Liverpool FC Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread 2014 - Mod Note in OP, 1/09

Oranage2 · 30-10-2014 12:01PM

MR NINE wrote: »

What are any of these posts contributing to the thread. What have any of em got to do with liverpool? I dunno what youre trying to achieve or why, but have a think about it next time youre whining about a liverpool fan spoiling a Utd thread

It's safe to say this poster is well known on the soccer board for want of a better word!

Grayditch · 30-10-2014 12:02PM

5live · 30-10-2014 01:15PM

MR NINE wrote: »

What are any of these posts contributing to the thread. What have any of em got to do with liverpool? I dunno what youre trying to achieve or why, but have a think about it next time youre whining about a liverpool fan spoiling a Utd thread

Oranage2 wrote: »

It's safe to say this poster is well known on the soccer board for want of a better word!

Aw now lads, it's just a bit of Willi waving:pac:

BMMachine · 30-10-2014 01:35PM

Will I Amnt wrote: »

If you have a problem with the posts being off topic then you know what to do. All of those posts are replies bar one where I was agreeing with someone.

I'm embarrassed for you thinking you're proving something here, what you have just done makes no sense.

"I'm embarrassed for you" - now William, do we have to have another conversation about you and your little victories. I mean, I get that its a Utd thing (Its a Jersey thing!) but come on, reel it in a bit son.

the league cup is what it is, the poor mans FA Cup. generally a good place to blood youngsters and the like and can make for some quite interesting matches late on

Utopia Parkway · 30-10-2014 01:37PM

ush wrote: »

Top 4 and a respectable CL run. Domestic Cups are just day trips.

Once you get to the quarter-finals of any cup competition you might as well try and win it. Different matter if you are knocked out early but once you reach the business end you have to go for it.

kfallon · 30-10-2014 01:39PM

Will I Amnt wrote: »

Of course, have you heard much about it since?

Eh it was only mentioned a few times last night..... :pac:

dirkmeister · 30-10-2014 01:43PM

Balotelli has just been criticised on Sky Sports by Andy Hinchcliffe for not celebrating his goal "correctly".

Talk about nitpicking, Balotelli has already explained why he doesn't celebrate.

Will I Amnt · 30-10-2014 01:45PM

BMMachine wrote: »

"I'm embarrassed for you" - now William, do we have to have another conversation about you and your little victories.

5live wrote: »

Aw now lads, it's just a bit of Willi waving:pac:

Oranage2 wrote: »

It's safe to say this poster is well known on the soccer board for want of a better word!

MR NINE wrote: »

I dunno what youre trying to achieve or why, but have a think about it next time youre whining about a liverpool fan spoiling a Utd thread

whatawaster wrote: »

I'm sure United glumly accepted their medals in 2010 and our friend Will I Amnt wouldn't even let himself crack a smile at the TV

Milkers wrote: »

United fan arrives in Liverpool thread to remind everyone how unimportant League Cup is.

Can any of you actually argue what I posted or is it just another case of attack the username???

kfallon · 30-10-2014 01:48PM

dirkmeister wrote: »

Balotelli has just been criticised on Sky Sports by Andy Hinchcliffe for not celebrating his goal "correctly".

Talk about nitpicking, Balotelli has already explained why he doesn't celebrate.

He is the devil incarnate don't ya know

BMMachine · 30-10-2014 01:55PM

Will I Amnt wrote: »

Can any of you actually argue what I posted or is it just another case of attack the username???

watcha post? something about the league cup being unimportant?

You are kinda right. its the least important of all the cups during a season. this is not news. now stop trying to score imaginary points in your head and move on with your life

Augmerson · 30-10-2014 01:59PM

Guise stahp.

Gbear · 30-10-2014 02:04PM

dirkmeister wrote: »

Balotelli has just been criticised on Sky Sports by Andy Hinchcliffe for not celebrating his goal "correctly".

Talk about nitpicking, Balotelli has already explained why he doesn't celebrate.

Either they're making a concerted effort to attack Balotelli for purely cynical reasons or almost the entirity of football media are debilitatingly stupid.

It's hard to know which scenario is worse.

brevity · 30-10-2014 02:07PM

dirkmeister wrote: »

Balotelli has just been criticised on Sky Sports by Andy Hinchcliffe for not celebrating his goal "correctly".

Talk about nitpicking, Balotelli has already explained why he doesn't celebrate.

What a moronic thing to say. He actually did the right thing by getting the ball out of the back of the net and trying to the game going again.

I remember Suarez and Gerrard doing something similar last season and they were applauded for it but Balotelli "didn't celebrate properly"...

D'Agger · 30-10-2014 02:21PM

BMMachine wrote: »

You are kinda right. its the least important of all the cups during a season. this is not news.

You realise this isn't a news website but rather a discussion forum right? The merits of the league cup are as applicable to this thread as a new signing, old players, games etc.

Harry Palmr · 30-10-2014 02:42PM

Bournemouth v Liverpool is a Sky pick.

skywalker · 30-10-2014 02:58PM

skywalker wrote: »

Cant find the image this relates to but its from last week when there was a pic floating around of him chatting to a young lad & his dad leaning over the wall at Melwood.

The story is on the official site now. Heres the image I mentioned earlier & a few others from the story.

LuckyLloyd · 30-10-2014 03:00PM

Gbear wrote: »

Winning the league cup would mean almost nothing to me.

I was kinda shocked in 2012 when we won it and I found myself really not giving a ****. Of course it probably didn't help that it was a poor game and it was against Cardiff.

What the **** would the quality of a game or the opposition have to do with taking away from the club's significant achievements. Would be more than happy if every single game was a **** 1 - 0 bore fest if we won every time.

rarnes1 wrote: »

The day I don't care about Liverpool winning a trophy is the day I stop following football

Right.

marklazarcovic wrote: »

Id take a league cup and 3rd/4th right now

Yep, that would be great.

Winning a trophy is always brilliant. But I think if Rodgers is to survive long term it's something that needs to happen. Getting a trophy gets everyone a taste of winning and removes the 'no trophy in X years' monkey off the backs.

Gbear · 30-10-2014 03:04PM

LuckyLloyd wrote: »

What the **** would the quality of a game or the opposition have to do with taking away from the club's significant achievements. Would be more than happy if every single game was a **** 1 - 0 bore fest if we won every time.

If it had been against Chelsea or something then the game would've mattered more because it's nice to beat Chelsea. But the cup itself is scarcely more important than the Community Shield.

It's a nothing trophy.

noodler · 30-10-2014 03:13PM

Gbear wrote: »

If it had been against Chelsea or something then the game would've mattered more because it's nice to beat Chelsea. But the cup itself is scarcely more important than the Community Shield.

It's a nothing trophy.

Very weird logic to devalue winning something because of the opposition you face in the final though.

ArmaniJeanss · 30-10-2014 03:13PM

All I'm seeing there is some scouse dad and his kid trying to rob a ball from Ballotelli at training, and then the kid trying a carjack on a clearly worried Mario.

Gbear · 30-10-2014 03:16PM

noodler wrote: »

Very weird logic to devalue winning something because of the opposition you face in the final though.

That's not what I'm doing.

I don't put much value in the fact that it's a league Cup Final regardless who the opposition is.

However, everything else being equal, the value I place in a match depends on the opposition.

So I could get reasonably excited about playing a big team in a friendly whereas playing Scunthorpe in the 3rd rnd of the FA cup isn't terribly exciting.

noodler · 30-10-2014 03:19PM

Gbear wrote: »

That's not what I'm doing.

I don't put much value in the fact that it's a league Cup Final regardless who the opposition is.

However, everything else being equal, the value I place in a match depends on the opposition.

So I could get reasonably excited about playing a big team in a friendly whereas playing Scunthorpe in the 3rd rnd of the FA cup isn't terribly exciting.

Playing Chelsea in a semi but Burnley in the final

OR

Playing Burnley in the semi and Chelsea in the final

Should equate to the same feeling of accomplishment for me.

A final isn't just any match!

Maybe you will argue I have misrepresented you again!

googled eyes · 30-10-2014 03:20PM

Winning a trophy is never a bad thing lads. Doesn't matter the prestige of the comp or the ability of the opposition.

THE LEAGUE CUP
We won it 8 times

Fck the begrudgers :pac:

noodler · 30-10-2014 03:23PM

Winning the League Cup but finishing outside the top 4 would be of only marginal benefit to Rodgers though.

We all know that real league progression can be judged on league performance and potentially advanced by revenues. The League Cup obviously wouldn't provide much encouragement on that score if we are sans-CL.

5live · 30-10-2014 03:25PM

googled eyes wrote: »

Winning a trophy is never a bad thing lads. Doesn't matter the prestige of the comp or the ability of the opposition.

Fck the begrudgers :pac:

True and it gets european qualification sorted early in the season.

The problem is that it's Europa League qualification.

That's pretty meh, tbh, unless you like Thu/Sun games which i don't.

Gbear · 30-10-2014 03:31PM

noodler wrote: »

Playing Chelsea in a semi but Burnley in the final

OR

Playing Burnley in the semi and Chelsea in the final

Should equate to the same feeling of accomplishment for me.

A final isn't just any match!

Maybe you will argue I have misrepresented you again!

The order isn't important. I don't get much out of the overall competition itself.

Beating Chelsea in the Semi would be more important to me than beating Burnley in the final because it's Chelsea. It may as well be comparing two friendlies as far as I'm concerned.

MR NINE · 30-10-2014 03:40PM

Gbear wrote: »

If it had been against Chelsea or something then the game would've mattered more because it's nice to beat Chelsea. But the cup itself is scarcely more important than the Community Shield.

It's a nothing trophy.

I disagree with comparing it to the charity shield. The charity shield is a glorified friendly. The teams competing in it want to win of course, but winning it is just adding a miniscule gloss to whichever trophy they won to gain entry. Playing in the charity shield is a far greater achievement than winning it. The league cup is a cup competition with 90+ teams involved, admittedly some teams dont take it too seriously, but for all but a handful of the entries winning it would be a huge achievement. Even city last year seemed to really want to win it, and their lineup last night would suggest they wanted to win it again this year. Im sure arsenal were desperate to win it when they lost to birmingham. If we dont win a trophy this season thatll be three years without a trophy, thats a long time for a so called big club. Im sure if United or Chelsea went three years without a trophy theyd be desperate to win anything the following year.

Sir Gallagher · 30-10-2014 03:48PM

skywalker wrote: »

The story is on the official site now.

I'm sorry, but Mario clearly isn't smiling properly in this. He's a disease on the beautiful game, he takes the great out of Great Britain.

Rayne Wooney · 30-10-2014 03:50PM

I'd rank the cups/league in the order

Champions league
Premier league
Europa
FA Cup
International champions cup
League Cup
Charity Shield

Gbear · 30-10-2014 03:53PM

MR NINE wrote: »

If we dont win a trophy this season thatll be three years without a trophy, thats a long time for a so called big club. Im sure if United or Chelsea went three years without a trophy theyd be desperate to win anything the following year.

That just sounds like a meaningless box-ticking exercise to me.

Even under Kenny with the two finals, I don't think that really said much for where we were as a club.

It'd be the same now. If a club is in the CL every year it's always in a position to challenge. It might need some investment or a new manager but it's within striking distance. That's something worth gloating about to those who aren't.

With a one-off cup, especially one that has as little cachet and historical value as the LC, it's largely meaningless.

Some cups have enough history, prestige or exclusivity to give them more value - obviously the CL is the pinnacle of club football, but the FA cup and EL do still have some value as well.
But the LC doesn't for me.

Liverpool FC Team Talk/Gossip/Rumours Thread 2014 - Mod Note in OP, 1/09

Comments