Fight back against rip-off

dmc101

I have had enough of the no come-back rip off business & shops, I am going to write up on here what & when it happens to me from now on, small or big rip off's

Starting with

Charlie Foleys pub Killarney, 1 bacardi & coke & 1 coke €9.60

Automainia Ballincollig Cork 25.02.11. 5pm. Items on the shelf are not priced. 1lt de-ionised water, I was charged €4. (No till receipt issued) last one I bought in Killarney 3 weeks ago cost €1.95

Run_to_da_hills

I propose a "Name and Shame Rip off" thread.

dr ro

Bruxelles saturday night pint of guinness 5.50e

ch750536

How ironic, you say fight back, then you list stuff you stupidly bought. A real fight back would be to list things you decided not to buy & let the retailer know about it.

alyuciao

OP .... great idea, pay no heed to the previous post, but he is right. Next time I'll be posting here too. Problem is that I live in Tokyo and everything is expensive.... except electrical goods.

The name and shame post; great idea.

Atlantic Dawn

Perhaps name, shame and attach the receipt for all to see.

flan59

Next time ur in a smallish shop have a look at the water/minerals which are sold individually but clearly state on the bottles "Not to be sold Seperately". its a rip off by the shop owner

DELTATIP

cork city - {plumbing } Recently i declined to buy a 4 inch waste elbow from a blackpool pluming outfit blackpool industrail park cork charging E10
a quote from the reps head

I told him it was E7.40 in atlantic homecare and to get real with his
prices

Went to another pluming outfit cremins of blackpool cork and purchased
the same elbow type E5.50

ejmaztec

DELTATIP wrote: »

cork city - {plumbing } Recently i declined to buy a 4 inch waste elbow from a blackpool pluming outfit blackpool industrail park cork charging E10
a quote from the reps head

I told him it was E7.40 in atlantic homecare and to get real with his
prices

Went to another pluming outfit cremins of blackpool cork and purchased
the same elbow type E5.50

Were these all the same make? There's quite a difference in quality in the plumbing fittings industry.

DELTATIP

ejmaztec wrote: »

Were these all the same make? There's quite a difference in quality in the plumbing fittings industry.

The 10 euro fitting was in the raw state -no brand or packaging
the others were packaged and branded - What stiffled me was the uncertainty the rep showed when he thought before calling out the price -I think he thought of the first figure that came into his head and said it

mcwhirter

dmc101 wrote: »

I have had enough of the no come-back rip off business & shops, I am going to write up on here what & when it happens to me from now on, small or big rip off's

Starting with

Charlie Foleys pub Killarney, 1 bacardi & coke & 1 coke €9.60

Automainia Ballincollig Cork 25.02.11. 5pm. Items on the shelf are not priced. 1lt de-ionised water, I was charged €4. (No till receipt issued) last one I bought in Killarney 3 weeks ago cost €1.95

How come alcohol has come down in price generally in all shops but pubs are still charging crazy prices??

Jaysoose

mcwhirter wrote: »

How come alcohol has come down in price generally in all shops but pubs are still charging crazy prices??

Because a lot of pubs bought into the whole "refurb the pub and they will come" and spent fortunes. Also there are commercial rates that have not come down but in fact are increasing in a lot of cases along with the likes of diageo and Musgraves refusing to pass on any savings that may be had.

Im not defending the publicans and some of the €5+ pinters out there are takin the mickey but its not as simple as walking into tesco and comparing the price in the offlicence.

Staplor

Shops charge less for booze because they'll make up the difference on other products in store. Charge a tenner for ten beers, get the customers in and ramp up the cost of other things.

91011

mcwhirter wrote: »

How come alcohol has come down in price generally in all shops but pubs are still charging crazy prices??

Because wages still cost the same, heating bills have gone up, rent is still the same, rates are the same or have gone up. They'll pour the drink for you, you'll sit on their furniture, you'll watch their TV or listen to the live music, you'll enjoy the heat they provide and they'll pick up your glass when your finished and wash it.

Go to any place in the UK, a pint of decent beer is at least £3.50, (£3.90 in Birmingham a couple of week ago) on the continent, expect to pay up to €8 in some pubs, especially in Paris. €5 is cheap there!

Yes - the high cost of minerals - or more the fact that you can only buy them in 220ml sizes, is a bugbear. Bring in a 330ml size for the same price and that negativity may go away. (330ml glass bottle is standard mineral serving size in UK)

parsi

91011 wrote: »

on the continent, expect to pay up to €8 in some pubs, especially in Paris. €5 is cheap there!

They tend to nurse their beer a bit more on the continent (sweeping generalisation) with much less of the 2-pints-an-hour merchants than we have here.

kevin99

Did you ask for a receipt for the goods purchased? The shop is legally obliged to provide you with a receipt.

dmc101 wrote: »

I have had enough of the no come-back rip off business & shops, I am going to write up on here what & when it happens to me from now on, small or big rip off's

Starting with

Charlie Foleys pub Killarney, 1 bacardi & coke & 1 coke €9.60

Automainia Ballincollig Cork 25.02.11. 5pm. Items on the shelf are not priced. 1lt de-ionised water, I was charged €4. (No till receipt issued) last one I bought in Killarney 3 weeks ago cost €1.95

ICE HOUSE

Petrol almost everywhere €1.50 + per litre

Col200sx

Was after a replacement H2 60w headlight bulb for the wifes car, went to Halfords in Galway to get it.

A single bulb was priced at a staggering €26.95 :eek:

So I left, went to the motor factors across the road, and got the same bulb for €7.99

Hence the aptly nicknamed "Halfrauds"

Alicano

Fitzsimons Temple Bar Dublin: Pint of Miller: eur6.05...yikes.
I'd also throw in a general comment regarding the price of a coffee in the city/airport etc..burns the pocket and lips at the same time!:)

Jaysoose

Alicano wrote: »

Fitzsimons Temple Bar Dublin: Pint of Miller: eur6.05...yikes.
I'd also throw in a general comment regarding the price of a coffee in the city/airport etc..burns the pocket and lips at the same time!:)

Gotta disagree with the price of coffee i work up on baggot street and all im seeing in every coffee shop is €3.50 for any size coffee and a pastry/muffin...thats pretty good value..stop getting your coffee from starbucks buddy.

Who drinks miller on draught? you deserve to be ripped off.

Alicano

You're doing very well to get a coffee and pastry for 3.50..And I'm referring to all the major coffee houses not just Starbucks who I agree have high prices. I drink 3in1 Nescafe sachets from Tesco.
As for Miller, I thought it was Stella Artois that was reassuringly expensive!

snugglebear

During the bad weather our boiler packed and we had to get someone out, we hadn't lived in the house that long or the area and most of my family were snowed in.
Anyway guy comes out charges us €100 it works for about 5 hours and then packs up altogether the next time we try and use the heating, luckily my uncle was able to fit a new one for cost price once the snowed melted :cool:
Also when for lunch in a dublin hotel last week, they were charging €8.50 for a soup and €3.50 for a tiny bottle of coke, crazy prices

kevin99

When was the last time the CAI launched a major nationwide publicity camaign encouraging people NOT to support Rip-off Ireland?
Why hasn't RTE aired another series of Eddie Hobbs' huge successfull and highly popular programme of the same title?
'Cos the various lobbyists, politicians were encouraged to appeal to the former Cowen governmment to cull the programme. RTE did was it was told to do.

I listen to Scott Williams' Q102 radio show at tea time and he carries an item with Dermot Jewell of the CAI. People phone in with complaints about items/products/ or services they paid for, but are unhappy with, and want advice on what to do.
Dermot basically gives every caller the same advice ie write to the store manager, tell them xy and z. Bla bla bla.

I'd like to hear the outcome of some cases whether successful or otherwise.

It's a better consumer segment than the one on the Pat Kenny radio programme which this week focussed on ticket sales for the Olympic Games in London next year. Now with all due respect, I don't think that subject is uppermost in most Irish people's minds at the moment.
He rarely features a strong consumer story. But then I suppose the consumer expert, Tina Leonard just tells the researchers what she will cover from week to week.

She and Dermot should be telling people every week what we should be paying for food, drinks, petrol, white goods, insurance products etc.

Eddie Hobbs is the best person to explain consumer rip offs in the financial services sector. Charlie Weston of the Indo is good too.

Conor Pope is excellent in the Irish Times.

But we need a sustained, concerted effort to keep rip off Ireland to the forefront of the public and media. Only that way will we see change.

Don't drink or eat in overpriced pubs and restaurants, don't pay in to a night club that increases its prices after 11am, find out te cheapest petrol station in your area, ditto menswear, womenswear, childrenswear.

Her's my tip from shopping for deodrant this week. Don't buy men's deodrant in Tesco because the same is cheaper in Boots, Jervis centre.

I bought a new keyboard and mouse for my PC for just €26 in Power City. I was in PC world, Jervis street shopping centre and the same product was on offer for just over €20.

CAI, Q102 and PK radio show should all support a nationwide online campaign to urge the new Goverment to reduce its take from a litre of petrol by 50c.
We should all sign an online petition to that affect and present it to the relevant Minister at the end of the month.
Road tax should also be reduced.

By the way, does anybody know how many successful court prosecutions there were in 2009 against individuals or organisations for over-charging customers?



But I really do believe we need a sustained online, print and broadcast media campaign against this rip off culture. Inflation is over 2% now so with the increase in oil it will increase again.

the groutch

kevin99 wrote: »

CAI, Q102 and PK radio show should all support a nationwide online campaign to urge the new Goverment to reduce its take from a litre of petrol by 50c.
We should all sign an online petition to that affect and present it to the relevant Minister at the end of the month.

sorry to burst your bubble, but the country doesnt have the money to do that
at a very conservative estimate (one million vehicles using 10 litres a week), that'd be a loss to governement of €250m, which would have to be found elsewhere

jett

Energy saving light bulbs, here 3E+, England 75p.
As for prices. Go to Aldis,LIDL and buy on offer. Freeze or refrigerate and things will last a long time.
Don't impulse buy and shop around. Go without if its a rip off.

borderlinemeath

I've seen energy saving bulbs in loads of places for €1.00

Buylo in Ashbourne, I think Woodies as well, a couple of local household stores as well.

whippet

Col200sx wrote: »

Was after a replacement H2 60w headlight bulb for the wifes car, went to Halfords in Galway to get it.

A single bulb was priced at a staggering €26.95 :eek:

So I left, went to the motor factors across the road, and got the same bulb for €7.99

Hence the aptly nicknamed "Halfrauds"

I didn't realise Halfords let independent motor factors sell their branded bulbs ? Or maybe you are not comparing like with like? And I am sure that there isn't a Halfords in the country which has a Motor Factors across the road ... Good chance your little story is embellished a bit to make it sound better .......:rolleyes:

jett

Not like for like power wise.

parsi

jett wrote: »

Not like for like power wise.

There were some respectable wattage Phillips on sale in my local spar for €1 each. Genuine brand.

MASTER...of the bra

jett wrote: »

Energy saving light bulbs, here 3E+, England 75p.
As for prices. Go to Aldis,LIDL and buy on offer. Freeze or refrigerate and things will last a long time.
Don't impulse buy and shop around. Go without if its a rip off.

England subsidise their bulbs. Try Homebase. I got mine there for around a euro last year. Philips brand.

jett

give them free to OAPs my parents have loads, pity ROI does not put its subsidy where its green ( partys) mouth was.

Guitar Wizard

Hi there,

I recently got a crown fitted before Christmas as a result of excessive sensitivity for a number of years, and after several white fillings on the tooth. - The dentist advised getting a crown as she said it would "sort out all those problems once and for all". However, there was a delay with the time it took to get the real crown as it had to be sent back to get reshaped due to it fitting incorrectly. As a result, the dentist said that the temporary crown may have slightly altered how my gum sat against the new crown when I got it about 5 weeks later.

The main problem Im having is that there is still an immense amount of pain any time something cold hits the tooth or when I bit on it still, and the dentist told me I may have to get root canal done on it. I paid 750 for my crown under the belief it would work as she said it would, and never told me of the risk attached, i.e. not working.

If I need root canal, does anyone know if its fair to have to pay extra for this dentist to do it? Is there relevant legislation I can argue if they demand me to pay for a root canal as the crown is effectively useless...

Thanks in advance for your reply.

MASTER...of the bra

Hi Guitar Wizard,

Boards has a Dental Issues Forum, if you start a new thread there and copy and paste your above post you'll get better answers over there.

Pressing Control + F on your keyboard and using the little search box, is handy for searching through the list of Forums untill you get use to the layout.

borderlinemeath

jett wrote: »

give them free to OAPs my parents have loads, pity ROI does not put its subsidy where its green ( partys) mouth was.

And the UK OAP pension is how much compared to Irelands??

swings and roundabouts really.

jett

Whats that got to do with it?
Simply pointing out a fact.

borderlinemeath

jett wrote: »

Whats that got to do with it?
Simply pointing out a fact.

It's got a lot to do with it.
Ireland system of taxation, coupled with a lack of service rates and public amenities is vastly different to the UK and plenty of other countries.

The higher social welfare and pensions that Irish residents enjoy is far higher than elsewhere and as such they are expected to pay for their own lightbulbs.

It's all well and good government bashing but it's not all black and white.
We're all giving out about the amount of taxpayers money being pumped into the banks - there's probably a similar forum in the UK giving out about the education cuts and the amount of money spent on sending troops to Afghanistan and maybe OAPs are saying wouldn't it be great to live in Ireland and get the higher pension...:D

The grass is always greener etc...

jett

Not wishing to be classed as a troll and hesitating to appear confrontational. ( in other words having a go)
When push comes to shove the actual income when its all taken into account for the average senior citizen is about the same.
Note some OAPs in Blighty are very well off and as well as various add ons to the basic state pension may have private or civil service pensions added far in excess of the apparant high Irish basic pension.
My point was that the UK government in an attempt to make things easier for senior citizens makes energy saving light bulbs available, wether they want them or not.
The Irish government whilst attempting to be politically correct by championing green taxes does not make energy saving devises attractive by supplying them at an inflated cost.
Therefore expounding the whole thing and extrapolating thus, its all the same but one is transparent the other is at best obscured.
Its like the nonsence insulation grants. its cheaper to do it yourself than make use of the grants because you have to use an approved contractor that charges the earth for labour weras do it yourself and its cost effective.
As a guide loft insulation at Woodies 27-30 E, same product B&Q Blighty £3. This is a commercial product and not subsidised.
So we have (had) a government championing insulation grants etc yet Irish insulation manufacturing company Moy Goes down the pan because it cannot compete.
Its whats called a rip off and unless people are aware of what our best client and nearest neighbour does it will carry on.
People are not flocking North to occupied territory because they want to burn fuel its because they want to stay ahead of the game.
Minor rant over

borderlinemeath

jett wrote: »

Not wishing to be classed as a troll and hesitating to appear confrontational. ( in other words having a go)
When push comes to shove the actual income when its all taken into account for the average senior citizen is about the same.
Note some OAPs in Blighty are very well off and as well as various add ons to the basic state pension may have private or civil service pensions added far in excess of the apparant high Irish basic pension.
My point was that the UK government in an attempt to make things easier for senior citizens makes energy saving light bulbs available, wether they want them or not.
The Irish government whilst attempting to be politically correct by championing green taxes does not make energy saving devises attractive by supplying them at an inflated cost.
Therefore expounding the whole thing and extrapolating thus, its all the same but one is transparent the other is at best obscured.
Its like the nonsence insulation grants. its cheaper to do it yourself than make use of the grants because you have to use an approved contractor that charges the earth for labour weras do it yourself and its cost effective.
As a guide loft insulation at Woodies 27-30 E, same product B&Q Blighty £3. This is a commercial product and not subsidised.
So we have (had) a government championing insulation grants etc yet Irish insulation manufacturing company Moy Goes down the pan because it cannot compete.
Its whats called a rip off and unless people are aware of what our best client and nearest neighbour does it will carry on.
People are not flocking North to occupied territory because they want to burn fuel its because they want to stay ahead of the game.
Minor rant over

Not appearing as a troll at all, debate is a two way game!

Irish pensioners can also be either wealthy with their own pension pot or on the breadline with the state pension alone and thus both eligible for their bus pass and every other perk of old age.

I don't agree with you're sentiment that it is a rip off. You cannot justify cross border shopping by stating that the the entire country is engaged in a rip off. Different countries, different wages, rates, taxation etc.

I have worked in retail for years and have worked for both UK and Irish companies and the cost base for both is vastly different and goods must be priced accordingly to this. I can understand the frustration of Irish consumers, after all I am one myself, but anybody that doesn't have experience of managing or running a business in this country has a very blinkered view of why the cost of goods and services are higher than the UK or mainland Europe. (and it's not just wages although that is a factor)

As stated previously, I bought Philips energy saver bulbs for €1, 60watt and 75watt bulb, they state on the packet that they are energy A rated and will last up to 10years.

jett

No one expected Spanish Inquisition ( Monty Python Joke)
The threads about rip off prices, I think the bulbs are a rip off, people i know think they are a rip off, no one I know says they are not. Of course we may all be uninformed and incorrect.
I saw the average hourly rate item on the news yesterday. Average hourly wage is slightly below 22E per hour.
Well with all the minimum wage jobs plus retail, construction and in general private company rates at half that then lots ( by average) must be still coining it.
When I go into places like Woodies there are lots of staff standing around like zombies, things are lying about and many items are not even priced. No wonder they are not selling much. Its just plain poor.
Thats why people go up North, for service and a greater choice at a more reasonable cost.
I am not saying its right to shop up there. Its something that needs correcting by competitiveness and the government needs to address this.
Cowan went on about cheaper VAT and Euro increasing against the pound which would solve it. Well VAT is now the same and the currency has gone the other way and its still better up there.
I needed some parts for a broken item the other day. Emailed all the ROI agents for the products and got not one reply. I got emails by return from Brit companies, even if they could not help they passed me on to others who could.
Trying my best but there is a limit to putting up with could not care less attitudes.
See Currys and PC world thread for tales of woe from myself and other ( Its not just ROI companies its endemic to certain types of organistion.

