Is Jumbletown ok?

luckat

I've put a couple of things up on Jumbletown, but all the answers seem to be from people who want them for... commercial reasons. I was expecting ordinary folks who needed the stuff.

Have people here had ok experiences advertising there?

Ideo

Do the Vincent de Paul not collect old furniture and give it to old people who need it? Might be an option

eliza64

hi i am a great fan of jumbletown as both a giver and taker .anyone i have delt with seamed genuine.

bmaxi

luckat wrote: »

I've put a couple of things up on Jumbletown, but all the answers seem to be from people who want them for... commercial reasons. I was expecting ordinary folks who needed the stuff.

Have people here had ok experiences advertising there?

I agree, I gave away a car 2 years ago and saw it for sale by a roadside dealer a few weeks later. To be fair, they don't claim to be a charitable organisation, rather that they want to stop usable things ending up on the tip and you don't have to give the items to anyone you don't want to. I think dealers have people trawling the site day and night because the same names appear again and again.

luckat

Well, I suppose no harm for scavengers to be taking stuff for free... I'll try Simon or Threshold or Focus, maybe, though. One of the people who answered turns out to run a business that revolts me...

Tony255

Ideo wrote: »

Do the Vincent de Paul not collect old furniture and give it to old people who need it? Might be an option

from what i remember they dont collect it anymore, probably sick of getting junk from other people.

eliza64 wrote: »

both a giver and taker .

had to have a little giggle

dewsbury

I have given stuff away on these sites and found it very satisfactory.

I think that the objective is NOT specifically to help the less well off. If is about preventing waste.

I gave a telly away a few months ago and the taker had a signature on his email.

He worked for a major bank and was a "Wealth Management Consultant" !! ... not too poverty stricken I would imagine !

luckat

dewsbury wrote: »

I think that the objective is NOT specifically to help the less well off. If is about preventing waste.

Oh, sure. But there are some people to whom I wouldn't give anything willingly. And that would include wealth management consultants, have to say.

lizzyd66

It is your choice who you give it to so you can look at their past posts and get an idea of who they are from that. There is one guy who collects a lot of TVs, stereos etc , I presume he repairs them and sells them on. I have no problem with that but the last few items I had, even if he was the first to reply , I have given to someone else who wants the item for their own use. I love the site , it is great to save things from landfill. I've also been given great things from it - most of my furniture is either from jumbletown, freecycle, boot sales or passed on from rellies (saves on a burglar alarm too as we have nothing worth stealing). It is all lovely stuff and has saved us a small fortune!

Orion

We were giving away a kitchen table and chairs recently and did something similar. The first reply was from someone who seemed to be making a living from jumbletown so the post was ignored in favour of someone who's history showed they were actually looking for what I was giving away.

TheGrinch50

I also posted quite a lot of stuff on Jumbletown. Once, a guy called with a van and a couple of kids. While I gathered all the stuff to give to him, his kids ran wild throughout my house. He then asked me not to bother posting any more items on the site but to phone him instead and he would take whatever he could sell. Some cheek! Well, I have since discovered an excellent site and I can either give my items for free or sell them. The site is: www.itsinmyway.com There's lots of interesting forums on the site too.

mawk

there is also freecycle which is quite a good service. not as much stuff goes on it as jumbletown but every offer on it is genuine. its moderated fairly heavily to stop people mooching and you can only post a request if you have a greater number of items donated than requested

they even email out digests with articles of note like today's


Taken: Graco Rear Facing Infant Seat with Base From: marissamcl 2. Offered - gas fire From: urbanachiever1 3. OFFER:Singles From: roni_1309 4. OFFER: Play station 1 From: roni_1309 5. OFFER: Tummy cruncher From: roni_1309 6. OFFERED: Dell Computer From: saorbaba 7. Wanted - Oven door glass From: disantlion

I like the crowd and recommend registering

TheGrinch50

That's a great idea mawk. I don't like jumbletown because the same people are asking for everything. Actually I got banned from the site because I sent a pm with a link to itsinmyway.com. The person I sent it to had an item of jewellery stolen and she put a request for a similar item on jumbletown. I thought she might get a replacement if she posted a request on another couple of sites. However, the admin reads the pms and I got banned for trying to help. They are so pathetic! I forgot to tell her to post on adverts but I will mention it to her now. I am having a clearout so I will start posting it on adverts and the site you mentioned but I will stay clear of jumbletown.

TheGrinch50

dewsbury wrote: »

I have given stuff away on these sites and found it very satisfactory.

I think that the objective is NOT specifically to help the less well off. If is about preventing waste.

I gave a telly away a few months ago and the taker had a signature on his email.

He worked for a major bank and was a "Wealth Management Consultant" !! ... not too poverty stricken I would imagine !

I was giving away a set of bunk beds on itsinmyway.com and somebody saw that a person was looking for a set on jumbletown. They posted the link so that the person could ask for them and within minutes the admin on jumbletown deleted the post. I don't think the admin on jumbletown are interest in preventing waste. Running the site is just a job for them and they don't want competition.

TheGrinch50

mawk wrote: »

there is also freecycle which is quite a good service. not as much stuff goes on it as jumbletown but every offer on it is genuine. its moderated fairly heavily to stop people mooching and you can only post a request if you have a greater number of items donated than requested

they even email out digests with articles of note like today's


Taken: Graco Rear Facing Infant Seat with Base From: marissamcl 2. Offered - gas fire From: urbanachiever1 3. OFFER:Singles From: roni_1309 4. OFFER: Play station 1 From: roni_1309 5. OFFER: Tummy cruncher From: roni_1309 6. OFFERED: Dell Computer From: saorbaba 7. Wanted - Oven door glass From: disantlion

I like the crowd and recommend registering

mawk, could you let me have the name of the site in your post, please.

the_syco

TheGrinch50 wrote: »

mawk, could you let me have the name of the site in your post, please.

Guessing it's http://www.freecycle.org/

TheGrinch50

Brilliant! Thank you.

Orion

TheGrinch50 wrote: »

However, the admin reads the pms

Are they aware that that's illegal? Or at least potentially illegal. Admins here don't read pms unless given express permission by the recipient and only then in cases of abuse/harassment afaik. Private messages are exactly that - private.

TheGrinch50

You could be right Macros42. Now that you mention it, it could be classed as an invasion of privacy. However, I can't prove that they read my pm and if they didn't, then I was banned from the site for no reason. I was always very loyal to them and I gave away qaulity items which I could have sold. I even got my daughter to advertise their site on her own website, but that's the thanks I got. Ah well. Live and learn!

MOH

Macros42 wrote: »

Are they aware that that's illegal? Or at least potentially illegal. Admins here don't read pms unless given express permission by the recipient and only then in cases of abuse/harassment afaik. Private messages are exactly that - private.

I'd never assume anything I post on the internet is private.

It's not illegal.
It's their site, it's their DB, and you agree to it when you sign up.

Jumbletown T&Cs wrote:

6. the User agrees that in providing matter to the Web Site, the User provides to the owners a perpetual and irrevocable right to use and manipulate (in any way that the owner thinks fit and at their absolute discretion) the said matter, in respect of which in all cases the User warrants that he has every right and entitlement to furnish that said right to the owner.

There's nothing in the description of PMs to indicate that they can't be read by admins.

All that said, it does seem that they're a bit over-zealous in deleting all mention of similar websites.

TheGrinch50

MOH wrote: »

I'd never assume anything I post on the internet is private.

It's not illegal.
It's their site, it's their DB, and you agree to it when you sign up.


There's nothing in the description of PMs to indicate that they can't be read by admins.

All that said, it does seem that they're a bit over-zealous in deleting all mention of similar websites.

I just tried to help another person who was desperate to find a replacement for a piece of jewellery that was stolen, and I did this by way of a pm so that it wouldn't seem like I was spamming the site. My IP address was blocked as a reward for being so helpful. I can't think of anything more petty!

MOH

TheGrinch50 wrote: »

I just tried to help another person who was desperate to find a replacement for a piece of jewellery that was stolen, and I did this by way of a pm so that it wouldn't seem like I was spamming the site. My IP address was blocked as a reward for being so helpful. I can't think of anything more petty!

Sorry, wasn't disagreeing with you, I think it's extremely petty.
I was just saying I didn't think it was illegal, as Macros42 had claimed.

Would definitely put me off using them if that's their attitude.

TheGrinch50

Somebody somewhere must have made the admin on Jumbletown aware of this thread as I have now been reinstated as a member. No email, no pm and no apology! Well it just doesn't work like that. I will never use the site again. I think Boards and Adverts are about the best sites on the web and I intend to stick with them. I will of course give some support to itsinmyway.com as the admin there are extremely friendly, nice and helpful. It is also a great site for having a bit of a banter and it's great fun.

Greaney

I found most Jumbletowners were based in the East of the Country... the west was really missing out... I didn't really like the freecycle site (it's a yahoo group), it didn't have layout, no photos, you didn't know what you were getting, but boy it's effective if you're trying to de-clutter. It has so many members.

GavinZac

Jumbletown is great but I can never get my hands on things first. I wish they'd make an RSS feed for Cork.

Macros42 wrote: »

Are they aware that that's illegal?

No its not - PMs, in vBulletin at least, like this very forum, are stored as plain text in the database and can be read by anyone with access to the database. vBulletin itself doesn't give direct access to the database but its extensions can do so.

Private messages are exactly that - private.

Essentially nothing on the internet is actually private - you're at the mercy of policy.

kandeekan

I would just like to say, that there is some thing more petty, as stated on thread, but its not about jumble town, i think jumbletown is the best site for free items, they treat their users extremely well, its a great site and easy to use and also fun, i love it and have reccommended it to my friends and family.
I use it to find replacement items for my household, its very usefull. i was looking for a kettle and a toaster which i definately need, but it had none at the time, so i saw an add in my supermarket for itsinmyway thought id try it, see what it was like, way bad move, in my opinion they are very very PETTY in the extreme, its a hard site to use i thought, as im not very computor literate, i didnt think i had registered right so i tried again........ result ? i was PERMANENTLY banned on the spot !! so much for helping new users.
I wish them all the luck with their site, because with their treatment of new users, they will need all the luck in the world, i would never recommend itsinmyway to anyone in case they are treated the same.
I think i will stick with user friendly, helpfull sites like jumbletown, who respect their users and stop greedy people promoting other sites, thanx for reading,
kandeekane.

sorry dudara, i was just very heated at the time. thanx

dudara

kandeekan Can you please try to post in normal text with paragraphs/strucure etc and without all the emoticons?

It's quite painful to read right now.

dudara

Eireen

In view of the above comments by Kandeekan, I felt I just had to make a response in defence of itsinmyway.

I myself posted a few items on itsinmyway a couple of weeks back and one person asked for a few of them. For reasons which I will not discuss here, I decided not to give them to this person and I would wait to see if I got any more responses to my posts. The next day I got a response and decided I would give the items to the second person who asked for them. I received a pm from the second person and when I read the address in the pm, I realised that both requests seemed to be from the same person. This person was so greedy that they couldn’t wait for a response and instead registered with the site for the second time in the space of a couple of days in order to get their hands and whatever was going for free. This annoyed me very much so I reported them to admin@itsinmyway.

When I checked the members list a couple of days later, I noticed that both names were gone off it and so I felt I could go ahead and post some more items without being bothered by this person. Well, as luck would have it, the first person to ask for one of my items was the same person whom I had reported to admin, and so once again I had to report them.

I hope now that they have finally got the message and will not bother me again, otherwise admin will have to get a new logo to read as follows:
<snip>

Sorry for the long post but I detest people who think they are entitled to something just because they request it and then run the site down when they are banned. Ugh!!

By the way, Adverts is still my favourite site thanks to the mods who do a great job.

borderlinemeath

Just on Jumbletown, I have taken some great things off the site and dealt with some really nice people.
However on giving away items, I have met some very strange individuals who would literally take the hand off you.
There is a lot of dealers who trawl the site looking to scavenge anything they can get, so I tend not to take the first reply and research the respondants to see who is most in need of my items.

DublinWriter

At the end of the day, do you want to get rid of the stuff or not?

I've gotten rid of a lot of stuff through jumbletown, yes it did tick me off a little that most of them were part-time dealers who had seen one-too-many episodes of Flog-It and were posing as average punters.

One particular middle-aged English couple rang about an antique rosewood China Cabinet I was getting rid of from my late Mum's house. The wife of the couple went on at great length about the 'antique house' they had just purchased in the country and how the cabinet would really suit it.

For 'antique house' read 'antique shop'. When they came to collect it my wife overheard the husband taking several calls on his mobile making deals to buy and sell other antiques, mentioning his 'shop' several times when he thought he was out of earshot.

Having said that, I'm no eejit and had the item valued at around €50 in the first place.

The most satisfying 'takers' were the young Eastern European couples who were taking the most basic of stuff to kit out their houses.

Basically the service does what it says on the tin and does it effectively.

amdublin

I use freecycle - have got rid of stuff and have got stuff on it.

TBH I don't care who takes my item. Or what they do with it. I want rid of it. Me, myself am too lazy to do anything with it aside from put it up on the net. If they sell it good for them!

Also, how do you know they are selling it/doing something you don't like with the item??? Any things I have put up, when they come to pick up the transaction takes about two minutes ie. they come in take the thing and go.

Do you want rid of the item or not?!

Serendipity121

kandeekan wrote: »

I would just like to say, that there is some thing more petty, as stated on thread, but its not about jumble town, i think jumbletown is the best site for free items, they treat their users extremely well, its a great site and easy to use and also fun, i love it and have reccommended it to my friends and family.
I use it to find replacement items for my household, its very usefull. i was looking for a kettle and a toaster which i definately need, but it had none at the time, so i saw an add in my supermarket for itsinmyway thought id try it, see what it was like, way bad move, in my opinion they are very very PETTY in the extreme, its a hard site to use i thought, as im not very computor literate, i didnt think i had registered right so i tried again........ result ? i was PERMANENTLY banned on the spot !! so much for helping new users.
I wish them all the luck with their site, because with their treatment of new users, they will need all the luck in the world, i would never recommend itsinmyway to anyone in case they are treated the same.
I think i will stick with user friendly, helpfull sites like jumbletown, who respect their users and stop greedy people promoting other sites, thanx for reading,
kandeekane.

sorry dudara, i was just very heated at the time. thanx

What a load of rubbish Kandeekan! I am a member of itsinmyway and I saw your posts requesting the kettle and toaster so obviously you saw them too. I watched the posts for a day as I also could have done with a new toaster and then I noticed that another person called "irishmolly" asked for the kettle and toaster. When the poster responded to irishmolly I was sorry that I hadn't asked for the toaster and then I noticed that the posts disappeared, so I am guessing that both posts were made by you. You seem like a very sad, pathetic person and I feel really sorry for you.

BnB

There seems to be a bit of a turf way between Jumbletown and itsinmyway going back a few years with a few dubious new posters logging on to take sides.

TheGrinch (from 2 years ago) was obviously from itsinmyway.com

Tis all a bit pathetic really.

Orion

yet you're only a member since January this year. That's some serious research.

dudara

I hate it when users start sniping at each other. Please behave

dudara

BnB

Macros42 wrote: »

yet you're only a member since January this year. That's some serious research.

Marcos

I don't really get you. I have been a member for a few years. My name was BnA. I screwed up my password change in January when there was a problem with the site so I set up a new username...BnB. (But I don't see what that has to do with anything)

RE the "serious research" work..... I just saw this thread and read it. I noticed it was a 2 year old thread that had been dragged up again, and made a comment. I don't get where the "serious research" came from.

I know nothing about either site. I did look at both of them out of curiosity after reading this thread and they both look fine to me.

kandeekan

Serendipity121 wrote: »

What a load of rubbish Kandeekan! I am a member of itsinmyway and I saw your posts requesting the kettle and toaster so obviously you saw them too. I watched the posts for a day as I also could have done with a new toaster and then I noticed that another person called "irishmolly" asked for the kettle and toaster. When the poster responded to irishmolly I was sorry that I hadn't asked for the toaster and then I noticed that the posts disappeared, so I am guessing that both posts were made by you. You seem like a very sad, pathetic person and I feel really sorry for you.

thank you for your sympathy, im not sad or pathetic tho, i am a mother of 7 children, i work part time, but some things i just couldnt replace, so the site had a kettle and mine is held together by sticky tape my toaster died afew weeks ago, so i really did need them, im new to computer, the only "sites" i knew had building in front of them, so computor sites are new to me, i thought i did it wrong so i tried again, obviously i asked for the same again as i still needed them and as i thought id done it wrong, i also appologised to steve before i was taken off, explaining where i went wrong, didnt i hold my hands up to getting it wrong, in my message ? i wasnt intending for anything to be done underhanded, it was a genuine mistake, my mistake tho was being to dumb to properly use the computor and the site, but admin could have wrote and tried to explain and help me correct it not instantly ban me that left me confused and left the poor steve wondering why i had gone, i still have a battered kettle and no toaster, so you see im not sad or pathetic, im a hard working single mum trying to do her best for the children, you should feel sorry for me that im not able to properly use these sites, or that i didnt get two things i genuinly needed, but dont feel sorry for me cos im sad and pathetic, as i am not thank you, and that statement is nasty and uncalled for, i was talking about a site and its policys and how they enforce them, but you made it personal at me serendipity, that in my book is sad and pathetic.

Serendipity121

Oh dear, Kandeekane, you obviously didn't read "the poor steve's" reply to your post on reverbstudio.ie. For a person who is not computer literate, you are making a great job of badmouthing people all over the web and that disgusts me. I and members of my family had the misfortune of making your acquaintance when you requested items from us on Jumbletown and even after this, you continued to request similar items from other JT members. It must cost a fortune for fuel to drive around the country in your big car collecting freebies and if you were to refrain from making just one of these trips, I am sure you could afford to buy a reasonably good kettle and toaster. The mind boggles!

Biggins

The wife and I have used it - had mostly good use out of it for getting rid of stuff.
Had one person turn up and be rude/arrogant but by far the rest were nice and pleasant.

dudara

@Serendipity121 and kandeekan

Are you adults or children? Stop this petty, childish one-upmanship or I will give you both a break from the Consumer Issue fourm

dudara

kandeekan

Serendipity121 wrote: »

Oh dear, Kandeekane, you obviously didn't read "the poor steve's" reply to your post on reverbstudio.ie. For a person who is not computer literate, you are making a great job of badmouthing people all over the web and that disgusts me. I and members of my family had the misfortune of making your acquaintance when you requested items from us on Jumbletown and even after this, you continued to request similar items from other JT members. It must cost a fortune for fuel to drive around the country in your big car collecting freebies and if you were to refrain from making just one of these trips, I am sure you could afford to buy a reasonably good kettle and toaster. The mind boggles!

iv had enough of this rubbish, yes i have got things of jt but isnt that what its for. i also drove once to limerick for a computor and abbeyliex for a suite (a friend drove) and ballyroan to get (bits n bobs)
i have not badmouthed anyone except itsinmyway on this once, i do drive i took my daughter to limerick with me we made a day of it as we never were there before. it doesnt cost much for fuel thanx tho for caring , i do need a big car iv 7 kids what do you suggest a mini, you keep making personal remarks to a reply i made about itsinmyway, is it your site ? because although i have a big car only 2 of the givers have seen it (due to parking difficulties) one in lucan and one in ballyroan, and i had tea with one ive only ever been polite. so i would like the assaults on my character to cease thankyou, its getting petty.

dudara

kandeekan banned for 10 days for failing to heed two moderator warnings.

dudara

the groutch

with any site (including adverts.ie), if you're giving something away it's impossible to know who genuinely needs the items and who is just trying to make a quick buck.

i've been very lucky with anything I've given away, all of them had genuine use for the stuff. you've just gotta have a bit of savvy to suss out who is just trying to take anything for free.

adverts.ie is good in that way because I'm not gonna name names, but there have been, and still are members who if you look at their comments, it has "I'll take it" or something similar 20 times in a row, which I always look for before committing to giving the item to a person

Greaney

Gosh lads, ye're a great argument for car boot sales....

