Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

King George

  • 19-12-2010 9:58pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭


    Hopefully this goes ahead, although reading some comments on the Betfair forum it's far from certain to

    First up the sponsors are guaranteeing top price on Kauto until the opening show. Oddschecker prices are here

    Starting with the one and only Kauto Star! Not much that can be said about this horse that hasn't already been said. I really hope he can make it 5 in a row but some niggling doubt in the back of my had is stopping me from backing him. I think he's by far the best horse in the race (and the official figures will back this up) but I started this season not wanting to back him on the basis of his age and mileage and unless he really drifts on the day (and I don't think he will) I probably won't back him. Price could look huge after the race though

    I must say I can't have Long Run. Don't get me wrong I'm not really knocking him but I can't back a 5 year old at 5/1 when he failed to win a handicap off 158 last time out (with his jockey claiming 5lbs). Last year they really went a scorching gallop in this and it could really put his jumping under pressure. He made mistakes all through last year (including when winning a weak Feltham here) and I think is both bad value and also a likely drifter on the day

    Next on the list is Forpadytheplasterer. must say I respect this horse but am skeptical he'll stay and his form figures show he's either the unluckiest horse in training or just doesn't want to win races

    Riverside Theatre is a horse is a horse who seems to like Kempton but has a bit to find on the book and stamina must also be questionable

    The horse I like is Sizing Europe. Respect for Kauto will probably stop me backing him against the jolly but I think he's very good value in the "without" market at 8/1. Ran well at Down Royal despite uncharacteristically making jumping errors early on and was kept wide too. Seemed to see out the trip fine and was kept wide a lot of the way round. This horse would possibly be 2nd favourite in my book. Hopefully will jump better this time and is the only threat I see to Kauto.

    Nacarat seems to like going right handed and is respected but I can't see him beating Kauto in a million years but would be respected in the without market. I thought he deserved a place in this race last year

    Similar comments apply to Planet of Sound, surely one to concentrate in the without market or possibly place only

    Betfair market suggests Punchestowns is unlikely to run, ditto Alberta's Run but the latter could be interesting if he did run (and the ground was OK) having been 2nd in this race 2 years ago. Again I cn't see him beating the favourite but would have a huge place chance if he ran

    Betfair market suggests Burton Port is a possible (no idea if owner would run both him and Albertas Run) but he'd be respected if he ran

    For me it'll be a case of hoping Kauto wins the 5th and Sizing Europe chases him home. However I will really respect Albertas Run if he lines up


«13

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    Hopefully this goes ahead, although reading some comments on the Betfair forum it's far from certain to

    Just on this. In the "will racing go ahead?" market on betfair, "No" is now 1.66 to lay which doesn't look good at all


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭MassDeb8r


    Re: Sizing Europe....

    Firsty I like Sizing Europe but he simply doesn't stay 3 miles, he was 7l adrift of China Rock at Punchestown over 2m 7f and 4l back behind Kauto Star at Down Royal over 3 miles where he just held second, if you look at the way he stayed the last 3 furlongs he was a spent force 2 out and just lugged along.

    He has won over 2m4f but that seems to be his limit. 8 of his 10 wins were over 2 miles, in fact the way he won the Craddockstown and Arkle suggest he is a proper speed chaser.

    By Pistolet Bleu, it is noteworthy that getting 3 miles is not a guarantee. Geos, who was also by Pistolet Bleu never won beyond 2 miles (he finished last in the long walk hurdle) I'msingingtheblues, by the same stallion fell over 2m 4f and was beaten 9 lengths when favourite for the Future Champion Novices' Chase (grade 2) in Ayr last year, also over 2 m 4f. Indeed Pistolet Bleu’s collective progeny produce very few winners over distances greater than 2 miles.

    Kauto Star is unstoppable on the speed track on St. Stephens Day, you can just plough into him, there won't be a moments worry (assuming the meet goes ahead!)

    SD

    http://irishhorseracingblog.blogspot.com/


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,219 ✭✭✭Goldcupfav


    MassDeb8r wrote: »
    Re: Sizing Europe....

    Firsty I like Sizing Europe but he simply doesn't stay 3 miles, he was 7l adrift of China Rock at Punchestown over 2m 7f and 4l back behind Kauto Star at Down Royal over 3 miles where he just held second, if you look at the way he stayed the last 3 furlongs he was a spent force 2 out and just lugged along.

