Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Separation after wife affair. Father's rights..

  • 04-09-2019 5:54pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭


    Hi all

      I recently found out my wife of 10+ years(20 years together) had been having an affair with work colleague for 8 months. When I confronted her, she denied before I provided evidence.she told me it was over and she was going to tell me. Not very believable to be honest.

    We spent the next couple of days talking about it, but after six days she dropped the bombshell she wanted to move. So she started, found a house locally and is taking the kids (10 & 7) 4 days a week while I get them 3 days. I'm having to pay rent and the mortgage on both houses, along with all family home expenses. This is literally going to take 75% of my salary. I'm also left with the credit card debt of around €1200  which the majority is family expenses. She wants to keep child benefit as well.. 

    I've tried everything to get her to stay, and we try and work it out... Her answer  is no to everything and is hell bent on moving out.. This weekend actually. Only a very small group know about the affair and we agreed to keep it that way mainly for the kids.. 

    I'm wondering how am I fixed legally.. Is it right that she can take the kids, for half the week, and I pay so much? I don't want them to not see her, as she always was a good mother but I'm losing out here. 

    However, I've done nothing wrong, provided my family with everything required while she was spending money on herself and going away for nights with him. (under the guise of work nights out) 

    I didn't have much of a social life myself besides training with local club - alot due to money not been available. Now I'm losing my kids for half the week, in debt (which isn't huge, but I'm on the backfoot already) 

    We have said we don't want to go legal yet just see how living seperate works out. However I have my suspicious she is back having a relationship with this guy.. Even before she moves out & after me trying so hard to make things work. 

    I'm trying to be amicable but every time I see her I'm so angry at what she has done to the family.. 

    So should I just shut up and take my kids now that I can, even for half the week.. Would I have any leg to stand on if going legal considering the circumstances? Or is it the usual in Ireland legal system that the father is second best no matter what.. 

    Thanks for advice and apologies for long winded story 


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,298 ✭✭✭Snotty


    Speak to a solicitor immediately, I guarantee you she has already.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 312 ✭✭Abba987


    bellucio wrote: »
    Hi all

      I recently found out my wife of 10+ years(20 years together) had been having an affair with work colleague for 8 months. When I confronted her, she denied before I provided evidence.she told me it was over and she was going to tell me. Not very believable to be honest.

    We spent the next couple of days talking about it, but after six days she dropped the bombshell she wanted to move. So she started, found a house locally and is taking the kids (10 & 7) 4 days a week while I get them 3 days. I'm having to pay rent and the mortgage on both houses, along with all family home expenses. This is literally going to take 75% of my salary. I'm also left with the credit card debt of around €1200  which the majority is family expenses. She wants to keep child benefit as well.. 

    I've tried everything to get her to stay, and we try and work it out... Her answer  is no to everything and is hell bent on moving out.. This weekend actually. Only a very small group know about the affair and we agreed to keep it that way mainly for the kids.. 

    I'm wondering how am I fixed legally.. Is it right that she can take the kids, for half the week, and I pay so much? I don't want them to not see her, as she always was a good mother but I'm losing out here. 

    However, I've done nothing wrong, provided my family with everything required while she was spending money on herself and going away for nights with him. (under the guise of work nights out) 

    I didn't have much of a social life myself besides training with local club - alot due to money not been available. Now I'm losing my kids for half the week, in debt (which isn't huge, but I'm on the backfoot already) 

    We have said we don't want to go legal yet just see how living seperate works out. However I have my suspicious she is back having a relationship with this guy.. Even before she moves out & after me trying so hard to make things work. 

    I'm trying to be amicable but every time I see her I'm so angry at what she has done to the family.. 

    So should I just shut up and take my kids now that I can, even for half the week.. Would I have any leg to stand on if going legal considering the circumstances? Or is it the usual in Ireland legal system that the father is second best no matter what.. 

    Thanks for advice and apologies for long winded story 

    I think you should speak to a solicitor. I cant imagine you have to pay for both houses in full. If she is back with himself you dont want to be paying a cent for the roof over his head.

