South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:02am

Doris WW wrote: »

Is this for Clodagh?

Argh, yes Clodagh. This game has gone on so long now all the names are blending into one.

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 9:04am

For info, my protect doesn't seem to affect powers applying to people's backrooms. I protected Wini on the day Frank interrogated her, and neither of them seemed to notice.

So if Frank could still take Wini to his backroom, surely Tegan's backroom blocking power would still work on Doris.

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 9:16am

I've put my vote onto Doris - I need to know whether the wolves knew that the Tegan vote was going to be overturned.

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:27am

Henry WW wrote: »

I've put my vote onto Doris - I need to know whether the wolves knew that the Tegan vote was going to be overturned.

Is that 6, for Doris now? 7 would mean majority

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 9:33am

Isla WW wrote: »

Is that 6, for Doris now? 7 would mean majority

Oh for ****s sake

I’ve tried to give you a plan that pretty much has no out for me if I was a wolf. Im actually telling you to lynch me post my peek. And all folks are interested in is totting the numbers to get majority as quick as they can

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 9:43am

Isla WW wrote: »

Is that 6, for Doris now? 7 would mean majority

no, we're only at 5 by my count

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:44am

Doris WW wrote: »

Oh for ****s sake

I’ve tried to give you a plan that pretty much has no out for me if I was a wolf. Im actually telling you to lynch me post my peek. And all folks are interested in is totting the numbers to get majority as quick as they can

If people think your most likely person to be bad then saying wait till I can have a peek isn't going to convince them. Why would they believe your "peek" to be truthful is they already think your a wolf?

I fear most of the conversation for this day phase might be done unless someone changes their story or we have a reveal from Phil or something though.

I also think that even if the village is wrong on both the poisoned & up for lynch we should have the numbers (impossible to know for sure) even if we have to lose lovers and all that entails to win out.

Clodagh is either a wolf or gives us patrick.

That already is the 8th bad player accounted for. 8 x 4 = the size of the original village so that could feasibly be all of them.

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:45am

Henry WW wrote: »

no, we're only at 5 by my count

My bad I must have counted Clodagh who then moved to No lynch.

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 9:47am

Doris, persuade me.

Take day 2 lynch and say you're good. If I'm right and one of you or Tegan is lying, then one is presumably bad.

If you're good, wolves have no idea that lynch result will be overturned. So at least 3 of them pile on a fellow wolf to lynch her. They could have gone elsewhere. They created the wagon that hid barbara - I can't see the reason for it.

If you're bad, wolves know the vote result will be overturned and so can pile on wherever they want...

That's based on one of you and Tegan being evil. Did you go into your backroom during the night you had protection?

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 9:48am

I'd actually put myself up for lynch just to move this on tbh.

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 9:50am

Isla WW wrote: »

If people think your most likely person to be bad then saying wait till I can have a peek isn't going to convince them. Why would they believe your "peek" to be truthful is they already think your a wolf?

I fear most of the conversation for this day phase might be done unless someone changes their story or we have a reveal from Phil or something though.

I also think that even if the village is wrong on both the poisoned & up for lynch we should have the numbers (impossible to know for sure) even if we have to lose lovers and all that entails to win out.

Clodagh is either a wolf or gives us patrick.

That already is the 8th bad player accounted for. 8 x 4 = the size of the original village so that could feasibly be all of them.

I’m not asking them to believe me, I’m asking them to get the peek result and then lynch me. Then they can believe me

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:51am

Doris WW wrote: »

I’m not asking them to believe me, I’m asking them to get the peek result and then lynch me. Then they can believe me

and if they don't believe you why would they do that?

Also while waiting for you to get your peek who should they lynch ?

Patrick WW · 27-10-2019 9:53am

Doris WW wrote: »

I’m not asking them to believe me, I’m asking them to get the peek result and then lynch me. Then they can believe me

No offence here but you'd also need BG protection, your talking about using village resources for an unverified and disputed role, do you not see the issue with this at all?

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 9:55am

Doris WW wrote: »

I’m not asking them to believe me, I’m asking them to get the peek result and then lynch me. Then they can believe me

If you had a peek right now, peeked me and said I am good. Even though I would believe you had a peek and told the truth that I am good I would not think that makes you any less of a wolf. Just that you could steal a peek or that you already know I'm good.

Lucy WW · 27-10-2019 10:00am

So much for a quiet weekend ye feckers

Necro · 27-10-2019 10:01am

Lucy WW wrote: »

So much for a quiet weekend ye feckers

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 10:03am

Isla WW wrote: »

If people think your most likely person to be bad then saying wait till I can have a peek isn't going to convince them. Why would they believe your "peek" to be truthful is they already think your a wolf?

I fear most of the conversation for this day phase might be done unless someone changes their story or we have a reveal from Phil or something though.

I also think that even if the village is wrong on both the poisoned & up for lynch we should have the numbers (impossible to know for sure) even if we have to lose lovers and all that entails to win out.

Clodagh is either a wolf or gives us patrick.

That already is the 8th bad player accounted for. 8 x 4 = the size of the original village so that could feasibly be all of them.

Regardless of Clodaghs alignment, if Patrick was the last wolf they’d have no incentive to play on right now. He’s not the last wolf

Patrick WW · 27-10-2019 10:06am

Doris WW wrote: »

Regardless of Clodaghs alignment, if Patrick was the last wolf they’d have no incentive to play on right now. He’s not the last wolf

And if you and Clodagh are the last wolves your playing for an opening here! There has been confusion about your power for a couple of days and contradictions. Clodagh poisoned and you under pressure, desperate play but your only one I suppose

Henry WW · 27-10-2019 10:07am

Conor. If you read this - you mentioned before that you got a PM when Tegan blocked you from your backroom. Is that right?

Frank, did you get a PM?

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 10:07am

Necro wrote: »

You should be, it seems we may potentially have a near 6k posts South Park game and nobody is (my dad) Randy Marsh!

I mean Towlie made the cut, whats going on! :pac:

Lucy WW · 27-10-2019 10:08am

Necro wrote: »

You will be

Lucy WW · 27-10-2019 10:12am

This is how I feel right now

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 10:12am

Henry WW wrote: »

Doris, persuade me.

Take day 2 lynch and say you're good. If I'm right and one of you or Tegan is lying, then one is presumably bad.

If you're good, wolves have no idea that lynch result will be overturned. So at least 3 of them pile on a fellow wolf to lynch her. They could have gone elsewhere. They created the wagon that hid barbara - I can't see the reason for it.

If you're bad, wolves know the vote result will be overturned and so can pile on wherever they want...

That's based on one of you and Tegan being evil. Did you go into your backroom during the night you had protection?

I have no idea why the wolves voted the way they did, I simply did what I thought was right for the village. Votes were on thread so I figured no damage to wagonomics and try to get a wolf. If I’d picked a different player we might not even be having this conversation

Necro · 27-10-2019 10:15am

Isla WW wrote: »

You should be, it seems we may potentially have a near 6k posts South Park game and nobody is (my dad) Randy Marsh!

I mean Towlie made the cut, whats going on! :pac:

Mods suggest that players actually read the character reveals in future

Necro wrote: »

Mary WW was....

Randy Marsh - Derp

And also....
Good

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 10:17am

I'll take that under advisement Necro

Patrick WW · 27-10-2019 10:17am

Isla WW wrote: »

You should be, it seems we may potentially have a near 6k posts South Park game and nobody is (my dad) Randy Marsh!

I mean Towlie made the cut, whats going on! :pac:

Necro wrote: »

Barbara WW was....

Saddam Hussein - Jester

And also, obviously...
Evil

Mary WW was....

Randy Marsh - Derp

And also....
Good

Bad news Isla

Lucy WW · 27-10-2019 10:17am

Whats going on Necro,

Where's this guy?

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 10:18am

Isla WW wrote: »

and if they don't believe you why would they do that?

Also while waiting for you to get your peek who should they lynch ?

Clodagh is my suggestion since she’s dying anyway

Isla WW · 27-10-2019 10:19am

Patrick WW wrote: »

Bad news Isla

Almost got there before himself. My dad derved better. Derp, Y'all ain't got no Tegridy :P

Doris WW · 27-10-2019 10:20am

Patrick WW wrote: »

No offence here but you'd also need BG protection, your talking about using village resources for an unverified and disputed role, do you not see the issue with this at all?

If the bag doesn’t trust me then the wolves munch me and save you the hassle. If they don’t you would have to lynch me which is what I’ve suggested anyway

South Park WW ROLE MADNESS - Game Thread

Comments