    He has won over 2m4f but that seems to be his limit. 8 of his 10 wins were over 2 miles, in fact the way he won the Craddockstown and Arkle suggest he is a proper speed chaser.


    How can you say Sizing simply doesnt stay 3 miles when he has had 2 runs over that kind of trip? First time against China Rock it was common knowledge that the horse wasnt fully fit and would improve on the run (opened up at 8/13 and went off 5/4) then at Down Royal he did improve to beat China Rock and make Kauto work very hard for his win. You also said he was a spent force over 2 out and lugged along but to me his two best jumps in the race were over the last two fences im sure a spent force wouldnt of jumped them that well. It should also be noted that Sizing didnt jump well most of the way round and lost plenty of ground at most of his fences. 2008 Arkle winner FPTP is lining up the KG plus the 2007 Arkle winner Tidal Bay was last seen running a length behind Imperial in the Betfair Chase, Kauto himself won the Tingle Creek and went off favourite for the Queen Mother before falling. So winning over two miles doesnt always suggest that horses are proper speed chasers.

    Sizing Europe is reported as being in good form ahead of his tilt at the King George VI Chase at Kempton. The talented 8-y-o has seemingly taken well to the increase in trip this year to 3-miles and finished just 4-lengths behind Kauto Star at Down Royal last month.

    Trainer Henry De Bromhead gave an upbeat bulletin about his runner ahead of the Boxing Day spectacular, telling At The Races;

    "He seems in good form and that's what we are aiming for. I thought his run at Down Royal was very good and I think he'll still improve for that. We are hoping for goodish ground which would be of benefit for us and Kauto Star. We think that there are a few things we could improve upon from Down Royal and we are working on those. He flipped going into the first and seemed to lose his confidence over the first couple of fences, and I think he's only just getting use to the slower pace of jumping over three miles. His jumping should improve again as he becomes more used to that pace as opposed to last year in the Arkle where he went flat out and took the fences in his stride. This year he has had more time to think and that's why he was probably a bit deliberate at them but his schooling has been really good."

    Really dont think anyone can say that Sizing doesnt stay 3 miles yet. I think he has got to run over the distance a couple more times before that can be said for sure.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 176 ✭✭MassDeb8r


    I personally don't think Sizing Europe getsthe 3 mile trip. I think he is better over shorter. I may be proved wrong, but nothing in his races has ever said to me that he would be a good horse over 3 miles. If you look at the form book you will see "found little" and "weakened" in the latter end of the last two races.

    No matter what trip he runs over this season, I think he'll struggle to win races. I don't think he's quite good enough for the top 2 milers - his run at Punchestown behind Golden Silver suggested as much and it's hard to see him developing into a Gold Cup horse. 2m4f will probably be his trip in the long term.

    Sizing Europe is 12/1 for the King George and 25/1 for The Gold Cup, I hope I'm proved wrong and he does stay 3 miles but Sunday will see his third attempt at the trip and de Bromhead may seriously look at his options if he doesn't stay on what is a generally easy, flat speed track but can he beat Kauto ? Not a prayer.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,219 ✭✭✭Goldcupfav


    MassDeb8r wrote: »
    I personally don't think Sizing Europe getsthe 3 mile trip. I think he is better over shorter. I may be proved wrong, but nothing in his races has ever said to me that he would be a good horse over 3 miles. If you look at the form book you will see "found little" and "weakened" in the latter end of the last two races.

    No matter what trip he runs over this season, I think he'll struggle to win races. I don't think he's quite good enough for the top 2 milers - his run at Punchestown behind Golden Silver suggested as much and it's hard to see him developing into a Gold Cup horse. 2m4f will probably be his trip in the long term.

    Sizing Europe is 12/1 for the King George and 25/1 for The Gold Cup, I hope I'm proved wrong and he does stay 3 miles but Sunday will see his third attempt at the trip and de Bromhead may seriously look at his options if he doesn't stay on what is a generally easy, flat speed track but can he beat Kauto ? Not a prayer.

