Irish Seinfeld

fade2black

A mate of mine wrote and starred in this. It's not fantastic but you have to applaud them for the effort!

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6785278870496324219&q=seinfeld

tbh

fair play to them - the faux american accent bugged me a little, thought it would have been better if played more naturally. But everyone's a critic, right? Looks very professional - A for effort.

smuckers

Fair play to him, v good.

therecklessone

I've seen people shot for less.

billygannon

I watched this and I thought it was dreadful. Why did they make this?

Damon_Kind

I'm gonna find them and kill them.

lee_baby_simms

I thought it was pretty funny.

Damon_Kind wrote:

I'm gonna find them and kill them.

Moderator.

DadaKopf

Why would you bother making a Donnybrook Seinfeld and do it in affected American accents. Wouldn't it have been funnier in local accents? Doyyy.

Vinnie

I'm making an Irish version of Father Ted. I cant find any Irish people to do it though so I'll be using Americans. When the DVD gets released I'll be using the proceeds to fly over to Canada and begin casting.

brianoak

smuckers wrote:

Fair play to him, v good.

Are you posting this from a mental home?

Zeelander

lee_baby_simms wrote:

I thought it was pretty funny.

Moderator.

fade2black

This thread sums up pretty much everything I hate about boards.ie and most of the idiots that post on it.

o1s1n

Bah it's the internet, you'll get arses everywhere, not just here.

Still watching it. Not a bad attempt.

fade2black

What bugs me though, oisin, is people who are too lazy to even scratch their arse properly will criticize people making an effort like this.

therecklessone

fade2black wrote:

What bugs me though, oisin, is people who are too lazy to even scratch their arse properly will criticize people making an effort like this.

How do you know anything about me or the others who've been critical?

Don't be such an arse, people are entitled to their opinions.

You think we should applaud effort? Its not the special olympics you know.

kinaldo

Just watched the intro bit.. Eddie Rockets lol

Having been to Tom's Restaurant / Monks in NY a few times it probably is the closest thing we have, if not nearly as good.

Fair play to them, I look forward to watching the rest of it later tonight.

sprinkles

Thought some of it was funny, good writing and a lot better produced than I anticipated. Accent got a bit on the nerves but good try.

billygannon

fade2black wrote:

This thread sums up pretty much everything I hate about boards.ie and most of the idiots that post on it.

I watched this and I thought it was terrible. I thought it was a tragic waste of time for both myself and the people involved making it.
To put it simply, Dublin's not New York. It's like watching Far and Away.

Clearly they're youngsters who are big fans of Seinfeld, and they'll probably look back at this and laugh.

What next? An Irish version of the Daily Show? Why? Why did they do this and why did their clearly unhelpful friends allow them to?

tbh

billygannon wrote:

I watched this and I thought it was terrible. I thought it was a tragic waste of time for both myself and the people involved making it.
To put it simply, Dublin's not New York. It's like watching Far and Away.

Clearly they're youngsters who are big fans of Seinfeld, and they'll probably look back at this and laugh.

What next? An Irish version of the Daily Show? Why? Why did they do this and why did their clearly unhelpful friends allow them to?

you're right billy. In future, I just wish people wouldn't bother. We have enough artists as it is, we don't need more. I also think we should insult the OP and his mates for having the audacity to think they should give it a go.



:rolleyes:
Totally agree with F2B on this.

ed: didn't know F2B was the OP, so he's obviously biased. I'm not tho, and I still agree with him.

Wilbert

tbh wrote:

you're right billy. In future, I just wish people wouldn't bother. We have enough artists as it is, we don't need more. I also think we should insult the OP and his mates for having the audacity to think they should give it a go.



:rolleyes:
Totally agree with F2B on this.

I saw this Seinfled thing and it made me want to kill!
It is so painfully bad and everyone involved should be deeply ashamed of themselves.
Did they really think it was going to be as good as even the worst episode of Seinfeld?
Just because someone had a go at something doesn't mean it was worth doing.
Also, when you say someone shouldn't criticise someone for having a go at someone you must be the kind of person who never criticised anything otherwise you'd be a hypocrite, right TBH?

billygannon

tbh wrote:

you're right billy. In future, I just wish people wouldn't bother. We have enough artists as it is, we don't need more. I also think we should insult the OP and his mates for having the audacity to think they should give it a go.



:rolleyes:
Totally agree with F2B on this.

I'm not saying they shouldn't do anything. This piece of work is really bad. It's not funny - in fact, it's made me angry.

Fair play for effort and they'll all probably end up in great film and tv jobs, but it's still rubbish.

fade2black

If I don't like something creative, like a movie, piece of writing or whatever I'll be honest but I won't try to be a comedian in the process. There's nothing wrong with saying fair play to them for the effort but it wasn't for me because....

Most of the crap on this thread is people just trying to be smart.

Wilbert

fade2black wrote:

If I don't like something creative, like a movie, piece of writing or whatever I'll be honest but I won't try to be a comedian in the process. There's nothing wrong with saying fair play to them for the effort but it wasn't for me because....

Most of the crap on this thread is people just trying to be smart.

So, you're saying you've never just slagged something off that you think is rubbish?

billygannon

fade2black wrote:

If I don't like something creative, like a movie, piece of writing or whatever I'll be honest but I won't try to be a comedian in the process. There's nothing wrong with saying fair play to them for the effort but it wasn't for me because....

Most of the crap on this thread is people just trying to be smart.

I haven't tried to be smart in the slightest. I've said what I thought.

I'm not going to say fair play to them, because I think they've wasted a lot of time and money doing this. They can clearly make a film and understand the various technical necessitites to produce it. Indeed, they clearly had the money to produce this as well.
But why didn't they stop and think, or someone in their circle stop them and ask them seriously why they would go and spend all their talent and resources producing something like this?
None of them can act. It's totally derivative. And if they are smart guys, which I reckon they are, they probably could have done something quite original and a lot better.

fade2black

Wilbert wrote:

So, you're saying you've never just slagged something off that you think is rubbish?

To be honest Wilbert, I'm not trying to make myself out to be holier than thou but because I'm used to submitting a lot of creative pieces for appraisal I try to give the kind of responses that I'd like to receive whether it be negative or positive.

If you wrote something or produced something and showed people and they said to ya "that's the worst bit of muck I've ever seen"....that's not going to help your cause in anyway. An acknowledgement of effort and constructive criticism is always the way to go. But hey, this is just my opinion.

tbh

billygannon wrote:

I haven't tried to be smart in the slightest. I've said what I thought.

I'm not going to say fair play to them, because I think they've wasted a lot of time and money doing this. They can clearly make a film and understand the various technical necessitites to produce it. Indeed, they clearly had the money to produce this as well.
But why didn't they stop and think, or someone in their circle stop them and ask them seriously why they would go and spend all their talent and resources producing something like this?
None of them can act. It's totally derivative. And if they are smart guys, which I reckon they are, they probably could have done something quite original and a lot better.

it's a start. They are not looking for money or anything just maybe a bit of constructive criticism.

wilbert wrote:

I saw this Seinfled thing and it made me want to kill!
It is so painfully bad and everyone involved should be deeply ashamed of themselves.
Did they really think it was going to be as good as even the worst episode of Seinfeld?
Just because someone had a go at something doesn't mean it was worth doing.
Also, when you say someone shouldn't criticise someone for having a go at someone you must be the kind of person who never criticised anything otherwise you'd be a hypocrite, right TBH?

have a look at my first post - I criticized them for the accents. I admire them for not simply sitting on the couch going "this is ****e, this is ****e" at the tv - they gave it a go. It's not going to set the world of TV alight, but to be fair, I don't think that was their intention.

therecklessone

Here's something constructive...

Next time they want to write something, try creating characters of their own instead of ripping off someone elses creation.

What next, an Irish Only Fools and Horses? Set it in Joey's Mansions, get three students to attempt Cockney accents and drive around in a Reliant Robin selling Christmas decorations and Toblerones?

The episode is poorly acted (what's with all the hand gestures?) and poorly written (seeing as they had to put zero effort into creating their leading characters).

That do?

Oh yeah, A for effort...

tbh

I don't think they were hoping you would be fooled into believing it's a real episode of Seinfeld you know.

Wilbert

fade2black wrote:

To be honest Wilbert, I'm not trying to make myself out to be holier than thou but because I'm used to submitting a lot of creative pieces for appraisal I try to give the kind of responses that I'd like to receive whether it be negative or positive.

If you wrote something or produced something and showed people and they said to ya "that's the worst bit of muck I've ever seen"....that's not going to help your cause in anyway. An acknowledgement of effort and constructive criticism is always the way to go. But hey, this is just my opinion.

Saying something is the worst bit of muck they've ever seen is a valid criticism. It may not be the most elegantly crafted critique but it is a direct response to the work so has to be considered.

I think this Seinfeld thing is a monumental waste of time, with some of the worst acting/accents I've ever witnessed. The writing is painfully amateurish and the whole thing is actually embarrassing to watch.

I wouldn't give them anything for effort because their efforts have produced one of the worst things I have ever seen.

The fact that they can't see how bad it is and put it up for the world to see on Google video is also staggering.

therecklessone

tbh wrote:

I don't think they were hoping you would be fooled into believing it's a real episode of Seinfeld you know.

Gold star for you.

tbh

therecklessone wrote:

Gold star for you.

I've already got 5. I keep 'em on my Liverpool European shirt

don't be so grumpy, it's nearly christmas. You didn't have to pay anything to watch them, they're just having a bit of craic.