Why not to get a mac?

Cianos

I'm thinking of getting a new laptop, and a friend told me I should get a mac. I never really considered it before, but I guess I'm open to the possibility. So, what would be your reasons as to why I shouldn't get a mac?

art

GoTo: http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=2055302777

Voodu Child

Less spec for the money is a pretty compelling reason.

The screens on the Macbooks are pretty bad also, imo.

Passenger

voodoo_child wrote: »

The screens on the Macbooks are pretty bad also, imo.

So that's why most professionals (Graphics, Video, Film, etc.) use macs (MacBooks and Desktops).

Tar.Aldarion

Way overpriced. I don't see the point.

Snickers Man

I stopped using a Mac about five years ago as I was totally pissed off with the way they keep changing the architecture and making all your installed software redundant.

They say they don't but in practice they do. When they went from Macintosh 9 to OSX the task of switching from one OS to another on the fly if you wanted to run some pretty nifty piece of software (and they do occasionally have pretty nifty pieces of software) was just too painful to bother with.

since then, I believe they may have had another change from IBM/Motorola processors to Intel ones. Can't really comment on those changes. But I have to say I never missed the Mac once I stopped using it.

Voodu Child

Passenger wrote: »

So that's why most professionals (Graphics, Video, Film, etc.) use macs (MacBooks and Desktops).

I don't care who does or doesnt use them; ive got a new macbook in front of me (not mine) and the screen is sub-par. A lot of light leakage.

projectmayhem

lot of negativity here.

i got a macbook pro in february or thereabouts. i wanted/needed a laptop and decided there's no point in putting up with vista on the go - i can do that on my desktop.

since purchasing i've used my pc only for games. everything else (college, web browsing, etc.) is done on my mac. life is just easier. OSX is stunning too. i've yet to have any problems with it, at all.

the laptop itself is probably under-powered for the money i paid... but you're paying for OSX and the badge to a certain extent.

my experience has been so good with my mac that i'm considering buying a mac desktop solution for myself.

Tar.Aldarion

Why are you paying for linux tbh. I'd get a non-mac laptop with better specs and put linux on it if I did not want vista on it.
Just my two cents. Ah I finally used that term.

Passenger

voodoo_child wrote: »

I don't care who does or doesnt use them; ive got a new macbook in front of me (not mine) and the screen is sub-par. A lot of light leakage.

Well then there's a problem with that particular mac you're using. You need to calibrate the screen.

The very reason graphics professionals use Macintosh is for the irrefutably superior quality in screens.

Tar.Aldarion

How are they better? In what way.

tramoredude

Passenger wrote: »

Well then there's a problem with that particular mac you're using. You need to calibrate the screen.

The very reason graphics professionals use Macintosh is for the irrefutably superior quality in screens.

What a downright stupid biased comment...

Firstly you CAN NOT calibrate light bleed it is a defect with the screen

Sure some artsy folk use macs, but just because a screen has a little apple logo on it DOES NOT mean its good or the best...Any decent CRT or high end LCD is significantly better than any apple display.

humbert

I thought people working in the aforementioned areas traditionally used macs because the hardware and software was geared more toward multimedia. I've seen mac laptops and there sure as hell is nothing special about the screens.

Oh. OSX is much more accessible for computer users who know squat about computers.

Tar.Aldarion

I didn't think anything could be simpler than windows! /points and clicks
Heh

Ghost Train

well mac books have issues with grainy 6-bit lcd screen just like some dells and other laptops http://peewaiweb.free.fr/
http://www.engadget.com/2008/03/26/apple-quietly-settles-macbook-6-bit-lcd-screen-lawsuit/
their larger displays are high quality but the laptop screens are similar to other manufacturers

Voodu Child

Passenger wrote: »

Well then there's a problem with that particular mac you're using. You need to calibrate the screen.

The screen is the same as every other Macbook ive seen. When i said i've got one in front of me, I lied.....ive got two

Its just not a great screen imo, ive gotten cheaper laptops with better screens.

humbert

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

I didn't think anything could be simpler than windows! /points and clicks
Heh

Ah yeah, of course. I just meant in terms of using linux as an alternative, in my experience that would terrify the average mac user.

Tar.Aldarion

But...irrefutable?

He he he

Ah yeah, of course. I just meant in terms of using linux as an alternative, in my experience that would terrify the average mac user.

True I don't think a lot of people would handle it too well. Maybe if they stayed away from the CLI.

Tar.Aldarion

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

I didn't think anything could be simpler than windows! /points and clicks
Heh

I've found my macbook pro to be much easier to use than any windows machine I've had or used before.
It's my first mac and I'm well impressed with it, so impressed in fact I'm going to replace my desktop with an imac as soon as I can afford it. No issues with the screen at all.

Tar.Aldarion

In what ways is it easier to use? I only ever really use my gfs mac, it's grand but not easier that I can see. It's also annoying for software that I use that isn't available for mac. Most poeple wouldn't have that problem so not really a downside. Don't get me started on the one clicky button though.

Can you just buy a normal desktop/laptop and put OSX on it if you prefer it? Cheaper prices for better specs if you are replacing your comp. Or why not get OSX on your current comp? /0.02

Tar.Aldarion

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

In what ways is it easier to use? I only ever really use my gfs mac, it's grand but not easier that I can see. It's also annoying for software that I use that isn't available for mac. Most poeple wouldn't have that problem so not really a downside. Don't get me started on the one clicky button though.

I've found it works just as well as windows for pretty much every application I use. It hasn't crashed once in the two months I've had it, my windows machine crashed regularly. The one button click doesn't bother me at all. The two button mouse I had for my old laptop works fine with it so it's not an issue at all.:)

FruitLover

Passenger wrote: »

The very reason graphics professionals use Macintosh is for the irrefutably superior quality in screens.

No, it's because they've become industry standard over the years and mac-based software is what people in the industry have learnt how to use. Nothing to do with hardware, other than the fact that macs have traditionally been relatively standardized hardware-wise.

Plus the OS has historically been easier for non-technical people to get to grips with than operating systems that are more PC-associated.

Soundman

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

Can you just buy a normal desktop/laptop and put OSX on it if you prefer it? Cheaper prices for better specs if you are replacing your comp. Or why not get OSX on your current comp? /0.02

As in a PC desktop/laptop?

No you can't install OSX in that case.

ethernet

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

...Don't get me started on the one clicky button though. ...

Ctrl-clicking solves this or, if you have a MacBook (Pro), then two finger on the trackpad does the job nicely. I just got a MBP having used Windows and Linux for the past few years. It's good to see the other side and it amazes me how things 'just work'.

Price is the killer but not as bad if you're a student. Just be sure to go to an actual Apple Store when buying for the best deals.

Tar.Aldarion

Deleted User wrote: »

I've found it works just as well as windows for pretty much every application I use. It hasn't crashed once in the two months I've had it, my windows machine crashed regularly. The one button click doesn't bother me at all. The two button mouse I had for my old laptop works fine with it so it's not an issue at all.:)

That would be computer dependent, in ten years i've had about one or two crashes over 4 laptops and a desktop. Although people tend to crash windows more than another operating sytem. Linux might be best for this. If you have a mouse for a mac laptop it would be grand all right, it's when you don't it pisses me off.

Soundman wrote: »

As in a PC desktop/laptop?

No you can't install OSX in that case.

Apple keep it wrapped up for their products eh, suppose that's smart.

ethernet wrote: »

Ctrl-clicking solves this or, if you have a MacBook (Pro), then two finger on the trackpad does the job nicely. I just got a MBP having used Windows and Linux for the past few years. It's good to see the other side and it amazes me how things 'just work'.

Price is the killer but not as bad if you're a student. Just be sure to go to an actual Apple Store when buying for the best deals.

I have used both those methods, it's just that I find them cumbersome/pointless. I suppose it's just me, I want to right click, not press a button and click or use two fingers, personal preference that I find it rather annoying. A mac laptop with two buttons is better so I think they should have that. :-)
A lot of people express the same opinion.

Don't you only get a few percent off as a student? I tried looking it up, can't remember. I do remember comparing macs and my laptop when I bought it and getting my laptop at half the price of the mac laptop, why pay twice as much tbh. I would't mind them apart from the needless price.

challengemaster

Soundman wrote: »

As in a PC desktop/laptop?

No you can't install OSX in that case.

Actually you can.. Seeing as the apple products now run on intel chips, there's really no issues with it. There's ways of doing things. Google will tell you.

Why not? way overpriced for what it is, reason: apple logo
You can get the exact same specs from Dell for about 1/2 the price, if not even less.

Cianos

Ok so to summarise the thread;

For
Always reliable and easy to use
Most people who get one seem to swear by them and not want to go back to PC

Against
More expensive for the same specs
Bad screen(?)

ethernet

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

That would be computer dependent, in ten years i've had about one or two crashes over 4 laptops and a desktop. Although people tend to crash windows more than another operating sytem. Linux might be best for this. If you have a mouse for a mac laptop it would be grand all right, it's when you don't it pisses me off.


Apple keep it wrapped up for their products eh, suppose that's smart.


I have used both those methods, it's just that I find them cumbersome/pointless. I suppose it's just me, I want to right click, not press a button and click or use two fingers, personal preference that I find it rather annoying. A mac laptop with two buttons is better so I think they should have that. :-)
A lot of people express the same opinion.

Don't you only get a few percent off as a student? I tried looking it up, can't remember. I do remember comparing macs and my laptop when I bought it and getting my laptop at half the price of the mac laptop, why pay twice as much tbh. I would't mind them apart from the needless price.

I got 15% off in an Apple Store (in the UK). The salesperson said even employees don't get discounts as good. On top of that, he threw in an all-in-one printer and 3-year AppleCare all for just over £1,500. I was well impressed considering the MBP costs €2,200 without a discount here.

Tar.Aldarion

You are basically paying twice the price for an OS that you can just install on a machine half the price, if you want OSX that much.
Macs are normal laptops, intel hardware, sold more because of the apple logo and OS.

I got 15% off in an Apple Store (in the UK). The salesperson said even employees don't get discounts as good. On top of that, he threw in an all-in-one printer and 3-year AppleCare all for just over £1,500. I was well impressed considering the MBP costs €2,200 without a discount here.

What specs is that, and why do you have to pay more if a mac is black? For 1900e it would want to be a beast! That's two and a half times the price of my laptop.
15% was a very good deal btw, it is that much here?

Soundman

challengemaster wrote: »

Actually you can.. Seeing as the apple products now run on intel chips, there's really no issues with it. There's ways of doing things. Google will tell you.

I meant legally with zero problems.

Hugh_C

Tar.Aldarion wrote: »

You are basically paying twice the price for an OS that you can just install on a machine half the price, if you want OSX that much.

Not legally. And the installation breaks every time there's an update, or so I've read.

Macs are normal laptops, intel hardware, sold more because of the apple logo and OS.

I use Macs because I like using Macs and I've used them for a long time. There's nothing I can't do on a Mac that I would need to do on any other platform except Unix and YES, I'm in the creative sector and NO I'm not a gamer.

Of course I like the OS, especially since OS X, but I'm not especially slavish to the brand.

Horses for courses.

Blazer

voodoo_child wrote: »

I don't care who does or doesnt use them; ive got a new macbook in front of me (not mine) and the screen is sub-par. A lot of light leakage.

Well known issue- Apple are being sued at the moment for their so-called high end monitors when the colour display is sub par on them.
Besides I'm happy with Windows.
I'm a gamer and I use Vista 64bit at home and it runs flawlessly. Same for my work system which is XP. Have never got a blue screen on any of my work systems in over 10 years of using them..probably because I only use certified drivers/programs to use with them. And they've been changed on a yearly basis.
OS X is the same basically..apple control what you can run on it/install hardware so it's easy to get it stable.