borderlinemeath

jett wrote: »

No one expected Spanish Inquisition ( Monty Python Joke)
The threads about rip off prices, I think the bulbs are a rip off, people i know think they are a rip off, no one I know says they are not. Of course we may all be uninformed and incorrect.
I saw the average hourly rate item on the news yesterday. Average hourly wage is slightly below 22E per hour.
Well with all the minimum wage jobs plus retail, construction and in general private company rates at half that then lots ( by average) must be still coining it.
When I go into places like Woodies there are lots of staff standing around like zombies, things are lying about and many items are not even priced. No wonder they are not selling much. Its just plain poor.
Thats why people go up North, for service and a greater choice at a more reasonable cost.
I am not saying its right to shop up there. Its something that needs correcting by competitiveness and the government needs to address this.
Cowan went on about cheaper VAT and Euro increasing against the pound which would solve it. Well VAT is now the same and the currency has gone the other way and its still better up there.
I needed some parts for a broken item the other day. Emailed all the ROI agents for the products and got not one reply. I got emails by return from Brit companies, even if they could not help they passed me on to others who could.
Trying my best but there is a limit to putting up with could not care less attitudes.
See Currys and PC world thread for tales of woe from myself and other ( Its not just ROI companies its endemic to certain types of organistion.

Nobody is "coining it" in retail. Except for maybe pawnbrokers.

If that was the case, why are there so many empty retail units across the country, on every main street and shopping centre?
As I stated in my previous post - it's not all down to the wages, although that is a factor.

There are leases. Some retailers are still tied into upward only rent reviews. The average Irish lease is for 25-30 years with reviews at least every 5 years.

Commercial Rates. Each individual county council sets rates based usually on the value/size of the property. Note - it is their departments that value the property,not independent valuations. If you wish to have your premises rerated you can do so for a fee, but the chances are just as likely that the council may increase the rates as opposed to lowering them!

Utilities/Bills. Commercial utilities are far higher than private households.
Even with shopping around with airtricity/bord gais etc, the prices for a fairly small unit trading 6/7 days a week can exceed €100 a week for electricity alone. Think of all lights needed for windows, lighting shop floors, running air conditioning, tills etc.
Phone bills/credit card terminals. Each terminal is rented from the bank so there is a charge. Each transaction there is a charge. That is why most newsagents, small stores have a minimum spend on their terminals.

IMRO rates. If play a CD or a radio in your premises you have to pay IMRO for the privilege. Or you sign up to the likes of "mood media" who provide music from unsigned artists. It's basically supermarket music and again you pay for the privilege. Either way it costs you.

Insurance. Much higher on commercial units naturally as there is usually a lot of stock to insure as well as a small amount of cash holdings.

Transport and Warehousing. Depending on your suppliers and your premises, you may have to pay for transport of goods and perhaps for storage of same.
Most companies have a dedicated shipper that charges them a rate for both.

Accountancy fees - the old death and taxes chestnut!
Security fees - to protect the stock and your staff.
Cleaners - most companies use contract staff, on top of their hourly rate, a premium to the company and also supplies.
Refuse charges. Huge amounts for retailers as the amount of waste generated even though mostly recyclable is still high.

Wages and taxation.
Not only does an employer have to pay the staff, but also employers PRSI contributions for each staff member.
VAT returns on goods sold at the selling price.

There's also lots of other charges, if for example you sell food and beverages or perishable goods then you have to factor in wastage.

