Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Is my Routine Good / Bad?

  • 30-08-2017 1:32pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭


    So, I have been self educating myself, getting back into the gym after 7 years out! I have been going to the gym for the past 3-4 weeks, easing myself back into it. I have read so much about, 'how many times should you train X muscle', and 'what are the best muscles to train together'...etc
    My problem is, that in order to work each muscle group twice, I need to go at least one day on the weekend. But I am not always able to go on the weekends.

    The reason for my choice in muscle groups, was from an article which talked about how it is good to train opposite muscle groups so that you can work them more. As in, when you work Chest & Triceps, your triceps are fatigued after Chest, therefore do Chest and then Biceps. And then 2 days later do Back & Triceps.

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Rest day / Cardio
    Wednesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Thursday
    Rest day / Cardio
    Friday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Back & Triceps
    So as you can see, I'd rather not have to do main muscles on the Sunday. But a rest day after each is essential for muscle healing. What adjustments can I make? Are the rest days between muscle groups necessary? Or should I do the opposite? That is a push / pull day instead? As in, Chest & Tris and then Back and Bis?

    Is it ok to do a push day on Monday and pull day on Tuesday? I'm trying to exhaust all my resources and research before I pay a PT. I believe I can find a good routine through trial and error and bypass an expensive PT.

    Some other info I'm Male, 27 and I weigh about 81kg. I am looking to lose weight and tone up (lose that little belly). I have made all relevant changes to my diet, so I believe I am ok with that part.

    Thanks guys.

    EDIT: I forgot to mention my excersises. I got all my excersises from bodybuilding.com:

    Biceps = all the main curls
    Back = wide pull ups, rows..etc
    Triceps = skullcrushers, cable curls..etc
    Chest= pec flys, dumbell press..etc

    I do each excersise for 10-12 Reps. For example my Barbell Curls are 15kg - 3 Sets x10-12


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,900 ✭✭✭✭Mellor


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    The reason for my choice in muscle groups, was from an article which talked about how it is good to train opposite muscle groups so that you can work them more. As in, when you work Chest & Triceps, your triceps are fatigued after Chest, therefore do Chest and then Biceps. And then 2 days later do Back & Triceps.
    Or you end up doing your triceps/biceps partially everyday. Hindering recover.
    If you do chest and trips together, you get 4 days recover instead of 2.
    Both approaches are valid, but if you'd rather no go on sunday the above might suit you better fitting in 4 sessions. over 6 days. Monday, tuesday, thursday, friday.

    You are neglecting legs though


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    Mellor wrote: »
    BaRcOe wrote: »
    The reason for my choice in muscle groups, was from an article which talked about how it is good to train opposite muscle groups so that you can work them more. As in, when you work Chest & Triceps, your triceps are fatigued after Chest, therefore do Chest and then Biceps. And then 2 days later do Back & Triceps.
    Or you end up doing your triceps/biceps partially everyday.  Hindering recover.
    If you do chest and trips together, you get 4 days recover instead of 2.
    Both approaches are valid, but if you'd rather no go on sunday the above might suit you better fitting in 4 sessions. over 6 days. Monday, tuesday, thursday, friday.

    You are neglecting legs though
    Sorry I made a mistake, I meant 'Back & Triceps'. So you're saying to do the following?

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Wednesday
    Rest
    Thursday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Friday
    Back & Triceps
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Rest day

    Doing Back & Tri on Tuesday, doesn't really give 100% recovery from the Mondays Chest & Bi?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,694 ✭✭✭✭Alf Veedersane


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sorry I made a mistake, I meant 'Back & Triceps'. So you're saying to do the following?

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Wednesday
    Rest
    Thursday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Friday
    Back & Triceps
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Rest day

    Doing Back & Tri on Tuesday, doesn't really give 100% recovery from the Mondays Chest & Bi?

    Did you misspell 'legs' somewhere?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sorry I made a mistake, I meant 'Back & Triceps'. So you're saying to do the following?

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Wednesday
    Rest
    Thursday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Friday
    Back & Triceps
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Rest day

    Doing Back & Tri on Tuesday, doesn't really give 100% recovery from the Mondays Chest & Bi?

