How old is too old to return to study GAMSAT and Grad Med ?

eeinke

Wondering whether my dream of becoming a doctor is for another life. Having family commitments and a mortgage have prevented me from even going there, but this dream doesnt go away.
Are there other courses that would allow me to fulfil a dream of working in a caring environment that maybe do not take up so much time and effort esp with a young family?
Again, what would be the age cut off to go back and study medicine? And whats the quickest way - Grad Med?
Thanking you

What is your background - do you have a 2:1 in a honours degree? What do you think you would like about being a doctor and what type would you like to be? The more information we have the better the advice will be. Also how is your financial situation? The will only give loan for fees now at best.

Celestial12

It’s a personal decision, and I think it depends on what you want to get out of medicine. If you started GEM at 40, you could be finished at 44, and a GP by 49/50 for example. You could then work 20 or so in a profession you’re happy with.

If you haven’t applied for the GAMSAT, then you won’t be able to apply for entry this year.

brendanwalsh

I think 35 would be my cut off. Going to be very hard to do 24 or 36 hour shifts, not to mind working 80-100 hours a week when you're in your 40s with a young family

letsdothis

This is an entirely personal question taking into account your own personal circumstances, drive and commitment. Of course you can take things like stamina into account for long shifts but these aren't as long as they used to be / can be minimised on certain rotations / only have to be for 3 years if you go for GP.

There are plenty of other jobs even within the healthcare which might fulfil you desire for a caring profession. The major difference between many of these roles and being a doctor is much larger focus on problem solving and ultimate decision-making and responsibility for patients.

turningviolet

Hi there, I’m a GEM student and while I’m ‘average’ age, there are plenty of older students that I’ve been in classes/on placements with.

The oldest student in our year is mid forties. A few others are early forties with kids and families. There’s an intern I’ve met that’s about 43 and has a family. Other students in their thirties have had babies during the course and took no time off at all. Others take a year out if they need it and it’s no problem. They’re all excellent students, and they have the work/family balance thing really figured out.

While difficult, it’s totally possible to do. Good luck with whatever you decide!

Sgro

Hi all,

Just wanted to jump on this thread rather than start a new one.

It's encouraging to hear there are some GEM students in their forties - I am still a relatively recent grad in my mid 20s but feel kind of silly considering GEM.

I have a good job in the finance sector that pays well and allows me a good work/life balance, however I don't find the work incredibly fulfilling and the prospect of a big salary or material gain as the measure of success doesn't really get me going I have found. I have been considering med in the back of my head for a long time now and as I am getting older (although mid 20s is still young!) I decided I would rather try than wonder 'what if?' years down the road. I have aired my thoughts with some close family members and friends and some of them think I would be mad to give up my current job but as said above it's just not what my idea of success is.

I've always enjoyed helping others and volunteering etc., and have always had an interest in science and the body.

Would anyone have any advice for how you knew GEM was 100% what you wanted to do? I feel I do strongly want to do it, but if I pursue it then I will realistically be 29/30 by the time I start working as a doctor and my 20s will be long behind me, and I would also hate to put all them years into it only to find I'm not good at it.

I've started studying to sit in September and still intend to go through with it but would be curious to hear your thoughts. What are some questions I should consider/you considered before deciding to pursue GEM?

Thanks

che oh

If you want to do it then do it- I started GEMS last September aged 35 with a 2 year old and a 6 month old- I have no science background and I have no money- But I’m there and I love it-If you think you’ll regret not doing it then give it a go and sure if it doesn’t work out that’s fine too

brendanwalsh

I would not recommend medicine to anyone over the age of 30, even less so if you already have a decent career and decent wage. Intern starting salary is something like 34 k.

You can make more money but you will seriously work for it. You won't be long getting sick of 100 hour weeks, 24 + hour shifts, these things are even harder as you get older.

A colleague of mine did grad Med, in his late forties now, has a wife and kids and is literally living hand to mouth each week due to the burden of debt on him of circa >100k. Not to mention he hasn't even started paying off the principle.

Gp was an option back in the day but is now a minefield, you only need to have a quick look on twitter to see the impending gp crisis that is coming.

If you insist on doing this be prepared you will have to emigrate to make money and get trained properly. The training in this country is appalling. It's essentially third world training.

che oh

Well aren't you a rainbow Brendan. Let me firstly say that you are wrong and I know this because one is always wrong when comparing the individual to the collective. You used relatively punchy paragraphs to be negative so in the interest of fluidity I'll address them succinctly. The money one - money goes up - not everyone is in this for money. The hours etc - you enjoy recounting media headlines when typing. Your friend with the debt one - People do have debt and some people have a lot of debt therefore point taken with regards to your friend, but refer back to the second line please. The GP one - There will be increased opportunity for GPs in the coming years. There are others types of doctors too. And finally the third world training one - Nope Training here is good.

Look if you want to do medicine (regardless of age) then do it. It's really interesting and enjoyable from an educational perspective. If you do it and don't like it, or it doesn't suit you then just do something else. No drama, at least you tried.

brendanwalsh

che oh wrote: »

Well aren't you a rainbow Brendan. Let me firstly say that you are wrong and I know this because one is always wrong when comparing the individual to the collective. You used relatively punchy paragraphs to be negative so in the interest of fluidity I'll address them succinctly. The money one - money goes up - not everyone is in this for money. The hours etc - you enjoy recounting media headlines when typing. Your friend with the debt one - People do have debt and some people have a lot of debt therefore point taken with regards to your friend, but refer back to the second line please. The GP one - There will be increased opportunity for GPs in the coming years. There are others types of doctors too. And finally the third world training one - Nope Training here is good.

Look if you want to do medicine (regardless of age) then do it. It's really interesting and enjoyable from an educational perspective. If you do it and don't like it, or it doesn't suit you then just do something else. No drama, at least you tried.

Spoken like a true first year medical student! Glad you still have some ideals left. Wait till the bank of ireland have a boot on your neck 364 days of the year to get their thirty pieces.

I'd keep your opinions on training to yourself until you have actually worked as a doctor. The amount of scut work is horrendous, and the dedicated teaching minimal.

You'll find plenty doctors in this country doing Canulation, phlebotomy, catheterisation and even portering patients even at spr level.

Ariana Grande

che oh wrote: »

Well aren't you a rainbow Brendan. Let me firstly say that you are wrong and I know this because one is always wrong when comparing the individual to the collective. You used relatively punchy paragraphs to be negative so in the interest of fluidity I'll address them succinctly. The money one - money goes up - not everyone is in this for money. The hours etc - you enjoy recounting media headlines when typing. Your friend with the debt one - People do have debt and some people have a lot of debt therefore point taken with regards to your friend, but refer back to the second line please. The GP one - There will be increased opportunity for GPs in the coming years. There are others types of doctors too. And finally the third world training one - Nope Training here is good.

Look if you want to do medicine (regardless of age) then do it. It's really interesting and enjoyable from an educational perspective. If you do it and don't like it, or it doesn't suit you then just do something else. No drama, at least you tried.

True. Everyone's background is different. Brendan seems to be only speaking on behalf of himself and his "friend" as if he was speaking for every person. It's also not the first time he's done this iirc.

che oh

Indeed spoken like a first year medical student. A student who researched extensively from doctors at varying levels and varying fields before making a decision. I have close friends who recently went through intern, SHO, etc. I also know some GPs very well and spoke to them. Further to this I spoke to consultants in different fields. All of them spoke very highly of their jobs. Granted they did say this and that about things that aren't perfect, but nothing is really. They also spoke of hard work, dedication, and the emotional side of the job, but none of them regret becoming doctors (I asked them this specifically).

"You'll find plenty doctors in this country doing Canulation, phlebotomy, catheterisation and even portering patients even at spr level."

My god, the horror at having to porter a patient!!

Do you not think Brendan, that negativity outside the parameters of pragmatic discussion is a bad thing.

I was going to ask you if you were a doctor, but it doesn't really matter. This thread is about someone querying whether to do Grad med or not, and I genuinely don't think you are helpful.

brendanwalsh

che oh wrote: »

Indeed spoken like a first year medical student. A student who researched extensively from doctors at varying levels and varying fields before making a decision. I have close friends who recently went through intern, SHO, etc. I also know some GPs very well and spoke to them. Further to this I spoke to consultants in different fields. All of them spoke very highly of their jobs. Granted they did say this and that about things that aren't perfect, but nothing is really. They also spoke of hard work, dedication, and the emotional side of the job, but none of them regret becoming doctors (I asked them this specifically).

"You'll find plenty doctors in this country doing Canulation, phlebotomy, catheterisation and even portering patients even at spr level."

My god, the horror at having to porter a patient!!

Do you not think Brendan, that negativity outside the parameters of pragmatic discussion is a bad thing.

I was going to ask you if you were a doctor, but it doesn't really matter. This thread is about someone querying whether to do Grad med or not, and I genuinely don't think you are helpful.

If you think it's appropriate for trainee doctors to porter patients, then your probably the wrong person to have a discussion with about training in this country.

Keep singing from the hymn sheet in the front row of the church choir, the hse needs brain dead warm bodies to keep their slave trade alive.

Even if anyone on this thread disagrees with me, the gentleman asked if it's worth going back to be a doctor. He should be aware of the reality of it. Fair enough if most of you enjoy Catheterisation and Canulation, however in any other developed country this is not the job of awareness doctor. Doctors doing these tasks would be considered laughable in North America. In ireland you have to train to be a nurse and a doctor at the same time

Sgro

brendanwalsh wrote: »

I would not recommend medicine to anyone over the age of 30, even less so if you already have a decent career and decent wage. Intern starting salary is something like 34 k.

