Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Are you Fattist?

  • 16-08-2009 09:07PM
    #1
    Moderators, Motoring & Transport Moderators, Music Moderators Posts: 12,616 Mod ✭✭✭✭


    I was told that I was "Fattist" the other day by a friend, and I have to say I can't really deny it. It may not be very PC but its something I've got little sympathy for. Met a girl a few weeks ago who was a fitness instructor and specialised in weight loss. She told me all this Genetic Predisposition stuff is all rubbish, 99.9% is bad diet and not enough exercise. She said loads of her clients loose loads of weight but few keep it off. It's just a lifestyle thing.

    It may be hard for some, but ultimately everyone has control over their own weight - so really you cannot pass the blame. If you really want to do it, it can be done. I on the other hand am quite short, but there is not a dam thing I can do to make myself taller (without ridiculous surgery)

    Statistics show that if you child is overweight by the age of 5, it has an 80% chance of having weight problems for the rest of its life. Many countries around the world are in pandemic states with health problems due to so many people being massively overweight. Being all PC and defending obese people is not the way to fixing the problem


«134

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 84 ✭✭MrEko


    Yes, without any shame either. Whenever I see an already large kid walk (or waddle) around with an ice cream in its hand I get the urge to take it off him and just tell him 'No!'.

    People who say 'Its not his/her fault' or 'They cant help be who they are' are just kidding themselves. It is all down to diet imo. If you eat too much processed foods, microwave foods, fast foods, it is going to come back and show on you. It doesn't take much to go to a fruit and veg shop, go to a butchers, and get some good food to cook from scratch. It helps so, so much.

    When i was in college a lot of my friends would just throw a pizza in the oven or go to a chipper. Couple that with all the booze you'd drink and its not a good combination. College is where your eating habits for life will start, its normally the first time you live away from home and have to fend for yourself. I wish people would just start right.

    So yes, I am a fattist. I look down on overwight people, I think its all down to laziness and bad habits. You may call that shallow but I sure as hell know I wont be the first or last to judge people on how they look. Thing is, if you look unhealthy, you generally are unhealthy. You have the power to change that though, you just have to choose to.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 19,080 ✭✭✭✭Random


    So you have no sympathy for them or you dislike them and discrimate against them because they are fat?


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,182 ✭✭✭nyarlothothep


    Metabolism can slow down very much so in people in their 20s or 30s. It is a case of too much food and too little exercise in many cases, but its also context based.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,892 ✭✭✭ChocolateSauce


    Yes and no. While I have limited sympathy for people who don't exercise and overeat, there are people who have a biological predisposition to be overweight, and these people are not at fault for their weight. I've known one person who has this really bad; she walked an hour a day, went swimming regularly, and dieted until the cows came home but couldn't get below 25 stone.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,510 ✭✭✭Tricity Bendix


    Zascar wrote: »
    I was told that I was "Fattist" the other day by a friend, and I have to say I can't really deny it. It may not be very PC but its something I've got little sympathy for. Met a girl a few weeks ago who was a fitness instructor and specialised in weight loss. She told me all this Genetic Predisposition stuff is all rubbish, 99.9% is bad diet and not enough exercise. She said loads of her clients loose loads of weight but few keep it off. It's just a lifestyle thing.

    Well, I would ask your fitness instructor friend what she would make of two brothers, only two years apart, who eat the same food, lead the same lifestyle with regards to alcohol consumption and such, one of whom goes to the gym twice a week, the other does no exercise whatsoever. The brother who does exercise has been struggling with weight since his early teens, yet the one who rarely gets off his ass is a thin as a rake, and always has been.

    lifestyle my ass.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,770 ✭✭✭Bottle_of_Smoke


    Obviously some of it comes down to genetics, but this is no excuse. If you're predisposed to being fat you should be making MORE of an effort to stay slim, not using it as an excuse.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,754 ✭✭✭oldyouth


    I'd be fattist if I saw such a person engage in obviously unhealthy eating habits. Other than that I wouldn't pass judgement


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 235 ✭✭enry


    People are fat because they eat more food then their body needs there is no other reason. Think about fat people you know, not the chubby, not kind of fat, I mean those people whose fingers are too fat to dial a phone with out using a pen. These people have a problem not simply a physical problem but are in fact mentally unwell and their mental illness is the cause of their physical problem.

    I believe that this problem is going to grow :). We in this country are way to fat we need to really educate our children we need to sort this problem out before it becomes a bigger issue :) then it is already.

    I think if we can keep ourselves fit and healthy we can look over to our left and laugh at england (or the quite fat people) and look to our right and laugh at the USA ( or the Fattiest)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,510 ✭✭✭Tricity Bendix


    We'll all be dead and cold in the ground before Irish people as a nation can laugh at others for being fat. Our drinking culture and general ignorance when it come to things like nutrition aren't about to disappear any time soon.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,286 ✭✭✭WesternNight


    Plenty of slim people are lazy as all hell too. Do you look down on them too? Or just the lazy people who happen to also be overweight?

    I suppose you haven't given much consideration to *why* they're overweight? I mean, aside from "well they're obviously unable to control themselves when it comes to food and can't be bothered getting off their arses".

    I've been overweight since I was a child. That was almost entirely down to one of my parents. Children repeat the behaviours of their parents...and I was set a very bad example. I fully accept that now I'm an adult it's *my* problem and it's down to me and only me to fix it. But those years of bad parenting took its toll...physically and emotionally.

    People who are "fattist"...have you ever been overweight yourselves? Have you any idea what a person goes through when they're overweight? It's not quite as cut and dry as "it's all down to laziness and bad habits".


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,057 ✭✭✭Wacker


    Once someone's weight impinges upon me, I'll become a 'Fattist'. I can't recall that ever happening though, and I can only imaging a handful of scenarios when it could.

    Feel free to give me examples of fatties ruining things for everyone; I'm very open to correction. I just can't help but feel that I've got more important concerns in my sock drawer right now. :pac:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,267 ✭✭✭00sully


    yep i probably am a "fattist" too. I became overweight during college from booze and unhealthy eating - never noticed it creep up until I saw pics of myself. I was disgusted so promptly sorted it out.

    Its up to everyone to sort it out for themselves and everyone should. Does anyone feel sympathy for a smoker with lung cancer? I certainly didn't feel sorry for George Best either and thought the fact he was given a liver transplant was a disgrace. Well I feel little sympathy for obese people with medical conditions either.

    The only sympathy I do feel for these people is for their distinct lack of will power.
    two brothers, only two years apart, who eat the same food, lead the same lifestyle with regards to alcohol consumption and such, one of whom goes to the gym twice a week, the other does no exercise whatsoever. The brother who does exercise has been struggling with weight since his early teens, yet the one who rarely gets off his ass is a thin as a rake, and always has been.

    well maybe the fatter one should cut out alcohol? maybe go to the gym more than twice a week? maybe eat healthier? You can't justify his condition just because someone is a little lazier but doesn't exhibit the same characteristics. (albeit thin with probably a very high cholesterol rate)

    Maybe I should complain that people are more intelligent than me even though I put in as much work as them into studying?? Or just maybe I have to work harder than them. I can accept that.

    There maybe a few excuses that hold up like psychological reasons but the fact remains its not hard to address and fix this issue compared to other more serious ones. It is only beneficial to be healthy.

    I kinda get peeved at it as well because it sort of comes across as greed or (and I don't like to use this word) gluttony.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Am I a Fattist? Um, I probably am. but then I think most people will fall into one category or another. I'm quite skinny being over 6ft, and a high metabolism. So, I've been rather skinny all my life, and nothing seems to help. I've done the gym, protein supplements, and even some horrible tasting crap that anorexic's use, and no real improvement. And after 20 years of being like this (I'm in my 30's now) I can't be bothered trying to change it.

    And I figure its similar for people with fat problems. I know how hard it was for me to gain weight & muscle (which would be lost immediately after gaining it), I figure losing weight must be even harder.

    But I don't have any real sympathy for them. I sure as hell didn't get any sympathy for being skinny. And I don't really want any. Being skinny or fat is a personal thing, and nothing to do with someone else. After a few years, I grew to be generally comfortable with my weight.. although beaches still make me uncomfortable, with all those other guys with six-packs. Living in Australia was interesting. :rolleyes:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,135 ✭✭✭fifth


    No definitely not -

    If it's their lifestyle choice - let them be
    If it's to do with their upbringing - which I do believe can have an unmerciful effect on a childs eating habits, very hard to shake off when older - then how could I pass judgement?

    My weight fluctuated when I was younger, under control now in the last few years. I'm lucky that I can make a decision to eat less and exercise more and control how I look.

    Some people, it takes a lot more time and motivation to break those habits that took years to form.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 9,578 ✭✭✭DublinWriter


    We'll all be dead and cold in the ground before Irish people as a nation can laugh at others for being fat.
    Amen to that. A recent couple of weeks in continental Europe really brought home to me what a nation of reckless porkers we all are.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Amen to that. A recent couple of weeks in continental Europe really brought home to me what a nation of reckless porkers we all are.

    Its more noticeable here because of population density.. Higher populations spread it out in other countries.. I don't think Ireland is all that much worse than other countries in Europe for their diet and/or exercise.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 950 ✭✭✭cotwold


    I'm a fattist, its horrible. I used to be fat and when i see fat people i just well up with anger at them. Its purely because im afraid of ever being like that again. Also i think to myself if i could beat it so can they but i only have to remind myself how hard it is to loose weight once you are obese. Every pound lost always seems like a million more pounds too lose.

    People who've never been fat have no business being fattists. Unless you fly a lot and find yourself sandwitched between two obese people all the time.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    cotwold wrote: »
    People who've never been fat have no business being fattists. Unless you fly a lot and find yourself sandwitched between two obese people all the time.

    I have to disagree. In Ireland, and many other countries fat people act in a manner which is designed to be abusive. I don't know if its a reaction to being criticised by society, or just because they're projecting their own insecurities, but many fat people aren't the jolly cliché anymore. Unless you're living in an isolated spot, you're going to be exposed to fat people, and that gives people the right to be fatists, if they so feel that way. Just as I have the right to be against racists, sexists, anorexics, ageist's, etc


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 950 ✭✭✭cotwold


    I have to disagree. In Ireland, and many other countries fat people act in a manner which is designed to be abusive. I don't know if its a reaction to being criticised by society, or just because they're projecting their own insecurities, but many fat people aren't the jolly cliché anymore.

    Yeah hatred of the kind of people you describe would be rational and hardly fattist, as you're not hating them for being fat but rather mean.

    Unless you're living in an isolated spot, you're going to be exposed to fat people, and that gives people the right to be fatists, if they so feel that way. Just as I have the right to be against racists, sexists, anorexics, ageist's, etc
    You dont have a right to be any of those things and its completely aside from the point i was making.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2 dj m


    I was fat.Not in my opinion but apparently a size 10-12 is now considered fat.I was called fat by strangers on the street and by a few guys i knew with their heads stuck so far up their own ass.Anyway it started to get to me and coupled with other emotional distress going on i decided to diet.No longer fat.Instead a skeleton.My heart rate was so low i spent 3 weeks on a heart montior and months in hospital.

    Everyone is entitled to their own opinion.But is it really necessary to share it with some body you dont know?or even with some one you do know.People who are over weight are well able to see them selves in a mirror and read the scales.Theres no need to lower any ones self esteem even further

    also im not saying the comments on my weight contributed to my problems but they certaintly didnt help.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 3,587 ✭✭✭Pace2008


    I would never consciously look down on a person or treat them differently because of their weight, in the same way I'd never consciously look down on a person because they're ugly or disabled. However, I can't help but feel a slight sense of revulsion when I see people actively feeding their destructive lifestyles - the twenty-stoner ordering three meals at McDonalds or the colossus I see carrying a bag half his size from the chippers every evening. I know there are psychological issues at play but in most cases it's not a full-blown mental or physical illness that has them where they are; like anything it could be overcome if they bothered their arses.
    Wacker wrote: »
    Feel free to give me examples of fatties ruining things for everyone; I'm very open to correction. I just can't help but feel that I've got more important concerns in my sock drawer right now. [Pacman]
    Obese people are a considerable drain on the health system and cost the taxpayer a good deal of money.
    Well, I would ask your fitness instructor friend what she would make of two brothers, only two years apart, who eat the same food, lead the same lifestyle with regards to alcohol consumption and such, one of whom goes to the gym twice a week, the other does no exercise whatsoever. The brother who does exercise has been struggling with weight since his early teens, yet the one who rarely gets off his ass is a thin as a rake, and always has been.
    Tough luck - he lost the genetic lottery and has a slower metabolism than his brother. He shouldn't be eating the same food as his brother, he should be eating less. Controlling one's weight is simple for most people: you have a basal metabolic rate - the amount of energy or calories you expend per day at rest - which could be 1500 or 3000 calories. If you take in significantly more than that amount you gain weight, if you take in less you lose it. It's as simple as that for the majority of people. It'd also be worth pointing out that exercise plays a minor role in weight control compared to diet. It would take well over an hour of steady-state cardio to burn off the calories taken in by eating a Big Mac Meal. It'd be easier to just not eat the burger.

    That said - and I know it sounds like a clichéd cop-out- the government is partly to blame for this problem. The information on proper diet they provide to the public is shocking. The Food Pyramid is still being pushed as the guideline for healthy eating despite the fact that it's broken. Eating six portions of starchy carbohydrates is one of the more effective ways to put on weight and white bread is more likely to contribute to heart disease than the demonised saturated fat, which is appearing to be increasingly benign as research progresses. Between this misinformation, parental neglect in regards to nutrition, and confusing fad diets, I find it somewhat understandable that people develop bad habits and fail to keep their weight in check.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 432 ✭✭RealEstateKing


    There seems to be a never-ending stream of people on boards with this sort of "Boo-hoo you're breaking my heart" , "Sort yourself out" "Take responsibility for yourself" attitude to overweight people.

    Though they are correct in that any overweight person is ultimately responsible for their own fatness, there is a simplification to their thinking that misses the issue. Fatness is as complicated and difficult to solve as other issues like alcoholism and heroin addiction. Just because ultimately, being overweight is a question of eating more calories than you burn, does not make it a simple thing to change.

    Imagine you were talking to an alcohol counsellor and their advice was simply: "What you need to do, is to stop drinking." You'd say "Well duh! If it was as simple as that I wouldnt need to talk to an alcohol consellor to find out how to do it!"

    Of course losing weight is simply a question of eating less calories than you burn. Its how one gets into the headspace to do that that is the question. There are any number of psychological reasons that make people more likely to be over-eaters, in much the same way (and often in the same people) as there are in alcoholics and/or drug users.

    There are a myriad of feelings of emptiness/depression and anxiety that the person is medicating with food in many cases. This bone-headed "Just pull-your-socks-up" attitude does not help to deal with the fundamental issue - unless we're talking about somebody who just needs to drop a dress size before a wedding or something comparitively easy.

    If a person is obese, getting skinny (and remaining so) , is easily one of the hardest things any human being can possibly experience. Far harder, in fact than quitting the booze or smack would be, as those drugs satisfy no normal need in the human body: Food, on the other hand is very difficult to deprive your body of, and if a person is really obese it can take several years to lose the amount of weight needed to be a normal size. Most alcohol/drug addicts are clean within 28 days. Most of us wouldnt even be able to lose a noticable amount of weight in that time.


    As well as this there ARE differences in the way different human bodies deal with energy consumption. While these differences do not explain every pound in difference between people, they are a general tendency in the same way that some people pick up musical instruments easily where others might struggle for years to learn to play a chord.

    I have several friends who are rake thin, do no exercise and drink 3 or 4 pints every night - Where I myself am always potentially overweight: I cycle at least 1 and a half hours every day, and do 5 or 6 hours on both days at the weekend, and have to deny myself food that I badly want most of the rest of the time, to remain at a normalish weight. My friend desperately wants to be bulkier, and has at times even resorted to stuffing himself with more food than he wants and doing no exercise for a few weeks to bulk up, and it doesnt work. We often joke about how his metabolism mixed with mine would create the perfect guy.

    Further to this, as well, is that of all the addictions/psychological illnesses that a person can suffer from, obesity must be the one that garners the least sympathy. All reasonably educated people have an enlightened attitude to alcoholism now, we see it as a disease, and those that struggle with it as deserving of our sympathy and our support. We know that there is a whole complex of psychological, physical, historical and possibly genetic factors that go into making a person an alcoholic. But for some reason, some of us do not extend this thinking to the issue of obesity.

    And to add insult to injury: As well as being physically handicapping, obesity can actually destroy a person's personal life: One of my friends is obese. They are still a virgin at 32 and likely to remain so, forever. Nobody is ever likely to want a sexual relationship with this person as a result of his weight. Were he an alco or a junkie he'd actually be better off in this regard. Hell he could be a sexy wasted youth like Pete Doherty with Kate Moss on his arm.

    As a result of this, I have every sympathy for those who struggle with their weight and particularly those who are obese. Its a ****in' toughie and there's no easy way around it. I in no way condone of course, those who suggest 'Fat Pride' or any of that, and I am fattist in the sense that I too would never sleep with an obese person. But I absolutely respect them for the struggle they deal with every day, that many skinny people simply dont know about or understand.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Lets be honest here... if people avoided fast food and eating late at nights most of them wouldn't have weight issues. The problem is that they gain the weight in their early twenties, keep it going into their thirties, and when they try to turn into a healthy (ish) lifestyle they have to change habits well formed.

    There's nothing wrong with most of the "normal" food thats part of Irish culture. The problem is the times that people eat, and the other types of food they take in.

    I have a friend who's particularly large. Moans all the time about it. Goes to the Gym and punishes herself every few days. Eats small quantities of low-fat food each day, drinks water, goes for walks.... and then goes drinking heavily on the weekend, which is usually followed up on both nights with large portions of fast food crap. At least once a week, she'll also "treat" herself to a home delivery of a Chinese or other such. (which isn't really chinese food, but more glug) And of course its ordered after 8pm.

    Most fat people I know aren't really interested in losing weight. Oh a few pounds here or there, but they'll not change their lifestyle where it counts. They're convinced that punishing themselves in the gym, taking walks, and other such activities will offset their lazy attitudes towards food.

    But then it also gives them something they can complain about, and considering the numbers of fat people these days, they form a club almost. Its a bit like smokers following the introduction of the smoking ban. We knew what we were doing was extremely unhealthy, but misery loves company. And misery can be awfully appealing at times.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    I have several friends who are rake thin, do no exercise and drink 3 or 4 pints every night - Where I myself am always potentially overweight: I cycle at least 1 and a half hours every day, and do 5 or 6 hours on both days at the weekend, and have to deny myself food that I badly want most of the rest of the time, to remain at a normalish weight. My friend desperately wants to be bulkier, and has at times even resorted to stuffing himself with more food than he wants and doing no exercise for a few weeks to bulk up, and it doesnt work. We often joke about how his metabolism mixed with mine would create the perfect guy.

    Ever see that film Super Size Me about McDonalds' food? I saw that and thought cool (regardless of the health issues). So I ate in McDonalds for four weeks (Breakfast, lunch, and dinner), thinking I'd see some noticeable gain. Nope. Not a bit. Only thing I got was a hatred for that type of fast food..

    Thanks to age, my metabolism is starting to slow down a wee bit. I take great pride that my hip bones no longer jut out. I am the normal weight for my height, but even so, I gave up on gaining muscle mass years ago. Maybe in another 5 years, I might be able to get it, and keep it. :D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,122 ✭✭✭LadyJ


    Zascar wrote: »
    She told me all this Genetic Predisposition stuff is all rubbish, 99.9% is bad diet and not enough exercise. She said loads of her clients loose loads of weight but few keep it off. It's just a lifestyle thing.

    While this may be true, there is sometimes a lot more going on with a person than just making bad lifestyle choices. Over-eating, like anorexia, can be about control and a whole range of emotional/psychological problems can be at play, even if the person does not realise it themselves.

    As for exercise, conditions like depression/anxiety can cause a lot of people to not want to go outside much and they can feel seriously demotivated.

    I'm sure there are people who are just lazy out there but don't oversimplify the matter too quickly.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 271 ✭✭Starfox


    Its about attitude and what kind of it you have, your body is your car and your food is your fuel, so what type of fuel do you use, or do you even care!

    If you look at fat america, its easy to agree that for the most part people are overfed and undernourished and its all about taste rather than quality. (or else its all that growth hormones in their life stock) And i have to agree that unless you have some sort of condition like an overactive thyroid or something else like an emotional hold back you cant get over, you have no excuse for being a overweight and nobody to blame but yourself, eat healthy get out or get in the gym or sit on that couch and drown your sorrows eating that pie.

    After i turned 20 i was heading down hill putting on weight, eating junk! but over year ago i started going to go to the gym and eating healthy, lost nearly 2 stone, toned well up and am feeling pretty dam well, so im not just waffling on here

    If you want something badly enough do something about it!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,306 ✭✭✭Zamboni


    Being fat is quite depressing.
    I experienced it for a number of years and spent years struggling with it.
    Then I did something that the majority of overweight people don't do and I educated myself about obesity and nutrition.
    After a lot of blood, sweat and tears I brought my body back to a healthy bodyfat level.
    It is not easy. And therein lies the problem. Although most overweight people hate having excess fat tissue, few are prepared to make the sacrifices required to fix the problem.
    Some overweight people would rather cry into a tub full of Chinese on a Friday night then go to a gym, weigh their food, count calories, cook their own food, drink water, take measurements etc. I know this because (a) I was one and (b) I have trained a number of them.
    As has been previously said, it is ultimately up to the individual, regardless of other causes such as loneliness, bad parents, psychological issues etc.
    My main sympathy lies with the overweight person who makes serious attempts to lose weight only to be fooled by the many gimmicks out there such as weight loss tablets and fitness contraptions on TV ads and dodgy weight loss guru's.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 37,214 ✭✭✭✭Dudess


    Judging someone's character based on their weight is pretty hateful really. The "they're affecting the health service/my taxes" argument is a cop-out, as well as the "they obviously have no strength of character" one. And why feel such disdain for a person whose choices do not affect you?

    That said, I do have a problem with certain aspects of our culture celebrating obesity (I know our culture does the very opposite too) - e.g. very overweight women being urged to "celebrate their curves". That's of no help to them whatsoever. Overweight women should be given support and encouragement to improve their health, not that condescending "real women have curves" bullsh1t.

    But while the majority of cases of obesity are due to storing too much calories, the black and white "just eat less, move more" approach is often useless - as if overweight people don't know that. There are complex psychological aspects to it, and most people don't want to be fat. As LadyJ says, anorexia is recognised as a psychologically complex relationship with food, why can't some cases of obesity be? Because they are. There are people with food addictions - like a drug or alcohol or nicotine addiction.

    By the way, I do not think there are not overweight people who could just lose the weight by going about it the usual way except they're just too lazy. I also have no patience with people who whinge non stop about being overweight and never appear to make a hint of an effort to do anything about it, nor do I have patience for people coming up with all sorts of excuses for their weight.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 37,214 ✭✭✭✭Dudess


    There seems to be a never-ending stream of people on boards with this sort of "Boo-hoo you're breaking my heart" , "Sort yourself out" "Take responsibility for yourself" attitude to overweight people.

    Though they are correct in that any overweight person is ultimately responsible for their own fatness, there is a simplification to their thinking that misses the issue. Fatness is as complicated and difficult to solve as other issues like alcoholism and heroin addiction. Just because ultimately, being overweight is a question of eating more calories than you burn, does not make it a simple thing to change.

    Imagine you were talking to an alcohol counsellor and their advice was simply: "What you need to do, is to stop drinking." You'd say "Well duh! If it was as simple as that I wouldnt need to talk to an alcohol consellor to find out how to do it!"

    Of course losing weight is simply a question of eating less calories than you burn. Its how one gets into the headspace to do that that is the question. There are any number of psychological reasons that make people more likely to be over-eaters, in much the same way (and often in the same people) as there are in alcoholics and/or drug users.

    There are a myriad of feelings of emptiness/depression and anxiety that the person is medicating with food in many cases. This bone-headed "Just pull-your-socks-up" attitude does not help to deal with the fundamental issue - unless we're talking about somebody who just needs to drop a dress size before a wedding or something comparitively easy.

    If a person is obese, getting skinny (and remaining so) , is easily one of the hardest things any human being can possibly experience. Far harder, in fact than quitting the booze or smack would be, as those drugs satisfy no normal need in the human body: Food, on the other hand is very difficult to deprive your body of, and if a person is really obese it can take several years to lose the amount of weight needed to be a normal size. Most alcohol/drug addicts are clean within 28 days. Most of us wouldnt even be able to lose a noticable amount of weight in that time.


    As well as this there ARE differences in the way different human bodies deal with energy consumption. While these differences do not explain every pound in difference between people, they are a general tendency in the same way that some people pick up musical instruments easily where others might struggle for years to learn to play a chord.

    I have several friends who are rake thin, do no exercise and drink 3 or 4 pints every night - Where I myself am always potentially overweight: I cycle at least 1 and a half hours every day, and do 5 or 6 hours on both days at the weekend, and have to deny myself food that I badly want most of the rest of the time, to remain at a normalish weight. My friend desperately wants to be bulkier, and has at times even resorted to stuffing himself with more food than he wants and doing no exercise for a few weeks to bulk up, and it doesnt work. We often joke about how his metabolism mixed with mine would create the perfect guy.

    Further to this, as well, is that of all the addictions/psychological illnesses that a person can suffer from, obesity must be the one that garners the least sympathy. All reasonably educated people have an enlightened attitude to alcoholism now, we see it as a disease, and those that struggle with it as deserving of our sympathy and our support. We know that there is a whole complex of psychological, physical, historical and possibly genetic factors that go into making a person an alcoholic. But for some reason, some of us do not extend this thinking to the issue of obesity.

    And to add insult to injury: As well as being physically handicapping, obesity can actually destroy a person's personal life: One of my friends is obese. They are still a virgin at 32 and likely to remain so, forever. Nobody is ever likely to want a sexual relationship with this person as a result of his weight. Were he an alco or a junkie he'd actually be better off in this regard. Hell he could be a sexy wasted youth like Pete Doherty with Kate Moss on his arm.

    As a result of this, I have every sympathy for those who struggle with their weight and particularly those who are obese. Its a ****in' toughie and there's no easy way around it. I in no way condone of course, those who suggest 'Fat Pride' or any of that, and I am fattist in the sense that I too would never sleep with an obese person. But I absolutely respect them for the struggle they deal with every day, that many skinny people simply dont know about or understand.
    Amazing post. Yeah, some people just don't like fat people for how they look, end of.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,306 ✭✭✭Zamboni


    The more people continue to spout 'complex psychological issues' the more people will continue to die of heart disease and diabetes type 2 and other obesity related illness.
    Don't judge overweight people but please don't mollycoddle them either.
    If you keep focusing the why you will never get to the solution.
    Overweight people need support not a get out of jail free card.


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement