Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Winter Miles, Summer Smiles

  • 28-09-2015 9:21pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭


    Time to start the journey towards 2016 races. I sat down with El Coachio and went through goals for next year, and what to do to make them happen. I want to get faster in the water, but realistically becoming more efficient at the same speed will be more productive, if I can target bigger gains on the bike and run. The long spins are something I avoid as a time sink from family, but they will have to be fitted in somewhere, so either long turbos in the office, or spins when the kids are at swimming classes. My running will make big gains if I keep the weight down (currently 86kg) and stay injury free. S&C will play a big part here, it has to become more regular.

    Goals for 2016 are Lough Cutra Oly as an early season target, with Caroline Kearney as the later A goal. In between, Carlow, Wicklow, and HOTW look appealing. Competition and performance are important, but fun while doing so is the name of the game. I get an awful lot out of Tri, it informs and helps structure other aspects of my daily life, and most important keeps me off the golf course when my job is every more hastening towards the Pringle sweater and slacks :D

    The log title is a mantra from one of the girls who used swim with us in Arklow, something she always used say when we were hanging on the bank gasping air halfway down a killer set. Foundation for a good summer starts now. I have two weeks easy/unstructured but no harm in logging it all from this point, if only to add to the general brain sweepings that make these logs fun to read.


«13456712

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Mon 28th Sept Masters Swim

    100m easy
    6x100 free (25k25d50s) 15s
    6x75 free pull buoy 15s
    6x50 free 20m Max 30m easy
    Main set
    6x200 free on 3:20 (hold 2:48-2:52)
    200m easy

    Saturday's bike spill is hitting me now, aches and pains in shoulder and arm muscles. While the swim helped a bit, I didn't feel 100% for the 200's and so sat out the third (I've been told not to push too hard, I should be going easier these couple of weeks). So the 200's were in 2:50-2:59, not brilliant times but I worked on my stroke during them rather than powering them.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,435 ✭✭✭joey100


    Good to see your still logging Kurt. Just a quick question about your swimming though, I've been looking at your sessions for a while and some of the times you can hit I would love to be able to hit, sub 3 min 200's and sub 6 min 400's. How do you feel this transfers out to open water? Mainly asking because I can't hit those times but was on your feet in CK and out just before you in Dublin, are the sessions transferring well to open water swimming? I was probably a little bit slower in the pool this year than last but my open water times were on average a min faster over Olympic distance, must be down to the coach!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    The biggest difference I've made to my tri swimming this year has been to consciously slow the effort during races. So my times are down somewhat but I'm exiting a lot more refreshed, and this has transferred into better bikes and runs (and faster overall times). For next year I'd like to bring down the swim time (for similar effort), but bike/run gains are the main focus.

    To answer your question, how do sub 3 min 200's and sub 6 min 400's transfer out to open water?* Gains in these pool times will be made with improving technique over the winter, and that improved technique should manifest itself in OW racing. Whether it manifests itself in faster times without much extra effort, or similar times with a refreshed entry to T1, I don't mind.

    *I'd suspect some would say improved form is more important per se than sub 3 min 200's and sub 6 min 400's.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Races for next year below. Want to travel less, and what will be will be regarding swim cancellations or others drafting.

    16/04/2016 North Tipp Sprint Sprint Nenagh Tipperary (Pool tri)
    22/05/2016 Tri 795 Carlow Sprint Carlow Carlow (nearby)
    29/05/2016 Lough Cutra Standard Galway (Early season A race)
    25/06/2016 Hell of the West Standard Kilkee Clare National Champs ???
    10/07/2016 Wicklow Town Black Castle Standard Wicklow Town Wicklow (nearby)
    16/07/2016 Two Proviences Sprint Lanesboro Longford National Champs ???(More likely than not)
    13/08/2016 Caroline Kearney Standard Mullingar Westmeath (A race)
    20/08/2016 Tri the Hook Sprint Fethard on Sea Wexford ???(Maybe, it is close but sh1t organization)
    28/08/2016 Vodafone Dublin City Triathlon Standard Phoenix Park Dublin ???(More likely than not)
    17/09/2016 Pulse Port Beach Triathlon Sprint Clogherhead Louth


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 8,208 ✭✭✭shotgunmcos


    Good to see a new log KG.

