Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Aiming for 625 points? (600+25 from maths)

  • 06-07-2011 11:41am
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭


    I'm wondering what the best way of going about this is. I'm a very mathematical person and am interested in economics so I have Maths, Applied maths, Economics, Physics, and Chemistry which I will be able to get an A1 in with enough work. I'm doing ordinary level Irish so forget that. Then the only other two are english and german.
    I'm not very good at languages so I'd be worried that this'd be a risk. I'm just after finishing 5th year at the institute so I can take up another subject for sixth year if needed. I'm thinking accounting maybe? Would the workload be too big and should I just try get an A1 in english or German?


«1

Comments

  • Moderators, Sports Moderators Posts: 5,042 Mod ✭✭✭✭GoldFour4


    Your aiming for 600 points, 625 doesn't exist. Your going to need to start studying in september especially in your lasnguages. Try reading as many books as you can over summer, it will really help with eng. Paper 1.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 448 ✭✭Bbbbolger


    Does the new bonus points for Maths not increase the available total to 625?


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,503 Mod ✭✭✭✭dambarude


    Roughly what points do you actually need?

    Do as much work as you can, but don't burn yourself out, it won't be worth it. LC points are forgotten much quicker than fifth or sixth years would believe.

    AFAIK, it will be possible to get 625 points from next year on.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,989 ✭✭✭PictureFrame


    sdiff wrote: »
    I'm wondering what the best way of going about this is. I'm a very mathematical person and am interested in economics so I have Maths, Applied maths, Economics, Physics, and Chemistry which I will be able to get an A1 in with enough work. I'm doing ordinary level Irish so forget that. Then the only other two are english and german.
    I'm not very good at languages so I'd be worried that this'd be a risk. I'm just after finishing 5th year at the institute so I can take up another subject for sixth year if needed. I'm thinking accounting maybe? Would the workload be too big and should I just try get an A1 in english or German?
    Do you realise how difficult it is to obtain an A1 an any subject?.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    Malachy - I'm going for six A1s. So Be that 600 or 625... Maths now awards up to 125 points so I think 625 is possible.
    Dambarude - At the moment I'm looking at either Maths and Economics TSM in trinity (I think its 540 but it's hard to find the individual points requirements for each TSM combo.) or Actuarial studies in UCD (570). Either way its alot and will probably go up what with maths going up. And getting full points has to look good on a CV right?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    Do you realise how difficult it is to obtain an A1 an any subject?.
    Yes but with study+aptitude you can get alot of A1s. It's not impossible.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 309 ✭✭DaveMur1


    600 points is still the maximum, bonus points for maths is a scheme that has been agreed with the universaties in Ireland. By the logic of just apply extra points to a total, would mean a person going to UL this year could say they achieved much higher than they actually have. Points based grants and scholarships next year will also not include an extra 25 points for maths. The extra points are purely based on admissions into colleges.
    Also, don't pick up accounting for sixth year it's much more time consuming then business/geog/or/ag science , economics also links in well with business.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 164 ✭✭Mr.Fun


    So for instance if I got 605 points that would be brought back down to 600 points?
    I dont fully understand.

    Accounting in one year is possible but hugely time consuming.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 427 ✭✭scotty_irish


    if you're mathematically minded, A1s are easy in maths, applied maths, physics, chemistry. languages are all logic just like maths - learn and understand a set of rules (granted not as strict as mathematical ones unfortunately - some nasty irregulars out there), so languages are worth doing. (french is way easier than german, spanish ain't too bad - certainly possible to get to an A1 standard in a year if you're committed). so one language. that's five A1s. geography - i could teach that to a monkey - if you're on for getting A1s in maths etc, A1 is geography will be píss easy. that's 6. BOOM!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 215 ✭✭BrendaN_f


    he's right, 625 is the new maximum


  • Advertisement
  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,503 Mod ✭✭✭✭dambarude


    While the bonus maths points might not apply for other schemes (I don't really know), they will mean that you can have more than 600 points as your score for ranking by the CAO.

