Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Record Label Looking For Bands *MOD WARNING IN POST #1*

  • 17-06-2010 2:06pm
    #1
    Closed Accounts Posts: 3


    Calling the irish unsigned entertainment industry.

    Are you a rock, indie, heavy metal band or solo artist.
    Are you sick to death of people trying to get you to pay for them to work with you. Òr pay to play gigs which are not providing you with access to labels, well if the answer is yes, then welcome to a new service called impa academy, we are currently looking for the best in new unsigned talent across all of ireland. It will cost you nothing, only your time. We are in the final stages of putting together a deal with major labels which will see irish bands get released worldwide. This is going to be the biggest drive in irish rock history, bands will be given access to recording studios , producers and engineers ,music tv and radio worldwide. We get paid everytime one of you get signed, so if you want a record deal, publishing deal then contact us on here, to earn money priavte msg us today, please note impa academy is new,we have a website being designed, we will never ask a single artist for a penny by email or phone, this service is totally free to bands and solo artists,

    become a record producer/sound enigneer
    it is your dream to become a record producer producing singles an albums for artists who are up for international release, become know to the record industry, build up a portfolio of production work so everybody knows who you are , who you have produced, for what label and chart placing worldwide your productions have reach, build you a cv of released productions which your paid for producing and engineering, well we will have the courses for you, and they wont cost a fortune and give nothing back. At impa you will be recording in professional recording studios in ireland and the uk. If your a person who wishes to train as a record producer or enigneer, but find other courses are to expensive then priave msg us and we will contact you to go over everything with you.

    Are you a trained a producer/enigneer

    finding it hard to gain work, after college most studios and labels want to see a cv of work outside your college course which will show them how good you really are. Them private msg us, we have a service for you that will see you gain work and a cv of productions across the world. This servive cannot be provided free . But it fairly priced for what we will do for you.all work provided is provided under a legal contract in ireland. So for roducers who wish to be the new timbaland or jay z or if your dream is to produce for some of the biggest bands in the world when your cv is out their then contact us toda

    MOD WARNING:

    Alright, ok. The dude doesn't have a great grasp of English. But really, if you don't have anything to add to this thread, why bother?

    If you have no interest in responding to the guy, don't post. Simple. If you do, I will see it as thread spoiling and issue bans as I see deserve it.


«13

Comments

  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    That's a LOT OF CAPS


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,911 ✭✭✭Zombienosh


    impa academy returns no results on google


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    I actually applaud whoever is doing this (I just didn't dig all the painful caps)!

    It's good that people are trying, at least trying, to help the Irish music scene.

    I wish you guys a TON of success.

    It's very painful to me to see all the bands that move to London and all the people that say, "you can't make it here in Ireland".

    If this kind of thing helps change the scene and people's expectations, then I fully support it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,070 ✭✭✭✭Malice


    I've reformatted the first post so that it's actually readable. I've left the typos in though.
    AlcoholicA wrote: »
    impa academy returns no results on google
    Yes it does. I got the International Marine Purchasing Association, the Inventory Management Practitioner - Advanced Course and about 33,300 more. Mind you, I found nothing about the IMPA referred to in the first post :).


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3 impaacademy


    we are new and dont at this time have a website up online. we are different in that our music production courses will be though by real music industry professionals, our film and tv courses is though by a guy who has many hollywood years behind him. but is young enough to be able to give our students and bands the chance to reach their goal and make money along the way

    impa team


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,070 ✭✭✭✭Malice


    we are new and dont at this time have a website up online. we are different in that our music production courses will be though by real music industry professionals, our film and tv courses is though by a guy who has many hollywood years behind him. but is young enough to be able to give our students and bands the chance to reach their goal and make money along the way

    impa team
    I mean this as constructive criticism so don't take offense but please, if you're representing a professional organisation, take more care over your posts. What you've written on this thread so far is littered with mistakes that, to me, reflect very poorly on the message you're putting across (and that's without mentioning the original post that was written in all caps).


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3 impaacademy


    Malice_ wrote: »
    I mean this as constructive criticism so don't take offense but please, if you're representing a professional organisation, take more care over your posts. What you've written on this thread so far is littered with mistakes that, to me, reflect very poorly on the message you're putting across (and that's without mentioning the original post that was written in all caps).


    please understand that we are new and only posted to day., our new pr team will be taken the post another level shortly. but your views will be passed and thank you for taken the time to contact us


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,507 ✭✭✭nitromaster


    please understand that we are new and only posted to day., our new pr team will be taken the post another level shortly. but your views will be passed and thank you for taken the time to contact us

    Still agree to the post you responded to,
    If you're going to get proper PR who can write stuff properly then do it before you started posting publically. (PR=public relations)


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    Still agree to the post you responded to,
    If you're going to get proper PR who can write stuff properly then do it before you started posting publically. (PR=public relations)

    Boards is a harsh mistress.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,301 ✭✭✭artvandulet


    please understand that we are new and only posted to day., our new pr team will be taken the post another level shortly. but your views will be passed and thank you for taken the time to contact us

    Unfortunately, I can't figure out if this is going to be something legitimate or not. The wording and spelling of your posts are so bad that I immediately have doubts about your legitimacy. Otherwise it sounds interesting.
    I strongly advise you to get someone else to post messages on behalf of your organisation before you do it any further damage.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,070 ✭✭✭✭Malice


    our new pr team will be taken the post another level shortly.
    Jesus wept, what does that even mean?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 354 ✭✭drumdrum


    Its like they are using Google Translate to post here from a different language or something!!

    But Malice is right, first impressions are too important to underestimate!

    Its like if I represented a professional organisation and put up an advert like:

    "Yo whatsup peeps? My company "AI: Awseom Instruments" sells alot of uniqe instruemnts and stuff so chek us out like, yeah? Cool beans!"

    instead of:

    "Greetings musicians of Ireland!
    AI: Awesome Instruments are a new up and coming business enterprise that specialise in the retail and distribution of specialised instruments....." etc etc...

    I know which ad I would take more seriously!


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    Unfortunately, I can't figure out if this is going to be something legitimate or not. The wording and spelling of your posts are so bad that I immediately have doubts about your legitimacy. Otherwise it sounds interesting.
    I strongly advise you to get someone else to post messages on behalf of your organisation before you do it any further damage.

    I agree.

    I think this is def intended to be a VERY serious thing, which would be cool, but it needs a different approach to communicating it's goals, etc.

    Yer, man, who I PM'd to try and sus this out, was very responsive and nice, for the record, and was prolly just over excited by the project to hold off on posting.

    That can all be forgiven and even overlooked completely if the project turn out to be 10% as promising as the OP made it sound.

    Come OP, follow through with this! We're all pulling for ye to be legit!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,731 ✭✭✭greenpilot


    This may be of help to folks......
    IMPA may refer to:


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    greenpilot wrote: »
    This may be of help to folks......
    IMPA may refer to:
    Savman wrote: »
    Brutally harsh, but fair.

    Looks farcical already tbh.
    drumdrum wrote: »
    Its like they are using Google Translate to post here from a different language or something!!

    But Malice is right, first impressions are too important to underestimate!

    Its like if I represented a professional organisation and put up an advert like:

    "Yo whatsup peeps? My company "AI: Awseom Instruments" sells alot of uniqe instruemnts and stuff so chek us out like, yeah? Cool beans!"

    instead of:

    "Greetings musicians of Ireland!
    AI: Awesome Instruments are a new up and coming business enterprise that specialise in the retail and distribution of specialised instruments....." etc etc...