Now, once you have paid all of the above, then you are ready to open the door and start trading! So the item that you might have paid €10 for in the wholesalers might be selling for €20 on the shelf but all the bills have to be paid before you see maybe €1 or less profit!! :eek:

So please don't be fooled into thinking that it's a bed of roses and everyone is making huge profits. If that was the case, everybody would be a retailer and nobody would be going out of business.

jett

I totally agree with all the facts you have stated and the wages in retail are poor compared to the task.
Its all the charges that you mention that need to be reduced and until the country gets real and realises that costs rewards have to go down in bad times then it will carry on spairaling downwards.
I could not believe the level of wages when I first moved over nor could I believe the low taxation compared to England.
My observations were that people got beyond themselves and thought that borrowing money and throwing it at things was reasonable.
I imagine that for people who lived here all their lives the myth of the Celtic Tiger was something that crept up on them and became the norm.
Personally I find living here very competitive compared to England,then again I don't use pubs or restaurants and perhaps cut my cloth to suit my income.
Plus it is a damn sight more pleasant here with a national identity that has not been damaged too much.
I hate seeing such an idylic place going down the pan due to greed and complacency.
Market forces will always win in the market place but in the sacred halls of the Government services with protected salaries and incredible pensions, that will not apply.
Some people are having the life of Riley while others are in despair. I don,t think those who formed the Republic would have imagined such differentials.

borderlinemeath

jett wrote: »

I totally agree with all the facts you have stated and the wages in retail are poor compared to the task.
Its all the charges that you mention that need to be reduced and until the country gets real and realises that costs rewards have to go down in bad times then it will carry on spairaling downwards.
I could not believe the level of wages when I first moved over nor could I believe the low taxation compared to England.
My observations were that people got beyond themselves and thought that borrowing money and throwing it at things was reasonable.
I imagine that for people who lived here all their lives the myth of the Celtic Tiger was something that crept up on them and became the norm.
Personally I find living here very competitive compared to England,then again I don't use pubs or restaurants and perhaps cut my cloth to suit my income.
Plus it is a damn sight more pleasant here with a national identity that has not been damaged too much.
I hate seeing such an idylic place going down the pan due to greed and complacency.
Market forces will always win in the market place but in the sacred halls of the Government services with protected salaries and incredible pensions, that will not apply.
Some people are having the life of Riley while others are in despair. I don,t think those who formed the Republic would have imagined such differentials.

You mention the low taxation - while there is are low enough levels of income tax, the taxation on food is mainly 21%, only the basic staples are 13.5%.
In the UK the tax rate on a lot of groceries is 0% with only true luxury items having 20% applied. This has a huge difference on an average grocery bill for a family trying to live on a budget.

There are plenty of stealth taxes in Ireland, take VRT for example, a tax on a tax. Say for example you brought your car from the UK, where you had purchased it and paid the tax, then on moving to Ireland had to import the car and pay Vehicle Registration Tax on top of the tax you already paid. :eek:
Ridiculous!

ejmaztec

borderlinemeath wrote: »

You mention the low taxation - while there is are low enough levels of income tax, the taxation on food is mainly 21%, only the basic staples are 13.5%.
In the UK the tax rate on a lot of groceries is 0% with only true luxury items having 20% applied. This has a huge difference on an average grocery bill for a family trying to live on a budget.

There are plenty of stealth taxes in Ireland, take VRT for example, a tax on a tax. Say for example you brought your car from the UK, where you had purchased it and paid the tax, then on moving to Ireland had to import the car and pay Vehicle Registration Tax on top of the tax you already paid. :eek:
Ridiculous!

That's a particularly sneaky rip-off by the State, after they were told that there could be no duty on intra-EU transactions. Instead of scrapping it, the crafty feckers changed the name, so that it was no longer import-duty, but still had the same people enforcing it.:mad:

Had they scrapped it however, they would only have recouped it from somewhere else, so it was a lose lose situation either way.

cjgib

I agree wholeheartedly with Kevin99.
We need to become more militant and organised as consumers.
I dont buy the argument that the cost base in retailing here is so different than that of the UK.
We need to apply political pressure to change the law on filing corporate accounts.
If the retail chains were obliged to file accounts same as public companies it would be a start.
There is also the difference in tax rates applied to these chains,it's much lowere here but we dont see that in the prices.
Net margins for Tesco in Ireland are believed to be around 9% whereas in the UK the figure fluctuates from 3 to 6%.Tesco UK managers privately refer to Tesco here as treasure Ireland(I have that on good authority).
The penny has'nt dropped with our politicians that the corporate tax rate for Retail chains could be increased to the same level as the UK and they would not be able to argue for price increases as they are presently pocketing the difference.
The penny has'nt dropped with them either that downward pressure on prices helps them in negotiating wage rates

borderlinemeath

cjgib wrote: »

I agree wholeheartedly with Kevin99.
We need to become more militant and organised as consumers.
I dont buy the argument that the cost base in retailing here is so different than that of the UK.
We need to apply political pressure to change the law on filing corporate accounts.
If the retail chains were obliged to file accounts same as public companies it would be a start.
There is also the difference in tax rates applied to these chains,it's much lowere here but we dont see that in the prices.
Net margins for Tesco in Ireland are believed to be around 9% whereas in the UK the figure fluctuates from 3 to 6%.Tesco UK managers privately refer to Tesco here as treasure Ireland(I have that on good authority).
The penny has'nt dropped with our politicians that the corporate tax rate for Retail chains could be increased to the same level as the UK and they would not be able to argue for price increases as they are presently pocketing the difference.
The penny has'nt dropped with them either that downward pressure on prices helps them in negotiating wage rates

A lot of retailers are ltd companies

I've outlined the costs in a retail business above. The bigger the premises, the higher the rates, rents and payroll. And like I said - pay them all - then open the door and try and recoup those costs before you make a penny.
It's far from the cash cow that you seem to imagine it is.:eek:

There has never been any back up to the argument that Tesco makes a higher profit margin here than in the UK, plenty of rumour and innuendo as they are a large british company in the Irish market and an easy target.
It doesn't matter to me where I buy my groceries, I'll shop around for the cheapest rather than hold a grudge based on hearsay.

jett

You can import one car without paying VRT.
I notice that car prices seem to be getting lower due to market forces.
Road tax is diabolical compared to Britain.
The one thing that Britain has got is a good NHS but it isn,t free as National insurance is very high compared to the ROI equivelent.
Of course things are different in different countries and Ireland is certainly not a bit of the UK stuck off the coast of wales.
I personally believe in different cultures/ customs etc. The common market was assumed to be a great equaliser. Wrong! in my opinion it has damaged the individuality of every nation that joined it. Bribes and threats are the only reason voted for the incomplete Lisbon Treaty
Lets not forget VAT was a condition of being in it.
Now they are trying to alter our soverign corporation tax rate. Of course they are calling it a different thing at the moment but the two main bullys in Europe have their eye on our business.
They have already harmed, farming,fishing,tourism etc and overheated the place with virtually forced short term ecconomic immigration and control of interest rates.
The result of a few EU grants to develop Ireland( curtesy of Britains input ) has resulted in a massive debt caused by Globalisation that the EU did nothing to protect us from.
Lets hope Enda tells em to stick their currency, loan etc and stop the errosion of the Irish way of life.
Happy St Pats tommorrow and "Up The Republic" because its very precious, hard won and easilly lost.

ejmaztec

jett wrote: »

You can import one car without paying VRT.
I notice that car prices seem to be getting lower due to market forces.
Road tax is diabolical compared to Britain.
The one thing that Britain has got is a good NHS but it isn,t free as National insurance is very high compared to the ROI equivelent.
Of course things are different in different countries and Ireland is certainly not a bit of the UK stuck off the coast of wales.
I personally believe in different cultures/ customs etc. The common market was assumed to be a great equaliser. Wrong! in my opinion it has damaged the individuality of every nation that joined it. Bribes and threats are the only reason voted for the incomplete Lisbon Treaty
Lets not forget VAT was a condition of being in it.
Now they are trying to alter our soverign corporation tax rate. Of course they are calling it a different thing at the moment but the two main bullys in Europe have their eye on our business.
They have already harmed, farming,fishing,tourism etc and overheated the place with virtually forced short term ecconomic immigration and control of interest rates.
The result of a few EU grants to develop Ireland( curtesy of Britains input ) has resulted in a massive debt caused by Globalisation that the EU did nothing to protect us from.
Lets hope Enda tells em to stick their currency, loan etc and stop the errosion of the Irish way of life.
Happy St Pats tommorrow and "Up The Republic" because its very precious, hard won and easilly lost.

You can import one car without paying VRT if you've owned it for at least 6 months in the UK, and providing that you don't sell it here within 12 months of arriving.

Before VAT was introduced, both the UK and Ireland had purchase tax, which in some cases, e.g. luxury items, was as much as 33.33%.

I wouldn't say that the difference between UK NIC and Irish PRSI is that astronomical, in deciding whether the NHS was free or not.

Blaming EU grants on the current state of Ireland is ridiculous, and reverting to the Punt and telling the EU to feck off is complete economic suicide.

questionmark?

91011 wrote: »

Because wages still cost the same, heating bills have gone up, rent is still the same, rates are the same or have gone up. They'll pour the drink for you, you'll sit on their furniture, you'll watch their TV or listen to the live music, you'll enjoy the heat they provide and they'll pick up your glass when your finished and wash it.

Go to any place in the UK, a pint of decent beer is at least £3.50, (£3.90 in Birmingham a couple of week ago) on the continent, expect to pay up to €8 in some pubs, especially in Paris. €5 is cheap there!

Yes - the high cost of minerals - or more the fact that you can only buy them in 220ml sizes, is a bugbear. Bring in a 330ml size for the same price and that negativity may go away. (330ml glass bottle is standard mineral serving size in UK)

Thats not true. I think you may have got seriously ripped off in some so called up market establishment. I spend a lot of time in the UK and the only time I have payed 3.50 was in a posh ass nightclub at 4 in the morning. Most pubs vary average price I would say is 2.60. Depending on the pub/time/day of the week the price can vary from 1.70 to 3.00. Central London being an exception. Lots of bars charge anything from £1 to £2.50 at most for shooters compared to €5 for a shot in Ireland.

What really annoys me in Irish pubs is the fact that most bars charge the same price for all pints of say lager. In the UK you will find most drinks will be priced slightly differently depending on quality, lager,cider,ale, how strong it is,imported,local etc...

Also this crack of paying €2.50 to €3.00 for a bottle of coke is a joke when all you want is a dash. Compare to the UK when dashs of coke are often free or for a nominal fee.

I think pubs are the worst rip offs in Ireland and quite frankly charge extortionate prices. If they stopped to think for a minute and dropped there prices just by a little bit to make it affordable people may consider going for a pint more often. Before its said I know the costs involved so I am not suggesting dropping to UK prices but a reasonable reduction.

jett

Guiness at £2 a pint, Bitter £1.70 in most areas of Greater London. Even Stella fully loaded at about £2.40.
Heres another rip off, Tesco London Pride 500ML bottle E1.99 Xmas, E2.60 January.
If its piled high and flogged cheap it will fly of the shelf. It worked for M & S. ( or was it Woolworth )

jett

I am well aware of the rules on imported cars, I did it myself and it was easy.
Purchase tax at least went to the countries coffers and not to the EU to distribute and embezzle. Or have you forgotten the scandal which has been swept under the carpet.
The difference between PRSI and NI is astronomical look it up. As a basic rate taxpayer in the UK half my earnings went in Employers NI, Employees NI and tax. Plus all my so called benifits, ie business car, phone, fuel etc were taxed as a perk. Some bloody perk paying to sit in the M25 carpark.
I did not come over here to be worse off.
Ireland has sucked up to the EU and is now paying the price. It has alienated itself from Britain ( where there are more Irish than Ireland) and is dictated to by people who have no respect or even knowledge of the country that is Eire.
The health situation here is third world if you are rich you are okay, destitute you are okay but middle of the road and you can rot.
Like many Anglo Irish I moved here because its a damn nice place with nice people and oppertunities.
My reward like a (100,000 others) for sticking half a million into the place is to be ripped off while the Government sucks up to foreigners who wish to steal our wealth, foreign investment, goodwill and our nationality.
Rant over because you cannot see it.

ejmaztec

jett wrote: »

I am well aware of the rules on imported cars, I did it myself and it was easy.
Purchase tax at least went to the countries coffers and not to the EU to distribute and embezzle. Or have you forgotten the scandal which has been swept under the carpet.
The difference between PRSI and NI is astronomical look it up. As a basic rate taxpayer in the UK half my earnings went in Employers NI, Employees NI and tax. Plus all my so called benifits, ie business car, phone, fuel etc were taxed as a perk. Some bloody perk paying to sit in the M25 carpark.
I did not come over here to be worse off.
Ireland has sucked up to the EU and is now paying the price. It has alienated itself from Britain ( where there are more Irish than Ireland) and is dictated to by people who have no respect or even knowledge of the country that is Eire.
The health situation here is third world if you are rich you are okay, destitute you are okay but middle of the road and you can rot.
Like many Anglo Irish I moved here because its a damn nice place with nice people and oppertunities.
My reward like a (100,000 others) for sticking half a million into the place is to be ripped off while the Government sucks up to foreigners who wish to steal our wealth, foreign investment, goodwill and our nationality.
Rant over because you cannot see it.

Sorry, but the "facts" in your post are completely inaccurate. VAT, like the old Purchase Tax goes straight into the country's coffers, and not the EU's. If anything, monies from the EU coffers came here to be blown away on a multitude of different projects.

You wouldn't have paid employers' NIC in the UK, only the employer pays that, in the same way that employers' PRSI is paid by the employer here. It isn't part of your gross income. The only NIC/PRSI deducted from your pay is the employee contribution.

You get stung for tax on benefits-in-kind in Ireland as well as in the UK.