    When I did my LC in 08 I got an A1 in HL Maths and 600 points. A slip from the CAO said that I had 640 points for my application for a course in UL (they have always give bonus points) but 600 points for the rest of my courses in other colleges (which didn't give bonus points).


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,601 ✭✭✭Desire.


    if you're mathematically minded, A1s are easy in maths, applied maths, physics, chemistry. languages are all logic just like maths - learn and understand a set of rules (granted not as strict as mathematical ones unfortunately - some nasty irregulars out there), so languages are worth doing. (french is way easier than german, spanish ain't too bad - certainly possible to get to an A1 standard in a year if you're committed). so one language. that's five A1s. geography - i could teach that to a monkey - if you're on for getting A1s in maths etc, A1 is geography will be píss easy. that's 6. BOOM!

    Vastly overestimating how easy it is to get an A1.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 712 ✭✭✭teenagedream


    sdiff wrote: »
    I'm wondering what the best way of going about this is. I'm a very mathematical person and am interested in economics so I have Maths, Applied maths, Economics, Physics, and Chemistry which I will be able to get an A1 in with enough work. I'm doing ordinary level Irish so forget that. Then the only other two are english and german.
    I'm not very good at languages so I'd be worried that this'd be a risk. I'm just after finishing 5th year at the institute so I can take up another subject for sixth year if needed. I'm thinking accounting maybe? Would the workload be too big and should I just try get an A1 in english or German?

    Honestly, don't pick up another subject. You don't need it just please don't do it. I had seven higher level subjects and if I was doing it again I'd have dropped to pass in either maths or irish. I kept on honours maths because I needed it for my course and irish because I had a fear of dropping it and then wanting to be a primary school teacher. Which was ridiculous, I hate kids and they hate me. You do not need another subject. You cannot count more than 6. I sat all my exams at higher level because I'd worked myself into the ground for those 7 subjects and I wasn't going to waste 2 years of work. I had 9 subjects at the start of 6th year, and I could not be more delighted to have dropped to 7. I only wished I'd dropped to ordinary level in one of them. My advice is if you really don't gel well with languages then drop to ordinary german and concentrate on your 6 subjects. It'll save you a lot of hassle in the long run. And it's never going to be easy to get an A1 so don't listen to anybody who says you can get an A1 in accounting but not English.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,962 ✭✭✭jumpguy


    Tbh, in my mind you should play to your strenghts to get 600, and if there's no way you'll improve your English or German (although German is easily improvable IMO) you need to do another subject that you can get an A1 in, as far as I see it. If the workload gets too high, drop to OL in a subject you're weak at (i.e. one you won't get an A1 in).

    You really need to play the points game for 600 tbh.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,139 ✭✭✭martineatworld


    Although I agree with the route that's being recommended with being the best for 600 points, it's a shame the system doesn't put an emphasis on another language instead of maths imo.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    The system does, you have always needed 3 languages to get into uni.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 712 ✭✭✭teenagedream


    AdamD wrote: »
    The system does, you have always needed 3 languages to get into uni.

    Not true. Trinity doesn't require a third language, neither does DCU or most IT's.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,509 ✭✭✭✭randylonghorn


    AdamD wrote: »
    The system does, you have always needed 3 languages to get into uni.
    That used to be more true than it has been for the last few years.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,545 ✭✭✭Geo10


    if you're mathematically minded, A1s are easy in maths, applied maths, physics, chemistry. languages are all logic just like maths - learn and understand a set of rules (granted not as strict as mathematical ones unfortunately - some nasty irregulars out there), so languages are worth doing. (french is way easier than german, spanish ain't too bad - certainly possible to get to an A1 standard in a year if you're committed). so one language. that's five A1s. geography - i could teach that to a monkey - if you're on for getting A1s in maths etc, A1 is geography will be píss easy. that's 6. BOOM!

    How do you know? Did you do both? Everyone I know who did both for Junior Cert dropped French for the leaving and kept German. According to them German is much easier. I can see why.. English is a Germanic language (originates from German) unlike French which is in another language category. That's why German vocabulary is so easy... it's very much like English and the grammar is very systematic. Also statistically it's easier to do better in German and it has a much lower fail rate than French.

    Geography has one of the lowest A1 rates at around 3% I believe. Did you actually do this subject? So many in my class struggle with it and it's a very big course. Although I love it, it is not easy (like any other LC subject). Many of my friends say it is their most difficult subject.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 427 ✭✭scotty_irish


    Geo10 wrote: »
    How do you know? Did you do both? Everyone I know who did both for Junior Cert dropped French for the leaving and kept German. According to them German is much easier. I can see why.. English is a Germanic language (originates from German) unlike French which is in another language category. That's why German vocabulary is so easy... it's very much like English and the grammar is very systematic. Also statistically it's easier to do better in German and it has a much lower fail rate than French.

    Geography has one of the lowest A1 rates at around 3% I believe. Did you actually do this subject? So many in my class struggle with it and it's a very big course. Although I love it, it is not easy (like any other LC subject). Many of my friends say it is their most difficult subject.

    i did both for JC, german grammer is much more complicated, pronunciation much harder and in general a harder language. don't even attempt to say german grammer is easy, far from it. look at the difference in standard in people just finished the JC in the two languages, i had a reasonable level of french, couldn't string a sentence in german (As in both). and we're not talking about the lower end of the scale here with failing, the OP clearly doesn't intend on being anywhere near this.

    i did geography and took me 100 easy points. i did it in 2005, maybe there's been some massive changes to the course, although i believe the LCs being getting easier every year.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,188 ✭✭✭mrboswell


    Desire. wrote: »
    Vastly overestimating how easy it is to get an A1.

    Well said Desire.

    There seems to be a lot of "high fiving" going on about how easy it is.

    No matter how hard you work or how good a student you are you still need a bit of luck on the day.

    Anyone that I know who got an A1 (in various subjects) were excellent students from 1st year and didn't have to decide that they were going to get an A1...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,545 ✭✭✭Geo10


    i did both for JC, german grammer is much more complicated, pronunciation much harder and in general a harder language. don't even attempt to say german grammer is easy, far from it. look at the difference in standard in people just finished the JC in the two languages, i had a reasonable level of french, couldn't string a sentence in german (As in both). and we're not talking about the lower end of the scale here with failing, the OP clearly doesn't intend on being anywhere near this.

    i did geography and took me 100 easy points. i did it in 2005, maybe there's been some massive changes to the course, although i believe the LCs being getting easier every year.
    Yes the course has changed drastically since 2005. My teacher said it was easy before 2006 as it was a really short and predictable course. BTW, I don't speak French but do speak Irish, German and Spanish. Out if the three German grammar is definitely the easiest. Really easy once you sit down and learn a few rules.:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,595 ✭✭✭MathsManiac


    In 2010, 136 people got 600 points. That's 1 out of every 400 applicants.

    Some of those people will have got an A1 in Maths and others won't. So, the proportion of people getting the 2012 maximum of 625 will probably be a little bit lower than that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 60 ✭✭Call Me Lia


    sdiff wrote: »
    I'm wondering what the best way of going about this is. I'm a very mathematical person and am interested in economics so I have Maths, Applied maths, Economics, Physics, and Chemistry which I will be able to get an A1 in with enough work. I'm doing ordinary level Irish so forget that. Then the only other two are english and german.
    I'm not very good at languages so I'd be worried that this'd be a risk. I'm just after finishing 5th year at the institute so I can take up another subject for sixth year if needed. I'm thinking accounting maybe? Would the workload be too big and should I just try get an A1 in english or German?
    I'm going into 6th year also, and I'm doing Applied Maths, Accounting, Physics, Chemistry, French. In my opinion so far, Accounting can take up quite a bit of time like everyone has been saying. The actual figuring out how to do each account can vary from about half an hour to a few hours, and even then can be rote learnt off (not a good idea), but thats not enough for the Leaving. To do well, you have to improve on timing and accuracy, as I find that's what lets me down. Your times for each account have to be on the dot in the actual exam so much so that that requires a lot of regular practice. And contrary to what one might think, there is some theory involved, just one or two qs after most accounts (which adds up to quite a bit in the end), and for that the whole account has to be very well understood (that's why it's a bad idea to rote learn everything). But I think it CAN be done in one year if you really want it. Plus it can be very relaxing and a break from actual thinking because it gets very repetitive :D

    This is just my opinion of everything so far bearing in mind that I'm only going into 6th year in September like you.
    Now would you care to tell me if I should take economics as an extra subject for 6th year? I really wanted to study it in school because I loved it for the Junior Cert but there wasn't enough places available. I'm in the same boat as you with the languages. :p


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    I'm going into 6th year also, and I'm doing Applied Maths, Accounting, Physics, Chemistry, French. In my opinion so far, Accounting can take up quite a bit of time like everyone has been saying. The actual figuring out how to do each account can vary from about half an hour to a few hours, and even then can be rote learnt off (not a good idea), but thats not enough for the Leaving. To do well, you have to improve on timing and accuracy, as I find that's what lets me down. Your times for each account have to be on the dot in the actual exam so much so that that requires a lot of regular practice. And contrary to what one might think, there is some theory involved, just one or two qs after most accounts (which adds up to quite a bit in the end), and for that the whole account has to be very well understood (that's why it's a bad idea to rote learn everything). But I think it CAN be done in one year if you really want it. Plus it can be very relaxing and a break from actual thinking because it gets very repetitive :D

    This is just my opinion of everything so far bearing in mind that I'm only going into 6th year in September like you.
    Now would you care to tell me if I should take economics as an extra subject for 6th year? I really wanted to study it in school because I loved it for the Junior Cert but there wasn't enough places available. I'm in the same boat as you with the languages. :p
    Well it depends. What school are you going into? if it's a good school that will cover the course in sixth year then yeah go for it. It's actually a very easy subject. Even more so if you're interested in economics as I am. Myself and someone else in the class when we'd be doing something really trivial at the start of the year like drawing a graph "this is the hardest part of all of economics, pay attention" :pac: So it's a pretty easy subject. As for learning it on your own, hmm. If you started during the summer and if you could dedicate a few hours each day I'm sure you'[d have no difficulty. As I said it's an easy subject. Probably the easiest that I'm doing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,152 ✭✭✭Cakes.


    Does the extra 25 points for Higher Maths not only go to those who get below a C or something around that ?

    I remember a teacher telling us that the max would still be 600 and if you get an A1 you still only get 100 points not 125.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 60 ✭✭Call Me Lia


    sdiff wrote: »
    Well it depends. What school are you going into? if it's a good school that will cover the course in sixth year then yeah go for it. It's actually a very easy subject. Even more so if you're interested in economics as I am. Myself and someone else in the class when we'd be doing something really trivial at the start of the year like drawing a graph "this is the hardest part of all of economics, pay attention" :pac: So it's a pretty easy subject. As for learning it on your own, hmm. If you started during the summer and if you could dedicate a few hours each day I'm sure you'[d have no difficulty. As I said it's an easy subject. Probably the easiest that I'm doing.
    I would have to learn it myself because I'm not moving school :p Might give it a shot now that I've got some time and I'll see after that :cool: You going to try accounting? :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    I would have to learn it myself because I'm not moving school :p Might give it a shot now that I've got some time and I'll see after that :cool: You going to try accounting? :)
    Not sure, It seems it's a big workload and I think it'd be easier to just work harder for the German. What school are you in out of curiosity? Doing applied maths in school?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 274 ✭✭Belmono


    Geo10 wrote: »
    How do you know? Did you do both? Everyone I know who did both for Junior Cert dropped French for the leaving and kept German. According to them German is much easier. I can see why.. English is a Germanic language (originates from German) unlike French which is in another language category. That's why German vocabulary is so easy... it's very much like English and the grammar is very systematic. Also statistically it's easier to do better in German and it has a much lower fail rate than French.

    Geography has one of the lowest A1 rates at around 3% I believe. Did you actually do this subject? So many in my class struggle with it and it's a very big course. Although I love it, it is not easy (like any other LC subject). Many of my friends say it is their most difficult subject.

    Just a friendly word of caution regarding anybody wanting to make a decision on choosing a language for Leaving Cert. First off, English is a Germanic language, but that (a) does not mean it originates from German (they share a common ancestral language, which is usually referred to as Proto-Germanic, a hypothetical language based on studying English, German, Dutch and a whole host of other Germanic languages and (b) does not necessarily make it easier to learn than, say, a language like French. This is not to undermine Geo10's success with learning German, but more a cautionary word for anyone assuming that German is necessarily easier than French because it is categorised by linguists as being part of the same language family. In fact, because of the various waves of influence of French throughout the history of the English language, there is a lot of vocabulary borrowed into English from French, making it look perhaps, to the untrained/innocent eye, that English is more 'related' to French because of the shared vocabulary (religious and administrative language, for example).
    On another note, I'd also caution against using the LC stats published when the results are released in August as a reliable indicator of how 'easy' a subject is. As much fewer students take up German compared to French, it is difficult to come to any really valid conclusions about how easy/difficult learning foreign languages is. Neither is the failure rate for languages a suitable measure of the relative ease with which you can learn a language.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 60 ✭✭Call Me Lia


    sdiff wrote: »
    I would have to learn it myself because I'm not moving school :p Might give it a shot now that I've got some time and I'll see after that :cool: You going to try accounting? :)
    Not sure, It seems it's a big workload and I think it'd be easier to just work harder for the German. What school are you in out of curiosity? Doing applied maths in school?
    It's a school in Lucan Co. Dublin and sort of to the Applied maths question. A group of us do it before and after school with our physics teacher. You're in the institute :D lucky... Love to go there :) What school were you in before it? :P


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 146 ✭✭lctake2


    It's difficult enough trying to get the points you need and trying to maintain some kind of a life apart from studying, why would you want 625? Just to prove to yourself you could?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,819 ✭✭✭EuropeanSon


    Do you realise how difficult it is to obtain an A1 an any subject?.

    It depends on how capable you are. For some, it's not at all difficult. All people aren't the same.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 448 ✭✭Bbbbolger


    While some people may find it easier than others I would still maintain that it's very difficult to get all A1's. No matter how smart you are it would take sacrifices and a lot of time studying to achieve those grades. Not to mention the fact that luck does play an important part in the Leaving Cert. In some subjects it is very hard to get all the course finished so you will have to hope for some luck in the questions. Other subjects, English being the prime example, are very subjective. Regardless of how talented a writer you may be, the examiner might just not click with your style of writing. I know that examiners aren't supposed to grade like that but after hundreds and hundreds of scripts it would be easy to see how your grade could go down.

    If you think you are capable of 625 go for it. Let that be your target but just dont let that become your goal. Your dream college place is the goal. At the end of the day I doubt anyone would be too sad with a place in their number 1 course. Dont let your quest for full marks ruin your final years in school is what I suppose I'm trying to say.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 232 ✭✭MegGustaa


    I'm doing nine higher subjects next year (going into 5th) and yeah, in an ideal world I'd like to get 625 (hell, I'd love to get the equivalent of 925) and I'm probably capable of it, but I need around 570 max in any course I'd be considering so I wouldn't be too put out if I didn't quite get it. Like, I got 11 As in the Junior and was chuffed but only because I knew I could do it and I deserved to get it because I worked really hard consistently from First Year, not that it impacted on my life at all.

    It's hard for me to know what I'll be aiming for before I start the Leaving Cert curriculum. Like, I've never even learned Japanese before - how could I say now that I want an A1 in it? At the end of Fifth I'll probably be in a better position to set my targets.

    And the maximum is indeed 625 - there's a flat 25 bonus points going for any pass in Honours Maths from next year's Leaving. It's a total farce tbh. I want to do Law and French or European Studies or something along those lines and my points will be bolstered by my strength in Maths? Nonsense.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    MegGustaa wrote: »
    I'm doing nine higher subjects next year (going into 5th) and yeah, in an ideal world I'd like to get 625 (hell, I'd love to get the equivalent of 925) and I'm probably capable of it, but I need around 570 max in any course I'd be considering so I wouldn't be too put out if I didn't quite get it. Like, I got 11 As in the Junior and was chuffed but only because I knew I could do it and I deserved to get it because I worked really hard consistently from First Year, not that it impacted on my life at all.

    It's hard for me to know what I'll be aiming for before I start the Leaving Cert curriculum. Like, I've never even learned Japanese before - how could I say now that I want an A1 in it? At the end of Fifth I'll probably be in a better position to set my targets.

    And the maximum is indeed 625 - there's a flat 25 bonus points going for any pass in Honours Maths from next year's Leaving. It's a total farce tbh. I want to do Law and French or European Studies or something along those lines and my points will be bolstered by my strength in Maths? Nonsense.
    Well maths is arguably a harder subject so it's logical that it should offer more points. It's also more intuitive and less rote learning so it's an indicator that you do more then learn something off by heart and regurgitate it on paper. Just out of curiosity, what school are you in?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 232 ✭✭MegGustaa


    sdiff wrote: »
    Well maths is arguably a harder subject so it's logical that it should offer more points. It's also more intuitive and less rote learning so it's an indicator that you do more then learn something off by heart and regurgitate it on paper. Just out of curiosity, what school are you in?

    Well I'd rather not say the name but an all-girls school on the Southside of Dublin :)

    I suppose, but giving 25 points for every course in uni is a bit much. Science related ones, particularly those that don't necessarily require HL Maths as a subject requirement, should, but it seems unfair to reward someone going for English or French, and give them an edge over other students (who might be better at English or French than them) on the basis of their Maths results.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭sdiff


    MegGustaa wrote: »
    Well I'd rather not say the name but an all-girls school on the Southside of Dublin :)

    I suppose, but giving 25 points for every course in uni is a bit much. Science related ones, particularly those that don't necessarily require HL Maths as a subject requirement, should, but it seems unfair to reward someone going for English or French, and give them an edge over other students (who might be better at English or French than them) on the basis of their Maths results.
    Ah that's understandable. It's just I have a friend who got 11 As and is just going into fifth year and is probably doing 9 subjects so I just thought for a moment...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 232 ✭✭MegGustaa


    sdiff wrote: »
    Ah that's understandable. It's just I have a friend who got 11 As and is just going into fifth year and is probably doing 9 subjects so I just thought for a moment...

    Well there's not many of us - though I would imagine there's a strong correlation between getting 11 As in the Junior and taking 9 (or more) subjects in the Leaving...oh Project Maths statistics what are you doing to me?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 712 ✭✭✭teenagedream


    sdiff wrote: »
    Well maths is arguably a harder subject so it's logical that it should offer more points. It's also more intuitive and less rote learning so it's an indicator that you do more then learn something off by heart and regurgitate it on paper. Just out of curiosity, what school are you in?
    But isn't maths arguably harder subject depending on the person.
    Someone who might find maths enjoyable and a breeze might earn extra points over someone who finds it difficult. Whereas someone who works incredibly hard in irish receives no extra points. And therefore no advantage unlike someone doing honours maths.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Yes but in general its more difficult..for the majority of people


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 712 ✭✭✭teenagedream


    AdamD wrote: »
    Yes but in general its more difficult..for the majority of people
    But why does that give anyone who does honours maths a right to extra points?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 211 ✭✭_LilyRose_


    The whole Leaving Cert is a mess tbh.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,503 Mod ✭✭✭✭dambarude


    The only reason for the bonus maths points is to attract more people to do honours. It looks bad for the government that so few do.

    The logic is that the extra points would negate the impact of the extra work that goes into honours as opposed to pass. It's not particularly fair for those who would never have the ability to do honours, but it's not aimed at them. It's aimed at the people who do have the ability, but choose not to do it for a variety of reasons (interest/time etc.).

    The bonus points don't exist to make things fair, but rather to address a supposed skills shortage.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 60 ✭✭Call Me Lia


    AdamD wrote: »
    Yes but in general its more difficult..for the majority of people
    But why does that give anyone who does honours maths a right to extra points?
    Because the government want a knowledge economy. They want students to be good at maths and giving those extra points is the incentive that people could use to work harder at it and stay in higher level. It helps with a lot of other subjects like the sciences and businesses and is useful for a lot of different areas in real life. How does the Irish language progress the economy as much as the logical skills maths brings? That's why they decided that people who stick with higher level should get bonus points.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 712 ✭✭✭teenagedream


    Because the government want a knowledge economy. They want students to be good at maths and giving those extra points is the incentive that people could use to work harder at it and stay in higher level. It helps with a lot of other subjects like the sciences and businesses and is useful for a lot of different areas in real life. How does the Irish language progress the economy as much as the logical skills maths brings? That's why they decided that people who stick with higher level should get bonus points.

    And if I repeat next year and decide to drop maths and I apply for a course but I miss out on a place because someone who did maths and got the extra points got a place instead of me(even if the course is entirely unrelated to maths) how is that fair.


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,503 Mod ✭✭✭✭dambarude


    And if I repeat next year and decide to drop maths and I apply for a course but I miss out on a place because someone who did maths and got the extra points got a place instead of me(even if the course is entirely unrelated to maths) how is that fair.

    One could argue that it would be fair because those 25 extra points required more study, and that an A1 (or A2, whatever) in HL Maths requires more time and effort than the same grade in another subject. Almost everybody who does honours will say that an enormous amount of time is spent on in in comparison with other subjects (well I would anyway).

    But on the other hand one could say that it's unfairly advantaging those who are naturally good at maths (and those people do exist).

    Personally I can't make up my mind whether it's fair or unfair TBH. There isn't much point in going into hypothetical situations like this, because it causes unnecessary rise in blood pressure!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,509 ✭✭✭✭randylonghorn


    And if I repeat next year and decide to drop maths and I apply for a course but I miss out on a place because someone who did maths and got the extra points got a place instead of me(even if the course is entirely unrelated to maths) how is that fair.
    I hate to break it to you, teenagedream, but life isn't always 100% fair.

    It should be, in an ideal world, but we don't live in an ideal world.

    Over the years, many people who are capable of doing honours maths have chosen not to do it on the basis that it would (for them) take up too much time, and they felt they could get the extra points more easily by investing that time in their other subjects.

    The employer's organisations felt that the low level of people doing hons. maths was discouraging people from taking up science and other maths-related courses at third level, and thus damaging competitiveness, and put pressure on the government, who in turn put pressure on the universities. Most of the universities were far from convinced that the bonus points scheme was the best solution, but they weren't given much choice in the end.

    So you're stuck with the situation as it is, I'm afraid. Best to invest the energy you might spend worrying about it in dealing with the situation, and doing the very best you can in your LC.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 60 ✭✭Call Me Lia


    Because the government want a knowledge economy. They want students to be good at maths and giving those extra points is the incentive that people could use to work harder at it and stay in higher level. It helps with a lot of other subjects like the sciences and businesses and is useful for a lot of different areas in real life. How does the Irish language progress the economy as much as the logical skills maths brings? That's why they decided that people who stick with higher level should get bonus points.

    And if I repeat next year and decide to drop maths and I apply for a course but I miss out on a place because someone who did maths and got the extra points got a place instead of me(even if the course is entirely unrelated to maths) how is that fair.
    The points system is a way of assesing intelligence for all the courses in Ireland. As I've already stated maths is important and deserves the 25 extra points in the first place. But to deal with your newest argument: If someone got that 25 points more because of honours maths than the pass maths person, and (if intelligence was indeed measured by leaving cert points), than the person with honours maths is seen as being more intelligent, and therefore is also the more appealing option about who would get on that course. No matter what course it is (even art and music courses have point requirements) it is ultimately about education and smartness, and honours maths gives that.
    Anyway that wasn't the OP's question, he was looking for help about how to go about achieving maximum grades in 6 subjects, and he did not receive much of a reply to answer that :P


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 2,503 Mod ✭✭✭✭dambarude


    Equating intelligence and leaving cert points is a risky thing to do!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 29,509 ✭✭✭✭randylonghorn


    Let's NOT get into the "what constitutes intelligence?" debate again please!
    Anyway that wasn't the OP's question, he was looking for help about how to go about achieving maximum grades in 6 subjects, and he did not receive much of a reply to answer that :P
    Here, I agree with you! :)


  • Advertisement
Advertisement