Choice Music Prize Thread

Explosions in the Sky

Hey guys I didn't see a thread on the Choice Music Prize from this year or previous years so I said I would start a thread

The Nominees are
And So I Watch You From Afar – Gangs (Richter Collective)
Bell X1 – Bloodless Coup (Belly Up Records)
Cashier No 9 – To The Death of Fun (Bella Union)
Lisa Hannigan - Passenger (Hoop)
The Japanese Popstars – Controlling Your Allegiance (EMI)
Jape – Ocean of Frequency (Music Is For Losers)
Patrick Kelleher & His Cold Dead Hands – Golden Syrup (Osaka Records)
Pugwash – The Olympus Sounds (EMI/1969 Records)
Tieranniesaur – Tieranniesaur (Popical Island)
We Cut Corners – Today I Realised I Could Go Home Backwards (Delphi)

My money is on Lisa Hannigan any thoughts guys ?

deeks

Would love to see ASIWYFA win it. Great album.

Explosions in the Sky

deeks wrote: »

Would love to see ASIWYFA win it. Great album.

Their music says enough without lyrics , amazing record

lordgoat

Think it'll be Jape or Hannigan to win it. Would prefer Richie to take it.

Agree about ASIWYFA but don't think it'll be all the judges cup of tea.

catch--22

Cashier No.9 would be my choice to win (I have €20 on them).

But I'd rather see ASIWYFA (I also have €20 on them )

noideaforaname

Very surprised the Minutes are on that shortlist. They brought out a great debut.

cossy09

noideaforaname wrote: »

Very surprised the Minutes are on that shortlist. They brought out a great debut.

Have to agree with that. They were being well tipped to win it never mind nominated. Still some good music nominated but I thought Marcata was a very strong debut.

Could be the best thing that ever happened them:)

Jordo141

Deffo agree that The Minutes should be there.

ASIWYFA will probably win it, but I'd prefer to see Lisa Hannigan or Jape snag it.

Explosions in the Sky

Bought Marcata recently, yes the minutes deserve to be there :mad:

Jim_Kiy

I think the last band are top and deserve a claim!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itf8LOqBLfY

val_jester

Its quite a strong list, really hard for me to pick a favourite but I would like to see Lisa Hannigan win it, she really made a superb album and she is excellent live.


Delighted We Cut Corners got a nomination, another fantastic live band and really interesting album.

The Scientician

Tieranniesaur all the way but the strongest selection ever I'm pretty sure. Irish music is going through a solid golden age.

JerryHandbag

I've only heard Jape, Bellx1 & Hannigan, Jape would get my vote from those. Brilliant album (as I keep telling him on Twitter )

Joe_Dull

If there is any justice in the world ASIWYFA will win!

FewFew

The Scientician wrote: »

Irish music is going through a solid golden age.

Dunno about that. Many of the bands on the list are the aul mainstays that have had a solid following for years but haven't been able to cut the mustard in other markets.
Being an Irish centred band doesn't make them bad, and isn't even the main point I'm making, but, it just feels very... meh.

If you're talking about the health of Irish music, I much prefer the years where there was a greater mix. This nearly feels like a shortlist for the UCD ball or something. The mainstays to get most of the punters in; the established alternative acts for the "other" kids; the token trendy bands for the hipsters.

I'm sure they're all great albums, but it's far from a good sign for the Irish music industry.

lordgoat

JerryHandbag wrote: »

I've only heard Jape, Bellx1 & Hannigan, Jape would get my vote from those. Brilliant album (as I keep telling him on Twitter )

He's a good guy is Rich!

Fewcifur wrote: »

Dunno about that. Many of the bands on the list are the aul mainstays that have had a solid following for years but haven't been able to cut the mustard in other markets.
Being an Irish centred band doesn't make them bad, and isn't even the main point I'm making, but, it just feels very... meh.

