Manchester United Superthread 2014 mod warning #8081

keane2097

McCarthy is criminally underrated by Irish people.

tallaghtmick

UnitedIrishman wrote: »

But a step below top four/titles which is what we're aiming for, and Champions League beyond that.

McCarthy wasn't even the best midfielder in his team last year and the guy who was can't get in a top four side.

xtal191 wrote: »

Get in two starting midfielders and then Carrick, Cleverley, Fellaini and Fletcher will be squad players. So yeah we def dont need to be wasting money on squad players.

I'd rather not have Cleverley or Fletcher as squad players.

homerjay2005 wrote: »

do we? we have more squad players than anyother club in the world. what we lack, is world class players.

that part, is not even up for debate. the signings we need this summer need to go straight into the first 11, not on the bench to play against the likes of Stoke and Sunderland.

Em yes we do, if we sign new midfielders they cant play every game, even our superstar signing Fellaini got injured for most of last year, bitch and moan all you like but we need new squad players.

NoviGlitzko

keane2097 wrote: »

McCarthy is criminally underrated by Irish people.

Why? What exactly does he do apart from distribute reasonably well, decent positional sense, and can tackle? He's like our Michael Carrick except younger.

homerjay2005

tallaghtmick wrote: »

I'd rather not have Cleverley or Fletcher as squad players.



Em yes we do, if we sign new midfielders they cant play every game, even our superstar signing Fellaini got injured for most of last year, bitch and moan all you like but we need new squad players.

Carrick and Fellaini become our squad players if we have proper first 11 players in there.

Carrick and fellaini will do grand against most teams from 7-20 in the league, theres enough games in there for them. we do however lack quality to beat the first 6 teams.

UnitedIrishman

tallaghtmick wrote: »

Em yes we do, if we sign new midfielders they cant play every game, even our superstar signing Fellaini got injured for most of last year, bitch and moan all you like but we need new squad players.

Which would be Carrick, Fellaini and others. We need two top class midfielders. Simple as.

Liverpool have played the same 3-4 center midfielders all season because they were not in Europe. The same team can play week to week.

As for McCarthy being underrated, I think he's a decent player but he hasn't kicked on like I thought he would. He doesn't dominate games like I thought he would and I've seen a lot of big games bypass him. If you're going to be a central midfield player at the top of the table then you're going to have to dictate, dominate or create in almost every game.

keane2097

NoviGlitzko wrote: »

Why? What exactly does he do apart from distribute reasonably well, decent positional sense, and can tackle? He's like our Michael Carrick except younger.

Because "reasonably", and "decent", and "can tackle" at the same time as "like Michael Carrick".

Lord TSC

homerjay2005 wrote: »

Carrick and Fellaini become our squad players if we have proper first 11 players in there.

Carrick and fellaini will do grand against most teams from 7-20 in the league, theres enough games in there for them. we do however lack quality to beat the first 6 teams.

You're also presuming that if this option was put to Carrick and Fel, they wouldn't say "No, I want first team football or I'm off". Or that as our new manager, LVG might see McCarthy as a better option as a squad player than those two.

Also, reading the article which caused this fuss, it said Everton are trying to open up contract negotiations with McCarthy. In other words, this is more than likely his agent linking him to us to get a contract bump...

tallaghtmick

Thing is McCarthy is better than our squad players, so would it not be smart to have better squad players

RasTa

They only signed him when we got Fellani, paying £13m. I can't find the contract length but it suggests a long term deal so would be surprised if he is getting a new contract already.

glued

keane2097 wrote: »

McCarthy is criminally underrated by Irish people.

His name isn't exotic enough... NEXT!

James McCarthy>>>>>Ander Herrera

aperture_nuig

glued wrote: »

His name isn't exotic enough... NEXT!

James McCarthy>>>>>Ander Herrera

His name isn't exotic enough, but he's much greater than Ander Herrera?

DARK-KNIGHT

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

That would only be one Irish signing. :pac:

Irish internationals then......

redbaron_99

from Fabregas and Kroos to Clasie and McCarthy in one day. haha. Another agonizing summer in store so it seems.

Will I Amnt

keane2097 wrote: »

McCarthy is criminally underrated by Irish people.

I rate him quite highly and you will find posts I've made here to back that up. I would have been happy to have him when he was at Wigan as another option but if he's the main target this season I'll be very unimpressed.

UnitedIrishman

Yeah, because we don't rate McCarthy because his name isn't foreign enough. :rolleyes:

redbaron_99

Will I Amnt wrote: »

I rate him quite highly and you will find posts I've made here to back that up. I would have been happy to have him when he was at Wigan as another option but if he's the main target this season I'll be very unimpressed.

I'd be of a similar mind. I wouldn't have a problem with McCarthy coming in, but only alongside a genuinely top midfielder.

keane2097

glued wrote: »

His name isn't exotic enough... NEXT!

James McCarthy>>>>>Ander Herrera

The Ander Herrera comparison had crossed my mind a fair bit in the last few hours.

Will I Amnt wrote: »

I rate him quite highly and you will find posts I've made here to back that up. I would have been happy to have him when he was at Wigan as another option but if he's the main target this season I'll be very unimpressed.

Oh yeah like he's not going to be knocking on the door of the world team of the year next year like, but he'd be a very solid signing with a lot of upside.

Unearthly

McCarthy is a good player but I think Everton got him at the correct price. He would be costing a lot more now I'd imagine

Maximus Alexander

redbaron_99 wrote: »

from Fabregas and Kroos to Clasie and McCarthy in one day. haha. Another agonizing summer in store so it seems.

Be grand. Signings will happen. Ultimately, I expect the squad to look like this quality wise next season:

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

-PREMIER LEAGUE----WORLD CLASS---PREMIER LEAGUE----WORLD CLASS-

---

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

---

-PREMIER LEAGUE

---

PREMIER LEAGUE-

---

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

---

WORLD CLASS

---

Will I Amnt

http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showpost.php?p=78170379&postcount=2562

There's what I said about McCarthy over 2 years ago and it's word for word exactly the same as my opinion today.

redbaron_99

Maximus Alexander wrote: »

Be grand. Signings will happen. Ultimately, I expect the squad to look like this quality wise next season:

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

-PREMIER LEAGUE----WORLD CLASS---PREMIER LEAGUE----WORLD CLASS-

---

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

---

-PREMIER LEAGUE

---

PREMIER LEAGUE-

---

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

---

WORLD CLASS

---

I expect something like this:

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

-INJURED

---

PREMIER LEAGUE

---

INJURED

---

WORLD CLASS-

---

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

CHAMPIONSHIP

---

---

-PREMIER LEAGUE

---

PREMIER LEAGUE-

---

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

---

INJURED

---

Son Of A Vidic

Maximus & Red, love this new team line up format your using.

Lord TSC

RasTa wrote: »

They only signed him when we got Fellani, paying £13m. I can't find the contract length but it suggests a long term deal so would be surprised if he is getting a new contract already.

Chances are it's not cause it's about to run out but because he feels he can get an improvement. Plenty of contracts get renegotiated after the first season if the player (and his agent) feel he's deserving of a bump.

redbaron_99

Corvus Maximus wrote: »

Maximus & Red, love this new team line up format your using.

Join us

Al Capwned

I've just realised that there are two seperate posters called Maximus Alexander and Corvus Maximus.

Sorry lads.

Maximus Alexander

Al Capwned wrote: »

I've just realised that there are two seperate posters called Maximus Alexander and Corvus Maximus.

Sorry lads.

I feel bad for Corvus now since you've clearly been attributing my ridiculous opinions to him!

bangkok

david luiz to psg 50m?!!!!!!! crazy

Mikeyt086

UnitedIrishman wrote: »

Yeah, because we don't rate McCarthy because his name isn't foreign enough. :rolleyes:

Makes sense.

Sure we only praise De Gea, Mata, Kagawa and Hernandez because we're all gay for them.

Maximus Alexander

Mikeyt086 wrote: »

Makes sense.

Sure we only praise De Gea, Mata, Kagawa and Hernandez because we're all gay for them.

They're just so pretty.

Son Of A Vidic

redbaron_99 wrote: »

Join us

o.k. but you might find this a bit overly ambitious........

---

WORLD CLASS

---

---

INJURED

---

INJURED

---

INJURED

---

INJURED

---

---

INJURED

---

INJURED

---

---INJURED

---

INJURED--

---

---

INJURED

---

---

---

INJURED

---

:pac: