Meath GAA discussion thread

vapor trails · 21-07-2019 8:26pm

rpurfield wrote: »

We're not as fit or conditioned as other teams at this level, it's something that doesn't come in one year. I'm really frustrated with today as I believe we didn't play as well as last week and left it behind us today as Mayo weren't great. They did seem to be able to win frees a lot handier than us too. I don't believe Colgan is a bad keeper but we need to work on the kick out strategy as a whole. It's costing us too dearly, at least 2-2 came from them today. You can blame Colgan but if lads don't move or make space he can't hit them safely.

If you look at our performances V the 3 division 1 sides we played in this year's Championship we have been destroyed 4-17 V 0-4 over the last 15 minutes of play. This would say conditioning is a factor. Also, sorry for the soccer reference but I am also slightly worried that we have a bunch of forwards who might all be what I can only describe as "Philippe Coutinho" like in their midset/physical approach to the game. Not much of an engine and disappear somewhat when the game is in the balance. Really finding it hard to make my mind up on O'Sullivan. He's either in or I'd completely jettison him. James Conlon shot to points percentage can't be much better than 20% since the Laois match. I love his willingness to show for the ball but he got ripped once or twice and looked a minor amongst seniors. Newman is looking a bit lethargic recently missed an early free. Shane Walsh might put him under pressure over the league although he left a handy free short today. He kicked a nice one from the turf V Clare but everything today was out of the hand? I prefer my free taking from the ground.

I kind of want to say defensively we are not too bad but the scores opposing teams have racked up over the last 3 games seems to be at odd's with that. Lavin was very good today and showed an attacking part of his game I had not really known was there. If we happened to unearth a bit more depth defensively maybe he could make a workhorse half-forward in time? I think if Keoghan got his goal he was a lock for an All-Star. He's right on the line for that. Meath being out of the Championship 6 weeks before it's over might go against him.

Does anyone know a depth chart of our Goal Keeper position? Are there options beyond Colgin?

Rock Lesnar · 21-07-2019 8:30pm

Hammer Archer wrote: »

I’ll defend Colgan slightly. Yes, the goal came from a bad kickout, but the defending after the kickout was shocking. McLoughlin simply sauntered into the box unnoticed and wasn’t tracked. His kickouts were decent enough up to then.

Forwards again killed us. O’Sullivan’s sitter would have put us 3 up with less than 20 to go. Mayo went up the other end and bought a free. Think we only got 3 more points after that.
Baptism of fire for us. Have played well for 60 minutes in both games but have lost both by 9. At least the players know the work they need to put in over the winter if they are to have any chance of staying up. And again, every effort needs to be made to get players back!
Hopefully a big crowd next week. It’s been an excellent season regardless of the last two results.

I agree Hammer but kickouts have been a problem since the league, i fully understand there is not enough running from players to create space for him, my problem is how many times kicks go over the sideline, or to opposition players maybe 20-30 yards away from him and scores are conceded, i dont believe he's a bad keeper, and its a fixable problem, i was told 2-4 was conceded from that area today, he's not alone by the way, O'Sullivan dropped the ball 2 or 3 times and we were punished with points to, turnovers have really hurt us in the championship this year along with kicking wides, we need to find some scoring forwards next year, i'll just add, i felt Shane Walsh was terrific when introduced today, his movement off the ball was fantastic.

Iike i said before the super 8's, its been a great season and these games are great prep for the league, roll on next year.

Cavan_King · 21-07-2019 8:32pm

Even as a neutral hoping Meath would win, today was very frustrating. Meath should have kicked on and had three or four points before Mayo had even scored.

The space the Meath forwards had in the first half was criminal and at least one goal should have been scored.

Newman, whose praises I have sung in the past for his free taking, needs to learn to look up rather than constantly going for the same dummy and shot.

I was surprised how poor Mayo were because I expected a lot more from them. They were there for the taking today.

Still, as others have said, this has been a very good year for Meath. Promotion to Division One and the Super 8s is a great return for this team.

However, no team of true quality has been beaten in the Championship and unless a few of the junior team or your underage sides can step up quickly, I foresee a very difficult League campaign for the Royals next year.

Cavan_King · 21-07-2019 8:38pm

rpurfield wrote: »

We're not as fit or conditioned as other teams at this level, it's something that doesn't come in one year. I'm really frustrated with today as I believe we didn't play as well as last week and left it behind us today as Mayo weren't great. They did seem to be able to win frees a lot handier than us too. I don't believe Colgan is a bad keeper but we need to work on the kick out strategy as a whole. It's costing us too dearly, at least 2-2 came from them today. You can blame Colgan but if lads don't move or make space he can't hit them safely.

24 months to get up to full intercounty conditioning is what this lad reckons:

https://www.irishnews.com/sport/gaafootball/2018/11/09/news/respected-rugby-coach-andre-quinn-appointed-cavan-s-head-of-athletic-performance-1481018/

It’s why Cavan brought in a few U20s to a 40 man senior panel this year who were pretty much told they wouldn’t play until next year at the earliest.

Rock Lesnar · 21-07-2019 8:39pm

Cavan_King wrote: »

I was surprised how poor Mayo were because I expected a lot more from them. They were there for the taking today.

Ha well a mayo man (who should know better judging by the amount of finals i'd say he has seen) sitting in front of me would disagree with you, he taught they were very good and will qualify for the final

SameOleJay · 21-07-2019 8:51pm

The forward play is very concerning, irrespective of the milestones reached. No difference makers and young guys who really are not improving as necessary. I'm really struggling to keep my cool with COS, Colgan and Newman too at times.

Backs have way exceeded my expectations. Really hope they go out with a big performance.

Cavan_King · 21-07-2019 8:59pm

Rock Lesnar wrote: »

Ha well a mayo man (who should know better judging by the amount of finals i'd say he has seen) sitting in front of me would disagree with you, he taught they were very good and will qualify for the final

Was he still saying that after watching the second game!?

Rock Lesnar · 21-07-2019 9:33pm

Cavan_King wrote: »

Was he still saying that after watching the second game!?

He'd gone by HT, i got the impression he's the type of lad who wouldnt worry about the opposition, ha

Panrich · 21-07-2019 9:36pm

Rock Lesnar wrote: »

Ha well a mayo man (who should know better judging by the amount of finals i'd say he has seen) sitting in front of me would disagree with you, he taught they were very good and will qualify for the final

He had too much beer beforehand is the only explanation for that viewpoint.

Obrieski · 21-07-2019 11:57pm

Just want to say thanks to all the lads and management for a wonderful year (I know it's not over but it's raw at the moment).

If you had told me at the start of the year we would have got to Division 1 (and could easily have won the league final), got to a Leinster final and kept Dublin to 5 points in the first half without being overly defensive and got to the Super 8s where we showed we certainly are not out of place at that level I would have told you to go and get yourself checked out.

A hugely positive year, yes there are multiple learning points and things we need to work on, but hey...I'd rather be in this position than having achieved none of the above 3 goals.

Imperative that the lads stick together, give Kerry a serious rattle and then go off and move our game to another level for next year. I've had a hugely enjoyable year following this team and I know full well the huge sacrifices they make for our enjoyment

Thanks men and keep those heads high, you've brought serious pride back to Meath GAA.

sc86 · 22-07-2019 3:09pm

Mayo have really gone back alot in the last 2 years .
Unlucky not to win a all ireland at their peak , hard see them beat donegal to get out of group.
End of the road for alot of them.

Hammer Archer · 22-07-2019 3:27pm

Rock Lesnar wrote: »

I agree Hammer but kickouts have been a problem since the league, i fully understand there is not enough running from players to create space for him, my problem is how many times kicks go over the sideline, or to opposition players maybe 20-30 yards away from him and scores are conceded, i dont believe he's a bad keeper, and its a fixable problem, i was told 2-4 was conceded from that area today, he's not alone by the way, O'Sullivan dropped the ball 2 or 3 times and we were punished with points to, turnovers have really hurt us in the championship this year along with kicking wides, we need to find some scoring forwards next year, i'll just add, i felt Shane Walsh was terrific when introduced today, his movement off the ball was fantastic.

Iike i said before the super 8's, its been a great season and these games are great prep for the league, roll on next year.

Oh absolutely. I think we need a new keeper without a doubt! Just think he wasn't too bad yesterday.
Walsh was very good today and will only improve. James Conlon made some fantastic runs off the ball at times but these weren't spotted. It's another infuriating thing about our forward play. We just seem to put the head down and not see anything further than 10 yards ahead. There were a couple of goal chances had we played the correct ball.

As Obrieski said, a great year. I think it would be a travesty if some of that defence don't end up with All Star nominations (Keogan, McGill and Lavin in my view). I think Keogan is definitely in with a shout of winning one.

Stoner · 22-07-2019 11:03pm

Hammer Archer wrote:

All Star nominations (Keogan, McGill and Lavin in my view). I think Keogan is definitely in with a shout of winning one.

McGill is a class act. I remember seeing him in a couple of games at underage, he held a promanate member of the current Dublin team scoreless in one provincial final.

If Meath get one for reaching the super 8s I think fullback would be a good position for it, as Mayo don't have one.

Dublin are playing 3 corner backs, Morley for Kerry or Mark Griffen I'd say McGill is out a head of Dublin, Mayo, Tyrone, Cork and Kerry

McGee being out for Donegal and no Monghan there this year would rule out the other better No 3s in the country.

A gambling man, ie 80 percent of the posters on boards, might put a fiver on him

rpurfield · 23-07-2019 12:23pm

Not so sure on the full back line getting a nomination, they've been class (McGill in particular) but I think the high scores conceded in the last few games will kill them. Unfairly so.

rpurfield · 24-07-2019 12:12pm

Donal Lenihan with 1-5 in the B league final for Dunboyne last night. Lovely boost for them ahead of the championship to have him back

rpurfield · 30-07-2019 10:12am

So will we have much of a turn out in the stands on Saturday? I hope we do, the squad and management deserve a show of support for what has been the best season in at least 9 years.

theunforgiven · 31-07-2019 10:21am

Going to this with the kids. Have only been to a few games in PT and am wondering if it's a case of turn up early to get the best seats as per the league games?

meath4sam · 31-07-2019 10:25am

I really think we can win this one. If andy can get them in the correct mind set and treat this like the previous two games I fancy us to win.
Navan will be a big advantage to us. A win here would be such a boost going into division 1 next year.
Home games in division 1 will be the making or breaking of us next year.

Edgware · 31-07-2019 10:45am

rpurfield wrote: »

So will we have much of a turn out in the stands on Saturday? I hope we do, the squad and management deserve a show of support for what has been the best season in at least 9 years.

The Meath support should come out. There have been some very good performances this year. It will be a 70 minute plus game so a 60 minute outing wont do. There is a big game in those lads

Clare in Exile · 02-08-2019 11:13am

Heading to the game tmw (father from Kerry). First time in Pairc Tailteann - regarding tickets, is there a ticket office outside the ground? My father will be getting an OAP ticket, and they can only be purchased on the day.

What kind of attendance is being predicted?

Obrieski · 02-08-2019 11:20am

Clare in Exile wrote: »

Heading to the game tmw (father from Kerry). First time in Pairc Tailteann - regarding tickets, is there a ticket office outside the ground? My father will be getting an OAP ticket, and they can only be purchased on the day.

What kind of attendance is being predicted?

No idea on attendance being predicted, but there is a ticket office.
Now I would advise you to get there early as the crowds that can develop around that ticket office can be quite large, so best to get to it early.

Hammer Archer · 03-08-2019 12:46pm

Brennan comes in between the sticks for Colgan. Walsh and Campion are in for Newman and Conlon.

risteard7 · 03-08-2019 6:53pm

Marcus Brennan far more composed. I dont think we'll see Colgan in a Meath shirt again

Hammer Archer · 03-08-2019 7:51pm

Carbon copy of the other two games. Good for two-thirds of the game before falling apart.
But fair play to the team. They haven't disgraced themselves in any of the games.
Back to knocking lumps out of each other in the club championship.

rpurfield · 04-08-2019 12:00pm

Yeah same script as the other games. Is it the game plan that causes lads to fade, there is a lot of running involved in breaking out of a packed defence? Shane Walsh looked sharp, he's going to develop into a serious footballer. It's been a generally good year, hit the targets we needed to hit. It's going to be hard to push on now to the next level. I genuinely think we might have a couple of years of yo-yoing between one and two in the league

whatnext · 04-08-2019 12:45pm

Playing championship football in August is a big step forward for the team, remember last year!!
We can see that the ability is there to complete for 75% of the game with regard to intensity, physicality, skill and speed. So the fundamentals are in place, certain things probably need tweaking but there is so much that is already right. Next season mental and physical fitness will be miles ahead of where the team started this season.
I really enjoyed watching this team. Kerry and Mayo both got a bit of a fright for a period in those games. The defeats were tough on the scoreboard in the end which is unfortunate.
Anyway I’m looking forward to next season. The league is going to be tough, but there will be scalps to be taken early on in the campaign. Could really do with a favourable fixture draw!!

On a side note I think the ref had a bit of a stinker yesterday. In these cases I fell the linesmen / umpires need to share some of the blame. Especially regarding the stuff going on in the fullback line.

Over 2700km travelled this year for league and championship. That’s just shy of a road trip from Paris to Moscow!!

Hammer Archer · 05-08-2019 8:58pm

SHC
Ratoath 3-19 Killyon 1-14
Trim 1-13 Blackhall Gaels 1-12 (Last minute Trim goal won it)
Kiltale 3-34 Dunboyne 1-11 :eek:

I know Dunboyne went down to 14 early on, but that is one serious tanking. Dunboyne are surely favourites to drop to group B.

Hammer Archer · 11-08-2019 5:06pm

Curraha beat Simonstown by 5 points :eek:

rpurfield · 11-08-2019 5:52pm

Hammer Archer wrote: »

Curraha beat Simonstown by 5 points :eek:

Seen on Twitter that they've a lot of lads back from travelling etc. Still wouldn't have expected them to beat Simonstown though

Hammer Archer · 14-08-2019 8:44pm

NOM's victory over Gaeil Colmcille means that there are four teams level on four points in each of the three SFC groups.

Obrieski · 15-08-2019 12:04am

Stephen Bray with 4 points from play...the man just oozes class!
What a player!!

Hammer Archer · 19-08-2019 9:29am

U16s beat Dublin 2-11 to 2-10 to win the Gerry Reilly tournament for the second year in a row.
The Ladies' footballers are into the All Ireland Intermediate final again after beating Roscommon 4-20 to 1-12. They'll play Tipperary in the final. Tipperary were relegated from the senior championship last season.

rpurfield · 19-08-2019 12:18pm

I watched the ladies game on the box, they played very well. Emma Duggan and Vikki Wall were excellent. I think the final will be a tough ask, it seems Tipp are a lot of people's picks to win it from the start of the year.

On a side note, I was reading an article a couple of weeks back about how poorly attended the women's games are outside of the finals. Doing things like bringing Meath, Roscommon and Sligo all the way to Kilkenny for games doesn't help.

Obrieski · 25-08-2019 9:32am

Dunshaughlin with a big win over NOM last night...big result that.
Kells are flying - amazing how little representation they have on the Meath squad.

Hammer Archer · 25-08-2019 9:35pm

How bad were Skryne though? Kells were down to 14 men for all the second half and they outscored Skryne by 3-11 to 2 points. They're likely going to be in the relegation playoff but they're steeped that they'll play Longwood and avoid relegation.
Another fantastic win by Curraha, hammering Tones by 12 points. They're in a great position to make the knockout stages now.

vapor trails · 25-08-2019 9:42pm

Meath GAA website down again at the moment. We've been **** digitally. I've said it a few times

RoyalCelt · 26-08-2019 3:10am

The meath club championship is the best in the country bar none. Curraha the story of the summer so far. So many teams in contention, dunshaughlin my dark horses.

rpurfield · 26-08-2019 9:51am

Some mad results over the weekend. I didn't get to Pats v Seneschalstown because my young lad had a match at the same time. I was talking to my father though and he was highly impressed with Seneschalstown, he reckons they could go deep in the championship, and it takes a lot to impress him!

I wouldn't have expected Dunshaughlin to win this weekend, and the Cilles getting a draw against Dunboyne is a good result for them, although probably frustrating as they led for a lot of it. Going to a 16 team championship will probably make things more competitive as ourselves and Longwood really shouldn't be in there. Apart from ourselves, Group A is all level pegging you couldn't get more even than that, although I'll have a degree of sympathy for whoever ends up in the relegation play off out of the rest of the group when they could've went on to the know outs.

sc86 · 26-08-2019 3:44pm

RoyalCelt wrote: »

The meath club championship is the best in the country bar none. Curraha the story of the summer so far. So many teams in contention, dunshaughlin my dark horses.

How is it best in country?
Most games at the weeknd were very one sided.
19 / 22 / 17 / 22 / 12 / 18 point victories

Far to many bad teams at senior level

Hammer Archer · 27-08-2019 9:57am

If NOM, Skryne and Seneschalstown happen to win their final games in group A you'd end up with 5 teams on 6 points meaning the top team will be level with a team in the relegation playoffs.
Seneschalstown seem to be improving after nearly a decade of rebuilding. Their underage teams seem to be competing very well at the moment too.

While I don't think the quality of the SFC is necessarily great and there are some very one-sided games, the fact that 13 of the 18 teams have won at least half their games shows that most teams are relatively competitive. When it's at 16 teams next year and one bad result could be the difference between a quarter final spot or a relegation playoff, I can see it being even more competitive.

rpurfield · 27-08-2019 11:58am

The one I can't get my head around is the relative struggles of Colmcilles. They've an absolute machine of an underage set up for years now, but seem to be struggling at senior level. They could be a team that's caught in a relegation play off against a pretty good side and drop down but be too goo for inter.

I think the move to 16 will certainly help the SFC. It's the 20 team IFC that's going to be an issue. The spread will be far too wide and they'll need to reduce it fairly quickly.

Hammer Archer · 02-09-2019 12:40pm

Hurling group stages are done and dusted. Boardsmill relegated to intermediate which was confirmed before their walkover in the last game. Trim promoted to group A next season while Dunboyne drop to group B.

Quarter finals see Ratoath v Trim and Longwood v Na Fianna. Kiltale and Kildalkey are straight through to the semi finals. Anyone know who plays who in the semi finals?

Could be wrong, but it looks as though Donaghmore/Ashbourne are in a relegation playoff with Kilmessan's second team to determine who drops to the JHC. Now they'll win that easily (Kilmessan have been hockeyed in all but one of the games they played) but it's still not great for such a big club.

Hammer Archer · 02-09-2019 12:46pm

rpurfield wrote: »

The one I can't get my head around is the relative struggles of Colmcilles. They've an absolute machine of an underage set up for years now, but seem to be struggling at senior level. They could be a team that's caught in a relegation play off against a pretty good side and drop down but be too goo for inter.

I think the move to 16 will certainly help the SFC. It's the 20 team IFC that's going to be an issue. The spread will be far too wide and they'll need to reduce it fairly quickly.

For Cilles, I know it does take a while for the good underage work to bear fruit at adult level with players dropping out and whatnot. Also, from chatting to someone involved, their approach this year hasn't been great as in they don't seem to have a concrete system that they play and a number of their players weren't giving 100% commitment. That was rectified prior to the Dunboyne game and I wouldn't bet against them against Curraha. They should have way too much for Rathkenny in the relegation playoff.

I think the CB have gone with the softly softly approach when it comes to rejigging the football championships after the debacle a few years ago. They'll probably bring a motion to reduce the IFC to 16 teams by relegating five teams in the next few years.

CrabRevolution · 02-09-2019 3:02pm

Hammer Archer wrote: »

Hurling group stages are done and dusted. Boardsmill relegated to intermediate which was confirmed before their walkover in the last game. Trim promoted to group A next season while Dunboyne drop to group B.

Quarter finals see Ratoath v Trim and Longwood v Na Fianna. Kiltale and Kildalkey are straight through to the semi finals. Anyone know who plays who in the semi finals?

Could be wrong, but it looks as though Donaghmore/Ashbourne are in a relegation playoff with Kilmessan's second team to determine who drops to the JHC. Now they'll win that easily (Kilmessan have been hockeyed in all but one of the games they played) but it's still not great for such a big club.

Winner of Trim/Ratoath plays Kiltale in the semi final.

I only learned a week or two ago that the IHC is structured the same as the SHC this year with an A group and a B group. So Ashbourne are down to the B group and Kilmessan are down to Junior.

Hammer Archer · 02-09-2019 6:11pm

Ah right I didn't realize that myself.

rpurfield · 02-09-2019 10:02pm

Andy Mc ratified for another three years tonight. The correct move anyway, although some keyboard warriors aren't happy

Obrieski · 03-09-2019 12:05am

rpurfield wrote: »

Andy Mc ratified for another three years tonight. The correct move anyway, although some keyboard warriors aren't happy

Good news.

Stability is what is needed now and Andy has brought together a strong squad and with a couple more additions and carrying forward some momentum I am going into next year with renewed optimism and hope.

Hopefully Colm Nally stays on board too

rpurfield · 03-09-2019 12:23pm

Yep I'm delighted it's all tied down now, no messing about or uncertainty. Colm Nally staying will be key.

The4Sisters · 04-09-2019 8:51pm

Very interesting article in the Mail last weekend. Anybody see it?

vapor trails · 05-09-2019 10:41pm

The4Sisters wrote: »

Very interesting article in the Mail last weekend. Anybody see it?

What was it about?

Meath GAA discussion thread

Comments