Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Self build mortgage?

  • 24-02-2012 06:21PM
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18


    Hi all,
    I'm wondering if anyone can tell me do aib give mortgages for self builds? Also to calculate the LTV do I use build cost plus site to represent value?
    Is there a better bank out there for self builds, AIBs rate seems to be the best.


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    shelly4720 wrote: »
    Hi all,
    I'm wondering if anyone can tell me do aib give mortgages for self builds? Also to calculate the LTV do I use build cost plus site to represent value?
    Is there a better bank out there for self builds, AIBs rate seems to be the best.

    Hi Shelly,
    AIB do self build mortgages. Other banks do self build mortgages too and they all have differing criteria. They look for you to put your equity input in at the site purchase stage. The will lend up to 92% of the value on completion. How this works as a practical example would be as follows:

    Say your site purchase is €80,000 the build cost is €170,000 and you have 20k savings to put towards the purchase. They will lend you €60,000 towards the site purchase (75% of €80k) and then fund 100% of the construction cost (€170,000). The total they will have lent by the end of the build is €230,000 which is 92% of €250,000.

    Hope this clarifies, any queries let me know!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18 shelly4720


    Thanks killers1, still confused re the LTV and if we could qualify for 50 - 80%LTV rate. Am I right in saying the value is build cost plus site cost?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    shelly4720 wrote: »
    Thanks killers1, still confused re the LTV and if we could qualify for 50 - 80%LTV rate. Am I right in saying the value is build cost plus site cost?

    The value is determined by the bank's valuer when he inspects the site and views the plans for the property. The value will not necessarily be equal to the cost of site + cost of build & in the majority of cases the value on completion will be higher. How far along are you on this? Can you give me site value? build cost? & your equity input and I'll give you an idea of your LTV to see if you are in the 50-80% range...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18 shelly4720


    Site cost is 25k, build cost 220k and equity of 75k, thanks again!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    No problem, you'll definitely be in the 50-80% LTV bracket.
    Cost of Site + Cost of Build = €245k
    Less equity input = €75k
    Mortgage Required = €170k

    So €170k is 69.38% of €245k so LTV is 69%. Even if the valuation comes in higher than the site + build costs combined (€245k) it won't be high enough to bring you into the less than 50% rate bracket. You'll definitely be in the 3.04% AIB rate bracket...(50-80%)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18 shelly4720


    Thanks so much, really appreciate that, you've put my mind at ease!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    shelly4720 wrote: »
    Thanks so much, really appreciate that, you've put my mind at ease!

    No problem, my pleasure! Best of luck!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 68 ✭✭lollymob


    killers1 wrote: »
    No problem, you'll definitely be in the 50-80% LTV bracket.
    Cost of Site + Cost of Build = €245k
    Less equity input = €75k
    Mortgage Required = €170k

    So €170k is 69.38% of €245k so LTV is 69%. Even if the valuation comes in higher than the site + build costs combined (€245k) it won't be high enough to bring you into the less than 50% rate bracket. You'll definitely be in the 3.04% AIB rate bracket...(50-80%)
    Hi killers1, I found the above posts to be very well explained and easy to understand so I hope you don't mind me asking you a question! I am in a similar situation and will be hoping to get a self build mortgage later in year once pp has been granted! I will be building on a site that has been gifted to me and have no idea of it's value! I am aware that bank have to value it so I'm wondering how this will affect my mortgage! I will be hoping to borrow 200,000 and have a deposit! I'm sorry if I'm not making sense!
    Thanking you in advance!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    lollymob wrote: »
    killers1 wrote: »
    No problem, you'll definitely be in the 50-80% LTV bracket.
    Cost of Site + Cost of Build = €245k
    Less equity input = €75k
    Mortgage Required = €170k

    So €170k is 69.38% of €245k so LTV is 69%. Even if the valuation comes in higher than the site + build costs combined (€245k) it won't be high enough to bring you into the less than 50% rate bracket. You'll definitely be in the 3.04% AIB rate bracket...(50-80%)
    Hi killers1, I found the above posts to be very well explained and easy to understand so I hope you don't mind me asking you a question! I am in a similar situation and will be hoping to get a self build mortgage later in year once pp has been granted! I will be building on a site that has been gifted to me and have no idea of it's value! I am aware that bank have to value it so I'm wondering how this will affect my mortgage! I will be hoping to borrow 200,000 and have a deposit! I'm sorry if I'm not making sense!
    Thanking you in advance!

    Hi Lollymob,
    No problem at all! The value of your site will be factored in as part of your overall loan to value. Say for example your site is valued at 60k and the build cost is 200k and the valuer indicates the property will be worth 260k on completion then the bank could in theory lend you the full amount you need to build the house (presuming you qualify for the mortgage). Your loan to value would be 77% (200\260). You wouldn't necessarily need an 8% deposit as your equity input is the site value but the bank will want to see that you have savings to cover any cost overruns etc..hope this helps & if you need anything else let me know...you could always ask a local estate agent or Valuer to give you an idea if what your site would be worth with PP


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 42 grayman


    killers1 wrote: »
    Hi Lollymob,
    No problem at all! The value of your site will be factored in as part of your overall loan to value. Say for example your site is valued at 60k and the build cost is 200k and the valuer indicates the property will be worth 260k on completion then the bank could in theory lend you the full amount you need to build the house (presuming you qualify for the mortgage). Your loan to value would be 77% (200\260). You wouldn't necessarily need an 8% deposit as your equity input is the site value but the bank will want to see that you have savings to cover any cost overruns etc..hope this helps & if you need anything else let me know...you could always ask a local estate agent or Valuer to give you an idea if what your site would be worth with PP