    Your swim times have improved a lot. How did the pool times stack up against your tri swims this year? Is there much of a difference between SC and LC pool times?

    I'd agree with form over times. Exiting with more juice etc...

    Its mad that I went down to the pool yesterday morning after months out, hopped into the middle lane and was expected to lead it. When I dropped back, they literally waited for me to kick off first. I healdfast and let them off. I got many bizarre looks when I said it was because I was unfit and want to improve stroke form first :confused::cool:


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 827 ✭✭✭RJM85


    Jaysus, someone's eager! I'm starting to feel guilty!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,939 ✭✭✭MojoMaker


    "Winter smiles", and it still the end of the summer and the 2015 season not over yet.

    What else are you throwing in the mix Kurt? Some of the blue riband OW swim races I assume, maybe even a few prominent 10K road races?

    How much gain are you targeting in the pool - i.e. sub 5:30 400?

    Do you hope to crack sub-40 10K next year?

    Giving me some food for thought myself now :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    MojoMaker wrote: »
    "Winter smiles", and it still the end of the summer and the 2015 season not over yet.

    What else are you throwing in the mix Kurt? Some of the blue riband OW swim races I assume, maybe even a few prominent 10K road races?

    How much gain are you targeting in the pool - i.e. sub 5:30 400?

    Do you hope to crack sub-40 10K next year?

    Giving me some food for thought myself now :)

    Eager to look forward I guess, I like racing and won't be able to atone for last weekends truncation for a good while... I'm sure that enthusiasm will quieten down soon enough ;)

    Maybe some OW races buts its hard to fit it all in.

    Yes the target is 5:30 400TT but if I don't get it I'll be happy with better form. The real improvement targets are for the bike and run.

    Sub-40 10k this December at the Aware 10k :)

    Glad you are looking ahead too... get that 400m time down! ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,435 ✭✭✭joey100


    I'm going to predict you will need to go comfortably below Sub 40 for the 10km to win that bet!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    joey100 wrote: »
    I'm going to predict you will need to go comfortably below Sub 40 for the 10km to win that bet!

    Yes sub 39 needed.

    I met him at the weekend and was a bit surprised at how much weight he's shed since I last saw him... still, he was hungover so there's always hope ;)


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Tue 16k easy run 1:18

    Kids were at swimming so I took off for a jog along the coast road. Everything the next couple of weeks has to be easy, only one session a day, and unstructured. I had the garmin but figured I would only look at it while it beeped, and took off at an easy pace which I figured to be 5:30min/km... checked at the beep, it was a 4:47. From there I slowed, but to be honest it felt difficult and unnatural keeping the pace under 5min/km. Not sure if this is because I'm still primed for a race that never happened, or whatever, but this was a very enjoyable very easy trot along the coast road and back. 4:55 average pace.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,939 ✭✭✭MojoMaker


    If 4:55 is your easy pace what's your marathon pace kurt?

    I know what you mean though, sometimes it's really hard to run at an easy pace, it's different mechanics in some ways.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    MojoMaker wrote: »
    If 4:55 is your easy pace what's your marathon pace kurt?

    I know what you mean though, sometimes it's really hard to run at an easy pace, it's different mechanics in some ways.

    It's been a good few years since I ran a marathon but MP would have been 4:15-4:30 (never broke 3 hours).

    In general I run by feel (that may have to change and HR numbers needed), and 4:55 pace over 16k yesterday felt easy. I guess the previous week was a taper week of sorts and then I didn't get to race. Some days >5:30 pace is easy pace.

    Agree with you on the mechanics, there is nothing I dislike more than artificially slowing your stride. I once paced a 5-hour marathon. It was horrible to "run" like that, very difficult cadence and body posture, it felt alien. I quit after halfway.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Fri 10.16k @ 4:36 av pace

    Railway walk with Mick, a great day for a trot. Conversation pace the way around. Enjoyed this run, even though I had to fend off Rotterdam woo'ings. You can exact revenge for both of us there Mick ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Sat Hilly spin 1:43 42k