If you're talking about the health of Irish music, I much prefer the years where there was a greater mix. This nearly feels like a shortlist for the UCD ball or something. The mainstays to get most of the punters in; the established alternative acts for the "other" kids; the token trendy bands for the hipsters.

I'm sure they're all great albums, but it's far from a good sign for the Irish music industry.

Disagree completely, the strength of Irish music can be judged by the number of great acts that brought out albums and didn't make the list.
There's a great mix of bands on that list and where you see it 'aul mainstays' i see it as bands that have worked hard over the years and brought out a really good ****ing album. Something to be proud of.

Take the Jape album, he held off on releasing it and re recorded alot of it as he wasn't happy with it. A few years ago, he wouldn't have been in a position to do that. It's all about progress. (imo)

FewFew

lordgoat wrote: »

Disagree completely, the strength of Irish music can be judged by the number of great acts that brought out albums and didn't make the list.
There's a great mix of bands on that list and where you see it 'aul mainstays' i see it as bands that have worked hard over the years and brought out a really good ****ing album. Something to be proud of.

Take the Jape album, he held off on releasing it and re recorded alot of it as he wasn't happy with it. A few years ago, he wouldn't have been in a position to do that. It's all about progress. (imo)

Yeah, I understand they're probably all great albums, but I'd have to debate using this choice prize as a snapshot of a healthy Irish music scene. Somewhat stagnant perhaps.


Don't get me wrong, I always argue that there's a good Irish music scene, because there is, whether you're into your Popical Island or your Richter Collective or whatever, I just don't think this year's Choice is any more deserving of the "indication of a healthy Irish music scene" tag than more recent ones.

Funnily enough, the Sunday Times Culture section has an article about the death of popular music and lists everyone of the Choice nominees. I don't completely agree with the jist of the article, but, interesting none the less.

Edit: And it's not even a bad list, I'd probably enjoy a higher percentage of the albums on it, but that's more down to a lack of variety. Where's the "I completely don't get this..." factor from bands making their own music that I just dislike.

Tree Scape

All of the bands are apparantly playing the live event in the olympia

JerryHandbag

Bump....


Just announced Japes album Ocean Of Frequency has won. The man himself has commented on Twitter

"F**k me"

Well done Ritchie!!

longshanks

It's a decent album alright but I don't think it was the best of the bunch.

pappyodaniel

Ritchie's rich, is the prize-money still 10Gs?

I agree with the decision, Ocean of Frequency for me was a slow burner but now I can't stop listening to it.

I heard Royseven won best song, meh.

Oh and I still think it was an injustice not to include The Minutes' Marcata.

mehfesto

Just back from the show.

Great performances all 'round, though We Cut Corners and ASIWYFA were head and shoulders above the rest. ASIWYFA in suits was a sight to behold. And then the drummer got bored with wearing clothes before song two. The new lad in the band is also fitting in really well. They're tight as f*ck.

Overall though, the show was pretty shambolic. Yeah, the stage looked great and the sound was good (except for Cashier #9), but as a show for the punters, down-stairs at least, it was very, very poor.

First off the speakers protruded out further than normal, meaning that anyone in the front and near the edges of the aisle had quite badly restricted views. The seats were also too close together and people had awful trouble getting in and out of rows at the intervals. First time I've seen that at the Olympia.

Then there was the photographers (of which I was one). They weren't allowed in the pit because of the videographers (who also blocked the view for those seated) and as such they were left roaming around the venue, in front of people who'd paid to get in. The Olympia staff were apologetic to punters and photographers alike, but they said there'd been no plan for them according to the organisers. There were 11 photographers in all, which meant there was lots of movement all night.

Anyway, moaning aside I feel that Jape deserved it for being that nice of a guy at least. Great album too, but I'd a tenner on We Cut Corners.

Mushy

Anyone go to the free ASIWYFA gig in the Mercantile after?

Stompbox

My God, that Royseven tune is MOR mediocrity at it's blandest.

rock whore

mehfesto wrote: »

Then there was the photographers (of which I was one). They weren't allowed in the pit because of the videographers .

was the whole show filmed?
i was flicking round the telly last night expecting to see it or at least some highlights. it's a shame that our national channels can show award ceremonys for british soap operas but didn't cover this.

Stompbox

It was streamed live on Venue One.

InTheTrees

A little off topic but this thread got me looking and theres an excellent seies of ASIWYFA youtube videos:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NR6j7yLltfw

rock whore

Stompbox wrote: »

It was streamed live on Venue One.

never heard of that before, nice one!

Finneen

Stompbox wrote: »

My God, that Royseven tune is MOR mediocrity at it's blandest.

Have one of their albums, bland rubbish for bland people.

homerun_homer

Did they not win for most (over)played Irish song as opposed to best song?

Woeful.

Delighted for Richie again, this a real grower of an album but not perfect.

paddylonglegs

homerun_homer wrote: »

Did they not win for most (over)played Irish song as opposed to best song?

Woeful.

Delighted for Richie again, this a real grower of an album but not perfect.

Shame, as usual, how a successful band always get sweared blindly at for being successful. Saw Roy Seven support Director a few years ago in the ambassador and blew everyone away, had everyone talking about it for months after. Fair enough, they took a different direction and came up with one of the best produced Irish pop songs of the year and didn't need Louise Walsh, Simon Cowell etc to hype it up. I say fair play and well done for picking up the award.

homerun_homer

paddylonglegs wrote: »

Shame, as usual, how a successful band always get sweared blindly at for being successful. Saw Roy Seven support Director a few years ago in the ambassador and blew everyone away, had everyone talking about it for months after. Fair enough, they took a different direction and came up with one of the best produced Irish pop songs of the year and didn't need Louise Walsh, Simon Cowell etc to hype it up. I say fair play and well done for picking up the award.

To me anything that's overplayed begins to grate. I can't stand hearing Lonely Boy by the Black Keys because it's the alternate rock song du-jour that's most overplayed on radio atm but I still have plenty of time for the Black Keys.
Royseven on the other hand are just awful in every sense of the word. I didn't need to hear that song over and over to get sick of the song. It just needed one listen. He has an annoying voice & it's trite music best kept to daytime radio listeners than an indie/alt forum.

Tree Scape

2012 list out today?

few predictions here
http://nialler9.com/the-choice-music-prize-nominations-are-announced-tomorrow-predictions/#more-16413

anyone think last days of 1984 might make it?

notnumber

Tree Scape wrote: »

2012 list out today?

few predictions here
http://nialler9.com/the-choice-music-prize-nominations-are-announced-tomorrow-predictions/#more-16413

anyone think last days of 1984 might make it?

Never heard of this award ..whats the criteria to win?
1984 have some great material but its not the type of music that wins populist awards.

mosstin

notnumber wrote: »

Never heard of this award ..whats the criteria to win?
1984 have some great material but its not the type of music that wins populist awards.

You basically have to be in a band called Jape. That's about it.

SilverScreen

Here be the list
http://www.irishtimes.com/blogs/ontherecord/2013/01/09/jmj-omg-ffs-its-the-choice-music-prize-shortlist-for-2012/

Wallis Bird “Wallis Bird” (Rubyworks)
The Cast of Cheers “Family” (Schoolboy Error)
Adrian Crowley “I See Three Birds Flying” (Chemikal Underground)
Delorentos “Little Sparks” (Delo Records)
Damien Dempsey “Almighty Love” (Sony)
Julie Feeney “Clocks” (Mittens)
Heathers “Kingdom” (Warner Music)
Mumblin’ Deaf Ro “Dictionary Crimes” (Popical Island)
Two Door Cinema Club “Beacon” (Kitsune)
Windings “I Am Not The Crow” (Out On A Limb)

Bats didn't make it on to the list. Disgraceful.