    I know which ad I would take more seriously!
    Unfortunately, I can't figure out if this is going to be something legitimate or not. The wording and spelling of your posts are so bad that I immediately have doubts about your legitimacy. Otherwise it sounds interesting.
    I strongly advise you to get someone else to post messages on behalf of your organisation before you do it any further damage.
    MilanPan!c wrote: »
    Boards is a harsh mistress.
    Still agree to the post you responded to,
    If you're going to get proper PR who can write stuff properly then do it before you started posting publically. (PR=public relations)
    MilanPan!c wrote: »
    That's a LOT OF CAPS
    AlcoholicA wrote: »
    impa academy returns no results on google


    Alright, ok. The dude doesn't have a great grasp of English. But really, if you don't have anything to add to this thread, why bother?

    If you have no interest in responding to the guy, don't post. Simple. If you do, I will see it as thread spoiling and issue bans as I see deserve it.

    This is the line btw. Cross it and you will be banned.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 6,911 ✭✭✭Zombienosh


    I was/am interested in this, I just said i couldnt see anything when i googled, I've pm'd and am waiting for an email response :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 65 ✭✭Jibbs


    AlcoholicA wrote: »
    I was/am interested in this, I just said i couldnt see anything when i googled, I've pm'd and am waiting for an email response :)

    Lettuce no how you get on with this. Sounds intriguing.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 72 ✭✭Pawsome54


    I pm'd the guy who put this up the other day and have to say, he was bang on, helpful as he could be and no bullsh*t about him.
    Strongly reccomend others get in touch too


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 35 SpittinStuff


    +1


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 606 ✭✭✭gibson


    I pm'ed too just waiting for reply, ill let you know how I get on!


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,062 ✭✭✭all the stars


    Pm'ed also


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    Are you guys PM'ing this crowd out of some morbid curiosity, as in, looking for red flags? Or do you actually believe they can do something for your music/band that you're somehow incapable of doing for yourselves?
    It's good that people are trying, at least trying, to help the Irish music scene.

    I can't disagree with that sentiment at all. It just seems there's a vast sea of people who are all for “helping” but haven't put together something that doesn't smack of amateurism masquerading as semi-professionalism.
    If you have no interest in responding to the guy, don't post. Simple. If you do, I will see it as thread spoiling and issue bans as I see deserve it. This is the line btw. Cross it and you will be banned.

    I'm all for people helping out, but in the same fashion that bands are sometimes given harsh criticism of their music from would-be listeners, these kind of start-ups should not be exempt from sceptical analysis either. To be clear, I don't condone personal attacks or rude insults and put-downs (which is all too frequent on the internet) but placing certain ventures into a protective box where they can't be commented on reasonably isn't the solution.

    Let this thread be a good lesson to bands on what to look for when you encounter others who give you a great pitch on helping you out.

    If it sounds too good to be true... it probably is... you don't get something for nothing...

    Remember, no one else creates the appeal and demand for your music. YOU create the appeal and demand for your music.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 15,070 ✭✭✭✭Malice


    Remember, no one else creates the appeal and demand for your music. YOU create the appeal and demand for your music.
    So Jedward created the appeal and demand for their music? Louis Walsh and their record label had nothing to do with it?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    I think my point has been misunderstood.

    So let's take your example of Jedward. They're the ones up on that stage aren't they? If they were totally useless (which is open to debate of course), no marketing or PR could convince people to like them unless they found some kind of entertainment value in them. The music industry has a long history of flops (I think it's something like an 80% rate of commercial “failure”), acts which had all the marketing and record label promo behind them; still didn't turn 'em into successes at the end of the day.

    So when I say, you create the appeal and demand for your music, the key word is you, because you are the artist/band and it is your performance that seals the deal, not whether the record label buys you tons of advertising space and hypes your music through the media, etc. YOU still have to deliver the goods. You are the appeal that's in demand by consumers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 72 ✭✭Pawsome54


    I think my point has been misunderstood.

    So let's take your example of Jedward. They're the ones up on that stage aren't they? If they were totally useless (which is open to debate of course), no marketing or PR could convince people to like them unless they found some kind of entertainment value in them. The music industry has a long history of flops (I think it's something like an 80% rate of commercial “failure”), acts which had all the marketing and record label promo behind them; still didn't turn 'em into successes at the end of the day.

    So when I say, you create the appeal and demand for your music, the key word is you, because you are the artist/band and it is your performance that seals the deal, not whether the record label buys you tons of advertising space and hypes your music through the media, etc. YOU still have to deliver the goods. You are the appeal that's in demand by consumers.

    I disagree, you can be the best, most incredibly talented band in the world, but if you don't have the right people behind you and the right contacts, you're never gonna get anywhere.

    Yes, i do agree that it's up to a band to create their appeal, and make themselves good enough so that people would maintain interest in them, however without the right marketing and help along the way, unfortunately all that hard work and effort will go to waste.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    That's a horrible, short-sighted mentality to have; that all your efforts are in vain if commerce isn't behind you and you don't attain the levels of success your musical icons and heroes once did.

    Although at 16 years of age, I certainly believed that too.

    There's no yard stick to measuring success; it means different things to differnet people. Success for some can mean having more money than your neighbour; having more friends; a bigger or faster car, a wife with huge breasts, a more interesting job, or... being in a band that tours the world.

    A band that are “talented” get a label, promotion and gain “success”. Most musicians (particularly unsigned ones) attribute a large part of their “success” to the label's involvement.

    Similarly, when another talented band get a label, promotion, yet gain no success (they fail to sell enough records), musicians tend to attribute a large part of the band's failure down to the band's lack of ability to win over the public, and the label are still held in high esteem.

    So if you succeed; thumbs up for the label; if you lose; it's your own fault... kinda.

    Warped thinking or what?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 72 ✭✭Pawsome54


    Well I'm not going to get into an ethical debate with you about the measure of success.

    What I mean by the above is that most musicians wish to pursue a career professionally, and not just in their spare time after their day-job.
    That's what I mean by success, that a band can get by just with their music.
    Now I completely accept that some people only want to have a laugh with their mates, play a couple of gigs, have a pint and enjoy the music. However, there are others who yes, do dream of being your rock stars or pop stars etc. And these people do, in general, need help from record labels and the likes to help them get by, and get where they want to be.

    Either way its the love of the music that counts, not just wanting to make money or be famous.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    there are others who yes, do dream of being your rock stars or pop stars etc. And these people do, in general, need help from record labels and the likes to help them get by, and get where they want to be.

    I think you misunderstand what I'm trying to say here. That's not in dispute. If you read the "looking for a record deal?" thread, you'll see I don't write off a label's involvement if the goal is to become a big music star.

    In the above example I gave here, where band A succeeds and band B fails, the common denominator in both is still the band's music; their appeal, not the label's input and organisation skills presenting the band to consumers. You can take the horse to water but you can't make him drink. It's the label's job to try and convince the public to drink whatever is put in front of them, whether the music is crap, good, great, or amazing... but in any case, the band's appeal is what wins over the crowd and this is something that they can and do work on themselves.
    So when I say, you create the appeal and demand for your music, the key word is you, because you are the artist/band and it is your performance that seals the deal, not whether the record label buys you tons of advertising space and hypes your music through the media, etc. YOU still have to deliver the goods. You are the appeal that's in demand by consumers.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 606 ✭✭✭gibson


    Are you guys PM'ing this crowd out of some morbid curiosity, as in, looking for red flags? Or do you actually believe they can do something for your music/band that you're somehow incapable of doing for yourselves?

    .

    Whats the harm in sending them a PM and finding out some more information?


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 72 ✭✭Pawsome54


    Oh ok, sorry for the misunderstanding, in that case I do agree with you Waking-Dream. Marketing can be difficult for a band on its own to do though without good management and such, so having a record label would still help in that respect, and there's no harm in being open to taking all the halp you can get.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    Learn to help yourself as much as you can is all I'll say. :D
    Whats the harm in sending them a PM and finding out some more information?

    What's the harm in going to see a palm reader either? It all depends on what you expect you will get out of it based on what evidence you have gathered beforehand.

    It just seems as if this crowd shot itself in the foot by not having a website set-up, and the nature of the post as well for that matter gives off the impression of good intentions soaked in amateurism. Again, nothing wrong with wanting to help, but in order to be taken seriously, one has to present some level of professionalism. Otherwise, as a band, you don't know what kind of person/people you're dealing with and how useful they actually are.

    Case in point, a few years ago I was in band very briefly with a guy who was very much looking to get signed and tour the world. He had big ideas, and big ambitions. Yet just like you see on Dragon's Den when it goes all wrong, he was one of those manic, nonsensical, crazy, all over the place people – his "pitches" just sounded like those of a dreamer every time he spoke to the rest of the band and other people about us doing something that would help the band and further our progress, all based in unreality too. I think he had some deep issues about succeeding and wanting to make something of himself. I felt sorry for the guy.

    Anyways, we went our separate ways but then months later he resurfaced, putting together his own “production company” for unsigned bands to help them get signed, get their music out there, make money, forge a career, etc – pretty much the kind of thing that this crowd here are offering it seems. Yet, in my example, this is the last person you would want to get involved with or waste your time listening to. Again, he had no website yet (just a myspace page), said everything was in the making, he was negotiating with record labels, the list goes on...

    In the end it never went anywhere.

    I'm not suggesting the people running the IMPA are anything like this now, but it's just something to think about in general. Don't overestimate what other people can do for you just because they have good intentions. That guy I mentioned had good intentions too, though I wouldn't entrust him with others people's music because he couldn't even handle his own affairs. He was a mess.

    Again, people set-up these things to help. But there's no criteria for qualifications. It could be a bedroom warrior who just wants to feel important by having a “production company” that promotes bands no more effectively than you or I could by spending an evening on MySpace/Facebook messaging people.

    Then again, tons of bands act like amateurs in a state of arrested development so no wonder they're open to working with such people. But I think you'll find bands and artists who have their heads screwed on tend not to waste their time and energy with such ventures. They can see the wood for the trees.

    Have you ever been approached by someone at a gig who claims they have a website that will review your music, or have a podcast and will play your music? Of course, there's no harm in giving them a disc you say, but what if the amount of people they reach is almost no one, or worse, they don't even have a website and just scored a free disc from you for nothing? These people are out there.

    It's just food for thought. That's all I'm offering.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 606 ✭✭✭gibson


    What's the harm in going to see a palm reader either? It all depends on what you expect you will get out of it based on what evidence you have gathered beforehand.
    I have no set expectations what so ever merely seeing what they have to say and that will prove how professional they actually are
    Have you ever been approached by someone at a gig who claims they have a website that will review your music, or have a podcast and will play your music? Of course, there's no harm in giving them a disc you say, but what if the amount of people they reach is almost no one, or worse, they don't even have a website and just scored a free disc from you for nothing? These people are out there.

    It's just food for thought. That's all I'm offering.

    And what if that same producer even reached 1 important person with that disc? How are you gonna know unless you try....all for the sake of maybe loosing 1 copy of a burnt cd? Not a huge price to pay in my opinion.

    In fact Ive seen plenty of people after gigs giving out their CDs for free. I dont see how it can be a bad idea when you never know who might hear it. It doesnt cost much to get a few blank Cds and burn a few copies at very least, its not like your giving out bars of gold!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 74 ✭✭Zendali


    Tonight I decided to explore this thread as I was understandably curious, given that I started a broadly-similar thread called: "Looking For A Record Deal?" I empathised immediately with the OP of this thread, irrespective of the grammatical weakness of his opening post. My gut reaction was that maybe this guy`s first language isnt English but that he`s built up an extensive network of music biz contacts over the years,(same as me),relocated to Ireland, and is offering a conduit to the industry for unsigned artists and bands. That`s a healthy contribution straight away in my book and the more of these outlets the better. It`s widely acknowledged in the global music industry that Ireland is a great source of talent and the success of acts from this island is completely disproportionate to it`s (relatively) tiny population.
    As I began reading the thread and noticing how the OP was being assailed from all sides by an excitable lynch mob, I was glad to read the mod`s intervention asking to give the guy a chance.
    The OP was offering a free service to the thousands of unsigned acts out there and given the chronic congestion unleashed by the internet, every avenue of opportunity is more than welcome.
    Then I got to a post from "Waking-Dreams" on page 2 and it beggared belief. In one breath he was telling us: "It just seems there`s a vast sea of people who are all for "helping" but havent put together something that doesnt smack of amateurism masquerading as semi-professionalism". I`ll be notifying some 55 contacts (and counting) among labels, publishers, management companies and music journos/radio producers. The "amateur" inference is a tad annoying, as "Waking-Dreams" sits on the fence sniper-like while taking pot shots at those trying to help, while offering zilch himself by way of support or opportunity for unsigned acts. It`s one thing to splash about in a paddling pool of idealism but pragmatism is uppermost here, not fanciful ideals. .
    His second point literally put the brakes on my reading the thread any further: "To be clear I dont condone personal attacks or rude insults and put-downs" Hello?! Am I reading the words of an aspiring Fianna Fail politician here, ready to run with the hare and chase with the hound? Ummm...When you signed off your post with that hackneyed cliche: "if it`s too good to be true then it probably is...you dont get something for nothing..." you forgot the one that makes up the cliche trinity: "There`s no such thing as a free lunch". Try thinking outside the box, believe in Karma, give and take, help and reward, etc etc


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 130 ✭✭rhythm90


    Hi mate,

    I have to say I think it's very commendable what you guys are trying to do... The lack of a decent Irish music scene in Ireland is a total sickener considering there are so many talented and dedicated musicians and bands the length and breadth of the country who will never get a look in unless they fly to foreign shores and give it a go there!

    My band Aggro-Culture (Dublin / Wexford based hard rock / metal) would be interested in hearing some more from you.

    http://www.myspace.com/aggroculturehome - some tunes up there.

    Thanks for your time.


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    Zendali wrote: »
    Tonight I decided to explore this thread as I was understandably curious, given that I started a broadly-similar thread called: "Looking For A Record Deal?" I empathised immediately with the OP of this thread, irrespective of the grammatical weakness of his opening post. My gut reaction was that maybe this guy`s first language isnt English but that he`s built up an extensive network of music biz contacts over the years,(same as me),relocated to Ireland, and is offering a conduit to the industry for unsigned artists and bands. That`s a healthy contribution straight away in my book and the more of these outlets the better. It`s widely acknowledged in the global music industry that Ireland is a great source of talent and the success of acts from this island is completely disproportionate to it`s (relatively) tiny population.

    As I began reading the thread and noticing how the OP was being assailed from all sides by an excitable lynch mob, I was glad to read the mod`s intervention asking to give the guy a chance.

    The OP was offering a free service to the thousands of unsigned acts out there and given the chronic congestion unleashed by the internet, every avenue of opportunity is more than welcome.