    Met up with Kirk as our kids were at the pool, and went out for an easy spin on one of his routes. Nothing planned except be back for the kids within 2 hours. The spin was a great lesson for me, as Kirk is a much better biker than I, and is active with the local bike club. He showed me how to take hills, and how to spin easy, all setting up nicely for a final 15mins big gear up and overs. The riding before the BG was easy, I was surprised to see how much elevation we had put in. The up and overs were along the old N11, no traffic, great surface, into a headwind. Turning with smooth constant rotation, keeping the power high. Towards the end he dropped me and I had to put in big effort to get him back- far better economy to keep the effort constant. A very useful spin.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Mon 6k easy run 30 mins; Masters swim

    The run was weird, my legs and body felt great, but something was amiss. I rarely eat takeaway but had a chinese while watching the rugger yesterday, and am probably awash with salt at this stage. Didn't sleep well either. But a good run in an autumnal setting.

    Swim:
    200m warm up
    10*50 as (25k, 25drill, 15s)
    Main set- 90% effort based on 100m pb
    5*150 on 2:30 (in 2:10-2:25)
    5*100 on 1:40 (in 1:22-1:29)
    5*50 on 60 (in 38-41)
    100m easy
    300m hypoxic

    This was a decent set- what I'm happiest about is that it wasn't eyeballs out. Sure, it was tough and it hurt, but I kept the stroke together and finished each set with the second fastest rep. Getting instant stroke feedback from the coach on the deck is fantastic.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    arguably why some fast pool swimmers never see translation to OW ... but worth a read imho

    http://www.hellefrederiksen.com/distance-per-stroke-effective/

    The catch phase is critical
    Pull band work is one of / if not the most effective drill work to be done


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,584 ✭✭✭✭tunney


    interested wrote: »
    arguably why some fast pool swimmers never see translation to OW ... but worth a read imho

    http://www.hellefrederiksen.com/distance-per-stroke-effective/

    The catch phase is critical
    Pull band work is one of / if not the most effective drill work to be done

    Thorpe is often held up as the poster boy for DPS as a result of his slight pause in the catch. he himself sees this slight pause as a disfunction in his stroke that should be resolved.

    Look at Any Potts in Kona at the weekend. One of the first out of the water with a horrible looking ballistic recovery stroke - it works though.

    Part of my objection to most masters sessions is the "this is the right way to swim" attitude. It doesn't translate. Alot easier if people tune out, don't think, and just do what they are told.

    I love B+B sets, most of my set yesterday was B+B, find it wonderful for the catch and oddly my rotation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    tunney wrote: »
    Thorpe is often held up as the poster boy for DPS as a result of his slight pause in the catch. he himself sees this slight pause as a disfunction in his stroke that should be resolved.

    Look at Any Potts in Kona at the weekend. One of the first out of the water with a horrible looking ballistic recovery stroke - it works though.

    Part of my objection to most masters sessions is the "this is the right way to swim" attitude. It doesn't translate. Alot easier if people tune out, don't think, and just do what they are told.

    I love B+B sets, most of my set yesterday was B+B, find it wonderful for the catch and oddly my rotation.

    From the article

    'Teaching amateurs and non-natural swimmers to apply a long DPS style brings more dead spots in the stroke than not.'

    Those dead spots (imho) combined with a not so strong leg kick are the big reasons why some triathletes struggle to swim fast in some OW races. Based on looking at someones stroke I can sometimes see these and recommend those swimmers focus on lake swims or calm rivers - in open water swims like Kilkee those dead spots cost more because the external environmental factors have more influence (wind, tide/current, chop).

    Band with a buoy, progressing to band work without a buoy is great for 'encouraging' both a effective catch and good strong core. I would say its just as important to 'finish' each stroke to the hip on each pull and be wary of snatching and not catching the water - without a pause ;)

    As before, great insight and I really like the summary table of why 'swimming' and 'open water' swimming differ.


    Many thanks for the use of your blog Paul ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    ^appreciate the input, always happy to talk swimming:)

    Last night stroke feedback was to lengthen my stroke, to find the slight glide.

    Tunney (and interested?) I presume this would be one of your objections to masters/pool swimming, in that its the opposite to a typically higher turnover Tri stroke?

