Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

I need your help! A.S.A.P.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 31-10-2010 7:15pm
    #1
    Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭


    I adopted a beautiful little dog from the pound last week. She was affectionate, placid and great with everyone she met. We noticed that she was not obiedient at all but never worried as I had planned on taking her to doggie training classes in a few weeks time anyway. After two days her personality changed, she was less affectionate and was exhibiting dominant behaviour. On Saturday morning we let her out the back garden and our neighbour's two dogs were outside also. Once she sensed them she went absolutely balistic. She was trying to get through the fence and was out of control. When I went down the end of the garden to her she snarled at me. My boyfriend told me to pick her up but when I hesitated he interveened and attemted to calm her down. She wasn't happy and growled at him. We simply had to give up as we were getting nowhere. Eventually, when she came into the house my boyfriend told her to get into her bed and coaxed her in with his hand and she bit him. We were both shocked as up until this point she had been the perfect pet. When the groomer came later on that day the dog got loose. My brother in law picked her up but found it difficult to hold onto her as there were two dogs loose on the street that she wanted to get at. The groomer offered to hold her but she was bitten by our dog because our dog felt so threatened and stressed by the whole situation. Thankfully the groomer was ok and so was our dog but we were all left a little shell shocked to say the least. We are now very wary of our dog and really don't feel experienced enough to socialise her properly with other dogs. I rang a dog therapist today and she told me to send her back to the pound but I cannot bring myself to do that to her. She just needs an experienced dog owner who can exert dominance and show her the way. We need someone to rescue her and give her the second chance and understanding she deserves. Unfortunately, we are not the people to do it but I know there's someone out there that can make her into the wonderful dog I know she can be. Please help us!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


«1

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,524 ✭✭✭Zapperzy


    Ring another trainer, no decent trainer would give up like that and say 'bring her back to the pound', that is absolutely disgraceful. Where are you based as someone might be able to recommend a good one near you? She sounds like she has severe issues with other dogs, but definitely doesn't need dominating. Dominance is just a myth spouted by the likes of cesar milan. Reward-based training can do wonders for dogs without the need for alpha rolls and what not the cesar uses.

    As regards the biting I wouldn't worry about it too much, both times she bit she was in a highly stressful state and was probably so worked up that she was just trying by any means to get away from the person trying to pick her up. One thing you should never do when a dog is in that much of a state is put your hands down near them or try and pick them up, if theres a lead attached just pull them away with that, if not well I suppose there's not much you can do except try and slip a slip lead around the dogs neck.

    Don't give up on her yet anyways, contact a good trainer and see what they advice, you've only had her a week so she's only really settling in and you don't know what her past was like. She's gorgeous by the way! :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,975 ✭✭✭Cherry Blossom


    You shouldn't try to pick her up, try leaving a short lead attached to her so you can use that to guide her when she gets into that frame of mind. I would get a behaviourist into your home if you have any inclination at all to try and resolve these issues. Such a pity this has happened and no way really of knowing what the cause is. I would also take her to a vet for a full check up to make sure there is no underlying medical cause before giving up on her.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 657 ✭✭✭portgirl123


    first of all well done from rescuing her from the pound, and secondly as u have all ready said please dont sent her back to the pound as she will be classified as a surrender and could be pts straight away.
    I would never use that dog theripist as without seen her telling you to send her back to the pound, what the f**k. Is she certified?
    Poor little Tilly sounds like she is just overweilmed (sp) and has prob never been socialised.
    Could u not give her more time and book her in to see a proper trainer/behaviorist? id say all she needs in some time. If you cant and good on you afor at least trying, im sure someone on here would know of a good place to send her. I would love to take her but with 3 other dogs proberley not the right place for her.
    again good on you for at least giving her a chance. Lets us know what you decide.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,900 ✭✭✭crotalus667


    pennyloves wrote: »
    She just needs an experienced dog owner who can exert dominance and show her the way.