    Did you misspell 'legs' somewhere?
    Ehm nope? I only want to do legs once a week?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 24,694 ✭✭✭✭Alf Veedersane


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Ehm nope? I only want to do legs once a week?

    Why?

    Why not on the second Back and Triceps day as well?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Ehm nope? I only want to do legs once a week?

    Why?

    Why not on the second Back and Triceps day as well?
    Sometimes I feel like I spend too much time at the gym. Before my excersises I do at least 10 mins cardio as a warm up.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Ehm nope? I only want to do legs once a week?

    Why?

    Why not on the second Back and Triceps day as well?
    Sometimes I feel like I spend too much time at the gym. Before my excersises I do at least 10 mins cardio as a warm up.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,271 ✭✭✭Elemonator


    I have understood your goals OP and to be honest, the workout you are following is closer to a bodybuilders programme than the goals you seek.

    I wouldn't spend too much time on isolation exercises like curls. I remember back when I was training for size that I had all those exercises but the thing is they don't build a whole lot of muscle or burn a lot of fat. May I suggest compound exercises? You already have a few. These would include squats, deadlifts, bent over rows/pull ups, bench press, and the overhead press. That is all you need as these exercises will train all muscle groups, burn a lot of calories, and give you the body you are looking for. Squats and deadlifts are full body exercises and will work abs, the bench press and overhead press will work your triceps, chest and shoulders in many ways. The rows and pullups/chins would work the rest of your arms and give you great biceps. The added bonus is less time in the gym which is the way to go, faster and better results, full body workouts with three days a week or 4 if you want an upper/lower split which may suit you better. Make sure you get your nutrition under control too, as 80-90pc of the physique is based on this. Remember the old adage "abs are made in the kitchen".

    This is just my 2c. I used to follow a very similar programme to yours and while I did see results, the intensity and unnecessary extended time in the gym killed it. I could have spent less time there and got better gains. I discovered what I read above and nearly didn't do it based on my previous experience and I felt like I had wasted a lot of time. Some research seems to indicate there are only 5-7 exercises you need, depending on the school of thought you follow. These would be a squat, hinge, pull, push, lunge + rotation/counter rotation if you are more sport specific. These 5 will get you amazing results alone. A good starter programme for you is Stronglifts 5x5 and if you want to do a bit of cardio before or on off days as active recovery you can. That's where I started and it got me off the ground. Can I also recommend you pay for a personal trainer, or ask experienced lifters in your gym. Bad form will lead to restricted results and injuries. Your own research will not cut it here. If you are going for the athletic look, dumbbells are just as suited to your workout. I have since switched to heavy kettlebells for GAA and I still have the same body. Best of luck.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 12,547 Mod ✭✭✭✭Amirani


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sometimes I feel like I spend too much time at the gym. Before my excersises I do at least 10 mins cardio as a warm up.

    Then drop something and do at least a second day with legs. Some of the main leg lifts (squad, deadlift) are massively beneficial to core strength and will increase overall strength and help you on your other compound lifts. Also - you say you want to lose some weight, your legs contain some of the largest muscle groupings in your body. Hitting legs will be a great way to burn promote fat loss.

    Last point I'd make is you don't necessarily have to be doing 4 sessions per week could easily do 3 if you feel 4 is a bit difficult in terms of recovery and time commitment. Overall though, your attitude seems good and your general approach seems pretty sound.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    Elemonator wrote: »
    I have understood your goals OP and to be honest, the workout you are following is closer to a bodybuilders programme than the goals you seek.

    I wouldn't spend too much time on isolation exercises like curls. I remember back when I was training for size that I had all those exercises but the thing is they don't build a whole lot of muscle or burn a lot of fat. May I suggest compound exercises? You already have a few. These would include squats, deadlifts, bent over rows/pull ups, bench press, and the overhead press. That is all you need as these exercises will train all muscle groups, burn a lot of calories, and give you the body you are looking for. Squats and deadlifts are full body exercises and will work abs, the bench press and overhead press will work your triceps, chest and shoulders in many ways. The rows and pullups/chins would work the rest of your arms and give you great biceps. The added bonus is less time in the gym which is the way to go, faster and better results, full body workouts with three days a week or 4 if you want an upper/lower split which may suit you better. Make sure you get your nutrition under control too, as 80-90pc of the physique is based on this. Remember the old adage "abs are made in the kitchen".

    This is just my 2c. I used to follow a very similar programme to yours and while I did see results, the intensity and unnecessary extended time in the gym killed it. I could have spent less time there and got better gains. I discovered what I read above and nearly didn't do it based on my previous experience and I felt like I had wasted a lot of time. Some research seems to indicate there are only 5-7 exercises you need, depending on the school of thought you follow. These would be a squat, hinge, pull, push, lunge + rotation/counter rotation if you are more sport specific. These 5 will get you amazing results alone. A good starter programme for you is Stronglifts 5x5 and if you want to do a bit of cardio before or on off days as active recovery you can. That's where I started and it got me off the ground. Can I also recommend you pay for a personal trainer, or ask experienced lifters in your gym. Bad form will lead to restricted results and injuries. Your own research will not cut it here. If you are going for the athletic look, dumbbells are just as suited to your workout. I have since switched to heavy kettlebells for GAA and I still have the same body. Best of luck.
    This sounds way more appealing to me. I look at the lads deadlifting, squating and the big one BENCH PRESSING, and I'm a little intimidated by it. This is just because I do not know how to do it / I'm afraid of getting injured. But I did plan on getting a PT to show me these compound movements. You're advice is really great. My current regime, takes me at least 90 minutes, and that doesn't include the shower! If I could be in and out in about 60 minutes, I'd much prefer the gym and get home so much earlier. It makes so much more sense to do one BIG movement that works multiple muscles. I will get a PT for 1-2 hours to show me these movements and make me a plan.
    Amirani wrote: »
    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sometimes I feel like I spend too much time at the gym. Before my excersises I do at least 10 mins cardio as a warm up.

    Then drop something and do at least a second day with legs. Some of the main leg lifts (squad, deadlift) are massively beneficial to core strength and will increase overall strength and help you on your other compound lifts. Also - you say you want to lose some weight, your legs contain some of the largest muscle groupings in your body. Hitting legs will be a great way to burn promote fat loss.

    Last point I'd make is you don't necessarily have to be doing 4 sessions per week could easily do 3 if you feel 4 is a bit difficult in terms of recovery and time commitment. Overall though, your attitude seems good and your general approach seems pretty sound.
    Great stuff, that tip about the legs is really good! I will probably put in a leg day, and then learn my compound movements, so squating will be another legs day.

    Really sound advice from both here, appreciate it lads(or lassies)! :D I'm very excited to learn good compound movements!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    And @Elemonator I have been tracking my food with MyFitnessPal (what else) for the past month. I have cut out all junk food, chocoloate, pastries and bad snacks. I have replaced all snacks with healthy snacks, I eat only wholegrain bread, I  meet my protein goal every day and I am only ever sometimes -100 calories on MFP. Its my gym routine that I'm trying to get right now. :)


    p.s. sorry I lied, on weekends my calories go up because of beer / random food


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 346 ✭✭IR1SH RANG3R


    Hi OP will you post whatever programme you land on here? I'm always on the look out for good programs to tweak or change my stuff and looking to get back into the gym. Similar goals to yourself


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,271 ✭✭✭Elemonator


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    This sounds way more appealing to me. I look at the lads deadlifting, squating and the big one BENCH PRESSING, and I'm a little intimidated by it. This is just because I do not know how to do it / I'm afraid of getting injured. But I did plan on getting a PT to show me these compound movements. You're advice is really great. My current regime, takes me at least 90 minutes, and that doesn't include the shower! If I could be in and out in about 60 minutes, I'd much prefer the gym and get home so much earlier. It makes so much more sense to do one BIG movement that works multiple muscles. I will get a PT for 1-2 hours to show me these movements and make me a plan.

    Great stuff, that tip about the legs is really good! I will probably put in a leg day, and then learn my compound movements, so squating will be another legs day.

    Really sound advice from both here, appreciate it lads(or lassies)! :D I'm very excited to learn good compound movements!

    I started off with goblet squats. It's going to seem like a pain because you won't feel like you are getting as good a workout. But its worth it. Start the movements with dumbbells even. You probably won't even need to move beyond that. And they are great for strength imbalances.
    BaRcOe wrote: »
    And @Elemonator I have been tracking my food with MyFitnessPal (what else) for the past month. I have cut out all junk food, chocoloate, pastries and bad snacks. I have replaced all snacks with healthy snacks, I eat only wholegrain bread, I  meet my protein goal every day and I am only ever sometimes -100 calories on MFP. Its my gym routine that I'm trying to get right now. :)


    p.s. sorry I lied, on weekends my calories go up because of beer / random food

    That's great to hear. Make sure you take plenty of water. I try to avoid bread usually but there's no need to get that nitty gritty about it to be honest. Make sure you speak to your personal trainer on that topic also, as I have seen people go from regular eating to eating the same diet as a professional athlete. Not necessary and it does more harm than good. Just try and stay clean as much as you can is all I'll say really. I try to stay clean during the week as that is when all my training takes place and I take a rest and eat what I want during the weekend within reason whether that be a chocolate bar or a few pints with the lads. If you find yourself falling off the bandwagon for a few days, don't beat yourself up about it. The calories consumed during two days of binging are nothing in the grand scheme of things. Just get back on the bandwagon. Allow yourself these weekends as they will make it easier, going cold turkey in my experience just meant that I found it harder and harder to maintain a reasonable diet and I would go out on an all out binge for a week! You seem pretty motivated so I have no doubt you will succeed. You are having fun and its better than sitting on the couch and if you aren't enjoying it now, you will when you see it all fall into place.

    'Lem


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    Hi OP will you post whatever programme you land on here? I'm always on the look out for good programs to tweak or change my stuff and looking to get back into the gym. Similar goals to yourself

    Sure :)
    Elemonator wrote: »
    I started off with goblet squats. It's going to seem like a pain because you won't feel like you are getting as good a workout. But its worth it. Start the movements with dumbbells even. You probably won't even need to move beyond that. And they are great for strength imbalances.

    That's great to hear. Make sure you take plenty of water. I try to avoid bread usually but there's no need to get that nitty gritty about it to be honest. Make sure you speak to your personal trainer on that topic also, as I have seen people go from regular eating to eating the same diet as a professional athlete. Not necessary and it does more harm than good. Just try and stay clean as much as you can is all I'll say really. I try to stay clean during the week as that is when all my training takes place and I take a rest and eat what I want during the weekend within reason whether that be a chocolate bar or a few pints with the lads. If you find yourself falling off the bandwagon for a few days, don't beat yourself up about it. The calories consumed during two days of binging are nothing in the grand scheme of things. Just get back on the bandwagon. Allow yourself these weekends as they will make it easier, going cold turkey in my experience just meant that I found it harder and harder to maintain a reasonable diet and I would go out on an all out binge for a week! You seem pretty motivated so I have no doubt you will succeed. You are having fun and its better than sitting on the couch and if you aren't enjoying it now, you will when you see it all fall into place.
    'Lem

    Yeah, it's all about that balance between commitment to the gym and having fun on the weekends! Cheers! I may even start a log in the fitness log section, just to keep up my motivation ;) Cheers again! Will update you on what the PT says in a week or two :cool:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    deleteme


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    Hi OP will you post whatever programme you land on here? I'm always on the look out for good programs to tweak or change my stuff and looking to get back into the gym. Similar goals to yourself
    Hey, I just found a good article into Compound Excersises and it includes a program, titled
    'This Is The Compound Lifts Training Program'
    Find it here: https://gymjunkies.com/training-with-only-compound-lifts/


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 39,900 ✭✭✭✭Mellor


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sorry I made a mistake, I meant 'Back & Triceps'. So you're saying to do the following?

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Wednesday
    Rest
    Thursday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Friday
    Back & Triceps
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Rest day

    Doing Back & Tri on Tuesday, doesn't really give 100% recovery from the Mondays Chest & Bi?
    No that's not what I'm saying.
    If the program above you are hitting biceps on Monday, Tuesday, thurs and Friday. Also hitting triceps on those same 4 days.

    I'm suggesting to do chest and triceps on the same day, and back and biceps on the same day. That means they'll each be trained 2 days instead of 4.

    I understand the logic behind splitting chest and triceps, to hit each harder. But that's more suited to somebody hitting each once per week, alongside maybe shoulders and do legs properly. In your case trying to do each twice you should prioritise recovery imo.

    And you should train your legs.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    Mellor wrote: »
    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Sorry I made a mistake, I meant 'Back & Triceps'. So you're saying to do the following?

    Monday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Tuesday
    Back & Triceps & Legs
    Wednesday
    Rest
    Thursday
    Chest & Biceps & Abs
    Friday
    Back & Triceps
    Saturday
    Rest day
    Sunday
    Rest day

    Doing Back & Tri on Tuesday, doesn't really give 100% recovery from the Mondays Chest & Bi?
    No that's not what I'm saying.
    If the program above you are hitting biceps on Monday, Tuesday, thurs and Friday. Also hitting triceps on those same 4 days.

    I'm suggesting to do chest and triceps on the same day, and back and biceps on the same day. That means they'll each be trained 2 days instead of 4.

    I understand the logic behind splitting chest and triceps, to hit each harder. But that's more suited to somebody hitting each once per week, alongside maybe shoulders and do legs properly. In your case trying to do each twice you should prioritise recovery imo.

    And you should train your legs.
    I guess you're right! Chest excersies does use Triceps so it is a bit overkill doing essentially each one x4 times. My goal is to try and spend less time in the gym, so it makes a lot of sense to bring compound movements into play. I am meeting with a PT next week. He will show me how to do my squats, deadlifts..etc Thanks :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 528 ✭✭✭marcus001


    Too much rest. At 27 you only need about 1 day of rest a week, if even.

    Most people don't know this but the more often you train a muscle group the faster it recovers. There is no standard recovery time you can read about in a book, it depends on you well conditioned you are.

    When I was 20 me and a friend used to push this a bit and sometimes trained the same muscle group back to back. We trained high volume and stopped before failure and gained strength between sessions. And yes, we got huge.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,164 ✭✭✭BaRcOe


    marcus001 wrote: »
    Too much rest. At 27 you only need about 1 day of rest a week, if even.

    Most people don't know this but the more often you train a muscle group the faster it recovers. There is no standard recovery time you can read about in a book, it depends on you well conditioned you are.

    When I was 20 me and a friend used to push this a bit and sometimes trained the same muscle group back to back. We trained high volume and stopped before failure and gained strength between sessions. And yes, we got huge.

    Ok, I will make Wednesdays my Rest day and try and do 3-4 sessions around that. Cheers for sharing your personal experience :)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 528 ✭✭✭marcus001


    BaRcOe wrote: »
    Ok, I will make Wednesdays my Rest day and try and do 3-4 sessions around that. Cheers for sharing your personal experience :)

    I know it depends entirely on your work schedule etc, but I find that having rest days set in advance is counter productive. I won't plan any rest during the week. I'll try to train every day but inevitably something will come up that means I'll have to skip. What I try to avoid is taking a rest on Sunday when I could have trained and then getting tied up on Monday and not making it. I usually only take a rest when I know I can train the following day.

    I also don't have a weekly routine. More of a daily routine. Work then exercise then relax. I'll try and train muscle groups in the same sort of order no matter what day of the week it is. Just my 2 cents.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 318 ✭✭zzfh


    Get a good pt op, even just for a few sessions to show you proper form on compounds and get a program etc.
    Your plan is very imbalanced,Zero rear shoulder,glute,hamstring work.

    It might seem fine for now but will lead to injury over time.


Advertisement