    Agree with you there if he doesnt get the trip at Kempton then he aint going to get anywhere near the Gold Cup trip. Id love to see Kauto win it again but stranger things have happened and i wouldnt totally rule out Sizing of pulling off this shock the KG has been the plan for this horse since the summer. So the 8/1 without Kauto Star to me looks like decent value.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,317 ✭✭✭HigginsJ


    Burton Port is currently 16-1 non runner no bet. Cracking effort in the Hennessy. 3 times the price of Long Run whom he beat a short head in last years RSA and 1lb better off. Bit of an ignored horse in my opinion. Only once outside the top 3 in 14 runs (and on that occasion he was 4th)

    Guaranteed Diamond Harry would be half the price if he were entered.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 2,783 ✭✭✭handsomecake


    if the nightingale runs he wins imo


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    if the nightingale runs he wins imo


    Are you taking the piss


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,335 ✭✭✭✭UrbanSea


    if the nightingale runs he wins imo

    The Nightingale hasn't beaten anything over fences in my opinion and was a very moderate hurdler(especially in terms of him getting some quotes of 3/1 for the GC)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,335 ✭✭✭✭UrbanSea


    *33/1


  • Advertisement
  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 2,783 ✭✭✭handsomecake


    Are you taking the piss
    very good horse right handed.
    jumps to the right.
    same daddy as big bucks.
    won a grade 2 at kempton last year.
    beat roberto goldback by 11 lenghts in down royal on the bridle, roberto was about a lenght and a 1/2 behind tranquil sea this week.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 882 ✭✭✭fr wishy washy


    Can't see Sizing Europe or Forpaddytheplasterer winning this,maybe a place but if it's anyway truly run they won't get home,both to travel well so maybe back to lay in running.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    very good horse right handed.
    jumps to the right.
    same daddy as big bucks.
    won a grade 2 at kempton last year.
    beat roberto goldback by 11 lenghts in down royal on the bridle, roberto was about a lenght and a 1/2 behind tranquil sea this week.

    Am i to believe that your trying to argue the Nightingales potential chances of winning chasings premier 3m event outside the festival by using Roberto Goldback as a form line


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    I've just watched the Down Royal Race again.

    I can't see how it can be used as evidence Sizing Europe does not stay 3m. He made 2 very sloppy jumps at the first 2 fences (probably losing at least a few lengths) and was often out jumped by China Rock. He was marginally ahead of CHine Rock at the 2nd last, marginally behind him at the last yet stayed on well enough to collar him for 2nd

    Add in the fact that Kempton is one of the easiest 3 miles you can find (former champion chaser Edredon Bleu won his only race over 3 miles here) and the trip is the least of my worries

    2.14 to go ahead now, fingers crossed!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    Just looking at the betting. Albertas Run has shortened today but not much on the lay side on Betfair. If both him and the Nightingale ran the w/o market would be shaken up a bit

    9/1 Sizing with Coral w/o Kauto. Pity they don't take euro bets


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 882 ✭✭✭fr wishy washy


    Add in the fact that Kempton is one of the easiest 3 miles you can find (former champion chaser Edredon Bleu won his only race over 3 miles here) and the trip is the least of my worries

    I think the pace of the race will be the deciding factor about whether the Irish pair "get it" fully,a strong pace would see S E and Forpaddy struggling if Kauto Star kicks off it turning in as he usually does.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 2,783 ✭✭✭handsomecake


    Am i to believe that your trying to argue the Nightingales potential chances of winning chasings premier 3m event outside the festival by using Roberto Goldback as a form line
    not neccessarily.the nightingale was 18l ahead of othermix (finished 2nd)in kempton in february,othermix was 18 l (3rd) behind time for rupert in cheltenham and finished ahead of reve de sivola who has won since.

    @33's i cant get past the nightingale.just worried about who nicholls will put on him


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    not neccessarily.the nightingale was 18l ahead of othermix (finished 2nd)in kempton in february,othermix was 18 l (3rd) behind time for rupert in cheltenham and finished ahead of reve de sivola who has won since.

    @33's i cant get past the nightingale.just worried about who nicholls will put on him

    Roberto Goldback, now Othermix :rolleyes:

    Your convienient leaving out the bashing he got at Aintree when beaten 24l by Mad Max who in turn ran 12l behind Long Run (LR was getting 4lbs)

    The Nightingale is actually rated 167, (im surprised at that, Ive no idea where that rating from, cant see any form to it), Long Run is only 158 so your right the 33s probably is value if the handicapper is right.

    Still that only leaves him 33lbs to find with Kauto.


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 2,783 ✭✭✭handsomecake


    Roberto Goldback, now Othermix :rolleyes:

    Your convienient leaving out the bashing he got at Aintree when beaten 24l by Mad Max who in turn ran 12l behind Long Run (LR was getting 4lbs)

    The Nightingale is actually rated 167, (im surprised at that, Ive no idea where that rating from, cant see any form to it), Long Run is only 158 so your right the 33s probably is value if the handicapper is right.

    Still that only leaves him 33lbs to find with Kauto.

    yep


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    190 - 167 = 23


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    King George card now odds on to go ahead


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    190 - 167 = 23

    CBS obv did me no good.

    It should be 33 anyway so gtfo


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 7,669 ✭✭✭Colonel Sanders


    certainly don't disagree that 167 is a high looking mark compared to other horses


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    Anyone think Fehily has bottled it. Standing himself down due to fitness issues.

    Bottled big time IMO


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,838 ✭✭✭Nulty


    I've lumped on (max bet) at EVENS so I'm hoping for a Kauto blitz for the first time (never backed him, jinx?).

    I dont know about Fehily, I doubt hes bottled it, Id give him more credit than that. Great news its likely to go ahead.

    Hugh Taylor put up Nacart ew, I backed him last year and got run out of a place. Dont really see why that wont happen again so long as the rest stay on their feet.

    May have a go at Forecast Kauto-Forpady....too obvious?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,173 ✭✭✭hucklebuck


    I too disagree that Sizing doesn't get the 3 Miles.

    I quite fancy the Nightingale to get into the top 3 in the w/o market, he looked absolutely fantastic in Down Royal and the won the race well, I reckon he will run above his mark in this.

    I am expecting big things from him, he looks like a decent improving type.

    The bet of the day looks Kauto and Khyber Kim double at 6.5/1


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    hucklebuck wrote: »
    I too disagree that Sizing doesn't get the 3 Miles.

    I quite fancy the Nightingale to get into the top 3 in the w/o market, he looked absolutely fantastic in Down Royal and the won the race well, I reckon he will run above his mark in this.

    I am expecting big things from him, he looks like a decent improving type.

    The bet of the day looks Kauto and Khyber Kim double at 6.5/1

    2 miles round Kempton will probably be a bit sharp for Kyber Kim.

    And Sizing Europe defo stays the trip imo


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,219 ✭✭✭Goldcupfav


    Surely Starluck is the value at 10/3. Beat Binocular last time out! Yes Binocular will improve for the run but so will Starluck plus he loves it around Kempton is 2 from 2 on the flat and won a novice hurdle here and finished a shd second to Go Native in the race last year. Dont think he will win the Champion hurdle so id say this is his best ever chance of landing a Grade 1.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    Goldcupfav wrote: »
    Surely Starluck is the value at 10/3. Beat Binocular last time out! Yes Binocular will improve for the run but so will Starluck plus he loves it around Kempton is 2 from 2 on the flat and won a novice hurdle here and finished a shd second to Go Native in the race last year. Dont think he will win the Champion hurdle so id say this is his best ever chance of landing a Grade 1.

    I wouldn't be backing Binocular till the Champion itself, needs to come off a strong pace and he's not going to get that here.

    Agree on Starluck btw


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,232 ✭✭✭meriwether


    I wouldn't be backing Binocular till the Champion itself, needs to come off a strong pace and he's not going to get that here.

    Agree on Starluck btw


    I went in to Boyles yesterday and was offered 2 on Binocular and 3 on Star luck and KK.

    on valuie alone, one would be remiss to not have ones mortgage on Binocular if he is 2/3s of the price of KK and Starluck.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    He might not stay but I think it's simply wrong to say that he definitely won'T. As the previous poster says there is no evidence from his two runs that he doesn't stay. You can draw a line through first time out for most horses. His 2nd outing looked a very good performance to me and I believe that he could possibly turn it around come the weekend. That's not to say I'll back him. I think you would be mad to back Kauto Star at the forecast price. He is an older horse now who has without doubt past his absolute peak.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    minty16 wrote: »
    He might not stay but I think it's simply wrong to say that he definitely won'T. As the previous poster says there is no evidence from his two runs that he doesn't stay. You can draw a line through first time out for most horses. His 2nd outing looked a very good performance to me and I believe that he could possibly turn it around come the weekend. That's not to say I'll back him. I think you would be mad to back Kauto Star at the forecast price. He is an older horse now who has without doubt past his absolute peak.

    What proof have you got that he's not as good as ever.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    What proof have you got that he's not as good as ever.

    He was once the premium chaser in Horse Racing. Now, he quite simply is not. You can't argue with that. That would tell me he is on the decline. He might well win at Kempton on Sunday but I wont be taking that price. I wouldn't back him with someone elses money for the GC.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    minty16 wrote: »
    He was once the premium chaser in Horse Racing. Now, he quite simply is not. You can't argue with that. That would tell me he is on the decline. He might well win at Kempton on Sunday but I wont be taking that price. I wouldn't back him with someone elses money for the GC.

    Why? Because he fell in the Gold Cup

    He is still the highest rated chaser in training.

    There is absolutely no evidence that he has declined. None


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,610 ✭✭✭yaboya1


    minty16 wrote: »
    He might not stay but I think it's simply wrong to say that he definitely won'T. As the previous poster says there is no evidence from his two runs that he doesn't stay. You can draw a line through first time out for most horses. His 2nd outing looked a very good performance to me and I believe that he could possibly turn it around come the weekend. That's not to say I'll back him. I think you would be mad to back Kauto Star at the forecast price. He is an older horse now who has without doubt past his absolute peak.

    First of all, I have not and do not intend to have a bet in this race so there is no bias involved here.

    I'm not sure whether Sizing Europe will or won't stay, but I'm surprised you seem to believe he can turn around form with Kauto Star. That was Kauto Stars first run against a race-fit Sizing Europe and he beat him by a pretty easy 4 lengths. Historically Kauto Star has been pretty unimpressive first time out and had then gone on to show massive improvement in the KG at Kempton. So if Sizing Europe couldn't beat a Kauto Star who wasn't fully tuned-up first time out at Down Royal, I can't see how he will beat him at his favourite track in his favourite race.

    He was once the premium chaser in Horse Racing. Now, he quite simply is not. You can't argue with that. That would tell me he is on the decline. He might well win at Kempton on Sunday but I wont be taking that price. I wouldn't back him with someone elses money for the GC.

    I think you can argue with that. He put up his most impressive performance EVER in this race last year. In his next run he fell. Then this season he won first time out (unimpressively as usual). He may/may not be as good as he once was but there is no clear evidence either way yet.

    Whether he wins the KG or not though, I'm pretty sure Sizing Europe will finish behind him.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    Why? Because he fell in the Gold Cup

    He is still the highest rated chaser in training.

    There is absolutely no evidence that he has declined. None


    Are you saying if he stays up last March he wins ? Seriously ? Never.
    I'll have a match bet with Imperial Commander with you for March. Name your stake. We'll see if you believe the ratings as much as you seem to portray. :P


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    yaboya1 wrote: »
    First of all, I have not and do not intend to have a bet in this race so there is no bias involved here.

    I'm not sure whether Sizing Europe will or won't stay, but I'm surprised you seem to believe he can turn around form with Kauto Star. That was Kauto Stars first run against a race-fit Sizing Europe and he beat him by a pretty easy 4 lengths. Historically Kauto Star has been pretty unimpressive first time out and had then gone on to show massive improvement in the KG at Kempton. So if Sizing Europe couldn't beat a Kauto Star who wasn't fully tuned-up first time out at Down Royal, I can't see how he will beat him at his favourite track in his favourite race.

    He was once the premium chaser in Horse Racing. Now, he quite simply is not. You can't argue with that. That would tell me he is on the decline. He might well win at Kempton on Sunday but I wont be taking that price. I wouldn't back him with someone elses money for the GC.

    I think you can argue with that. He put up his most impressive performance EVER in this race last year. In his next run he fell. Then this season he won first time out (unimpressively as usual). He may/may not be as good as he once was but there is no clear evidence either way yet.

    Whether he wins the KG or not though, I'm pretty sure Sizing Europe will finish behind him.


    Can I just say I did say 'possibly'. It is possible. SE is still very unexposed over the trip. I also think that he should love Kempton . I'm not one for trying to turn around form often, but the forecast prices of 4/5 and 14/1 look WAY off the mark on the basis of the DR run. I also have no bias in this. I'm not some sort of Sizing Europe fanatic!


    I disagree with your second point. He was a beaten horse in the Gold Cup a long way before he fell. He is 10 years old also, so naturally decline will come soon. There is no way can be considered the premium 3miler after the Gold Cup. Imperial Commander was immense. I think on the basis of his Kempton record he has a good chance to win on Sunday.But it's not a bold prediction for you to take a 4/5 shot in a match bet with a 14/1 one! I'm was simply pointing out that I think there is more to come from SE away from 2m after the DR run.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,610 ✭✭✭yaboya1


    I never said he wasn't beaten when he fell in the Gold Cup. One Cheltenham defeat and an unimpressive 4 length win is not clear evidence that the horse is on the decline. If that was the case, you could have said the same going into the 2008 KG after he was well beaten in the Gold Cup by Denman, beaten by Our Vic at Aintree, fell in his prep for the KG at Haydock after winning possibly the softest grade 1 ever at Down Royal. He still won easily at Kempton though.

    I'm not looking for a match bet. I'm just saying I'll be amazed if he can beat a race fit Kauto at Kempton when he couldn't beat a half-fit Kauto at Down Royal.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    yaboya1 wrote: »
    I never said he wasn't beaten when he fell in the Gold Cup. One Cheltenham defeat and an unimpressive 4 length win is not clear evidence that the horse is on the decline. If that was the case, you could have said the same going into the 2008 KG after he was well beaten in the Gold Cup by Denman, beaten by Our Vic at Aintree, fell in his prep for the KG at Haydock after winning possibly the softest grade 1 ever at Down Royal. He still won easily at Kempton though.

    I'm not looking for a match bet. I'm just saying I'll be amazed if he can beat a race fit Kauto at Kempton when he couldn't beat a half-fit Kauto at Down Royal.


    I wasn't offering up one! :D

    Who knows. Personally think the prices are wrong anyway.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,873 ✭✭✭RichieLawlor


    minty16 wrote: »
    Are you saying if he stays up last March he wins ? Seriously ? Never.
    I'll have a match bet with Imperial Commander with you for March. Name your stake. We'll see if you believe the ratings as much as you seem to portray. :P

    Kauto Star was beaten when he fell in the Gold Cup, that was due to the mistake he made down the back so we will
    Never know who would have won with a clear round.

    Kauto Star is a better horse than Imperial Commander, I do believe that, the ratings agree with me. But I wasn't arguing that point

    Again you say he is in the decline without offering up a single shread of evidence. Point me to the piece of form that shows Kauto is on the wane


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,838 ✭✭✭Nulty


    Kauto Star was beaten when he fell in the Gold Cup, that was due to the mistake he made down the back so we will
    Never know who would have won with a clear round.


    Kauto Star is a better horse than Imperial Commander, I do believe that, the ratings agree with me. But I wasn't arguing that point

    Again you say he is in the decline without offering up a single shread of evidence. Point me to the piece of form that shows Kauto is on the wane

    If you ask me (which you didn't) I'd say he was beaten before he stepped onto the track and that is the reason he made the blunder and subsequently fell. I made that clear on the day and still feel the same. Sweating on track and the comments from the groom when he was led out suggested things weren't as they would have liked on the day.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    Kauto Star was beaten when he fell in the Gold Cup, that was due to the mistake he made down the back so we will
    Never know who would have won with a clear round.

    Kauto Star is a better horse than Imperial Commander, I do believe that, the ratings agree with me. But I wasn't arguing that point

    Again you say he is in the decline without offering up a single shread of evidence. Point me to the piece of form that shows Kauto is on the wane

    I think you'll find that a horse making mistakes is a horse on the decline. Are you saying that mistakes don't count for Kauto or something ? I'm also baffled that you think he is a better horse than IC. It's a simple fact that he isn't anymore. Even Nicholls agreed after the GC that Kauto and Denman had bowed down to a new star. I take it you missed that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,286 ✭✭✭✭mdwexford


    minty16 wrote: »
    I think you'll find that a horse making mistakes is a horse on the decline. Are you saying that mistakes don't count for Kauto or something ? I'm also baffled that you think he is a better horse than IC. It's a simple fact that he isn't anymore. Even Nicholls agreed after the GC that Kauto and Denman had bowed down to a new star. I take it you missed that.

    lol so if a horse hits a fence now hes on the decline eh.

    He is obviously a far better horse than IC, score is still 3-1 to Kauto from where im sitting, maybe you missed that.

    And new star, the horse is 10 next week.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 561 ✭✭✭minty16


    Like I said if anyone wants a match bet for the Gold Cup at Cheltenham then name your stake.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 11,286 ✭✭✭✭mdwexford


    minty16 wrote: »
    Like I said if anyone wants a match bet for the Gold Cup at Cheltenham then name your stake.

    Dont worry if things are in his favour on the day i will take you up on that.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,838 ✭✭✭Nulty


    Kauto Star was close to death... but now the living legend is chasing immortality


    By Marcus Townend Last updated at 8:04 PM on 23rd December 2010


    You would not have blamed trainer Paul Nicholls if he had covered AP McCoy in bubble-wrap during his getting-to-know-you session with Kauto Star yesterday.


    Such has been the turmoil during the build-up to the gelding's shot at an historic fifth William Hill King George VI Chase on Boxing Day.



    article-1341198-0C8B9CC0000005DC-31_468x286.jpg The real McCoy: Kauto Star is poised to better the record of the iconic Desert Orchid





    McCoy is the substitute's substitute after first Ruby Walsh, the man who has ridden Kauto Star to his four previous King George wins, broke his leg and then Noel Fehily was forced into an 11thhour withdrawal. That's on top of the freezing weather disruption which still threatens to push the King George back from its Sunday slot.


    Actually winning the race and bettering the record of iconic grey Desert Orchid might end up proving the easy part with Kauto Star head and shoulders above his 10 rivals on paper. Nicholls, however, knows the unpredictable nature of racing too well to take too much for granted.



    The memories of Imperial Commander gatecrashing this year's Cheltenham Gold Cup, which was supposed to be a showdown between Kauto Star and his stablemate Denman, are still raw. As is just how close he was to losing 10-year-old Kauto Star in an ugly fall four fences from the finish.
    'There is a fine line in a fall like that between being fatal and not,' Nicholls recalled. 'It had rained and it was a bit slippery. That allowed him to slip away from the fall.


    'I felt sick but he was lucky. He usually has his manger (where he feeds) on the floor in a tyre. For a week afterwards, we had put three or four tyres on top of each other to raise his manger - he couldn't get down because his neck was so sore. That was why it was a big day going to Down Royal.'


    That trip to Northern Ireland delivered a four-length victory from his King George rival Sizing Europe and confirmation that Kauto Star's confidence remained intact for his shot at history in a race Nicholls has won six times – four with Kauto Star and twice with See More Business.
    The trainer added: 'His comeback run was as good as he has ever produced first time out. If there was a sign that he was underperforming, we'd stop him.


    But it is a long way off because he is going as well as he has done in any of the last three years. He has not deteriorated. Plenty of horses have ability but don't stay sound. He has been able to withstand the rigours of racing. He is a phenomenon.'


    On official ratings, Kauto Star's nearest rival in the King George is Albertas Run - the horse McCoy was due to ride - and he is a 22lb inferior animal. Long Run and Riverside Theatre are both up-and-coming chasers but with massive amounts to make up, while Nacarat, fourth last year, is an each-way option, but it is hard to find a flaw in the odds-on favourite's make-up.

    So, How does he compare with Dessie?

    Kauto Star
    Trainer: Paul Nicholls.
    Jockeys: Ruby Walsh, Mick Fitzgerald and Sam Thomas.
    Career starts: 35. Wins: 21.
    Prize-money: £2,086,991.
    Highest Timeform rating: 191.
    King George record: Unbeaten in his four attempts at the prize under Walsh over the past four years.
    Cheltenham Gold Cup wins: 2.
    Finest hour: Equalling Dessie's record 12 months ago with his most impressive King George win.


    Desert Orchid
    Trainer: David Elsworth.
    Jockeys: Colin Brown, Simon
    Sherwood and Richard Dunwoody.
    Career starts: 70. Wins: 34.
    Prize-money: £654,066.
    Highest Timeform rating: 187.
    King George record: Ran six times -
    winning four (1986, '88, '89 & '90),
    second to Nupsala in 1987 and fell in 1991.
    Cheltenham Gold Cup wins: 1.
    Finest hour: Despite his Boxing Day
    heroics, probably ending his Cheltenham Gold Cup hoodoo with victory in 1989.




    Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/racing/article-1341198/Kauto-Star-close-death--living-legend-chasing-immortality.html#ixzz18zUJYGba

    .


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,838 ✭✭✭Nulty


    Evergreen Kauto still a star at top of festive tree

    By Chris McGrath, Racing Correspondent

    Friday, 24 December 2010




    Pg-40-racing-pa_522603t.jpg PA
    Kempton remained frozen yesterday as hopes for a thaw in time for Boxing Day receded


    His new jockey may be man of the moment, but not even Tony McCoy will supplant Kauto Star at the top of the bill at Kempton on Boxing Day. True, the melancholy possibility remains that neither will be there, the weather having taken a discouraging turn yesterday. Assuming the meeting survives, however, McCoy would urge those who made him BBC Sports Personality of the Year to proceed now to a further breakthrough in their awareness of his sport.