You can make more money but you will seriously work for it. You won't be long getting sick of 100 hour weeks, 24 + hour shifts, these things are even harder as you get older.

A colleague of mine did grad Med, in his late forties now, has a wife and kids and is literally living hand to mouth each week due to the burden of debt on him of circa >100k. Not to mention he hasn't even started paying off the principle.

Gp was an option back in the day but is now a minefield, you only need to have a quick look on twitter to see the impending gp crisis that is coming.

If you insist on doing this be prepared you will have to emigrate to make money and get trained properly. The training in this country is appalling. It's essentially third world training.

Interesting take. Are you a doctor yourself? Did you do grad med route?

>100k seems a lot of debt if studying in Ireland? Did your friend study abroad?

Where would you say has the best options for emigrating?

Sgro

Sgro wrote: »

Interesting take. Are you a doctor yourself? Did you do grad med route?

>100k seems a lot of debt if studying in Ireland? Did your friend study abroad?

Where would you say has the best options for emigrating?

Gradmed costs this between fees and living expenses if you look it up. Banks used to give this all in a loan hence people with huge debts.

letsdothis

brendanwalsh wrote: »

If you think it's appropriate for trainee doctors to porter patients, then your probably the wrong person to have a discussion with about training in this country.

Brendan, if you think it's all about the money, prestige and avoiding 'scut work', you really should have researched medicine yourself before rushing into it because it clearly doesn't suit you.

brendanwalsh

letsdothis wrote: »

Brendan, if you think it's all about the money, prestige and avoiding 'scut work', you really should have researched medicine yourself before rushing into it because it clearly doesn't suit you.

Interesting you haven't argued any of my points.

Why are nchd doing non medical tasks like portering, phlebotomy, Canulation, changing patients, bladder scans etc?

Do you think these tasks are appropriate training?

Do you think Irish training is the same standard as north American?

supraspinaswim

Have to admit, some of whats been said here is amusing. Im a final year med student (grad entry via UL) am 26 and will finish in a month with 64k in debt from paying the fees.

Firstly, in addressing the cannulation, catheters etc, yes some of that is expected as a doctor, we arent trained in this stuff to completely ditch it once we hit the wards. Interns Ive worked with have been responsible for cannuation and venepuncture, putting in catheters. Nurses do have an input on some of those roles too, Ive met nurses in ED that were fantastic at those skills and could put doctors to shame, but its where the needs arise. Theres no shame in doing these tasks just because we are doctors, thats ludicrous. That sort of mentality fuels the lofty attitudes held by some that because as doctors we are better than that. Admittedly, the jobs nurses have to do are broad, some less pleasant than others and some I would not like to do, but if they need help, Im not going to shy away just because I ve got three degrees after my name and a huge debt. Arrogance like that just breeds an equal response back by staff on the wards.

Secondly, the comparison of training in the US to Ireland is just frustrating. I get that people can train as surgeon in under 5 yrs in the US but they are different systems, and regardless, as an SpR said to me, experience is what counts. So while our system is not the best, its not producing incompetent doctors (Im hopefully one of that cohort in a few months), I find that insulting to those of us that are in the system as it undermines our capacity and training. Opinions may exist, but if you dont have evidence to susbtantiate those wild claims, then its just mere conjecture.

As for going back to college and doing medicine GEMS style, its not easy and please dont be fooled by it. However it is pretty cool to study the stuff we cover, the skills we develop and then hit hospitals (at UL in third year) and join surgeries, clinics or assist in A&E. Its possible, but weigh up the capacity to afford it, as Ive had significant help from my family and wouldnt be here without that. Its all fine studying hard and achieving grades but financing it is also a reality.

Celestial12

Brendan what career stage are you at, and what type of doctor are you, if you don't mind me asking please?

I think you're entitled to your own opinion and appreciate your experiences - but it doesn't put me off this path. All going well, I'll be starting GEM this September. Even if working for the HSE turns out to be a nightmare, I think you regret the things you didn't do more than the things you did. I'm hoping it will be a good decision for me, and a fulfilling career.

Rodin

I'm looking out of healthcare never mind trying to get in.

Wesser

Is not the training in gem is the issue.

It's the gruelling long long hours that follow it. Its the 36 hours + without breaks for food and i remember not even having the time to go to the toilet. Nobody minds doing cannulation etc but when your tasks are piling up +++++ and you can't get around to seein g sick patients because you have so many cannula to insert. So your actually not using th e skills that you trained in because you spend all your time puttijng in cannulas. I remember having like 20 patients waiting for cannulas and each having to wait hours for fluids or antibiotics. Its having 50 sick patients on your list and all their worried families and dealing th e chaos that follows that. Its dealing with totally inadequate work spaces and facilities and your patients not getting the tests they need and having to constantly go down to the radiology dept to beg for scans for your patients . Starting work at 7am on a Monday and finishing at 9pm on a Tuesday. Getting lambasted by the media.
Dealing with angry patient who have no understanding of the above and start shouting at you for things that you can't control.