    Then I got to a post from "Waking-Dreams" on page 2 and it beggared belief. In one breath he was telling us: "It just seems there`s a vast sea of people who are all for "helping" but havent put together something that doesnt smack of amateurism masquerading as semi-professionalism". I`ll be notifying some 55 contacts (and counting) among labels, publishers, management companies and music journos/radio producers. The "amateur" inference is a tad annoying, as "Waking-Dreams" sits on the fence sniper-like while taking pot shots at those trying to help, while offering zilch himself by way of support or opportunity for unsigned acts. It`s one thing to splash about in a paddling pool of idealism but pragmatism is uppermost here, not fanciful ideals. .

    His second point literally put the brakes on my reading the thread any further: "To be clear I dont condone personal attacks or rude insults and put-downs" Hello?! Am I reading the words of an aspiring Fianna Fail politician here, ready to run with the hare and chase with the hound? Ummm...When you signed off your post with that hackneyed cliche: "if it`s too good to be true then it probably is...you dont get something for nothing..." you forgot the one that makes up the cliche trinity: "There`s no such thing as a free lunch". Try thinking outside the box, believe in Karma, give and take, help and reward, etc etc

    It's funny, isn't it.

    I had this same issue with another poster, who couldn't understand why I thought calling someone, "probably too good to be true" without actually talking to the poster, would be considering not only rudely ignorant, but self-destructive.

    That too good to be true person has opened up a HUGE number of doors for me and is a friend now.

    If I had listened to that pessimist I would be in a MUCH WORSE position personally.

    What a lot of people need to do is learn that you can't really base a whole heck of a lot on people's OP. Instead, PM the poster and engage personally. Don't let uninformed comments stop you either.

    Be optimistic AND smart.

    It's possible.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    In fact Ive seen plenty of people after gigs giving out their CDs for free. I dont see how it can be a bad idea when you never know who might hear it. It doesnt cost much to get a few blank Cds and burn a few copies at very least, its not like your giving out bars of gold!

    Have a look at most review websites. They typically state, “NO MP3's or copied discs. We require an original copy for review”. Giving out blank copies is one thing; handing out original demos to people who claim they'll give you a review in their site with zero readership is another thing. That's what I'm talking about.

    Now, Zendali, would you like a hug? :p
    As I began reading the thread and noticing how the OP was being assailed from all sides by an excitable lynch mob

    I'll agree some of the initial posts were sarcastic but this is the Internet, it's trial by fire. Someone makes claims that appeal to people's desire to further themselves musically, and people will naturally look for some evidence that they can back those claims up with. A lack of a web presence in this day and age just isn't a smart move. Sorry.
    The "amateur" inference is a tad annoying, as "Waking-Dreams" sits on the fence sniper-like while taking pot shots at those trying to help, while offering zilch himself by way of support or opportunity for unsigned acts.

    Sits on the fence? Offering zilch to bands? So some words of advice and observation is deemed zilch by your standards unless it leads to a pat on the back for “good effort” or an opportunity for unsigned bands (I offer them some industry contacts?). I have received PM's from people thanking me for my input into the various threads here and there's a few thanks from some users at the bottom of my posts in this forum. So, yeah, zilch offered indeed.

    I know you don't like what I have to say Zendali but with respect, this is a public forum where everyone should have their say. I think I have been most diplomatic in not wanting to piss people off but sometimes you have to ask the hard questions like, “is this for real?” People tend to get defensive when their self-esteem is threatened, but that's a part of life. You have to learn to take a bit of criticism and stand up for yourself and your ideas. Why haven't the IMPA come back and defended their venture by posting more info which would put people's concerns to rest? I'd love it if they did. I'm happy to be proven wrong. But my posts aren't really about IMPA, but about these kind of ventures in general. Bands should think things through and make smart choices, otherwise they're just acting on impulse. Like a consumer who buys a product they thought they wanted but turned out they didn't need.

    But pointing out where the guys went wrong is somehow “negative” in your mind and is a “personal attack, rude insult, or put-down”? So, we all have to be nice to each other? No one can say anything “negative” or make a criticism because we all come here to feel good about ourselves, and it's the thought that counts.

    All I have ever said on this forum, is that bands can help themselves more than they think. Instead, many of them are convinced they're powerless and badly need the help of anyone (even people who have no proven track record of their qualifications or use). I mean, what do bands usually ask of musicians when they try-out at an audition?

    “Who have you played with before? What experience do you have? OK, let's hear you play.” Imagine, the reply they got was, “Emm, I'm working on it, I'll get back to you soon, but I really can help your band's sound!”


    So if the band were to criticise and disregard this person, by your definition, they would be “negative”.

    And the FF comment was bit absurd but ironic coming from yourself.

    I noticed in the “looking for a record deal thread” you ignored the very first question you were asked.
    What will your role be in brokering these deals? Can you direct the readers of this board to previous deals you have been involved with? What is your track record? Out of , say, 200 artists that you have brought to publishers or labels how many have been offered deals?

    I overlooked this, but someone brought it up after I left the thread. Yet, your answer would have put the tactics of most politicians to shame.
    While living in London for several years I ran a music night in a pub venue. I also managed a couple of acts, studied Contract Law, and attended music industry seminars. I networked extensively during this time and scouted on a freelance basis for several labels including Epic, Polydor and Nude (Suede`s label). I also scouted songs for a couple of publishers, so I`m not exactly wet behind the ears as to how this industry works - or at least what`s left of the industry.

    That still didn't answer the initial question at all of what deals/bands you were involved with and how they got on. But well played nonetheless.

    Look, Zendali, I know it seems like I'm out to sh*t in your cereal but it's nothing personal. I'm speaking my mind like everyone else here does. I have studied music business for 3 years and have been out there in the real world playing in bands, locally and across Canada, interacting with lots of musicians and listening to the myriad testimonies, stories, and viewpoints of other seasoned players. I have my own views on the whole topic of the music industry and what people think about it and what they want from it. It's a fascinating subject about the human condition, to want validation and acceptance from people but on a larger scale than their social circle can provide.

    You and I are on polar opposites, like an atheist and a faith head, so I'm happy to stay clear because I have nothing constructive or useful to offer from your point of view.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,062 ✭✭✭all the stars


    gibson wrote: »

    In fact Ive seen plenty of people after gigs giving out their CDs for free. I dont see how it can be a bad idea when you never know who might hear it. It doesnt cost much to get a few blank Cds and burn a few copies at very least, its not like your giving out bars of gold!

    True, but if you have invested quite a bit of time, € and effort on recording, writing and getting good mixing/mastering/great production/Recording studio time etc on your CD - why would you give it away free? Its cost x amount to make it and then give it away free? Even asking €5 is probably not even going to chip away at the cost of buying blank CD's...
    I understand why people would do it, but i also dont understand why they would want to, i know people who are generally more than happy to pay for music - even if it is available free on various websites, people dont mind supporting good music and Artists, It helps them be able to afford making more...(i'm one of them, and i know lots of others).


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    True, but if you have invested quite a bit of time, € and effort on recording, writing and getting good mixing/mastering/great production/Recording studio time etc on your CD - why would you give it away free? Its cost x amount to make it and then give it away free? Even asking €5 is probably not even going to chip away at the cost of buying blank CD's...
    I understand why people would do it, but i also dont understand why they would want to, i know people who are generally more than happy to pay for music - even if it is available free on various websites, people dont mind supporting good music and Artists, It helps them be able to afford making more...(i'm one of them, and i know lots of others).

    I'm less on the fence.

    I think that good music will push people to buy it, at least in a venue setting...

    save the freebies for the industry folks...

    people can listen to my music online for free, but I'm not giving them copies...

    I know that's not the current rage, but at the end of the day, I want people to value what I do, so I attach a value to it.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,062 ✭✭✭all the stars


    Clearly i mis-understood, you just verbalised what i was thinking. i'm agreeing with you :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 606 ✭✭✭gibson


    True, but if you have invested quite a bit of time, € and effort on recording, writing and getting good mixing/mastering/great production/Recording studio time etc on your CD - why would you give it away free? Its cost x amount to make it and then give it away free? Even asking €5 is probably not even going to chip away at the cost of buying blank CD's...
    I understand why people would do it, but i also dont understand why they would want to, i know people who are generally more than happy to pay for music - even if it is available free on various websites, people dont mind supporting good music and Artists, It helps them be able to afford making more...(i'm one of them, and i know lots of others).

    Ye thats true but I suppose I meant maybe a less polished expensive version, maybe something that didnt really break the bank. I dunno I suppose theres pro's and con's as with everything. I can see what you mean about spending a lot of money why would you want to give it away for free and its probably true that if people want it they will pay but I suppose you never know who might pass on a CD or say to a mate oh have a listen to this its a band I heard the other night


  • Advertisement
  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    gibson wrote: »
    Ye thats true but I suppose I meant maybe a less polished expensive version, maybe something that didnt really break the bank. I dunno I suppose theres pro's and con's as with everything. I can see what you mean about spending a lot of money why would you want to give it away for free and its probably true that if people want it they will pay but I suppose you never know who might pass on a CD or say to a mate oh have a listen to this its a band I heard the other night

    I think in this day and age emailing a MySpace link is far more likely.

    It's not that you should NEVER do it, but I think it's a silly policy, if you're trying to be serious.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 606 ✭✭✭gibson


    MilanPan!c wrote: »
    I think in this day and age emailing a MySpace link is far more likely.

    It's not that you should NEVER do it, but I think it's a silly policy, if you're trying to be serious.

    Definitely true about the myspace link but then you could have that link on the CD itself as well or a website link to tell people where they can find out more about you. I suppose I just think the more you put it out there in as many mediums as possible the better chance there is of someone hearing it...not just a talent scout or someone to do with a record label but people who may potentially become fans of your music.

    but hey im only guessing! im not signed to a label so only my opinion! :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 74 ✭✭Zendali


    Waking-Dreams: I`m not looking for an ego massage or even a modicum of thanks :) I was angered because of your barbed comments to the OP and, by implication, to myself or anyone else who`s trying to give added exposure to unsigned acts. I agree that we`d both like to hear more from the OP of this thread, though from my own experience he`s probably
    submerged under an avalanche of music replies. The main point to consider is that he, like I, is offering a free service to unsigned bands and musicians. From my own experience over the past few months, such a voluntary service can be unbelievably time-consuming, even though hearing such a variety of new music can be a compensation of sorts. But above all else, it`s the most practical solution for unsigned acts to further their careers...in my opinion anyway.

    Artists and bands need industry support to progress to the next level. Fact. And I realise that you and I are diametrically opposed on this point, where you advocate that acts should be self-reliant and carve out their own careers independently of labels, management etc. While it may seem like an admirable goal, where the band or artist do everything for themselves and maximise the resources of the net, it`s frankly a romantic notion and a chronically inept business model. Facebooking and online hustling is all well and good but it pales beside the impact that a concerted industry campaign can have. Ask yourself,how many acts in Glastonbury this weekend are playing there without industry support, or at least have had some input from the industry along the way?

    It`s pointless citing examples of bloggers who have generated massive online followings. These are writers and fashion/music/movie reviewers, not unsigned music acts. And even Crystal Swing and Susan Boyle are just freakish examples of a viral in bushfire mode. Many of those who replied to me would echo my views on this and have grown exasperated with the type of approach you propose.They tried the DIY route and came to the conclusion that the net is merely another tool or means to an end - but never an end in itself. Essentially they want investment to fund a producer and a quality recording, along with some money for tour support. They also want management to help structure their plans and to tout on their behalf to labels and publishers. Personally I think it borders on rank stupidity to ignore a whole array of industry specialists, people with vast years of experience and an in-depth knowledge of promoting bands and artists.

    If I was planning on opening a garage then I`d first have to source my stock. I`d be loathe to open a showroom with no cars on view. In the same way my website is a work in progress, where I`m currently liaising with the web designer on design and content issues while compiling a list of acts to showcase. I`ve no burning wish to blow my vuvuzela here and boast of past achievements, inviting a further damburst of management requests on top of the music replies I`m already trying to cope with. And besides, it`s totally irrelevant to the purposes of my website, which is to showcase new talent to the various strands of the industry. As I`ve stressed before, all I`m doing here is asking acts to mail me their myspace links, from which I`ll compile a (subjective) list of 20 acts to appear in my site`s Gallery page. I`ll then hit the industry trail and notify them of the site`s existence. If any deals come about because of the site, then that`s entirely between the industry party and the relevant act. The bands and artists who appear on the site will be doing so free of charge. My primary goal will be to generate visitor hits, in order to attract sponsors to fund the site. `


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    I was angered because of your barbed comments to the OP and, by implication, to myself or anyone else who's trying to give added exposure to unsigned acts.
    Barbed by your definition because my comments simply highlighted the unprofessional approach in an age where you yourself keep mentioning there being a sea of amateur bands? So, you openly acknowledge that there are tons of amateur bands saturating the music scene but likewise, there are no amateur individuals who try to help out others and do a lousy job in the presentation? I'm pretty sure you've quickly overlooked bands who didn't come across as professional and now you're asking us all to suspend judgement and think positive? Sometimes, you have to call a spade a spade.

    I didn't come out and say, “Jeeez, learn how to spell first dudz LOL!!” You don't seem to like any negative criticism because by it's very nature, it is the opposite of positive. And the part about the implication to people like yourself is just the emotional part of your brain doing it's job, defending your self-esteem. I get it from some people now and then. People who believe in faith healers, homeopathy, mediums and psychics, retort and play the hurt feelings card when I happen to make a passing comment in conversation they hear, on how bogus the whole thing is, when I never actually attacked them outright (for example, pointing the finger, “you're an idiot for believing that stuff haha”). It just happened to be something they identified with; a little too much I might add.

    Do you realise how ridiculous I would sound if I asked people to refrain from speaking badly about my favourite movie, book, or band? Or if and when they did, I would start throwing the toys out of the pram and begin to sulk?
    ...you advocate that acts should be self-reliant and carve out their own careers independently of labels, management etc. While it may seem like an admirable goal, where the band or artist do everything for themselves and maximise the resources of the net, it's frankly a romantic notion and a chronically inept business model. Facebooking and online hustling is all well and good but it pales beside the impact that a concerted industry campaign can have. Ask yourself, how many acts in Glastonbury this weekend are playing there without industry support, or at least have had some input from the industry along the way?
    I advocate that acts who don't have big mainstream commercial appeal (the kind of appeal such as Lady Gaga, U2, Coldplay, etc) do not need to burden themselves with signing up to an industry whose goal is to make money. People who don't fall into that category can ignore me — and good luck in becoming super famous by the way. Honestly.

    But here's the thing: most bands flirt with the idea that with a little help they can become really big. They overestimate their commercial appeal.

    The people running record labels are very clever.

    1. They know that most musicians think they're really good and have what it takes.

    2. They know that nearly most of them will probably fail commercially.

    3. They know that people don’t like admitting they’ve been had or have made bad decisions.

    4. They know that most people will slink away quietly after an unsuccessful attempt at becoming a professional musician, or will rationalise it in a way that doesn't hurt their self-esteem, or become so deluded to the point where they never give up even when the writing is on the wall.

    5. And they know that most of their applicants don’t know how to investigate the ‘industry’ and prepare accordingly and know what's ahead and what they might have to sacrifice.


    But it's the same broken record with you Zendali and your ilk. “Show me unsigned bands that get to play big festivals; get national airplay; get featured in the pro-industry glossy magazines, make loads of money.”

    It's a logical fallacy; a straw man argument. The music industry is built on commerce, not music. Music is the sales vehicle. Humans have been making music for a very, very long time and we are now in a position where one doesn't need to spend a fortune to make a good album and share it with people across the world.

    No unsigned band will ever take the place of a signed band at a festival like Glastonbury for a very good reason. And it's the same reason why you won't read about them in NME, Hotpress or hear them on the radio. Because record labels have their own artists to trumpet and bring in the money. Labels take out magazine ads so who do you think the magazines are going to write about? Why would it concern itself with bands who don't generate them revenue? They wouldn't waste their time promoting the music of other bands (who may be equally talented, just not equally commercial).

    The unsigned community is full of people who are as good, if not potentially better than those who have been fortunate enough to reside in a distro-bottleneck and that is why the gatekeepers and their supporters are so smug and dismissive when it comes to talking down the DIY bands. Hard cash sales are the primary indicator of value to them.

    Unsigned is not going to replace professional but it will supplement and even expose mainstream media for it's commerce driven logic. This is the inevitable outcome of millions of people interacting on a daily basis whose tastes are more diverse than ever. You would have us trusting a decreasing number of dubious gatekeepers who chase the mass market with fervour, bleeding out the different and non-mass-appealing.
    It's pointless citing examples of bloggers who have generated massive online followings. These are writers and fashion/music/movie reviewers, not unsigned music acts.
    What is the real difference? It's still content which people consume, right? People don't discover new bands by seeing a poster in HMV and buying the record; they're hearing them online through peer recommendations (just like they always have, only more so now). And there are a sea of amateur writers too; the web is saturated with them, yet the really good ones manage to stand out and find an audience. How bizzare.
    Many of those who replied to me would echo my views on this and have grown exasperated with the type of approach you propose. They tried the DIY route and came to the conclusion that the net is merely another tool or means to an end - but never an end in itself.
    They tried the DIY approach? How hard did they try? Were they; are they any good of a band? Humans are hard-wired to seek instant-gratification. We want instant, push-button results. Have a look at people in a really long queue next time you're out in public. Some are patient and OK with it, but others get very frustrated, annoyed and want a shortcut. In general, we hate waiting for anything; look at how people use financial credit these days, no self-restraint at all! Bands typically make a balls of DIY and then reason it's never going to work for them like they want it to work. A self-fulfilling prophecy or what?
    Personally, I think it borders on rank stupidity to ignore a whole array of industry specialists, people with vast years of experience and an in-depth knowledge of promoting bands and artists.
    It makes sense to sign a deal if you are the type of artist who can sell records by the barrel load (pop stars and mainstream music bands) but what percentage of bands who seek labels even fall into that category? Of course, the independent labels are happy to clean up on those lesser acts if they think they can make some money, while the margins of profit for the band are not so great because their appeal is more limited and so niche.

    The media have caused this by the way. By pushing celebs and personalities in front of us they have in turn ignited a desire for us all to become famous and well-known. Rags to riches stories are perpetuated to keep us chasing the dream and buying into their lies and myths. We hear a couple of real-life examples and that's all the positive, confirmatory evidence we need.

    But I think you've got me all wrong. I never said a record label was useless for everyone.
    I've no burning wish to blow my vuvuzela here and boast of past achievements, inviting a further damburst of management requests on top of the music replies I'm already trying to cope with.
    Boast of past achievements? You were asked a basic question, just like a musician at an audition would be asked by any band... What kind of an answer would this be? “Well, I've no wish to boast of past bands I played in, you'll just have to take my word for it. Send me your songs and I'll go over them and give you my opinion”. If any bands have recruited members who were so secretive please post here and do tell.

    That's some way of sidestepping the awkward question. Personally, I don't care that much whether you answer it or not but it was worth pointing out and I applaud the person who did think of asking you.
    And besides, it's totally irrelevant to the purposes of my website, which is to showcase new talent to the various strands of the industry.
    A part of me is tempted to say, your whole aim in starting the record deal thread was to attract responses from Irish artists with the lure of industry-ears and contacts (through your producer friend, etc), and then transition the whole thing into it just being you cherry picking all the good acts and setting-up your own website to showcase and attract some industry attention and advertisement revenue in the process (maybe, include your own band among the gallery of artists too?) But, it's idle speculation, so disregard.

    I had a similar idea myself once many moons ago after I graduated from college. Set-up a website that would “represent” the best of unsigned bands, all gathered under the one URL where quality control would be paramount and then try and gain some industry attention, with the band I was playing with at the time included in the bunch too.

    Know why I didn't pursue it? Because as much as I liked to feel important and do something positive, I admitted to myself that it was kind of pompous. Why would bands need to be associated with such a self-serving website? Are they incapable of using the net and contacting labels themselves? At the end of the day, whoever was listening would still be making their own judgement, no matter where they hear the music.

    As you say yourself:
    If any deals come about because of the site, then that's entirely between the industry party and the relevant act.
    Of course, we all know a talent scout doesn't call the shots about who gets signed. They submit their chosen acts and see what the response is from the real business people. “Oh, but they're snowed under with bands!” No doubt, and always will be, but you're flogging a dead horse with this whole suggestion of, “I can get their attention better than unsigned bands can”. Really? Then why do you creatively avoid the question which asks for your track record? Oh right, it will trigger a possible explosion in your inbox (the same bloated inbox you seem to keep mentioning every 2nd or 3rd post). Yes, highlighting how busy and in demand you are is always a good tactic.

    Labels also look for acts to sign too, y'know? And do you know who they're looking for? Bands and artists who are already out there banking! Bands that don't sit online all day looking for talent scouts on message boards to help them out. Bands who aren't sitting around bitching about there being so much crap online and that it's so hard for them to get heard anymore.

    The labels are looking for bands who have their heads screwed on and understand how the game is played; bands who have done well for themselves without any help save for their own hard work ethos; not dreamers hoping someone is going to turn up backstage and say, “Come into my office next week and we'll talk” like something out of Wayne's World or other cliched movies.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    Believe it or not, I actually do care. You would class me as a cynic, ridiculing others for my own amusement, when I have actually offered some very good info and advice, which I'll add, I didn't arrive at overnight. That took quite a bit of trial and error and first-hand experience and college education, listening to many people and reading the works of many skilled authors.

    I was overly ambitious and naive once upon a time and I'd hate to see bands make the same mistakes I made; so much time, money and energy wasted, when there are alternatives.

    I've never said, “bah, just quit and give up!” to any musicians, but that they should at least acknowledge that it's a game, where there are no hard and fast rules and unpredictability is a given. Your desire and sense of entitlement are meaningless and will actually hinder the likelihood of deep satisfaction because you're setting yourself up for a big fall if you don't achieve your idealised ambition.

    I have always understood that the power of positive thinking works for some people because it empowers them (psychologically and emotionally) to act to achieve their desires in the face of life's challenges and occasional bouts of self-doubt. There is nothing wrong with thinking positively but it is crucially more important to think such thoughts in reality, not base them on raw desire or what you want to be true. Yet, the brain has a habit of sugar coating things to comfort us, to maintain that feel-good sensation inside. For example - in the extreme - lots of people take comfort in the “powers” of psychic mediums who communicate with their dead relatives; doesn't mean it's empirically true but hey, what's the harm some might say, right? Well, it can be damaging to very vulnerable people, who spend a great deal of their time and money, hoping for some kind of outcome that will bring them joy.
    “Humans are pattern-seeking, storytelling animals in search of deep meaning behind the seemingly random events of day-to-day life.” – Michael Shermer

    Have a read of, 'A Mind Of Its Own: How Your Brain Distorts And Deceives' by Cordelia Fine. You'd be amazed how much irrationality clouds our judgement, and how emotions add a gloss of their own, colouring and confusing our opinions. People are very skilled at defending beliefs they arrived at for not-so-smart reasons.

    While it is true our lives might be more comfortable when our desires are met, the universe doesn't work that way. It doesn't owe you a damn thing to be blunt about it. People should learn to focus on what they already have, not on what they lack. Be thankful you're not one of those poor individuals who gets to work 14+ hours per day sewing shoes for Nike and living on a pittance. That you even exist is an astonishing feat. And, thinking on a grander scale, there are so many people who are never going to experience what you already have because they're never going to be born.
    “The potential people who could have been here in my place but who will in fact never see the light of day outnumber the sand grains of Arabia. Certainly those unborn ghosts include greater poets than Keats, scientists greater than Newton. We know this because the set of possible people allowed by our DNA so massively exceeds the set of actual people. In the teeth of these stupefying odds it is you and I, in our ordinariness, that are here.” – Richard Dawkins

    If you don't become the most popular band in your local city, or a famous musician or make a living from your music, it's not the end of the world.


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    The thing is WD, and you readily admit this yourself, there is not ACTUALLY another option for people that accept the risk, conciously, but still wish to TRY.

    It seems that you think one can not conciously accept their own chances, conciously, and still desire to try.

    I disagree.

    I also don't think it's entirely, note the word entirely, a crap shoot.

    I know I have seen the same attibutes in the people that I PERSONALLY know that have been successful and I know that by adopting the same techniques and attitudes I can help my chances, meaningfully.

    I know this because I've seen and continue to see it work in my personal situation.

    I honestly think the most prevalent attitude in any creative scene is pessimism, followed by cynicism.

    Honest passion is WAY down the list.

    So, c'mon man, be realistic about the people involved. We're not all pie-in-the-sky, delusional dreamers.

    Our aim may be high, but the world would be an awful place if people didn't aim high.

    I appreciate your info, but as an ideology it probably blinds you, or at least leads you to publicly discount talented, intelligent, clued-up folks.

    No offense man. Just be completely honest. People do make it, lots for VERY good reasons, and there's currently NO BETTER alternative to labels.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    Sceptics and debunkers are often accused of being cynical, cold, negative people but who makes those accusations? Usually, it's the people who believe what they believe because it brings them comfort.

    Meh, what do I care if a band wants to sign a deal, go on the road and then have to quit because they can't afford it anymore? There are plenty of bands out there right now in that position, barely making ends meat and maybe having all their relatives/wives/girlfriends bailing them out of financial woes. That's OK if you're 18-25 years old I guess, we've all been helped out, but to keep putting yourself in that situation because you have high hopes for a 'way of life' as a musician?

    Some bands go through members like underwear because some of the people in the bands inevitably discover that it's not worth it; the pay-offs don't outweigh the negatives. And yet one or two permanent members of the group stay on to perpetuate the cycle.

    The thing is MP, is that touring is a necessary part of the record label sales model. Except, that it can really mess up your 'outside the band life' stability, which I highlighted in the record deal thread - I'm not repeating here.

    People can aim high sure, but keep a foot in reality. Each of us is one of 6.7 billion people in this world. Why are you or I so special? Where did this entitlement attitude you see in musicians come from?

    Of course people 'make it' in the music industry, and so do people at winning the lottery. I don't want to rehash the whole argument again, because musicians hate thinking that their fate was pure luck. The mind is a funny thing. When we succeed it seems only “right” that we did, we earned it, yet when we fail, we tend to rationalise it and deflect any responsibility or claim mitigating circumstances , “oh well, guess I'm just not commercial enough for the industry”...

    In my experience people have a strong desire to believe what they want to believe, to an extent, even when evidence might be pointing to the opposite of a belief. I myself used to be unaware of the level to which I believed things without any good supporting evidence.

    That book I recommended is great for opening your eyes to the false notions that are projected around contemporary society and to help you spot them.

    And no, of course you're not all pie-in-the-sky, delusional dreamers. But I have a gut feeling that a healthy percentage of Zendail's inbox is from such people.


  • Site Banned Posts: 4,415 ✭✭✭MilanPan!c


    Sceptics and debunkers are often accused of being cynical, cold, negative people but who makes those accusations? Usually, it's the people who believe what they believe because it brings them comfort.

    Meh, what do I care if a band wants to sign a deal, go on the road and then have to quit because they can't afford it anymore? There are plenty of bands out there right now in that position, barely making ends meat and maybe having all their relatives/wives/girlfriends bailing them out of financial woes. That's OK if you're 18-25 years old I guess, we've all been helped out, but to keep putting yourself in that situation because you have high hopes for a 'way of life' as a musician?

    Some bands go through members like underwear because some of the people in the bands inevitably discover that it's not worth it; the pay-offs don't outweigh the negatives. And yet one or two permanent members of the group stay on to perpetuate the cycle.

    The thing is MP, is that touring is a necessary part of the record label sales model. Except, that it can really mess up your 'outside the band life' stability, which I highlighted in the record deal thread - I'm not repeating here.

    People can aim high sure, but keep a foot in reality. Each of us is one of 6.7 billion people in this world. Why are you or I so special? Where did this entitlement attitude you see in musicians come from?

    Of course people 'make it' in the music industry, and so do people at winning the lottery. I don't want to rehash the whole argument again, because musicians hate thinking that their fate was pure luck. The mind is a funny thing. When we succeed it seems only “right” that we did, we earned it, yet when we fail, we tend to rationalise it and deflect any responsibility or claim mitigating circumstances , “oh well, guess I'm just not commercial enough for the industry”...

    In my experience people have a strong desire to believe what they want to believe, to an extent, even when evidence might be pointing to the opposite of a belief. I myself used to be unaware of the level to which I believed things without any good supporting evidence.

    That book I recommended is great for opening your eyes to the false notions that are projected around contemporary society and to help you spot them.

    And no, of course you're not all pie-in-the-sky, delusional dreamers. But I have a gut feeling that a healthy percentage of Zendail's inbox is from such people.

    It's funny, we always end up here.

    I do think it's a bit unfair to state your "reality" based opinions in such a way as to make a huge percentage of musicians interested in pursuing their dreams look unreasonable and setting themselves up for a heartbreaking fall.

    I also think that Z is right to say that you should probably, for everyone's sanity, choose your language very carefully when making insinuations about others... I know you're a very smart guy, we've had many of these conversations. If I had any advice for you if would be to make your advice seem less like criticism, less like you're telling people to wake up and see your truth.

    Just present your facts and opinions in a less directed way and you'll probably spend less time responding to people who were honestly offended by your tone and approach.

    I know, I really do, from our conversations, that you're not on here to insult people, etc., but if I just casually read some of the things you've written I might have a different opinion.

    I think the "truth" about people's chances is an important thing for people, all people taking chances that is, to bear in mind. But we need chancers.

    Ireland could really use a creative boom and people like Z (and he's def not the only one) are NOT asking for money AND not claiming to make folks rich and famous... it's not a trap... these folks are passionate people with connections that are doing there bit to help the scene, musicians and of course themselves.

    I personally hope we have MORE people busting their ass to create a world-class scene in this country.

    If that happened well, all involved won't all be famous, but they'll be part of history... and that's not dreaming, that's the truth.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,323 ✭✭✭Savman


    To the bone, Waking-Dreams, to the bone. But can't disagree with any of it, truth is a harsh mistress.

    The thing is tho, Musicians are just Artists who, by their very nature, are dreamers. Trying to mash that into some kind of commercial logic is extremely difficult, most simply can't ever think of their music/songs as a product on a shelf akin to bread and milk at the local Tesco.
    While it is true our lives might be more comfortable when our desires are met, the universe doesn't work that way. It doesn't owe you a damn thing to be blunt about it. People should learn to focus on what they already have, not on what they lack. Be thankful you're not one of those poor individuals who gets to work 14+ hours per day sewing shoes for Nike and living on a pittance. That you even exist is an astonishing feat.
    Smashing post this!!! Sums up my sentiments exactly, I wish to join your fellowship. Where can I send my cheque :pac:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 506 ✭✭✭Waking-Dreams


    MilanPan!c wrote: »
    It's funny, we always end up here.

    I do think it's a bit unfair to state your "reality" based opinions in such a way as to make a huge percentage of musicians interested in pursuing their dreams look unreasonable and setting themselves up for a heartbreaking fall.

    I also think that Z is right to say that you should probably, for everyone's sanity, choose your language very carefully when making insinuations about others... I know you're a very smart guy, we've had many of these conversations. If I had any advice for you if would be to make your advice seem less like criticism, less like you're telling people to wake up and see your truth.

    Just present your facts and opinions in a less directed way and you'll probably spend less time responding to people who were honestly offended by your tone and approach.

    I know, I really do, from our conversations, that you're not on here to insult people, etc., but if I just casually read some of the things you've written I might have a different opinion.

    I think the "truth" about people's chances is an important thing for people, all people taking chances that is, to bear in mind. But we need chancers.

    Ireland could really use a creative boom and people like Z (and he's def not the only one) are NOT asking for money AND not claiming to make folks rich and famous... it's not a trap... these folks are passionate people with connections that are doing there bit to help the scene, musicians and of course themselves.

    I personally hope we have MORE people busting their ass to create a world-class scene in this country.

    If that happened well, all involved won't all be famous, but they'll be part of history... and that's not dreaming, that's the truth.
    I do think it's a bit unfair to state your "reality" based opinions in such a way as to make a huge percentage of musicians interested in pursuing their dreams look unreasonable and setting themselves up for a heartbreaking fall.

    Really? Do you disagree there's not a massive number of musicians and artists trying to 'make it' and have high hopes that lean a little too much on the side of wishful thinking? So, who are all those people who line up in droves to audition for X-Factor and other talent shows? That's just one example. The online behaviours, attitudes and communications of bands also indicates such an unwavering belief. I wouldn't assume that the majority of musicians are that way without looking at the evidence first.

    And even still, what musicians are going to agree they are delusional? It' an oxymoron; a catch-22. I mean, we've all witnessed the X-Factor contestant who gets rejected and turned down by the judges, yet defiantly walks away saying, “yeah well, I will become a great singer, you'll see” then cries outside the hallway. And what do some people at home watching do? Some laugh out loud at how bad they are. I think it's a little cruel, but the producers know it makes for entertaining television and like just reality TV, it allows people at home to feel better about themselves... “Well, at least I'm not that bad/desperate/ugly!”
    Just present your facts and opinions in a less directed way and you'll probably spend less time responding to people who were honestly offended by your tone and approach.

    It's a point well-made and well-taken. I guess I feel that sometimes you just need to shake the sh*t out of people, because a less-direct, polite approach in persuading others can be sometimes futile, plus their minds aren't voluntarily open to considering contradictory evidence. Had I been able to go back in time to speak to my younger self, I (he) would probably have shook my (his) head too and dismissed any such talk. In fact, I'm reminded about the time my friend was talking me out of pursuing a girl I had my eye on when I was in my late teens. He laid out every reason why it was a bad idea and I just wasn't open to it at all. My brain was skilled at being able to counter whatever points he made with a: “yes, but...”. Of course, in the end, he was dead right, I should have cut my losses but I guess I had to learn the hard way through experience.

    I do think that we have a price to pay for a blinkered view.
    Ireland could really use a creative boom and people like Z (and he's def not the only one) are NOT asking for money AND not claiming to make folks rich and famous... it's not a trap... these folks are passionate people with connections that are doing their bit to help the scene, musicians and of course themselves.

    I did notice there's no money being asked, because if there were, that would cause a psychological barrier for most people. Free is very attractive. “What have I got to lose?”, they say. And yeah, of course it's no real harm, it's just funny how it's advertised in a way to lure people in, yet with enough 'get-out clauses' if it doesn't do what people thought it said on the tin. I know that's their problem too. This isn't Z's fault, it's a tactic the music industry and marketers have used for a long time.

    Most people admit that making a living in the record industry is hard these days. They admit it is theoretically achievable (because others have done so) but only after working extended hours and when all the connections and market conditions happen to fall into place, which they attribute to “hard work” and “believing in yourself”. Yet these pragmatic views weren't so commonplace back in the glory days. Record labels, managers, agents, etc al, used to promise new bands the moon and then took them for a ride to line their own pockets first and foremost. When word of these shenanigans finally got around to enough ears, they changed their approach, stating, “Indeed, there's a lot of sharks out there alright, so you need to be careful, it's a tough industry and you need to be dedicated”.

    But this didn't really address the issue of how the industry projects an image of success which can goad young people into pursuing such a life of seemingly lavish excess and popularity. Certainly, the record industry has operated on the right side of the law, making sure when their empty promises failed to materialise, the artist would be made out to be the weak link (they didn't sell enough records), but their moral standards are about as low as you could get.

    Take shows like X-Factor and American Idol, shows which seem to prey on people who are in a weak position. Their policy is obviously to recruit as many candidates as possible, whether or not they have a realistic chance of becoming a winner. Why do they send in those woeful singers to the celebrity judges? They get screened by other judges first.
    I personally hope we have MORE people busting their ass to create a world-class scene in this country.

    We can have a good music scene. A music scene can exist because humans have been creating music through the ages, it brings us together. A record-selling industry scene is a different matter, and if people want to chase after that, all well and good, but you have been warned.

    Anyways, my points are hardly going to disparage dyed-in-the-wool believers. Even a skilled therapist would have trouble convincing people that they're headed for a path of destruction; so good is the brain at seeing what it wants to see, not what's there. Once we make a decision, our mind snaps shut; the brain is adept at supplying a conveniently biased array of evidence and arguments to bolster its opinion.

    I have no vested interest in the music industry's demise, all I am doing is saying how it is, warts and all. People can either take the advice and run to the hills or ignore it. It's their call.


  • Advertisement
This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement