Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi all! We have been experiencing an issue on site where threads have been missing the latest postings. The platform host Vanilla are working on this issue. A workaround that has been used by some is to navigate back from 1 to 10+ pages to re-sync the thread and this will then show the latest posts. Thanks, Mike.
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

Can the Oireachtas 'prohibit' an EU Regulation?

  • 25-10-2020 1:45pm
    #1
    Registered Users Posts: 578 ✭✭✭


    I'm trying to make sense of the Minister for Children's statement
    https://www.gov.ie/en/press-release/c5585-statement-regarding-commission-of-investigation-mother-and-baby-homes-and-certain-related-matters-records-and-another-matter-bill/

    The legal advice received by the Department is that the GDPR right to access personal data (Article 15) is expressly prohibited by section 39 of the Commissions of Investigations Act 2004.
    While stated as a prohibited by the 2004 Act, this seems to mean the Act as amended by an Act in 2018, which inserts the following wording into that Act
    http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2018/act/7/section/198/enacted/en/html#sec198

    "Article 15 (Right of access) of the Data Protection Regulation is restricted, to the extent necessary and proportionate to safeguard the effective operation of commissions and the future cooperation of witnesses, in so far as it relates to personal data (within the meaning of that Regulation) provided to a commission"
    Article 15 is here

    I didn't think that the scope of EU legislation could be limited by a national parliament. Otherwise, the EU could hardly function. Our own Constitution is pretty clear on this
    http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/cons/en#article29_4_6

    No provision of this Constitution invalidates laws enacted, acts done or measures adopted by the State <...> that are necessitated by the obligations of membership of the European Union
    If our Constitution is explicitly subservient to the obligations of EU membership, it surely follows that any Act of the Oireachtas (that draws its authority from the Constitution) are similarly subservient.

    In particular, EU Regulations have direct effect in Member State laws - unlike Directives, they don't need to be transposed by Member States.
    https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-making-process/types-eu-law_en

    Regulations are legal acts that apply automatically and uniformly to all EU countries as soon as they enter into force, without needing to be transposed into national law. They are binding in their entirety on all EU countries.
    That seems to flatly contradict the idea that the Oireachtas could "prohibit" GDPR.

    Our own DPC seem to be saying something like this
    https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40070054.html

    “The Minister admits that he went back and forth with the Attorney General and that the 2004 Commissions act requires that the records be sealed,” a source with knowledge of the matter said. “But that act came in 2004 - it predates the EU’s charter on fundamental rights and GDPR and the 2018 data protection act, and where there’s conflict between national and EU legislation, the EU takes primacy,” they said.
    So it just seems plain wrong, maybe even nonsense, to be talking of an EU Regulation being "expressly prohibited" by an Act of the Oireachtas.

    So I suppose my question is - is there any possible explanation for this seemingly nonsensical legal advice?


Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 26,710 ✭✭✭✭Peregrinus


    GDPR itself allows member states to restrict the scope of GDPR obligations and rights "when such a restriction respects the essence of the fundamental rights and freedoms and is a necessary and proportionate measure in a democratic society to safeguard [a long list of public policy considerations]". Check out Article 23.

    So the argument is that the Oireachtas is not "prohibiting" GDPR. They are prohibiting access to [certain] information under Art 15 of GDPR, and they are allowed to do this by Art 23 of GDPR.


  • Registered Users Posts: 578 ✭✭✭VillageIdiot71


    Peregrinus wrote: »
    GDPR itself allows member states to restrict the scope of GDPR obligations and rights "when such a restriction respects the essence of the fundamental rights and freedoms and is a necessary and proportionate measure in a democratic society to safeguard [a long list of public policy considerations]". Check out Article 23.

    So the argument is that the Oireachtas is not "prohibiting" GDPR. They are prohibiting access to [certain] information under Art 15 of GDPR, and they are allowed to do this by Art 23 of GDPR.
    Very clear explanation, which I haven't found in media coverage!


Advertisement