    So she wants to keep all her wages and the child benefit and you pay for everything ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,228 ✭✭✭✭Dial Hard


    The legal system in Ireland is that all divorces are considered no-fault. This means that it doesn't matter if either party has been unfaithful, or violent, or criminal, or anything - as far as the law is concerned, it's irrelevant.

    You need to get legal advice, and ASAP. There are historical reasons that family courts *tend* to favour the mother in custody issues, but it's not always the case and it's a discussion for another thread anyway. Get a recommendation for a good family law solicitor and go for a consultation as soon as you can. It's not admitting defeat or committing to anything or any other reason that you might be reluctant to do so, it's just pure common sense.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,439 ✭✭✭✭Purple Mountain


    Just to wade in.. Make sure the solicitor is very well versed and recommended in family law circles.
    Definitely consult one, even if only for advice.
    I'd be even saying not to tell her.
    You have every right to protect yourself.

    To thine own self be true



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Wasn't expecting that many replies so quick... Thanks guys...
    No proof yet she is back with him, it's just my gut.. He is also married, don't know if he has left wife..
    I feel so sorry for his wife if he hasn't. Not knowing is so wrong.. Very tempted to try and find the poor woman and tell her, even though I know it's probably not right and not my business.. Again there is kids there..
    Anyway, on the family solicitor.. Fortunately I don't know anyone who has been through this situation so don't have people to ask locally..
    To that end, does anybody know of family solicitor in north Cork or city direction?
    Thanks..


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Abba987 wrote: »
    I think you should speak to a solicitor. I cant imagine you have to pay for both houses in full. If she is back with himself you dont want to be paying a cent for the roof over his head.

    So she wants to keep all her wages and the child benefit and you pay for everything ?

    She will be paying bills on the new house she is staying. I've the bills for family home...
    She would be on about 1/3 of my salary.


  • Moderators, Business & Finance Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 51,690 Mod ✭✭✭✭Stheno


    Does your wife work and is her salary comparable to yours?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,636 ✭✭✭Homelander


    Sorry to hear about this situation. I'm confused as to why you are paying all rent and expenses on two houses if the second house is a result of a) your wife having an affair and b) her wanting to move out? Either way, you do need to at least speak to a solicitor first before making any decisions. As for the personal aspect of it, I can't begin to imagine the pain, hurt and upset, but you need to focus on yourself and don't concern yourself with the "other man" or his own relationship with his wife.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Stheno wrote: »
    Does your wife work and is her salary comparable to yours?

    Yes she does. 4 day week, but salary is about 36% of mine... Plus she is getting child benefit.
    She will just have the new house bills, groceries etc. (outside of rent)
    There is a strong possibility that this time next year, she will have a family home available (rent free or minimal rent)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Homelander wrote: »
    Sorry to hear about this situation. I'm confused as to why you are paying all rent and expenses on two houses if the second house is a result of a) your wife having an affair and b) her wanting to move out? Either way, you do need to at least speak to a solicitor first before making any decisions. As for the personal aspect of it, I can't begin to imagine the pain, hurt and upset, but you need to focus on yourself and don't concern yourself with the "other man" or his own relationship with his wife.
    Thanks for the concern. 👠Pain/hurt/anger /upset +more... Trying to focus on myself all right. Going to start counseling next week, so hopefully that will help. Need to try and stay strong for the kids.
    Unfortunately decisions made and she is moving out this weekend..
    Looking back I should have been more of a b****ix and tell her I wouldn't pay it... But then the kids would be stuck in the middle of this relationship in the house. At the moment I can barely look at her... So again, kids are my big priority, need them to be some bit ok..
    I was hoping she would come to her senses and realize the mistake before the signed the lease on new place. Obviously I gave her too much credit.. 😡😡

    Yes I'm paying rent/mortgage on both, but only expenses on the family home. Where I am staying. She will pay those.
    Pain


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,531 ✭✭✭Car99


    What is your reasoning for paying rent on her new place ? She will be set up in her new place and then tell you she wants half the value of the family home so you'll either have to sell or buy her out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,671 ✭✭✭GarIT


    How do you have to pay anything? Make sure your salary is going into your own private account and make sure you don't give her a single cent for anything until a custody and maintenance agreement in place.


    Keep reccords/evidence of anything jointly owned that you pay like the mortgage.



    Talk to a solicitor ASAP.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 146 ✭✭Another day


    Absolutely stop paying her rent! It is her choice to move out. Splitting time with the kids is great, they will feel wanted and not abandoned. As they spend so much time with you, you don't need to pay maintenance, just split school and medical bills. Don't bad mother their mother.

    Get legal advice as advised previously. If you have a joint account only put kids related funds into it and tell your ex that's what you are doing. Move house bills etc to your own account. Write to your bank advising them of the separation and that no loans are to be issued with tge house as security. If you have savings, split them and get her to sign for the money. Only make payments via bank transfer to her, have a trail.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,259 ✭✭✭donkeykong5


    Stop paying for her in the rented house immediately. Shes working herself. Let her pay for it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,885 ✭✭✭Tzardine


    Paying for her house is mental. I genuinely dont mean to sound like a d1ck, but she is making a mug of you and laughing all the way. You pay her rent after she has an affair on you.

    Straight to a reputable family law solicitor you need to go.

    I wish you well.

    Edit - I would also not be so quick to keep the affair secret. This only benefits her. You dont want people to assume something else and potentially think you were at fault or the issue. There is no shame in the truth for you, only for her.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Thanks for all the comments everyone.

    Re the rent.. The only reason I'm paying that is to put a roof over my kids heads. There is no way she could afford the rent on her salary alone.
    Saying that if I find out she is back with him, I'm 100% pulling it.
    Should I have been stronger at the start and just tell her to f**k off without the kids, probably yes.

    She wanted to leave, said she was taking the kids 4 days. I was afraid at the time that if I contested, and we went the legal route that I would see them even less. I was/am still fuming that they are losing out on me for four days, through no fault of mine or theirs.
    However as far as I knew, that's the Irish legal system. Fall on side of mother no matter what.. Plus I was still in shock at the whole thing and hoping that a bit of space for a while might help.. I was willing to make a go of things.maybe that was the denial phase. Looking back, huge mistake I know.

    Through all of this I'm just trying to put the kids first, make it easy as possible for them. Have they blinded my judgment? maybe but I won't feel bad for trying to look after them first.. Isn't that what a father is supposed to do?

    I'm meeting a family law solicitor Monday to discuss the situation. Hopefully I can get some answers and advice. She comes recommended by someone who has seen this thread so it was worth starting it!

    As for making the affair common knowledge.. Again it's the kids I'm trying to protect. She was/is a good mother (aprt from the breaking up of the family! )
    Part of me doesn't want to blacken their image of her.. She doesn't talk to her mother who walked out when she was young. I don't want that for my kids. They deserve their mother, even if she has been an absolute b**ch...

    In a way I do feel ashamed.. How did I not see this sooner? I've been taken for a mug since early this year. Even my 95 year old grandmother said to me the other night "I knew there was something up"... I know other family members on both sides are suspicious as well..

    One of the other reasons I agreed to keep it quiet at the start was if we happened to make a second go what people would say.. At this moment however, I can't see anyway back..

    Where do I go now..
    Kids this weekend.. Make the most of this time. Solicitor Monday, counseling Tuesday. Busy few days..

    Thanks again for all the comments/advise/kick in the a**e.. Appreciate them all..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,378 ✭✭✭✭jimmycrackcorm


    bellucio wrote: »
    Thanks for all the comments everyone.

    Re the rent.. The only reason I'm paying that is to put a roof over my kids heads. There is no way she could afford the rent on her salary alone.

    But they already have a roof over their heads... You're living there.

    No need to be pandering to here. But basically you're screwed regardless once it goes to a judge.

    The only way to get it of that Mrs is of at that time you don't have a job and can't be forced to pay out.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,635 ✭✭✭FishOnABike


    Are both houses convenient to the children's schools, friends and activities? In my view whatever causes least disruption to the children is best - that might mean them remaining in the family home with you. You need to consider you and your wife's working arrangements and childcare arrangements to figure what new arrangements will work best..



    Your wife has chosen to destroy the family by having an affair and deciding to walk out on the family (both your children and you). If she wants to walk away that's her business but she should not be dragging your children into it - and it appears she is.



    Child benefit is paid to the children's mother by default. It can be assigned to another person - whichever parent the children spend most time with. This is probably why (on advice) that she wants the children with her for four days per week - even though this is taking them from the environment they are familiar with.



    If your children are spending 4 days per week with her and 3 with you there will be a strong argument that she should remain in the family home with them and you should move out to find other accommodation.



    Unfortunately men do not usually fare well in family law if things turn legal. Your wife has certainly been considering this for some time before you discovered. Her actions show signs that she has already received advice, legal or otherwise, to protect her own interests at the expense of the family. I'd make sure you get the best legal advice you can to make sure you are aware of the possible future implications of any decisions no matter how innocent they might now seem.

    She has chosen to walk out. I would be insisting your children remain in the family home but agree an access schedule for her to see them. It is crazy that she essentially expects you to pay to facilitate her actions.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 220 ✭✭mlem123


    I get you wanting to make sure things are OK for the kids, but paying her rent is ridiculous. For your own conscience and for your kids say you will pay for 3 months rent (for example), and after that it is up to herself. Pay what you think is fair for child support then.

    If she complains you can tell her that she could find something smaller or have the kids move in with you while she finds something - I don't see how she's not trying to become a full time worker now that she's on one income (although with you paying rent there's no incentive).

    Glad to hear you're getting legal advice, I'd say she already has seeing that she has found a place to say so quick..

    Keep the focus on the children, but don't let her make a fool of you having her cake and eating it too.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,256 ✭✭✭Ronin247


    You have my sympathy OP.
    A similar thing happened to a friend of mine. He was paying rent and mortgage and has the kids 3 days...... Friday night to Monday morning.
    His ex has the days when they are in school and freedom to have a life at the weekend while he worked all week and minds his kids at the weekend.
    Get a good lawyer even if it costs a fortune because you will be paying one way or another.

    Good luck.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,312 ✭✭✭paw patrol


    OP make sure your solicitor is a family law one . You are wasting your time and money with one who isn't.

    Also pay for the kids expenses only (only part of) do not pay her rent or anything she has.
    the money she gets for the kids off you and the child benefit is hers to manage with now.

    She isn't your concern anymore - let her sort herself out. The fact she earns less than you is her issue not yours.


    And don't take her back either. Go enjoy your life.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 43,028 ✭✭✭✭SEPT 23 1989


    What are you feeling ashamed about?

    your kids will eventually find out the truth about their mother

    Hold your head up


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,213 ✭✭✭utyh2ikcq9z76b


    You should have a long look in the mirror about how pathetic you where trying to work it out, hold on to your dignity, it's all you have left.

    Be strategic if you don't pay the rent for now, she could well throw you out of your home. Angle to have the kids 4 days a week, be the parent who is in charge of getting them dressed/breakfast/dinner getting to school/activities/birthday parties, buy there clothes etc etc then in a year go for full custody and demand maintenance from her


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 Webdoctor


    I hadn't thought about that 4 day 3 day thing

    I remember when I split up with the wife I was doing that 3 day weekend with 3 kids

    Collecting them early Friday while handing over a check and dropping them back Monday on the way to work

    It was exhausting but she used to talk a lot about the law alright so I guess she knew what she was doing.

    You get your freedom though


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,870 ✭✭✭✭Dtp1979


    I’m assuming of the custody is split so both do say 3.5 days each then there should be no maintenance paid to either party?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,213 ✭✭✭utyh2ikcq9z76b


    Dtp1979 wrote: »
    I’m assuming of the custody is split so both do say 3.5 days each then there should be no maintenance paid to either party?

    Doesn't work like that, the court will decide on a primary care giver


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 Webdoctor


    At least one person has to be reasonable for the sake of the children

    If both are reasonable that's great ,in general


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,870 ✭✭✭✭Dtp1979


    Doesn't work like that, the court will decide on a primary care giver

    Based on what?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,211 ✭✭✭✭Suckit


    OP, I had a friend who went through something similar and he asked a few of us to look around for information for him and help where we could.
    I asked around about advice and a solicitor, and one bit of advice that seemed to be mentioned more than once was whatever he was giving her in terms of money and paying for, it would be deemed that he could afford to give her that by the Judge for future.
    So if a Judge see's you are paying her rent and giving her money, it may no longer be your decision to pull the money even if you do find out she is still having an affair with the same guy.
    You should definitely talk to that solicitor on Monday and not pay her rent imho.

    It is a horrible position to be in, and you seem (by your posts) to be handling it much calmer than I think I would be able to. My friend was also fairly calm and I couldn't understand it (he was broken inside though). Now he isn't fond of her at all, she still uses their children as a tool, but he is used to her now, and see's her in a different light.
    He is also doing fairly well on Tinder, but that's another story.


  • Advertisement
  • Posts: 2,077 ✭✭✭ [Deleted User]


    Webdoctor wrote: »
    I hadn't thought about that 4 day 3 day thing

    I remember when I split up with the wife I was doing that 3 day weekend with 3 kids

    Collecting them early Friday while handing over a check and dropping them back Monday on the way to work

    It was exhausting but she used to talk a lot about the law alright so I guess she knew what she was doing.

    You get your freedom though

    Freedom to go out on a Tuesday night? Whoop de doo. That 3.day weekend custody is a joke. The kids are in school during the week. Realistically the 3 day weekend is something like 70% of the active time with your kids at a time when you could meet up with friends for no money.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9 Webdoctor


    Freedom to go out on a Tuesday night? Whoop de doo. That 3.day weekend custody is a joke. The kids are in school during the week. Realistically the 3 day weekend is something like 70% of the active time with your kids at a time when you could meet up with friends for no money.

    I don't do it anymore it wasn't a sustainable way of living at all

    She had the whole weekend to party and all the money flowing in


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,653 ✭✭✭AulWan


    Be aware when calculating the financial split, that once your wife moves out if her earnings are below the cut off she will be able to claim some benefits like Working Family Payment, possibly Back To School Allowance and apply for a medical card. She will most likely claim the Single Person Child Carer tax credit too. All potential extra income to her that she probably won't tell you about, while you're paying her rent. I too would put a strict time limit on that.

    If you have a joint mortgage on the family home, remind her that her moving out does not remove her liability towards the mortgage payments on the family home. She is also liable for at least 50% of any shared debts. She doesn't get to just walk away from that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,635 ✭✭✭FishOnABike


    Suckit wrote: »
    OP, I had a friend who went through something similar and he asked a few of us to look around for information for him and help where we could.
    I asked around about advice and a solicitor, and one bit of advice that seemed to be mentioned more than once was whatever he was giving her in terms of money and paying for, it would be deemed that he could afford to give her that by the Judge for future.
    So if a Judge see's you are paying her rent and giving her money, it may no longer be your decision to pull the money even if you do find out she is still having an affair with the same guy.
    You should definitely talk to that solicitor on Monday and not pay her rent imho.

    It is a horrible position to be in, and you seem (by your posts) to be handling it much calmer than I think I would be able to. My friend was also fairly calm and I couldn't understand it (he was broken inside though). Now he isn't fond of her at all, she still uses their children as a tool, but he is used to her now, and see's her in a different light.
    He is also doing fairly well on Tinder, but that's another story.
    This. Start as you mean to continue. Once something (financial, primary carer, living arrangements, access, etc...) has become established that becomes the norm + the burden of proof will fall on you convincing a court why it should change at a later date.



    Dr. Róisín O'Shea's Thesis on Judicial Separation and Divorce in the Circuit Court is worth reading to get a picture of what it can be like. https://repository.wit.ie/2825/1/thesis_ROS_WITLIB_201405final.pdf Unfortunately it does not paint a pretty picture of our family law system. From personal experience I'd consider it very restrained in its criticism as I've encountered even worse than that criticised in the thesis.



    As a father you will be disadvantaged before you even start. I'd be cautious about doing anything that might disadvantage you any further. Consider what you want longterm for your children and you and work towards that from the beginning.



    Your wife has chosen to do her own thing, there's no reason why you should bend over backwards to facilitate her to the detriment of you, your children and your relationship with them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,357 ✭✭✭Fiona


    When my partner's ex wife done the same and left with the kids he gave her €1,000 towards her deposit and that was it.

    Her choice to leave the family so she needs to put the roof over their head, you just need to assist in maintaining them in terms of electricity clothes and food etc.

    Set your maintenance amt now between you, €75per child would be very generous and start paying it into her bank account from day one.

    She is an adult, she made the decision so SHE needs to figure this out not you, and DO tell people what she done, no shame, don't hide her secret.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,635 ✭✭✭FishOnABike


    Fiona wrote: »
    When my partner's ex wife done the same and left with the kids he gave her €1,000 towards her deposit and that was it.

    Her choice to leave the family so she needs to put the roof over their her own head, you just need to assist in maintaining them in terms of electricity clothes and food etc.

    Set your maintenance amt now between you, €75per child would be very generous and ask her to start paying it into her your bank account from day one.

    She is an adult, she made the decision so SHE needs to figure this out not you, and DO tell people what she done, no shame, don't hide her secret.
    Fixed your post for you. The children have a family home. OP's ex is not considering their children's welfare in removing them from their family home. She cannot expect to have her cake and eat it. If she wants to live her own life she is perfectly entitled to but she has to expect her actions to have consequences.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,357 ✭✭✭Fiona


    Fixed your post for you. The children have a family home. OP's ex is not considering their children's welfare in removing them from their family home. She cannot expect to have her cake and eat it. If she wants to live her own life she is perfectly entitled to but she has to expect her actions to have consequences.

    The children will survive in a new home, children move homes all the time. Once they have their creature comforts, their telly tablets etc and warmth food heat and love they will be fine.

    And most of all two parents who love them, they just happen to live in different houses.

    She has made the decision to leave and she wants a new life for herself so who are we to stop her?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,653 ✭✭✭AulWan


    Given that (a) in this country separation is no fault (so the affair doesn't matter) and (b) the Family courts in overwhelming majority of cases award day-to-day care and control to the mother, there is only one solid reason I can think of why the mother is insisting on uprooting the kids and moving out and not seeking to remain in the family home with them, while asking her husband to leave.

    She plans to continue the affair, and eventually move the new boyfriend in with her, or move in with him, after a suitable period of time, (and he ends things with his wife). This will be a lot easier for her to do in a new place, then in the family home.

    Mark my words.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 861 ✭✭✭tomwaits48


    Fiona wrote: »
    The children will survive in a new home, children move homes all the time. Once they have their creature comforts, their telly tablets etc and warmth food heat and love they will be fine.

    And most of all two parents who love them, they just happen to live in different houses.

    She has made the decision to leave and she wants a new life for herself so who are we to stop her?

    What?!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,357 ✭✭✭Fiona


    tomwaits48 wrote: »
    What?!

    Exactly what I just said. Why should it always be the father who has to leave the family home?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Just coming back to read all the posts here today. Thanks to everyone for your comments. Personally alot of hard things to hear , but the truth hurts .
    I met with solicitor earlier this week. Not going to go into details but there will be a hard conversation and a few home truths spoken to the (ex) wife this weekend.

    As for this - I'm not even going to justify it with a comment....:mad:
    Fiona wrote: »
    The children will survive in a new home, children move homes all the time. Once they have their creature comforts, their telly tablets etc and warmth food heat and love they will be fine.

    And most of all two parents who love them, they just happen to live in different houses.

    She has made the decision to leave and she wants a new life for herself so who are we to stop her?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,357 ✭✭✭Fiona


    bellucio wrote: »
    I have come to the same realization in the last few days myself...
    But I will be dammed if my kids are to raised by them...:mad::mad:

    Well then you better put in an application for full custody and hope you never fall in love with anybody else ever again and want to start a relationship with them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,635 ✭✭✭FishOnABike


    When the dust settles your children will still have two parents. One will be their primary carer and the other will have access, either agreed or court ordered. You will each still be responsible for your children's welfare and they will spend time with each of you. At some stage you may both have someone else in your lives and they will, by association, also play some part in your children's lives.

    You need to decide if you being their primary carer is best and if it is, then take steps to put that in place. There is something to be said for minimising the disruption and your children remaining in a familiar environment in the family home with you rather than being removed to circumstances which may be less stable.

    As far as I see it your wife has put her temporary gratifiction above the longterm welfare of the family. There is no need to make a doormat of yourself to facilitate her in her choice and allow her avoid the natural consequences of her actions.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,378 ✭✭✭✭jimmycrackcorm


    bellucio wrote: »
    Just coming back to read all the posts here today. Thanks to everyone for your comments. Personally alot of hard things to hear , but the truth hurts .
    I met with solicitor earlier this week. Not going to go into details but there will be a hard conversation and a few home truths spoken to the (ex) wife this weekend.

    As for this - I'm not even going to justify it with a comment....:mad:

    You might be justifiably mad but it doesn't change the fact that what is being said is true.

    Kids all over the country live in separate homes with their parents. How well it works is largely down to how both partners treat each other in regards to the kids.

    I should know, I'm in your position having herself behave the same.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 13,439 ✭✭✭✭Purple Mountain


    Well done, OP on taking the steps with the solicitor and the counsellor.
    You sound like a great dad and very mature.
    I wish you sincere luck and your children too.

    To thine own self be true



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Fiona wrote: »
    Well then you better put in an application for full custody and hope you never fall in love with anybody else ever again and want to start a relationship with them.

    I fully intend to live my life and put this past few months behind me. At some stage if that involves falling for somebody else then so be it.
    However falling for someone else & starting a new relationship would not be while I would still be married. THAT is the big difference between me & her.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,357 ✭✭✭Fiona


    bellucio wrote: »
    I fully intend to live my life and put this past few months behind me. At some stage if that involves falling for somebody else then so be it.
    However falling for someone else & starting a new relationship would not be while I would still be married. THAT is the big difference between me & her.

    And that's fine but it will be a while before you are divorced so don't put your life on the line for somebody who didn't consider you first.

    Statistically her new relationship probably won't work out anyway.

    I know my messages might not have been what you want to hear in relation to your children but I am completely in your corner it's a horrible thing to happen to somebody.

    It's ok to put yourself first for a while.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 93 ✭✭bellucio


    Fiona wrote: »
    And that's fine but it will be a while before you are divorced so don't put your life on the line for somebody who didn't consider you first.

    .

    Didnt mean I was going to wait for divorce. I will NOT be putting my life on hold for someone that treated my kids & me this way.
    What I meant was I had no intention of doing this in the way she did - while we still married and living in the family home.


  • Moderators, Category Moderators, Education Moderators Posts: 27,315 CMod ✭✭✭✭spurious


    10 and 7 are very impressionable ages. Please make sure they know they are not to blame for any of this. They almost always think they are.

    Please do not bad mouth their mother in front of them, whether it is true or not. Make sure other relatives toe the line there too.

    Can't advise on the rest of it, but get a solicitor soon.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7 JimFlynn


    Posted this elsewhere but people may no here
    I was together with my former partner for 8 years. We split and remained living in the same house for 18 months, she then left to move in with a lover. I remain in the family home. We were not married and have three young children , access has been 50/50. The house is in positive equity, I’m probably not in a position to buy her out. Her and her partner are in a position to buy me out but I want to keep the house and maybe in a position to buy her out in 18 months time.
    All advice welcome, as in how long would it be for them to get me out?


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,624 ✭✭✭Millionaire only not


    JimFlynn wrote: »
    Posted this elsewhere but people may no here
    I was together with my former partner for 8 years. We split and remained living in the same house for 18 months, she then left to move in with a lover. I remain in the family home. We were not married and have three young children , access has been 50/50. The house is in positive equity, I’m probably not in a position to buy her out. Her and her partner are in a position to buy me out but I want to keep the house and maybe in a position to buy her out in 18 months time.
    All advice welcome, as in how long would it be for them to get me out?

    He was badly stuck to take on a lady with 3 kids !


  • Advertisement
Advertisement