Digital and Analogue divide

CabanSail

The forum has seen a separation of people using Digital Technology and those who are using Analogue methods (ie. Film)

After much consultation this Forum will soon be split into two.

This forum will remain, under the Arts category for those who use Film.


A New Forum, Digital Imaging and Design, will be set up in the Technology and Internet category.

oleras

I am new enough to the forum. I like it. I bought a camera.

Splitting it is wack, does not make any sense.

Again, i am new but unless there are secret hidden forums, i didn't see any of the discussion/consultation.

I thought photography was just that, taking a photograph, be is digital or film.

Again, just a newb.

Edit: In light of recent information, and a lack of wine in my system, this seems a great idea.

magicbastarder

i do hope the film forum will be further subdivided into colour and monochrome.

OldGoat

...but I'm a photographer, I just don't use film. Splitting the forum seems a bit unnecessary.

CabanSail

magicbastarder wrote: »

i do hope the film forum will be further subdivided into colour and monochrome.

Film will have Mono, Colour, Print and Transparency sub-forums

Digital will have Mac, Windows, Nikon, Canon and Other Makes sub-forums.

OldGoat

/Facepalm.
I feckin' hate today.

zero19

Pfft why bother, film is dead.

CabanSail

zero19 wrote: »

Pfft why bother, film is dead.

Film is Art.

lenscap

Film is far from dead. It may not be main stream but there is still a market for selling, shooting and processing film.

(I know I have a minilab)

Myksyk

Everything considered, this makes complete sense.

Metric Tensor

Can I further suggest the following:

1. Within the Nikon sub-forum I think there should be 3 further sub-fora for Full Size, Cropped and Consumer sized sensors.
2. Separate fora within the mono and colour film forums for each ISO level. So a Mono200 forum, Mono400, etc. etc.

magicbastarder

and a swan subforum.

AnCatDubh

magicbastarder wrote: »

and a swan subforum.

I'll give you that but only if I can have a foreground rock subforum...

Tiriel

Maybe it is also worth looking at processing. Photos that are processed are really more digital design? Should they be a part of the new Digital Imaging and Design sub-forum?

dinneenp

Why aren't they both sub-forums of photography?

Tiriel

dinneenp wrote: »

Why aren't they both sub-forums of photography?

Art and photography are different though - so for design and digital manipulation it is felt to be more suited to be put with digital design.

D.S.

CabanSail wrote: »

Film is Art.

No it's not CabanSail. Film and Digital are only art if they have a creative / expressive vision, i.e. created with some creative intent. Over the years I have seen film and digital photography here which is quite simply not art (but is still interesting photography). There is also equally plenty of film and digital photography which have had an artistic vision.

I think people who want to create and share any form of art should live in the art forum - regardless of the media used. Putting Digital Photography into Technology / Internet forum is a bit of shame. It almost implies that Digital is inferior / not art worthy?

Personally - I shoot digital. Have always tried (to varying degrees of success) - through my landscape or portraits - to tell stories / share emotions. I've loved this forum for the v reason that digital and film media were together under the photography banner. And it was a fantastic melting pot where you got to see various perspectives / story telling. So I am not particularly keen on the change myself. And didn't see any discussion here in the photography thread (which I visit daily)? Not sure where/when this discussion happened?

Myksyk

With the passing of time, and on mature reflection, I am leaning towards thinking that it is perhaps unwise to make this type of change CabanSail. In fact I'd go so far as to say that the whole notion, and the thinking behind it, has been entirely foolish.

CabanSail

Yes. I think we might leave it for now. Maybe revisit this idea next year, let's say 1st April 2017.

D.S.

Wow - hook line and sinker. Bien joue people

zero19

zero19 wrote: »

Pfft why bother, film is dead.

*I'm actually really enjoying using film for the first time over the last few weeks.

amdgilmore

This was much funnier than most efforts.

Good work.

FlipperThePriest

CabanSail wrote: »

Yes. I think we might leave it for now. Maybe revisit this idea next year, let's say 1st April 2017.

Well played. I had already began to gather my thoughts and attempt a reasoned plea. Those initial thankers... actually think it would have been a good idea or where they just not caught?!

CabanSail

zippy84 wrote: »

Those initial thankers... actually think it would have been a good idea or where they just not caught?!

I hope the latter as it was a very bad idea.

Portlawslim

CabanSail wrote: »

Yes. I think we might leave it for now. Maybe revisit this idea next year, let's say 1st April 2017.

Bravo, Bravo!!
Hadn't been on here since last week and started reading this thread without checking the date, roaring I was...Well Done young Sail:)

EyeCake

I only saw this on April5th and was angered and saddened and ready to to leave.
Then I realised it was an April Fool and realised its one of the best I have ever seed!

sunny2004

OldGoat wrote: »

...but I'm a photographer, I just don't use film. Splitting the forum seems a bit unnecessary.

I was more active in the past, in fact the previous splitting of the forums contributed to my inactivity here, and now you are doing it again ?

Photography is Photography, be it Digital, Film, black and white or colour..

I think its a mistake to do this and I think you will see a drop in activity in each separate forum..

In addition, I'm sure we all learn from seeing posts on subjects we either know little about, or have had no interest in the past in, but the post are interesting..

Even the title of this thread is divisive, as someone who has been involved in photography for decades, I don't know of any divide, its all photography and chopping it up into smaller and smaller sections to me is the divide, not the subject of photography..

To me it's a mistake...

sunny2004

CabanSail wrote: »

Yes. I think we might leave it for now. Maybe revisit this idea next year, let's say 1st April 2017.

LMAO...

mystic86

sunny2004 wrote: »

Photography is Photography, be it Digital, Film, black and white or colour..

I think its a mistake to do this and I think you will see a drop in activity in each separate forum..

In addition, I'm sure we all learn from seeing posts on subjects we either know little about, or have had no interest in the past in, but the post are interesting..

Off topic, but these are good reasons as to why I don't believe we should have a separate random film photo thread.

Esel

But... but I just bought a hardly used 64Mp tellyfloato (with Low Pro bag) incl 2 bottles of dehydrated H20 developing chemtrails from a new reg on Adverts. He met me in Blanch and all. Package included a handwritten link to this thread.

The battery in his phone must be dead (thought he was low), because I don't even get a recorded message when I call him.

I just need his cousin's number, because he has the very rare manual for sale.

Seller told me I can get the developing trays in MacDonald's. Didn't say which branch though?

Help?

Silva360

magicbastarder wrote: »

and a swan subforum.

Studio120

zero19 wrote: »

Pfft why bother, film is dead.

I thought that kind of statement went the way the Dodo did .

zero19

Studio120 wrote: »

I thought that kind of statement went the way the Dodo did .

Check the date I made that post...

Studio120

Yeah I copped that :-)......afterwards.

It is ironic though that statements like that are actually more extinct then film :-)

Myksyk

... A thread that just keeps giving!

Adrian.Sadlier

Well it is a subject that will evoke negative remarks ..... Or is this too transparent a comment?

I fear I may be causing this thread to slide into obscurity - did I frame that properly or should I just hand in my resignation from boards on a plate?

Myksyk

Adrian.Sadlier wrote: »

...should I just hand in my resignation from boards on a plate?

... maybe just go hide in a dark room.

Adrian.Sadlier

Myksyk wrote: »

... maybe just go hide in a dark room.

And see what develops?

CabanSail

Adrian.Sadlier wrote: »

And see what develops?

That should Fix it.

beth-lou

This whole thread is a thing of beauty. I think I've gone through the whole gamut of emotions. Well done!