Reform any one band

Seraphicblue

If you could reform any one band with its "classic" lineup
who would it be.
I'd think Emperor
thoughts?

cedomination

The Mad Capsule Markets

ShawnRaven

Guns N Roses, it'll never happen, but i think this ends the thread.

cedomination

ShawnRaven wrote: »

Guns N Roses, it'll never happen, but i think this ends the thread.

Not until someone says Nirvana :pac:

ShawnRaven

cedomination wrote: »

Not until someone says Nirvana :pac:

If the dead counted, the i'm sure that either The Beatles or Led Zeppelin would have won

Kurt who?

Nea

Soundgarden
And brainwash Chris Cornell to forget about all the silly Timbaland nonsense

damonjewel

Genesis or king crimson

Furious-Red

cedomination wrote: »

Not until someone says Nirvana :pac:

Ugh god i hated Nirvana. If had to choose it would be the classic line up of GNR

Fad

The Misfits or At The Drive In.

(or Bands that recently broke up Reuben or I Killed the Prom Queen w/Butcher)

Mental Mickey

ShawnRaven wrote: »

Guns N Roses, it'll never happen, but i think this ends the thread.

Plus one gazzillion!!!!!

/thread.

ShawnRaven

damonjewel wrote: »

Genesis

I love Genesis, but i really don't know about this. It's like who was the better vocalist for Marillion in the sense that for Genesis, you'll have a good percentage who'll favour Gabriel, just as good a percentage favouring Collins, a smaller percentage who couldn't care less and a very small percentage asking "Who the f*ck was Ray Wilson?".

tony 2 tone

Faith No More, Big Jim Martin era, end of thread.

adox

Jellyfish.

damonjewel

ShawnRaven wrote: »

I love Genesis, but i really don't know about this. It's like who was the better vocalist for Marillion in the sense that for Genesis, you'll have a good percentage who'll favour Gabriel, just as good a percentage favouring Collins, a smaller percentage who couldn't care less and a very small percentage asking "Who the f*ck was Ray Wilson?".

I just think the original lineup with Hackett on Guitar and Gabriel on vocals were really it, they made some truly classic albums, and they haven't been the same since really. Big B is going to do his nut here :pac:

sofa kingcool

definitely Guns n Roses ...


END OF!

redenemyjoe

Pink Floyd. End of.

Six of One

Been said but saying it again.
The answer is Guns N'Roses! Feic getting any other band back for nostagic reasons! But failing Guns, bring back Audioslave and lets see what they can do.

sofa kingcool

redenemyjoe wrote: »

Pink Floyd. End of.

Although floyd were an AMAZING band it would still have to be guns n roses..

their splitting up was quite controversial AND they are probably the least expected band to reform in the whole world..


therefore the reformation of them would be oh so awesome ..:D

brendansmith

Pantera. End this thread.

brendansmith

Chaos AD era Sepultura. Close this thread.

brendansmith

Original line-up metallica. Lock the thread

sofa kingcool

:rolleyes:

LightofDarkness

Toughie... Pink Floyd, Original Metallica or Death (circa 1990-1991). Decisions, decisions...

funnyname

AC/DC with Bon Scott

redenemyjoe

I'm sorry I can't sympathise with the Guns & Roses crew. I really only liked justice.

Pantera would be unbelievable and if we get into bands that have dead members I would have to submit the might Zep.

Also, Decapitated and Taste would be incredible.

ShawnRaven

brendansmith wrote: »

Original line-up metallica. Lock the thread

Someone take the keyboard away from brendansmith....

THEN lock the thread.

Sammag

Alice in Chains.

brendansmith

Sammag wrote: »

Alice in Chains.

You going on the 26th?

Sammag

brendansmith wrote: »

You going on the 26th?

I was looking at getting tickets (if they're still available) but I dunno – just can't imagine them without Layne

Still in 2 minds though, but I haven't heard any of their stuff William DuVall...

Malice

Appetite for Destruction-era Guns N' Roses were who I thought of immediately when I saw this thread so I'll have to join the many others in going for them.

redenemyjoe wrote: »

I'm sorry I can't sympathise with the Guns & Roses crew. I really only liked justice.

Justice?

GhostInTheRuins

Seraphicblue wrote: »

If you could reform any one band with its "classic" lineup
who would it be.
I'd think Emperor
thoughts?

Didn't Emperor reform a few years back?

Maybe I'm mixing them up with another band.

Samurai

definitly the stone roses

Bubs101

Samurai wrote: »

definitly the stone roses

Lock the mother****ing thread

lord lucan

G N' R ftw though it's not gonna happen.:(

failing that it'd have to be FNM w/ big jim:cool:

poundhound

Pink Floyd without a doubt. Come on Roger and Dave, cant we all just get along? Guns N Roses could sell ice creams at it.

ZiMZuM

Queen would be class,Manson with Pogo,John 5 and Twiggy or GnR AFD era.

Seraphicblue

GhostInTheRuins wrote: »

Didn't Emperor reform a few years back?

Maybe I'm mixing them up with another band.

they did
i missed them
i want them to do it again

rainbow kirby

brendansmith wrote: »

Pantera. End this thread.

+1

Mr. Presentable

The Small Faces

But they'd be so old now.

Ian Hunter's website says Mott the Hoople are doing two shows at the beginning of October. That's a reunion of a previous best band in the world they said would never happen! I love Mott, but I couldn't watch 70 year old blokes in sequins and platform boots play...........

Motley Crue

if the dead count then Queen will surely win the title

but if we are going by only those who are still alive then I would have to say that I struggle to think of a band who haven't reunited in the last couple of years that I didn't want to see, although Megadeth circa 92 would be nice as Countdown to Extinction was a group effort and the only time Megadeth ever really felt like a band as opposed to a Mustaine solo effort.

David Ellefson, Marty Friedman, Dave Mustaine, Nick Menza is the true lineup

Like the current lads though and I think if Mustaine keeps them around they could go far

redenemyjoe

malice_ wrote: »

Appetite for Destruction-era Guns N' Roses were who I thought of immediately when I saw this thread so I'll have to join the many others in going for them.

Justice?

Justice!? Ha, what the hell was I thinking! I meant Appetite, ****ing hell.

damonjewel

nipplenuts wrote: »

The Small Faces

But they'd be so old now.

....

if not quite dead, Steve Marriot and Ronnie Lane, Great band all the same

Mushy

Death From Above 1979...heard them again today and was like "Wow...can't wait till they reform!"

ShawnRaven

Bubs101 wrote: »

Lock the mother****ing thread

No way! Not after the disaster that was Second Coming! Brown and Squire mercy killed that band!

ShawnRaven

Motley Crue wrote: »

David Ellefson, Marty Friedman, Dave Mustaine, Nick Menza is the true lineup

Dunno about a true lineup, but definitely the longest lasting.

Like the current lads though and I think if Mustaine keeps them around they could go far

Megadeth have pretty much been a revolving door of musicians for most of their existance. The RIP lineup lasted what, seven years? Mustaine is too much of a control freak and ends up driving members away. Once he and Ellefson drifted, it was pretty much the death of a stable existance for the band, now i love Megadeth, don't get me wrong, but lets be real here, nobody thought Ellefson would ever leave/be fired.

ShawnRaven

damonjewel wrote: »

I just think the original lineup with Hackett on Guitar and Gabriel on vocals were really it, they made some truly classic albums, and they haven't been the same since really. Big B is going to do his nut here :pac:

He's not the only one! I'm so refraining from comment on this one as i'm avoiding a banning! I will agree that they haven't been the same since though...


... they got better and took it to the next level, something that would never have happened with Gabriel on vocals.

Bubs101

ShawnRaven wrote: »

No way! Not after the disaster that was Second Coming! Brown and Squire mercy killed that band!

Second coming > Spaghetti incident

ShawnRaven

Bubs101 wrote: »

Second coming > Spaghetti incident

Yes, but Second Coming was the Roses second full studio effort (excluding compilations), and what was Guns N Roses? The Two Use Your Illusion albums.

GNR > Stone Roses..... > YOU!

SouperComputer

Jimi Hendrix Experience. Might be difficult with all three of them being dead though!

Red Sleeping Beauty

McCarthy and Guns n Roses to do a world tour.

Red Sleeping Beauty

Bubs101 wrote: »

Second coming > Spaghetti incident

Oi! that's rubbish

Spaghetti has some good tunes:

Ain't it Fun
Down on the Farm
New Rose
Raw Power
Buick Makane

All good tunes and worth the price of admission