Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Afraid to call in sick. :(

  • 18-12-2012 07:38PM
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,091 ✭✭✭


    Hi,

    I'm wondering if I could get some advice.

    I changed jobs in October, the job I was in previous to that, I very rarely called in sick unless I absolutely had to, and would sometimes come in when I probably shouldn't.

    In my new job I'm on probation for six months, two weeks ago my mum got really ill and I had to call in for two days and head home which is on the other end of the country, and with all the stress of that I caught a cold last week. When I came back, I had a back to work interview that was basically told that sick days is something that they look at when they're deciding who to give permanent contracts to, and to not develop any bad patterns.

    I went in for three days last week and I had two days off (Thursday and Friday) and spent as much time as I could resting, but on Sunday I started getting chest pains and had trouble breathing, and my boyfriend's mother dragged me to the doctor on Monday morning before I went to work.

    I was told I have a chest infection, and pulled muscles from coughing, and she tried to cert me off for the week. I took a cert for two days, but she wants me to take the week, and I'm on very strong antibiotics and anti-inflammatories since Monday.

    I thought I'd be feeling much better today but I'm not, I'm weak as a kitten and I'm really sweating from a temp. I'm due to be working til Friday, and then Xmas Eve, and then back on the 27th and 28th of December.

    Should I just go in and work away, or should I take the week off? I'm really really afraid that I won't get the job because of this as a permanent contract is a really difficult thing to get from them, only 10% of the previous applicants were successful after probation, and I can't afford to lose this job. :(


«13456789

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,263 ✭✭✭✭Eoin


    I know it's easy for me to say - but absolutely take the week off before you get even sicker. Deal with the work stuff when you're in a fit state, you'll be no good to them if you're as ill as you say.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda


    Hi,

    I'm wondering if I could get some advice.

    I changed jobs in October, the job I was in previous to that, I very rarely called in sick unless I absolutely had to, and would sometimes come in when I probably shouldn't.

    In my new job I'm on probation for six months, two weeks ago my mum got really ill and I had to call in for two days and head home which is on the other end of the country, and with all the stress of that I caught a cold last week. When I came back, I had a back to work interview that was basically told that sick days is something that they look at when they're deciding who to give permanent contracts to, and to not develop any bad patterns.

    I went in for three days last week and I had two days off (Thursday and Friday) and spent as much time as I could resting, but on Sunday I started getting chest pains and had trouble breathing, and my boyfriend's mother dragged me to the doctor on Monday morning before I went to work.

    I was told I have a chest infection, and pulled muscles from coughing, and she tried to cert me off for the week. I took a cert for two days, but she wants me to take the week, and I'm on very strong antibiotics and anti-inflammatories since Monday.

    I thought I'd be feeling much better today but I'm not, I'm weak as a kitten and I'm really sweating from a temp. I'm due to be working til Friday, and then Xmas Eve, and then back on the 27th and 28th of December.

    Should I just go in and work away, or should I take the week off? I'm really really afraid that I won't get the job because of this as a permanent contract is a really difficult thing to get from them, only 10% of the previous applicants were successful after probation, and I can't afford to lose this job. :(


    They sound like a right shower of ******.
    I still am amazed at how unbelievable some employers can be regarding their expectations of employers who work for them.

    Ultimately your health should be the first priority. What is your direct manager like? Can you call them and explain that you are I'll.

    Tbh If you are not fit to work then don't. You risk your own health as well as the health if collegues you work with.

    At the end of the day a company who treats its employees with so little consideration is more than likley not going to be a good employer.


    Many employers don't even bother to pay employees sick pay and yet they expect employees to bend themselves over backward even against medical advice to 'make up' the time. Simply unbelievable tbh ...

    Its Christmas - Scrooge is alive and well & Tiny Tim might as well go and jump....


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,380 ✭✭✭O.A.P


    Stay at home until you are well enough to work again.
    I learned this the hard way kept coming to work with the flu until I got pneumonia, Then spent two weeks in hospital and four weeks at home recovering.
    All because I needed to take a few days off at the end of that month :o


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,224 ✭✭✭Procrastastudy


    OP sorry to come in and be the barer of bad news but you have to see this from the employers point of view. Make sure you are in daily contact with your line manager and I would suggest requesting a meeting upon your return. At that meeting I would offer them your permission to check with your previous employer that you had a good attendance record (assuming you do) and that you would be more than willing to extend your probationary period due to them not getting a good picture of the 'real you'. Make sure all your sickness is properly certified.

    Realistically most employers say three months or six months but really everyone is on 12 months probation anyway. The only way to play this one is to play Ms Co-operative. It's simply not worth the risk to an employer to be stuck with someone with poor attendance these days. That said - played right there is no need for this to be a massive issue.

    Remember the MOST IMPORTANT thing is your health.

    EDIT: I'd also offer (if you are 100% sure you'll be recovered) to do some unsocial hours like New Years eve and day if they need cover. Don't offer this if there is even a 0.1% chance of letting them down.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,091 ✭✭✭hattoncracker


    OP sorry to come in and be the barer of bad news but you have to see this from the employers point of view. Make sure you are in daily contact with your line manager and I would suggest requesting a meeting upon your return. At that meeting I would offer them your permission to check with your previous employer that you had a good attendance record (assuming you do) and that you would be more than willing to extend your probationary period due to them not getting a good picture of the 'real you'. Make sure all your sickness is properly certified.

    Realistically most employers say three months or six months but really everyone is on 12 months probation anyway. The only way to play this one is to play Ms Co-operative. It's simply not worth the risk to an employer to be stuck with someone with poor attendance these days. That said - played right there is no need for this to be a massive issue.

    Remember the MOST IMPORTANT thing is your health.

    EDIT: I'd also offer (if you are 100% sure you'll be recovered) to do some unsocial hours like New Years eve and day if they need cover. Don't offer this if there is even a 0.1% chance of letting them down.

    Yeah, I know.. :( I'll be having a meeting if I go back tomorrow-but I'm afraid to go back tomorrow in case it makes me worse and I have to call in Thursday or Friday. Aaah!! I'm a bit torn, tbh. If I knew that they didn't think I was taking the piss then I'd be ok with it. But I don't know. I'm already working Christmas Eve, the 27th and the 28th (my birthday), and NYE so it's not like I don't have any anti-social hours ahead of me!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda



    Yeah, I know.. :( I'll be having a meeting if I go back tomorrow-but I'm afraid to go back tomorrow in case it makes me worse and I have to call in Thursday or Friday. Aaah!! I'm a bit torn, tbh. If I knew that they didn't think I was taking the piss then I'd be ok with it. But I don't know. I'm already working Christmas Eve, the 27th and the 28th (my birthday), and NYE so it's not like I don't have any anti-social hours ahead of me!


    Tbh 'meetings' because you have been out sick is a bit of a joke. Tbh.

    Did you get a medical cert? If you did hand it to them and politly but firmly stand your ground. Be clear and concise with facts. You were Sick and were advised to stay of work on medical grounds. If they think you are "taking the piss" that's their problem. This amounts to them being unreasonable and bullying imo.

    HC - try not to think about this too much - it can make it harder to get better if you are feeling stressed or anxious.

    Hope you are feeling better soon.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,263 ✭✭✭✭Eoin


    gozunda wrote: »
    Tbh 'meetings' because you have been out sick is a bit of a joke. Tbh.

    Did you get a medical cert? If you did hand it to them and politly but firmly stand your ground. Be clear and concise with facts. You were Sick and were advised to stay of work on medical grounds. If they think you are "taking the piss" that's their problem. This amounts to them being unreasonable and bullying imo.

    HC - try not to think about this too much - it can make it harder to get better if you are feeling stressed or anxious.

    Hope you are feeling better soon.

    For a start, those meetings can be a good idea to make sure that the person is fit to return to work, confirm that there are no factors in work causing it etc - it doesn't have to have a negative or accusatory tone to it.

    Also, no - it's not just their problem. For a start, if you're on probation and can be let go very easily. You do not hold the upper hand by any means. Not to mention that disciplinary procedures can be followed for absenteeism, no matter how genuine the illness (if you're probation or not).

    As I said earlier, the OP has to look after their health first - but it's not a good idea to assume that there's no chance of any blowback just because you've a sick cert.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 28,974 ✭✭✭✭drunkmonkey


    Yeah, I know.. :( I'll be having a meeting if I go back tomorrow-but I'm afraid to go back tomorrow in case it makes me worse and I have to call in Thursday or Friday.

    Cracker, you have a cough and a cold, your not on deaths door, it's Christmas week and your not showing up. I know your sick but if your that sick they'll send you home anyway once you turn up, nobody wants somebody coughing and spluttering on them this time of year. (especially if your in the Hospitality industry?).
    If your in a Job that winds down at Christmas you could probably stay at home, but if your on probation in a business that is busy at Christmas and somebody else has to carry the can for you I wouldn't fancy your chances of holding on to the Job.
    Go in to work. If you had the flu I'd understand but taking a week off for a cold is a bit much.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda


    Eoin wrote: »

    For a start, those meetings can be a good idea to make sure that the person is fit to return to work, confirm that there are no factors in work causing it etc - it doesn't have to have a negative or accusatory tone to it.

    Also, no - it's not just their problem. For a start, if you're on probation and can be let go very easily. You do not hold the upper hand by any means. Not to mention that disciplinary procedures can be followed for absenteeism, no matter how genuine the illness (if you're probation or not).

    As I said earlier, the OP has to look after their health first - but it's not a good idea to assume that there's no chance of any blowback just because you've a sick cert.


    My point is the OP has a sick note relative to a chest infection and torn muscles from coughing. Not just a 'cold'

    Company Staff are not qualified to check or verify if a staff member is medically fit or otherwise. The medical note will state why the OP was out. There is no need for the Spanish inquisition tbh.

    I'm sorry but no there cannot be disciplinary action held against an employee for being sick - that suggestion is itself sick.

    If the company is that analy retentive regarding genuine illness then they are potentially going to bigger issues to deal with due to unfair work practices

    As I suggested OP - Attend the 'meeting' be polite with medical cert details and stand your ground. Tbh it is sad but it sounds like the OP is absolutely petrified at the companies attitudes. This is hardly conducive to a good working environment.


  • Moderators, Business & Finance Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 51,690 Mod ✭✭✭✭Stheno


    gozunda wrote: »
    My point is the OP has a sick note.
    Company Staff are not qualified to check or verify if a staff member is medically fit or otherwise. The medical note will state why the OP was out. There is no need for the Dpanish inquisition tbh.

    I'm sorry but no there cannot be disciplinary action held against an employee for being sick - that suggestion is itself sick.

    If the company is that analy retentive regarding genuine illness then they are potentially going to bigger issues to deal with due to unfair work practices

    As I suggested OP - Attend the 'meeting' be polite with medical cert details and stand your ground. Tbh it is sad but it sounds like the OP is absolutely petrified at the companies attitudes. This is hardly conducive to a good working environment.

    Gozunda

    You are talking complete bollox to be honest.
    Having worked in companies like that, if staff were on the level and trusted they would'nt do the interviews, and I've worked in plenty of companies where they didn't and faced the sack.

    OP needs to talk to his/her superior and understand the criteria to be made permanent.

    OP also needs to be job hunting for a new job as they are temporary


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,224 ✭✭✭Procrastastudy


    gozunda wrote: »
    My point is the OP has a sick note.
    Company Staff are not qualified to check or verify if a staff member is medically fit or otherwise. The medical note will state why the OP was out. There is no need for the Dpanish inquisition tbh.

    I'm sorry but no there cannot be disciplinary action held against an employee for being sick - that suggestion is itself sick.

    If the company is that analy retentive regarding genuine illness then they are potentially going to bigger issues to deal with due to unfair work practices

    As I suggested OP - Attend the 'meeting' be polite with medical cert details and stand your ground. Tbh it is sad but it sounds like the OP is absolutely petrified at the companies attitudes. This is hardly conducive to a good working environment.

    People forget that even if you are genuinely sick it can get to the point that you'll be let go for not fulfilling your contract. Employers know this and use the probationary period as a yard stick.

    It has to be seen from both sides.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,263 ✭✭✭✭Eoin


    gozunda wrote: »
    I'm sorry but no there cannot be disciplinary action held against an employee for being sick - that suggestion is itself sick.

    This is incorrect - see this page.
    If illness or injury is at issue, it is often assumed that you cannot be dismissed fairly while on certified sick leave from your work. However, this is not true. It is difficult to lay down hard and fast rules to apply to these cases as each will be treated on its own merits. Issues such as length of service, previous record and the importance of the job will vary and will have to be taken into account.

    Regardless, no disciplinary procedures need be followed at all while on probation.

    I don't want to panic the OP, but it's not a good idea to give incorrect information.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,268 ✭✭✭✭uck51js9zml2yt


    If you are medically certified to be off sick then you are not insured to be in work. I often sent guys home even when I was desperate and needed them to work.

    Also, going in does no one any favours. You get sicker and your colleagues get sick.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda



    People forget that even if you are genuinely sick it can get to the point that you'll be let go for not fulfilling your contract. Employers know this and use the probationary period as a yard stick.

    It has to be seen from both sides.

    Tbh that kind of kick off takes a hell of a lot of time out sick. Not short periods that are medically certified. Trouble with these type of set ups is that unfortunately no balance of sides. As I said this type of management is not condusive to a good working environment.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda


    Eoin wrote: »

    This is incorrect - see this page.

    Regardless, no disciplinary procedures need be followed at all while on probation.

    I don't want to panic the OP, but it's not a good idea to give incorrect information.

    This is not incorrect

    My point was that an employee can not be disciplined for being 'sick' - I did not say for 'being out sick'

    However for correct information in context for the OP I have abstracted the following from your link

    Dismissal related to short-term illness generally occurs where you have a medical problem that results in frequent absences for short periods from the workplace. Assuming that the genuine nature of your problem was not in question, your employer will have to show that a pattern of absence exists, that it is causing problems, that the problem is unlikely to get better and that you have been warned that dismissal is likely.

    The onus is on the employer to show a persistent pattern. Hardly the case in normal illness type situations.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 21,263 ✭✭✭✭Eoin


    gozunda wrote: »
    Tbh that kind of kick off takes a hell of a lot of time out sick. Not short periods that are medically certified. Trouble with these type of set ups is that unfortunately no balance of sides. As I said this type of management is not condusive to a good working environment.

    Regular short absences are just as likely to cause it - possibly more so. But again, the OP is on probation. They can let him/her go tomorrow without following any procedures.

    It might not be the sign of a particularly flexible company to work for, or hopefully the company just does this during probation just to scare people off pulling sickies when they start, and relax soon after.

    But either way, the point is that the OP does not have a particularly strong position to dig his/her heels in, so I don't think you're giving very good advice.

    @hattoncracker - hopefully this is all academic arguing and they'll be reasonable when you return. But you don't sound like you're in a good state at the moment, so just worry about getting better and maybe keep in contact with your line manager as suggested.
    The onus is on the employer to show a persistent pattern. Hardly the case in normal illness type situations.

    Fair point - but while on probation it's irrelevant.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,091 ✭✭✭hattoncracker



    Cracker, you have a cough and a cold, your not on deaths door, it's Christmas week and your not showing up. I know your sick but if your that sick they'll send you home anyway once you turn up, nobody wants somebody coughing and spluttering on them this time of year. (especially if your in the Hospitality industry?).
    If your in a Job that winds down at Christmas you could probably stay at home, but if your on probation in a business that is busy at Christmas and somebody else has to carry the can for you I wouldn't fancy your chances of holding on to the Job.
    Go in to work. If you had the flu I'd understand but taking a week off for a cold is a bit much.


    With respect, it was a cough and a cold last week. Now its a chest infection and I'm quite unwell. If it was a cough and a cold then id just be going in like I was last week-and I'm on some heavy duty meds for the infection.

    My job is an inbound call centre so its hard not to cough as I spend all day talking.

    But you are right, I think maybe I'll just suck this one up.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,080 ✭✭✭foxinsox


    A lot of companies do "Back to Work" meetings after an employee absence. I remember the main reason when I used to do them in an old job was to genuinely make sure the employee was ok to work.

    @ OP

    Many years ago I would have worried about it like you are..

    But as I've got older I've realised that your health is more important than anything else.

    That sounds crap I know, it won't pay the bills.
    It may affect whether you get the full time position or not.

    But, in the grand scheme of things, life, the universe and stuff: you being well in life is much more important than any job.

    I know it's hard and probably wrecking your head, which is not helping your health.

    Could you survive if you didn't have a job?

    Yes, you could, it might not be fun but I'm sure you would be ok.

    It's not just a cold you have, only you can decide if you really are able for work. If you really aren't, just call in sick, say you are really sorry to let them down but you are feeling awful and have to return to your doctor tomorrow. Phone to doctors surgery and ask for another cert.

    Hope you feel better soon :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 28,974 ✭✭✭✭drunkmonkey



    But you are right, I think maybe I'll just suck this one up.

    Your well able for it don't be a bit worried, tell them at the interview your hopefully over the worst of it, if your still crook at the end of the day head over to your boss and say it to them.
    I'm an ex-smoker and an employer if you gave me that torn muscles in your chest excuse i'd laugh and start plotting how to get rid of you for being too soft!!
    Work could be a bit of a giggle christmas week anyway, makes the best of it, it's a good time to bond with other staff...probably plenty of prizes & gifts floating around as well.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,332 ✭✭✭tatli_lokma


    OP, as others have said, try not to stress too much about it. I understand that you are worried due to having a 'back to work' interview last time. But for perspective, I would say that in large companies, particularly call centre environments, they do tend to hold the reigns quite tight when it comes to unscheduled absence. This is so that across all departments things are run the same. Cynically, I would also think that they know full well that the environment is stressful and that people may well pull sickies because they weren't up to facing work some days. So knowing this, they actively discourage uncertified or unscheduled sickness leave by reminding you that regular absence is potentially a disciplinary matter.

    My own husband worked for a large multi national - in 23 mths of employment he never had a sick day or was even late. Then 1 mth before his 2 yr anniversary at the company, he ended up with a broken rib, thanks to an over zealous co-worker at a charity football event the company had organised. He was off for 4 days. Despite this he still had the stern 'absence could lead to disciplinary' meeting. So my point is, in many companies, regardless of the situation, regardless of whether they believe you or not, it is just standard practice to give this spiel.

    All you can do, as Eoin says is to make sure that you keep in contact with your manager. Don't be appologetic as its not your fault you are sick, but do make sure s/he knows that you are sympathetic to the fact that it is a busy time of year and that you appreciate that your time off may cause staffing difficulties. I would even say, don't be afraid to voice your concerns to your manager that your time off may have a detrimental effect on your probation decision.

    When you return, keep the head down and make sure your work is to a high standard. Then hopefully when it comes to review time and they are deciding if to keep you or not, your work will be the main deciding factor and they will be able to identify your time off as a one off for genuine reasons.

    You do have to accept that possibly if it comes down to you and another colleague based on work quality, they will decide to offer the permanent position to the other person because of the absence - particularly if they work on a scoring matrix when it comes to making these decision. But that is a risk you just have to take. You have no choice really - you are ill and that can't be helped.


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Science, Health & Environment Moderators Posts: 18,281 Mod ✭✭✭✭CatFromHue


    I've only ever had one back to work interview, it was when I was working on contract too.

    I'd been out for a week, I'd rang on the Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday mornings to give them an update before I had to just say I'm not going to be in for the week. I had a Doctors cert and my main vibe from the meeting was that my manager didn't want me at work if others were going to pick something up for me.

    It didn't affect my contract and about a month later I was offered a permanent position.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,766 ✭✭✭juan.kerr


    gozunda wrote: »
    They sound like a right shower of ******.
    I still am amazed at how unbelievable some employers can be regarding their expectations of employers who work for them.

    Unless the OP has changed the post, this is a bit much. To me it reads that the employer gave friendly advice before something became a problem.

    While I have sympathy for the OP, the first 2 days weren't actually legitimate sick leave since the OP wasn't actually sick - his mother was.

    Hope you and your mum are getting better OP.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,482 ✭✭✭✭Mrs OBumble


    juan.kerr wrote: »
    Unless the OP has changed the post, this is a bit much. To me it reads that the employer gave friendly advice before something became a problem.

    While I have sympathy for the OP, the first 2 days weren't actually legitimate sick leave since the OP wasn't actually sick - his mother was.

    One of the great things about boards is that people get a variety of advice ... inevitably some people will some from biases that lead more strongly toward one side (employer perspective) or the other (workers rights) ;)

    I've met contracts in the past that allowed people to use their own sick leave to care for dependent relatives. Originally this was to care for sick children, but as people age their parents can be equally dependent.

    I don't know if contracts in this sick-leave-optional country routinely cover that, but some may allow it as an acceptable reason for being absent from work without prior agreement. Remember if you don't turn up and don't have an acceptable excuse, you're considered to have abandoned the job. Sick leave does not necessarily mean paid leave, it just means permission to be absent.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,370 ✭✭✭micosoft


    One of the big problems is that Doctors notes are completely discredited at this point from an employers point of view. GP's in Ireland have a reputation of giving out certs on demand leading a lot of employers to disregard them. This is why Back to Work interviews are increasingly important and why a lot of employers no longer accept the employees GP but refer to an occupational GP to verify.

    Aside from that the advice from some is sound. You are on probation - I'd try to make it in at this stage. You aren't on deaths door and your job is seditionary. Keep a finger on the mute button.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda


    micosoft wrote: »
    One of the big problems is that Doctors notes are completely discredited at this point from an employers point of view. GP's in Ireland have a reputation of giving out certs on demand leading a lot of employers to disregard them. This is why Back to Work interviews are increasingly important and why a lot of employers no longer accept the employees GP but refer to an occupational GP to verify.

    Aside from that the advice from some is sound. You are on probation - I'd try to make it in at this stage. You aren't on deaths door and your job is seditionary. Keep a finger on the mute button.

    By disregarding medical opinion employers leave themselves open to ignoring the rights of employees and the risk of legal action. At the end of the day employers cannot assume to override a statement medical opinion. If they are in doubt then the can assign the employee to their own medical representative.

    Employers are the ones looking for the medical certificates - by the same instance they cannot then ignore them. If an employer is calling into doubt the opinion or behaviour of a medical professional then take the correct action by reporting the GP to the medical council etc.

    Back to work interviews are an artificial construct that are worthless for medical determination as HR staff / management cannot give medical opinion.
    As in the case of the OP they serve to harass employees who have already provided employer designated medical certs for absence. I can see some application where an absence is prolonged and a return to work where change has taken place.

    Other wise they serve simply as a bully tactic by employers. I see no basis in employment practice or law that gives any employer any rights for such direct intimidation in an area where an employee has a right to medical confidentiality and has already provided a professional statement of their absence especially where many employers do not even basic sick pay.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,482 ✭✭✭✭Mrs OBumble


    gozunda wrote: »
    By disregarding medical opinion employers leave themselves open to ignoring the rights of employees and the risk of legal action. At the end of the day employers cannot assume to override a statement medical opinion. If they are in doubt then the can assign the employee to their own medical representative.

    ....

    where an employee has a right to medical confidentiality and has already provided a professional statement of their absence especially where many employers do not even basic sick pay.

    I totally agree with your first paragraph.

    But do keep in mind that a professional statement about ill health explains but does not excuse absence from work.

    Unless there is a disability issue involved (in which case discrimination is illegal), employers are free to use absence patterns as a basis for employment decisions. And I totally sympathize: there's no point have a someone one staff if they're frequently going out sick.

    It's not about whether sick leave is paid or not, it's about the operational cost and disruption to business involved in replacing a staff member at short notice.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,996 ✭✭✭✭gozunda



    I totally agree with your first paragraph.

    But do keep in mind that a professional statement about ill health explains but does not excuse absence from work.

    Unless there is a disability issue involved (in which case discrimination is illegal), employers are free to use absence patterns as a basis for employment decisions. And I totally sympathize: there's no point have a someone one staff if they're frequently going out sick.

    It's not about whether sick leave is paid or not, it's about the operational cost and disruption to business involved in replacing a staff member at short notice.


    Get what you are saying but where this is relevant is where the absences are minor and or limited - then subjecting employees to such inquisitions has an negative effect such as creating an atmosphere of fear of reporting in when actually ill. This is counter-productive to a good working environment imo. In fact This thread highlights this issue very well - "Afraid to call in Sick" - is this what employers really want?

    I also find it disturbing that some employers may be casting dispersions on the medical profession provision of medical certificates considering some of the behaviour of some employers highlighted at times in the Labour court / Employment Appeals tribunal

    As I said if there is a specific problem with a medical professional then it should be reported and not used an excuse for the introduction of such extreme control practices


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,386 ✭✭✭monkeypants


    two weeks ago my mum got really ill and I had to call in for two days and head home which is on the other end of the country
    Make sure this is counted as personal leave or unpaid leave. It shouldn't be sick leave as you weren't sick.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,301 ✭✭✭✭martingriff


    OP sorry to come in and be the barer of bad news but you have to see this from the employers point of view. Make sure you are in daily contact with your line manager and I would suggest requesting a meeting upon your return. At that meeting I would offer them your permission to check with your previous employer that you had a good attendance record (assuming you do) and that you would be more than willing to extend your probationary period due to them not getting a good picture of the 'real you'. Make sure all your sickness is properly certified.

    Realistically most employers say three months or six months but really everyone is on 12 months probation anyway. The only way to play this one is to play Ms Co-operative. It's simply not worth the risk to an employer to be stuck with someone with poor attendance these days. That said - played right there is no need for this to be a massive issue.

    Remember the MOST IMPORTANT thing is your health.

    EDIT: I'd also offer (if you are 100% sure you'll be recovered) to do some unsocial hours like New Years eve and day if they need cover. Don't offer this if there is even a 0.1% chance of letting them down.

    No offence but why should he do all this. If he is sick and the doctor has told him to take time off and take a cert it should be up to the employer if they want to prove he is not sick. It would be worse if he came in had an accident because he was sick or gave it to everyone else.

    OP stay in bed take as much time as the doctor says you have to and don't worry about your work. If they are going to let you go as you were genuinely ill or your mother was very sick then I say they are looking for any reason to lay off someone.

    It is sickening that an employer can make you feel pressurized that way. I suppose they think now you should be glad and kissing there feet they gave you a job.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,301 ✭✭✭✭martingriff


    Eoin wrote: »
    For a start, those meetings can be a good idea to make sure that the person is fit to return to work, confirm that there are no factors in work causing it etc - it doesn't have to have a negative or accusatory tone to it.

    Also, no - it's not just their problem. For a start, if you're on probation and can be let go very easily. You do not hold the upper hand by any means. Not to mention that disciplinary procedures can be followed for absenteeism, no matter how genuine the illness (if you're probation or not).

    As I said earlier, the OP has to look after their health first - but it's not a good idea to assume that there's no chance of any blowback just because you've a sick cert.

    If they fire you for been sick witch can happen then it is terrible state of affairs


Advertisement