Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Its official : public sector pay per hour is 49% higher than private sector

1565759616280

Comments

  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,897 ✭✭✭MagicSean


    gigino wrote: »
    In London and other big uk cities they used to say that when you drunk a glass of water, it had been drunken eight times before ;). With so much water falling in Ireland over such a wide, green area for a much smaller population, you would think that if anyone needed the filtration, it would be those across the water.

    Anyway, tap water should be safe enough to drink, it does not say much for the government if its not. At least in this country private houses do not pay water rates, or property tax. Thats a huge saving compared to the UK, in fairness.


    Yes it is usually safe to drink, assuming you dont mind drinking brown water. But it is also very hard in many areas and does massive damage to pipes and appliances unless the home owner installs a treatment system. Perhaps you should look into this topic before you comment any further on it as you seem to have little knowledge of how much it costs to get proper water in the country. I'd welcome water charges if it meant I didn't have to have a water treatment plant in my kitchen, as would many people living in hard water areas.
    Finland with similar prices, but much lower wages for public servants will be more appropriate

    The average wage in Ireland isn't comparable to other countries because the structure of the Irish public sector is wrong. It is too bloated in the middle to allow for a proper comparison on this basis. This is the first thing which should be addressed.

    If you wish to look at comparing individual wages you need to take into account the number of deductions public sector workers pay. PAYE, PRSI, USC, Pension Levy, mandatory pension deductions. There are also other things to look at such as benefits. In Ireland you have to pay for proper medical care. Finland has a superb public healthcare system and private healthcare is rare.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    bryaner wrote: »
    Up north 2 months ago, €1.429 per liter for petrol here £1.199 there

    Sorry to have to correct you yet again, but even an auld dog who lives along the border would know which side of the border , petrol and diesel is cheapest on, by observing which side of the border people fill up on. This has been consistently the case over the past 10-15 years, say the lifetime of the dog in question. You really have no excuse for your ignorance. Please check your facts . If you have filled your tank up north and thought it was cheaper, you were done ! You probably bought nappies up north too and thought they were cheaper. Sorry, they can be got cheaper down here now than in Asda.
    Anyway, do'nt take my word for it, ask anyone who lives along the border.
    Or look at the following AA survey from February.

    http://www.aaireland.ie/AA/Motoring-advice/Petrol-Prices.aspx



    [Irish Petrol Prices : February 2011

    AA Surveyed in February (avg. retail price per litre)

    Rep. of Ireland : Unleaded petrol 144.5 ; diesel 138.5

    GB Sterling : Unleaded petrol (£ 131.9) € 155.8 ; diesel ( £132.5 ) € 156.5


    The AA do historical price guides for fuel, you can check that too. Or have a look at any other fuel price survey on the net if you think the AA is in on the conspiracy to lower any current average 47k Irish public sector salary towards the average UK public sector salary of £22 to 23 k.

    As you can see its considerably cheaper for petrol / diesel on this side of the border. If misguided public servants like you think otherwise, what else do you get wrong ? Please fill up this side of the border any more. Not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,181 ✭✭✭bryaner


    gigino wrote: »
    Sorry to have to correct you yet again, but even an auld dog who lives along the border would know which side of the border , petrol and diesel is cheapest on, by observing which side of the border people fill up on. This has been consistently the case over the past 10-15 years, say the lifetime of the dog in question. You really have no excuse for your ignorance. Please check your facts . If you have filled your tank up north and thought it was cheaper, you were done ! You probably bought nappies up north too and thought they were cheaper. Sorry, they can be got cheaper down here now than in Asda.
    Anyway, do'nt take my word for it, ask anyone who lives along the border.
    Or look at the following AA survey from February.

    http://www.aaireland.ie/AA/Motoring-advice/Petrol-Prices.aspx



    [Irish Petrol Prices : February 2011

    AA Surveyed in February (avg. retail price per litre)

    Rep. of Ireland : Unleaded petrol 144.5 ; diesel 138.5

    GB Sterling : Unleaded petrol (£ 131.9) € 155.8 ; diesel ( £132.5 ) € 156.5


    The AA do historical price guides for fuel, you can check that too. Or have a look at any other fuel price survey on the net if you think the AA is in on the conspiracy to lower any current average 47k Irish public sector salary towards the average UK public sector salary of £22 to 23 k.

    As you can see its considerably cheaper for petrol / diesel on this side of the border. If misguided public servants like you think otherwise, what else do you get wrong ? Please fill up this side of the border any more. Not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    CAN YOU READ I BOUGHT KEROSENE 9C CHEAPER PER LITRE IN THE NORTH


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,181 ✭✭✭bryaner


    sollar wrote: »
    Gigino claims he doesn't have a private sector boss. He is obviously not a public servant. So he is either unemployed or self employed. My guess is a farmer ;)

    I'd guess failed business man..


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 42,341 Mod ✭✭✭✭Gumbo


    gigino wrote: »
    As you can see its considerably cheaper for petrol / diesel on this side of the border. If misguided public servants like you think otherwise, what else do you get wrong ? Please fill up this side of the border any more. Not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    why would he fill up this side of the border when its cheaper in NI?you should really read other peoples post before replying as it looks like you live in your student bubble ;)

    he is saving 9c per litre, so depending on the size of the tank on site he is making a hefty saving ;)


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 7,476 ✭✭✭ardmacha


    Sorry to have to correct you yet again, but even an auld dog who lives along the border would know which side of the border , petrol and diesel is cheapest on, by observing which side of the border people fill up on.

    Many's the cute oul hound living along the border knows rightly that the red diesel is the cheapest of all. ;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    kceire wrote: »

    Diesel and petrol is and has been for many years cheaper on the southern side of the border, as everyone living close to the border knows. I showed you the AA survey link to prove my point.
    kceire wrote: »
    you should really read other peoples post before replying as it looks like you live in your student bubble ;)


    I am not a student and do not live in a bubble , and I do read others posts. He is obviously telling lies and I proved his "Up north 2 months ago, €1.429 per liter for petrol here £1.199 there" statement to be incorrect.

    Again I plead to you to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,181 ✭✭✭bryaner


    gigino wrote: »
    Diesel and petrol is and has been for many years cheaper on the southern side of the border, as everyone living close to the border knows. I showed you the AA survey link to prove my point.




    I am not a student and do not live in a bubble , and I do read others posts. He is obviously telling lies and I proved his "Up north 2 months ago, €1.429 per liter for petrol here £1.199 there" statement to be incorrect.

    Again I plead to you to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    One trick pony, it is impossible to educate pork..


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    bryaner wrote: »
    I'd guess failed business man..
    No way is he in the public sector. He posts 24/7 :D. everyone knows public sector uses websense and other filters so they can't be on the internet all day long. The way he cries and whinges about estate agents and buying apartments to provide for a pension he's obviously lost daddy's money in the property market and is now looking for someone to blame.
    Its obvious he's a WUM. Why hasn't he been banned?
    I suppose he would just post the same crap as one of his alter egos. Some of it is very funny though.:D he's either really really intellectually challenged or a comedy genius.:)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    Current uk petrol prices
    http://www.petrolprices.com/price-of-petrol.html
    Current irish petrol prices
    http://www.pumps.ie/
    use a currency converter. Feck all difference.
    On average (Because Japer likes averages) Cost of motoring in Ireland is WAY more expensive than cost of motoring in UK.... FACT!
    End of Story! You simply cannot prove motoring is cheaper here....It isn't!


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    He posts 24/7
    I do not actually ( not that its any of your business how I spend my non-working time ).


    lol lol. that not current uk petrol price. Thats an out of date website showing

    "If a litre of unleaded cost 126.9p, it would be split in the following way: blah blah blah ".


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    I do not actually ( not that its any of your business how I spend my non-working time ).




    lol lol. that not current uk petrol price. Thats an out of date website showing

    "If a litre of unleaded cost 126.9p, it would be split in the following way: blah blah blah ".

    OOps! Link opens on the wrong page. But as I said, feck all difference.

    http://www.petrolprices.com/index.html?invalidlocation=Belfast

    Petrol prices on 10th March in Belfast. The price will have gone up again since then. Wrong again sonny!:D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,897 ✭✭✭MagicSean


    gigino wrote: »
    Diesel and petrol is and has been for many years cheaper on the southern side of the border, as everyone living close to the border knows. I showed you the AA survey link to prove my point.




    I am not a student and do not live in a bubble , and I do read others posts. He is obviously telling lies and I proved his "Up north 2 months ago, €1.429 per liter for petrol here £1.199 there" statement to be incorrect.

    Again I plead to you to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    In fairness I think you do read other posts. But you seem to just ignore their contents unless you can challenge it in some way.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    OOps! Link opens on the wrong page. But as I said, feck all difference.

    http://www.petrolprices.com/index.html?invalidlocation=Belfast

    Petrol prices on 10th March in Belfast. The price will have gone up again since then. Wrong again sonny!:D

    I am not your "sonny" and would ask you to be more polite on boards.ie.

    using the link you supply, average newry diesel price is 141.40 stg i.e € 1.66

    http://www.petrolprices.com/search.html?search=newry

    The gap may be narrowing a bit, but thats still considerably dearer than here.

    Again I plead to the public service people who wrote and who thought it was cheaper to fill up in the north, to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    I am not your sonny and would ask you to be more polite on boards.ie.

    using the link you supply, average newry diesel price is 141.40 stg i.e € 1.66

    http://www.petrolprices.com/search.html?search=newry

    The gap may be narrowing a bit, but thats still considerably dearer than here.
    a couple of cent? Feck all difference. It still costs me 3 times as much to tax my car here. It costs more...much more to buy a car here and it costs more to insure here.There is a cent or two difference in petrol prices but it still don't make motoring cheaper here. End of story. Argument won! :D:D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    Again I plead to the public service people who wrote and who thought it was cheaper to fill up in the north, to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    :D:D:D


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    a couple of cent?

    no , up to 20 cent

    http://www.aaireland.ie/AA/Motoring-advice/Petrol-Prices.aspx

    and that adds up on a tank;)
    Feck all difference.

    maybe if you earn the average p.s. wage of 47k a year you can afford to pay the extra for fuel in the North, but I do not.
    It still costs me 3 times as much to tax my car here.

    others pay 104 or 156 a year to tax their cars here, so its not always dearer than the north ;)

    It costs more...much more to buy a car here
    and no wonder when the tax involved goes toward paying our public servants almost double what they get in the UK.

    There is a cent or two difference in petrol prices but it still don't make motoring cheaper here.
    I never said motoring was cheaper here, only petrol + diesel.

    But at least we do not have to pay that property tax, water rates etc they do in the UK.;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 9,897 ✭✭✭MagicSean


    gigino wrote: »
    But at least we do not have to pay that property tax, water rates etc they do in the UK.;)

    Seriously? Again with this?


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    no , up to 20 cent

    http://www.aaireland.ie/AA/Motoring-advice/Petrol-Prices.aspx

    and that adds up on a tank;)


    That link shows petrol prices from february. Its a lot more expensive now. I bet prices have gone up more here than up North
    If your trying to show that prices vary,price varies down here too. They go up to 1.59 Euro here
    http://www.pumps.ie/viewNationalStatistics.php

    gigino wrote: »
    maybe if you earn the average p.s. wage of 47k a year you can afford to pay the extra for fuel in the North, but I do not.
    :D:D Pathetic!
    1. Where did I say I go north for petrol??
    2.Where did I say I earn 47k.
    I'm sorry to hear you don't earn 47k a year. I bet the majority of the public sector don't either. Maybe getting a job would help?;):rolleyes:
    gigino wrote: »
    others pay 104 or 156 a year to tax their cars here, so its not always dearer than the north ;)
    A very small minority are paying 156 euro.An even smaller minority are paying 104 euro. Lets go by average as you like averages.:rolleyes:


    gigino wrote: »
    and no wonder when the tax involved goes toward paying our public servants almost double what they get in the UK.
    Again...Pathetic!:D.
    gigino wrote: »
    I never said motoring was cheaper here, only petrol + diesel.
    But at least we do not have to pay that property tax, water rates etc they do in the UK.;)
    Friends and family in the UK pay council/property tax which covers bin charges, maintenence of parks etc. I personally pay about 600 in bin charges. Would property tax here incorporate bin charges? Probably not, so again it would be a rip-off!
    My UK family and friends all pay a few quid/week for water and don't mind.The water quality is crap where I live but if it improves I would have no problem paying something for water. When they come here to visit they can't believe the price of a pint, eating out,food, cigarettes, you name it it is all dearer. End of! I say again...argument won. End of!:cool:


  • Moderators, Society & Culture Moderators Posts: 42,341 Mod ✭✭✭✭Gumbo


    gigino wrote: »
    Again I plead to the public service people who wrote and who thought it was cheaper to fill up in the north, to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.

    no chance, not when the OP is saving 9c a litre while up there. when filling the family tank thats a huge saving and makes going up north even more attractive.


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 200 ✭✭Yourwellcum


    gigino wrote: »
    no , up to 20 cent

    http://www.aaireland.ie/AA/Motoring-advice/Petrol-Prices.aspx

    and that adds up on a tank;)



    maybe if you earn the average p.s. wage of 47k a year you can afford to pay the extra for fuel in the North, but I do not.



    others pay 104 or 156 a year to tax their cars here, so its not always dearer than the north ;)



    and no wonder when the tax involved goes toward paying our public servants almost double what they get in the UK.



    I never said motoring was cheaper here, only petrol + diesel.

    But at least we do not have to pay that property tax, water rates etc they do in the UK.;)

    Can we just clarify that VRT came into existence long before we had the problem of the public sector pay bill, so to use it in this argument makes no sense. If the wage bill were no longer the problem, VRT aint going anywhere


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    Just to explain to latecomers we have been sidetracked by gigino's claim that the cost of living in Ireland is now cheaper than the cost of living in the UK.:D:D


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 3,181 ✭✭✭bryaner


    gigino wrote: »
    I am not your "sonny" and would ask you to be more polite on boards.ie.

    using the link you supply, average newry diesel price is 141.40 stg i.e € 1.66

    http://www.petrolprices.com/search.html?search=newry

    The gap may be narrowing a bit, but thats still considerably dearer than here.

    Again I plead to the public service people who wrote and who thought it was cheaper to fill up in the north, to please fill up this side of the border any more. As said before not only will you keep money circulating in this economy, but the considerable tax involved will go towards paying your own wages, and the rest of us in the public service. And you will save yourself up to a tenner on a tank.


    Fly my pretty fly..;)


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,819 ✭✭✭dan_d


    Just to explain to latecomers we have been sidetracked by gigino's claim that the cost of living in Ireland is now cheaper than the cost of living in the UK.:D:D

    Thanks, I got completely lost there....:confused::confused::confused:


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,567 ✭✭✭Vizzy


    Vizzy wrote: »
    Gigino,
    Just to be clear here,are you seeking a 50% cut for all PS or is it just the ones who are earning big money ( say over €60K)
    also I assume that you want major reductions in PS numbers ?
    If so what kind of cuts would you propose ( 20,000,30,000,100,000).
    Additionally you constantly quote comparisons with the UK/NI.
    Why not compare to places like Sweden or alternatively Bulgaria or Mexico ?
    Gigino,do you intend to answer my questions so that I can get a better insight in to your feelings towards the PS


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    Just to explain to latecomers we have been sidetracked by gigino's claim that the cost of living in Ireland is now cheaper than the cost of living in the UK.:D:D

    Thats a lie again, I never said such a thing. I explained how some things continue to be cheaper here e.g. petrol and diesel. I provided AA statistices to prove my point. Not that that should need proving - just ask anyone who lives close to the border. Or see the open petrol stations on the southern side of the border and see the ones on the northern side of the border (close to the border) all closed up for years.;). On ordinary luxury + other hard goods there is only a 1% difference in vat between the 2 jurisdictions now. On the southern side of the border we do not (yet anyway ) have to pay property tax or water rates on domestic dwellings...unlike people north of the border. So there are swings and roundabouts, as someone else said. People can always shop online from wherever they way. The cost of living argument advanced by a few people does not justify our average public sector wage being 47k while the average UK public secrtor wage is only 22 or 23k stg. .....especially when you remember our government is bust + having to borrow the money at high interest rates.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    Thats a lie again, I never said such a thing. I explained how some things continue to be cheaper here e.g. petrol and diesel. I provided AA statistices to prove my point. Not that that should need proving - just ask anyone who lives close to the border. Or see the open petrol stations on the southern side of the border and see the ones on the northern side of the border (close to the border) all closed up for years.;). On ordinary luxury + other hard goods there is only a 1% difference in vat between the 2 jurisdictions now. On the southern side of the border we do not (yet anyway ) have to pay property tax or water rates on domestic dwellings...unlike people north of the border. So there are swings and roundabouts, as someone else said. People can always shop online from wherever they way. The cost of living argument advanced by a few people does not justify our average public sector wage being 47k while the average UK public secrtor wage is only 22 or 23k stg. .....especially when you remember our government is bust + having to borrow the money at high interest rates.
    Argument over! You lost!:pac::pac:


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    Thats a childish answer which does should not even justify the dignity of a reply.


  • Closed Accounts Posts: 160 ✭✭erictheviking1


    gigino wrote: »
    Thats a childish answer which does should not even justify the dignity of a reply.

    As I said.....Argument over You lost!:pac:


  • Advertisement
  • Closed Accounts Posts: 2,350 ✭✭✭gigino


    Vizzy wrote: »
    Gigino,do you intend to answer my questions
    I am not online 24/7 but will answer your question now

    People at the top should be cut the most. eg Its absurd that our Taoiseach who sang so well at 3 am in Galway + adressed the nation on national radio at breakfast some hours later, earns more than the President of the USA. The likes of Dermot Ahern , ex minister for foreign affairs should not be able to retire with a lump sum of 300k plus and a pension which is double the average industrial wage. Cut that 50%. Lower paid people should be cut only 25%. Public sector pay should not be so much higher than private sector. Of course social welfare, quangos, etc should be cut too.

    Numbers to be cut : I agree with the main government party, 30,000

    I have compared to other countries,eg Germany, not just the UK. However we share a land border with the UK. Nearly everyone has a friend or relative or old classmate who went to the North or England or Scotland....its a place we are very familiar with. Universities from the north for example have students from both sides of the border, some of whom have traditionally got jobs in the public sector on both sdides of the border. Its easy for people to make comparisons, there are no language barriers etc.


Advertisement