    Hi Killers 1. I also found the posts interesting. You might ansber this if you can. We recently applied for a mortgage and got turned down. We own the site our self and have got full pp on it so have spent all our savings on that so have no money to put towards the build. we looked to borrow 150000 and had to get the site valued which was valued at 210000 because of its location in dublin, we alsso have to get a value of it all when the build was finished at it came in a 525000 so the bank put a value of 360000 on it until it is build which is a LTV of 42% but then said we could not afford to pay it back even though the mortgage payment per month is 210 less than our current rent which we can more than afford so I dont get it. I thought we were in a really good place with owing the site and getting the full pp on it. Any advice??:)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    grayman wrote: »
    Hi Killers 1. I also found the posts interesting. You might ansber this if you can. We recently applied for a mortgage and got turned down. We own the site our self and have got full pp on it so have spent all our savings on that so have no money to put towards the build. we looked to borrow 150000 and had to get the site valued which was valued at 210000 because of its location in dublin, we alsso have to get a value of it all when the build was finished at it came in a 525000 so the bank put a value of 360000 on it until it is build which is a LTV of 42% but then said we could not afford to pay it back even though the mortgage payment per month is 210 less than our current rent which we can more than afford so I dont get it. I thought we were in a really good place with owing the site and getting the full pp on it. Any advice??:)

    Hi grayman, I'll try my best to answer it for you. The banks decision to lend is twofold. One is the security on offer (i.e. the property you are buying/building etc). In your case the security you were offering the bank is absolutely fine as it is a low loan to value so they would have had no issue with that part of your application. The second part of an application is the credit underwriting. This is where they assess you ability to repay the mortgage. There are a huge amount of variables to this. The 2 main points are that your gross annual income when put through their calculators has to allow you to borrow the amount required. If it does then they will look at the stressed repayment on the proposed mortgage & any other loans etc that you have to see if it fits into their criteria. They then look for evidence from you that you have proven that you can afford over and above the monthly repayments. The one area where banks have tightened up on self builds is in the area of cost overruns. Were you proposing to build the property using Direct Labour or by way of Fixed Price Contract? The former of these is seen as more riskier by the lender and the one most likely to lead to cost overruns. You say that you used all your savings on the site purchase? My initial reaction is that they have turned you down because you don't have sufficient funds left over to cover any unexpected cost overruns. If you want me to fully assess your credit situation to see for definite why you were refused I would need you to send me the following info (by PM is fine if you'd prefer?)
    Your ages
    Do you have kids?
    Employment details, occupation, salary, length of time in roles? permanent?
    Savings build up, how much? how much per month? for how long?
    Cost of site? Did you buy the site outright yourselves?
    Any other borrowings?
    How long are you renting? how much per month? is it paid through your bank a/c?
    Are you building by Direct Labour or Fixed Price Contract?
    What bank did you apply to?
    On receipt of the above I should be able to give you a fairly accurate idea of where you stand, why you were declined and whether you would have a better chance with a different lender.
    I hope this helps!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 42 grayman


    killers1 wrote: »
    Hi grayman, I'll try my best to answer it for you. The banks decision to lend is twofold. One is the security on offer (i.e. the property you are buying/building etc). In your case the security you were offering the bank is absolutely fine as it is a low loan to value so they would have had no issue with that part of your application. The second part of an application is the credit underwriting. This is where they assess you ability to repay the mortgage. There are a huge amount of variables to this. The 2 main points are that your gross annual income when put through their calculators has to allow you to borrow the amount required. If it does then they will look at the stressed repayment on the proposed mortgage & any other loans etc that you have to see if it fits into their criteria. They then look for evidence from you that you have proven that you can afford over and above the monthly repayments. The one area where banks have tightened up on self builds is in the area of cost overruns. Were you proposing to build the property using Direct Labour or by way of Fixed Price Contract? The former of these is seen as more riskier by the lender and the one most likely to lead to cost overruns. You say that you used all your savings on the site purchase? My initial reaction is that they have turned you down because you don't have sufficient funds left over to cover any unexpected cost overruns. If you want me to fully assess your credit situation to see for definite why you were refused I would need you to send me the following info (by PM is fine if you'd prefer?)
    Your ages
    Do you have kids?
    Employment details, occupation, salary, length of time in roles? permanent?
    Savings build up, how much? how much per month? for how long?
    Cost of site? Did you buy the site outright yourselves?
    Any other borrowings?
    How long are you renting? how much per month? is it paid through your bank a/c?
    Are you building by Direct Labour or Fixed Price Contract?
    What bank did you apply to?
    On receipt of the above I should be able to give you a fairly accurate idea of where you stand, why you were declined and whether you would have a better chance with a different lender.
    I hope this helps!

    Thanks for the reply it really helps. The main reason they said they were refusing us was becauce we they stressed tested we should be left we 2250 per month but we would only be left with 2115 per month (135 per month short). we have got pay rises since which works out at 150 after tax per month so we now answer the main fefussal point. We are self building (direct labour) build cost is coming in a 152000 we want to borrow 150000 and have a few grand in savings and also getting a small gift from family to cover any over run. so i suppose my next question is do we re apply now or wait till we save a bit more.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    grayman wrote: »
    Thanks for the reply it really helps. The main reason they said they were refusing us was becauce we they stressed tested we should be left we 2250 per month but we would only be left with 2115 per month (135 per month short). we have got pay rises since which works out at 150 after tax per month so we now answer the main fefussal point. We are self building (direct labour) build cost is coming in a 152000 we want to borrow 150000 and have a few grand in savings and also getting a small gift from family to cover any over run. so i suppose my next question is do we re apply now or wait till we save a bit more.

    Am I right in assuming you applied to AIB and have 1 dependent? As I said if you want to PM me the answers to my questions above I can answer your question as to whether you should apply now & where to etc...Without those answers I can't really give you an accurate assessment..


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 68 ✭✭lollymob


    killers1 wrote: »
    lollymob wrote: »
    killers1 wrote: »
    No problem, you'll definitely be in the 50-80% LTV bracket.
    Cost of Site + Cost of Build = €245k
    Less equity input = €75k
    Mortgage Required = €170k

    So €170k is 69.38% of €245k so LTV is 69%. Even if the valuation comes in higher than the site + build costs combined (€245k) it won't be high enough to bring you into the less than 50% rate bracket. You'll definitely be in the 3.04% AIB rate bracket...(50-80%)
    Hi killers1, I found the above posts to be very well explained and easy to understand so I hope you don't mind me asking you a question! I am in a similar situation and will be hoping to get a self build mortgage later in year once pp has been granted! I will be building on a site that has been gifted to me and have no idea of it's value! I am aware that bank have to value it so I'm wondering how this will affect my mortgage! I will be hoping to borrow 200,000 and have a deposit! I'm sorry if I'm not making sense!
    Thanking you in advance!

    Hi Lollymob,
    No problem at all! The value of your site will be factored in as part of your overall loan to value. Say for example your site is valued at 60k and the build cost is 200k and the valuer indicates the property will be worth 260k on completion then the bank could in theory lend you the full amount you need to build the house (presuming you qualify for the mortgage). Your loan to value would be 77% (200\260). You wouldn't necessarily need an 8% deposit as your equity input is the site value but the bank will want to see that you have savings to cover any cost overruns etc..hope this helps & if you need anything else let me know...you could always ask a local estate agent or Valuer to give you an idea if what your site would be worth with PP
    Thanks a million for that reply killers1! Very well explained as always!
    Regards,
    Lollymob


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17 0utandAbout


    Hi All
    Can I ask a related question - for a self build mortgage what is included in the total cost of the build? On top of the actual builder's cost, can any professional fees be included? And what about the development contribution?
    Thanks!!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Hi All
    Can I ask a related question - for a self build mortgage what is included in the total cost of the build? On top of the actual builder's cost, can any professional fees be included? And what about the development contribution?
    Thanks!!

    If your loan to value allows i.e overall loan is less than 92% of the value of the completed property you can include all of those items as they all form part of the costs of constructing the property. The main thing is the loan to value and obviously that you qualify to borrow the amount required.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17 0utandAbout


    Thanks a mil killers1!
    only at early stages now of our planning/design but just trying to get my head around the finances. : )


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Thanks a mil killers1!
    only at early stages now of our planning/design but just trying to get my head around the finances. : )

    Exciting times! If you've any other queries at any stage let me know!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17 0utandAbout


    killers1 wrote: »
    Thanks a mil killers1!
    only at early stages now of our planning/design but just trying to get my head around the finances. : )

    Exciting times! If you've any other queries at any stage let me know!


    Thanks! No doubt I'll be struggling over coming months figuring it out....have to say have found your posts on here really helpful!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Thanks! No doubt I'll be struggling over coming months figuring it out....have to say have found your posts on here really helpful!

    Thanks a mill! Nice to be appreciated!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6 Elledix


    Hi,

    Can i ask the probability of getting self-build mortgage with my own circumstances. We own the site, have €20k savings (from him much more than me)(he is self-employed and i am in fulltime employment for 6 years) and have a cost of €150,000 for the build. I was recently advised to contact AIB/BOI as they were the only banks really giving out mortgages.

    We are just at the initial stages of starting to talk to the banks. Just wondering if anyone has an idea of times from approval from banks, if or if you think we need more savings etc. etc.
    Thanks,


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Elledix wrote: »
    Hi,

    Can i ask the probability of getting self-build mortgage with my own circumstances. We own the site, have €20k savings (from him much more than me)(he is self-employed and i am in fulltime employment for 6 years) and have a cost of €150,000 for the build. I was recently advised to contact AIB/BOI as they were the only banks really giving out mortgages.

    We are just at the initial stages of starting to talk to the banks. Just wondering if anyone has an idea of times from approval from banks, if or if you think we need more savings etc. etc.
    Thanks,

    Hard to give you an indication based on that info, would need to know ages, dependents, salaries, monthly rent, savings contributions, whether you bought or were gifted site, fixed price contract or direct labour etc etc... If you are putting the €20k towards the construction cost then you don't have funds left over for cost overruns etc.. There are a huge amount of variables to each application and impossible to give an accurate answer without all the details. In terms of the timeframe for approval you should have word back from the banks in a week or two provided you supply all the relevant info at the start and they don't need to keep coming back looking for additional documentation.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6 Elledix


    More info...

    salaries are €34k & €25k, age 31 & 30, no dependants, he lives at home (no rent), I pay rent of €320 per month, monthly savings of €1000pm (combined), the site was gifted and we have a fixed price contract for the build. I hope this is enough info...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Elledix wrote: »
    More info...

    salaries are €34k & €25k, age 31 & 30, no dependants, he lives at home (no rent), I pay rent of €320 per month, monthly savings of €1000pm (combined), the site was gifted and we have a fixed price contract for the build. I hope this is enough info...

    Sounds fine, salary is more than sufficient to borrow that amount and you have a proven repayment capacity for €1,320pm (presuming you've been saving at that level for a while and rent is paid through your accounts). The fact that you have a fixed price contract means less chance of cost overruns so I'd say on the face of it you'll qualify.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6 Elledix


    Thanks for the advice!! What is it about applying for mortgages that turns people into quivering wrecks looking for reassurance everywhere:D:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Elledix wrote: »
    Thanks for the advice!! What is it about applying for mortgages that turns people into quivering wrecks looking for reassurance everywhere:D:)

    You'll be fine, stop stressing about it!!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 802 ✭✭✭Rebel1977


    Whats better direct labour or fixed price contract ?

    What paperwork do banks require for each stage of the drawdown for the above ?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Rebel1977 wrote: »
    Whats better direct labour or fixed price contract ?

    What paperwork do banks require for each stage of the drawdown for the above ?

    You could write a 5 page answer to that question....!

    Basically direct labour tends to work out cheaper as you are employing the contractors directly and negotiate on each of the jobs to be done. It can be a lot of hassle if you are managing the project yourself and need to have the skills to organise the correct tradesmen to arrive at the correct time & also arranging delivery of building materials etc... It's a good route to go down if you have someone competent in the building trade to oversee the project for you. The fixed price contract tends to be more expensive but on the flip side you have agreed a price with a builder to deliver a completed property. Again you'll need someone competent to oversee the project for you. I would base my decision on the person who is going to manage everything and if that person is you then be prepared for a lot more hassle going the direct labour route.

    For stage payment drawdowns you'll need your supervising architect/engineer to sign off on the value of works completed to date & that the property is on course to come in on budget.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    Hi there, find your answers very informative so hope you don't mind if I throw one in...Have been gifted a site, purchased for 100k by my parents, planning permission received. Have a salary of 31k, with about 2k overtime guaranteed per annum, no kids, no loans or cc, save €800pm and have approx 11k savings. Looking for 100% construction costs mortgage as site is in place, first of all is this ok or have things changed? So far, I applied to my own bank UB which have called me to say its approved but are looking for a letter to state that my parents have paid the architect fees and solicitor fees etc which they have, is this ok to give, will it ever come back on my parents? They are offering 155k fir the build, my fiancé and family are building the house so very little labour costs, by he way I applied as a single applicant for mortgage. I was hoping to go with AIB for a mortgage as they're rates seem far less that other banks, at first they said they would give me €170k (monthly repayments were nearly the same with the rate difference) but called them today and said it had been refused. I'm now worried that it will go on file that I have been refused by AIB and it will affect my chances with proceeding?? Can I now re- apply to AIB for the lower amount of 155k or how do I go about this?? Also, my solicitor told me today that as part of getting the mortgage that the applicant now has to pay the banks solicitors fees, is this true??? Apparently it was only recently brought it, I nearly died..!! So sorry for such a long rant, would just love some advice as to hwhat o do next, whether to just accept the higher rate mortgage with UB as don't want to push my luck!!! Thanks a mill :)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Hi there, find your answers very informative so hope you don't mind if I throw one in...Have been gifted a site, purchased for 100k by my parents, planning permission received. Have a salary of 31k, with about 2k overtime guaranteed per annum, no kids, no loans or cc, save €800pm and have approx 11k savings. Looking for 100% construction costs mortgage as site is in place, first of all is this ok or have things changed? So far, I applied to my own bank UB which have called me to say its approved but are looking for a letter to state that my parents have paid the architect fees and solicitor fees etc which they have, is this ok to give, will it ever come back on my parents? They are offering 155k fir the build, my fiancé and family are building the house so very little labour costs, by he way I applied as a single applicant for mortgage. I was hoping to go with AIB for a mortgage as they're rates seem far less that other banks, at first they said they would give me €170k (monthly repayments were nearly the same with the rate difference) but called them today and said it had been refused. I'm now worried that it will go on file that I have been refused by AIB and it will affect my chances with proceeding?? Can I now re- apply to AIB for the lower amount of 155k or how do I go about this?? Also, my solicitor told me today that as part of getting the mortgage that the applicant now has to pay the banks solicitors fees, is this true??? Apparently it was only recently brought it, I nearly died..!! So sorry for such a long rant, would just love some advice as to hwhat o do next, whether to just accept the higher rate mortgage with UB as don't want to push my luck!!! Thanks a mill :)

    Hi Duffers11,
    Wow you managed to squeeze a lot of questions in there!! I'll try to answer them in the order you have them above (in bold).
    1. Ok to fund 100% of the construction costs when you have a site worth €100k as equity towards the build. If your borrowing €155k and your value on completion is €255k your loan to value is only 60% and well within Bank's policies.
    2. The fact that you applied to AIB and have been declined will have no bearing on your ability to proceed with UB. Have you been given the reasons that you were declined? Are you building using direct labour or by way of fixed price contract with your fiance's family? Did AIB know which route you were going down before decision changed? Bank's view direct labour as a more riskier type of lending and would like to see you have further savings than €11k to cover any cost overruns.
    3. Re-applying with AIB and whether it's worth your while doing so will purely depend on the reasons that you were declined? (If you can let me know what they said I can tell you whether it's worth your while and how you should go about it)
    4. The Bank do not employ a separate solicitor to deal with a self build or a standard house purchase and your solicitor is allowed to do all the legal work involved with the transaction. I would be wary of this being an attempt by your solicitor to bump up the fees they are charging you.
    If you can answer the questions above in relation to the response from AIB I might be able to throw some more light on this for you....


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    killers1 wrote: »
    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Hi there, find your answers very informative so hope you don't mind if I throw one in...Have been gifted a site, purchased for 100k by my parents, planning permission received. Have a salary of 31k, with about 2k overtime guaranteed per annum, no kids, no loans or cc, save €800pm and have approx 11k savings. Looking for 100% construction costs mortgage as site is in place, first of all is this ok or have things changed? So far, I applied to my own bank UB which have called me to say its approved but are looking for a letter to state that my parents have paid the architect fees and solicitor fees etc which they have, is this ok to give, will it ever come back on my parents? They are offering 155k fir the build, my fiancé and family are building the house so very little labour costs, by he way I applied as a single applicant for mortgage. I was hoping to go with AIB for a mortgage as they're rates seem far less that other banks, at first they said they would give me €170k (monthly repayments were nearly the same with the rate difference) but called them today and said it had been refused. I'm now worried that it will go on file that I have been refused by AIB and it will affect my chances with proceeding?? Can I now re- apply to AIB for the lower amount of 155k or how do I go about this?? Also, my solicitor told me today that as part of getting the mortgage that the applicant now has to pay the banks solicitors fees, is this true??? Apparently it was only recently brought it, I nearly died..!! So sorry for such a long rant, would just love some advice as to hwhat o do next, whether to just accept the higher rate mortgage with UB as don't want to push my luck!!! Thanks a mill :)

    Hi Duffers11,
    Wow you managed to squeeze a lot of questions in there!! I'll try to answer them in the order you have them above (in bold).
    1. Ok to fund 100% of the construction costs when you have a site worth €100k as equity towards the build. If your borrowing €155k and your value on completion is €255k your loan to value is only 60% and well within Bank's policies.
    2. The fact that you applied to AIB and have been declined will have no bearing on your ability to proceed with UB. Have you been given the reasons that you were declined? Are you building using direct labour or by way of fixed price contract with your fiance's family? Did AIB know which route you were going down before decision changed? Bank's view direct labour as a more riskier type of lending and would like to see you have further savings than €11k to cover any cost overruns.
    3. Re-applying with AIB and whether it's worth your while doing so will purely depend on the reasons that you were declined? (If you can let me know what they said I can tell you whether it's worth your while and how you should go about it)
    4. The Bank do not employ a separate solicitor to deal with a self build or a standard house purchase and your solicitor is allowed to do all the legal work involved with the transaction. I would be wary of this being an attempt by your solicitor to bump up the fees they are charging you.
    If you can answer the questions above in relation to the response from AIB I might be able to throw some more light on this for you....

    Thanks so much for your quick reply. So I should have no problem getting 100%, we reckon at a guess, house will be worth approx 450-500k upon completion.
    No wasn't given any reasons, just a quick mention of repayment capacity but I would be well able to cover even at stressed rate, I am wondering however, with it being 170k this might be a push. They r a nightmare 2 deal with, so rude, I won't even begin to tell u what they done, at the start they sent me out somebody else's mortgage details, name, address, salary, job, mortgage looked for, what they sold their house for, everything and because I had the courtesy to let them and man know, to be refused feel a little hard done by. Building direct labour, fiancé is a builder out of work and can do a hell of alot on his own, thankfully! Architect added 15% contingency in the costings to cover over runs, so this was included in mortgage sought and have my savings aswell.It's just crazy at the mo with the rates available, AIB seem to have the best rate options across the board! Going to try and ring them 2mo and get a few more answers from them. Was thinking that with solicitor, sounded very strange that not only do I cover his fees but also the banks solicitor fees???


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Thanks so much for your quick reply. So I should have no problem getting 100%, we reckon at a guess, house will be worth approx 450-500k upon completion.
    No wasn't given any reasons, just a quick mention of repayment capacity but I would be well able to cover even at stressed rate, I am wondering however, with it being 170k this might be a push. They r a nightmare 2 deal with, so rude, I won't even begin to tell u what they done, at the start they sent me out somebody else's mortgage details, name, address, salary, job, mortgage looked for, what they sold their house for, everything and because I had the courtesy to let them and man know, to be refused feel a little hard done by. Building direct labour, fiancé is a builder out of work and can do a hell of alot on his own, thankfully! Architect added 15% contingency in the costings to cover over runs, so this was included in mortgage sought and have my savings aswell.It's just crazy at the mo with the rates available, AIB seem to have the best rate options across the board! Going to try and ring them 2mo and get a few more answers from them. Was thinking that with solicitor, sounded very strange that not only do I cover his fees but also the banks solicitor fees???

    I think what's happened is this. AIB assess applications in 2 ways, firstly they put your income figure into their calc to see what it allows you to borrow. In your case using the full €33k and presuming you are aged younger than 30 it would spit out a figure of €171k. They then look at the second part of their calculations which will look at your net monthly income. They stress the repayment on the amount applied for €170k @ 5% over the term available, €857.97pm. Their guideline is that when you subtract this figure from your net monthly income you should be left with €1,500 disposable income to live off. I would imagine when they did this exercise you fell short of the €1,500 figure and this is one of the reasons you were declined. Stressed repayments on €155k only reduce the repayments to €782pm so my guess is it won't effect their decision. You probably have been living at home and the only repayment capacity you can show is contributing €800pm to your savings? If so, they are not going to lend you a figure where the stressed repayment equals the amount you have proven capacity for. They will take the view that you have no experience of managing a household budget and the additional expenses related to owning your own home and in their eyes repayment capacity isn't evident. For AIB to lend to the figure that the income part of their calculation allows you need to have a proven repayment capacity for well in excess of the stressed mortgage repayment. Did you mention to the bank that your fiance was going to carry out the build? This would have a very negative effect on your application because they would take the view that once the house is built and he is unemployed (they always take a worst case scenario view) you would need more than €1,500 in disposable income to sustain two adults. Overall the figures at €170k are outside of AIB's policy and at €155k very very marginal at best....

    In relation to your parents signing to say they have paid for Architects & Solrs fees that is no problem at all, at worst the costs involved would be considered a gift to you for tax computations down the road but @ €100k + those fees you are still well below the gift tax thresholds for a gift from a parent to a child.

    Other thing I'd say is to get quotes from different solicitors! Ask your solicitor to email you a detailed breakdown of the full fees involved...I'd be very interested to see how it's worded!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    Hi, thanks again for reply. I had a car loan in previous years which was €265.00 pm and I also saved at that time aswell, cleared the loan with no arrears etc so dont knwo if this would help, they would be able to see that from my ICB check. I am currently living in a house rent free until I had got mortgage :), so my current account would show payments for electricty, gas etc, again I dont know if this would show that I can pay as a 'homeowner'. Would you have any advice as to what I should say when I contact AIB later today? No I just said that build was direct labour and put that I was single applicant, didnt go into detail as to whom would build it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Hi, thanks again for reply. I had a car loan in previous years which was €265.00 pm and I also saved at that time aswell, cleared the loan with no arrears etc so dont knwo if this would help, they would be able to see that from my ICB check. I am currently living in a house rent free until I had got mortgage :), so my current account would show payments for electricty, gas etc, again I dont know if this would show that I can pay as a 'homeowner'. Would you have any advice as to what I should say when I contact AIB later today? No I just said that build was direct labour and put that I was single applicant, didnt go into detail as to whom would build it.

    Ok, just tell them that you were saving €800pm and repaying €265pm car loan at the same time. This gives you a repayment capacity for €1065pm. Also mention that although you were living rent free you were covering bills such as food & utility costs so are accustomed to the expenses associated with running a household. Just say that you have recalculated your figures and a loan amount of €155k would be sufficient. Not much else you can tell them really... figures just about work on a loan amount of €155k, you have a repayment capacity evident so it'll really boil down to the Underwriter on the day making a decision. Hard for me to give you a definitive answer as I haven't seen any of the paperwork... best of luck and if you need anything else let me know!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    Ok, so I have rang them, got speaking to someone who was really rude (not surprised)!! She said that I cannot build a house for what I said I could, she said that the cost the banks use is €83 per sq ft and that I couldnt build a house for what I said I could (think it was approx €65 per sq ft), I advised as to where she got her figure from as things have changed dramatically with cost of building, she wasnt bothered. I advised her that my family were building it for me so majority of fees were for materials, then she proceeded to say that it was beacuse I was only in my job since Sep last year, I advised that I am in a permanent position and that I have had 3.5 years continous employment which is normally ok. She then said that I am of no interest to them, and that they wouldnt ever be interested unless I brought something else to the table. Cannot get over how rude and derogative these people are...Starting to think I should just accept a bank with a higher rate!!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Ok, so I have rang them, got speaking to someone who was really rude (not surprised)!! She said that I cannot build a house for what I said I could, she said that the cost the banks use is €83 per sq ft and that I couldnt build a house for what I said I could (think it was approx €65 per sq ft), I advised as to where she got her figure from as things have changed dramatically with cost of building, she wasnt bothered. I advised her that my family were building it for me so majority of fees were for materials, then she proceeded to say that it was beacuse I was only in my job since Sep last year, I advised that I am in a permanent position and that I have had 3.5 years continous employment which is normally ok. She then said that I am of no interest to them, and that they wouldnt ever be interested unless I brought something else to the table. Cannot get over how rude and derogative these people are...Starting to think I should just accept a bank with a higher rate!!

    Wow! Sounds like you got to speak to someone having a really bad day! Reading between the lines - they tried to fob you off by saying that your costings were off, then tried to say it was because you're not in your job long enough (which is rubbish as AIB insist only a minimum of 6 months I'm a permanent job). Ultimately they don't like and are not attracted to the proposal. They view a direct labour self build as the riskiest type of lending as cost overruns happen quite regularly. In my opinion they have declined your application because they don't feel your income level is sufficient and probably feel that you don't have sufficient funds in the background to cover any unexpected additional expenses. Yours is another example of why people should use a broker a) to put your best foot forward with your application & b) So you wouldn't have to deal with rude staff members! I think you'll just have to accept this isn't one for AIB and look elsewhere...only thing that might change AIB's decision would be a fixed price contract for the build and a parental gift of cash to hold in the background to cover any cost overruns...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 145 ✭✭mmc2010


    Hi Duffers11, don't get disheatened. This might take you a while. I had been waiting for ages to get approval and worked extremely hard paying off loans for a year and trying to build up my savings. Thankfully, in the past couple of weeks, we have been approved in principle. There is still abit of an uphill climb with further documentation we have to provide but we're getting there. The banks do tend to be quite fussy with the likes of funding over-runs and the likes. I can only advise working very hard for the next year saving, if you can afford to put €1000 a month away, that will both help with the over-runs issue and prove your repayment capacity. This may not be possible if you're getting married in the meantime and your h2b is unemployed as they will underwrite you both together, regardless of whether you're applying on your own or not. I too would recommend a broker.... they say a mortgage approval is 50% information and 50% application. I didn't use killers1 in my mortgage application but he certainly seems to know his stuff!!!;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    Hi, thanks for all your advice. Just stressing as its such a big process and its for the next 35 years!!:eek: Starting to lose faith, they are all corrupt! Dont know how this country is ever going to recover with an attitude like that!! Anyway, thanks again killers!!:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 786 ✭✭✭padraig.od


    Duffers11 wrote: »
    Ok, so I have rang them, got speaking to someone who was really rude (not surprised)!! She said that I cannot build a house for what I said I could, she said that the cost the banks use is €83 per sq ft and that I couldnt build a house for what I said I could (think it was approx €65 per sq ft), I advised as to where she got her figure from as things have changed dramatically with cost of building, she wasnt bothered. I advised her that my family were building it for me so majority of fees were for materials, then she proceeded to say that it was beacuse I was only in my job since Sep last year, I advised that I am in a permanent position and that I have had 3.5 years continous employment which is normally ok. She then said that I am of no interest to them, and that they wouldnt ever be interested unless I brought something else to the table. Cannot get over how rude and derogative these people are...Starting to think I should just accept a bank with a higher rate!!

    I've been talking to both BoI and AIB re a self build.

    The reason they request costings to come in at 83 - 90 per sq ft is because they don't want you coming back to them in 6 months looking for another 15-20k to finish the build. Remember this house is collateral for the loan. AIB or BoI don't want to be repossessing a half built house so they want expensive quotes so that they are confident the house will be built and finished in case you stop paying your loan down the line.

    If its possible and you think you will qualify resubmit a quote hitting 85per sq ft and fingers crossed you get approved. You then have space in case you overrun, and remember you don't have to draw the full amount down.

    So say you calculate your build cost at 150k @ 63psf. Apply for 200k @ 85psf. If you are approved and you can build for 150 then you can hand back the extra 50k you don't need.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 145 ✭✭mmc2010


    padraig.od wrote: »
    I've been talking to both BoI and AIB re a self build.

    The reason they request costings to come in at 83 - 90 per sq ft is because they don't want you coming back to them in 6 months looking for another 15-20k to finish the build. Remember this house is collateral for the loan. AIB or BoI don't want to be repossessing a half built house so they want expensive quotes so that they are confident the house will be built and finished in case you stop paying your loan down the line.

    If its possible and you think you will qualify resubmit a quote hitting 85per sq ft and fingers crossed you get approved. You then have space in case you overrun, and remember you don't have to draw the full amount down.

    So say you calculate your build cost at 150k @ 63psf. Apply for 200k @ 85psf. If you are approved and you can build for 150 then you can hand back the extra 50k you don't need.


    Unfortunately Duffers11 won't qualify for that amount in her current circumstances...
    I know it doesn't feel like it now Duffers11 but honestly I think you will be thanking the bank in a year or two when you're able to put yourself in a better position. The last thing you want is to be putting yourself under pressure trying to finish the house. I know you say 150k will build it but you're probably looking at another 20-30k to finish it - especially when you factor in ESB connection, dev contribution fees, solicitor fees, water connection etc but maybe you've done this already.
    I was like you about 1.5yrs ago when I was initially refused. Now I'm much happier with the situation I'm in and ready to start this big undertaking. Also bear in mind that AIB only give 25 yr mortgages now which would increase your monthly repayment.
    Honestly, take your time and don't be upsetting youself. It'll all work out and use the time now to do your homework.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    padraig.od wrote: »
    I've been talking to both BoI and AIB re a self build.

    The reason they request costings to come in at 83 - 90 per sq ft is because they don't want you coming back to them in 6 months looking for another 15-20k to finish the build. Remember this house is collateral for the loan. AIB or BoI don't want to be repossessing a half built house so they want expensive quotes so that they are confident the house will be built and finished in case you stop paying your loan down the line.

    If its possible and you think you will qualify resubmit a quote hitting 85per sq ft and fingers crossed you get approved. You then have space in case you overrun, and remember you don't have to draw the full amount down.

    So say you calculate your build cost at 150k @ 63psf. Apply for 200k @ 85psf. If you are approved and you can build for 150 then you can hand back the extra 50k you don't need.

    This isn't an option due to salary constraints. Even if you apply on the basis that the cost is 85psf you still need to satisfy the bank that you have sufficient funds to cover any cost overruns and need that €15-€20k left over. You can't apply for €200k if you're producing costings for €150k as they won't lend 125% of the build cost. If you're applying on the basis that it's going to actually cost €200k to build (whether it really will or not) you need to have surplus funds to get approval


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    mmc2010 wrote: »
    Unfortunately Duffers11 won't qualify for that amount in her current circumstances...
    I know it doesn't feel like it now Duffers11 but honestly I think you will be thanking the bank in a year or two when you're able to put yourself in a better position. The last thing you want is to be putting yourself under pressure trying to finish the house. I know you say 150k will build it but you're probably looking at another 20-30k to finish it - especially when you factor in ESB connection, dev contribution fees, solicitor fees, water connection etc but maybe you've done this already.
    I was like you about 1.5yrs ago when I was initially refused. Now I'm much happier with the situation I'm in and ready to start this big undertaking. Also bear in mind that AIB only give 25 yr mortgages now which would increase your monthly repayment.
    Honestly, take your time and don't be upsetting youself. It'll all work out and use the time now to do your homework.

    I agree with this, you are under no immediate pressure to build the house immediately & your PP is probably valid for 5 yrs or so. There is a lot you can do to ensure that when you apply again your proposal is more attractive to the bank and one of those is to save, save & save some more. Only thing I'd mention is that AIB don't just do 25 yr mortgages, they'll lend over a max term of 35 years up to age 65 at expiry.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 74 ✭✭Duffers11


    Yeah the max I can qualify for with AIB is 170k, either way I would not apply for a higher mortgage just to suit them. As mentioned previously, the fiancé is building it, the only part he is unable to complete himself is plumbing & electrics and even at that we have good contacts in the trade. I think it's a blessing in disguise, I have already been approved with Ulster Bank and they didn't seem to find a problem with the costings. Furthermore I am in the process of complaint to AIB after the way I was treated by every member of staff. I only heard today on the radio that AIB are introducing charges to their current account holders if they do not retain €2500 on deposit in current account at all times! I think it's time to go back to the days of cash under the matress instead of getting involved with these corrupt idiots!!! I'd be interested to hear if anyone else has been approved a mortgage from AIB for a self build and what conditions they had to satisfy. Rant over, thanks again guys!!:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6 Elledix


    Well duffers,

    I'm hitting the mortgage road this week with my boyfriend - using a broker though. We really want to get it right the first time round so i reckon they are the best foot forward rather than going to the banks ourselves. And after reading your experience with AIB above I'm well put off them. I am looking for less than would be expected also as my other half is a plumber and knows plenty of the right people to get best prices. Fingers crossed we get apporved - we got quotes around the €150k mark from contract companies but we think we can do it for €110k and have about €15k+ for overruns ourselves. Will keep you posted how we get on.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 786 ✭✭✭padraig.od


    mmc2010 wrote: »
    Unfortunately Duffers11 won't qualify for that amount in her current circumstances...
    I know it doesn't feel like it now Duffers11 but honestly I think you will be thanking the bank in a year or two when you're able to put yourself in a better position. The last thing you want is to be putting yourself under pressure trying to finish the house. I know you say 150k will build it but you're probably looking at another 20-30k to finish it - especially when you factor in ESB connection, dev contribution fees, solicitor fees, water connection etc but maybe you've done this already.
    I was like you about 1.5yrs ago when I was initially refused. Now I'm much happier with the situation I'm in and ready to start this big undertaking. Also bear in mind that AIB only give 25 yr mortgages now which would increase your monthly repayment.
    Honestly, take your time and don't be upsetting youself. It'll all work out and use the time now to do your homework.

    yes sorry I meant to say only to apply for the higher amount if you think they will approve it. AIB are giving out greater than 25 year mortgage provided you are young enough. They were really pushing us towards a 35 year mortgage and said I could pay down at any rate I wanted without penalty so it would be cleared after 25 years, if I could afford to.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 46 jambon29


    Hi people, i was wondering what people think about my scenario. I have a free site off my parents, have savings of 11k and a job with an annual salary of 25k. How much of a mortgage would i be likely to get? I would presume it would'nt be too high considering my salary.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 128 ✭✭user37


    jambon29 wrote: »
    Hi people, i was wondering what people think about my scenario. I have a free site off my parents, have savings of 11k and a job with an annual salary of 25k. How much of a mortgage would i be likely to get? I would presume it would'nt be too high considering my salary.

    Hi, id say about 115k, go to your bank or broker they will advise you better


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,443 ✭✭✭killers1


    jambon29 wrote: »
    Hi people, i was wondering what people think about my scenario. I have a free site off my parents, have savings of 11k and a job with an annual salary of 25k. How much of a mortgage would i be likely to get? I would presume it would'nt be too high considering my salary.

    Presuming you're younger than 30 yrs old with no dependents or loans you are looking at up to a max of €119k...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 46 jambon29


    killers1 wrote: »
    Presuming you're younger than 30 yrs old with no dependents or loans you are looking at up to a max of €119k...
    I'm 31 with no dependents or loans. I presume i'd be looking at 110,000 to 115,000, probably just about get buy on that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1 FifiM


    Hi Killers1, I wonder would you mind giving me a bit of advice.
    Me and my patner are both 22 yrs of age and are looking into gettting a self build mortgage.
    We are hoping to purchase land from a friend of my partners father at a low rate (approx 15-20k).
    Jointly we earn approx 43k per annum. We both live at home so pay no rent. We have savings of €5000 so far (saving €500 monthly) and my partner was made redunandat but went straight into full time employment with a different company, so we also have some of his rundandancy to put towards savings.
    I have a loan with credit union of 2k and his loan is 4k.
    We reckon we will need approx €180,000.
    Do you think we have a good chance of been approved?
    A close friend of ours will be doing the building and we also have a friend who is a carpenter and an electrician.
    I am also wondering about stage payments. Would we be able to use money from the mortgage to complete the inside of the house, ie fixtures & fittings and furniture? We have included these in the amount we reckon we will need.

    Any information you could supply me with would be greatly appreciated.

    Thanks A Mil
    :p


  • Advertisement
Advertisement