New Import Duty/VAT Thread. Read Post #1 for Rules Updated 10/9/2024

Suckit · 06-09-2019 1:22pm

You can ring them and ask them where are they getting the custom fees from. It is possible they used their infamous :pac: volumetric calculator if the shipping cost wasn't marked clearly on the item.
Then you could point out to them that it falls under the negligent fees threshold even when shipping is included. You may have to contact the seller to prove shipping cost. I used to do that first, so it ws ready when I rang them.

I have found when dealing with them in the past, if you can point out to them and prove that it is an incorrect charge, before they have attempted to deliver it, they usually waive it, or amend any charges. Otherwise it will be up to you to chase down any refund from revenue, and you won't get back DHL handling fees.

Wing126 · 16-09-2019 12:06am

Is there some sort of ELI5 on how to figure out how to calculate customs?

I really do not understand what I'm doing when using the TARIC website.

mondeo · 12-10-2019 12:04pm

I'm buying a watch from china for $80 on ebay... how much would I expect to pay for customs if any ?

Thanks

whiterebel · 12-10-2019 1:34pm

MOD: See Post 1.

witnessmenow · 11-11-2019 11:17am

I got something from China that I paid $108 for, this was after a $15 discount.

When I got the bill from DHL they said that customs was to be VAT at the full amount, $123, as customs do not consider discounts. Is this right? The invoice from the seller does break it down as

Goods = x
Shipping = y
Discount = -$15

Total = $108

I paid $108 via paypal

Suckit · 11-11-2019 3:26pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

I got something from China that I paid $108 for, this was after a $15 discount.

When I got the bill from DHL they said that customs was to be VAT at the full amount, $123, as customs do not consider discounts. Is this right? The invoice from the seller does break it down as

Goods = x
Shipping = y
Discount = -$15

Total = $108

I paid $108 via paypal

I have never heard that customs do not consider discounts, it could be true, but the far more likely would be that the value of something is what you paid for it. So if you have a receipt and the price/value is marked clearly on the package, then that is the price of it.

But the seller having written it like that on the invoice may not have helped.

Email them with the receipt of the price you paid and maybe ask the seller to send you a receipt with the same. DHL will always go for the highest possible price.

scamalert · 11-11-2019 6:07pm

this used to be large case with arrow.com, when they ran discount deals on raspberry pi's costing under 25e, but full price would been 30ish, and many getting massive inflated invoices from DHL,fedex. anyway email your paypal invoice to them, or even ask seller to to the same, and to re calculate of it, as seems usual practice by them.

witnessmenow · 12-11-2019 4:47pm

Suckit wrote: »

I have never heard that customs do not consider discounts, it could be true, but the far more likely would be that the value of something is what you paid for it. So if you have a receipt and the price/value is marked clearly on the package, then that is the price of it.

But the seller having written it like that on the invoice may not have helped.

Email them with the receipt of the price you paid and maybe ask the seller to send you a receipt with the same. DHL will always go for the highest possible price.

I rang DHL and she had the exact invoice and said about discount thing. I needed the package sooner rather than later so I just paid the extra couple of euro.

Does anyone know a contact in customs who I can get clarification on this if it arises in the future?

Suckit · 12-11-2019 5:02pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

I rang DHL and she had the exact invoice and said about discount thing. I needed the package sooner rather than later so I just paid the extra couple of euro.

Does anyone know a contact in customs who I can get clarification on this if it arises in the future?

Here is the number 01 738 3676 - https://www.revenue.ie/en/contact-us/customs-ports-and-airports/customs-division.aspx

you could appeal it here - https://www.revenue.ie/en/customs-traders-and-agents/customs-appeals/index.aspx

whiterebel · 12-11-2019 5:37pm

Here is the official C&E line on declared, or non-declared, value for transport.

https://www.revenue.ie/en/customs-traders-and-agents/customs-electronic-systems/aep/ecustoms-notifications/2016/aep-notification-009-2016.pdf

j14 · 28-11-2019 12:16am

My post is similar to one a few posts above.
I buy from a website in the US and they have a rewards programme (think of Tesco Club points that you can build up and then use against a purchase).
I ordered an item for €250 plus €40 shipping.
There was a promotion on the site for free shipping that I availed of and I also used €100 worth of points to bring the total paid to the company €150 on my credit card.
I was charged duty on the full value of €290 (€250 plus €40 shipping).
I was told customs do not recognise free shipping promotions as and I quote, "the company had to pay something to shop it to you".
Was this a correct charge?
The invoice showed the full amount and the discounts applied but customs were not interested in talking to me and only wanted payment on the full €290.

ohnonotgmail · 28-11-2019 10:35am

j14 wrote: »

My post is similar to one a few posts above.
I buy from a website in the US and they have a rewards programme (think of Tesco Club points that you can build up and then use against a purchase).
I ordered an item for €250 plus €40 shipping.
There was a promotion on the site for free shipping that I availed of and I also used €100 worth of points to bring the total paid to the company €150 on my credit card.
I was charged duty on the full value of €290 (€250 plus €40 shipping).
I was told customs do not recognise free shipping promotions as and I quote, "the company had to pay something to shop it to you".
Was this a correct charge?
The invoice showed the full amount and the discounts applied but customs were not interested in talking to me and only wanted payment on the full €290.

whatever about the free shipping they are correct that they €100 worth of points being irrelevant when it comes to vat and duty. vat and duty is applied on the value of the goods imported. the goods you imported had a value of €250 so you pay vat and duty on that.

waterfaerie · 13-12-2019 4:22pm

I have a few orders coming and have a few questions I hope someone can answer.

1. I'm expecting some things to come with An Post that might have customs charges. Does the postman carry a card machine or do I need to keep some cash around?

2. I just had something stopped by DHL asking for proof of purchase as they thought the seller had undervalued it. I provided them with the proof and had to pay before the parcel was delivered. I've seen a lot of threads around about them doing that. I'm wondering how that compares to the other couriers? What is the procedure if something like that happens with a courier like fedex who usually bill after the fact?

3. I was horrified to find that DHL charge a percentage based fee for processing the customs. I knew they charge a fee on top of the actual VAT but I can't understand how they can charge a percentage since the value of the goods makes no difference to the amount of work they need to do. My order wasn't affected as it was small so I just paid the flat rate but it annoyed me when I read that they charge a percentage for higher value parcels. Can they get away with that?

4. Does anyone have a list of the different rates / fees that the different couriers charge for this "service" or can we create one here so shoppers can see them before selecting a courier? DHL's fee is €14.50 or 2.5% of the customs charge, whichever is higher.

5. Finally, is it possible to deal with customs directly and pay anything due in advance of the parcel arriving so that the couriers can't rob you with their administration fees? My recent order was approximately €30 including shipping, so approximately €7 was due in VAT but I had to pay over €21 to DHL.

Thanks if you can answer any of these.

ohnonotgmail · 13-12-2019 4:29pm

waterfaerie wrote: »

I have a few orders coming and have a few questions I hope someone can answer.

1. I'm expecting some things to come with An Post that might have customs charges. Does the postman carry a card machine or do I need to keep some cash around?

2. I just had something stopped by DHL asking for proof of purchase as they thought the seller had undervalued it. I provided them with the proof and had to pay before the parcel was delivered. I've seen a lot of threads around about them doing that. I'm wondering how that compares to the other couriers? What is the procedure if something like that happens with a courier like fedex who usually bill after the fact?

3. I was horrified to find that DHL charge a percentage based fee for processing the customs. I knew they charge a fee on top of the actual VAT but I can't understand how they can charge a percentage since the value of the goods makes no difference to the amount of work they need to do. My order wasn't affected as it was small so I just paid the flat rate but it annoyed me when I read that they charge a percentage for higher value parcels. Can they get away with that?

4. Does anyone have a list of the different rates / fees that the different couriers charge for this "service" or can we create one here so shoppers can see them before selecting a courier? DHL's fee is €14.50 or 2.5% of the customs charge, whichever is higher.

5. Finally, is it possible to deal with customs directly and pay anything due in advance of the parcel arriving so that the couriers can't rob you with their administration fees? My recent order was approximately €30 including shipping, so approximately €7 was due in VAT but I had to pay over €21 to DHL.

Thanks if you can answer any of these.

1. Cash only. and they dont carry change

2. They send you a bill for what customs thinks it is worth and then you argue the toss with them.

3. Never paid more than the standard charge and i have never heard of a personal import being charged more. Are you sure the charges you were looking at were not business customers?

5. Not that i know of. and those figures look way off.

waterfaerie · 13-12-2019 4:38pm

ohnonotgmail wrote: »

Are you sure the charges you were looking at were not business customers?

Fairly sure. Here's the document.

ohnonotgmail wrote: »

those figures look way off.

In what way do they look way off? 23% of €30 is €6.90. €6.90 VAT + €14.50 DHL fee = €21.40

ohnonotgmail · 13-12-2019 4:43pm

waterfaerie wrote: »

Fairly sure. Here's the document.

Perhaps you can quote the section of that document you are referring to. Its a big document. It also seems to be targetted at people sending parcels.

waterfaerie · 13-12-2019 4:48pm

I just use search to find what I'm looking for in a large document but it's on page 9. under Customs Services.

whiterebel · 14-12-2019 1:27am

The couriers outlay the VAT and/or duty on your behalf, hence the charge based on value, with a minimum. They are fairly reasonable on customs clearance charges compared to some specialist companies who charge €40/50 per single line import entry.

DECEiFER · 09-01-2020 12:52am

Hi all. A friend has sent over a gift from the US, which is in transit, started to pass through Customs in Portlaoise yesterday lunchtime and has an "ITEM IN DEPOT" status as of earlier this evening. I have a feeling Customs are going to charge me (the value is way over the threshold for VAT). It will be duty-free as it's a computer component, but in terms of the value for VAT calculation, the item was bought on Amazon.com and I'm told the state sales tax was already paid on it. So my question is, if I got a copy of the invoice for Customs from my friend, would they then assess the VAT based on the pre-sales tax value or is the full value after tax (paid in the US) what they'd use? If it's the latter, I'll keep my mouth shut as I believe declared value on the package is $10 less than the price paid with tax, as he just slapped a rounded down to the nearest 100 value on the declaration.

He assumed wrongly that marking it as a gift would make it exempt, otherwise it probably would have worked out better to purchase it within the EU. I would have assumed the same, to be honest. There goes any ideas of using Amazon.com instead of .co.uk to get items for less shipped through him, which I had been considering. You live and learn...

Plus, I'd love to know their currency conversion rates. I presume An Post would show up with a complete breakdown for every cent of what would be charged?

sniper_samurai · 09-01-2020 1:11am

DECEiFER wrote: »

Hi all. A friend has sent over a gift from the US, which is in transit, started to pass through Customs in Portlaoise yesterday lunchtime and has an "ITEM IN DEPOT" status as of earlier this evening. I have a feeling Customs are going to charge me (the value is way over the threshold for VAT). It will be duty-free as it's a computer component, but in terms of the value for VAT calculation, the item was bought on Amazon.com and I'm told the state sales tax was already paid on it. So my question is, if I got a copy of the invoice for Customs from my friend, would they then assess the VAT based on the pre-sales tax value or is the full value after tax (paid in the US) what they'd use? If it's the latter, I'll keep my mouth shut as I believe declared value on the package is $10 less than the price paid with tax, as he just slapped a rounded down to the nearest 100 value on the declaration.

He assumed wrongly that marking it as a gift would make it exempt, otherwise it probably would have worked out better to purchase it within the EU. I would have assumed the same, to be honest. There goes any ideas of using Amazon.com instead of .co.uk to get items for less shipped through him, which I had been considering. You live and learn...

Plus, I'd love to know their currency conversion rates. I presume An Post would show up with a complete breakdown for every cent of what would be charged?

An Post will charge you the VAT on the item, including shipping cost if declared, plus €10.

If buying from Amazon US you are much better off buying directly, or in this case having your friend ship it directly as you pre-pay the vat charge avoiding the extra €10 An Post fee. Amazon will refund the customs charge if no fee was applied upon entry.

DECEiFER · 09-01-2020 1:19am

sniper_samurai wrote: »

An Post will charge you the VAT on the item, including shipping cost if declared, plus €10.

If buying from Amazon US you are much better off buying directly, or in this case having your friend ship it directly as you pre-pay the vat charge avoiding the extra €10 An Post fee. Amazon will refund the customs charge if no fee was applied upon entry.

Excellent advice - thank you.

Do you happen to know if Customs would use the pre-sales tax (US) value or include the sales tax for the VAT calculation?

Suckit · 09-01-2020 1:55am

https://www.revenue.ie/en/importing-vehicles-duty-free-allowances/gifts-and-consignments-of-low-value/what-rate-of-customs-duty-is-charged-on-gift-consignments.aspx

What rate of Customs Duty is charged on gift consignments?

If the total value of your gift consignment does not exceed €700, a flat rate of 2.5% Customs Duty may be applied. This flat rate applies to Customs Duty only, not to Value-Added Tax (VAT) or Excise Duty. In calculating whether the €700 limit is exceeded, the following should be excluded:
the value of any individual item(s) which qualify under the €45 gift relief allowance

the value of any items not subject to Customs Duty

and

the value of tobacco products.

The importer may choose to have the goods charged at the normal rate of Customs Duty that applies.
If the total value of your gift consignment exceeds €700, the ‘normal’ rates of Customs Duty will apply to each item in the consignment.

whiterebel · 09-01-2020 12:02pm

DECEiFER wrote: »

Excellent advice - thank you.

Do you happen to know if Customs would use the pre-sales tax (US) value or include the sales tax for the VAT calculation?

Mod: if you intend to import again, please read through the first post in this thread, and the forum charter. Thanks

styron · 11-01-2020 1:32pm

A heads up that as of next January all 'third county' (ie. non-EU) consignments are due to be liable for 23% import VAT:

Customs Manual on Import VAT pg.15:

The plan appears to be that non-EU sites are to collect and forward the appropriate VAT to each State on all (non-excise) transactions under €150
with Customs declarations no longer required.

Sales of goods B2C from outside the EU into the EU (imports)

Besides being extended to EU-international sales, MOSS will also be implemented for certain B2C imports. It will apply for products not subject to excise duties with a value of less than EUR 150 per import. Such imports will be taxed at the rate of the Member State of the customer.
Consequently, the existing VAT exemption for consignments with a value of less than EUR 22 will be abolished. While EU businesses have to apply VAT regardless of the value of the goods sold, imported goods can currently still benefit from this VAT exemption. The EU claims that import values are often underdeclared for the purpose of avoiding the tax. The removal of the exemption is hence also an action to combat VAT fraud.
In the case of imported goods subject to excise duties or with a value exceeding EUR 150, a full customs declaration will still be required.
Electronic marketplaces

As of 1 January 2021, electronic marketplaces including platforms or portals that facilitate either intracommunity distance sales by businesses not established in the EU, or facilitate distance sales of goods imported into the EU with a value not exceeding EUR 150, will be liable to pay VAT in the Member State where the customer is located. According to the new VAT rules, such marketplaces will be deemed commissionaires who have bought and now sell the products traded on their platforms.

https://blog.kpmg.ch/tax-legal-news/new-eu-vat-system-digital-economy-2019-2021/

whiterebel · 11-01-2020 6:57pm

Just an update on Customs Clearance charges for FedEx: From 1st January the charge to pay out VAT/Duty and do the customs entry will be 2.5% of the amount paid out, with a €15 Minimum, up from the previous €12.50.

Sam the Sham · 16-01-2020 1:14pm

In the past, I've found An Post's enforcement of duties/VAT on small parcels/packets to be virtually non-existent. I don't usually order anything from outside the EU but on those occasions when I did, I found that small items that had values on the customs form that were clearly above €26 (but below €150) were not being charged VAT. Note, I'm not saying that this state of affairs was desirable, just that I often wondered whether I had somehow misunderstood some portion of what was, to me, pretty arcane law regarding duties and tariffs on which information was hard to find. I once waded through the TARIC database and couldn't find anything of use to me to determine a simple duty rate.

I now get the distinct impression from one delivery received this week (a wallet from the US, not from Amazon) that this may be changing, as it was worth a total of $60 or so and the postman came to me asking for €20 and change (cash, of course) in duties, VAT, and An Post's administrative fee. (As per post #1 in this thread: I am most certainly not asking anyone to calculate these charges for me; I assume that whatever the postman was asking for was accurate).

Has something changed recently (perhaps in the new year) or am I just clueless about how any of this works? Probably the latter, I freely admit.

ohnonotgmail · 16-01-2020 1:21pm

In my experience it depends where the parcel is coming from. If it is something from china they dont tend to bother. I think the volume is too much for them. For stuff from the US i find they look for the VAT more often.

sniper_samurai · 16-01-2020 1:22pm

Sam the Sham wrote: »

In the past, I've found An Post's enforcement of duties/VAT on small parcels/packets to be virtually non-existent. I don't usually order anything from outside the EU but on those occasions when I did, I found that small items that had values on the customs form that were clearly above €26 (but below €150) were not being charged VAT. Note, I'm not saying that this state of affairs was desirable, just that I often wondered whether I had somehow misunderstood some portion of what was, to me, pretty arcane law regarding duties and tariffs on which information was hard to find. I once waded through the TARIC database and couldn't find anything of use to me to determine a simple duty rate.

I now get the distinct impression from one delivery received this week (a wallet from the US, not from Amazon) that this may be changing, as it was worth a total of $60 or so and the postman came to me asking for €20 and change (cash, of course) in duties, VAT, and An Post's administrative fee. (As per post #1 in this thread: I am most certainly not asking anyone to calculate these charges for me; I assume that whatever the postman was asking for was accurate).

Has something changed recently (perhaps in the new year) or am I just clueless about how any of this works? Probably the latter, I freely admit.

Not really. It is hit or miss whether customs grabs it from the normal post, but I find there is usually a significantly higher chance of packages having customs charges November-January for the Christmas/Sales period.

Suckit · 16-01-2020 1:45pm

Often items from China are marked at a lower price or take an indirect route to your postal address to try and avoid fees. Channel Islands of do the same.
I haven't ever received an item from the States without having to pay, unless tariffs were prepaid.

witnessmenow · 28-01-2020 8:26am

I just made an order of electronic components from China this morning, and I have a question about the future VAT bill I will get

The goods were $310 , Shipping is valued at $127 , but it was free because I spent over $300 on goods. Summary of receipt below

Am I liable for the tax on the shipping? The amount I paid was $310. The discount on shipping is a general offer and is not specific to me.

Goods are to be delivered by Fedex

Thanks

Trick of the Tail · 28-01-2020 10:02am

FedEx will examine the commercial invoice which should be in a pouch on the outside of the package. Assuming that carries the info you've mentioned above, you'll be charged duty on the total you paid, then VAT on the duty-paid figure.

The amount of duty depends upon the commodity code mentioned on the invoice - if none is included Customs will guess. Well, FedEx's clearing agents will handle it, not Customs themselves.

Its always useful to spend a little time to find the correct commodity code for the goods and tell the sender to put this on the commercial invoice. For example, electronic capacitors are 8532300000.

This page explains it:

https://www.revenue.ie/en/importing-vehicles-duty-free-allowances/buying-of-goods-online-for-personal-use/buying-goods-from-outside-the-eu.aspx

witnessmenow · 28-01-2020 10:10am

Thank you, very helpful!

The code you gave covers $19 of my order anyways :P

Do you have any advise on how to find the other codes? I've ended up on this page, but it doesn't seem to have a way of looking anything up

https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/dds2/taric/taric_consultation.jsp?Lang=en

Trick of the Tail · 28-01-2020 10:20am

witnessmenow wrote: »

Thank you, very helpful!

The code you gave covers $19 of my order anyways :P

Do you have any advise on how to find the other codes? I've ended up on this page, but it doesn't seem to have a way of looking anything up

https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/dds2/taric/taric_consultation.jsp?Lang=en

Click on Browse the Nomenclature. Be prepared for a long walk!

https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/dds2/taric/taric_consultation.jsp?Lang=en&Expand=true&SimDate=20200128

whiterebel · 28-01-2020 7:03pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

I just made an order of electronic components from China this morning, and I have a question about the future VAT bill I will get

The goods were $310 , Shipping is valued at $127 , but it was free because I spent over $300 on goods. Summary of receipt below

Am I liable for the tax on the shipping? The amount I paid was $310. The discount on shipping is a general offer and is not specific to me.

Goods are to be delivered by Fedex

Thanks

I would email revenue and get the correct answer, and then be prepared is case FedEx do it incorrectly.

andrewfaulk · 28-01-2020 9:55pm

whiterebel wrote: »

I would email revenue and get the correct answer, and then be prepared is case FedEx do it incorrectly.

Discounts aren’t included when completing a customs entry.. It’s based on the landed value of the goods, not the price you apparently paid..

Otherwise you could get the seller to say you paid $1 for the goods to avoid duty and Vat

Rael · 08-02-2020 11:52pm

Out of interest, has anyone got anything from the UK since Brexit. If so, did they charge you VAT etc?

ohnonotgmail · 08-02-2020 11:55pm

Rael wrote: »

Out of interest, has anyone got anything from the UK since Brexit. If so, did they charge you VAT etc?

nothing has changed in relation to importing from the UK. Nothing will change until Jan 1st next year at the earliest but nobody has the foggiest if there will be changes and what those possible changes will be.

LillyIsland · 23-02-2020 7:36pm

Quick query. I got something on Indiegogo worth about €550 which will be sent from Germany in the next few weeks. It says on the product page:

"VAT not included in price and will be determined by country on delivery. Backers are responsible for these costs (VAT, duties, taxes, etc) on delivery."

Obiously it won't be liable for customs duty as it's coming from an EU country, but it will be for VAT.

Am I likely to get away without paying this though? Or is it likely customs will catch it? It will be coming in a box about half the size of a shoe box.

whiterebel · 23-02-2020 7:59pm

By the looks of it they will add VAT when you are completing the order.

witnessmenow · 12-03-2020 1:31pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

I just made an order of electronic components from China this morning, and I have a question about the future VAT bill I will get

The goods were $310 , Shipping is valued at $127 , but it was free because I spent over $300 on goods. Summary of receipt below

Am I liable for the tax on the shipping? The amount I paid was $310. The discount on shipping is a general offer and is not specific to me.

Goods are to be delivered by Fedex

Thanks

Goods received about 3/4 weeks ago, Fedex bill came today.

Unsurprisingly the amount they charged on VAT (~E90) seems to be based on Shipping as well. I did reach out to Revenue a few weeks ago and they did advise I should only be liable for what I paid. I've reached out to Fedex on this.

What was surprising is on top of the E15 administration fee (which I expected, although it is invoiced as "Advancement Fee") there is an "Additional line items" charge of E16 that I have no idea what that is, also querying that.

andrewfaulk wrote: »

Discounts aren’t included when completing a customs entry.. It’s based on the landed value of the goods, not the price you apparently paid..

Otherwise you could get the seller to say you paid $1 for the goods to avoid duty and Vat

That's fine for an Apple Mac where you can walk into a shop and see the price of one, but I'm not sure where they are going to get reference prices for Electronic components and connectors, I can't buy them here. There isn't a reference, so it has to be based on the invoice amount.

Saying it doesn't apply to discounts because you get get the seller to say it was $1 doesn't make sense, it would be easier to just get them to change the entire invoice amount than make up a fake discount. I can also provide proof how much I paid if required.

ohnonotgmail · 12-03-2020 1:37pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

Goods received about 3/4 weeks ago, Fedex bill came today.

Unsurprisingly the amount they charged on VAT (~E90) seems to be based on Shipping as well. I did reach out to Revenue a few weeks ago and they did advise I should only be liable for what I paid. I've reached out to Fedex on this.

What was surprising is on top of the E15 administration fee (which I expected, although it is invoiced as "Advancement Fee") there is an "Additional line items" charge of E16 that I have no idea what that is, also querying that.

That's fine for an Apple Mac where you can walk into a shop and see the price of one, but I'm not sure where they are going to get reference prices for Electronic components and connectors, I can't buy them here. There isn't a reference, so it has to be based on the invoice amount.

Saying it doesn't apply to discounts because you get get the seller to say it was $1 doesn't make sense, it would be easier to just get them to change the entire invoice amount than make up a fake discount. I can also provide proof how much I paid if required.

They dont care how much you paid. you received a discount and have admitted as much so they will base the vat/duty based on the landed value of the goods.

witnessmenow · 12-03-2020 3:10pm

ohnonotgmail wrote: »

They dont care how much you paid. you received a discount and have admitted as much so they will base the vat/duty based on the landed value of the goods.

Revenue disagrees with you

My email:

I made an order of electronics components to the value of $313. As the order was over $300, I qualified for free shipping. The invoice (attached) lists the Freight Cost as $127, but applies a discount of $129. The total I paid was $311.45

My question is, is the total price I paid the value of what the VAT would be applied on?

The relevant part of their response:

Customs Duty is chargeable on the customs value of the goods, this is the Cost plus Insurance plus Freight (CIF) cost of your goods.

VAT is chargeable at the same rate as applies to the sale within Ireland of similar goods. The value of the goods for VAT purposes is their value for customs purposes increased by the amount of any duty or other tax (but not including VAT) payable and any other transport, handling or insurance costs between entry into the EU and delivery to their final destination. The standard rate of VAT is 23%. So to answer your specific question, yes VAT is applied to the total you paid plus the Customs Duty.

ohnonotgmail · 12-03-2020 3:11pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

Revenue disagrees with you

My email:

The relevant part of their response:

yeah i'm not sure that says what you think it says.

witnessmenow · 12-03-2020 3:14pm

ohnonotgmail wrote: »

yeah i'm not sure that says what you think it says.

VAT is applied to the total you paid plus the Customs Duty.

How do you interpret that? Seems pretty clear to me

whiterebel · 12-03-2020 7:17pm

The Shipper has shown the freight amount on it, they should have shown zero. Customs are looking at it now, wondering who gives free shipping to almost 50% of the value of the material. Additional line items are other tariff codes for the different products. They might attract different rates of duty and must be separated on the customs entry.

Suckit · 12-03-2020 10:37pm

I had a similar issue about 3 years ago. There was a lot of to-ing and fro-ing.
I was lucky in in some ways that it was fedex, as I already had the goods.
In the end I think I had to email the store I bought it from and as them to send me a new invoice for the final price paid. I also had to match it with a screenshot of my bank account at the same date/seller.
My issue was free shipping internationally for all items over $150, which I got, but they had the price of the shipping (that they paid) on the outside of the parcel.
I argued my case for almost three weeks.
IIRC there was a question over who paid the shipping separately, but there was no way to prove it was me (which it wasn't).

I believe the VAT on items entering Ireland is the total price of the item (incl. shipping) that the buyer paid. But the courier companies will (sometimes correctly) ask questions first.
Which is what seems to be happening in this instance. If you can prove the total that you paid is what you say it is, with new invoice and bank statement they will likely realise that.
They most likely haven't looked too deep into your case as they get a lot of them, and a lot chancing their arms, along with a lot that are incorrectly worked out.

Suckit · 12-03-2020 10:45pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

Revenue disagrees with you

My email:

The relevant part of their response:

To me, that reads like they are just saying "Yes, you pay vat on the total price you paid to get the item(s) delivered to Ireland."
But they are not reading/replying to your case individually about the price. They don't seem to be aware that you paid $311.45 but are getting charged vat for $438.45.
I would ring instead of emailing, and stress that the price you paid in total, is $127 less than the price that they are charging vat on.

witnessmenow · 13-03-2020 9:58am

whiterebel wrote: »

The Shipper has shown the freight amount on it, they should have shown zero. Customs are looking at it now, wondering who gives free shipping to almost 50% of the value of the material. Additional line items are other tariff codes for the different products. They might attract different rates of duty and must be separated on the customs entry.

There is a seperate line for Duty, 60c. I have no idea why they wouldn't give more detail on what the "Additional Line Items" is, it may as well be called "Random Extra charge". Like if its a fee for doing the Duty entry, "Duty fee calculation fee" or something might be a better name!

Kind of an aside, the offer ended up working in my favor quite a lot. I was buying cheap heavy things (connectors etc) while I guess normally people would be buying more expensive lighter things like components and ICs etc, that's how it ended up being such a large percentage.

Suckit wrote: »

To me, that reads like they are just saying "Yes, you pay vat on the total price you paid to get the item(s) delivered to Ireland."
But they are not reading/replying to your case individually about the price. They don't seem to be aware that you paid $311.45 but are getting charged vat for $438.45.
I would ring instead of emailing, and stress that the price you paid in total, is $127 less than the price that they are charging vat on.

I emailed them before I got my package even so Fedex had not sent me the bill yet. I did send the original Invoice to them though.

When you say ring though, is it Fedex or Revenue you are talking about?

Similar to your previous situation, I already have the goods which makes it a bit easier. I've no plans to drag it out any longer than it needs to, but there isn't much incentive for me to just cave and pay it unless it's clear that I'm in the wrong.

Suckit · 13-03-2020 7:36pm

witnessmenow wrote: »

When you say ring though, is it Fedex or Revenue you are talking about?

Similar to your previous situation, I already have the goods which makes it a bit easier. I've no plans to drag it out any longer than it needs to, but there isn't much incentive for me to just cave and pay it unless it's clear that I'm in the wrong.

Fedex, and tell them that you will forward them the correct invoice. The invoice with the $127 shipping included is not correct, as you did not pay that.
It shouldn't take long once you can cut away all the crap and extra phonecalls I had to make. If I had done that at the start it would have been ammended then.

ED E · 03-04-2020 4:11pm

Complete bollix invoice from DHL. Enjoy delivering it back to the middle east lads.

New Import Duty/VAT Thread. Read Post #1 for Rules Updated 10/9/2024

Comments