Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Name and Shame Job Bridge

11315171819

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 20,118 ✭✭✭✭road_high


    Last week i was at a party in sligo. My mate who organised it is on a jobbridge scheme up there.

    His boss, or mentor i should say was making him write out an internship description for the fas job bank to advertise for the internship he is currently on so someone can immeadiately replace him. Seeing as they cannot take someone on for the same role right after him, he needed to re-word his job title.

    With all due respect to your friend, if he wants to be treated like a doormat then he will be treated like a doormat.
    That is outrageous and shows the depths to which bosses are sinking to. The scheme gives them so much control it's unreal. Why no prospect of a job after? Answer is simple; why pay staff when you can get thwem fro free. A complaint needs to go in about this behaviour.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    Jesus wept....Why am I NOT surprised by this???


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    Jesus wept....Why am I NOT surprised by this???

    I'm astounded.... I can see the headline now

    "Unscrupulous individual in 'trying to bend the rules for personal gain' shocker". :D


    It's simple. If that fella is writing out an internship description for someone to take over his own job, and he is aware of it, and hasn't got the cop on to report the boss as soon as he's finished, well I'm sorry to say this, but those kinda smarts don't put you at the top of the queue for any job anyway


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    Last week i was at a party in sligo. My mate who organised it is on a jobbridge scheme up there.

    His boss, or mentor i should say was making him write out an internship description for the fas job bank to advertise for the internship he is currently on so someone can immeadiately replace him. Seeing as they cannot take someone on for the same role right after him, he needed to re-word his job title.

    Jaysus, no recession with the parties i Sligeach!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    I just saw This thread here which has since been closed. It seems that if you do a Jobbridge, then you may not be eligible for Fuel Allowance.

    Something to be aware of.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 18,252 ✭✭✭✭uck51js9zml2yt


    I just saw This thread here which has since been closed. It seems that if you do a Jobbridge, then you may not be eligible for Fuel Allowance.

    Something to be aware of.

    3. Will participants keep their secondary benefits (e.g. medical card, rent supplement, mortgage interest supplement, fuel allowance, etc) while participating in JobBridge?
    Yes, participants will keep any additional benefits that they were receiving immediately prior to taking up an internship.


    http://www.welfare.ie/EN/Press/PressReleases/2011/Pages/pr290611.aspx


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    I am aware of this. But if you read the thread, it seems that if you might otherwise have been eligible for the FA if you didn't take the internship, then it won't be granted as when doing the internship you're taken off the Live Register.

    Makes a huge difference in finances if you're affected, as the posters on that thread have shown.

    That is why I linked that thread as a heads up.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    I don't understand the problem??

    If I do a college course and come out of it and don't qualify for the fuel allowance is that fair?

    It's the same scenario. I could easily say "well if I hadn't done the course, I could have claimed for the last four years and I'd get it now"


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    It's not the same. A college course and UB are like chalk & cheese. So it's silly to say that.

    If you're long-term unemployed, then in order to qualify for the E23 Fuel Allowance, you have to be unemployed for 390 days (15 mths). This makes a big difference in the winter months.

    Now. If you take a JB position, having been unemployed for say 300 days. The days that you are on the JB DO NOT count as time unemployed as you are taken off the Live Register. Which means that as you only have 300 qualifying days, you will not be able to claim FA, until the remaining 90 days are 'made up'

    That is why it could potentially be a problem if you're not already claiming FA. I suspect it might also be a problem claiming Rent Allowance as well, but stand to be corrected on that.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    It's not the same. A college course and UB are like chalk & cheese. So it's silly to say that.

    If you're long-term unemployed, then in order to qualify for the E23 Fuel Allowance, you have to be unemployed for 390 days (15 mths). This makes a big difference in the winter months.

    Now. If you take a JB position, having been unemployed for say 300 days. The days that you are on the JB DO NOT count as time unemployed as you are taken off the Live Register. Which means that as you only have 300 qualifying days, you will not be able to claim FA, until the remaining 90 days are 'made up'

    That is why it could potentially be a problem if you're not already claiming FA. I suspect it might also be a problem claiming Rent Allowance as well, but stand to be corrected on that.

