Advertisement
Help Keep Boards Alive. Support us by going ad free today. See here: https://subscriptions.boards.ie/.
https://www.boards.ie/group/1878-subscribers-forum

Private Group for paid up members of Boards.ie. Join the club.
Hi all, please see this major site announcement: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058427594/boards-ie-2026

Are there inconsistencies and contradictions in the Quran ?

2»

Comments

  • Banned (with Prison Access) Posts: 1,081 ✭✭✭jcf


    Hi all, I've come across the following passages in the Quran that appear to inconsistent or a contradiction ?

    What are the Muslim explanations for each of these ?

    2:23.If you have doubts about our revelations to our servant (Mohammad) call on your martyrs (Shohadaikum).
    - Should it be call on your partners (Shorakaikum) as no one would call on the dead people to witness anything ?

    86:7 human sperms originate from between the back and the ribs
    - Yet we know sperms originate from the testicles ?

    4: 78, 79. Verse 78 says that all actions good or evil come from God while the verse 79 says that good comes from God while evil comes from humans ?

    37:139-145 Jona ( Younis) was ejected from the belly of the whale, while in 68:48-49 Jona was not ejected. Which is it ejected or not ejected ?

    2:6-7 God blinded the unbelievers as he closed their hearts, their vision and their hearing. Why would God, who wanted everyone to believe, do that ?

    2:10 The kuffars are sick in their hearts and God increased their sickness.
    - Is that logical that God would increase their sickness instead of healing them ?

    2: 264 God does not guide the Kuffars.
    - But why ? who needs guidance the believer or the unbeliever?

    4:88 Do you want to guide those that God had misled?
    - Why would the all loving God mislead his own creatures?

    6:149 If God wished He would have guided all of you.
    - It seems God did not wish to guide all, why he did not want everyone to believe ?

    13: 33 If God misleads his creature no one can guide them.
    - Why would the most merciful mislead his creatures, and also not want anyone else to guide them. ?

    14:4 God misleads whoever He wants and guide whoever he wants.
    - Is God selective in guidance?

    91:8 God inspires humans their good and evil.
    - If God, in His unlimited capability, inspires good and evil for all beings, have we any other alternative when God has already inspired it ?
    - Does Repentance means anything when such a decision of God has already been made ?

    18:83-86 Zu-El Qarnin found out that the sun sets in a hole of murky water. How does the sun which is so much larger than the earth set in a murky hole on the same earth ?

    Such a statement is attributed not only to Zu-Al Qarnin, in holy hadeeth Mohammad (PBUH) also confirmsmthe setting of the sun in a hole of murky water to Abu-Darr ?

    23:12-14 in Quranic embryology a stage is reached when it becomes bones then the bones are dressed with flesh.
    - Yet in the womb, flesh and bones are developed simultaneously ?

    17:1 Mohammad visited Al-Masjid Al-Aqsa.
    - Yet there was no Masjid Al-Aqsa nor any other masjid during the life of Mohammad.
    Islam entered Palestine after Omar Bin El Khattab conquered Palestine after the death of the prophet. Al-Masjid Al-Aqsa was built almost sixty years after the death of Mohammad by Marwan bin Abdelmalik ?

    23:14 blessed Allah the best of all creators.
    - How many creators do we have?

    88: 20 The earth has been flattened.
    - Is this not a contradiction to science ?

    5: 73 He blasphemes who says that God is one of three gods.
    - Yet Christianity does not claim that there are three gods.
    Why does Mohammad (PBUH) seem confused about the trinity belief which describes God as one, with three different personalities ?

    31:10 God created the heavens and supported them with invisible pillars.
    - What are these invisable pillars and where are they ?

    71:15-16 God created the seven stories heavens and made the moon as a source of light in these heavens.
    - Yet the moon is not a source of light, it merely reflects sunlight ?


    Hahahaahh. You may as well question messages written in sh,it in a lunatic asylum ....


Advertisement