The universuty bit is the fun bit!!!!

thomasdylan

letsdothis wrote: »

Brendan, if you think it's all about the money, prestige and avoiding 'scut work', you really should have researched medicine yourself before rushing into it because it clearly doesn't suit you.

I can only imagine your not qualified yet. It's easy to have opinions like that in college. I'm non-GEM at Reg level. When your on call covering an ED and wards in some peripheral hospital on a 24 hour shift you'll have a different opinion. You'll get bleeped to put a cannula in or do a repeat trop or first dose antibiotics when you're drowning in ED and the nurses have more than enough staff and time but aren't trained or aren't engaging with handover of tasks. And it's an absolute misuse of skills to have a doctor porter a patient.

I think anyone signing up for GEM needs to understand the reality of working in the HSE. You'll have a loan that I imagine will take 10-12 years to pay back. If you want kids you'll have to hope that you get rotations in the same place and don't get shipped around the place. If you're hoping to jump straight to GP scheme from Intern you probably won't. GP applications doubled last year with loads of people having completed BST as competitive applicants.

brendanwalsh

Thanks for other doctors posting here to give a better reflection of working in this country.

Lot of idealistic pre medicine or medicine students posting, trying to drown me out. I too had ideals as a medical student. You will be quick abandoning your ideal to save the world when you're working a 48 hour weekend shift in a peripheral hospital.

Working conditions in this country are truly appalling;training just as bad.

The amount of doctors who are planning to emigrate or leave medicine entirely is rising.

I know multiple grad med students who regret their chosen path. I know others who are leaving medicine altogether. I also know of people who are pinned so tight to the collar that they cannot afford to take appalling hse contracts and have to do long term locum just to keep their head above water.

100k debt is a lifetime of servitude. Easy to think you'll clear the debt and save every penny. Try paying off a loan of over a 1000 quid a month while taking home 2000 a month and living in dublin. It's hand to mouth for a lot of doctors and that's a harsh reality. Wait till your pals start saying "you must be loaded sure, you're a doctor".

There are finance and comp science grads coming out of college and getting bigger starting contracts that hse interns and will make more money faster too.

Medicine is no longer a career for the privileged. It's a career for the dumb. It's an intellectual death, financial ruin and an insurmountable cost to your personal life.

Back at the ranch, I've just finished a 24 hour shift this morning, and have another 24 hour shift to look forward to this easter sunday. And they say the crucifixion only happened once.

Avatar MIA

2,000 a month take home as a reg? Is the HSE that bad?

My experience is in the private sector and an RMO (never mind a reg) would be on low 6 figures with little OT. And they'd have a relatively cushy number.

The consultants are in a different league and in some specialties can work significantly beyond 65 without much effort.

So, it's not that working as a doctor is a bad career choice, you just need to make the most of it and progress.

thomasdylan

Avatar MIA wrote: »

2,000 a moth take home as a reg? Is the HSE that bad?

My experience is in the private sector and an RMO (never mind a reg) would be on low 6 figures with little OT. And they'd have a relatively cushy number.

The consultants are in a different league and in some specialties can work significantly beyond 65 without much effort.

So, it's not that working as a doctor is a bad career choice, you just need to make the most of it and progress.

Take home for a Spr should be 3.3k plus a month anyway I think A fair bit less for a Reg.

RMO isnt a job you'd want to be doing for a long time. It's not a job title they have in public hospitals. It's a bit of a dead end, doesn't look great to be doing it for a long time in my opinion. I'm surprised the pay is so good, you can get an RMO job after intern year sometimes.

Avatar MIA

thomasdylan wrote: »

Take home for a Spr should be 3.3k plus a month anyway I think A fair bit less for a Reg.

That's surprising, approx. €60k before tax. But I suppose it's still a "training" role with a good pay off at the end.

Does anyone know what the approx. breakdown is for someone qualifying with their degree? How many go on to become GPs, Reg's or Consultants as their destination level? How many Reg's remain at that level and how many go on to be consultants. Some peak at Reg level, which is no mean feat.

thomasdylan

Avatar MIA wrote: »

That's surprising, approx. €60k before tax. But I suppose it's still a "training" role with a good pay off at the end.

Does anyone know what the approx. breakdown is for someone qualifying with their degree? How many go on to become GPs, Reg's or Consultants as their destination level? How many Reg's remain at that level and how many go on to be consultants. Some peak at Reg level, which is no mean feat.

I was old once 2 percent of every graduating less will go on to be a consultant here. That could be completely wrong though.

PhoneMain

brendanwalsh wrote: »

Thanks for other doctors posting here to give a better reflection of working in this country.

Lot of idealistic pre medicine or medicine students posting, trying to drown me out. I too had ideals as a medical student. You will be quick abandoning your ideal to save the world when you're working a 48 hour weekend shift in a peripheral hospital.

Working conditions in this country are truly appalling;training just as bad.

The amount of doctors who are planning to emigrate or leave medicine entirely is rising.

I know multiple grad med students who regret their chosen path. I know others who are leaving medicine altogether. I also know of people who are pinned so tight to the collar that they cannot afford to take appalling hse contracts and have to do long term locum just to keep their head above water.

100k debt is a lifetime of servitude. Easy to think you'll clear the debt and save every penny. Try paying off a loan of over a 1000 quid a month while taking home 2000 a month and living in dublin. It's hand to mouth for a lot of doctors and that's a harsh reality. Wait till your pals start saying "you must be loaded sure, you're a doctor".

There are finance and comp science grads coming out of college and getting bigger starting contracts that hse interns and will make more money faster too.

Medicine is no longer a career for the privileged. It's a career for the dumb. It's an intellectual death, financial ruin and an insurmountable cost to your personal life.

Back at the ranch, I've just finished a 24 hour shift this morning, and have another 24 hour shift to look forward to this easter sunday. And they say the crucifixion only happened once.

Just going to address some of the points made here for some perspective.

I'm currently an intern in a large teaching hospital working in surgery having worked in medicine in a peripheral hospital up to January.

I previously worked in finance and have lots of friends who work in finance. While some of them may be making great money, they have to do big hours. A couple of my friends now work as managers and often have to work in excess of 12 hour days and occasionally at the weekend, for which they do not receive time in lieu or overtime. I also worked in finance for 3.5 years and I got more money starting as an intern than I did at the end of my 3.5 years in finance. I keep a good eye on my pay slips and if there's any issues with missed overtime, its always remidied in the next payslip.

I loved my time working in the peripheral hospital. While I did have to do a lot of cannulation, phlebotomy and urinary catherisation, my whole day wasn't taken up with this sort of work. I never had to do any portering work. I've been in the larger hospital now and only once had to porter a patient and that was to make it easier for the reg. The SHO's and Reg's on the team get great training and I have NEVER ONCE seen them doing cannulation, phlebotomy or portering while I've been working at them. 1 Reg admitted that I'm far more experienced at cannulation than her. They spend their days seeing patients in clinic or upskilling in this particular surgical field. We have journal clubs where they get good teaching from consultants and the consultants are very keen for them to learn.

I've worked 1 set of nights this rotation, 3 saturdays and no sundays and finish nearly every evening at 6 latest (which I don't mind as I'm paid this in overtime!).

Most of my intern year are probably going emigrating to Australia but that's because they're mostly 24/25 and it's a rite of passage at this stage, definitely not because they hate their work. I must reitterate this, I have not been talking to 1 intern who hates their work, they might hate particular rotations their on because some are definitely worse than others but I know noone who has hated all 3 rotations!!

I know noone who regrets their chosen career route. I have got onto the GP training scheme for next year and any interns I know who applied for it got it also. The ICGP are more open to those who pursue GP as their first career path over those who pursued some other hospital career first.

As I said, I love my job, I've absolutely no regrets about pursuing this career and if you have the supports to go through GEM, I'd highly recommend it! A helpful family and a very understanding partner are key!

supraspinaswim

brendanwalsh wrote: »

Thanks for other doctors posting here to give a better reflection of working in this country.

Lot of idealistic pre medicine or medicine students posting, trying to drown me out. I too had ideals as a medical student. You will be quick abandoning your ideal to save the world when you're working a 48 hour weekend shift in a peripheral hospital.

Working conditions in this country are truly appalling;training just as bad.

The amount of doctors who are planning to emigrate or leave medicine entirely is rising.

I know multiple grad med students who regret their chosen path. I know others who are leaving medicine altogether. I also know of people who are pinned so tight to the collar that they cannot afford to take appalling hse contracts and have to do long term locum just to keep their head above water.

100k debt is a lifetime of servitude. Easy to think you'll clear the debt and save every penny. Try paying off a loan of over a 1000 quid a month while taking home 2000 a month and living in dublin. It's hand to mouth for a lot of doctors and that's a harsh reality. Wait till your pals start saying "you must be loaded sure, you're a doctor".

There are finance and comp science grads coming out of college and getting bigger starting contracts that hse interns and will make more money faster too.

Medicine is no longer a career for the privileged. It's a career for the dumb. It's an intellectual death, financial ruin and an insurmountable cost to your personal life.

Back at the ranch, I've just finished a 24 hour shift this morning, and have another 24 hour shift to look forward to this easter sunday. And they say the crucifixion only happened once.

Hey Im not trying to drown out someones opinion far from it, and yes its easy to state things as a med student (its easier to toe the line of " I is only a med student, I know nothing" a line a consultant I had used often ). The only point I was making is that having the skills is crucial, espec when theres no else bothered or able to do it. ive seen it in ED with nurses not trained in doing ECGs (wtf, we do them in first year and theres no training course on it). One particular midlands hosp is known, from my experiences of first doses etc, Im aware that July is going to be an eye opener, Im just trying to see both sides.

letsdothis

I think some of the comments above from current doctors are slightly condescending towards GEMS / potential GEMS, whether they mean to be or not. Do you think intelligent people with existing good quality degrees just jump into medicine and the related debt, personal and family sacrifice without full consideration of what that involves, phlebotomy and all? As others have said, there are plenty of other professions where you are required to work long hours, often doing monotonous or menial tasks too - medicine doesn't have exclusivity on that. What medicine probably does have almost exclusivity on is an attitude of superiority and expectation because you probably excelled in your leaving cert and came from a wealthy family. I could have made my money by now with my primary degree if I was that way inclined. However, like many other students and doctors I know, we have chosen an incredibly privileged career path because of a sense of public service rather a desire to chase cash. I'll come back in a year's time to this forum to post my experience as an intern to see if this attitude changes but I'm certain it won't.

While I fully appreciate the frustrations of some doctors (including those above), I think the voice of the disgruntled few is most prominent online and doesn't really reflect my own experience of colleagues, who by in large say that they love their jobs. I think this is important for those considering GEM to hear because they'll already have considered all the negatives by now.

thomasdylan

[PHP][/PHP]

letsdothis wrote: »

I think some of the comments above from current doctors are slightly condescending towards GEMS / potential GEMS, whether they mean to be or not. Do you think intelligent people with existing good quality degrees just jump into medicine and the related debt, personal and family sacrifice without full consideration of what that involves, phlebotomy and all? As others have said, there are plenty of other professions where you are required to work long hours, often doing monotonous or menial tasks too - medicine doesn't have exclusivity on that. What medicine probably does have almost exclusivity on is an attitude of superiority and expectation because you probably excelled in your leaving cert and came from a wealthy family. I could have made my money by now with my primary degree if I was that way inclined. However, like many other students and doctors I know, we have chosen an incredibly privileged career path because of a sense of public service rather a desire to chase cash. I'll come back in a year's time to this forum to post my experience as an intern to see if this attitude changes but I'm certain it won't.

While I fully appreciate the frustrations of some doctors (including those above), I think the voice of the disgruntled few is most prominent online and doesn't really reflect my own experience of colleagues, who by in large say that they love their jobs. I think this is important for those considering GEM to hear because they'll already have considered all the negatives by now.

I think the most condescending thing that has been said in this thread has been you telling someone they should have done more research as they clearly weren't suited to medicine.

Medicine is a tough and rewarding career. But I think the GEM loan is huge considering payscales. I cant imagine it can be paid back in less than 8-10 years. Having said that you will never be unemployed.

letsdothis

thomasdylan wrote: »

[PHP][/PHP]


I think the most condescending thing that has been said in this thread has been you telling someone they should have done more research as they clearly weren't suited to medicine.

Do you think so? You're clearly blinkered to any posts that don't reinforce your own views, then. We've been told in numerous posts in numerous treads by brendanwalsh how awful medicine is in Ireland and how naive we all are for rushing into it; my comment was in response to that.

In relation to the debt, would you rather pay 700 a month for 10 years to do something you love, or be miserable for the rest of your life in an unsatisfactory job, regretting never going for medicine? Because these are the choices that GEM students have made before taking it on.

thomasdylan

letsdothis wrote: »

Do you think so? You're clearly blinkered to any posts that don't reinforce your own views, then. We've been told in numerous posts in numerous treads by brendanwalsh how awful medicine is in Ireland and how naive we all are for rushing into it; my comment was in response to that.

In relation to the debt, would you rather pay 700 a month for 10 years to do something you love, or be miserable for the rest of your life in an unsatisfactory job, regretting never going for medicine? Because these are the choices that GEM students have made before taking it on.

I don't think I'm blinkered at all. It shouldn't be an echo chamber here.

You said someone was unsuited to do their job. That's a hugely insulting thing to say to anyone.

I don't think GEM is a particularly bad choice for anyone. You'll never be unemployed. What I think it's important to say is that medicine can require big sacrifices. It's easier to make those sacrifices when you don't have children or a mortgage and are tied yo one place. The older you are the more difficult those things become. Pretty much all yhe schemes will send you round a province.

Pierre_Robin

To answer the original question: it depends.

If you want to be a plastic surgeon, it's earlier, if you want to be a GP, it's later.

I've worked for bosses who came back to do medicine at a later age, or indeed did a lot of training in one are and then moved specialty. They are outliers though, and the majority of your colleagues will be doing medicine as their first job from the age of 24/25.

I'd advise talking to people currently working in Ireland. I'm a GEM working at the SpR level. I've made my feelings about working in Ireland very clear in previous threads so won't go into it in as much detail here. I can only speak from experience, but I love my job. I have plenty of friends who love their jobs. Similarly, I know far too many doctors, both scheme and off-scheme who are unhappy. As others have pointed out, do your research before you commit to anything.

Just to add another data point. My take home with OT (all of it paid - and in a peripheral :pac::pac::pac:) is approx 3.6 - 3.8k a month depending on how many Saturdays I've worked.

Avatar MIA

Pierre_Robin wrote: »

Just to add another data point. My take home with OT (all of it paid - and in a peripheral :pac::pac::pac:) is approx 3.6 - 3.8k a month depending on how many Saturdays I've worked.

That's significantly better than Joe Soap. And with the possibility of significant further career advancement. Most people wont come near your current basic salary, even at the end of their careers.

As for a €100k loan, as a Cost Benefit Analysis, it's a very good investment.

Avatar MIA

Avatar MIA wrote: »

That's significantly better than Joe Soap. And with the possibility of significant further career advancement. Most people wont come near your current basic salary, even at the end of their careers.

As for a €100k loan, as a Cost Benefit Analysis, it's a very good investment.

I earn 3k net a month as a teacher so I’m surprised that this is the wage I would expect a doctor would have been on more (even at beginning of their career). It would be difficult to pay a mortgage and a loan for GEM on that to be fair. Thank you for the information it’s great to see reality of being a doctor starting out in Ireland.

Edit: sorry this is supposed to be in reply to Pierre_Robin 😊

brendanwalsh

Avatar MIA wrote: »

That's significantly better than Joe Soap. And with the possibility of significant further career advancement. Most people wont come near your current basic salary, even at the end of their careers.

As for a €100k loan, as a Cost Benefit Analysis, it's a very good investment.

Did you do this cost benefit analysis in your head ?

100k loan is a very bad investment.
It will be the guts of 130 to 150k in total depending on how far out you stretch the repayments. This doesn't account for the opportunity cost of working for the four years in college and the opportunity cost of earning a lower salary for your first few years as a nchd than you would have earned if in a senior position in your old job. Obviously if you worked in spar you won't have been on much but if you were an actuary or pharmacist you could expect 6 figures.

Let's not start on the time value of money or the inflation rate when paying back your money. Hse salaries don't rise in concordance with same.

There are easier ways of earning 6 or 7 hundred quid a week.

As example above the teacher with 4.5 months holidays per year on the same wage as a spr working 90 hours a week.

Pierre_Robin

brendanwalsh wrote: »

As example above the teacher with 4.5 months holidays per year on the same wage as a spr working 90 hours a week.

I don't work 90 hours a week. I used to, but not anymore. I'm in a busy specialty as well. If I did, my estimate of my take home is closer to 4.5k.

Pension is also quite good, and guaranteed as well. I'm not in finance, but I think it's called a defined benefit pension and is not the norm.

We should be paid more, agreed. I'm not skint though, and haven't done a catheter in aaaaaaaaages!

Pierre_Robin

[Deleted User] wrote: »

I earn 3k net a month as a teacher so I’m surprised that this is the wage I would expect a doctor would have been on more (even at beginning of their career). It would be difficult to pay a mortgage and a loan for GEM on that to be fair. Thank you for the information it’s great to see reality of being a doctor starting out in Ireland.

Edit: sorry this is supposed to be in reply to Pierre_Robin 😊

Not that difficult to pay to be honest, maybe I don't have an otherwise expensive life?

I'm surprised at 3k a month as a teacher, I imagine you're relatively senior? From my reading of the paper I thought teachers earned feck all.

Doctors aren't as well paid as the rte news makes out, not nchds at least. Consultants with private practice are another story.

Pierre_Robin

Pierre_Robin wrote: »

Not that difficult to pay to be honest, maybe I don't have an otherwise expensive life?

I'm surprised at 3k a month as a teacher, I imagine you're relatively senior? From my reading of the paper I thought teachers earned feck all.

Doctors aren't as well paid as the rte news makes out, not nchds at least. Consultants with private practice are another story.

8 years teaching and I do after school club 2 evenings and grinds 2 evenings. I would work say 9-3 every day and then an extra 2 hours two evenings (homework club) and 1 hour (for the grinds) 2 evenings. I do one week summer camp also and July Provision. I wouldn’t say it’s great money but definitely a good income that’s why I was surprised at a doctors take home feel lucky now. Without the extras (see above for all the nixers which add up it would be a lot lower). A year or two ago I was struggling so added in all them bits of extra work and made a good improvement in my take home. We have a mortgage on a big enough house and are relatively frugal and I still would find it next to impossible if I had a big loan to pay - I considered medicine myself this is why this thread is of particular interest to me. It’s not all about the money though and it’s not 100% ruled out in my mind yet as I see medicine as a really worthwhile intellectually demanding job.

Edit: younger teachers are on feck all and I will strike with them when the time comes - don’t think this is the norm I just came out at a better time than them.

Pierre_Robin

[Deleted User] wrote: »

8 years teaching and I do after school club 2 evenings and grinds 2 evenings. I would work say 9-3 every day and then an extra 2 hours two evenings (homework club) and 1 hour (for the grinds) 2 evenings. I do one week summer camp also and July Provision. I wouldn’t say it’s great money but definitely a good income that’s why I was surprised at a doctors take home feel lucky now. Without the extras (see above for all the nixers which add up it would be a lot lower). A year or two ago I was struggling so added in all them bits of extra work and made a good improvement in my take home. We have a mortgage on a big enough house and are relatively frugal and I still would find it next to impossible if I had a big loan to pay - I considered medicine myself this is why this thread is of particular interest to me. It’s not all about the money though and it’s not 100% ruled out in my mind yet as I see medicine as a really worthwhile intellectually demanding job.

Edit: younger teachers are on feck all and I will strike with them when the time comes - don’t think this is the norm I just came out at a better time than them.

Ah that makes sense. Especially with the nixers. Fair play for doing the extra work!

Medicine isn't that intellectually demanding, it's mostly rote learning and pattern recognition.

Pierre_Robin

Pierre_Robin wrote: »

Ah that makes sense. Especially with the nixers. Fair play for doing the extra work!

Medicine isn't that intellectually demanding, it's mostly rote learning and pattern recognition.

Thanks it’s made me enjoy my career a lot more as I have a much more comfortable lifestyle. Very tough few years at the beginning and I feel really bad for our younger colleagues. It’s hard to enjoy a career when you don’t feel you are making a good living from it. I always (assumed I suppose!) that medicine would be intellectually demanding that’s what had me thinking it would be a lovely career.

m5ex9oqjawdg2i

Never OP, age is but a number, don't let that restrict you.

Avatar MIA

Pierre_Robin wrote: »

Ah that makes sense. Especially with the nixers. Fair play for doing the extra work!

Medicine isn't that intellectually demanding, it's mostly rote learning and pattern recognition.

Is the profession going to morph into Dr Google ?

Pierre_Robin

Avatar MIA wrote: »

Is the profession going to morph into Dr Google ?

I'm not quite sure what you mean.

There's some exciting stuff being done with machine learning and diagnostic radiology, though it's a while off replacing radiologists.

I probably simplified what I meant by pattern recognition. A lot of medicine is having seen a similar case previously, or perhaps more correctly, having seen tons of one type of presentation and so recognising the subtle difference in a new case. Or at least I've found that.

Katiecoffey555

I am selling Gold Standard GAMSAT books if you are interested in taking it. My dad did GRADMED when he was 37 and never looked back. Go for it

Sgro

Katiecoffey555 wrote: »

I am selling Gold Standard GAMSAT books if you are interested in taking it. My dad did GRADMED when he was 37 and never looked back. Go for it

37 fairplay!

I'm currently in the midst of studying and grappling with doubting myself - could you tell us a bit more about your Dad? What was his career before, is he still working as a Doctor now?
Could use a good motivational story tbh

APower79

che oh wrote: »

If you want to do it then do it- I started GEMS last September aged 35 with a 2 year old and a 6 month old- I have no science background and I have no money- But I’m there and I love it-If you think you’ll regret not doing it then give it a go and sure if it doesn’t work out that’s fine too

Well done you! I’m 39 with young kids and would really love to do it. Am I crazy though?! I think those around me would say I am. But I think I will regret it if I don’t try

milhous

APower79 wrote: »

Well done you! I’m 39 with young kids and would really love to do it. Am I crazy though?! I think those around me would say I am. But I think I will regret it if I don’t try

Early thirties, science degree. Thought about going back, but looked at the costs and decided against it. I'm not inherently a good person who just wants to help people, whilst it would be a perk I'd really be in it for the money. Going without my salary for 4 years, plus the 15k a year fees and living expenses..

I would recoup it eventually (even though Drs are not outreagously well paid at a lot of levels), however by intern year I'd be midthirties, another 10years of nchd posts that are manic.. I'd miss a large part of my kids early years and end up working myself to ****.. wish I had the sense to do it 10years ago though

brendanwalsh

milhous wrote: »

Early thirties, science degree. Thought about going back, but looked at the costs and decided against it. I'm not inherently a good person who just wants to help people, whilst it would be a perk I'd really be in it for the money. Going without my salary for 4 years, plus the 15k a year fees and living expenses..

I would recoup it eventually (even though Drs are not outreagously well paid at a lot of levels), however by intern year I'd be midthirties, another 10years of nchd posts that are manic.. I'd miss a large part of my kids early years and end up working myself to ****.. wish I had the sense to do it 10years ago though

Honestly, you made the right choice. Medicine is just a job, with a sh1t salary and horrible work life balance. You lose the best years of your life working for a company that knifes you in the back at every chance they can. Medicine in this country is dead. It's emigration or leave clinical medicine for most people. Our system is propped up by doctors from 3rd world countries but even they are starting to fight back.