1. Downlighters
2. Island lights
3. Under and Over cabinet lights
4. Kitchen table light
What I want to achieve
1. & 2. no change
3. Under cabinet lights
4. Over cabinet lights (kitchen table light will be removed)

I thought I could move one of the top wires from 3 to 4, to split the cabinet lights, & remove the existing top wire in 4, which I thought would connect to the kitchen table light.
When I did that, the kitchen light continued to work as before, and the over cabinet lights stayed on permanently.
Suggestions?