    No what she needs is a dog behaviourist that is not using out dated theories like dominance. You dog is still settling in , it’s not hard to see what went wrong , your dog was stressed , you stressed it out more and it reacted it's not the dogs fault the fact that you did not say "went to the local A&E would sugest that it was not an atempt inflicting injury merly a warning which would of been given after other warning which you where oblivous to


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 16 Thedogspyjamas


    this poor dog must be shell shocked from her new, albeit great, situation and suffering some terrible emotional abuse from the last owner. you should give it time, quiet and patience. how old is the dog?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 49 tulipi


    I would not necessarily agree that you need to exert dominance to help train a difficult or traumatised dog. If you have read anything about positive reinforcement and positive training you'll see that there are other ways of helping a dog rather than being dominant. Look up victoria stilwell and others and try and find a positive trainer instead. That trainer doesn't sound very helpful. How could she have known that the dog should be sent back to the pound without coming to your house and seeing the dog's behaviour for herself?

    You've only had this dog for a week. She is probably still unsure where she is and to be honest I would suspect that rather than being dominant or agressive she is fearful.

    So basically it all depends on how much effort you want to put into this dog. If you're going to keep her you're going to need to do a lot of research, contact a trainer (I would suggest a positive trainer because with a dog that has been in the pound you don't know what they have been through), socialise her with lots of other dogs and put in a lot of work and training. If you're willing to put in the work then it is likely that your dog will turn out great and will get better. But it will take time.

    You need to decide whether that's a route you can take or not. If it's not then don't take her back to the pound. She will most likely be put down because you have returned her for her aggression. Try and find a rescue that can take her. There are lots around but they usually have too many dogs as it is so you might have to look around. There is paws.ie, dog's trust, the DSPCA, Dog's Aid etc.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,634 ✭✭✭✭Graces7


    Her personality did not change; many who rescue dogs know that at first they are as you found, then when they start to feel secure, they show their true often abused nature.

    It has cetainly been thus with our collie.

    It seems there was just too much stimulation for this dog too soon? So many things she was not used to , too many people she did not know.

    Our wee "russet" even now can be overwhelmed if there are too many people, however friendly.

    Dogs show their unease by growling; and if that warning is not heeded, then they will add to it.

    Dogs like children need a lot of time to get used to new situations and to settle into very new surroundings.

    If she is not used to other dogs etc? Then her behaviour is for her, normal and natural. It is not dominant as you think.

    When we take in a new rescue, things are kept very, very quiet for some weeks even. Little by little...

    It surely is not too late with this dog? Backtrack? Take things at her pace?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 116 ✭✭Phenix


    first off well done on taking this little dog in, she's gorgeous by the way and secondly any 'therapist' who's advise it is to just bring her back to the pound should be avoided at all cost!
    i suggest bringing her to classes. you should be able to find some local classes or your vet might be able to recomend someone? speak to the trainers first and discuss what problems you are having with her and they should be able to help you out.
    best of luck and please dont bring her back to the pound, she obviously has some issues, has never been properly socialised and trained. a good trainer should be able to guide you and ur dog in the right direction :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,939 ✭✭✭goat2


    if i were you, i would put a muzzle on her and walk her on a lead every day for a few weeks, let her near other dogs with muzzle on, help her to socialise, even if it is ten, fifteen, minuits two or three times a day, the more you do it the better the results, also when leaving her out in garden put muzzle on, and when you are having visitors whack it on, you will find that after a few months she will be fine, she does not trust people at moment, so she will have to learn to trust again, patience is the key, she looks beautiful and will come out great, i once had a dog with that problem and this was my way of doing things, muzzle mean you will not have to worry about nips


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,961 ✭✭✭✭Discodog


    Firstly well done. There is some excellent advice here but the key is to realise that your little dog has at very least been through a huge trauma & may of been dominated to the point of being beaten.

    Dogs are not aggressive without a very good reason. Your dog trusted people & that trust was betrayed so, like you in a similar situation, it will be very wary. You need some proper professional help & that is not easy to find as anyone can call themselves a trainer or behaviourist.

    I would look on all the Pet boards & forums. Some have specific forums just for training. Go by recommendation. What area are you in ?.

    In the meantime follow the advice here & minimise the stress on the dog. If ever you absolutely had to get rid of the dog please do not return it to a Pound but try & find a rescue who could take it.

    Oh & definitely go to a Vet & get the dog checked over.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,188 ✭✭✭pH


    Just to say I wouldn't make any decision on a dog that's new - in the first 3 weeks anyway. We just rehomed a sprocker, and whist he didn't bite anyone he was an absolute nightmare for 3 weeks.

    However he's about as changed a dog as can be in 3 weeks.

    Your dog has been through a lot - lost (abandoned?) and now with a new home - they're also trying to find out what's allowed and not. Give the dog some time.
    • Get into a regular routine.
    • Walk the dog twice a day.
    • Don't get angry or frustrated with it
    • Positive reinforcement all the time - Use food (even dried dog food) as a treat ALL THE TIME - reward calm behaviour.
    • If the dog has problems with other dogs then socialise it - meet them on the lead, visit friends who have dogs.

    Oh, and an obvious question, is she spayed? Could she be in heat?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,190 ✭✭✭✭IvySlayer


    Well, people can go on about positive reinforcement, but your dog is ignoring your commands. From the pound or not, they have to respect you. I really think you shouldn't of showed fear, but tried to outwit the dog. OK she bit someone, but was she punished? She's new, but she still had to learn the rules.

    Next time she even bares her teeth, give out to her and muzzle her straight away to show you will tolerate no BS. When she's calmed down, then give her a treat to show you like her when shes calm. Tough love is needed, but it will pay off.

    Find another dog trainer, book yourself into some classes.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,975 ✭✭✭Cherry Blossom


    OP - having just looked at the photo's, there looks to be a fair bit of Westie in her. They are very sensitive to changes in diet and are known to have digestive problems and food intollerences. I can't feed my Westie anything with chicken in it or she goes bouncing off the walls mad for a week. What are you feeding her?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,737 ✭✭✭✭kylith


    IvySlayer wrote: »
    Well, people can go on about positive reinforcement, but your dog is ignoring your commands.
    If the dog is completely untrained how can it be ignoring commands? The OP may as well be speaking Greek for all the dog understands.

    OP get on to a decent trainer, and stock up on patience.

    One of mine was similar when we got her first; very shy, but after about a week she started trying to attack any strange dog that came within 10 feet. After literally years of work she's gotten much better; the snarling and lunging has pretty much stopped as long as the other dog is calm and the other day a loose terrier trotted up behind her and she did nothing but glare at it. She has even made some doggie friends.

    Good luck!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,634 ✭✭✭✭Graces7


    IvySlayer wrote: »
    Well, people can go on about positive reinforcement, but your dog is ignoring your commands. From the pound or not, they have to respect you. I really think you shouldn't of showed fear, but tried to outwit the dog. OK she bit someone, but was she punished? She's new, but she still had to learn the rules.

    Next time she even bares her teeth, give out to her and muzzle her straight away to show you will tolerate no BS. When she's calmed down, then give her a treat to show you like her when shes calm. Tough love is needed, but it will pay off.

    Find another dog trainer, book yourself into some classes.

    This is the most worrying post I have seen for a long time. Thankfully others know better. "Tough love" to a dog so new? Really!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,531 ✭✭✭Tranceypoo


    Graces7 wrote: »
    This is the most worrying post I have seen for a long time. Thankfully others know better. "Tough love" to a dog so new? Really!

    Just what I was thinking.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 183 ✭✭sionnaic


    I wholeheartedly agree with all the other posts here - with the notable exception of IvySlayer's...please PLEASE ignore that one!!!

    Your little dog needs time and patience and a calm non-threatening environment. You've no idea what horrors she's been through before and while in the pound, so it's hard to judge, but it does sound like you may inadvertantly overwhelmed the poor thing with too many new people and new experiences and she freaked. You need to let her settle and learn to trust you before confronting her with more.

    The "dog therapist" who told you to bring her back to the pound is an absolute disgrace. :mad: What a truly awful person and they proclaim themselves to be a dog therapist??! :eek:

    There are great trainers and behavourists out there who could really help you using positive techniques that are not based on the out-dated and unpleasant dominance model. We had fairly similar problems with our little rescue dog (lack of socialisation, fear aggression to strange dogs and men) and we got a dog trainer to come to our house and she was really great (if you're based in the East / South-east PM me and I'll give you her details). Anyway the techniques she taught us have just completely turned our guy around and it's only been about 3 weeks. So don't give up - honestly, with the right help, the problems can be fixed if you're willing to put in a bit of work.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    Thanks for the responses.
    We had a behaviourist out to the house last night.
    He was very positive & left us feeling positive.