    For the most accomplished steeplechaser of the era, the William Hill King George VI Chase this year transcends Christmas ritual. It is a matter of history, and the passage of years – and the precarious margin between the two. Kauto Star is seeking a fifth consecutive success in steeplechasing's midwinter championship, something beyond even Desert Orchid, the grey spectre of Christmas past.

    Sooner or later, however, Kauto Star must begin to betray the erosion of age. He is on the cusp of his 11th birthday. Desert Orchid, having himself won the race four times, was well beaten when he fell at the third last in 1991. He was promptly retired. Admittedly, he was a veteran then, nearly 13, and Kauto Star has been campaigned more sparingly.

    Even so, his owner, Clive Smith, has distressing memories of that day, and vows not to push his own champion as far. "I wouldn't want Kauto Star to go out like that," he admits. "I want him to go out at the top."

    Smith had an excruciating glimpse of the nightmare scenario when Kauto Star took that ghastly fall going for his third Cheltenham Gold Cup in March. "I was very worried," his owner says. "I thought it might be the end, even. So it was fantastic to see Ruby [Walsh] jumping back on, and riding him back to the cheers of the crowd."

    In his only start since Kauto Star produced an efficient display at Down Royal last month, and Paul Nicholls, his trainer, is adamant he has yet to perceive even the faintest hint of decline. Certainly, the bookmakers have been curiously generous about Kauto Star, just two starts after the most breathtaking performance of his life, in this race last year. Timeform have him no fewer than 26lb clear on their ratings. Yet until poor Noel Fehily decided he was not fit to do justice to the biggest opportunity of his career, in a deed of excoriating honesty two days ago, the sponsors were offering Kauto Star at 11-10. Only this new association with McCoy, the punters' favourite, has now forced them into a shade of odds-on. But even that seems very fair when you remember the way he demoralised his rivals last year, carting Walsh clear to win by 36 lengths on the bridle.
    The increasingly conservative strategy of Nicholls and Smith will surely keep the petrol gauge out of the red a while longer. The annals of this race are strewn with serial winners, and it is certainly tailor-made for Kauto Star. Tempted by the flat, sharp turns, the runners tend to go a hectic gallop and that enables Kauto Star to take them a place they would sooner not go.

    Long Run made an impressive British debut on the equivalent card last year, but his fortunes since require a leap of faith if he is supposed to give the champion a race at level weights. Similar assumptions have to be made in favour of the Irish pair, Forpadydeplasterer and Sizing Europe, neither being established stayers. And while Riverside Theatre is progressive and adores the track, to step up in trip and beat Kauto Star himself would represent a melodrama so far-fetched that his co-owner, the splendid Jimmy Nesbitt, would generally send the script straight back to his agent.
    Still, his involvement offers another boost to a sport glad to be reminding a broader public of its charms. For all that the heart goes out to Fehily – not to mention Walsh, who broke a leg last month – McCoy and Kauto Star is certainly an engaging double act. A pity, then, that reality may yet bite today when an inspection is scheduled at noon. The thaw in the snow on the frost blankets had slowed yesterday, with some of them now freezing to the turf.

    So far as Kauto Star himself is concerned, however, Nicholls is certain he retains that perennial, midwinter bloom. "They're a long time retired," he observes. "At the end of the day, this horse has the best of everything at the moment, and loves what he's doing. That's why it will be a sad day when he does retire. He really is enthusiastic about life in the stable. In theory, he could run in the next three Gold Cups. But if there were any sign, at any stage, of him underperforming, we'd stop him. We all know that. But it's a long way off at the moment. I'm not even thinking about it."

    http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/racing/evergreen-kauto-still-a-star-at-top-of-festive-tree-2168270.html


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,816 ✭✭✭corny




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,588 ✭✭✭Bluetonic


    KG supposed to be on the 15th (Lanzarote), so say the sponsors


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,261 ✭✭✭Juwwi


    20 days late but better late than never. :)

    Im thinking of doing Forpaddy in the betting w/o kauto market at
    7/1 with pp's.

    With only 9 runners 4th place could probably pay out on the place money
    or Albertas Run at 16/1 betting w/o market is another one lm looking at.

    Forpaddy ran in the 2m5f hurdle at the festival and was 4th and was second behind cooldine over 2m5f at leop not beaten far,those runs help to lessen the worry that he wont stay 3m at kempton.

    Anyone else fancy anything.


  • Advertisement
Advertisement