Video of plane landing bad...

ando · 23-07-2004 7:05pm #1

just wondering if anyone has seen this video yet... it’s a Boeing 737 (I think) landing badly. Is it for real or some sort of Photoshop, mpeg style !! Needless to say, the pilot needs more practice :dunno:

Video ( 1.5Megs )

smoke.me.a.kipper · 23-07-2004 7:11pm

holy-moley! fair ****s to the pilot for actually landing that.

jim_bob · 23-07-2004 7:22pm

is that real

fcuk me i won't have liked to be on that

impr0v · 23-07-2004 8:30pm

Dunno, looks kinda faked to me. The bounces look too fast or something. The third bounce is higher than the second, and I reckon the nose wheel strut would collapse with the force of those bounces.

aphex™ · 23-07-2004 8:57pm

Originally posted by impr0v
Dunno, looks kinda faked to me. The bounces look too fast or something. The third bounce is higher than the second, and I reckon the nose wheel strut would collapse with the force of those bounces.

Well he's coming in too fast, then putting the brakes on way too hard. Also at the high speed, the plane ain't meant to be on the ground, so its still got lift. I'd say both of those *could* cause it to bounce a bit.

EDIT: yeah look at the smoke comin' off those brakes. I'd say it's real.

seamus · 23-07-2004 9:04pm

Either that's high winds, or some serious emergency landing. Looks like the kind of landing I'd do in a flight sim.

Think that video's speeded up a little?

bambam · 23-07-2004 9:08pm

KINDA ? it looks well fake. Ms Flight sim has come a long way.

RobertFoster · 23-07-2004 9:14pm

hear the people laughing in the background?

Lenny · 23-07-2004 9:21pm

That is well fake. tha plane bounces way too fast.
also the front wheel would not be able to handle that sort of pressure 2/3 times and would give it.
Don'#t think its a 737 either.. too small

The Real B-man · 23-07-2004 10:05pm

yeah but its really funny and well made

OfflerCrocGod · 23-07-2004 11:21pm

That's real - MS Flight Sim my ass.

bizmark · 23-07-2004 11:29pm

Thats not real theres no way the front landing gear would take the weight of big aircraft (maybe 50-100 ton) bouncing up and down like that

[CALIBUR] · 24-07-2004 12:20am

If that really happened it be on the news and on newspapers all over the world.

But good job to the guy who made that

OfflerCrocGod · 24-07-2004 5:46am

Originally posted by #MEAT#
If that really happened it be on the news and on newspapers all over the world.

But good job to the guy who made that

Why? - it looks old, could you imagine the headlines "An airliner has a rough landing 7 years ago - wow!!!". Just because something didn't get on to Sky News doesn't mean it didn't happen.

OfflerCrocGod · 24-07-2004 5:49am

Originally posted by bizmark
Thats not real theres no way the front landing gear would take the weight of big aircraft (maybe 50-100 ton) bouncing up and down like that

Says you - a car can be bounced up and down like that onto it's front wheels and it will still be OK, granted a plane is bigger but I'd say planes are built to take quite some punishment in case of bad landings. After all they can carry 300 or so people - that's some serious responsibilty.

bizmark · 24-07-2004 6:19am

heavy landings yes but i dont think it would be designed to bounce like that on just its front landing gear

beer enigma · 24-07-2004 9:26am

I'd say its real enough -

Might like to check out this site too - need Real Player for most of the stuff

http://www.univers-cite.qc.ca/tucs/crash_video/

dahamsta · 24-07-2004 10:52am

This is a heavy landing. Apparently it's an MD 80 test flight landing at Edwards AFB.

adam

maxheadroom · 24-07-2004 11:02am

Originally posted by dahamsta
This is a heavy landing. Apparently it's an MD 80 test flight landing at Edwards AFB.

Not Found
The requested URL /play/MD-80.mpg was not found on this server.

Moriarty · 24-07-2004 11:42am

Try this instead for a working link.

mad m · 24-07-2004 4:10pm

Holy SH*TE u wudnt want to be in the back of that plane taking a piss.......Jaysus

OfflerCrocGod · 24-07-2004 5:18pm

Originally posted by mad m
Holy SH*TE u wudnt want to be in the back of that plane taking a piss.......Jaysus

Thanks I was drinking that orange juice you know!!:D

andrew163 · 24-07-2004 7:38pm

its computer generated....the shading is wrong for real life, the fog doesnt look right, you can't see the shimmering from the hot air that should be coming off the engines, and as someone else said you can hear people laughing in the background...:rolleyes:

Mossy Monk · 24-07-2004 7:59pm

do you watch films for mistakes?

mad m · 24-07-2004 8:04pm

[Thanks I was drinking that orange juice you know!!:D

i have missed something maybe its that plane flying over my head?......

OfflerCrocGod · 24-07-2004 8:11pm

Originally posted by andrew163
and as someone else said you can hear people laughing in the background...:rolleyes:

That's because they are watching it and are astonished by what they are seeing - what you think that ppl who are generating this on their PCs decided to add their laughter for......?

BuffyBot · 24-07-2004 8:32pm

I never know boards.ie had so many aviation safety specialists!

Webmonkey · 24-07-2004 8:55pm

I think it is real but it may be speeded up a little. The reason it bounces is because the pilot is pressing on and off the breaks every second...probably cause he doesn't want the plane to skid out of control...the front gear gets more and more damaged , by the end it is almost bent 90 degrees...

DiscoStu · 25-07-2004 12:53am

that's a fake. the real md-80 video shows the vibratations running up the fuselage before the tail breaks off. the plane in the other video is totally rigid throughout the landing and appears to hit the ground multiple times with similar force to md-80 crash.

Third_Echelon · 26-07-2004 12:55pm

The MD-80 seems to hit the ground more 'dead-on' at a faster speed which would cause what happened i.e. the tail breaking off etc... it was a very steep descent...

The boeing landing looks real enough... he is coming in at a lot slower pace than the MD-80 was... he was still going faster than he should be though...

His descent was a lot more gradual and not as steep as the MD-80... I could believe that this is what would happen in that particular situation... fair play for landing that with nasty cross-winds...

The landing gears would more than likely be well ****ed after that though, but it would take a lot of pressure and force to break them....

In all aircraft manufacturing the parts are stress tested well above the necessary attributes set out in safety standards...

His landing was a 'botched' landing... the MD-80 was more of a crash, which looks like one of those safety videos that they produce during testing of new aircraft...

jor el · 27-07-2004 9:58am

The bounces do look a bit fast and faked but the vid looks real. I wonder is it a test flight like the MD-80 one, maybe they're testing the planes abilty.

AdMMM · 27-07-2004 11:30am

Just have to wait till I get BB in bout 90mins to watch it.

Not wasting my time downloading during peak time on 56gay

OfflerCrocGod · 27-07-2004 11:35am

Originally posted by |.Murderer.|
Just have to wait till I get BB in bout 90mins to watch it.

Not wasting my time downloading during peak time on 56gay

Thank God! then we can finally get the opinion of a real expert;) |.Murderer.| will shut us all up once he gives his verdict. By the way if you have just gotten BB today congrats welcome to the fast lane:cool:

FX Meister · 27-07-2004 11:52am

Like, hellooooo!! It's an overtaking lane!!! There's no such thing as a fast lane! Learn to drive/surf properly man

Originally posted by OfflerCrocGod
Thank God! then we can finally get the opinion of a real expert;) |.Murderer.| will shut us all up once he gives his verdict. By the way if you have just gotten BB today congrats welcome to the fast lane:cool:

Tommy Vercetti · 27-07-2004 12:10pm

The video is real but it is speeded up in the parts where it is bouncing to exaggerate it's movement - look at the background speeding up just after the rear wheels touch down. It also sounds as if they added in some sound effects too which ruined any chance of it seeming real. It's quite possible that it's a test flight or an emergency landing because it is unlikely that a passenger plane would be cleared to land in those sort of winds.

jor el · 27-07-2004 12:45pm

Ah, I wonder was it taped off a Kirsty's Home Videos styly program where they often speed up or slow down clips to exagerate the humor? All it's missing is the 'Boing Boing' style sound effects.

Tommy Vercetti · 27-07-2004 1:17pm

mmm Kirsty *drools*

stevo19ie · 14-12-2004 6:04pm

Hi All,

Firstly, the aircraft in the first video is an Airbus A319, it is possible that it's real but it may be speeded up, the approach looks way too fast, the only other possibility is that it's a scale model, the second one is definetely real, such a hard landing would put enormous amounts of strain on the stringers causing the aircraft to break up

Cheers
Steve

Lump · 14-12-2004 6:50pm

I think the first one is a fake... I can't comment on the second one as the link doesn't work.

The first one is fake because the approach of the landing wouldn't cause that to happen.

Planes glide down.... once on the runway, the fiction would cause a major slow down on the plane, hence causing it to make a smooth landing. Only way it'd bounce happen is if the pilot had too much power on.

The wheels have massive Hydrolic rams on the.... so the obsorb the impact... It's not that amazing!

John

Pataman · 14-12-2004 8:49pm

Lump wrote:

I think the first one is a fake... I can't comment on the second one as the link doesn't work.

The first one is fake because the approach of the landing wouldn't cause that to happen.

Planes glide down.... once on the runway, the fiction would cause a major slow down on the plane, hence causing it to make a smooth landing. Only way it'd bounce happen is if the pilot had too much power on.

The wheels have massive Hydrolic rams on the.... so the obsorb the impact... It's not that amazing!

John

not necessarily. A plane can bounce if the approach speed is too high. The plane is set up on approach in a certain configeration and the speed then bleeds off as the plane is about to touch down "a greaser". Parts of this vid look speeded up but its very hard to tell. My feeling is its true. If you look closely at the front wheels towards the end of the vid there are sparks possibly indication type blowout and the rims hitting the tarmac.

my 2c worth

Video of plane landing bad...

Comments