiring.

How Soon Is Now

Costello been great today apart from second peno hasn't put a foot wrong.

Fann Linn

How Soon Is Now wrote: »

Costello been great today apart from second peno hasn't put a foot wrong.

Defo need penalty practice with this new ruling.

How Soon Is Now

Fann Linn wrote: »

Defo need penalty practice with this new ruling.

Ya surely Rock or Killkenny be taking them.

Strumms

Did he take a point there ? Ffs it matters not try entertain people !

Fake Scores

He wasn't going for a point.

Don't like the short run up.

gormdubhgorm

dobman88 wrote: »

Yep. Anywhere inside the 20m line when a foul is committed and is considered a goal scoring opportunity, is a penalty now.

Edit. It actually includes inside the D also

GAA Congress voted to introduce the new rule on a trial basis. This sees any cynical foul which prevents a goal-scoring opportunity, within the 20m line or the 'D', get punished with a penalty and a 10-minute sin-bin for the perpetrator

Seems a bit 'soccer-ish' fellas will be diving next!

gormdubhgorm

How Soon Is Now wrote: »

Ya surely Rock or Killkenny be taking them.

Or Con maybe?

poppers

gormdubhgorm wrote: »

Seems a bit 'soccer-ish' fellas will be diving next!

Agree. Going to be a lot of forwards going down as they feel the contact just like soccer

FullBack Jam

Fake Scores wrote: »

He wasn't going for a point.

Don't like the short run up.

Really?? I thought he was taking the point, as a kinda concession that it shouldn't have been a penalty in the first place.

ArielAtom

flasher0030 wrote: »

Really?? I thought he was taking the point, as a kinda concession that it shouldn't have been a penalty in the first place.

Nah, just a poor penalty.

Strumms

Dunno lads, he cleared the bar by a distance and a real lazy run up to it.

Actually Mick Galvin confirms afterwards that the second peno was ‘missed’.. not happy.

gormdubhgorm

Strumms wrote: »

Dunno lads, he cleared the bar by a distance and a real lazy run up to it.

Actually Mick Galvin confirms afterwards that the second peno was ‘missed’.. not happy.

Jayus and my first impression was, he tapped it over cos the game was over anyway.

Always feel sorry for Costello in virtually any other Dublin era he would be THE main man. Freetaker, household name, etc.
Late 20's now and rarely seems to get the recognition.

How Soon Is Now

gormdubhgorm wrote: »

Jayus and my first impression was, he tapped it over cos the game was over anyway.

Always feel sorry for Costello in virtually any other Dublin era he would be THE main man. Freetaker, household name, etc.
Late 20's now and rarely seems to get the recognition.

He's a confidence player though. He's prone to having very off days where nothing will go right.

The big names for Dublin over the last few years have been more consistent.

Jizique

gormdubhgorm wrote: »

Jayus and my first impression was, he tapped it over cos the game was over anyway.

Always feel sorry for Costello in virtually any other Dublin era he would be THE main man. Freetaker, household name, etc.
Late 20's now and rarely seems to get the recognition.

He should have stuck to the hurling

Dyr

How Soon Is Now wrote: »

He's a confidence player though. He's prone to having very off days where nothing will go right.

The big names for Dublin over the last few years have been more consistent.

All three penalties were poor, his goal chance he managed to blast off the keeper, he's inconsistent.

How Soon Is Now

Bambi wrote: »

All three penalties were poor, his goal chance he managed to blast off the keeper, he's inconsistent.

Ya i wasn't confident with any of those penalties soon as i seen how he took the first one. Hopefully he can have a proper go at things this season with Mannion out but its early days yet. He did finish last season in decent form though so hes carried it into this year so far so good.