    Im a bit worried about her at the moment.
    She's not eating her food & drinking very little water.
    (Im feeding her pedigree chum variety pack - beef, rabbit, chicken).
    When she doesn't eat what I give her, I feed her some ham,
    but she's only eaten 2 slices of ham all day today.
    The behaviourist told us that she was very nervous at the moment.
    She just sits on the couch for most of the day & doesn't seem well.
    I've seen her rench a few times over the past two days.
    She seems very stressed.
    The only active thing she does is hump her bed, mainly from 9am to 1pm.

    Im going to get the vet out to have a look at her tomorrow.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,961 ✭✭✭✭Discodog


    It can be really helpful if people know the general area that you are in. We may be able to recommend Vets, behaviourists etc.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,713 ✭✭✭lrushe


    kylith wrote: »
    If the dog is completely untrained how can it be ignoring commands? The OP may as well be speaking Greek for all the dog understands.

    Couldn't agree more, how can you harshly correct a dog if it didn't understand what you wanted from it in the first place.
    This dog has been through a huge upheaval, I would allow it to settle in a bit, then progress to a trainer.
    You'd be surprised the progress you can make once your dog understands what you expect from it, but of course they have to be taught this first.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 183 ✭✭sionnaic


    pennyloves wrote: »
    Thanks for the responses.
    We had a behaviourist out to the house last night.
    He was very positive & left us feeling positive.

    Im a bit worried about her at the moment.
    She's not eating her food & drinking very little water.
    (Im feeding her pedigree chum variety pack - beef, rabbit, chicken).
    When she doesn't eat what I give her, I feed her some ham,
    but she's only eaten 2 slices of ham all day today.
    The behaviourist told us that she was very nervous at the moment.
    She just sits on the couch for most of the day & doesn't seem well.
    I've seen her rench a few times over the past two days.
    She seems very stressed.
    The only active thing she does is hump her bed, mainly from 9am to 1pm.

    Im going to get the vet out to have a look at her tomorrow.

    Definitely bring her to the vet to get checked out.

    Also don't feed her ham - pork in general is not good for dogs and the salt content in ham in particular is way too high. Salt is not good for dogs.

    If she won't eat dog food, give her boiled chicken and rice. Finely chop a chicken breast and put into a saucepan with a mug of rice, cover with water and bring to boil for about 30 mins. Drain and allow to cool (can rinse in cold water to speed it up).

    Also pedigree chum is a really bad quality food so you should consider switching her to something better quality. Feeding dogs a supermarket brand is like feeding MacDonalds to a child every day - they'll eat it but it's not healthy. Look for food with natural ingredients only with no additives, meat derivatives or things like that. I feed ours "Robbies" lamb and rice from "Land of Holistic Pets" and they're doing really well on it. I order it online. There are a lot of other good foods out there too if you do a bit of research.

    Remember to switch her over gradually to a new food, over 7 days gradually mix in small amounts of the new food into her chicken and rice, increasing the amount of new food gradually every meal until on day 8 she's on 100% new food.

    Also it can be a good idea to feed 2 medium meals a day (morning and evening) rather than just one big meal once a day. It can be easier on their digestive system.

    If she's uneasy you could consider making her a little "den" somewhere - comfy bedding in a crate (door left open) or a roomy cardboard box on it's side with the open side half covered with a sheet/towel.

    I'm glad you found a good trainer to help you! Best of luck


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,975 ✭✭✭Cherry Blossom


    Glad you are getting help with her OP! On the food I would suggest a high quality dry food labelled 'hypoallergenic'. Westies (and I assume crosses of) seem to do quite well on a lamb and rice based kibble. You can add a little warm water to it if she isn't keen on it or microwave for 3-5 seconds (brings out the smell). They also have a tendancy to go off their food every once in a while so don't worry to much about that especially as she's a bit put out at the minute.

    Some of the foods you could look into are: Burns lamb and rice (highly recommended), Arden Grange lamb & Rice, James Wellbeloved Lamb & Rice. Don't be put off thinking they are more expensive as you'd be feeding a third of the amount. A 3 kilo bag lasts me 6 weeks.

