GW23 transfers

fourinarow

fourinarow wrote: »

I have Baines, Jones, Chambers, Yoshida and Rose. Who did I bring Brunt(y) in for??

Depends if you play 3 or 4 at the back.

If you're bringing him in to start then I'd suggest you'd have to get rid of one of your current starters.

I shipped out Jones for Baines recently but I'm fearing 3 United clean sheets in their next 3 matches.

Sorry if I'm not helping but it's a real tough call. That said, I did sell Jones recently so I suppose that would be my answer.

Colking

Deleted User wrote: »

That gave me a real good chuckle.

Sorry fourinarow, the smartarse in me couldn't resist.

I'd personally go Jones>Brunt. Like FHFC I've had Brunt for a loong time now and am very happy.

Shanotheslayer

Colking wrote: »

I love riddles, but I give up, who ?

Deserves more credit :pac:

fourinarow

Colking wrote: »

Sorry fourinarow, the smartarse in me couldn't resist.

I'd personally go Jones>Brunt. Like FHFC I've had Brunt for a loong time now and am very happy.

Serves me right! 😀 Similarly, I've had Jones for a long time and I don't want to give up a route into the United defence that easily! I hate this game 😂

wanderer100

Is it worth taking out Friend for Brunt??

km79

fourinarow wrote: »

I have Baines, Jones, Chambers, Yoshida and Rose. Who did I bring Brunt(y) in for??

Jones
He offers ZERO attacks no threat . Doesn't even go up for corners. So you are relying solely on clean sheets . And they have an annoying habit of conceding just one goal

2nd Row Donkey

FHFC wrote:

Its Bruntinho. End of discussion.

Bruntinho works. Much better than Brunty anyway.

iroced

2nd Row Donkey wrote: »

Bruntinho works. Much better than Brunty anyway.

Must protest! Brazil is overrated right now . So what about Michel Bruntini, Zinedine Bruntidane, Johann Bruyuntff, Diego Baruntadona or to take his position into account Franz Beckenbrunter :pac:...

2nd Row Donkey

Franz Beckenbrunter. Classic.

fourinarow

km79 wrote: »

Jones
He offers ZERO attacks no threat . Doesn't even go up for corners. So you are relying solely on clean sheets . And they have an annoying habit of conceding just one goal

Jones seems to be the unanimous decision so, might hold off for a day or two though, looks like he's due a rise...

2nd Row Donkey

fourinarow wrote:

looks like he's due a rise...

... Thats because him and Mrs Jones got a thing going on.

km79

fourinarow wrote: »

Jones seems to be the unanimous decision so, might hold off for a day or two though, looks like he's due a rise...

He has been looking like rising for 4 weeks! I held him till end of WC and he was on 97%

FHFC

km79 wrote: »

He has been looking like rising for 4 weeks! I held him till end of WC and he was on 97%

Poor lad, there's a pill he can get nowadays...

siblers

wanderer100 wrote: »

Is it worth taking out Friend for Brunt??

Who are your other defenders? Chambers seems like the best choice for a 'Boro defender

wanderer100

siblers wrote: »

Who are your other defenders? Chambers seems like the best choice for a 'Boro defender

My defence is Alonso, Jones, Friend, Pieters, Amat

Is there room for Brunt??

siblers

wanderer100 wrote: »

My defence is Alonso, Jones, Friend, Pieters, Amat

Is there room for Brunt??

There is, I'd probably do Friend to Brunt but others on here might suggest doing Jones to Brunt due to Jones lack of n attacking threat.

Shedite27

wanderer100 wrote: »

My defence is Alonso, Jones, Friend, Pieters, Amat

Is there room for Brunt??

Judging by this thread today, you've a perfect Jones-sized hole for him (if you've the cash)

FHFC

Lads. Unless you have a pressing transfer and no wriggle room in budget it's largely pointless debating some of the transfers above till after the FA Cup 5th round draw.

Boro for example are a side with a better than most chance of no blank in 28. Selling Boro assets would be premature IMO. Meanwhile Jones has a high chance of two blanks in his next 6.

Lawros Tache

2nd Row Donkey wrote: »

... Thats because him and Mrs Jones got a thing going on.

Thought that deserved at least a little bit of recognition

Maybe no Billy Paul fans on here....

2nd Row Donkey

Lawros Tache wrote:

Thought that deserved at least a little bit of recognition

Yes. Finally some recognition. Cheers.

Father Hernandez

Lawros Tache wrote: »

Thought that deserved at least a little bit of recognition

Maybe no Billy Paul fans on here....

YES!! :pac:

El festino

Have McAuley since the start. Very tempted by Brunt though. But of a sideways move isn't it?

alchemist33

El festino wrote: »

Have McAuley since the start. Very tempted by Brunt though. But of a sideways move isn't it?

If I was to choose one now, having neither, it would obviously be Bruntenbauer (that was my favourite). But I also have McAuley and don't feel its worth a transfer right now

dahat

Snodgrass at 5.7 or Pedro at 6.9.

Snodgrass on freekicks plus penalties could be huge value at 5.7, very likely to do this transfer next gameweek which givese Lukaku to Costa if I so desire.

2nd Row Donkey

dahat wrote:

Snodgrass on freekicks plus penalties could be huge value at 5.7, very likely to do this transfer next gameweek which givese Lukaku to Costa if I so desire.

... No guarantee he will be on them at WH though. He was a big fish in a small pond at Hull, could be different in the big smoke.

Iused2likebusts

2nd Row Donkey wrote: »

... No guarantee he will be on them at WH though. He was a big fish in a small pond at Hull, could be different in the big smoke.

Ye I don't think he will be on pens.

spock.

dahat wrote:

Snodgrass at 5.7 or Pedro at 6.9.

Snodgrass on freekicks plus penalties could be huge value at 5.7, very likely to do this transfer next gameweek which givese Lukaku to Costa if I so desire.

If Noble didn't give up pens for Payet, I can't see him doing it for Snodgrass.

2nd Row Donkey

spock. wrote:

If Noble didn't give up pens for Payet, I can't see him doing it for Snodgrass.

It would be the noble thing to do.

Bah-dum-tish

Jayzus, it's quiet around here on non epl weekends

Aenaes

I did Holebas, Hazard and Carroll to Holgate, Stanislas and Ibra for a -4.

carnie

Haven't a clue what to do this week I might just bank it. The only possible transfer i might make would be Costa to kane but that's not really essential.

I haven't been this happy with my team in many fpl seasons