Queen to Replace Freddie with some guy from American Idol

allanb49 · 03-02-2012 01:35PM #1

American Idol winner Adam Lambert is rumoured to be joining Queen as their new vocalist for a tour rumoured for this summer.

Lambert teamed up with the band at the EMAs to perform Queen classics 'The Show Must Go On' and 'We Are The Champions' and reportedly impressed Queen so much that they're considering him for a more full time position within the group.

Lambert said: "After the EMAs, I heard faint little slithers of backlash from people saying: 'You can't replace Freddie Mercury.' But I already knew that. There's no intention in my mind of replacing Freddie. That's impossible. The way I'm choosing to view it is that it's a great honour and one I'm in no way going to shirk."

Link

I'm losing more and more respect for May and Taylor as time goes on.

Just let it be, Move on and stop trying to resurrect something irreplaceable,

Scram · 03-02-2012 01:38PM

there replacing "a gay" with "a gay"? Seems logical

Irish Aris · 03-02-2012 01:52PM

Scram wrote: »

there replacing "a gay" with "a gay"? Seems logical

true, and I guess he's flamboyant enough (not sure how he will sound live).

Well, Freddie Mercury can't be replaced and the same applies for other bands too - the likes of INXS, Doors etc.
But if they want to do it, fine by me. I mean, I have never actually seen Freddie Mercury perform live except for DVDs/Videos, but still it would be different listening to the songs from someone else.
That said, I think Brian May is a superb guitarist

Scram · 03-02-2012 01:55PM

Irish Aris wrote: »

true, and I guess he's flamboyant enough (not sure how he will sound live).

Well, Freddie Mercury can't be replaced and the same applies for other bands too - the likes of INXS, Doors etc.
But if they want to do it, fine by me. I mean, I have never actually seen Freddie Mercury perform live except for DVDs/Videos, but still it would be different listening to the songs from someone else.
That said, I think Brian May is a superb guitarist

No doubt, its a strange one alright but at least people get to see and experience the other members of the band.

Motley Crue · 03-02-2012 05:01PM

Scram wrote: »

No doubt, its a strange one alright but at least people get to see and experience the other members of the band.

Yes, and also May is probably doing this because he's helping to admit the biggest, most important fact of all....that music is bigger then the mortal men involved, and in 10 years May won't be able to perform AT ALL...so he might as well get out and give the world what he wants. Plus, what other band which has lost its original vocalist 20 years ago gets to headline Knebworth 40 years after the band was founded?

adox · 04-02-2012 03:29PM

The lead singer of Keane is the only one I've seen do justice to a Queen song since Feddies death. I'd probably go and see them if he was on board.

Kess73 · 04-02-2012 04:24PM

adox wrote: »

The lead singer of Keane is the only one I've seen do justice to a Queen song since Feddies death. I'd probably go and see them if he was on board.

George Michael has covered a few Queen tracks and sounded bloody good. Heard Mika covering some of the 70's stuff and he sounded good as well, but I don't think he could handle some of Rockier stuff anywhere near as well as Freddie.

As for Lambert, have no idea what he would sound like fronting Queen. I am not overly keen on him based on what I can find of him online, but maybe he has the range to surprise folk and do a good job with Queen's music.

There will never be another Freddie, but Queen's music coupled with a singer who can do even 50% of what Freddie could would be a good live listen imho.

grimm2005 · 04-02-2012 05:32PM

Freddie Nelson would have been a good man to get on board (although I'm firmly in the "what's the point without Freddie Mercury?" camp). He did a collaboration with Paul Gilbert and has also done some Queen covers, but I guess he's too much of an "unknown" to get in:

adox · 04-02-2012 07:46PM

Heres the Tom Chaplin one I was talking about:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPB0h7g9JwA

ush · 04-02-2012 07:59PM

They did this before with Paul Rodgers and there was a huge Freddie Mercury size gap at the front of the stage. At least Deacon still has his intregrity.

Have they made bad investments or can they not keep funding their lifestyles on past record sales?

Owen · 04-02-2012 08:02PM

In fairness to Tom from Keane, the first time I heard that performance I closed my eyes and at times it really did sound like Freddie!

kumate_champ07 · 04-02-2012 08:05PM

Kess73 wrote: »

George Michael has covered a few Queen tracks and sounded bloody good. Heard Mika covering some of the 70's stuff and he sounded good as well, but I don't think he could handle some of Rockier stuff anywhere near as well as Freddie.

As for Lambert, have no idea what he would sound like fronting Queen. I am not overly keen on him based on what I can find of him online, but maybe he has the range to surprise folk and do a good job with Queen's music.

There will never be another Freddie, but Queen's music coupled with a singer who can do even 50% of what Freddie could would be a good live listen imho.

that sounds like it would work

adox · 04-02-2012 08:17PM

Of course Hetfield did a great version of Stone Cold Crazy with them but that song was really specifically suited to his vocal style

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QwUp_MDHU4

symbolic · 05-02-2012 01:29PM

adox wrote: »

Heres the Tom Chaplin one I was talking about:

That's really good!

Motley Crue · 05-02-2012 01:41PM

adox wrote: »

Heres the Tom Chaplin one I was talking about:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPB0h7g9JwA

That performance was excellent, but just a small correction for Brian

A version of 'It's A Hard Life' was performed live in Rio in 1985 and on their tour of Japan and is now on the second disc of the special edition of the 2011 remastered version of The Works

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tEXm5974kUc

D1976 · 05-02-2012 01:48PM

I thought this guy was picked and was meant to be touring with them, he sounds amazing

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dREKkAk628I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NyC77mlkyXA

Motley Crue · 05-02-2012 09:01PM

D1976 wrote: »

I thought this guy was picked and was meant to be touring with them, he sounds amazing

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dREKkAk628I

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NyC77mlkyXA

He was a favorite for the tribute band that Roger Taylor was supposed to be setting up to tour America last year. Haven't heard much beyond the original auditions but I assume the band will be touring to some description.

sham69 · 06-02-2012 11:47AM

Love queen but its time to call it a day.
By all means tour under another guise or whatever, I didn't like the Paul Rodgers thing so not going to like this either.

I was offered a free ticket to the Paul Rodgers gig in Dublin with a chance to meet Brian as a mate is related to him (ex inlaw) and declined.
Kind of sorry as it would have been great to meet him but I am not into the whole new singer thing with bands.
I'm also a big country fan but won't be going to see them for the same reason.

The only 2 singers I have heard doing justice to Freddie's voice are George Michael and Gary Cherone from Extreme.
I wouldn't be a big fan of Cherone and joining Van Halen was a disaster but he was great at the tribute gig for Freddie.

Honourable mention to Seal's rendition of Who wants to live forever, which was amazing apart from him singing it too fast...

Motley Crue · 06-02-2012 07:28PM

sham69 wrote: »

I was offered a free ticket to the Paul Rodgers gig in Dublin with a chance to meet Brian as a mate is related to him (ex inlaw) and declined.

sham69 · 06-02-2012 09:57PM

I got an autograph though....:D
I actually missed 2 opportunities to meet him, on the last night of we will rock you in the O2, Brian and rog turned up, I could have gotten back stage and all but again declined.
Next time they play i am guaranteed a meet so won't be so quick to turn it down...

Motley Crue · 07-02-2012 08:04AM

sham69 wrote: »

I got an autograph though....:D

Well that's cool

sham69 wrote: »

I actually missed 2 opportunities to meet him, on the last night of we will rock you in the O2, Brian and rog turned up, I could have gotten back stage and all but again declined.

Oh no, that's it....

There is a quadruple one but I won't bother

smilerf · 07-02-2012 08:15AM

of course not a man but Patti Russo has covered some queen songs brilliantly

RonMexico · 07-02-2012 02:37PM

http://www.metatube.com/en/videos/84169/Queen-Global-Icon-Award-Adam-Lambert-MTV-EMA-2011/

Video of Adam Lambert & Queen performing last November at the EMA's - Show Must Go On/We Will Rock You/We Are the Champions Medley.

triggermortis · 08-02-2012 04:35AM

I wish they'd just let it be. Freddie is gone and will never be forgotten, so do we need Queen karaoke?
I don't mind bands doing cover versions, but this will be Queen doing Queen covers.

Just leave it!

Kess73 · 08-02-2012 01:35PM

RonMexico wrote: »

http://www.metatube.com/en/videos/84169/Queen-Global-Icon-Award-Adam-Lambert-MTV-EMA-2011/

Video of Adam Lambert & Queen performing last November at the EMA's - Show Must Go On/We Will Rock You/We Are the Champions Medley.

Uggghhh. Had not heard him sing a Queen song before, but I don't like how his voice sounds on those three songs. Something very annoying and bland about his voice.

The guy in Motley Crue's post has a much better Queen voice and even has a little bit of a resemblance to Freddie if being a Queen cover band is what May/Taylor want to become.

Bluefoam · 09-02-2012 05:54AM

I read somewhere (probably on Blabbermouth) that this rumor is untrue. He is not singing with the band...

windingo · 09-02-2012 10:10AM

I haven't heard this guy Adam, but seriously Queen replacing Freddie (one of the most iconic rockstars of all time) with someone who won American Idol! I personally think this is a disgrace if Queen are seriously thinking about this. I think no matter how good anybody is Queen shouldn't replace him he made Queen who they are.

grames_bond · 09-02-2012 07:57PM

Funny thing is he DIDN'T win American idol - because he is a nasely little winey screachy voiced poser!!

Queen to Replace Freddie with some guy from American Idol

Comments