But yes, I have to admit, there's always a place for freecycling, to get rid of perfectly good usable stuff, that you couldn't ask for cash for (eg. a chipped, formica bookcase for example...):P

Personally, I use heaps of sites to shift my clobber, I found jumbletown has a lot of rules of what you could or couldn't freecycle though. A bit limiting (I posted unused makeup samples once, and they pointed out that they had to remove my post because cosmetics weren't allowed to be posted, they were polite about it though). I just put them on yahoos freecycle group (alas, you can't post images there though:()

keithclancy

Holland has a great system with Kringloopwinkels (Recycling Shops), running is funded by the local authority (council)

Stuff is sold for a nominal amount and all money goes to charity.

Huge network all over the country and they come to pickup stuff from your house.

We furnished our first apartment here with stuff from the charity shop, saves everyone money as your not paying for disposal of stuff in your city taxes.

With those online sites I'd say go with the premise "I want to get rid of this without the hassle of selling it" rather than dealing with people your giving it to as a charity case.

You want get rid of it, your not doing someone a favour.

delllat

professional collectors ruin these sites

they are designed to be a two way sytem where you can give what you dont need and people can get what they do need or maybe cant afford

if i was running it id restrict people to collecting an item per week and ban anyone who seems to be "interested in everything"

DublinWriter

delllat wrote: »

professional collectors ruin these sites

Perhaps true, but you either want shot of the stuff or not - as long as they aren't fly-tipping what you give away then why are you concerned with the fact that they might be making a few quid on the side?

delllat

DublinWriter wrote: »

Perhaps true, but you either want shot of the stuff or not - as long as they aren't fly-tipping what you give away then why are you concerned with the fact that they might be making a few quid on the side?

its not what they do with it that bothers me ,more the fact that theyre so greedy it eliminates any chance of someone who might need something getting it

advertise almost anything that may be worth something and the same few cockroaches will come scuttling for it every time

it just lowers the qulaity of the site IMO

still handy for getting rid off stuff ,i just wud rather give to someone who hasnt made a career out of getting freebies

primavera85

i kinda like jumbletown. havent taken any items yet, but ive put my wedding dress up + was amazed how quick i had a response, several pm's in minutes! im waiting on a person to collect it later in the week!

ann0

jumbletown is good its in my way not so much then theres gumtree and the adverts.ie.jumbletown and the adverts sites are a lot easier for getting replies.im helping some oaps that i know get some furniture and its been harder than i thought and if u put up a wanted add on these sights u dont seem to get many replys.i put up a wanted add for a decent laptop for the old neighbour next door.i got one reply and was asked to meet the person in the omni shopping centre.wen i saw the laptop it was one of the very first laptops ever.wen i knocked it on the screen wasent working and the buttons started popping out.the owner of this pre historic laptop said its working wen it clearly wasent.a lot of people think old people wouldent know the difference but they do.why should they except crap.
ive noticed a lot of people seem to advertise for free christmas presents for there kids on jumbletown.little johnny wants handy manny little mary wants dora toys.im sorry but unless i know the person i wouldent send any toys how do u know that there not going to sell them.and then theres the people advertising for a free fishing boat or barge or a seven seater car.both will be used for oap trips theres been no replys to that one.a few months ago someone asked for the original transformer toys these toys are worth an absolute fortune.who in there right mind would give them away just like that

dudara

ann0 It would help greatly if you use full punctuation and structure in your post. It's quite hard to read in its current format.

regards

dudara