    What I find is if I introduce a slight glide/overreach, I get a better catch (in that my catch is typically bad anyway). A typical set last night had me fast the first rep, slowing the next two as I tired, and getting faster again (for less perceived effort) when I focussed on a longer stroke. Typically in Tri races a longer stroke focus in the second half of the swim means a better second half.

    Again in the spirit of swim chatter... I don't get the point HF is trying to make. Sure, a higher cadence will be needed in whitecap swimming versus pool, but in general what works is what works to make you faster. A good catch isn't necessitated from higher turnover; if a longer stroke gets you a better catch (and better streamline) then that works for all her bulletpoints. In particular, "Efficiency comes from being fluid in the water, irrelevant of stroke rate."


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    Last night stroke feedback was to lengthen my stroke, to find the slight glide.

    Tunney (and interested?) I presume this would be one of your objections to masters/pool swimming, in that its the opposite to a typically higher turnover Tri stroke?


    In a word: Yep!
    The masters swimming club / coach is gearing swimmers to race in pools and galas, they're coaching a group.
    This was the reason I posted this article on your blog btw ;)


    Also adult swimmers (even kids) take everything very literally - the glide or pause instruction by a coach is for a reason - the reason being is that your not 'slipping' water at the start of the power/pull phase and you've a grip with the palm of your hand / or hold of the water before you pull yourself through on the stroke.
    Unfortunately for lots of swimmers the exaggeration / instruction sticks and they pause ... almost 'catchup' like fashion which might look pretty, but leads to the dead spots ... unless you've a 6 beat kick ... and even with this 'pausing' or exaggerated / elongated glide will be an issue in the pool .. but again, imho, plays a big part of good pool swimmers not seeing similar speeds / results in the open water.


    So ... swim as a triathlete and not a swimmer :) understand that DPS and Stroke count dictate the speed we move through the water, understand that moving through the water in a pool and the open water are very different ... train appropriately for what you want to excel in.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,034 ✭✭✭griffin100


    You've probably seen this video as I have posted it before but it's interesting:

    http://marathonswimmers.org/blog/2013/06/dave-scott-open-water-technique/


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,584 ✭✭✭✭tunney


    interested wrote: »
    From the article

    'Teaching amateurs and non-natural swimmers to apply a long DPS style brings more dead spots in the stroke than not.'

    Those dead spots (imho) combined with a not so strong leg kick are the big reasons why some triathletes struggle to swim fast in some OW races. Based on looking at someones stroke I can sometimes see these .....

    I wasn't referring to your masters sessions by the way


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    tunney wrote: »
    I wasn't referring to your masters sessions by the way


    :D laughing out loud in a good way purely because I never thought of that ! :D

    Truthfully I always saw it / continue to see it a coached session for triathletes - as in there's no individual medley sets etc etc I also based the training around the triathlon season, last year we added a short block of 5 sessions to bring folks closer to key races and in those weeks would regularly do OW skills/drills in the pool (I know PK does the same to good effect at his Thursday morning sessions)...
    and also its been a 3D session for a few years now, but open to all with a TI license.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    tunney wrote: »
    Thorpe is often held up as the poster boy for DPS as a result of his slight pause in the catch. he himself sees this slight pause as a disfunction in his stroke that should be resolved.

    This brings to mind the great Garrett Fitzgerald quote- “That’s fine in practice, but will it work in theory?”


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,839 ✭✭✭zico10


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    What I find is if I introduce a slight glide/overreach, I get a better catch (in that my catch is typically bad anyway). A typical set last night had me fast the first rep, slowing the next two as I tired, and getting faster again (for less perceived effort) when I focussed on a longer stroke. Typically in Tri races a longer stroke focus in the second half of the swim means a better second half.

    Interesting discussion happening and I don't mean to be fatuous, but why not focus on this the whole way through?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    zico10 wrote: »
    Interesting discussion happening and I don't mean to be fatuous, but why not focus on this the whole way through?

    Usual method in races up to mid-summer has been to power from the start (usually go out with the leaders for first 100-200m), try and grab feet, and power the rest of the way. Exiting quite tired.

    Recently I've gone out hard 100m, then steadied and grabbed feet, start tiring mid-way, lengthen reach and that seems to work, I can maintain position and exit relatively fit for the bike.

    Thats only started to work and I will try a longer reach all the way next race. I think the longer reach is giving a better catch, I can certainly "feel" the grab of water with a longer reach, in a way I couldn't before.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 12,584 ✭✭✭✭tunney


    zico10 wrote: »
    Interesting discussion happening and I don't mean to be fatuous, but why not focus on this the whole way through?

    Do you need to work on focus in the first half? By that I mean your focus will naturally be there until you start to fatigue and then, at that point the real focus is required. My 2c but been 5 years since I last raced.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Tue 50 min turbo

    10 easy
    5x(30sec build30sec easy)
    5x(4 BG steady cad, 1 easy)
    5x(15sec sprint, 45 easy)
    5 easy

    This was a slog, but not as hard as the numbers would suggest. 4 min BG were 285W, 66rpm
    310, 70
    309, 71
    305, 71
    309, 72


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 827 ✭✭✭RJM85


    tunney wrote: »
    Do you need to work on focus in the first half? By that I mean your focus will naturally be there until you start to fatigue and then, at that point the real focus is required. My 2c but been 5 years since I last raced.

    Focus will be there alright, but not necessarily on the right things in my experience. I'll often find that I've slipped into bad habits when I'm focussed on 'racing' when I actually need to take a step back, not panic and focus on my form. But again, that's just n=1.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Wed 2,000m swim

    200sw,2x100p,4x50k
    10x50p as 25 fist, 25p + 10sec
    5x100p mod + 15sec
    4x50 as 25fast, 25 easy
    200 choice easy

    This session verified adding reach into my stroke. The 5X100p mod came in on a very comfortable 1:35 each time, and the effort was no more than moderate. The reach is helping a lot with catch.

    The fast 25's were all in 17-19s.

    PM 6.42k easy run at 4:46 pace (with 5*20 stride, 40s easy)

    Ran along the river, it was a massive bugfest tonight, thousands of the little feckers got into my eyes, ears, nose, and gob. I will surely turn into Jeff Goldblum tonight.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    griffin100 wrote: »
    You've probably seen this video as I have posted it before but it's interesting:

    http://marathonswimmers.org/blog/2013/06/dave-scott-open-water-technique/

    Just watched it all the way through, its very informative, thanks for posting it.

    Dave Scott talks of optimally swimming 25m in a range of 15-24 strokes, (suggesting 15 is too few for most, and suggesting 24 is exceptionally fast). I guess this is the DPS emphasis that Helle talks about in the link Mark gave- but crucially she didn't give any indication of what range stroke turnover in her opinion piece.

    I swim 19/20 strokes per 25m, and extending my reach is bringing this down to 18/19. And I'm relatively long in reach. So what I take is my stroke rate is right where it should be (as a triathlete).

    DS- "I think the game is to go faster, isn't it"


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Thurs 12k easy run 4:52av pace

    Between work and life I didn't manage to get the scheduled easy spin today... so while the kids were swimming I fit (fat? fitted?) in an easy run along the coast, brilliant evening to be out in the country between the waves and the setting sun.

    I skipped tonights Masters crossfit session. I might argue, I might protest, but I sometimes do listen ;)

    Sat on the bank after to watch the kids. Its been a while since I did this, and my jaw dropped when I saw what Junior was doing. 10*50 off 60s, each one in between 38-41s...:eek: I'd be happy to make that set, and he had an hour of swim work done already. His stroke and position have improved immensely, and he's seeing the benefits now. Coach told me he did a 400TT under 7 mins a week ago... this will be a good year for him. The only problem is the club is too successful- they are operating at capacity, and there is no room for anyone to move up a lane. That's something we'll have to rectify soon.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,034 ✭✭✭griffin100


    When it comes to distance per stroke and optimal efficiency I'm minded of Sean Kelly when Harmon was asking him on Eurosport one time about gearing in the TDF. Harmon is blathering on about the various gearing options as the riders struggle up a long climb. He asks Kelly what gearing he would suggest for the climb. After a long long pause Kelly says 'the one that gets you to the top quickest' I suppose you could take the same approach to DPS and stroke rate :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    griffin100 wrote: »
    When it comes to distance per stroke and optimal efficiency I'm minded of Sean Kelly when Harmon was asking him on Eurosport one time about gearing in the TDF. Harmon is blathering on about the various gearing options as the riders struggle up a long climb. He asks Kelly what gearing he would suggest for the climb. After a long long pause Kelly says 'the one that gets you to the top quickest' I suppose you could take the same approach to DPS and stroke rate :)

    Ain't that the truth! Sometimes if its working, its working, and thats all you need to know.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    worth a watch


    Apart from the audible slap/slap/slap and bubbles from slightly opened fingers on entry - the flow, rhythm and (not to be underestimated) the aerobic capacity and swim fitness to swim 1.10/100 all day is impressive - great pics of catch and the importance of a high elbow for leverage under the water is excellently presented.

    Eliminate deadspots, not unreasonable to increase the stroke rate ... yada yada yada :)


    Swim, find your own rhythm, do the basics ... don't over-think it ;)


    edit: and another ... swimming with bands ... I was playing with myself this morning .... finger paddles or no paddles ... bunches of 50's


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Horrible looking stroke by Jodie Swallow! But 1:10/100 for lots of 100's... not to be sniffed at.

    During Pulse race I was passed on my left by a guy with a similar punchy stroke... must be a short arse thing ;) But if it works it works.

    The hand entry on the band video- whats the point in doing it this way (an exaggerated reach from what I can see)? That is, what do you learn from it? Your answer will determine how I swim next week :)

    (as ever, thanks for droppin' by)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    The hand entry on the band video- whats the point in doing it this way (an exaggerated reach from what I can see)? That is, what do you learn from it? Your answer will determine how I swim next week :)
    (as ever, thanks for droppin' by)


    The first 42 seconds of the video illustrate how to do band work correctly: to eliminate deadspots etc ... hand entry, pulling all the way to the hips with a good catch phase and NO PAUSE. After that they talk about how not to do it.



    Aside:
    Reason was poking about youtube was to find good video's for the fix for no rotation or 'flat swimming' - meaning your stomach always faces the bottom of the pool ( versus rotating from side to side ).
    Swimming flat is a really common problem imho, and can lead to tendonitis and rotator cuff issues when people push up mileage in the pool.

    The drill to fix that issue: as you reach out in front of you, over extend the arm all the way until you feel your body rotate to the side, this should cause the other shoulder to roll out of the water and your belly button should be pointing more towards the sides of the pool than at the black line at the bottom. If taken literally, someone doing this will pause as they over extend, fixing one issue and introducing another :D

    .... if you put a band on, any PAUSE will leave you dragging your legs at bottom of pool and drowning :)


    So ... if you don't swim flat Paul .... which you don't then don't over extend / pause / introduce more complexity .... if you want to swim pretty as you cruise about the south of France in budgie smugglers then by all means carry on ... with Jnr's progress he'll be able to get changed, take a nap, order you a warm beverage before you catch up to him when swimming ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    interested wrote: »
    The first 42 seconds of the video illustrate how to do band work correctly: to eliminate deadspots etc ... hand entry, pulling all the way to the hips with a good catch phase and NO PAUSE. After that they talk about how not to do it.

    I was scratching my head watching it- thinking why on earth did you post this crazy entry?... the video starts 43secs in from your link!:)

    Just rewatched the whole thing, makes more sense now.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    I was scratching my head watching it- thinking why on earth did you post this crazy entry?... the video starts 43secs in from your link!:)

    Just rewatched the whole thing, makes more sense now.


    Too funny - fixed it above


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,034 ✭✭✭griffin100


    interested wrote: »

    Swimming flat is a really common problem imho, and can lead to tendonitis and rotator cuff issues when people push up mileage in the pool.

    You may have just described the cause of all my arm and shoulder problems for the last 6 months:( This is an area I'll work on.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    interested wrote: »
    ... I was playing with myself this morning ....

    hehehe :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,957 ✭✭✭interested


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    hehehe :)

    Cute coming from the guy on here daily fretting about his ... hehehe ... 'stroke' :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Sat 2:10 hilly spin (52K, 529m elevation gain)

    Another early Saturday morning spin with Kirk. He's great for holding me to the correct pace, I have a tendency to expect all training should be hard, and these longer weekend spins should be easy. We got in some climbing almost despite ourselves, and again he showed the correct way to spin up a hill (vs. Mr. Grinderman here). As well as pointing out my skewers were sticking out too far, my chain needed oil, and my terrible cornering. A lot to learn! Done on the road bike, as the back was a bit sore, and I think I'll move to the roadie for the winter for most of my rides.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Sun 2,200m swim

    300sw,200p,100k
    4x50 fist + 10sec
    400p easy
    300sw steady
    200p steady
    100sw mod
    4x50 as 25 fast, 25 easy + 10sec
    4x50 choice easy

    Out for a meal last night, with an eternal red wine bottle. The days of suffering on Sunday are long gone, so a morning trip to the pool took care of any excess. Decent enough form.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Mon 3,050m Masters swim

    400m warm up
    6*75 (25k, 25drill, 25swim, 10s)
    Main set
    2*400 (1 min rest)
    First 400 +10s outside your PB (5:49)
    Second 400 +15s outside your PB (6:10)
    3*200 (45s rest)
    First 200 +5s outside your PB (2:55)
    Second 200 +10s outside your PB (3:05)
    Third 200 +15s outside your PB (3:10)
    4*100 (30s rest)
    First 100 +3s outside your PB (1:25)
    Second 100 +6s outside your PB (1:30)
    Third 100 +9s outside your PB (1:32)
    Fourth 100 +12s outside your PB (1:32)
    400m swim down (incl 300m hypoxic)

    Ah this was a tough set, I was hanging at the end. For reference my PB's for 400, 200, 100, are 5:50, 2:49, 1:17. Had a draft for the first half of the first 400, but held back from drafting after that. The 100's were hell on earth, I was hurting during them and didn't have great form.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,034 ✭✭✭griffin100


    Kurt_Godel wrote: »
    Mon 3,050m Masters swim

    400m warm up
    6*75 (25k, 25drill, 25swim, 10s)
    Main set
    2*400 (1 min rest)
    First 400 +10s outside your PB (5:49)
    Second 400 +15s outside your PB (6:10)
    3*200 (45s rest)
    First 200 +5s outside your PB (2:55)
    Second 200 +10s outside your PB (3:05)
    Third 200 +15s outside your PB (3:10)
    4*100 (30s rest)
    First 100 +3s outside your PB (1:25)
    Second 100 +6s outside your PB (1:30)
    Third 100 +9s outside your PB (1:32)
    Fourth 100 +12s outside your PB (1:32)
    400m swim down (incl 300m hypoxic)

    Ah this was a tough set, I was hanging at the end. For reference my PB's for 400, 200, 100, are 5:50, 2:49, 1:17. Had a draft for the first half of the first 400, but held back from drafting after that. The 100's were hell on earth, I was hurting during them and didn't have great form.

    Ouch.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Tue 8k easy run @ 4:50/km av

    Very busy day, had to swap round s turbo for a run this was easy pace but I felt great running for little perceived effort. The 3rd km had quickened despite trying to slow it down, and towards the end of it I felt a slight pull in the calf. I think the culprit is the 3/4 length tights I ran in, they are tight at the back of the knee. Into the bin with them.
    I jogged back without any trouble and it's not hurting now so I dodged a Bullet.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,888 ✭✭✭Dory Dory


    At what point did you take the tights off and toss them into the bin? Sounds like it was before you "jogged back without any trouble"...which begs the question....skivvies, was it?????


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,157 ✭✭✭Kurt_Godel


    Wed 2,500m swim

    200sw,2x100p,4x50k (3:21sw; 1:42, 1:41pb; k all 1:17)
    5x200p mod + 15sec (all 3:12-3:15)
    5x100sw hard + 10sec (1:27, 1:29, 1:31, 1:32, 1:32)
    4x50 as 25fast, 25 easy (fast all <20s)
    200 choice easy (last 100 BE 3, 5, 7, 9)

    What do I take from the above? A few things:
    1. Pull bouy times are a lot closer to swim times than they were before (albeit swim times are still faster). Suggesting leg positioning is an issue, but I think ease of breathing is an issue too.
    2. My easy swim pace isn't hugely different than my fast swim pace. I think the limiter here is breathing- I can cruise with decent breathing but "run out of steam" and start slowing (as per the fast 100's).
    3. My kick needs a lot of work!


  • Advertisement
Advertisement