Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Charleville Half-Marathon

«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭NoGutsNoGlory


    ran last year.. .... defo not worth the two and a half hour trip in the car to get there... the top was nice if your in to tops .. but as a race overrated..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 298 ✭✭redved


    ran last year.. .... defo not worth the two and a half hour trip in the car to get there... the top was nice if your in to tops .. but as a race overrated..

    Uh oh...I'm doing the 2 and a half hour drive for this. Hope its better than last year


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,844 ✭✭✭Cartman78


    ran last year.. .... defo not worth the two and a half hour trip in the car to get there... the top was nice if your in to tops .. but as a race overrated..

    Why did you think it was overrated?

    Haven't signed up yet and still flip-flopping between this and Galway Bay Half and the new Cork 10 miler


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 963 ✭✭✭chavezychavez


    Heat was a killer last year in fairness.
    Beautiful day and well run race, but was take note, the course may be flat enough when it comes to hills, but its by no means level. There are a few long drags in there as well.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,896 ✭✭✭Sacksian


    It's not pancake flat but it's definitely a fast course and should have a pretty deep field - was very well organised and had a really good atmosphere in 2012.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    I was considering this race but it's 40 euro plus booking fee. That's absolutely crazy. Most ten milers are 15-20 euro so how can 40 for a half marathon be acceptable? It is going up to 45e next week + booking fee will make it around 47e to enter if you are late getting in. It's a pity that Blarney isn't on because that has been my preference in the past and you could enter for 20e on the day. I hate paying out weeks or months before the event because I've been caught out too many times with my money going to waste.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 842 ✭✭✭mr.wiggle


    Easy there Hawley, I seem to remember a bit of a backlash on here last year when price increases were queried :eek:
    The number of participants this year will let us know what the public think of the
    race , one way or the other.
    I've run it the past two years and found it a well organised race with a monster feed at the end.

    Mr.W


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭NoGutsNoGlory


    Cartman78 wrote: »
    Why did you think it was overrated?

    Haven't signed up yet and still flip-flopping between this and Galway Bay Half and the new Cork 10 miler

    a lot of online hype about this race last year. and loads of advertising (not as much this year) like other posters it is not as flat as advertised . a few long drags especially in the 2nd half... i remember some problem with the the spilt times as well. .. i was just disappointed with the race in general .. and nearly every local race has a spread of food afterwards if thats your thing ..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,844 ✭✭✭Cartman78


    a lot of online hype about this race last year. and loads of advertising (not as much this year) like other posters it is not as flat as advertised . a few long drags especially in the 2nd half... i remember some problem with the the spilt times as well. .. i was just disappointed with the race in general .. and nearly every local race has a spread of food afterwards if thats your thing ..

    Cheers for getting back....might give this a miss altogether....hadn't realised the price was so exorbitant and won't be 100% sure of my availability on the day for another couple of weeks


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 591 ✭✭✭Cona


    Based on last year's thread the organisers will defend the cost of entry due to the fact that it is AIMS certified.
    I'm not sure that really matters to most people but they seem to place a large emphasis on it.

    Personally, I am looking for a half that week so it suits me to do it but would probably skip it due to the events either side of it which will be just as well organised ie Cork 10 miler and Cork to Cobh 15


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 498 ✭✭DOCO12


    I'm very disappointed to read bad reviews here, from last year's thread I thought this looked like a good option. Has anyone here ever done this and the Dublin half in the Phoenix park? I've to chose between the two,it's a long drive to both for me.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2 Charleville Intl Half Marathon


    We don't really mind when people provide constructive criticism of a particular aspect of the race but the above posts have failed to identify any one aspect which has not lived up to what was advertised ....... but at the same time complained simply because they didn't want to pay the entry fee.... We have demonstrated time and again why our event is better quality than most, but those who fail to appreciate real quality often miss all the small things that add up to provide this.

    Also, as a small voluntary athletics club, it takes a massive amount of time and resources to organise what is a fundraiser for our club and to give something back to the St Josephs Foundation for people with Special Needs who help us with facilities throughout the year. In previous years we had a lower entry fee but were only breaking even and as numbers increased we took on extra risk to pay for t-shirts, food, road closures in 2 counties and all other costs involved in such an event. This is a BIG risk for a small club to take on but we do so because we want to offer an event which is actually of better quality than most. We challenge anyone to point to events which offer all the quality aspects that we do that really matter to runners!

    The quality of the event is borne out by the fact that;
    1. Year on year we have had bigger and bigger numbers of entrants (from 400 to 800 in just 3 years)
    2. The top athletes who are on form come from far and wide to compete. Most don't even ask about the prizes - they are actually mostly just impressed with the race itself.
    3. Experienced club runners are prominent entrants in our event, indicating they identify the quality of our event. They aren't the kind of runners that enter just any event.

    So, again, we welcome all constructive criticism. However, I would ask you to consider that this is a 100% voluntary effort by our club so try to be a bit fair and give a more balanced criticism. The price is as fair as we can make it. I'd be interested to see if the above posters level the same level of proportional criticism at commercially organised events or is it that clubs are expected to not get anything from organising these events? Do the above posters think that we can make athletics and distance running sustainable in the long term and maintain a decent quality event with no reasonable finances to hand???? Are the above posters involved in athletics coaching/promotion/race organisation or any other role on a voluntary basis putting something back into the sport???

    Everyone's opinion is welcome and people are welcome to a bit of banter etc but the reality is that often this kind of ANONYMOUS criticism is damaging to those who are working hard for the sport with no personal reward. We are willing to compete with the commercial events but often it seems we are expected to not charge for the same, if not better quality events!!!
    Please take a minute before throwing out unconsidered, unbalanced and unqualified opinion. Don't just make an unqualified or unconsidered superficial judgement.

    We have proven that we are willing to do the kind of work that most other events don't want to do in order to promote the sport and bring some attention to it. How many other small-club events put together a competitive field with such depth as we do without offering any financial assistance to the athletes? e.g. see our elite athlete line-up this year!
    A lot of hurlers on the ditch complain about falling standards in Irish distance running but how many do something about it?

    If you believe in participating in supporting a real running race of high quality and want to support a voluntary athletics club who organises it and at the same time donates significantly to a worthy charity, then come to Charleville! You can choose the cheaper poor-quality events but you will pay for what you get. You can choose the more expensive commercial events with all the bells and whistles but you still won't feel like you ran in a real race. Real Runners choose the quality of Charleville designed for runners who want to run faster and for runners who want to enjoy a nice flat course that allows for easy pacing on good roads. see charleville half dot com for more info and registration! :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 207 ✭✭Tipp man running


    DOCO12 wrote: »
    I'm very disappointed to read bad reviews here, from last year's thread I thought this looked like a good option. Has anyone here ever done this and the Dublin half in the Phoenix park? I've to chose between the two,it's a long drive to both for me.

    Yip I've done both...Did the Dublin half about 4 yrs ago before Charleville started...while I enjoyed the Dublin Half and think its well run I would definitely prefer Charleville based on a few things; When I line up in Charleville I feel most people are there for business i.e.its their A goal...its long straight roads through the countryside makes it easy to run the racing line..no hills as such and a very good running surface...in general very professionally run. Unless you get very warm weather you have very little excuses on this course.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 498 ✭✭DOCO12


    Thanks Tipp man I'm going to sign up tomo. Looking forward to it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 239 ✭✭NoGutsNoGlory


    welcome to boards charlevill half .. as i already said .... ran last year.. .... defo not worth the two and a half hour trip in the car to get there... the top was nice if your in to tops .. but as a race overrated..

    i am a club runner "a real runner" as you say

    .. i'm train kids, i organize two local races in kilkenny for fund raising so i fully understand the finances involved.. i tick all your boxes ... and i avoid the money grabbing for profit events ......... but your attitude to the above posters (as you call them) is condescending.. on boards you have to take be able to take good with the bad. any way best of luck with the half ..i hope you raise loads of cash for your club!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58 ✭✭GoTheDistance


