Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Freemasons: Evil secret society or misunderstood nice guys...

1356711

Comments

  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    Wow, this link below is absolutely fascinating.
    http://www.ulster-scots.co.uk/docs/orange/orangeism%20compared%20with%20freemasonry.htm

    Its a comparision of the Orange Order and The Freemasons (who most people seem to think are connected in some way, but who appear to not be particularly friendly to each other).

    Its written from the slant of the Orange Order being the superior of the two (though it claims to even handed).

    Whats fascinating is that all the things they claim freemasonry is worse then the OO for, are things I admire now about them!
    (For example they berate them for not being political and involving themselves in the catholic v protestant thing, and for letting muslims, jews and "papists" in... where as the OO is strictly Protestant!).

    I dunno it just tickled my funny bone that an article written by people I wouldnt have a great deal of time for, castigating the FM makes me think better of the FM...

    As Bill Hicks says: Its irony at a base level but you can still get a laugh from it....

    DeV.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 43,045 ✭✭✭✭Nevyn


    Thead stands back as all the Devore posts compact uppon themselves , and the engry from them sprials into a wormhole.


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    Yeah, thead, this stuff runs around in my head quite a bit. I guess I've never brought it to Boards before because, well , Boards occupies a different area of my brain. But as a mathematician I like to tease this stuff out.

    Ironically its only since I started this (what seems eons ago but in reality its less then a month) that i've really gained a clarity on what I want from my spirituality and my morality.

    As for FM's , well I opened this Pandoras box, I cant really decide I want to stop just because I dont like the answers dont fit my prejudice. Thats the most uncomfortable thing, I think I was wrong and I hate being wrong. :)

    DeV.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,838 ✭✭✭DapperGent


    /DeVore banging two bits of sub-critical plutonium together to keep warm.


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    I get the reference (and isnt it Uranium 235 that is banged together to make bigbaddaboom) but I dont understand?

    You think I'm about to explode or that I'm playing with fire or that everything is going to go critical soon? *raises one eyebrow* :)

    HMmmm, you might be right hahah...

    DeV.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,314 ✭✭✭Talliesin


    One thing that intrigues me about these conspiracy theories is how good they are at distracting a certain type of mentality that would be dangerous if they checked their facts, and potentially discredits some genuine whistle-blowers.

    When you think of some of the ****ed up stuff governments have gotten up to in the past (from bribes for re-zoning land, through the forced sterilisation campaign in Virginia all the way up to the Shoah) I can see a certian benefit to the real abusers of power if people spend more time looking for 12' reptilian masons receiving the lyrics for Marilyn Manson's next album from their UFO-bound Satanic overlords and less time working out just how could that junior minister afford his new yaught.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 43,045 ✭✭✭✭Nevyn


    Originally posted by DeVore
    I think I was wrong and I hate being wrong. :)

    DeV.

    Y'know that is such a handy lil quote I may file that away for further reference :)

    As for over obessing well the thing is you do have a set of expectations but you dont seem any closer to proving them one was or the other and the more you learn the more fascinated you become and it will drive you demeneted ( or more demented then you are ).

    /Thead wonders how many San points Dev has left.

    Maybe you should rest that part of your brain a lil then rerurn and review what you have learned .


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    You presume I *started* with San Points :p

    Wouldnt it be GREAT if you could just switch off your brain and not think about stuff like this at 3am! God I'd love that.
    I'm going to go home, enjoy xmas with my family, hug my nephew and nieces and stuff myself with turkey.
    Then next year I'm going to go looking for more stuff that I've been wrong about. :)

    DeV.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 43,045 ✭✭✭✭Nevyn


    I think you may have a very busy new years Dev but at least it wont be boring :)


  • Registered Users Posts: 524 ✭✭✭silverski


    Dev.

    This is one of the most interesting posts that I have seen in long time......

    I attended one of the above schools mentioned.......

    And one of my closest friends is a FM. although I am not. although I do maintain a high level of curiosity.


    And yes anyone can visit the FM Building in Molesworth street..

    I do understand from him that you have to be introduced to the FM's if you express an interest in join.

    oops... just saw the link to web site listed above, but if you are introduced by existing memebers it would assist your application....

    Also I understand that you have to have an income....
    but that joining the FM's would not gain you any edge in business. but well noted earlier that memebers do have to uphold other members, the Interview being case in point. It is a grey area as far as I can see....

    And more interestingly any religious question that I have had I have found his answers to be very informative and not bias.

    I am at the present moment in a area of life that is demanding many questions and seeking many answers....


    Similar to seeing a very large jigsaw and not having the picture on the box as a reference...

    The FM's have not changed my friend in anyway.

    but please do ask me any questions and perhaps he would consider answering them...

    as with all organistions in the world there will always be conspiracy theories abound.....


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Well, may as well jump in with my 2 cents..

    I am a Freemason, and have been for 14 years. I was initiated at the age of 21, and have enjoyed my time in the Order. I am agnostic, born Catholic, and have sat in my Lodge with Protestants of all stripes, Catholics, and Muslims. Most of what is held up as 'truth' about Freemasons is of course rubbish..but it sure makes for a good laugh! Anyone want to ask questions I'm happy to answer from what I know..I'm no historian, but I have done some research into the Order. DeVore..happy to see you there anytime!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    I believe your instincts were absolutely correct to start with DeVore.

    The issues have never been that Freemasons have been involved in anything nasty or bad per se. Most people know that they are essentially a schoolboy-like organisation that get more of their kicks out of being secret and having secret and peculiar rituals.

    The issues that have caused most negativity over the decades have been a) their secretiveness and b) their track record of nepotism.

    Secret organisations that operate such a nepotistic system in their work and business life are a corrupting presence in our society and should be rooted out wherever they exist. Membership of a society with this kind of track record is good grounds for suspician, lack of trust and in my opinion exclusion. I have had two ocassions in the past, both about twelve years ago, where I was assessing people for senior positions in business and discovered that applicants were FMs. I excluded them on both occasions as it is a totally inappropriate activity for such a position of responsibility. I am aware of several colleagues of mine that did the same.

    What they do in their 'club' is of no consequence or interest to 99% of us. What they do in society is.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    I think Chills response is typical of the kneejerk attitude from those who haven't found out about Freemasonry.

    The Order is neither secret nor secretive; you'll find a Lodge building in every large city, and many towns which is open to visitors and in no way hidden. We're in the phonebook! Back in the '50s and '60s, Masonic meetings were listed in local papers as social events,as were our calendars of events and functions. It is only with the Vaticans renewed objections to an organisation which does not insist all its members recognise Jesus Christ that many Catholic members are reluctant to promote their membership; and with the rise in visiblity of the Orange Order, which apes the appearance of Freemasnry, that Masons in general are reluctant to visibly parade our Order. Nonetheless Masonic works are still strong in the background mof society; just ask the Altzheimers Society (take a look at the crest on the side of the ambulances we gave them), The Salvation Army, the SIMON community, womens' shelters throughout Dublin, and many outreach programs for children on the streets in Dublin. We support all these, and many more charitable causes, both financially and with manpower, not secretly, but quietly.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    As for nepotism, the rules of the Order require that a Brother may only be preferred over another person where each is entirely equal in all respects. People will always prefer other people they know already, because they have a history and common ground. This is the case with any group, whether it be a golf club or a bunch of gamers. At least we define where this preferment is inappropriate!

    I agree; what we do in our club is of little consequence to anyone. What we do in society is; check it out. You'll be surprised how much effort we put into trying to make society better for everyone.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    Absolam's response is typical of most FMs. An astonishing expectation that people will buy their lame stories about public buildings and the old 'we're in the book' line....
    The fact remains as true and valid today as ever before that the FMs are still essentially a closed and secretive organisation which practices nepotism at all levelswhenever it can possibly get away with it. It pays lips service to society's views of nepotism and the policy of deny deny deny is at the core of their very existence.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Wow..now you know why people don't walk around saying 'I'm a Freemason'!
    It's lame that we exist in public view? Or do you think we have secret buildings and phone numbers as well?
    If we're a closed society we'll really have to review that 'come on in and ask to join' policy that previous posters have noted....
    As for secretive, well, if you don't know it, we must be keeping it secret, right? Because, otherwise, you'd know it.......hmmmm..or maybe it's all in your imagination? More / less likely than a worldwide conspiracy to keep you in the dark?
    As for nepotism, well, no more and probably no less than The Lions, The Rotary Club, the Boy Scouts, Oxford alumni etc..and perhaps a neccesary leveling of the field against people who pursue a deliberate anti-masonic promotions policy?
    When the paranoids come calling, we do have to deny deny deny, after all, it's what everyone does when the allegations are false!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,838 ✭✭✭DapperGent


    There was some Masons on one of the godawful daytime RTE chat thingies today.

    Seemed like nice lads. I bet when the close the meeting doors they crack open a keg and put on some porno.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Well..perhaps a small sherry and a musical..............:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,335 ✭✭✭Cake Fiend


    Originally posted by chill
    I excluded them on both occasions as it is a totally inappropriate activity for such a position of responsibility. I am aware of several colleagues of mine that did the same.

    You denied people promotions purely on their membership of a boys' club?

    That's insane.

    And you complain that the FMs have inappropriate hiring biases? :rolleyes:


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    Originally posted by Sico
    You denied people promotions purely on their membership of a boys' club?

    That's insane.

    Dead right I did.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    dead right I did

    I sort of get the impression you have a more personal axe to grind with Freemasonry than you've already revealed. Care to discuss it?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    Originally posted by Absolam
    I sort of get the impression you have a more personal axe to grind with Freemasonry than you've already revealed. Care to discuss it?

    Nope... nothing more complicated than taking a cold look at their club and their documented behaviour and taking a view on that as regards potential for senior management. I have no axe, no history with them, no grudge.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 20 ganam


    Interesting discussion. While not wanting to digress, I have to say that chill's actions in his work sends a... ahem.. chill down my spine.

    This is the reason there are LAWS against discrimination. You seem to be proud of what you've done chill but really you're just lucky.

    Lucky that the people you discriminated against (illegally IMO) did not take legal action.

    With respect, you have a strange sense of right and wrong. You say no to freemasons, but yes to breaking the law.

    Ganam


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,876 ✭✭✭Borzoi


    Interestingly, Chill's discrimination would not appear to be covered by the Equality Act, though in my opinion it would be similar to not accepting applicants from a particular golf club, or university etc


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    Originally posted by ganam

    With respect, you have a strange sense of right and wrong. You say no to freemasons, but yes to breaking the law.

    Ganam

    What law did I and do others I know and knew break ?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 576 ✭✭✭chill


    Originally posted by Borzoi
    Interestingly, Chill's discrimination would not appear to be covered by the Equality Act, though in my opinion it would be similar to not accepting applicants from a particular golf club, or university etc
    I agree no law is broken. Also it is not similar to such a golf club membership. It is based on the assessment of such a club as the FMs as being a club that is documented over time as indulging in practices and behaviours that are inconsistent with senior management positions. That is a perfectly legal and legitimate assessment and decision to make.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    I would think basing your business decisions on hearsay rather than the candidates abilities makes no business sense, but it can only be your loss. For the record, I know many 'senior management' who are Freemasons, as it is an organisation which does atrract a fair amount of achievement-oriented individuals. And historically, it seems many Freemasons have held senior management positions quite successfully...going right back to the likes of George Washington.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,876 ✭✭✭Borzoi


    Did anyone (particularly Dev) happen to watch the Would You Belive documentary on RTE last week?

    Details here

    To the casual observer it did seem to take a balanced view on Freemasonry, but I'm curious as to others reactions - particularly the brothers down at the lodge.


  • Posts: 0 [Deleted User]


    Originally posted by DapperGent
    There was some Masons on one of the godawful daytime RTE chat thingies today.

    Seemed like nice lads. I bet when the close the meeting doors they crack open a keg and put on some porno.
    I didn't get that impression from watching the Would you believe programme :D

    They seem harmless,yet very quirky. I don't doubt that they help each other out in life, business and whatever and have the connections to do so.

    I'm curious about the apparent conflict of interest between their christianity ( The King James Bible being prominent at the meetings ) and the non Christain /pagan symbolism.
    There was a COI minister interviewed for instance who was a member who surely , must be aware of the combination three Gods that was being mentioned.
    I'm presuming also that most members are protestant , even though the membership is open to all-Am I correct in that assumtion?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,549 ✭✭✭The Brigadier


    The use of the King James bible is purely a tool to use in telling moral tales.

    The masons have a lot of pomp and ceremony, nothing more.

    I found the show to be fairly well presented. Unfortunatly I found the guy interviewed as an expert on the masonic order to be a little bit paranoid.

    One gripe that catholics have is the fact that a supreme being is not named. According to Catholic doctrine you must not call God by any other name. I find this idea to be more unsettling than anything proffered by freemasonry.

    Religion has caused more wars in the history of Man than anything else. Surely allowing men to come together as brothers regardless of their religion, and acting in a moral manner is more beneficial than insisting they all respect Catholic teachings and refer to the Supreme being as God as there can be no other?


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,414 ✭✭✭LoneGunM@n


    To start with I have to say that this is one of the most intriguing threads I've ever read on boards ... thanks Dev, I've just spent almost 2 hours [of work] reading through this thread [& the associated links] ... most productive 2 hours I've had in ages :D

    In relation to my stance on the freemasons, I don't really have 1! I don't know any freemasons or @ least if I do, they have never informed me of the fact. I'm just one more of the un-informed people who have had there perceptions moulded by the media, church, peers etc ... shame on me!

    Although I have always been a firm believer of if something is secret it can't be good, the whole idea of a secret society does lend to excitement.

    My only real knowledge, & I say knowledge in the loosest of terms, comes from my father & of course the aforementioned episode of the Simpsons [which does give some level of understanding to why Steve Guttenberg was a star :D].

    Of course, I have like most of us heard the conspiracy theories that have attached themselves to the freemasons, but I suppose like everything else, when an answer can't be found or the answer provided doesn't really hold water, we [society as a whole] try to pin it to those who are less transparent in their dealings than we would like!!

    It looks like I'll probably be the last poster to this thread, since Dev hasn't given any more insight he may have gleaned in a while, so this reply is more for me being able to voice my thoughts rather than recommencing the topic!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 18,484 ✭✭✭✭Stephen


    One question:

    Why do the freemasons not allow atheists to join? Atheists can be just as morally minded as the religious.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,414 ✭✭✭LoneGunM@n


    Originally posted by Stephen
    Why do the freemasons not allow atheists to join? Atheists can be just as morally minded as the religious.

    AFAIK to be a freemason, one must believe in a high being (i.e. God, Allah, Buddha etc.)

    See http://www.boards.ie/vbulletin/showthread.php?postid=655322#post655322


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    Dont worry I havent been abducted by aliens yet. I just havent had the time to post a decent reply on the topic.

    DeV.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,335 ✭✭✭Cake Fiend


    Originally posted by Stephen
    One question:

    Why do the freemasons not allow atheists to join? Atheists can be just as morally minded as the religious.

    That's something I've always wondered myself, being agnostic.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 68,317 ✭✭✭✭seamus


    Originally posted by Stephen
    One question:

    Why do the freemasons not allow atheists to join? Atheists can be just as morally minded as the religious.
    100% off-topic, but there was some religious survey programme on BBC the other night, and one question asked, "Does a belief in God make for a better human being?". I laughed out loud when it said that 45% of atheists said yes, it does make for a better human being, basically meaning that 45% of atheists think they're a bad human being :D
    I disregarded anything else I saw after seeing that farce :)

    Carry on.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 650 ✭✭✭dr_manhattan


    Damn! I treid and tried to keep off this one. I think there's almost too much to say here (so I PM'd DeVore with some entertainment stuff, haha) but:

    Chill, your decision to disallow candidates for a job is something that is highly discriminatory: fact is, catholics, muslims, preotestants, boy scouts, golfers ALL have a significant track record of employing via nepotism: sure, many don't, but many do - our country is pretty much a testament to nepotism, and our behaviour in the US also -

    So if a track record for nepotism is a problem, then surely anyone (especially that category, you know the bunch, the ones who all work together, and employ each other, keeping their wages high and everyone else's low... what's the name again.... oh yes: MEN)is just as capable of absorbing influences outside the work place?

    Especially christians, who are such a self righteous bunch sometimes that they reckon their moral values are enough to fix the world.

    So would you deny a job to a catholic? Or a jewish person? (no offense to any jews or catholics, but if you dig deep and long enough you lot have been helping each other out all the way down the line, LOL) For the same reasons?

    just curious - and also wondering if you're trolling, it's just the "dead right I did" makes me wonder if you're just out to shock people.

    For my 2 cents, I trust the freemasons much, much more than say, the catholic church. But that doesn't mean I trust them a huge amount; I CERTAINLY do not think they are engaged in mad daft conspiracies to insert radio control suppositories in the rear ends of every schizophrenic in the world ;-) - seriously though, use logic: if you wanted to control the world, why use one of the best known "secret societies" in the world? Why not use a new one? An actually really nobody-knows-about-it secret one?

    Chill, your cynicism is hilarious: if a freemason said "yes, I and all my brothers are alien sodomites from KaBlooga 6" would you then assume they were lying? And that the truth was that they're actually members of an old yet not very sinister club?

    IMHO, the freemasons certainly respect knowledge, tradition and the skills of the tradesmen they used to represent in society: and I have never seen convincing evidence of their nefarious activity. So that scores them huge points over most other 500+ year old organisations.

    Anyways: questions for the Masons here, I'm SO curious about this thingy:

    1) have any of you read "from hell" by alan moore, which suggests Sir William Gull, an eminent freemason, was Jack the Ripper (and no, it does not suggest that the freemasons made him do it)?

    2) if you have, then could you inform as to the accuracy of the "jah-bul-on" representation of the master architect? I found the trappings of masonic tradition explored here to be fascinating in the extreme, and I'd love to read more on the subject of the "dyonisian architects" and the ideas of tradition that the masons preserve.

    ...but don't have me killed and abducted by 12ft lizards, please. I'd really hate that.

    ;-)


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    I'm not an expert by any means but I now know a lot about the masons, have met quite a number and even been involved in one of their charity events. I've been invited (and attended) open nights, taken the public tour of their facilities and gotten very very drunk with them.

    I'm an agnostic (a "Strong Agnostic" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_agnosticism if I you really want to get specific). I've spoken to the guys I know and asked about the "Belief in a supreme being" requirement. Since I *do* believe in an "architect" (to use their words), I just dont believe humans are equiped with brains sufficent to the task of *understanding* forces that create universes , apparently thats sufficent. They never talk about religion, its forbidden when they meet as Freemasons (as is politics) otherwise the whole "brotherly friendship" stuff might quickly go out the window.

    I can tell you that they arent controlling anything behind the scenes. They just arent that organised. :) When I helped them with some computer stuff they were very grateful as they dont have the deepest knowledge of computers really. They keep dropping hints that I'd make a great Freemason (they arent allowed come right out and ask you, you have to make that decision willingly) which I find kinda funny... I'm pretty sure I'm going to join as I've already seen people leave and they were wished well and have remained friends so its not like some cult you cant get out of.

    Pretty soon I'll join to see things from the inside I reckon... I started this personal investigation (admittedly I was pretty negative at the start and fully expected to be having a right fight between Boards and the Freemasons by now). Now I've come to admire some of them (ok, some of them are right *******'s but thats life I guess) so I want to see it through. From what I can see they believe that communities/society has become too self-centred, that people should be honest and that charity is important, so I am roughly aligned with those sentiments. Yeah, I know. Aint life fnckin' weird? Still, a "life less ordinary" eh?

    I've had a couple of masons write to me and say they have read this thread and are fascinated by it too... some top level masons at that who are as intrigued by our world as much as we are with theirs lol!

    Jah-Bal-On seems to be some form of union of three of the old world Gods (Jahweh, Baal and Osiris) but it has no meaning in standard Freemason afaik (its got something to do with Royal Arch or Knight Masonry which are a bit different and separate fraternities).

    I'm far less freaked about the whole thing now, they're just a bunch of well meaning, very polite middle-aged-to-old men who have a lot of tradition surrounding what is basically a fraternity with charitable intentions. Some of them are fascinating blokes (I spent a good bit of an evening talking to a bloke who flew Spit-Fires in WW2 about how that felt and his thoughts on it all).

    I'll keep you all informed what happens while I play Nancy Drew :)

    DeV.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 650 ✭✭✭dr_manhattan


    Aha - yeah, I know the significance of the trinity-name for the older god. Reason I asked was that it's one of the foundations of respect I have for the masons: any institution that can allow as broad interpretation of divinity as to include osiris is at *least* interesting in my opinion, if not enlightened in the extreme.

    i was wondering if it was a fiction or not.

    To be honest, DeVore, I'm jealous as hell: not that i think you've embarked on a journey that will wind up with you being shown the foundations of the world, the secrets of foucalts pendulum and the holy grail ;-)

    but simply because I'd imagine there's a fair reserve of egalitarian knowledge at your disposal now.

    And one last question: have any masons read 'from hell'?

    Cos I'm thinking of dropping a copy round to molesworth street, haha.


  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    I found this absolutely gob-smacking.... apparently there is a tradition stretching back centuries between the masons and the Native Indians of America.

    http://www.westlancsfreemasons.org.uk/pages/pgl/oklahoma.htm

    http://www.srmason-sj.org/council/journal/jun01/cijune.html

    I'm currently looking into the Shriners (who are a frankly amazing bunch of blokes if what I'm reading is true, I need a confirmatory source for it, though I spoke to one Shriner who told me quite a bit). They are a side group of Masons particularly committed to children's charities and hospitals. My ingrained cynicism finds it a little difficult to accept that they run 22 hospitals completely free of charge but then as my mother said "I named you 'Thomas' for a very good reason" :)

    DeV.


  • Advertisement
  • Business & Finance Moderators, Entertainment Moderators Posts: 32,387 Mod ✭✭✭✭DeVore


    Dr Manhattan (great name btw)... I havent read From Hell but I am a huge Alan Moore fan. V for Vendetta being my favourite all time graphic novel. From Hell is on my list.

    The masons I know have a joke ... "The secret is... there are no secrets!". Personally, the attraction for me is not some leg-up, or some sooper sekrit knowledge or any of that crap. As most people on this site know, I do a fair bit of kids charity stuff. I happen to think its important, but its also damned hard and sometimes lonely work and it would be nice to be part of a group that thought it was important too. Thats not the only reason but its the main one.

    I'm a big social person (as evidenced by my passion for this site) and lets face facts, I'm not really your average run of the mill normal bloke, I've been labeled as "weird" "geek" "nerd" "assh*le :)" all my life, as many of us who were into the net and computers as teenagers in the 80's were... so I kinda got used to being called "odd" and determined not to prejudice others simply because they are not in line with "the norm". Hence I investigate stuff... but I've never run accross something like this before.
    If I were in line with "the norm" I'd be a beer-swilling footie-nut with a wife, two brats, a car and holiday every year in Majorca "cos their grub is like you get at home". I'd rather be "weird" thanks...

    Sorry, I'm ranting off topic now, so I'll stop :)

    DeV.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    1) have any of you read "from hell" by alan moore, which suggests Sir William Gull, an eminent freemason, was Jack the Ripper (and no, it does not suggest that the freemasons made him do it)?

    Yep, loved it! Tho I'm a big Alan Moore fan anyways, also enjoyed the movie with the excellent Mr Depp! Beyond that tho, even Alan Moore would say the content was fiction based on speculation...and meant to be enjoyed as such.
    2) if you have, then could you inform as to the accuracy of the "jah-bul-on" representation of the master architect? I found the trappings of masonic tradition explored here to be fascinating in the extreme, and I'd love to read more on the subject of the "dyonisian architects" and the ideas of tradition that the masons preserve.

    The reference exists in English Royal Arch freemasonry ( I believe)..unfortunately for the conspiracy theorists it's not the 'secret name of god' used by the Freemasons (and no, there isn't one either!). It's just part of another Masonic Legend used to illustrate a moral code. I haven't read much about the Dionysian architects, but Hodges & Figgis always seem to have at least a couple of good Masonic exposé books whenever I pop in...


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Did anyone (particularly Dev) happen to watch the Would You Belive documentary on RTE last week?

    I caught the last half of the show (dammit!). Perhaps it's being on the inside looking out, but I thought the bias was extreme!

    The guy who provided most of the anti Masonic slant was never a Freemason; but was a member of the Orange Order which he left because it seemed like Freemasonry? Not because the Orange order is devoted to religious bigotry and cultivates sectarianism....Irish Freemasonry, by the way, forbids it's members from being a member of the Orange Order.

    The 'reconstructed' rites were vaguely based on English Rite Masonry..quite different from the Irish version, and perhaps more exciting but still not so accurate!

    What the show overlooked consistently was that the 'bloodcurdling oaths' mentioned so often are always referred to as 'Ancient Oaths' in modern Freemasonry...they are not intended as being applicable, rather as a reminder of the allegorical legends which are part of Freemasonry.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Having reread my posts, I never mentioned..I loved that there was a show! Any discussion..accurate or other wise, that brings Freemasonry back into the main view of society is a great thing!


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 37,305 ✭✭✭✭the_syco


    Stopped reading the thread after it went a bit downhill. Looked at a few of the sites. They look like a nice bunch of people (they remind me of the CBSI / scouts for some reason), and I may join once I get a pernament job.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 5,025 ✭✭✭yellum


    Originally posted by the_syco
    and I may join once I get a pernament job.

    I think theres an online form somewhere on their website for joining if thats any help.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,913 ✭✭✭Absolam


    Or next time you're on Molesworth St you could pop in and ask to join. For a secret society we're kinda open that way :)


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,566 ✭✭✭Gillo


    Alternatively email them if it's not easy to get to Molesworth street. Thanks what I did, got sent out a number of leaflets in the post along with an application from. The information which they sent out was very helpful / informative.

    Anyone like to share with me (and other) the process of becoming a mason??


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,180 ✭✭✭keu


    havent had time to read all the posts. I believe the negative attitude towards freemasons is derived from the "illuminati" connections, the majority of which freemasons are unaware of.
    I understand that the Da Vinci code and Angels and demons have brought such issues to light and have brought about a lot of paranoia in the process, could such conspiracy theories actually exist in reality.

    I don't know if this will be understood in terms I would like it to be and I hope I don't get shot down for this, but I was initiated into a group which was "illuminati" at the core. If you take out the conspiracy values, much of what I experienced is mysticism on a hardcore scale. Its difficult to describe, but I look back now and think I was under some hypnotic influence for three years. (it was american based) Brainwashed. It was by all means for the first two years a society which was based on fundemental qualities such as charity and love for humanity and the desire to bring equality to all.
    Think Golden dawn.
    I see so much of it in Bush now, when I hear him say, God talks through him and thats how he can do his job, he's obviously been fed the same stuff.
    It's not a game either, and its not as easy as saying "wake up and smell the coffee", as far as these people are concerned they are the "awake" and as long as they continue to connect with their "divine aspect" they can use this "ability" to influence the masses, by means of critical mass.

    do they control the higher echelons of society? YES


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,566 ✭✭✭Gillo


    I'm not trying to shoot you down Keu, but the more I've looked into Freemasonry the more they seem to be good people.

    Do they control scoiety?
    I don't think so, maybe certain (or most) high ranking politian's are Freemasons, it dosen't mean that Freemasons are high ranking politians or control them. How many TD's, MLA's or MP's are members of golf clubs; do golf clubs have an underlying master plan for runnign the world??

    The reason I find the conspiracy theory hard to believe is that all you have to do is do a search on yahoo, google etc for freemasonry to find enough anti masonic to keep you there for days, then do a search for "freemasonry exposed" or something similar and you won't believe what you'll find. The stories are too far fetched to beleive (one story told of how freemasons appearently have sex with a goat, more claimed that Tomathy McVeigh & Hermann Goreing amongst many other nut job's were also members) and to be honest by the time I had finished reading everything I just felt that it was pure conspiracy theory of the highest order.

    Admittedly though as with every barrell you will find a few bad apples, look at boards for example.....


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement