Which Apple type for Apple pie

ellejay · 26-02-2014 12:04PM #1

Hi all

Apologies if I'm posting this in the wrong section.

I'm wondering what type of apples do you use for Apple Pie?

I've been using Bramley cooking apples, which is what the supermarkets are selling, but I find the apple filling can be quite sour, regardless of the amount of castor sugar I use.

I'd appreciate any tips / help on this.

Many Thanks,
ellejay

Dizzyblonde · 26-02-2014 01:13PM

I always use Bramleys but you do need a lot of sugar with them. You could use Granny Smiths, they require much less sugar and also keep their shape.

TheKBizzle · 26-02-2014 04:52PM

I use Braeburn apples as they have less moisture and tend to hold their shape better when cooking

Phars · 26-02-2014 05:01PM

I use mainley Bramleys, leave them standing for at least 45 min with lots of sugar and cinnamon, drain them and put on even more sugar. Also I use Splenda powder at times to cut down on sugar. As I mainley make Dutch apple pie I would have raisins mixed in as well, I guess that makes the pie a bit sweeter as well

ellejay · 27-02-2014 11:44AM

Dizzyblonde wrote: »

I always use Bramleys but you do need a lot of sugar with them. You could use Granny Smiths, they require much less sugar and also keep their shape.

Thanks Dizzy blonde
I find I'm using at least 6 heaped tablespoons of sugar, it got to the stage where it's more like sugar pie. I feel bad adding so much sugar I'm hoping a not so bitter apple ,would require less sugar!

ellejay · 27-02-2014 11:45AM

TheKBizzle wrote: »

I use Braeburn apples as they have less moisture and tend to hold their shape better when cooking

Thanks TheBizzle
I will definitely try to get some Braeburns.

ellejay · 27-02-2014 11:49AM

Phars wrote: »

I use mainley Bramleys, leave them standing for at least 45 min with lots of sugar and cinnamon, drain them and put on even more sugar. Also I use Splenda powder at times to cut down on sugar. As I mainley make Dutch apple pie I would have raisins mixed in as well, I guess that makes the pie a bit sweeter as well

Hi Phars

When you say you leave them standing, wold you put them in a sieve and cover with sugar and cinnamon?

I've never added cinnamon, do you add cinnamon for a "cinimony" flavour or does it do something to make the pie less sour? How much do you add to say 4 big Bramley apples?

Thanks for the splenda tip.

Phars · 27-02-2014 12:31PM

Used google translate for my basic recepie, might give it an odd twist like a spoon of brandy with apples

ellejay · 17-03-2014 07:24PM

Hi All

Just a quick update, made a lovely pie with Breburn apple's.
Think next time i'll try a combination of Bramley and Braeburn.

Thank you all for your replies.

GoodBridge · 24-03-2014 08:37PM

A pastry chef told me "the only good cooking apple is a free cooking apple". He said he uses eating apples all the time: granny smiths, galas, even pink ladies if they're on offer.

Which Apple type for Apple pie

Comments