    How are the special Elite Places funded? I read on the Charleville Half Website that Elite Athletes can be sponsored with accommodation and meals.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 511 ✭✭✭EauRouge79


    for whats its worth, I ran this last year. Ran badly, but found it very well run event.... I will run it again in 2 weeks time, hopefully a good deal quicker!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    welcome to boards charlevill half .. as i already said .... ran last year.. .... defo not worth the two and a half hour trip in the car to get there... the top was nice if your in to tops .. but as a race overrated..

    i am a club runner "a real runner" as you say

    .. i'm train kids, i organize two local races in kilkenny for fund raising so i fully understand the finances involved.. i tick all your boxes ... and i avoid the money grabbing for profit events ......... but your attitude to the above posters (as you call them) is condescending.. on boards you have to take be able to take good with the bad. any way best of luck with the half ..i hope you raise loads of cash for your club!
    At the end of the day there is very little difference between most half marathons for runners. Nearly all ten mile/hm races have chip timing, a few water points, a t-shirt and a post-race buffet. The majority of the 800plus runners wouldn't care if there are any elite athletes running on the day, they are only interested in how they get along and having a nice day out. I ran this race in 2012 but the price has gone up since and I generally avoid the more expensive races. The course is grand, it is not very "fast" in my opinion more in the mid-range of events with a quick first five miles and a few tough ones at the end. There is a lot of hype surrounding the race every year.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 347 ✭✭dukeraoul


    Gonna have to admit the defensive attitude and over the top response by the organiser has really put me off this race....


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,844 ✭✭✭Cartman78


    Blah blah blah

    I'm a club runner who is also heavily involved in race organisation but not doing the Global International Charleville Half Marathon....does that make me a real runner?? :rolleyes:

    Seriously, I think anyone who regularly participates and/or organises races appreciates the huge effort and sacrifice that goes in to holding an event.

    Now and again, these people might express an opinion that the price being charged for that effort and sacrifice is a bit expensive. I think you need to take that criticism on the chin, suck it up and hope that enough people turn up on the day to make the event a success. Getting up on your hyperbolic high horse isn't very appealing and isn't really going to solve anything.

    Anyway, best of luck to all doing this, can't make it this year but might have a crack next year


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,402 ✭✭✭ger664


    I have absolutely no affiliation with orgainsing club but a key factor that is not been taken into consideration of the cost with the race is the fact the roads are officially closed.
    Is it fair to compare this race against races that dont have full closure ?
    Whats the cost of the National Half or Limerick/Cork city Half Marathons ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58 ✭✭GoTheDistance


    I'm looking forward to running the race despite finding the organiser's comments very defensive. I understand that Charleville are selling the very fast flat course, deep elite field, value etc. It's probably a little easier to have roads closed in Charleville than in Limerick or Cork. Then again the Connemara half essentially closes one of Connemara's most important roads and the race director has integrated this into cost/race day organisation ec.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,703 ✭✭✭PDCAT


    i ran this race last year. The heat absolutely killed me and i ended up walking towards the end. I found it extremely well organised, had shower facilities after the race. I liked the t shirt. I think it ticks all the boxes.
    However, i do agree with a previous poster - i don't think its as fast a course as say the Athlone half or maybe even Tullamore half. I completed the Tullamore half two weeks ago, it had everything that Charleville had as well and was really well organised. No road closures though, it cost 25 euro. Well worth it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    How are the special Elite Places funded? I read on the Charleville Half Website that Elite Athletes can be sponsored with accommodation and meals.
    Who do you think funds them? Looking at the website, elite athletes seem to get free entry, free accommodation and free meals. Maybe that's why the costs have increased for everyone else. Having ran the Blarney and Clonmel hm's in the past and heard good reports about Tullamore I'd say that they are on a par with Charleville but entry fees for these races are far lower. Basically people seem to be paying a premium in order to subsidise elite athletes.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58 ✭✭GoTheDistance


    I've only ran Kinvara, Galway Bay half, Connemara half, River Moy. It seems like the marathons in the Midlands and Dublin offer better value. Perhaps Charleville get sponsorship to have the elite athletes down? Maybe some local hotel(s) or B&B(s) give some rooms as sponsorhip? Still I'm looking forward to Charleville and my first half marathon in Munster.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 591 ✭✭✭Cona


    If you believe in participating in supporting a real running race of high quality and want to support a voluntary athletics club who organises it and at the same time donates significantly to a worthy charity, then come to Charleville! You can choose the cheaper poor-quality events but you will pay for what you get. You can choose the more expensive commercial events with all the bells and whistles but you still won't feel like you ran in a real race. Real Runners choose the quality of Charleville designed for runners who want to run faster and for runners who want to enjoy a nice flat course that allows for easy pacing on good roads. see charleville half dot com for more info and registration! :)

    For what its worth I have already signed up to this event this year. I ran it the first year and found it to be a decent event, flat enough course to give an attempt at a PB.

    However, I find the above statement the biggest load of TRIPE I have ever seen. I am almost sorry I have already signed up. I am still not clear what Charleville organisers seem to be imagining makes their event so high and mighty. Its a flat half marathon, with a bit of grub afterwards. I couldnt care less if Fr.WishyWashy runs the race or if Mo Farah takes part. Its not like I am going to see them or anything.

    "You pay for what you get" is pure cr*p. I have and will run in many races that are every bit as good as Charleville HM and will pay on a par or less in most cases.
    Real Runners choose the quality of Charleville designed for runners who want to run faster

    :rolleyes:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,304 ✭✭✭viperlogic


    Good interview here with the race director Michael Herlihy by John Desmond

    http://corkrunning.blogspot.ie/2014/09/q-with-michael-herlihy-race-director-of.html


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    viperlogic wrote: »
    Good interview here with the race director Michael Herlihy by John Desmond

    http://corkrunning.blogspot.ie/2014/09/q-with-michael-herlihy-race-director-of.html

    Just two points that I picked up from the interview with John Desmond.

    1. "I ended up flying to Milan and Berlin for half-marathons to run against athletes I didn’t know in fields that were dominated by Kenyans just to try to run fast times."

    Obviously he has a huge desire to run good times and probably wants to compete at a high level, but the majority of the people in the race are not at his level. Most people want to do as well as they can on the day but it's a hobby, we are not going to make any money from it. If someone does decide to run abroad it's usually just to experience something different.

    2."Some don’t like the idea of big prize money being given to the winning athletes but usually these people are unaware of the link between the inspiration that our top runners provide to young athletes in clubs around the country and the need to provide this inspiration to ensure that young athletes stay in the sport."

    It seems that he is handing out a lot in cash prizes. Most hms of this size would only give about 250 euro to the winner but I saw on the cork running blog that the winners got 700 euro in 2012.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,402 ✭✭✭ger664


    [RANT]So its a bad idea to hand out good prize money to some of our top athletes who get massive grants and make a very decent living from the sport or allow a club who have serious amounts on money in buried their bank accounts get more money.

    No we would all rather run the high 5 look at me Commercial all sing and all dance event for the same cost where very little if any funds go back to juvenile development.[/RANT]


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 842 ✭✭✭mr.wiggle


    Maybe just keep the defensive rethoric to a minimum and enhance the part about fundraising for an athletic track? Thats something that all runners, club runners or not, can understand.
    Be nice to have a proper running track in North cork that all local clubs could use.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58 ✭✭GoTheDistance


    The race director, in his interview with John, bemoans the lack of quality in races here. So he has to head off to European races instead to find quality and competition. Not exactly statistically strong but I've just checked back over the Ballycotton 10 mile results back to 2008 - the race director is not to be seen anywhere in any of these races. Is Ballycotton not high quality enough? Surely a trip to a 10 miler like this within your own county would greatly mitigate against the expenses of going for the same thing in Europe and he would be helping promote quality in the race. I know he may have been stewarding, volunteering etc at these races but surely not every year?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2 Charleville Intl Half Marathon


    Anyone who is interested in getting a good idea of what the Charleville International Half-Marathon event is actually like, just look at the post race reviews/reactions from previous years of our race.

    I will just correct some factual inaccuracies of some of the posts above - considering the level of conjecture that is off the mark;
    1. The Charleville Park Hotel provide the room and meals for a limited number of elite athletes - no race money is directly invested in supporting the athletes attendance at the race. The hotel wouldn't be able to provide any other type of sponsorship.
    2. We have an International licence which we paid for so as to help provide Irish athletes with better competition from abroad in Ireland. These athletes from abroad spend their own money to travel here. We see this as doing something positive for our sport.
    3. The athletes who attend our race are of a high standard but aren't of the standard that they receive grants - this is publicly available information if people want to check it.
    4. Prize money is there to be won by anyone in the race who is willing to train hard and long enough to win it. A basic idea of athletics/sport is to reward effort and dedication and we hold these characteristics up as positive characteristics to our athletes. There are events that don't do this and runners can choose to participate in those also and they will probably be cheaper to enter because of less risk and cost involved.

    Our race stands for more than just putting on an event for the masses because as an athletics club we see a responsibility to contribute to competitive athletics in Ireland, therefore there is greater cost and risk involved in our event. We also think we are entitled to get something from our efforts for organising the event, rather than just breaking even as we did in the first year or two of the event. People are welcome to disagree with this and we welcome any constructive argument against this. We also welcome anyone who wants to praise us for taking such risks for the betterment of competitive athletics and for the betterment of the sport overall :)

    I think its good that runners have a choice between
    1. events that are low cost and more participation orientated,
    2. events that are commercially orientated that offer all the entertainment, medals, bands, bells and whistles at a higher cost,
    3. our type of event which aims to offer a quality competitive athletics event at medium cost.

    People have a great choice of events these days compared to even just 10 years ago.
    Enjoy the choice lads! Enjoy the variety that our sport offers to runners of all levels of ability.
    Its great that our sport is so inclusive and that there isn't bias towards just competitive or just participation as you see in other sports.
    Keep it positive & constructive?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    2. The top athletes who are on form come from far and wide to compete. Most don't even ask about the prizes - they are actually mostly just impressed with the race itself.
    ! :)
    So, if the top athletes don't even ask about prizes and are so desperate to compete in an event where there is a strong field what is the need for such a large prize fund? Also. should said athletes be given free entry which in reality is being subsidised by the rest of the field. The majority of the field constitutes club runners and fun runners, housewives in their 30s and 40s etc. Why should they be asked to subsidise "elite runners". I think this kind of elitism creates a two tier system at the race. Elite runners are given free accommodation, free meals, free entry and get big prize money while the rest including good local club runners are there just to make up the numbers on the day. Most elite runners in Ireland do well enough from community/club races where the prize money is a subvention to their working income. Most runners would know by the age of 22 whether or not they can make it as a professional. There is not much scope for full time athletes in this country and I presume that most of the elite will also be in employment.
    If you want to raise money for the club there are numerous other ways of doing so but maybe you might raise as much if you cut the winner's purse to 150/200 euro. Obviously the club is entitled to turn a profit on the day but in my opinion this race now charges the same rates as commercial races and excludes many people from partaking on the day.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 58 ✭✭GoTheDistance


    I agree with the previous poster - cut the prize money to 150 or 200 euros and you'll very quickly see how even the sweetners of free hotel, free meals, free entry, free hotel shuttle etc won't bring the elites down.

    To expand on what the previous poster said: the elites are getting plenty of prize money week in and week out winning small community/club races where there is little or no competition for them. Would it not be better for the club to focus on growing an interest in athletics and running in North Cork rather than trying to build some type of special elite race where ordinary decent club runners are merely there to pay the bills for the top 10 men and women.

    I am annoyed by the Race Director's responses but I'm entered now. Charleville is just an hour's drive from my home. Why am I entering? I'm just a 1-35 half guy but I'm entering for a well organised half marathon close to home. I couldn't care less how many elites show up. I do care that part of my entry fee is indirectly going into their pockets.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,549 ✭✭✭✭Krusty_Clown


    Are these complaints for real?. Too much prize money? Too far away? As the RD pointed out - there's plenty of choice out there. If you don't like it go do some other race. Crazy complaints.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 784 ✭✭✭Stazza


    I know, it's nuts; they could come and do the Tralee Half - it's only 50 Euro. But there's a good chance they won't be able to get their medal and banana because they'll get killed on the road out to Ardfert.

    The Tralee 10k (no T-shirt and the roads weren't closed) cost 26.50. How somebody wasn't killed going up the Caherslee Road was beyond me.

    The Charleville Half has already developed a great reputation and more of these races are needed to lift the level of competition/standard in Ireland.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,620 ✭✭✭ultrapercy


    Fair play Krusty and Stazza for brining some objective reason to the thread. I think Charleville areto be congratulated for trying to promote senior athletics proactively rather than just complaining about the state of things(like I do:)). If your not happy with a race choose another or set up your own.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,170 ✭✭✭Hard Worker


    The vast majority of races offer a free entry to elite athletes. Most would give petrol money also. I cannot see how anyone could begrudge an athlete some decent prize money when you consider how hard they train. I've seen golfers in this country finishing 46th in a tournament and picking up 40000 euro. They can do that every week.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,370 ✭✭✭pconn062


    Have to agree, while I would never personally dream of paying €45 to enter a race, it's good to see a race trying to put a little into the elite running scene in Ireland, nothing wrong with top runners earning good money from race and if you don't like the price, then simply don't enter and find a different race.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    Are these complaints for real?. Too much prize money? Too far away? As the RD pointed out - there's plenty of choice out there. If you don't like it go do some other race. Crazy complaints.
    1.Yes2.Yes, in my opinion there is too much prize money being given out. The winners got 700 euro each in 2012 with fewer numbers entering, so the winners purse could possibly be 1000 euro now(it doesn't give it on the website). Giving the top 8 in each sex a cash prize is a bit much and all these positions are likely to be filled by elite athletes who got all the free entry, hotel, meals etc.
    3.Where does anyone say that the race is too far away?

    I just happen to think that 45 euro is excessive for a provincial hm(Dublin hm on the same day is 20 euro). Do Clonmel, Tullamore etc. give free entry plus perks to elite athletes. I don't believe that most races do. Does anyone seriously believe that the elites aren't attracted by the huge pot on offer and if the hotel are giving free board to runners it negates the potential for any pecuniary embellishment to the club, therefore this is another cost burden for the majority.. It seems that the organiser wants to promote the race as an elite event but he shouldn't forget that it's the middle-aged housewives who are keeping athletics alive in this country.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,549 ✭✭✭✭Krusty_Clown


    hawley wrote: »
    1.Yes2.Yes, in my opinion there is too much prize money being given out. The winners got 700 euro each in 2012 with fewer numbers entering, so the winners purse could possibly be 1000 euro now(it doesn't give it on the website). Giving the top 8 in each sex a cash prize is a bit much and all these positions are likely to be filled by elite athletes who got all the free entry, hotel, meals etc.
    3.Where does anyone say that the race is too far away?
    1. Ridiculous.
    2. Don't do it.
    3. "It's not worth the 2.5 hour trip in the car to get there".


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,315 ✭✭✭hawley


    1. Ridiculous.
    2. Don't do it.
    3. "It's not worth the 2.5 hour trip in the car to get there".

    1.Why ridiculous? I'm not going to write it all again but in my opinion we are all paying for their excessive prize money and it's not as if these runners don't take part in races in Ireland and that they need to be attracted into the country in order to inspire Irish kids.
    2.I'm still undecided on this
    3.That point was made in relation to the race being billed as the fastest hm in the country. The poster was giving advice to the OP, basically said that he didn't feel that it was correct and that it wouldn't be worthwhile for someone to travel across the country believing it to be a such as fast course.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,402 ✭✭✭ger664


    hawley wrote: »
    I just happen to think that 45 euro is excessive for a provincial hm

    It is not a provincial Half Marathon it is an International Half Marathon. This requires a completely different permit from AAI which is ten times the cost of your standard club race permit.
    For such a race to hold any sort of credibility on the international stage they have to offer decent prize money, invite and put up the top runners. Yes us the participants further down the field ultimately pay/fund this. While some couldn't care less about who runs at the top end of these fields I think North Cork are to be applauded it trying to add a race of depth and quality to the Irish Road Racing scene.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,148 ✭✭✭rom


    A closed mouth catches no flies


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 19,549 ✭✭✭✭Krusty_Clown


    hawley wrote: »
    1.Why ridiculous?
    I probably shouldn't bother as the same basic point seems not to be gathering any traction but...
    we are all paying for their excessive prize money
    Only if you choose to enter the race. If you do not, then you are not paying for anything. Charleville are selling a product. Just like a mobile phone, if you don't like the features, don't buy it.
    2.I'm still undecided on this
    Your 'decision' is irrelevant. This is how this race organizer has chosen how to structure 'their' race.
    it wouldn't be worthwhile for someone to travel across the country
    Most races that are a 2.5 hour drive away are considered not worth travelling to, by somebody. It's not useful feedback. It translates to 'the race is too far to travel to'. In the interest of openness and honesty, I have never done Charleville Half marathon, as I believe that Athlone is the flag bearer for value for money when it comes down to price, product, and quality. I may do Charleville some year, particularly if I ever get to that sub 74 mark (unlikely), but I reckon that Charleville have their work cut out for them, to offer a better product than Athlone does. Have you done Athlone HM hawley - or is it just not worthwhile for someone to travel across the country for it?

    Also, in the interests of openness and honesty, do you have any associations with rival clubs or rival races in the area?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 558 ✭✭✭clear thinking


    What a bizzare thread.

    A half marathon for €40. Seems fair enough. Showers at the end, goody bag, facilities etc.

    Remind me the price of the R'N'R somebody?

    Lots of people travel to soulless kips on the continent like rotterdam and shell out way more.

    Frankly the organiser is well justified saying two words to the criticism, rather than taking time to address it. Maybe some posters don't like being caught out being critical for the sake of it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,049 ✭✭✭groovyg


    What a bizzare thread.
    +1
    I dunno how this thread disintegrated so much. I drove down from Dublin last year to do this race and couldn't find any fault with it. I thought it was brilliantly organised event. As for the price of the event, I have wasted a hell of lot more on nights out down through the years with nothing to show for it but a sore head! So if €40 gets me a pb on decent course I have no problem paying it.

    As for the prize money and elites raking it in!! Is that a joke? If the top Irish marathoners were making a living from running then why are most of them working in full time jobs in addition to running 100+miles a week. If a race like Charelville gets good group of the elite guys in to race against each other then there is more potential for them to improve their times.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,800 ✭✭✭thirstywork2




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,304 ✭✭✭viperlogic


    Good luck to all today.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,047 ✭✭✭Itziger


    Stazza wrote: »
    I know, it's nuts; they could come and do the Tralee Half - it's only 50 Euro. But there's a good chance they won't be able to get their medal and banana because they'll get killed on the road out to Ardfert.

    The Tralee 10k (no T-shirt and the roads weren't closed) cost 26.50. How somebody wasn't killed going up the Caherslee Road was beyond me.

    The Charleville Half has already developed a great reputation and more of these races are needed to lift the level of competition/standard in Ireland.

    Folks, I've said it before, but this has to be sorted. I might sound like the old 'continental' snob but where I run, this is unthinkable. What is it with Ireland and roads not closed. Jesus, you'd think it was Manhattan or LA they were trying to deal with. Wasn't there a problem with the Limerick marathon where runners were saying they had about 3 feet of space and clipped a few bollards. Complain, before someone is killed for Crissake or boycott races where runners are competing with cars.

    Hope Charleville went well today for all concerned. Cool half million for the winner, was it?


  • Advertisement
Advertisement