Is it legal to drive your friends in the back of a commersial vehicle?

Kensei · 31-05-2018 9:18pm #1

Like this:

https://gyazo.com/85cbfbebabb8e5da62a45729775203b1

verycool · 31-05-2018 9:21pm

No.

31-05-2018 9:22pm

No seatbelts, insurance only covers you for one passenger.

vicwatson · 31-05-2018 9:26pm

Yes illegal

Mooooo · 31-05-2018 9:30pm

Know of two crashes resulting in death in one case and paralysis in another carrying passengers like that.

minikin · 31-05-2018 9:38pm

It's ok, because he's already disabled - must have lost his legs in a previous accident.

Kensei · 31-05-2018 9:43pm

I specifically meant ILLEGAL, not uninsured. Meaning can the police stop you and fine you. Cuz information on that topic is pretty scarce.

Badger2009 · 31-05-2018 9:44pm

Thought I opened After Hours there for a second.

The Backwards Man · 31-05-2018 9:54pm

It's only legal if they're sitting on a load of turf. Or hay

Kensei · 31-05-2018 10:20pm

So if I present my friends as workers and have a box of tools in the car saying that we're going to fix some ghostly malfunctions in a phantom town, then it's ok. But if it's just 3 dudes in the back then it's not ok? Does that mean I'll get fined or are these just the insurance coverage rules?

I couldn't find anything specifically addressing this. So my guess was that you can't be fined if stopped while having people in the back.

Some people here say no, others say yes. Could anyone drop me a link to the specific piece of legislation that forbids this kind of use?

verycool · 31-05-2018 10:25pm

Kensei wrote: »

So if I present my friends as workers and have a box of tools in the car saying that we're going to fix some ghostly malfunctions in a phantom town, then it's ok. But if it's just 3 dudes in the back then it's not ok? Does that mean I'll get fined or are these just the insurance coverage rules?

I couldn't find anything specifically addressing this. So my guess was that you can't be fined if stopped while having people in the back.

Some people here say no, others say yes. Could anyone drop me a link to the specific piece of legislation that forbids this kind of use?

Link?

Contact your insurance show them this thread and let us know what they say.

31-05-2018 10:28pm

Kensei wrote: »

So if I present my friends as workers and have a box of tools in the car saying that we're going to fix some ghostly malfunctions in a phantom town, then it's ok. But if it's just 3 dudes in the back then it's not ok? Does that mean I'll get fined or are these just the insurance coverage rules?

I couldn't find anything specifically addressing this. So my guess was that you can't be fined if stopped while having people in the back.

Some people here say no, others say yes. Could anyone drop me a link to the specific piece of legislation that forbids this kind of use?

I think the Yes are taking the piss. Brother in law has a commercial van....its not legal, simple as.

Kensei · 31-05-2018 10:35pm

Ok, thanks. This sux

martinr5232 · 31-05-2018 11:06pm

Kensei wrote:

I specifically meant ILLEGAL, not uninsured. Meaning can the police stop you and fine you. Cuz information on that topic is pretty scarce.

Its scarce because it should be common sense.

aido79 · 31-05-2018 11:12pm

Kensei wrote: »

Ok, thanks. This sux

It would also suck if you had an accident and your friends in the back were killed or badly injured and their deaths or injuries could have been prevented if they were wearing seatbelts.

31-05-2018 11:28pm

11 (3) part c .....Road Transport Act.

http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/1932/act/2/enacted/en/print#sec11

Not specific but covers as the equipment used is not suitable for tranporting passengers in the back

Kensei · 01-06-2018 12:33am

aido79 wrote: »

It would also suck if you had an accident and your friends in the back were killed or badly injured and their deaths or injuries could have been prevented if they were wearing seatbelts.

Yes I'm sure an incident involving a 2.5 ton vehicle and presumably ~80 km/h would never be fatal thanks to 4 polyester bands designed to crush your rib cage. Also I've yet to see one person wear a seatbelt in the back.

My sentiments on seatbelt safety aside, it would also suck if you tripped on a staircase and broke your neck, but I'm sure you're not running for the handrail every time you have to go up.

Edit: Thanks 368100

Nekarsulm · 01-06-2018 12:43am

This is why Crew Cabs exist.

m5ex9oqjawdg2i · 01-06-2018 12:49am

Kensei wrote: »

Yes I'm sure an incident involving a 2.5 ton vehicle and presumably ~80 km/h would never be fatal thanks to 4 polyester bands designed to crush your rib cage. Also I've yet to see one person wear a seatbelt in the back.

My sentiments on seatbelt safety aside, it would also suck if you tripped on a staircase and broke your neck, but I'm sure you're not running for the handrail every time you have to go up.

Edit: Thanks 368100

Are you actually trying to say that it's not safe to wear a seat belt?

They are not designed to crush your rib cage, they are designed to save lives. Cars are not designed to crash, but they do. Your analogy is idiotic at best.

Look at the following video of all the ping pong balls and tell me again what you think.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqGv_x2xEZY

Kimbot · 01-06-2018 12:55am

Kensei wrote: »

Also I've yet to see one person wear a seatbelt in the back.

Do you live on an island where's there's only 1 other car or something??

endacl · 01-06-2018 1:02am

Kimbot wrote: »

Do you live on an island where's there's only 1 other car or something??

Lives under a bridge. There's only room for one car.

aido79 · 01-06-2018 3:04am

Kensei wrote: »

Yes I'm sure an incident involving a 2.5 ton vehicle and presumably ~80 km/h would never be fatal thanks to 4 polyester bands designed to crush your rib cage. Also I've yet to see one person wear a seatbelt in the back.

My sentiments on seatbelt safety aside, it would also suck if you tripped on a staircase and broke your neck, but I'm sure you're not running for the handrail every time you have to go up.

Edit: Thanks 368100

Sorry. I can't take you seriously after reading that.

tcawley29 · 01-06-2018 4:47am

This has to be a wind up.

If the passengers in the back are under 17/18 not sure which, you get the fine for each for not having a seatbelt. Not sure about what else could happen.

If they're over 17/18 they get the fine and more than likely told to walk the rest of the journey

Del2005 · 01-06-2018 5:13am

tcawley29 wrote: »

This has to be a wind up.

If the passengers in the back are under 17/18 not sure which, you get the fine for each for not having a seatbelt. Not sure about what else could happen.

If they're over 17/18 they get the fine and more than likely told to walk the rest of the journey

Won't happen as my car doesn't move then everyone clicks in. I've a friend who I always have to remind:mad:

Toyotafanboi · 01-06-2018 6:32am

endacl wrote: »

Lives under a bridge.

I thought so too.

It may be a legal grey area OP but it really is a common sense answer, so I'm going to close this.

Is it legal to drive your friends in the back of a commersial vehicle?

Comments