    Does the 390 days have a finite life? If someone is only just starting on the dole and they take a jobsbridge, they are prolonging their wait until they get fuel allowance...but aren't they also prolonging their entitlement to JSA?

    If a wife loses her job, she is entitled to one of them for a year or whatever regardless of her husbands salary. After that time is up, she goes under the other scheme and is assessed on her husbands income. If she does an internship/course, it prolongs her own entitlement. If you want the scheme to count as being on the dole, it will fu$k those people over.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    yore wrote: »
    Does the 390 days have a finite life? If someone is only just starting on the dole and they take a jobsbridge, they are prolonging their wait until they get fuel allowance...but aren't they also prolonging their entitlement to JSB?

    You can't just start the dole and then take a JB. You have to be unemployed at least 3 months before you're considered for one. Whether you're on JSB (if you're lucky) or JSA (if you're unfortunate enough to have the stamps run out) doesn't matter.

    When the JB ends, and you haven't been taken on by the host organisation or found alternative employment, you simply sign back on. That's it. So yes, the clock then starts 'running' again.

    Edit I've just seen your edit. What you're saying isn't quite true. Using your example, the wife is entitled to JSB if she has enough qualifying stamps. It is not means tested. When they run out, of if there's not enough qualifying stamps, she can apply for JSA which may or may not be granted, partially or in full depending on the spouse's earnings. So I'm not quite sure what point you're making here. Who is being ****ed over here? The unlucky interns or the employers??


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    You can't just start the dole and then take a JB. You have to be unemployed at least 3 months before you're considered for one. Whether you're on JSB (if you're lucky) or JSA (if you're unfortunate enough to have the stamps run out) doesn't matter.

    When the JB ends, and you haven't been taken on by the host organisation or found alternative employment, you simply sign back on. That's it. So yes, the clock then starts 'running' again.


    Sorry, I wasn't sure which was which - JSA/JSB

    But my point is valid. Stopping the clock is hugely beneficial for those people who would be assessed on their partners income when their own entitlement runs out. I wouldn't say it's fair to screw them out of maybe 6 months payments for the sake of an odd person who has to wait a few months extra for a fuel allowance!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    Sorry. My edits messed up the flow

    This is my scenario.

    Woman works for years, loses job on 1st Jan. Her husband has a good job so she won't get much at all, if anything, on JSA. Her stamps will run out on Dec 31st but on 1st June she gets a 9 month internship. She finishes this on 31st March and unfortunately has to sign on again. But as far as I'm aware, she will still have 6 months entitlements left whereas if you count the jobsbridge scheme as dole, she'd go for JSA and get feck all


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,822 ✭✭✭sunflower27


    yore wrote: »
    Sorry. My edits messed up the flow

    This is my scenario.

    Woman works for years, loses job on 1st Jan. Her husband has a good job so she won't get much at all, if anything, on JSA. Her stamps will run out on Dec 31st but on 1st June she gets a 9 month internship. She finishes this on 31st March and unfortunately has to sign on again. But as far as I'm aware, she will still have 6 months entitlements left whereas if you count the jobsbridge scheme as dole, she'd go for JSA and get feck all

    I am the person who missed out on Fuel Allowance.

    I am single and once my stamps ran out was put on JSA at the same rate. There is no other income to take into account and never was. Moving to JA was a simple procedure for me once I was means tested and I knew it would be.

    Am not letting this go though. This is wrong no matter which way you look at it or try and dress it up.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    I am the person who missed out on Fuel Allowance.

    I am single and once my stamps ran out was put on JSA at the same rate. There is no other income to take into account and never was. Moving to JA was a simple procedure for me once I was means tested and I knew it would be.

    Am not letting this go though. This is wrong no matter which way you look at it or try and dress it up.

    Translation:
    "I want the rules change because I feel entitled to that 20 euro. Even though changing the rules would take months of benefits away from lots of users, I don't care"

    Your case would be extremely rare. It only affects people who did the jobs bridge and are heading into a winter with between what, 320 and 389 days claiming. you want that changed and all those other people to do without their benefits so that you can get an extra 20 Euro.

    Why is it wrong? You are already getting something for nothing. It certainly is a truism that the more you give people, the more they'll want!


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    So you would rather work on the Jobbridge in the summer, and struggle to pay the winter bills then as you can't claim FA if you haven't already? No, I didn't think so. And NO sunflower's case is NOT rare if you bothered to read the other thread. This will be happening more and more. Welfare haven't exactly made this clear if you read up about it.

    In what case is are these people getting something for nothing? They've paid tax and paid stamps. What are you talking about??

    I just hope you'll never be in this sorry position...


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    So you would rather work on the Jobbridge in the summer, and struggle to pay the winter bills then as you can't claim FA if you haven't already? No, I didn't think so. And NO sunflower's case is NOT rare if you bothered to read the other thread. This will be happening more and more. Welfare haven't exactly made this clear if you read up about it.

    In what case is are these people getting something for nothing? They've paid tax and paid stamps. What are you talking about??

    I just hope you'll never be in this sorry position...


    I presume that if one has a fuel allowance, you also have a house and are getting rent allowance/mortgage relief. Add in the medical card and everything else and sure it's no wonder that people are "happy" to stay stuck in a rut.

    And yes, I'd rather work in jobsbridge for the Summer. I'd just get a job after it and not be worrying about handouts! I'd move if I had to. There's work there if you really want it. It might be work for the sake of work and not matching your own personal lofty ambitions, but it's there. And if you'd prefer to upskill, use your time in the local library. It'd be like being a student only getting paid for it when other students get no money.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    I replied, but rapidly got bored. Thread is being derailed by nonsense.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,822 ✭✭✭sunflower27


    yore wrote: »
    Translation:
    "I want the rules change because I feel entitled to that 20 euro. Even though changing the rules would take months of benefits away from lots of users, I don't care"

    Your case would be extremely rare. It only affects people who did the jobs bridge and are heading into a winter with between what, 320 and 389 days claiming. you want that changed and all those other people to do without their benefits so that you can get an extra 20 Euro.

    Why is it wrong? You are already getting something for nothing. It certainly is a truism that the more you give people, the more they'll want!


    I know it riles you Yore, but I will get the payment and come back here and report on it:D

    The only rule I want changed is for my days on jobbridge to count towards my fuel allowance. I am at 320 days, but with my 9 months on my internship I am well over that.

    The only reason I was taken off the live register, despite being paid a SW payment during my JobBridge, is so the government could be seen to improving unemployment figures.

    Where did I say I want anyone to lose their benefits? You have lost me????

    And finally, I will take what I should be entitled to.

    FWIW, my local sw office told me that the system wasvery unfair and should be changed so that days on JobBridge still count as signing on.

    Anyway, will be back when I have the payment. :)


  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 389 ✭✭micromary


    Just think that Yore is one of those people who does not live in the real world. They live in cloud cuckoo land as far as i can make out.


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    I know it riles you Yore, but I will get the payment and come back here and report on it:D

    No, it doesn't rile me. If an extra 20 quid from the state is an achievement for you then I wish you well and hope you enjoy it.
    What despairs and depresses me for people to have an "entitlement" attitude, not the money. It's their own waste. We all know people who were happy to drift along claiming the dole and living in the welfare houses when they could have achieved so much more in life.


    Where did I say I want anyone to lose their benefits? You have lost me????
    I explained it. I will give my example again is language you might understand. Ann is married to Barry. They both have been working for years. ann gets let go on 1st January 2012. She has enough stamps to last her until 31st Dec 2012. She wouldn't get dole otherwise based on tom's wages. In July she gets offered an internship which she completes on 31st March 2013. She doesn't get kept on but still has 6 months benefit left and can claim until the end of October 2013.

    Under your proposal, Ann's jobsbridge days counts as signing on and her entitlements run out on 31st Dec 2012. You should know this more than me. you seem to be well up on all the "entitlements" and schemes
    And finally, I will take what I should be entitled to.
    Need I say any more?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,127 ✭✭✭yore


    micromary wrote: »
    Just think that Yore is one of those people who does not live in the real world. They live in cloud cuckoo land as far as i can make out.

    Yeah you might be right.

    You should write a heartwarming struggle of your story of survival against all odds in the real world. I'll send it over to some starving kids. It doesn't matter where, there are no shortage of them around the world. I just hope it makes them realise how lucky they are in their little bubbles of starvation and disease.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,822 ✭✭✭sunflower27


    LOL yore

    If the SW department have told me they will be raising my case at their next management meeting then even they are on my side thatI am entitled to the money, which I am.

    I paid taxes for11 years,damn straight I am going to go for an extra €20 at a low time when I need it.

    You can try and shove me in the dole bludger camp all you like :D

    I am so far from that... but work away with your generalised comments.

    :)

    Was surprised to see you still on here, saying again and again that Jobbridge is not the scam so many seem to think it is.

    Fair play, you are certainly dedicated to your cause. :)

    Edit: WIth regards to Ann & Barry,of course Anne's stamps should be stopped while she doing a jobbridge internship at €10 a day - there has to be some advantages, but Jobbridge should not stop people getting fuel allowance in the winter or long term unemployment benefits when they do a FAS course (there is a €20/week payment if you are in a full-time FAS course and have in excess of 312 days signing on - and yes, I am up on this entitlement as I am doing a full-time FAS course. I would be pretty thick not to know about it when my classmates discuss it :D )


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 556 ✭✭✭sligoface


    sunflower it's best to just ignore posts from people like yore who are of the opinion that all of the half a million people on the dole in this country are all scroungers and who does a dance of joy when he hears of a struggling person being denied an entitlement to help they need. Anyone who says things like 'i would just work jobbridge in the summer and get a job after and not be worrying about handouts' obviously has no idea of what the unemployed are facing. the fact that you are doing an internship shows you are not one who is happy to sponge and most would agree you should be entitled to fuel allowance since you are unable to find full time paid work (thanks in part, to the jobbridge free labour scheme).

    The fact is that many people like sunflower and myself have been denied a 20 euro fuel allowance that they would otherwise be entitled to if they didn't do jobbridge. a large portion of people on jobbridge are in their first year of unemployment, ie: recent graduates, or people who have just been made redundant. they are not layabouts so they are doing something that they think is going to help them become more employable. And there's no way a person shouldn't be punished for that by being denied a fuel entitlement - after all, it's not a 'fun and games' entitlement, it's for heating your home, a basic need. Of course some people will think we just want the extra 20 for fags and booze but most of us don't.
    In any case, when you consider that you earn 50 euro from the scheme but are simultaneously denied 20 euro because of the scheme, you are effectively working full time for euro a week or 6 euro a day. that is unacceptable to any sane person.

    Also, the fact that this information is nowhere on their website or in the contract is a major concern. I believe it was most likely left off on purpose so that interns wouldn't know about it until it was too late and were faced with either leaving the internship and losing the fifty euro and on top of that still having to wait months until they qualified for fuel allowance, or stay on the scheme because they can't afford to heat our homes otherwise. I have contacted them and they said they intend to make the information more visible but have not done so yet.

    The thread about interns not being able to get fuel allowance was closed, don't know why it was as it is obviously still a talking point, and this thread was more about name and shaming companies taking advantage of free labour which is very important because the government won't do scrap the scheme and companies will use it unless it hurts their bottom line, for example, if all of us who are unemployed or have family who are unemployed stop doing business with them. Tesco pulled out of the scheme we need to try and get other companies to do the same. Like Centra.

    Finally getting around to what Ireally came to do: was post this link http://bit.ly/RBnYP4

    This exact ad for a jobbridge intern was on the fas website two weeks ago as a paid position and has now changed into an internship. I guess someone must have sent Centra a memo about the free labour available on jobbridge.

    Surely not even yore can defend the fact that large chain stores like Centra with a turnover of over half a billion a year are taking entry level jobs like working in shops out of the economy and replacing them with unpaid internships. That position would clearly be a job for someone in the community as working in a shop traditionally is.

    In fact, if you do a search in my area (sligo) for jobs on the FAS website and for type enter the value: Jobs, you get 28 (a good portion of which are part time temporary, etc). When you enter Interns, you get 31. CE scheme =13. Says it all really about where this country is headed if schemes like Jobbridge are allowed to continue. It's either work for free or emigrate. And if you can't afford to emigrate and don't want to work for free, then you will be at the mercy of the government's crusade against welfare payments.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,822 ✭✭✭sunflower27


    What doyou know, sligoface, that internship states:

    Ability to work in a busy and multi-tasked environment. Availability to work late shifts, weekends and bank holidays.


    Of f*cking course that is when you would work.

    I heard the scheme was towind up in July next year. I hope so. maybe then I will be able to find paid work.

    As someone who worked and paid taxes for 10 straight years, I have no shame accepting any entitlements. Icertainly don't want to live on the dole forever and won't, but agree that yes, there are people out there that would begrudge the unemployed everything if they could.

    It could just as easily happen to anyone.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 20,118 ✭✭✭✭road_high


    What doyou know, sligoface, that internship states:

    Ability to work in a busy and multi-tasked environment. Availability to work late shifts, weekends and bank holidays.


    Of f*cking course that is when you would work.

    I heard the scheme was towind up in July next year. I hope so. maybe then I will be able to find paid work.

    As someone who worked and paid taxes for 10 straight years, I have no shame accepting any entitlements. Icertainly don't want to live on the dole forever and won't, but agree that yes, there are people out there that would begrudge the unemployed everything if they could.

    It could just as easily happen to anyone.

    Where you hear this Sunflower? If so it's good news. Though I'd prefer it be abolished immediately (it should be).


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 4,822 ✭✭✭sunflower27


    mfitzy wrote: »
    Where you hear this Sunflower? If so it's good news. Though I'd prefer it be abolished immediately (it should be).

    Hi, it is all over the web. I got this off citizensinformation.ie :)
    1. JobBridge, the National Internship scheme provides work experience opportunities ... The scheme started on 1 July 2011 and will be open until 30 June 2013.
    'opportunities....for employers' ;)

    Can't wait for it to end :)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 1,927 ✭✭✭paddyp


    Well as a 36 year old with a degree in electronic engineering the only job I could find relevant to my degree and experience is now an internship in design wtf! it doesn't get more specialised than that.

    As my wife is working when my stamps run out I'd get about €70 per week, childcare €280 per week + travel costs €30 so I'm down €240 per week.

    And this for a position that would have been €22-€26k euro starting with no experience 5 years ago.

    Another example my friend works for a specialised building services company his colleague who had the most experience in the company left for a job in England and was replaced with two interns straight out of school. Which basically means that my friend is doing both jobs and training in two numbnuts at the same time.

    Some contract work I have been doing privately on and off for 3 years has also been given to an intern leaving me 5000-16000 euro out of pocket. This internship may be great for employers but its putting skilled people on the dole. I think its time to setup a company and hire some interns.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    Hi, it is all over the web. I got this off citizensinformation.ie :)
    1. JobBridge, the National Internship scheme provides work experience opportunities ... The scheme started on 1 July 2011 and will be open until 30 June 2013.
    'opportunities....for employers' ;)

    Can't wait for it to end :)

    I wouldn't get too excited. This is manna from heaven for the crooked politicians and greedy employers. It is NOT going to end, trust me on that one. Sorry to be so cynical...:(


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 8,411 ✭✭✭ABajaninCork


    People. Things are about to get an awful lot worse!

    See here

    And here

    Not content with trying to humiliate the unemployed, they're now trying to criminalise us!

    Be afraid. Be very afraid.


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement