Would you rather?

Chanandler Bong

I saw this on the soccer thread and its good laugh, as the OP, i post 2 options, then the next poster chooses 1 of the two, then poses a similar style question to the next poster and so forth. And be creative..

I'll kick things off...

Stafford or Sanchez?

Royal Seahawk

Sanchez.

Eli or Rivers?

Hazys

Royal Seahawk wrote: »

Sanchez.

Eli or Rivers?

Rivers

Brady or Gisselle?

Leslie91

Hazys wrote: »

Rivers

Brady or Gisselle?

Depends. If my team is down 6 with 2 mins to go and we are on our 20 then Brady. Any other situation, Gisele.

Merriman or Ware?.

kev_s88

Leslie91 wrote: »

Depends. If my team is down 6 with 2 mins to go and we are on our 20 then Brady. Any other situation, Gisele.

Merriman or Ware?.

Ware is just too athletic!!


Larry Fitz or Randy Moss (at his peak)

mikemac

Fitzgerald

Adrian Peterson or LT?

Leslie91

mikemac wrote: »

Fitzgerald

Adrian Peterson or LT?

In their primes, LT.

Cassell or Cutler?.

tallaghtoutlaws

Leslie91 wrote: »

In their primes, LT.

Cassell or Cutler?.

Cutler

College football or NFL

jdivision

NFL
3-4 or 4-3

Royal Seahawk

tallaghtoutlaws wrote: »

Cutler

College football or NFL

Until College Football brings in playoffs its NFL all the way.

Sea Devils

4-3

Frank Gore or Stephen Jackson?

Leslie91

Sea Devils wrote: »

4-3

Frank Gore or Stephen Jackson?

All things the same (no injuries both with same O line etc) Frank Gore.

Gates or Gonzalez?.

heyjude

Leslie91 wrote: »

All things the same (no injuries both with same O line etc) Frank Gore.

Gates or Gonzalez?.

Gonzalez

Asomugha or Bailey ?

eagle eye

Leslie91 wrote: »

In their primes, LT.

LOL

kev_s88

heyjude wrote: »

Gonzalez

Asomugha or Bailey ?

Champ by a mile


great offense or great defense?

Karlusss

Great offense.

Trash talker or quiet professional?

Sea Devils

Trash talker

Lambeau Field or the new Dallas Cowboys Stadium

Pherekydes

Lambeau

Favre or Rodgers?

Lirange

Rodgers

Al Davis or Jerry Jones?

Chanandler Bong

BIG AL!!

Pats without Bellichick or Pats without Brady

Sea Devils

Pats without Bellichick

Barry Sanders or Walter Payton?

Lorcan 17

Both are good players

Id tae stafford, but id take matt ryan over both of them

Chanandler Bong

dont think youve grasped the concept there, you respond to the previous post, not the original one,

Barry Sanders all day, greatest pure rusher I've ever seen


Worse division;

NFC West or AFC West?

Pherekydes

Chanandler Bong wrote: »

NFC West or AFC West?

AFC West.

Salary cap or free-for-all?

Karlusss

Salary cap, the last thing the NFL wants to turn into is the Premiership.

You've scored a touchdown with the last few seconds on the clock and pulled to one point behind.

Extra point and overtime, or gamble on the two point conversion?

themont85

Karlusss wrote: »

Salary cap, the last thing the NFL wants to turn into is the Premiership.

You've scored a touchdown with the last few seconds on the clock and pulled to one point behind.

Extra point and overtime, or gamble on the two point conversion?

Gamble, its in the hands of your main moneymen there and then, not at the whim of a coin toss.

85 Bears D or 2000 Ravens D?

Leslie91

eagle eye wrote: »

LOL

themont85 wrote: »

Gamble, its in the hands of your main moneymen there and then, not at the whim of a coin toss.

85 Bears D or 2000 Ravens D?

What was so funny eagle eye?. Ru seriously saying AP is better than LT when both are in their primes?. Everyone is entitled to an opinion but jeeeeeeeeez.

As for the defenses,

'85 Bears D for me.

Gary Imlach or Nick Halling?.

jdivision

Gary Imlach

Ed Reed or Troy Polamalu?

dougal

jdivision wrote: »

Ed Reed or Troy Polamalu?

Polamalu - he just gets involved everywhere the ball goes!

Old QB's

Kurt Warner or Brett Favre

eagle eye

Leslie91 wrote: »

What was so funny eagle eye?. Ru seriously saying AP is better than LT when both are in their primes?. Everyone is entitled to an opinion but jeeeeeeeeez.

AP is only two years in the league so he might not have hit his prime yet. Thats what I'm laughing at, the way you put you would think that both players are veterans.

Just to add its AP by a million miles for me but that had nothing to do with the lol.

Icepickle

dougal wrote: »

Old QB's

Kurt Warner or Brett Favre

In their prime - Favre
On current play - Warner


Retired QB's

Marino or Elway

Sea Devils

Marino

72 Dolphins or 85 Bears?

Oat23

Both awesome teams but I'll say 85 Bears because I'm a bears fan :P.

Matt Forte or Brandon Jacobs?

Pherekydes

Forte.


Vince Lombardi or Don Shula?

Leslie91

Oatesy23 wrote: »

Both awesome teams but I'll say 85 Bears because I'm a bears fan :P.

Matt Forte or Brandon Jacobs?

V different players.... On production I guess

Brandon Jacobs

NFL expansion team in Vegas or not

Leslie91

Pherekydes wrote: »

Forte.


Vince Lombardi or Don Shula?

Lombardi easy. Shula is like an Australian, real sore loser.

JJ

Let's get this going again...

LT (Lawrence Taylor) or LT (LaDainian Tomlinson)?

Leslie91

eagle eye wrote: »

AP is only two years in the league so he might not have hit his prime yet. Thats what I'm laughing at, the way you put you would think that both players are veterans.

Just to add its AP by a million miles for me but that had nothing to do with the lol.

Fair point, the fact that he is only 2 years done. I fear for him though. He runs too upright imho, I hope not, but I think the injury jinxer is gonna get him. He's already had a real bad knee injury and he is only, what 24?.

Leslie91

JJ wrote: »

Let's get this going again...

LT (Lawrence Taylor) or LT (LaDainian Tomlinson)?

Nice one, the LDT ****e only comes from Giants fans. No reason why there cannot be two LT's. Only one of em has class though.

I had a question above.

NFL team in Vegas or Not?.

SeekUp

I say a big fat meh to a Vegas team.

McNabb or Vick?

Pherekydes

JJ wrote: »

Let's get this going again...

LT (Lawrence Taylor) or LT (LaDainian Tomlinson)?

LT.

MNF or SNF?

Leslie91 wrote: »

I had a question above.

NFL team in Vegas or Not?.

Play the game. You were beaten to an answer.

Leslie91

Pherekydes wrote: »

LT.

MNF or SNF?



Play the game. You were beaten to an answer.

Right back at you, so were you!! (beaten to an answer).

Oat23

Oh ffs, If you are going to act like children please keep it on topic by adding a 'which one' to the end. Start again.

Colour commentry:

Cris Collinsworth or John Madden?

themont85

Oatesy23 wrote: »

Oh ffs, If you are going to act like children please keep it on topic by adding a 'which one' to the end. Start again.

Colour commentry:

Cris Collinsworth or John Madden?

Madden, easy.

Jay Cutler or A Rodgers?

Leslie91

themont85 wrote: »

Madden, easy.

Jay Cutler or A Rodgers?

I'll b in the minority, Rodgers.

Pro Bowl before or after Superbowl?.

SeekUp

Leslie91 wrote: »

I'll b in the minority, Rodgers.

Pro Bowl before or after Superbowl?.

After, no one cares then!

And my original question . . . Donovan McNabb or Michael Vick?

Chanandler Bong

McNabbs the better passer,

Greatest Show on Turf or 07 Pats??

jdivision

Greatest Show on Turf got me interested in football again so going with them.

Derek Anderson or Brady Quinn?

Hazys

jdivision wrote: »

Greatest Show on Turf got me interested in football again so going with them.

Derek Anderson or Brady Quinn?

Brady Quinn

TO or Chad Ochocinco?

Oat23

OchoCinco all day.

Housh or Torry Holt?

fisgon

Oatesy23 wrote: »

OchoCinco all day.

Housh or Torry Holt?

T.J, will have a good year this year.

. An obvious one.....Manning (the Colt) or Brady?