I Want The CD!

Mushy

Well, with iTunes now verging on 10billion downloads:eek:, is it no wonder record shops are going by the wayside? Walk into hmv, its primarily dvds that are on sale, probably even more space for computer games too.

Does anyone feel saddened by any of this? Or do ye prefer to download albums to be imported onto whatever mp3 player you may have? Myself, I always prefer the hard copy. Theres something about reading the liner notes, the pictures(mature right there), popping the cd out of the case and hearing the whir of the disc as it first loads up, then the second stop before the inevitable first notes. Just not the same with a download, even though some stuff I have are downloads(paid for though).

http://www.apple.com/itunes/10-billion-song-countdown/

Fad

I kinda like the thrill of buying a CD, but really, it's something I can do without.

I seldom pay for music though*. Current record label structure needs to die.

(*I support bands in other ways, if they bother touring here, I'll happily spend as much as I can on merch, having already paid for the ticket to go to them)

Pygmalion

Daysha

I would never buy an album unless I'm already a big fan of the artists themselves. So I'd never buy a debut album for instance, and instead just download them and see if they'd deserve my money in the future. That may be harsh on new artists trying to break into the industry, but in this day and age when so much music is so freely available I don't want to risk wasting 10-15 quid on something I'll end up hating.

Off the top of my head, the only bands I'd actually go out and buy their CDs are Muse, The Killers, Mumford and Sons, Radiohead, REM, Sufjan Stevens, Fleet Foxes, Yeah Yeah Yeahs etc. All top-notch bands.

phlegms

I use itunes a lot. Mainly for smaller independent bands who need the support in the early years. Having said that I don't particularly agree with the pricing structure available on itunes..

D4RK ONION

Fad wrote: »

I kinda like the thrill of buying a CD, but really, it's something I can do without.

I seldom pay for music though*. Current record label structure needs to die.

(*I support bands in other ways, if they bother touring here, I'll happily spend as much as I can on merch, having already paid for the ticket to go to them)

:rolleyes:

There was a similar thread to this a while back, but just to re-iterate, I always buy my music. I love getting the box and the art and such and building a big collection

Davidius

I don't know about them CDs and them there iTunes because I'm not a music head but I do know that I always prefer a physical copy of a game.

Mostly because digital distribution costs more despite offering less.

Fad

D4RK ONION wrote: »

:rolleyes:

There was a similar thread to this a while back, but just to re-iterate, I always buy my music. I love getting the box and the art and such and building a big collection

Nothing to do with sounding better......CDs are rapidly becoming obsolete, stereo in my bedroom has been unplugged for about 6 months now, I just dont play CDs, if I buy one, I rip it and then it gets stuck on a shelf.

I concede, some bands do have seriously good artwork (Converge have some brilliant stuff) and occasionally, I'll buy the CD.

There are a few bands I will always buy CDs of (MCR, BMTH, Metallica, stuff that I'm buying for completion of a collection more than anything else, I dont like the fact that MCR and Metallica are on major labels, I really dont like the idea of buying CDs off bands on major labels.....but gotta do what ya gotta do )

It's nothing to do with not wanting to risk money checking out a new band, I used to buy random CDs all the time, and often if you buy a CD and it isnt THAT good, you end up liking it a lot more than if you downloaded it, because of the fact you actually made some sort of sacrifice to buy the CD (Worship and Tribute is an example of this, an incredible number of people consider it to be one of the greatest post-hardcore albums ever, I downloaded it, I didnt like it, and I love post hardcore, and I like other Glassjaw music......so sometimes I might be better off paying for it )

Extrasupervery

I CD's

There's nothing more satisfying than a large pile of great albums. I just had to restore my computer and lost about 30 GB of music, some stolen, some paid for.

Jesus Juice

I love looking through CDs for ages trying to find the one you want, then putting it back down and buying a completely different one!

Also I think people dont appreciate music as much they use to, click of a mouse and the new album they want is on their computer.I remember reading Kerrang! or Q or some such and seeing an album that is coming out in the next few months, then having the agonizing wait for it to come out.
Now you dont even have to wait for it to ''come out'' cause it'll be leaked anyway!...But people like Lily Allen arent helping matters by complaining about it and saying stuff like shes not making anymore albums because shes not making money out of it:rolleyes:,You dont see someone like Fleet Foxes giving up cause they're not making money.

Pygmalion

Jesus Juice wrote: »

Also I think people dont appreciate music as much they use to, click of a mouse and the new album they want is on their computer.I remember reading Kerrang! or Q or some such and seeing an album that is coming out in the next few months, then having the agonizing wait for it to come out.

I'm agonisingly waiting for an album at the moment for many months, comes out next Friday and no leak in site ;_;, wouldn't say the fact that I'll (probably) end up downloading it has any real effect on this.
Except that was it not for blatant stealing I'd have no idea who this band are.

Jesus Juice

Yeah Like I'm not saying its a totally bad thing, I would literally be listening to a quarter of what I do now if it wasnt for the internetz.

KnifeWRENCH

I love buying CDs. Downloading music just doesn't appeal to me that much.

flyswatter

I've done a fair amount of downloading over the years but I often buy the CD even when I have it on download cos I like supporting the artist.

Bobalicious93

Free is good.

A Neurotic

It's the best kind of cheap.

Konata

I haven't bought a CD in over 2 years.
Downloading/scabbing off friends is just so handy and heaps cheaper.

Pigwidgeon

I'd download stuff online for free, if it's a new band that I'm not really sure if I'll like the entire album, and don't know whether it'll be worth spending what little money I have on it.
If I've liked an artist for ages and they bring out a new album.
Or generally during the HMV sales when CD's are less than €5, I'll buy a load that I've downloaded.

Although that being said, a lot of the time when I buy CD's I just put them straight on my ipod, and never touch the CD again, especially now that I have a decent ipod dock, I don't have as much use for CD's.

Luno

If you want the CD just get it! Don't start a thread about it.

D4RK ONION

M&S* wrote: »

If you want the CD just get it! Don't start a thread about it.

Yeah, I mean who wants to discuss things on a discussion forum?! MADNESS! IO, could you lock all the threads in the forum please?

PS: That would be the best mod power abuse of all time ever :P

Ash_M

To be honest, I download a lot, but it's really just stuff I wouldn't buy anyway. Any band that I really like, I'll buy their album, but new artists/music I'm only mildly into, that's either downloaded or not at all.

jefreywithonef

I went through an illegal downloading phase there for a while (free broadband in college) but I've kinda stopped it. I attained such a backlog of albums to get through I wasn't fully appreciating each album.

I much prefer buying CDs anyway. Sometimes it does annoy me a bit though that if I were to add up the price of each album I have ever bought the total would be in excess of a grand.

Jay P

I buy a lot of CDs, but I download a good bit as well... I don't have any real pattern with either. Sometimes I buy a CD on a whim because it looks kinda cool, or I've heard it's good.
Then I download bands like that when I've no money. Then if I really like the album, I buy it.

I really like having the CDs, and having the art work and everything, and then just having the actual CD too.

Luno

D4RK ONION wrote: »

Yeah, I mean who wants to discuss things on a discussion forum?! MADNESS! IO, could you lock all the threads in the forum please?

PS: That would be the best mod power abuse of all time ever :P

Ah I didn't mean it in a angry way, but seriously he should get the CD!

Fad

M&S* wrote: »

Ah I didn't mean it in a angry way, but seriously he should get the CD!

Did you read the OP's post at all?

Jesus Juice

M&S* wrote: »

Ah I didn't mean it in a angry way, but seriously he should get the CD!

Its a metaphorical CD ffs!

Pygmalion

Jesus Juice wrote: »

Its a metaphorical CD ffs!

OP is a big fan I assume?

Jesus Juice

Thats a horrible piece of art!:eek:

Luno

Fad wrote: »

Did you read the OP's post at all?

Yes but I forget what it was now! Sorry!!

Jako8

I pirate debut albums and if i think it's good i go out and buy it.

If an album is impossible to find, I pirate it until I can find it and buy it.

And sometimes if an album is cheap I buy it for the lulz. i also randomly pirate and if I don't like the album I won't buy it, if I do I will.

So yes, I prefer to buy a physical copy of the album. I get so much enjoyment (I don't know why) of buying and holding the CD. Also, I like adding to my collection.

Jay P

Jako8 wrote: »

I pirate debut albums and if i think it's good i go out and buy it.

If an album is impossible to find, I pirate it until I can find it and buy it.

And sometimes if an album is cheap I buy it for the lulz. i also randomly pirate and if I don't like the album I won't buy it, if I do I will.

So yes, I prefer to buy a physical copy of the album. I get so much enjoyment (I don't know why) of buying and holding the CD. Also, I like adding to my collection.

It's posts like this that make me sure that we're the same person...

suitcasepink

Will there be a Jako P?
Or a Jay 8?
:pac:

Jako8

Jay P wrote: »

It's posts like this that make me sure that we're the same person...

Either you're the anti matter (anti Jako8) or I am (anti-Jay P) and if we ever meet when I'm at UCC, we may cancel each other out.

Insect Overlord

D4RK ONION wrote: »

Yeah, I mean who wants to discuss things on a discussion forum?! MADNESS! IO, could you lock all the threads in the forum please?

PS: That would be the best mod power abuse of all time ever :P

I'm saving that trick for a special occasion! :pac:

I buy all my music in CD form. Not technically clued-in enough to download "cleverly" in bulk, so buying albums on Sale in HMV is the best alternative. Youtube keeps me going until I feel the need to own complete albums though.

tipperaryboy

I would only buy albums if i really like the artist otherwise just itunes.
i tunes pricing structure is terrible and needs to be changed immediately.

Jay P

tipperaryboy wrote: »

I would only buy albums if i really like the artist otherwise just itunes.
i tunes pricing structure is terrible and needs to be changed immediately.

What's wrong with it? I'm just curious.

banjopaul

Anyone got the CD "...Waltzing Alone" by the guggenheim grotto ?

Ridiculously cool album cover and booklet, including a graphic novel style account of one song, and a debate on the demise of proper album covers in place of plastic cases with no song information or anything else.

Really nice. Lovely music too.