    Please avoid supermarket brands like Pedigree, there is no telling what is in them and it really is a false economy.

    The fact that she is retching would make me believe the food isn't agreeing with her, it could of course be somthing else but you would honestly be amazed at the difference the food can make to these dogs.

    <ETA> Burns do an excellent booklet on pet nutrition and health care which they will post you out with a free food sample, just e-mail then at burnspet@eircom.net and ask.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    sionnaic wrote: »
    If she won't eat dog food, give her boiled chicken and rice. Finely chop a chicken breast and put into a saucepan with a mug of rice, cover with water and bring to boil for about 30 mins. Drain and allow to cool (can rinse in cold water to speed it up).

    Thanks for that, she ate the boiled chicken & rice, such a relief to see her eat something. Now Im off to bed.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    Hi OP - I second the suggestion of giving her a little den. It doesn't have to be something expensive, as sugested, a cardboard box on it's side would suffice. (although I believe a crate is a great investment). It would give her somewhere to go that she feels secure.

    The "ground rules" of her den is you do not send her there as punishment, if she's really nervous you ignore her when shes in it as if you cannot see her (if crate training this also helps to combat crying etc as the dog knows it wont get a reaction), and until she trusts you 100% you never pick her out of it against her will. It's important visitors know the rules too. (although the amount of visitors who choose to ignore them or "decide they're wrong" can be ridiculous. :mad:)

    Please don't try to dominate a nevous dog. At best you will turn her into a nervous wreck - at worst you could make her very agressive out of pure fear.

    Delighted you got her to eat, you sound like just what this poor girl needs, so well done. Please keep us up to date on how she is settling in.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 402 ✭✭Jelly2


    I don't know as much as some other posters here about what you should do, although most of the advice seems really sensible to me. I just want to say to you that you are doing the right thing in keeping that little dog, and working so hard and caringly to give her a good home. And every little step forward is encouraging! Please keep us updated on progress.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 183 ✭✭sionnaic


    pennyloves wrote: »
    Thanks for that, she ate the boiled chicken & rice, such a relief to see her eat something. Now Im off to bed.

    That's great! :)

    Having a new dog (especially if you haven't one before can be a bit overwhelming...and when that dog is a rescue it can be that little bit more intense! Believe me I know how you feel, the first couple of months we had our two little monsters felt like we were lurching from one mini-crisis to another. We didn't know what we'd gotten ourselves into! I felt like a new parent in a lot of ways :D

    But also believe me, it pays off and it all feels easier after a while...and seeing those waggy tails on two little dogs who are absolutely ecstatic to see you every morning, and getting slimed with millions of doggy kisses makes up for all the crappy little things :D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 32,634 ✭✭✭✭Graces7


    sionnaic wrote: »
    That's great! :)

    Having a new dog (especially if you haven't one before can be a bit overwhelming...and when that dog is a rescue it can be that little bit more intense! Believe me I know how you feel, the first couple of months we had our two little monsters felt like we were lurching from one mini-crisis to another. We didn't know what we'd gotten ourselves into! I felt like a new parent in a lot of ways :D

    But also believe me, it pays off and it all feels easier after a while...and seeing those waggy tails on two little dogs who are absolutely ecstatic to see you every morning, and getting slimed with millions of doggy kisses makes up for all the crappy little things :D

    Bonding with any dog takes time and a lot of quiet love. Small wonder she is not eating.. Just all too much.

    When we took the collie in, she was so over-subdued that she would allow us to do anything; but when we had to bathe a cut paw, she made herself so heavy we could hardly get the foot off the ground. she was terrified but so scared of being abandoned and tied up again that she submitted. That is over-dominant on her abusive owners.

    It took months to get her real trust; not the subservient kind that some seem to want, but the trust and the love that dogs need to have with us. She would run ahead but her head sideways so as not to lose sight of us; and no way would we exert more control over her than we need. Now she runs head to the front.

    They need skin contact too; sit with her, let her put her head on your lap if she needs to. Just sit quietly with her.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 596 ✭✭✭minterno


    from your pics its more than likely that the dog has assumed the alpha posisition in the house,its a pack thing,google it and you will see that no dog should be left share seating or bedding with a person as it will try to become the dom figure,not all dogs will behave like this but a lot will,they should allways be lower than yereselves when sitting and should be the last to be fed in the house,follow these directions and you should see an improvement,i had a dog years ago that i let develop these habits and had a lot of probs with him,nice dog by the way and i wish you the best but if it even growls at a child thats it,no chances,better safe than sorry


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    There is no way to tell from pics what "position" the dog has "assumed" in the house.

    There are many threads in the forum relating to dogs and dominance. It might interest you to have a look.

    I think most people now accept that where your dog sits and when it is fed has very little effect on its behaviour. If your dog sits where it is allowed to and respects the boundaries you set, then you have set the rules therefore "dominance" is not an issue. If it suits you better to feed the dog while your own dinner is cooking, that has nothing to do with dominance either.

    Peoples dogs are not sitting around trying to figure out how to usurp their leader and sieze control. :D

    The op's posts tells a story of a very scared and confused dog. It would be unwise to disregard what the OP has written and guess what the problem is based on a picture.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 183 ✭✭sionnaic


    Whispered wrote: »
    There is no way to tell from pics what "position" the dog has "assumed" in the house.

    There are many threads in the forum relating to dogs and dominance. It might interest you to have a look.

    I think most people now accept that where your dog sits and when it is fed has very little effect on its behaviour. If your dog sits where it is allowed to and respects the boundaries you set, then you have set the rules therefore "dominance" is not an issue. If it suits you better to feed the dog while your own dinner is cooking, that has nothing to do with dominance either.

    Peoples dogs are not sitting around trying to figure out how to usurp their leader and sieze control. :D

    The op's posts tells a story of a very scared and confused dog. It would be unwise to disregard what the OP has written and guess what the problem is based on a picture.


    Absolutely 100% +1 !!!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 596 ✭✭✭minterno


    Whispered,the pics look like the dog is sitting on a leather couch,and if the pics dont matter why mention it,the dog has issues that need to be addressed and from what i have read (yes its been some time that i had any need to look into the subject)the dog needs to learn his place in the home,ie pack,that does not mean mistreatment of any kind,it actually gives the dog confidence,a dog,any dog is a pack animal and needs the structure of a pack,i dont mean to offend you or anyone else,this is my opinion ands its a learned one,its not pulled out of my you know what,one of the biggest mistakes some people make with their pets is humanising them,regards


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,975 ✭✭✭Cherry Blossom


    minterno wrote: »
    Whispered,the pics look like the dog is sitting on a leather couch,and if the pics dont matter why mention it,the dog has issues that need to be addressed and from what i have read (yes its been some time that i had any need to look into the subject)the dog needs to learn his place in the home,ie pack,that does not mean mistreatment of any kind,it actually gives the dog confidence,a dog,any dog is a pack animal and needs the structure of a pack,i dont mean to offend you or anyone else,this is my opinion ands its a learned one,its not pulled out of my you know what,one of the biggest mistakes some people make with their pets is humanising them,regards

    No, it certainly hasn't been, Ceaser Millan couldn't have said it better himself. My Westie actually sits up on the back of the couch so she can see all the goings on out the window, it beats sitting on the floor barking at noises outside. She's happy, I'm happy, Everybodys happy :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    :confused:.... you mentioned the pics and I responded.

    The dog does look like it's on a leather couch. What has that got to do with dominance?

    I think that as well as learning its "place" (by that I mean routine, rules etc) the dog needs to learn to trust. It will be hard to earn its trust if you're preoccupied with dominating the dog.

    I agree with you that setting rules etc and sticking with them can help a dog with its confidence but it's up to each person to set the rules. If the op would like to allow the dog on the couch, and it's apparent she did considering she took photos instead of putting her off, then the OP set the rule that the dog can sit on the couch. No issue of diminance at all.

    My dog sits on the couch - he still knows who's the boss.

    (the cat :pac:)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 596 ✭✭✭minterno


    your dog knows your the boss,i think thats the difference,its only the odd dog that will try to be the boss,i had a lab years ago and i gave him some bad habits.their was allways a dog in my house,all were given the run of the house,3 different labs and a doberman and all were sweet,when i moved in to my first house after leaving home i got a yellow lab that went sour,the only thing he did not bite was himself,hence i did a lot of reading on the subject and took the advice from the vet,id say their could have been interbreeding with my fella because as he matured his head took on a kind of bulldog look,hopefully this fella will be ok,he def needs structure though,regards


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    My dog sits on the couch - he still knows who's the boss.

    (the cat :pac:)

    Oh how I laughed when I read this. The dog THOUGHT he was boss. My cat (who I recently lost) KNEW he was the boss!!


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭ISDW


    minterno wrote: »
    Whispered,the pics look like the dog is sitting on a leather couch,and if the pics dont matter why mention it,the dog has issues that need to be addressed and from what i have read (yes its been some time that i had any need to look into the subject)the dog needs to learn his place in the home,ie pack,that does not mean mistreatment of any kind,it actually gives the dog confidence,a dog,any dog is a pack animal and needs the structure of a pack,i dont mean to offend you or anyone else,this is my opinion ands its a learned one,its not pulled out of my you know what,one of the biggest mistakes some people make with their pets is humanising them,regards

    The ideas of dominance and being alpha are very old fashioned, maybe read up on it again, but read some more recent books. Dogs know that we are not dogs, so why would they think that we are part of their pack? I have huskies, a very, very pack oriented breed, but they know I'm their human, not their alpha, I have an alpha dog within the pack, the relationships between all the dogs and their relationship with me is very different. At the moment 4 of my dogs are lying near me on my bed, but when I tell them to get off, they will, not because I'm dominating them, but because when I tell them to get off something, thats what they do.

    The last thing that you want to do with a scared rescue dog is try to dominate it, you are likely to get badly bitten. You need to gain that dog's trust, which the OP is trying to do. A scared dog is a dangerous dog.

    I don't humanise my dogs, they are working dogs, but where they originally come from, part of their role is to act as hot water bottles at night with the inuit children, lying in bed with them. So, who am I to argue with history?:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    minterno wrote: »
    he def needs structure though
    +1


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    Tilly ate two bowls of rice and chicken today. She has been a tiny bit more alert and affectionate. My boyfriend removed the bed she was constantly humping and peeing on and she seems much happier and hasn't had an accident all day!!!!! I am over the moon - this is massive progress. I hope things will continue on in this way....I can't thank everyone enough for all their support. My boyfriend and I use this board as our crutch to keep us going - thank you;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    Thats brilliant news. Well done.

    It can be so overwhelming when you get a dog. Especially one with problems. If there is a step back don't worry it's only natural so no panicking. Take things at her pace. It will all be worth it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    As i've just said she has made a tiny bit of progress today that has definately restored hope in us. We have made an app. 2 c the vet 2mor but r a bit concerned that it may undo everything we have seen today as she is still extremely fearful and trembles when we bring her out the back. What do u think we should do? Should we reschedule for next week so that she can settle in a bit more and gain in confidence or should we just go 4 it 2mor nite and hope 4 the best?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 14,772 ✭✭✭✭Whispered


    Does she seem healthy?

    I think it's a matter of opinion. For me, my number 1 prority would be her mental state; unless she seems physically sick. If she is now eating, drinking and going to the toilet, I would put the visit off for a week.

    Now others may think differently so hopefully someone will give a second opinion.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,378 ✭✭✭ISDW


    Whispered wrote: »
    Does she seem healthy?

    I think it's a matter of opinion. For me, my number 1 prority would be her mental state; unless she seems physically sick. If she is now eating, drinking and going to the toilet, I would put the visit off for a week.

    Now others may think differently so hopefully someone will give a second opinion.

    No, I think I'd agree with you. Unless you have any obvious health concerns with her, I'd let her settle in and feel more secure with you and your partner before taking her to the vets. The vets can be a stressful place for a lot of dogs, due to the smells and sounds, so I'd just keep doing what you're doing for now.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    we thought so too so thanks 4 the reassurance. She's eating, drinking and seems much more at home today, I'd hate to rock the boat but also wanted her 2 b checked over by a vet. My boyfriend is off tomorrow so he's going to reschedule da app. 4 nxt week and also ask the trainer to come to our house 4 a few wks b4 we bring her to a socialising class as she's so vunerable at da mo. Can't thank u enough x


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,975 ✭✭✭Cherry Blossom


    pennyloves wrote: »
    we thought so too so thanks 4 the reassurance. She's eating, drinking and seems much more at home today, I'd hate to rock the boat but also wanted her 2 b checked over by a vet. My boyfriend is off tomorrow so he's going to reschedule da app. 4 nxt week and also ask the trainer to come to our house 4 a few wks b4 we bring her to a socialising class as she's so vunerable at da mo. Can't thank u enough x

    Perhaps when he rings he could ask to speak to the vet or get them to call him back. If he explains the situation the vet may well agree that it's best to wait a week and they may have some advice for you on her eating etc. in the meantime.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    John actually told us to leave until she settles down but I'm a worry wart and booked an app. Now that she's gobbling her food I'm happy 2 postpone da vet visit. Thanks again ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 17,737 ✭✭✭✭kylith


    What I do with mine is for the couple of weeks before a scheduled vet visit I'll bring them to the vet's office a few times and just sit in the waiting room for 15 minutes or so and feed them treats, then there's the vet visit, then I'll bring them back to sit in the waiting room a bit and have some more treats. This means that they don't automatically associate going to the vet with bad things, and they actually drag me in the door because they enjoy going there. If Tilly will take treats from you it might be worth a try.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    the problem is she won't do anything 4 a treat. We tried 2 get her off da couch the other day and she just sniffed the treat and went back to sleep! Thanks 4 the advice, I'm sure it'll wrk in a few mths time when she calms down a little :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,961 ✭✭✭✭Discodog


    OK we are trying to be nice here so I will say avoid & ignore anything or anyone that mentions, packs, dominance, aggression, alpha etc. If the dog is sitting on your furniture ignore it for now. As you are discovering the key is love, trust & security. There will be a time for training but it isn't now.

    I will predict that you will be really surprised at what happens. My rescue Greyhound was a bundle of nerves for about a month then suddenly something clicked, she felt safe & instantly turned into the most self assured thing on four legs. My new rescue pup only took less than a week & now is a totally adorable nutter. There will come a point when she realises that everything is going to be OK.

    Until then avoid stress & just give her time to get to know you. Do everything gradually. So for example, when she is ready entice her into the car, then big treat, lots of praise & lead her out. Next time make it a bit longer. Then as her confidence grows start the engine etc etc.

    Don't push her, go at her pace & the penny will drop. Then you will have a dog that thinks it's a puppy again & will seem reborn.

    EDIT: re you last post. Remember that she may not know what a treat is. My neighbour got a rescue & it took a couple of weeks before it would take a treat. I use Bakers Rewards Puppy treats. They come in sticks & it's so easy to keep a couple in your pocket & break a bit off as you need it. It is so funny when I walk my three. The two older dogs watch my hand. If it goes anywhere near the pocket, they know which one, they rush to my side. The pup loves them so much that he realised that he had to run off before I could call him back for a treat. He would run away from me & then keep stopping to see if I would call him back.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 113 ✭✭pennyloves


    That is great advice - we will introduce her 2 da car gradually this wk, starting from 2mor. I just can;t believe how far she's come in a day - she's sitting at the table begging 4 food! We have 2 take everything at a snail's pace and hopefully things will work out. Thank u again, Penny ;)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,961 ✭✭✭✭Discodog


    The thing is that you cannot train a dog until it knows & trusts you. Yes training is reward based but you do have to use firm words sometimes. A couple of days after getting my nervous wreck Greyhound, tail between the legs & quivering like a jelly, I forgot that she was there. My older dog had stolen a food wrapper & I admonished her with a firm "Who's a thief". The Greyhound nearly died of shock - took ages to calm her down & stop the shaking. Now the only time that she ever shakes is when she's cold.

    First Vet visit she had to be carried in - she had to go because of injuries that were there when I got her. Second visit she walked in - just. Now she bounds into the waiting room & jumps up with front paws on the counter !.

    As your confidence in her grows she will feed off it & become more secure. As you get happier she will get happier. She can sense your emotions.


  • Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement